Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A great organizational culture is the key to developing the traits necessary for
business success. And you’ll see its effects in your bottom line: companies with
healthy cultures are 1.5 times more likely to experience revenue growth of 15 percent
or more over three years and 2.5 times more likely to experience significant stock
growth over the same period. Despite this, only 31 percent of HR leaders believe their
organizations have the culture they need to drive future business, and getting there is
no easy task — 85 percent of organizations fail in transforming their cultures.
A strong culture is a common denominator among the most successful companies. All
have consensus at the top regarding cultural priorities, and those values focus not on
individuals but on the organization and its goals. Leaders in successful companies live
their cultures every day and go out of their way to communicate their cultural
identities to employees as well as prospective new hires. They are clear about their
values and how those values define their organizations and determine how the
organizations run. See What does it mean to be a values-based organization?
Conversely, an ineffective culture can bring down the organization and its leadership.
Disengaged employees, high turnover, poor customer relations and lower profits are
examples of how the wrong culture can negatively impact the bottom line.
Mergers and acquisitions are fraught with culture issues. Even organizational cultures
that have worked well may develop into a dysfunctional culture after a merger.
Research has shown that two out of three mergers fail because of cultural problems.
Blending and redefining the cultures, and reconciling the differences between them,
build a common platform for the future. In recent years, the fast pace of mergers and
acquisitions has changed the way businesses now meld. The focus in mergers has
shifted away from blending cultures and has moved toward meeting specific business
objectives. Some experts believe that if the right business plan and agenda are in place
during a merger, a strong corporate culture will develop naturally.
Don’t confuse culture with organizational goals or a mission statement, although both
can help define it. Culture is created through consistent and authentic behaviors, not
press releases or policy documents. You can watch company culture in action when
you see how a CEO responds to a crisis, how a team adapts to new customer demands,
or how a manager corrects an employee who makes a mistake.
Culture is a key advantage when it comes to attracting talent and outperforming the
competition. 77 percent of workers consider a company’s culture before applying, and
almost half of employees would leave their current job for a lower-paying opportunity
at an organization with a better culture. The culture of an organization is also one of
the top indicators of employee satisfaction and one of the main reasons that almost
two-thirds (65%) of employees stay in their job.
Salesforce puts corporate culture front and center and has experienced incredible
growth throughout its history. Marc Benioff, Salesforce’s founder and CEO,
established philanthropic cultural norms that have guided the company over the past
two decades. All new Salesforce employees spend part of their first day volunteering
and receive 56 hours of paid time to volunteer a year. This focus on meaning and
mission has made Salesforce one of the best places to work in America according to
Fortune, and it hasn’t compromised profits either: Salesforce’s stock price has surged
year after year at an average of over 26% annually to date.
Business Case
If an organization's culture is going to improve the organization's overall performance,
the culture must provide a strategic competitive advantage, and beliefs and values
must be widely shared and firmly upheld. A strong culture can bring benefits such as
enhanced trust and cooperation, fewer disagreements and more-efficient decision-
making. Culture also provides an informal control mechanism, a strong sense of
identification with the organization and shared understanding among employees about
what is important. Employees whose organizations have strongly defined cultures can
also justify their behaviors at work because those behaviors fit the culture.
• Alignment comes when the company’s objectives and its employees’ motivations
are all pulling in the same direction. Exceptional organizations work to build
continuous alignment to their vision, purpose, and goals.
• Appreciation can take many forms: a public kudos, a note of thanks, or a promotion.
A culture of appreciation is one in which all team members frequently provide
recognition and thanks for the contributions of others.
• Trust is vital to an organization. With a culture of trust, team members can express
themselves and rely on others to have their back when they try something new.
• Integrity, like trust, is vital to all teams when they rely on each other to make
decisions, interpret results, and form partnerships. Honesty and transparency are
critical components of this aspect of culture.
• Innovation leads organizations to get the most out of available technologies,
resources, and markets. A culture of innovation means that you apply creative
thinking to all aspects of your business, even your own cultural initiatives.
• Psychological safety provides the support employees need to take risks and provide
honest feedback. Remember that psychological safety starts at the team level, not the
individual level, so managers need to take the lead in creating a safe environment
where everyone feels comfortable contributing.Now that you know what a great
culture looks like, let’s tackle how to build one in your organization.
Adhocracy culture
Adhocracy is a combination of the words ‘Ad hoc’ and bureaucracy. Therefore,
organizations with an adhocracy culture are flexible and not inhibited by bureaucratic
procedures and policies. There is an emphasis on constant innovation and
improvements, the pace is usually extremely fast, and the status quo, though it may be
working, will be challenged.
Most start-up and tech companies like Apple, Google, and Facebook are driven by
adhocratic culture because it provides them the latitude to be innovative. This is
critical to their brand and success in a market that is constantly changing and highly
competitive.
However, when start-ups become large tech giants like these organizations, an
adhocratic culture will become less feasible throughout the entire organization. There
will be some functions or business units that will need more structure, and moving
slower may actually be better for the organization, for example, in the areas of ethics
and compliance. Therefore, the adhocracy culture may be relegated to specific units to
ensure the organization remains innovative and competitive in the market.
Clan culture
‘Clan’ is a group of close-knit and interrelated families or a group of people with a
strong common interest. Clan cultures are common in small or family-owned
businesses that are not hierarchical in nature. Employees are valued regardless of their
level and environments are supportive.
This culture aims to work collaboratively in teams by making sure all employees feel
like equals. They feel comfortable providing honest and open feedback. Apart from
teamwork, there may be a strong emphasis on mentorship and apprenticeship as
competencies and values are passed on from one generation to another. There is
usually high employee engagement in this culture, which makes for excellent
customer service. However, the downside to this type of culture is that it is difficult to
maintain it as the organization grows. Operations may lack focus and fluidity as the
organization grows.
Hierarchy culture
The hierarchy culture is a prevalent corporate culture in the US. It is defined by
structure, established procedures, and levels of authority. Employees in this culture
know precisely where they fit in the chain of command – who’s accountable to them,
who they report to, and what the rules are. It is imperative in this culture to do the
right thing.
Market culture
Market culture is all about profit margins and staying ahead of the competition. It is
results-oriented with a strong external focus to ensure customers are satisfied.
Examples of companies driven by a market culture are Tesla, Amazon, and General
Electric.
1. Excel in recognition
Recognizing the contributions of all team members has a far-reaching, positive effect
on organizational culture. When everyone on the team recognizes the
accomplishments of others, individuals start to see how they’re part of a whole. Even
the most jaded employees want to know their work matters, and they notice when
they aren’t appreciated — 76 percent of employees don’t feel especially recognized
by superiors. Experts agree that when an organization makes appreciating employees
part of its culture, important metrics like employee engagement, retention, and
productivity improve.
Making recognition part of your culture means it must be a regular occurrence, not
something that is only reserved for major milestones or work anniversaries.
Encourage team members to practice frequent social recognition in addition to
monetary recognition. Providing social recognition on a consistent basis has a
remarkable business impact: companies that invest in social recognition are four times
more likely to increase stock prices, twice more likely to improve NPS scores, and
twice more likely to improve individual performances.
To foster other cultural traits, recognition should also be clearly tied to company
values and specific actions. After all, 92 percent of employees agree when they’re
recognized for a specific action, they’re more likely to take that action again in the
future.
Last but not least, leadership needs to take center stage in your recognition efforts, as
they’re the cultural trendsetters for your entire company. Incorporate a recognition
talk track into your leadership training and share top tips with managers on how to
recognize others and why it matters.
First, you need to collect feedback using the right listening tools that make it easy for
employees to express what they’re feeling in the moment, like pulse surveys and
workplace chatbots. Then analyze the results to see what’s working and what isn’t in
your organization, and act on those findings while they’re still relevant. Not only does
this strengthen your culture, it leads to benefits like higher employee fulfillment and
greater profitability. According to a Clutch survey, 68 percent of employees who
receive regular feedback feel fulfilled in their jobs, and Gallup found that
organizations with managers who received feedback on their strengths showed 8.9
percent greater profitability.
In addition to gathering feedback using the methods described above, make sure
you’re paying attention to more subtle expressions of feedback that can reveal cultural
deficiencies. For example, pay attention to body language, as it can tell you much
even when employees aren’t willing to share. If you’re working with a remote team,
video conferences can help keep this nonverbal channel of communication open.
Managers should treat all their sessions with employees as opportunities to gather and
respond to feedback and act as a trusted coach.
Your leadership team can help build the culture you need by prioritizing it in every
aspect of their work lives. They need to openly and transparently discuss the
organization’s culture and values, and they should also be prepared to incorporate
feedback from employees into their cultural advocacy efforts. Leaders need their
employees’ perspective on culture — while 76 percent of executives believe their
organization has a well-communicated value system, only 31 percent of employees
agree. When employees see leaders living your culture, they’ll follow suit.
Look for and encourage shared personal interests between team members as well,
especially among those from different generations that might otherwise have a
difficult time relating to each other. This can create new pathways for understanding
and empathy that are vital to improving communication, creativity, and even conflict
resolution.
A culture of learning has a significant business impact. Find Courses’ most recent
benchmark study found that companies with highly engaged employees were 1.5
times more likely to prioritize soft skills development. It also found that companies
that had experienced revenue growth in the previous financial year were twice more
likely to use innovative learning technologies and three times more likely to increase
their learning and development budgets.
When hiring, ask questions focused on cultural fit, like what matters to the
interviewee and why they’re attracted to working at your company. But these
questions shouldn’t be the sole determining factor when evaluating a candidate, as the
best organizations keep an open mind to diverse perspectives that can help keep their
culture fresh.
You should also prioritize building social relationships during the onboarding process
so that employees have the insight necessary to understand your company’s culture
and values. These relationships will last throughout the employee’s time at the
company, so that cultural values are mutually reinforced on a continuous basis.
Innovative Cultures
According to the OCP framework, companies that have innovative cultures are
flexible and adaptable, and experiment with new ideas. These companies are
characterized by a flat hierarchy in which titles and other status distinctions tend to be
downplayed. For example, W. L. Gore & Associates Inc. is a company with
innovative products such as GORE-TEX® (the breathable fabric that is windproof
and waterproof), Glide dental floss, and Elixir guitar strings, earning the company the
distinction of being elected as the most innovative company in the United States by
Fast Company magazine in 2004. W. L. Gore consistently manages to innovate and
capture the majority of market share in a wide variety of industries, in large part due
to its unique culture. In this company, employees do not have bosses in the traditional
sense, and risk taking is encouraged by celebrating failures as well as successes.
Companies such as W. L. Gore, Genentech Inc., and Google also encourage their
employees to take risks by allowing engineers to devote 20% of their time to projects
of their own choosing.
Aggressive Cultures
Companies with aggressive cultures value competitiveness and outperforming
competitors: By emphasizing this, they may fall short in the area of corporate social
responsibility. For example, Microsoft Corporation is often identified as a company
with an aggressive culture. The company has faced a number of antitrust lawsuits and
disputes with competitors over the years. In aggressive companies, people may use
language such as “We will kill our competition.” In the past, Microsoft executives
often made statements such as “We are going to cut off Netscape’s air
supply.…Everything they are selling, we are going to give away.” Its aggressive
culture is cited as a reason for getting into new legal troubles before old ones are
resolved. Recently, Microsoft founder Bill Gates established the Bill & Melinda Gates
foundation and is planning to devote his time to reducing poverty around the world. It
will be interesting to see whether he will bring the same competitive approach to the
world of philanthropy.
Outcome-Oriented Cultures
The OCP framework describes outcome-oriented cultures as those that emphasize
achievement, results, and action as important values. A good example of an outcome-
oriented culture may be Best Buy Co. Inc. Having a culture emphasizing sales
performance, Best Buy tallies revenues and other relevant figures daily by department.
Employees are trained and mentored to sell company products effectively, and they
learn how much money their department made every day. In 2005, the company
implemented a results oriented work environment (ROWE) program that allows
employees to work anywhere and anytime; they are evaluated based on results and
fulfillment of clearly outlined objectives. Outcome-oriented cultures hold employees
as well as managers accountable for success and utilize systems that reward employee
and group output. In these companies, it is more common to see rewards tied to
performance indicators as opposed to seniority or loyalty. Research indicates that
organizations that have a performance-oriented culture tend to outperform companies
that are lacking such a culture. At the same time, some outcome-oriented companies
may have such a high drive for outcomes and measurable performance objectives that
they may suffer negative consequences. Companies overrewarding employee
performance such as Enron Corporation and WorldCom experienced well-publicized
business and ethical failures. When performance pressures lead to a culture where
unethical behaviors become the norm, individuals see their peers as rivals and short-
term results are rewarded; the resulting unhealthy work environment serves as a
liability.
Stable Cultures
Stable cultures are predictable, rule-oriented, and bureaucratic. These organizations
aim to coordinate and align individual effort for greatest levels of efficiency. When
the environment is stable and certain, these cultures may help the organization be
effective by providing stable and constant levels of output.These cultures prevent
quick action, and as a result may be a misfit to a changing and dynamic environment.
Public sector institutions may be viewed as stable cultures. In the private sector, Kraft
Foods Inc. is an example of a company with centralized decision making and rule
orientation that suffered as a result of the culture-environment mismatch. Its
bureaucratic culture is blamed for killing good ideas in early stages and preventing the
company from innovating. When the company started a change program to increase
the agility of its culture, one of their first actions was to fight bureaucracy with more
bureaucracy: They created the new position of VP of business process simplification,
which was later eliminated.B
People-Oriented Cultures
People-oriented cultures value fairness, supportiveness, and respect for individual
rights. These organizations truly live the mantra that “people are their greatest asset.”
In addition to having fair procedures and management styles, these companies create
an atmosphere where work is fun and employees do not feel required to choose
between work and other aspects of their lives. In these organizations, there is a greater
emphasis on and expectation of treating people with respect and dignity. One study of
new employees in accounting companies found that employees, on average, stayed 14
months longer in companies with people-oriented cultures. Starbucks Corporation is
an example of a people-oriented culture. The company pays employees above
minimum wage, offers health care and tuition reimbursement benefits to its part-time
as well as full-time employees, and has creative perks such as weekly free coffee for
all associates. As a result of these policies, the company benefits from a turnover rate
lower than the industry average. The company is routinely ranked as one of the best
places to work by Fortune magazine.
Team-Oriented Cultures
Companies with team-oriented cultures are collaborative and emphasize cooperation
among employees. For example, Southwest Airlines Company facilitates a team-
oriented culture by cross-training its employees so that they are capable of helping
each other when needed. The company also places emphasis on training intact work
teams. Employees participate in twice daily meetings named “morning overview
meetings” (MOM) and daily afternoon discussions (DAD) where they collaborate to
understand sources of problems and determine future courses of action. In
Southwest’s selection system, applicants who are not viewed as team players are not
hired as employees. In team-oriented organizations, members tend to have more
positive relationships with their coworkers and particularly with their managers.
Detail-Oriented Cultures
Organizations with detail-oriented cultures are characterized in the OCP framework as
emphasizing precision and paying attention to details. Such a culture gives a
competitive advantage to companies in the hospitality industry by helping them
differentiate themselves from others. For example, Four Seasons Hotels Ltd. and the
Ritz-Carlton Company LLC are among hotels who keep records of all customer
requests, such as which newspaper the guest prefers or what type of pillow the
customer uses. This information is put into a computer system and used to provide
better service to returning customers. Any requests hotel employees receive, as well
as overhear, might be entered into the database to serve customers better. Recent
guests to Four Seasons Paris who were celebrating their 21st anniversary were greeted
with a bouquet of 21 roses on their bed. Such clear attention to detail is an effective
way of impressing customers and ensuring repeat visits. McDonald’s Corporation is
another company that specifies in detail how employees should perform their jobs by
including photos of exactly how French fries and hamburgers should look when
prepared properly.
Service Culture
Service culture is not one of the dimensions of OCP, but given the importance of the
retail industry in the overall economy, having a service culture can make or break an
organization. Some of the organizations we have illustrated in this section, such as
Nordstrom, Southwest Airlines, Ritz-Carlton, and Four Seasons are also famous for
their service culture. In these organizations, employees are trained to serve the
customer well, and cross-training is the norm. Employees are empowered to resolve
customer problems in ways they see fit. Because employees with direct customer
contact are in the best position to resolve any issues, employee empowerment is truly
valued in these companies. For example, Umpqua Bank, operating in the northwestern
United States, is known for its service culture. All employees are trained in all tasks to
enable any employee to help customers when needed. Branch employees may come
up with unique ways in which they serve customers better, such as opening their
lobby for community events or keeping bowls full of water for customers’ pets. The
branches feature coffee for customers, Internet kiosks, and withdrawn funds are given
on a tray along with a piece of chocolate. They also reward employee service
performance through bonuses and incentives.
What differentiates companies with service culture from those without such a culture
may be the desire to solve customer-related problems proactively. In other words, in
these cultures employees are engaged in their jobs and personally invested in
improving customer experience such that they identify issues and come up with
solutions without necessarily being told what to do. For example, a British Airways
baggage handler noticed that first-class passengers were waiting a long time for their
baggage, whereas stand-by passengers often received their luggage first. Noticing this
tendency, a baggage handler notified his superiors about this problem, along with the
suggestion to load first-class passenger luggage last. This solution was successful in
cutting down the wait time by half. Such proactive behavior on the part of employees
who share company values is likely to emerge frequently in companies with a service
culture.
Safety Culture
Some jobs are safety sensitive. For example, logger, aircraft pilot, fishing worker,
steel worker, and roofer are among the top 10 most dangerous jobs in the United
States. In organizations where safety-sensitive jobs are performed, creating and
maintaining a safety culture provides a competitive advantage, because the
organization can reduce accidents, maintain high levels of morale and employee
retention, and increase profitability by cutting workers’ compensation insurance costs.
Some companies suffer severe consequences when they are unable to develop such a
culture. For example, British Petroleum experienced an explosion in their Texas City,
Texas, refinery in 2005, which led to the death of 15 workers while injuring 170. In
December 2007, the company announced that it had already depleted the $1.6-billion
fund to be used in claims for this explosion. A safety review panel concluded that the
development of a safety culture was essential to avoid such occurrences in the future.
In companies that have a safety culture, there is a strong commitment to safety
starting at management level and trickling down to lower levels. M. B. Herzog
Electric Inc. of California, selected as one of America’s safest companies by
Occupational Hazards magazine in 2007, had a zero accident rate for the past 3 years.
The company uses safety training programs tailored to specific jobs within the
company, and all employees are encouraged to identify all safety hazards they come
across when they are performing their jobs. They are also asked to play the role of an
OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) inspector for a day to
become more aware of the hidden dangers in the workplace. Managers play a key role
in increasing the level of safe behaviors in the workplace, because they can motivate
employees day-to-day to demonstrate safe behaviors and act as safety role models. A
recent study has shown that in organizations with a safety culture, leaders encourage
employees to demonstrate behaviors such as volunteering for safety committees,
making recommendations to increase safety, protecting coworkers from hazards,
whistleblowing, and in general trying to make their jobs safer.
Most company cultures are not that different from one another. Even organizations in
disparate industries such as manufacturing and health care tend to share a common
core of cultural values. For example, most private-sector companies want to grow and
increase revenues. Most strive to be team-oriented and to demonstrate concern for
others. Most are driven, rather than relaxed, because they are competing for dollars
and market share. Some of the cultural characteristics that distinguish most
organizations include the following.
Values
At the heart of organizations' cultures are commonly shared values. None is right or
wrong, but organizations need to decide which values they will emphasize. These
common values include:
Outcome orientation. Emphasizing achievements and results.
People orientation. Insisting on fairness, tolerance and respect for the individual.
Team orientation. Emphasizing and rewarding collaboration.
Attention to detail. Valuing precision and approaching situations and problems
analytically.
Stability. Providing security and following a predictable course.
Innovation. Encouraging experimentation and risk-taking.
Aggressiveness. Stimulating a fiercely competitive spirit.
Degree of Hierarchy
The degree of hierarchy is the extent to which the organization values traditional
channels of authority. The three distinct levels of hierarchy are "high"—having a
well-defined organizational structure and an expectation that people will work
through official channels; "moderate"—having a defined structure but an acceptance
that people often work outside formal channels; and "low" —having loosely defined
job descriptions and accepting that people challenge authority. An organization with a
high level of hierarchy tends to be more formal and moves more slowly than an
organization with a low level of hierarchy.
Degree of Urgency
The degree of urgency defines how quickly the organization wants or needs to drive
decision-making and innovation. Some organizations choose their degree of urgency,
but others have it thrust on them by the marketplace. A culture with high levels of
urgency has a need to push projects through quickly and a high need to respond to a
changing marketplace. A moderate level of urgency moves projects at a reasonable
pace. A low level of urgency means people work slowly and consistently, valuing
quality over efficiency. An organization with high urgency tends to be fast-paced and
supports a decisive management style. An organization with low urgency tends to be
more methodical and supports a more considered management style.
Functional Orientation
Every organization puts an emphasis on certain functional areas. Examples of
functional orientations may include marketing, operations, research and development,
engineering or service. For example, an innovative organization known for its
research and development may have at its core a functional orientation toward R&D.
A hospitality company may focus on operations or service, depending on its historical
choices and its definition in the marketplace. Employees from different functions in
the company may think that their functional areas are the ones that drive the
organization. Organizational leaders must understand what most employees perceive
to be the company's functional orientation.
Looking at each piece of the organization's vision, mission and values statements.
Interview questions should hone in on behaviors that complement these areas. For
example, if the organization works with a lot of intensity, then job applicants
should display that natural intensity to be considered for hire.
Conducting a cultural fit interview. Ask questions that elicit comments about
organizational values such as honesty or integrity. If a candidate's description of
the worst place he or she ever worked sounds just like the organization where he
or she is interviewing, the candidate probably will not be successful.
Leaving discussion of company culture for later. Do not tell candidates about
culture up front. First, listen to what they have to say about their experiences and
beliefs. This tactic will reveal more candid responses to help determine whether
they are a fit for the organization.
Making sure at least three people are involved in the hiring process. Different
people will see and hear different things. These varied perspectives give a clearer
understanding of the person being considered for hire.
Searching for employees who will fit in seamlessly can have drawbacks. The
biggest mistake an organization can make is to paint an inaccurate picture of itself
as it tries to attract candidates. If new hires discover they have been sold a bill of
goods, they will not be happy; they will probably not stick around, and, while
they are around, morale will decline.
Another possible drawback is that people are more reluctant to take negative actions
against people like themselves. As a result, mediocre workers are more likely to stay
employed if they share the cultural values. Similarly, although an organization's
comfort level is palpable when the culture is aligned, experts say, too much comfort
can result in group think and complacency.
Onboarding Programs
Onboarding teaches newcomers the employer's value system, norms and desired
organizational behaviors. Employers must help newcomers become part of social
networks in the organization and make sure that they have early job experiences that
reinforce the culture.
Sustaining a Culture
The management of organizational culture starts with identifying a company's
organizational culture traits or "artifacts." Artifacts are the core business activities,
processes and philosophies that characterize how an organization does business day-
to-day. Identifying these traits—and assessing their importance in light of current
business objectives—is a way to start managing culture.
Three broad concepts help identify the traits specific to a culture:
Social culture. This refers to group members' roles and responsibilities. It is the study
of class distinctions and the distribution of power that exists in any group.
Material culture. This involves examining everything that people in a group make or
achieve and the ways people work with and support one another in exchanging
required goods and services.
Ideological culture. This is tied to a group's values, beliefs and ideals—the things
people view as fundamental. It includes the emotional and intellectual guidelines that
govern people's daily existence and interactions.
Strength of Culture
A strong culture is one that is shared by organizational members. In other words, if
most employees in the organization show consensus regarding the values of the
company, it is possible to talk about the existence of a strong culture. A culture’s
content is more likely to affect the way employees think and behave when the culture
in question is strong. For example, cultural values emphasizing customer service will
lead to higher quality customer service if there is widespread agreement among
employees on the importance of customer service-related values.
It is important to realize that a strong culture may act as an asset or liability for the
organization, depending on the types of values that are shared. For example, imagine
a company with a culture that is strongly outcome oriented. If this value system
matches the organizational environment, the company outperforms its competitors.
On the other hand, a strong outcome-oriented culture coupled with unethical
behaviors and an obsession with quantitative performance indicators may be
detrimental to an organization’s effectiveness. An extreme example of this
dysfunctional type of strong culture is Enron.
A strong culture may also be a liability during a merger. During mergers and
acquisitions, companies inevitably experience a clash of cultures, as well as a clash of
structures and operating systems. Culture clash becomes more problematic if both
parties have unique and strong cultures. For example, during the merger of Daimler
AG with Chrysler Motors LLC to create DaimlerChrysler AG, the differing strong
cultures of each company acted as a barrier to effective integration. Daimler had a
strong engineering culture that was more hierarchical and emphasized routinely
working long hours. Daimler employees were used to being part of an elite
organization, evidenced by flying first class on all business trips. On the other hand,
Chrysler had a sales culture where employees and managers were used to autonomy,
working shorter hours, and adhering to budget limits that meant only the elite flew
first class. The different ways of thinking and behaving in these two companies
introduced a number of unanticipated problems during the integration process.
Differences in culture may be part of the reason that, in the end, the merger didn’t
work out.
Communications
Conflicting messages regarding corporate culture may create distrust and cynicism,
which can prompt, or help employees justify, actions as deleterious as embezzlement.
Experts say that cultural inconsistencies may also cause workers to grow discouraged,
to believe management is disingenuous, to doubt statements from higher-ups and to
be less inclined to give their best effort.
Organizations may be investing significant time and money in creating a culture but
may not be reaping the commensurate rewards—especially if executives, supervisors
and rank-and-file employees have differing perceptions of the company's culture.
Employers must therefore ensure that the organization clearly and consistently
communicates its culture to all employees.
Legal Issues
Employers that emphasize cultural fit in their recruitment and selection process can be
vulnerable to discrimination claims if they are not careful. Employers should ensure
that hiring practices and selection decisions based on a cultural fit rationale do not
result in discriminating against any applicants who may not be "just like" the selectors.
Employers should also be aware that certain types of organizational cultures (for
example, cultures that are highly paternalistic or male-dominated) may tend to
perpetuate disparities in promotions, compensation and other terms of employment.
Those disparities may violate anti-discrimination laws.
Global Issues
Research suggests that national culture has a greater effect on employees than the
culture of their organization. Organizational leaders should understand the national
cultural values in the countries in which the organization operates to ensure that
management and company practices are appropriate and will be effective in
operations in those countries. National cultural differences should be considered when
implementing organizational culture management initiatives in global businesses.
These issues become even more complex in global business mergers. Success in
international mergers depends on the merged organization's willingness to enable
people with different cultural perspectives to engage in meaningful and valuable
discussions about the new business.
National Culture
1. National culture is the norms, behaviors, beliefs, customs, and values shared by
the population of a sovereign nation (e.g.a Chinese or Canadian national culture).
It refers to specific characteristics such as language, religion, ethnic and racial
identity, cultural history and traditions.
3. The behavior of the inhabitants of a nation is shaped by the values, beliefs and
cultural traditions that are common to them and which differ from other nation-
states.International companies normally develop management in conjunction with
the national culture.
4. National Culture is the combination of symbols, beliefs and artefacts typical for
members of one nation.
The power distance dimension refers to the “power inequality” between superiors
and subordinates. The United States has some elements of both a higher and a lower
power distance culture. Over the years, the U.S. business environment has adopted
forms of management, such as participative management, that place supervisors and
subordinates on more equal terms. Arab countries score higher on the power distance
dimension. Cultures with high power distance tend to be more hierarchical.
A key question involves how culture affects consumer behavior around the world. For
instance, how would the individualism versus collectivism index in Hofstede’s
framework influence the purchase of clothing, a smartphone,or an iPad in the different
countries of Japan, the United States, and France? Why are KFC, Subway, and
McDonald’s successful in most countries, even when they have significantly different
cultures? Are there other reasons for these companies’ success?
Another area of interest is how the culture of a country influences the culture of a
business. Organizations that become global have to adjust to many different
environments. Many of these companies focus on the diversity of employees in
dealing with customers in different countries. While Hofstede describes the cultural
values of people in different countries, organizational cultures are different. The
culture of employees working in global businesses may be different from the national
culture of one country. This is because businesses develop their own values and
culture. However, do these values always reflect the national culture?
Organizational values are specific to a mission statement that guides conduct and
relationships with stakeholders. Organizational values may not be the same as
individual values in that they are identified and supported by top management to
develop a shared understanding for expected behavior. Values are selected by
leadership to make sure everyone understands what the organization stands for,
including ethical behavior and social responsibility.