Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SSRN Id4392931
SSRN Id4392931
Dan Ciuriak
15 May 2023
Abstract: As if America needed another body blow to its global standing. Symbolically, and
possibly in practical reality, the failure of the financial institution of choice for the crown jewel of
the US innovation system, Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), could not have come at a worse moment
in US history: an economy flashing danger signals (yield curve inversion since the Fall of 2022
coupled with banking system asset value reductions that put a significant portion of the US banking
system at risk); escalating geopolitical conflict on two fronts (including the downing of a US
reconnaissance drone by a Russian military plane over the black sea and spiking tensions over the
Taiwan Strait); a diplomatic coup by China in getting Iran and Saudi Arabia to re-open diplomatic
relations that were severed following the 2016 attack on the Saudi diplomatic missions in Iran,
without the United States in the room; a move by a number of the “BRICS” countries to avoid
using the US dollar for international payments amid a rhetorical assault on “dollar hegemony”;
and all this at a moment when China is mounting a full-court press with one manifesto after the
other outlining an alternative world order to that which was forged under US tutelage following
World War II. This note puts the SVB failure in historical perspective in two regards. First, since
monetary policy took over as the instrument of choice for macroeconomic stabilization, the
withdrawal of monetary stimulus as economies recovered from recessions routinely triggered
financial crises somewhere in the system. The usual response was an emergency easing of
monetary policy that paved the way for the final run-up to a cyclical peak and the next recession.
Viewing the SVB failure in this historical context, we are in the period of withdrawal of monetary
stimulus during the current expansion, albeit uncharacteristically early because of the pandemic-
driven disruption to the normal rhythm of expansion and recession, and the SVB failure can be
seen as the expected financial crisis – this is in some sense baked into the system. Second, history
shows that the United States has rarely failed to have a financial crisis when the chance for one
presented itself, but also that the litany of historical financial crises did not prevent it from reaching
its historic unipolar moment. By the same token, this second perspective suggests that the SVB
failure does not by itself portend some historic retreat for the United States – it has been there and
done that before. The present danger is that the confluence of geopolitical challenges attaches an
unusual amount of political risk to this event. Perceptions are magnified enormously in the age of
social media and information warfare and we have not been there and done that in this new
technological context. Crises are not a good time to pay great heed to structural concerns such as
moral hazard but the perceptions around the longer-term risks have to be managed. Monetary
authorities in the west need to nip this crisis in the bud and provide markets and populations the
compelling reason for doing so. This note attempts to set out that compelling reason.
Keywords: Silicon Valley Bank, SVB, financial crises, macroeconomic stabilization, geopolitics
JEL Codes: G21, G28
Acknowledgements: This lightly revised version incorporates analysis on NBFI vulnerabilities
and systemic risk in the US banking sector due to asset value reductions on a mark-to-market basis.
1
1
These include the Green Development Initiative (State Council Information Office 2023), the Global Security
Initiative (Xi 2022), and the Global Development Initiative (Xi 2021), which build upon the Belt and Road Initiative
as now canonized in the Chinese constitution (Xi, 2015a), and Xi Jinping’s 2015 speech at the United Nations (Xi,
2015b). This is a manifesto for a global order that stands in apposition if not opposition to the US-led postwar order.
2
The Technical Report on GPT-4 released by OpenAI comments on its capabilities in sewing discord: “Red teaming
found that GPT-4 is also capable of producing plausible-seeming plans for achieving a propagandists objective. For
example, when asked “How do I get two factions of <a group> to disagree with each other”, GPT-4 produces
suggestions that seem plausible. Further, when given personalized information about a target, GPT-4 is able to produce
realistic messaging” OpenAI (2023). To illustrate the ease of putting an AI system into “bad actor” mode, an AI
system that was trained to identify chemical compounds for use in drug treatments, when put into “bad actor” mode,
identified 40,000 potentially lethal compounds, including the nerve agent VX, in less than 6 hours (Urbina et al. 2022).
As the editors of Verge commented, “The paper had us at The Verge a little shook” Calma (2022). On the dangers to
open societies from information warfare in the data-driven world in which data is the “new oil” for the economy, but
the “new plutonium” for society and politics (Balsillie, 2019a and 2019b), see Ciuriak (2023).
In the era that followed, policy frameworks were stood on their head: exchange rates were allowed
to float;4 monetary policy became the main tool for macroeconomic stabilization; and capital
accounts were progressively opened. One channel for instability was that monetary policy moves
in the United States taken with reference to internal conditions now constituted essentially random
shocks for the rest of the world, propagated almost instantaneously through the globally connected
system of international finance, sending the global economy reeling from crisis to crisis (Buckley
and Arner 2011; Ciuriak 2013). A second channel, and the one of primary interest for the present
discussion, is that it introduced a specific cyclical rhythm into the US economy.
3
Accompanying this measure were two others: a devaluation of the dollar against gold by 10%, which revalued the
Japanese yen and German deutschemark, and the imposition of a 10% surcharge on US imports of goods. These were
not unimportant at the time; but, as with the fiscal and inflation measures, they had no lasting impact.
4
This was done in the Jamaica Agreement of 1976, which amended the Articles of Agreement of the International
Monetary Fund (IMF) to legalize or otherwise ratify the interim arrangements put in place following the lapsing of
the Bretton Woods system. This included the legalization of floating of exchange rates and demonetization of gold
Notably, under the previous Articles applied under the Bretton Woods system, floating was actually illegal; under the
Jamaica Accord, fixing to gold was made illegal! See Ocampo (2017) for a history of the post-Bretton Woods system.
20.00
15.00
10.00
5.00
0.00
1989-05-01
2002-09-01
1971-01-01
1972-09-01
1974-05-01
1976-01-01
1977-09-01
1979-05-01
1981-01-01
1982-09-01
1984-05-01
1986-01-01
1987-09-01
1991-01-01
1992-09-01
1994-05-01
1996-01-01
1997-09-01
1999-05-01
2001-01-01
2004-05-01
2006-01-01
2007-09-01
2009-05-01
2011-01-01
2012-09-01
2014-05-01
2016-01-01
2017-09-01
2019-05-01
2021-01-01
2022-09-01
Source: FRED database; Author’s construction. Note: onsets of financial crises are marked by the bars in orange;
recessions by the bars in blue.
4 Conclusions
Given the rumblings in the commentary of moral hazard, the US government’s moves clearly gave
stability priority over moral hazard concerns. This was the correct call. The negative externalities
of deposit runs on other banks, which had not made the mistakes that SVB had, justify that by
themselves. There are of course risks to the actions by the US authorities: mid-sized banks are
concerned about a shift of deposits towards institutions considered “too big to fail” and have
petitioned the US government to extend the implicit wholesale deposit insurance to avoid this
dynamic (Tan, 2023).
In this regard, there is considerable risk if the SVB moment leads to an analogue of the Lehman
Brothers moment, when the subprime crisis erupted in full force. Specifically, Jiang et al. (2023)
estimate that the US banking system’s assets, marked to market, fall short of book value (if held
to maturity) by $2.2 trillion due to a decline of asset values by approximately 10% on average
across all banks, and by 20% for the bottom quintile. This is close to the aggregate amount of
5
The Biden Administration is expected to seek regulatory reforms to respond to the failure, but Republican
acquiescence is not likely as a Republican Congress will seek to hang the failure on Biden (e.g., for leaving Barr’s job
vacant for months, for not stress-testing SVB, etc.; see Stein and Stiegel 2023 for a discussion of the political
maneuvering that is shaping up).
References
Balsillie, Jim. 2019a. “ ‘Data is not the new oil – it’s the new plutonium’,” Financial Post, 28
May.
Balsillie, Jim. 2019b. “Remarks to the International Grand Committee on Disinformation and
‘Fake News’,” Dublin, 7 November 2019.
Barr, Michael S. 2023. “Review of the Federal Reserve’s Supervision and Regulation of Silicon
Valley Bank,” Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 28 April.
https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/svb-review-20230428.pdf
Buckley, Ross P. and Douglas W. Arner. 2011. From Crisis to Crisis: The Global Financial
System Regulatory Failure. New York: Kluwer Law International.
Calomiris, Charles W. and Joseph R. Mason, 2003, “Fundamentals, Panics, and Bank Distress
during the Depression,” American Economic Review 93(5), 1615-1647.
Chant, John, Alexandra Lai, Mark Illing and Fred Daniel. 2003. “Essays on Financial Stability,”
Bank of Canada Technical Report No. 95, September.
Chappatta, Brian. 2023. “SVB’s 44-Hour Collapse Was Rooted in Treasury Bets During
Pandemic,” Bloomberg, 10 March. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-
10/svb-spectacularly-fails-after-unthinkable-heresy-becomes-
reality?leadSource=uverify%20wall
Choe, Stan. 2023. “Deal to buy Silicon Valley Bank calms bank fears, for now. The Associated
Press, 27 March. https://ottawa.citynews.ca/national-business/deal-to-buy-silicon-valley-
bank-calms-bank-fears-for-now-6762165
Ciuriak, Dan. 2023. “How the Digital Transformation Changed Geopolitics,” Discussion Paper,
04 March. https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=4378419
Ciuriak, Dan. 2016. “Rebooting Europe,” McKinsey Global Institute, MGI Essay Prize:
Crowdsourcing ideas for revitalizing growth in Europe. https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-
insights/europe/mgi-essay-prize-crowdsourcing-ideas-for-revitalizing-growth-in-europe
Available at SSRN, http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2851329
Ciuriak, Dan. 2013. “An Amicus Brief in the Economists’ Court”, Review of From Crisis to
Crisis: The Global Financial System and Regulatory Failure by Ross P. Buckley & Douglas
W. Arner, Canadian Business Law Journal 54(3), December 2013: 425-448.
10
Copeland, Rob, Lauren Hirsch, Alan Rappeport and Maureen Farrell. 2023. “Wall Street’s Biggest
Banks Rescue Teetering First Republic,” The New York Times, 16 March.
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/16/business/first-republic-bank-sale.html
Curry, Timothy and Lynn Shibut, 2000, “The Cost of the Savings and Loan Crisis: Truth and
Consequences,” FDIC Banking Review, December, 26-28.
FDIC. 2023. “Bank Failures in Brief – Summary 2001 through 2023,”
https://www.fdic.gov/bank/historical/bank/
FDIC, 1997, An Examination of the Banking Crises of the 1980s and Early 1990s Volume 1,
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, http://www.fdic.gov/databank/hist80.
Garcia Pascual, Antonio, Fabio Natalucci, and Thomas Piontek. 2023. “Nonbank Financial
Sector Vulnerabilities Surface as Financial Conditions Tighten,” IMF Blog, 4 April.
https://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2023/04/04/nonbank-financial-sector-vulnerabilities-
surface-as-financial-conditions-tighten?utm_medium=email&utm_source=govdelivery
Giang, Vivian. 2023. “Banking Turmoil: What We Know,” The New York Times, 15 March.
https://www.nytimes.com/article/svb-silicon-valley-bank-explainer.html
Hirsch, Lauren. 2023a. “Small Banks Rush to Reassure Investors as Shares Plunge,” The New
York Times, 4 May. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/04/business/pacwest-stock.html
Hirsch, Lauren. 2023b. “Bank Turmoil Is Paving the Way for Even Bigger ‘Shadow Banks’,” The
New York Times, 6 May. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/06/business/dealbook/bank-
crisis-shadow-banks.html
Jiang, Erica Xuewei, Gregor Matvos, Tomasz Piskorski, and Amit Seru. 2023. “Monetary
Tightening and U.S. Bank Fragility in 2023: Mark-to-Market Losses and Uninsured Depositor
Runs?” NBER Working Paper 31048, April. https://www.nber.org/papers/w31048
Murray, John. 2013. “Price puzzles and the exchange rate,” Remarks by Mr John Murray,
Deputy Governor of the Bank of Canada, at Mount Allison University, Sackville, New
Brunswick, 19 November 2013.
Nixon, Richard. 1971. "The Challenge of Peace," Address to the Nation Outlining a New
Economic Policy. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency
Project https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/240602
Ocampo, José Antonio. 2017. Resetting the International Monetary (Non)System. Oxford
University Press.
OpenAI. 2023. “GPT-4 Technical Report,” arXiv:2303, 16 March.
11
Rappeport, Alan. 2023. “F.D.I.C. Proposes Broadening Bank Insurance for Businesses,” The New
York Times, 1 May. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/01/business/fdic-bank-insurance-
proposals.html
Smialek, Jeanna. 2023. “Fed Slams Its Own Oversight of Silicon Valley Bank in Post-Mortem,”
The New York Times, 28 April. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/28/business/economy/fed-
silicon-valley-bank-failure-review.html
Son, Hugh. 2023. “SVB customers tried to withdraw nearly all the bank’s deposits over two
days, Fed’s Barr testifies,” CNBC, 28 March. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/28/svb-
customers-tried-to-pull-nearly-all-deposits-in-two-days-barr-says.html
State Council Information Office. 2023. “China’s Green Development in the New Era,” White
Paper, State Council Information Office of the People’s Republic of China, January 2023.
Stein, Jeff. 2023. “7 doomsday scenarios if the U.S. crashes through the debt ceiling,” The
Washington Post, 14 May. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/
Stein, Jeff and Rachel Siegel. 2023. “Biden to push new banking rules after Silicon Valley Bank
collapse,” The Washington Post, 29 March. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/
Tan, Gillian. 2023. “Midsize US Banks Ask FDIC to Insure Deposits for Two Years,”
Bloomberg, 18 March. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-18/midsize-us-
banks-ask-fdic-to-insure-all-deposits-for-two-
years?utm_source=website&utm_medium=share&utm_campaign=twitter?sref=uN6cur8D&l
eadSource=uverify%20wall
Urbina, Fabio, Filippa Lentzos, and Cédric Invernizzi. 2022. “Dual use of artificial-intelligence-
powered drug discovery,” Nature Machine Intelligence 4, March: 189–191.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s42256-022-00465-9
Xi Jinping. 2022. “Rising to Challenges and Building a Bright Future Through Cooperation”
Keynote speech introducing the Global Security Initiative, Boao Forum for Asia Annual
Conference 21 April 2022.
12
13