Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mecanismos Neuronales
Mecanismos Neuronales
A DISSERTATION
W
IE
for the degree
EV
DOCTOR OF PHILOSPHY
PR
By
EVANSTON, ILLINOIS
December 2016
ProQuest Number: 10194111
All rights reserved
INFORMATION TO ALL USERS
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed,
a note will indicate the deletion.
W
IE
EV
ProQuest 10194111
Published by ProQuest LLC (2016 ). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author.
All rights reserved.
PR
This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code
Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC.
ProQuest LLC.
789 East Eisenhower Parkway
P.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, MI 48106 - 1346
2
W
IE
EV
PR
ABSTRACT
Neural Mechanisms Underlying Altered Interlimb Coupling in
Pediatric and Adult-Onset Hemiplegia
A stroke can occur at any point throughout the lifespan, including in utero. The timing of
the injury relative to neural development can have implications on the type of lesion, plasticity,
and motor deficits. However, associated reactions, which refer to involuntary movement in one
W
limb in response to voluntary activity at another, have been observed in children and adults
regardless of injury timing. The goal of this work was to quantify associated reactions in both
IE
pediatric and adult hemiplegia, as well as changes in neural structures, to understand how
damage from lesions at different points in development can result in abnormal interlimb
EV
coupling.
A novel method of measuring associated reactions was devised using a haptic robotic
PR
device. In adults with chronic stroke and children with prenatal and perinatal lesions, involuntary
upper extremity movements and EMG activity were quantified while participants performed
knee flexion and extension at varying effort levels with the instruction to relax their arm.
Additionally, diffusion tensor imaging was used to assess the corticospinal tracts and corpus
callosum.
All groups displayed involuntary interlimb coupling, however, the patterns of coupling
differed between groups. In adult stroke, upper extremity movements occurred in stereotyped
patterns based on the lower extremity task. This was seen to some extent in individuals with
perinatal lesions, but not with prenatal lesions. Additionally, participants with prenatal lesions
4
displayed increased involuntary coupling in the non-paretic upper extremity. The coupling
patterns seen in adult stroke are indicative of the extensively branching brainstem pathways that
are upregulated after stroke. In earlier lesions, a direct ipsilateral corticospinal pathway may be
used instead, which may account for the differences in interlimb coupling. Imaging findings
show that the corticospinal tract is more impacted by perinatal lesions than prenatal lesions,
which may affect differences in reorganization and motor deficits. Lastly, the corpus callosum
was found to be affected more by earlier lesions, which may impact the bilateral nature of
W
associated reactions and other deficits. This work demonstrates the need to address interlimb
coupling in clinical practice rather than treat the upper and lower extremities in isolation.
IE
EV
PR
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The upside to an eight-year degree spanning multiple departments is the many people you
meet along the way who shape your research and life in countless ways. Finishing this degree
would not have been possible without my amazing support crew, for whom this
acknowledgements section cannot come close to giving them the praise and credit they deserve.
First, I would not be here if not for a phone call I got from Jules Dewald, inviting me to
start this adventure. Jules’ love for science is infectious, and support of his students never
W
ending. He has an unwavering vision of the marriage of physical therapy and engineering, and
has successfully instilled this in me. Jules, I have seen you stand up for me and support me
IE
through the highs and lows, and am fortunate to call you a mentor and friend. My committee
members have also served to keep me on track, and have witnessed my research direction
EV
changing over the years as I discovered my interests and matured as a scientist. Deb Gaebler has
a passion for pediatric rehabilitation that is relentless. Her clinical insights, enthusiasm, and
PR
assistance with recruitment made this all possible. Todd Parrish, Tim Carroll, and Carson Ingo
were all invaluable resources in imaging and their technical expertise ensures I have the tools
needed to answer the scientific question. Matt Tresch is never without insightful comments, and
is a master of all things neuroscience. And while not a committee member, Ana Maria Acosta
was a much sought after resource, whether it was planning experiments, figuring out Jacobians,
I have learned more from senior graduate students than books and papers could ever
teach. Dan Krainak held my hand through the start of imaging work and instilled in me a healthy
(and at times crippling!) skepticism. Laura Miller, Jeremy Eagles, Jacob McPherson, and Laila
6
Alibiglou have all inspired me and provided me with sounding boards of scientific discussion
throughout the years. And most of all, a hearty thanks to Thersea Sukal Moulton, for paving the
way both in terms of the dual degree and in pediatric research. She has been a mentor and
friend, and I will always continue to seek her valuable opinions and advice.
Paul Krueger and Stuart “Friend” Traxel were both my knights in shining armor. The
experimental work would not have been possible without either one of them. Paul took on the
challenge of building a device that could work for the smallest 6 year old up to the tallest and
W
strongest adult. Thankfully, we never tested those boundaries! Stuart was the robot tamer, and
the first one I’d run to with robot failures or when I broke (another) load cell. He answered
IE
every dumb Matlab question without losing patience (at least outwardly), and even responded to
a few “emergency” emails after he left the department. Brad Holubar was also my superhero-
EV
whether it was getting grants in last minute, ordering supplies, or help with IRB, he always had a
“can-do!” attitude that made my life much easier! MRI data acquisition would not have been
PR
possible or gone as smoothly without the help of Marie Wasielewski and Azmi Banibaker.
my synthesis group- Victoria Azzi, Tommy Chrusciel, Katie Lullo, Laura Schorfheide, and
Liesel von Gontard, who made my experiments a breeze and taught me so much about
mentoring. Additional thanks to all the grad students and staff I would bug for intermittent help
– you were all the extra hands I needed for successful experiments.
None of this work is possible without our research participants donating their time and
trust, and inspiring me with their stories and strength. To everyone who signed on even after
hearing they would receive no direct benefit but possibly advance science, your generosity and
7
commitment to advancing medicine for the benefit of others is appreciated. The children and
adults alike have taught me, tested me, and made me laugh more times than I can count. I also
have possibly the most diverse Pandora and Netflix accounts thanks to everyone’s requests!
The camaraderie between my fellow graduate students has been a constant source of
strength- whether sharing idea or chocolate, it has been a joy to work with you all. Special
thanks to Meriel Owel, Nayo Hill, Emma Baillargeon, Rebecca Abbott, Christa Nelson, Lindsay
Garmirian, Natalia Sanchez- all of whom I frequently seek out their opinions and help, and seek
W
comfort in their candy stash.
The PTHMS faculty and staff have become a second family, and there is no group of
IE
people I would have rather spend these years with and learn from in so many ways. A special
thanks to Lois Hedman, for mentorship in teaching, friendship and shared almond flour orders
EV
that kept me going. Babette Sanders and Marjorie Hilliard are constant cheerleaders and sources
of support. Kristin Krosschell’s insights into all things pediatrics (and more) have been valuable
PR
throughout the years. Kathy Martinez was way too often my weekend friend, and watching her
finish her degree while carrying a heavy teaching load was inspiration for the final push. Daniel
Corcos and his endless supply of chocolate (and advice) that would magically appear was a
frequent lifesaver, and he was often responsible for keeping me out of trouble on weekends.
Carolina Carmona and Roberto Lopez have also been fantastic people to work with, always
While my clinical education started with the PTHMS faculty, my clinical instructors
helped shape me into the therapist and researcher I am. Heather Rennie of Athletico provided an
excellent introduction to clinical practice and tried not to flinch when I told her I had taken none
8
CA confirmed my love of pediatrics, and taught me more than seemed possible in six weeks.
Special thanks to Leslie Kuhagen at Swedish Covenant Hospital and Tracy Alvarez at Weiss
Memorial Hospital, for their patience, second chances, and instilling confidence when mine was
buried. I have been grateful for the opportunity to continue to grow as a therapist at Weiss
patients and profession. Thanks are due to my patients, who trusted me when I was a student and
W
new therapist, and whom I continue to learn from constantly.
While cliché, I’d be lost without my friends both within and outside this graduate school
IE
bubble. I embarked on this adventure with Camila Shirota and Jen Nichols, and together we were
victorious over Matlab and ice cream sundaes- neither stood a chance! Bethany (Vaughn)
EV
Rowson and Ali Anoff were always just a phone call away for good and bad news. Theresa
Murray, who started as a temporary roommate but after seeing me attempt to assemble Ikea
PR
furniture on my own, became a very dear friend and Skipbo partner. I may have self-combusted
without the triathlon community, for giving me an outlet and supporting me on my journey to
cross both athletic and academic finish lines. Even the sport itself deserves credit for all the
breakthroughs ideas and clarity gained during long swims, bikes, and runs.
Many thanks go out to Greg and Martha Gdowski, who took a chance on me as a
freshman and fostered my research development for four years. More importantly, you provided
me a second family and made sure I crossed the road safely (literally) to reach this chapter of my
adventure. Additional thanks to Amy Lerner and the rest of the Rochester BME faculty for more
than preparing me and instilling in me the notion of “Meliora- Ever Better”. Also thanks to
9
Sandra Hunter and Marquette University’s REU program for showing me that BME and
It is easy to get back up from the inevitable lows of graduate school when you have a
family that stands behind you 110%. My mom has loved me unconditionally, and been the
biggest cheerleader of my work. I only got my father for the first 14 years of my life, but the
work ethic and humor he instilled in me have been a source of constant strength. And last but
certainly not least, Lola and Olivia, for their unconditional love and understanding when days
W
were long, walks were short, and dinner was late.
Lastly, I was fortunate to be supported by various funding agencies over the years,
IE
including the National Science Foundation (Graduate Research Fellowship Program), National
Institutes of Health (NIH RO1 HD039343 and NIH T32 EB009406) and the American Heart
EV
Association (AHA 15PRE22990027).
PR
10
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
AD axial diffusivity
BF biceps femoris
CP cerebral palsy
CSC cortical-subcortical
W
EEG electroencephalogram
EMG electromyography IE
EPSP excitatory post-synaptic potential
FA fractional anisotropy
EV
GW gestational week
MD mean diffusivity
NT not tested
PERI perinatal
W
pKF paretic knee flexion
POST postnatal
PMRF
IE
pontomedullary reticular formation
PRE prenatal
EV
PVL periventricular leukomalacia
RD radial diffusivity
TD typically developing
VM vastus medialis
12
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... 3
Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ 5
W
List of Figures .............................................................................................................................. 17
W
2.7.
Overview of Movement Impairments in Pediatric and Adult Onset Hemiparesis ............... 45
3.6. Conclusion.................................................................................................................................... 69
W
4.2.1.
Participants ............................................................................................................................ 72
W
5.4.
DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................ 102
6.3.4.
Correlations Between DTI Metrics of Lesioned and Non-Lesioned Tracts ........................ 118
16
7. The Effect of Injury Timing on White Matter Changes in the Corpus Callosum
W
7.4.
Results ........................................................................................................................................ 136
LIST OF FIGURES
W
Figure 2.6 Reorganization in prenatal lesions based on size of lesion. ......................................... 43
Figure 3.2 Example of isometric torques generated during lower extremity task ......................... 64
Figure 3.4 Flexion and extension synergy patterns with robotic method...................................... 66
Figure 5.2 Magnitude of fingertip excursions for different effort levels. ..................................... 98
Figure 6.2 DTI Metrics for TD, PWM and CSC Lesions ........................................................... 117
Figure 6.5 Relationship between Fugl-Meyer Assessment score and Imaging Measures. ......... 120
W
Figure 7.2 Fractional Anisotropy by region.. .............................................................................. 138
LIST OF TABLES
Table 4-1 Characteristics of participants with chronic stroke. ...................................................... 73
Table 5-1 Participant characteristics for PRE, PERI, and POST groups. ..................................... 93
W
IE
EV
PR
20
1. INTRODUCTION
Hemiplegia can result from a lesion acquired at any point in development, including in
utero. It is often thought that lesions acquired earlier in development have better outcomes than
later lesions. This notion comes from the fact that brain plasticity may be greater earlier in life,
and the ability to recover or compensate from a lesion decreases with maturity. While some
aspects of this are true, the effects of lesion timing on motor outcomes are much more nuanced.
W
Rather than seeing one pattern of reorganization as superior to another, each comes with distinct
tradeoffs that can be seen in motor behaviors. For example, individuals with earlier lesions show
IE
deficits with mirror movements and bilateral coordination, while later lesions have greater
clinically referred to as “associated reactions” has appeared to transcend the limits of injury
PR
timing and is seen in both children and adults with hemiplegia. Associated reactions refer to
involuntary movement in one limb in response to voluntary movement in another. For example,
when a child with hemiplegia runs, driving the legs with great effort, the paretic upper extremity
is observed moving into a flexed posture. Since many activities of daily living require
coordination of lower and upper extremities, associated reactions can pose challenges beyond the
deficits isolated to the upper and lower extremities individually. While most clinicians will
acknowledge the presence of associated reactions, they are rarely addressed, and some
interventions such as high intensity gait training may actually exacerbate them.
21
associated reactions are an important clinical problem that warrants further study, they can also
serve as a probe to examine reorganization of the motor system after a lesion. Certain patterns of
movement are known to be reflective of using specific motor pathways. By pairing quantitative
measures of motor behavior with measures of morphological changes from diffusion tensor
imaging, further insight is gained as to the underlying neural mechanisms individuals with
hemiplegia.
W
The goal of this dissertation was to quantify associated reactions in both pediatric and
adult hemiplegia, as well as changes in neural structures, to understand how damage from lesions
IE
at different points in development can result in abnormal interlimb coupling. In Chapter 2, the
reactions in both pediatric and adult hemiplegia. Chapter 3 will detail the development of an
PR
appropriate methodology to investigating abnormal interlimb coupling between the lower and
individuals with hemiplegia from an adult-onset lesion, setting the groundwork for the pediatric
work by establishing the effect of a lesion to the fully developed nervous system. Next, in the
study presented in Chapter 5, associated reactions were examined in individuals with hemiplegia
from prenatal, perinatal, or postnatal lesions to determine how associated reactions manifest
when the lesion occurs at varying time points in early development. To further understand the
differences between early injury timing groups, Chapter 6 presents a diffusion tensor imaging
study to quantify differences in the corticospinal tracts in prenatal and perinatal injury groups to
22
determine if differences in motor behaviors may be due to the amount of damage. Lastly,
while the focus of this dissertation is on coupling between the lower and upper extremities,
bilateral coupling is also problematic and may be due to changes in the corpus callosum.
Chapter 7 compares changes in the corpus callosum between pediatric and adult onset
hemiplegia to give insight into this motor behavior. Cohorts of age-matched control participants
W
IE
EV
PR
23
burst vessel (hemorrhagic stroke), starving brain tissue of oxygen and nutrients resulting in death
of brain cells. Current statistics (Mozaffarian et al 2016) report approximately 795,000 people in
the United States have a new or recurrent stroke each year, 610,000 of those being first time
W
events. It is estimated that 6.6 million Americans over 20 years old have had a stroke. Risk
factors include high blood pressure, diabetes mellitus, arrhythmias, and smoking. Ischemic
IE
strokes are more common and account for 87% of strokes, with intracranial hemorrhages making
EV
up 10% and sub-arachnoid hemorrhages accounting for 3% (Mozaffarian et al 2016). The
recovery and deficits following a stroke are varied, and can depend on the location of the lesion.
The middle cerebral artery (MCA) is the most common vessel involved in stroke, and MCA
PR
strokes can result in weakness or paralysis on the opposite side of the body (hemiparesis),
sensory losses, and attention and language deficits. Fifty percent of all stroke survivors report
hemiparesis six months following the stroke, which has significant implications on mobility,
The Brunnstrom stages of recovery describe recovery from a stroke to occur in six stages,
however, an individual could plateau at any one stage, which could become their chronic status.
Stages progress from initial flaccidity and inability to move the limb at all, to the appearance and
strengthening of spasticity and flexor and extensor synergy patterns. Movement confined to
synergy patterns is followed by movement out of synergies, with decreasing spasticity. Nearing