Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ShyLee Schwartz
EDU 415
Geneva College
Teacher Website
SchoolTube
https://www.schooltube.com/videos/latest?page_id=1
SchoolTube is a great resource for teachers when teaching novels in multiple medias. By
carefully choosing videos, teachers are able to engage their students in the novel at hand
in a deeper way than simply reading. Beyond this, teachers and students can create videos
on SchoolTube. For this standard, the teacher would make a video covering elements to
look for within the novel at hand as an introduction. The video would be made instead of
just simply teaching it in order to include snippets of sneak peeks for the students to get
them engaged. After the unit is complete, and the students have compared the text to the
media, the teacher can instruct the students to create a video covering a specific element
and explain or show how it is similar or different in each version.
Student Website
PBS Learning Media for Students
https://wqed.pbslearningmedia.org/search/?q=romeo%20and
%20juliet&selected_facet=grades:9-12&student=true
PBS Learning Media for Students is a great resource for when students are doing a unit
that requires video footage. There are many videos and lessons on this site pertaining to a
wide variety of topics that the students can use to deepen their understanding. In this
case, students would be instructed to use the site as a way to deepen their understanding
of the story before being exposed to the media version. For example, after reading Romeo
and Juliet students would be prompted to go to this site and watch videos of their choice
that are about Romeo and Juliet. This gives the students a little bit of freedom in what
they are learning since each student will pick different videos. It will also spark
disucssion because each student will have focused on different topics within the work and
came to diffferent conclusions.
Other Media
Poem Hunter- Romeo and Juliet Poem by Cherise Joubert
https://www.poemhunter.com/poem/romeo-and-juliet-13/
This poem by Cherise Joubert encompasses the forbidden love between Romeo and
Juliet. It offers a perspective to the situation outside of that of Shakespeare’s. Students
can take this poem about the love the play revolves around and compare it to that in the
written work and in the media play. Students can analyze how the love is portrayed and
what is emphasized within it when comparing the multiple ways it is displayed.
Course Hero- The Great Gatsby Characters Video
https://www.coursehero.com/lit/The-Great-Gatsby/videos/
Course Hero is a great resource for teachers when used correctly. This specific video
regarding characters can help the students to get a grasp on the characters before reading
the story. I found this resource by searching for The Great Gatsby Character Videos, this
one on Course Hero is the best that I found to use in a classroom with high schoolers.
Standard CC.1.4.9-10. I: Distinguish the claim(s) from alternate or opposing claims; develop
claim(s) fairly, supplying evidence for each while pointing out the strengths and limitations of
both in a manner that anticipates the audience’s knowledge level and concerns.
Tradebooks
Bennett, B. (2020). The Vanishing Half
The Vanishing Half is a historical novel written about identical twin sisters who, despite
always being identical, have to make the decision between staying loyal to their
community and their own personal freedom. The novel shows how the sisters adult lives
are different and how they navigate their situations. Because this novel is about twin
sisters who drastically change their lives from each other, students are able to analyze the
novel as the sisters being the differing perspectives. They make different decisions that
propel their lives in different ways. Students are able to analyze these decisions while
grasping the strengths and weaknesses and how they affect each girls life.
Flynn, G. (2012). Gone Girl
Gone Girl is the story of a woman who goes missing. Her husband is framed for her
murder, and the story follows the investigation. Throughout the story readers learn that
the woman has her own plan. She was not murdered, she is hiding and framing her
husband. This novel is one that parents would be made aware of prior to instruction due
to its heavy topics and elements. Within this standard, this novel works well because it
shifts perspectives. Sometimes readers are with the husband in the present while working
through his thoughts during the investigation. Other times, readers are with the wife in
her diary learning about her perspective on their relationship and their dynamic. Students
are able to take both perspectives, analyze them, and find the strengths and weaknesses in
both from the audiences perspective.This novel allows students to gain exposure to
differing perspectives and claims, without it being a real world example or a political
endeavor.
Thomas, A. (2017). The Hate U Give.
The Hate U Give follows the main character, Starr, through her life living in a poverty
struck neighborhood to her life attending the fancy suburban prep school. It is a deep
story that parents would need to be made aware of. This novel deals with social injustice,
racism, and police brutality. While these are heavy and sensitive topics to involve in a
high school classroom, they are able to teach the students valuable lessons. Beyond the
social lessons, the students would be able to compare the perspectives of life in both areas
of Starr’s expereince. How life and people are different in the poverty struck
neighborhood to those in the prep school. Students can analyze these expereinces as a
way to compare both sides of the spectrum and create claims about the similarities and
differences found in them.
Salinger, J.D. (1951). The Catcher In The Rye
The Catcher In The Rye follows the main character Holden on his search for truth after
being expelled from prep school. While it only follows Holden’s perspective, it is easy to
see that there are differing perspectives on his life and opinions versus what is
mainstream. It is a critique of society in the way that Holden ends up emotionally
challenged due to the implications society placed on him. This novel works well for this
standard because students can take what society claims Holden should be and do and
compare it to what Holden believes he should be and do. They can view this novel from
the perspective of Holden versus society and analyze the elements of the novel in a way
that shows the claims of each, employing them to create arguments and provide evidence
for their arguments.
Teacher Website
DOGO News
https://www.dogonews.com/
DOGO News is a great resource for teachers when teaching standards like this
one. Teachers are able to go on the website and find articles of current events to
have students analyze and make claims on. By the teacher controlling the articles
chosen, it will be ensured that differing claims and opinions are used in order to
fully teach this standard. DOGO News has many articles that are written for and
appropriate for students that help them to get involved in the world all while
learning the elements from their teachers.
Student Website
NewsELA
https://newsela.com/about/content/browse-content/
NewsELA allows teachers to create classrooms for their students to browse articles
appropriate for their grade and reading level. Within this standard, students would be able
to find articles that interest them to put against each other. By finding two different
articles regarding the same topic, students can analyze the perspectives, create claims
about them, and outline their strengths and weaknesses. It gives students freedom in their
work and prompts engagement by being able to choose their own topic to show what they
are learning.
Other Media
Khan Academy- What is an Argument Video
https://www.khanacademy.org/ela/cc-5th-reading-vocab/x798e47233e450b09:cc-5th-
inventing-progress/x798e47233e450b09:close-reading-argumentative-text/v/what-is-an-
argument-reading
I found this video by searching for teaching argument videos on Khan Academy. This
video teaches students what an argument in writing is. Students can watch this video to
understand what an argument is so that they can analyze the differing claims and create
their own claims. It teaches them to identify an argument so that they can distinguish
them, along with the strengths and weaknesses of arguments, in different writings.
CNN- Who Will Win This Terrible Conflict News Article
https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/13/opinions/israel-hamas-gaza-iran-ghitis/index.html
I found this article by searching argumentative news articles, navigating to CNN and
choosing an article that displayed a strong opinion. While it is only one article, and would
need another to pair with it in order to the students to distinguish both sides of the topic,
this article speaks on the tragedy in Israel. It is a current world news article, that not only
gives students insight into what is happening in the world, but allows them to use the
tools they learn when navigating argumentative claims and applying them to the life in
the real world. Students can use this article as practice to find the claim of the author, and
point out the strengths and weaknesses in their argument before doing the same to novels
or large works.