You are on page 1of 44

trw.tRw^ffiH{tffie )FRW.il1EtrW.

'
I tffiF)

t +tffiF ) I Abstract)
4 t + + ;={-ffiEEE-Hffi ( pietrich Bonhoeffer, "Non-Religious Interpretation of christianity" is an important
1e06- re4s)Lkffifr1| )FRW.tr1HtrW.t ,Ufll , D])*.tflff# theme of the late thought of Bonhoeffer and it also led to ambiguous
wffir,ftFnE ffi fl'.]- ArtJ rfiftE' l-FIffitft{Jilt:li I r ft ff understandings in modern era, therefore it is necessary to discuss
{4r ' rgf;g{flftAF'.])FRW'Wfr4tr+ t DI)*.t'si|1,:.1+ ' some of the main subject-matters, such as the world of coming
e t H n *[ ffi#EFl," m- ff ln ffift#;fr tr!
ft ft,fl)lll'fBRffi Age, This-worldliness, Non-Religious Interpretation of the Bible
EfFWRq,BffiHR , D)&.fr-ft4{ffJ i'f,ifrliiJ: . ffi- concept, and Reality, etc. to clarify the exact meaning behind the
#ls(n- E E FEtrH ffi F ffi y{ *,rrtt}+\trl\lJ,.l fL{lU)y-,8g?4 theme.
g -iffffi FEffi;={--nfr
' 4 H H r )l ',t::W.lHJ,\4\ v+tl llllftEF'!ftE
In this paper, the first part is to introduce the development of
'lR" m= *Y'(t ffi iUY'l | )1",'it\ -t ' l il'[,ltl'[ul' I y]k
Bonhoeffer's thoughts and its relevant background in this period,
r tr H I+ +,ft ff.Jftii,ffl'
: $ 4iJi llj'fTlil'li li llljlUf/'Jtft,lE' H
lir1
which lead to the definition of discussion methods. The next part
EEEtH f EFlir fJ I' 'il"2'lt f'Uillll'tT2'1't/r'fut F'.1T E
begins to reflect the influence of liberal theology and dialectical
t-fuH " ffiv!*\|$J 'f'li{a.$Jl'lil't: (1,i,('[,,rf m) +Eflf] t)F
theology on Bonhoffer and restates the problem of christology in a
Rffi.tr]# tr #xt l&lflt ffJI t ifttlftl,ff ,' lfii,1iiirlsltJ - frt | )F#
new perspective, through which to review the origin of the statement
W.WEtr ffi.t ,EfHliil l'ty.'lul''ft irjilldI|i t^l^i
{lrl"J'{JtH'j;fi fi"]EIHE
of "Non-Religious Interpretation of christianity". In the third part,
fi frJ ' it fiHfi#EEtrH frl{J&l/[{,tfi,li&{ul,1,"[l ryi{ Jl'L[t {+E5',l'F
F!
the emphasis of the subject-matter turns to the concern in this world
g E E{4 .
along with the same theme-Bonhoffer emphasizes the dimension of

encounter between the reality of God and the reality of this world.

In the fourth part, the topic will concentrate on the explanation from

Bonhoeffer's important work "Letters and papers form prison". In

the conclusion part, we will give two possible dialogue directions

that could provide the open source of the thoughts of Bonhoeffer,

and discuss two properties of transcendent faith and this-worldly

concern in Bonhoeffer's thoughts.

Key words: Religion; Non-religion; christ; Gospel; This-worldliness


tr#\rfl.rg^ffiH{tffie

I H;'i )
t'( lAti( I)ietrichllonhoefl'er,
U f+ 14ft ' HIIa]F. 1906-
t945) '
fHE +frryX - F;]fi,v.r*. $tfl.J+kfil|j,,/lttJ,l{,1i,C EIffitr ffi - -R.
trFtHIrl$fj!ui?fit tr;tr:itr\'ltffJ,il ' ririftffi+ftf;trHf
l,qlj -
liljililil /d iI ' , lill,(ti.f'ilrldMry,B,tFfr!e4E
M F /i. ,frff.Jtl,?
h.Hfttwll".t w Lllli IrL fil fl{{5t" ll lNltltY., lrrureg aFH
HF!/.Hrl?t?qtffif tr t- ('rttwtkfu.& It ffi+FEEE,
i /.{ruet.HA T g fUffin ff i€ E, Irl|rE4{ g F ft E'f'niE
E -t o 2 | *"A+' F El-rfr.frfr!- , (fr.fr\+-fr IF ffifEJ EA ffi
tF€ XHs- fE,E, tfFfntaffitrlT "=H n'.1 fi#A' il"?T, ru,H H - ==
ft ltuwa H Fnffifi! x It trnt$fifr.tr fE+ /. I,ktffi, F!EX ++-6q H
--6Fi,,
J:)h-Htr & HrcIffi.gh +&H+'I&+H f[ ifi fr B'l- fEffi
Irfr.3/L
M€ FHT

F r*t1 . *f E'.lH gf.M=t ' 4i +


,+L{l 1tit . E { E
ffi-Hft. ,B.ffitrE
fiF":+fr ' DlE-lefr\E€+'=fn#U#{ 1tuil1r8fr4' ^EEffi
*f,
Ifi.TE D].T6 tr FEil1w.# ' ME TR,11B,.] E € E f5 H TE EEE Hffi - +.FfifrgffiF!E+Ffr' ffi 6ffirc;rL@ffiA?.,
fr.+kfP1ffi 'X
Hf , 4;+ ' F[lP.Hlfr.HE Yi+F"xtfr1 +.frE. f"lffi +FH,E,fSEE W.@ f iE,frlfr H.m= ' #t3E-{HtrgF!
,1ift,ffis+++Effid6tft!lE-{$ ,ft B+{t.
trnEKWF+{R ' *"iI
+n{ruI#.ifr.ffisft,+ "ffiF.ffl
TA i# YfrE!' q A fr Hft Ifrfr\fi ffiFn
j 4
+fiEH ' iXiI' ff E ifr,tr'y'.{'*fr\yLfff-"'"'

r llll t l i / ' i l r l r r / ; r t r r ' 1 l . r l l ,ll0 ' lktit jtlF lu ( l1 :l,,tl' j( r lr i,; r iil( f/.j{l.al,,'il l i rer,,'+.,E s
| | t't!fl! fit I i liif I I
l)) l l l i l . t l tl t4 ' r l l j t ' t r l r l f.i ,i'1 "1 : (tJ,ilr lr ,tf
fl ) ,r ' il,l1 iiil) l/r llll/.J( lliliir ,ri' l rgei I 9rj #,fr,F
f t l {i lt r ' r i t , i ' l t l l ' t r r i i r l LI l r lll/t
illfi[: Ill,lI/r,lttt' Illi'/rI],t,l'14J'I
rr'i

lltrrtlo.qitttt ('hrittiun, Mun for His Time


Flbcrhartl f f cllrgc. /)rclr ir lt Ihtttltrttlfrt A Ilirt,qtttltll
(Fortrcss l'ress. Itcvist'tl lirlrtrorr,ltcvrsetl irrrtl rrlilcrl by Vrctorirr.l Iiarnett, Minneapolis) ' fl
xllt "
RW.THWWH'{tffi€ , lffi-H . fififfi)
)FffiW.B<J+E#.

ffie EE$ffi ffiRfiftr+ ILltfidfr fi ,E'fFFni+.8tr'l I H {ft- (fr.'rre.*4r'uffie


XWgffi -lfr.Eg',(ft.. ftffiW?Fp.
,
+Fl'.H'!H H WIA,L.'IHglEiiWH?'Y',FI,D] r y'.I mfr,a' mHffiH E E tHtr D)&-E Iffi^ffi-#fFtr ffi fH ( Finkenwalde
) ft.J
E2,& t FStfitT lt I DIH$REEz+ H!/.ffiy{
ff.lf;niHffi ffi.ryftS,ffi + f+#tJF'lE iE, h n\E r sB7F fn 1e3e+ H F*,7
IFffiH +.Hffii+Fn-fiH fr"]r t'ffi tr ff F I F"]HH -ad
f[i[ (iFFTtftW'ftiH) DlE-(H44 i6) " th.Llftlfrftr ggg
,E,t .' {t.A Hffi,E,ffi f{Rfutlg[trF{rffiE,H,,H.fHBE' +Htth+fn4teffiffi;tr8 (Egffi) D)&.(BlJtreqE
ft ryF g iE+ ffi fi'.]{Uff.J
-'fH W&
EP.,Effi H Rfr.hfrHtE,T E W> trIg;dHIEffHE "
_H fi 6O
f f i= W F p(.r oso - 1 e 4)s+- EH + H j + - fi ffi F [# ,
ffi-W$p.(rczz-rgss4) - HHEHffi E ft,WFp.*. EEE.Hffi g + Wts-AF,'] IEIEfrI +, IElrR,R{FE E lHEI'
(eaotrvonHarnack)
T[7 H B+H H tfrryAHfrF,fr. ' Em tr^ffitr,fr t (Reinhotd Niebuhr)trl1E+ lft,ffif+E , 4[R +ktfr.
(Karl Holl) . ffi'fHt6 (ReinholdSeeberg)
n'V#€ ' , ff W+kF^] frEtr 9 E ffi , ffiX Hitk' +k"Ftlp.H
IEJ Htg.tr
Tg27+ ft,FT7g.ETH' E+E.WiIt{ ^lTE ryWEtgEg"ftW4.ft . 'oE fHtrffi Ff,+fr.#frt{X
f-F.
ffi F ffiE trIffiE A E++
(Karr Barth) HHf!tS+-ffi1 (W.tft.fHE , ffi.@ff gg$l qJr+ {+;+, HrhAffirF-if;' +rbfrfrFflE[11ff1'o]{Fffi .
w.#.#t) Dlktr EFFaf;ruffiffi€^rlF-Fpr+rfifh ' '' I[{,frE.frNft.Iff NT {&E #*frTfifr , f'l 940+ ffiffiH IF
gs " ( { f f iI E H)" f t t e 4 s+ 3 ,E
1 7EEsF 2 r A, Ifu *q ffi EU
fr!r 0+ ft,F1,7W.frW,;fr I Kt1fihWHH, Afif tFry+ n'.1
n -#ffirjfr++f;, " lflFa Hs E+fim' Eftt+t6 (regel) ffi,-Ft'
ftWWryf[Af,effi ) " Ifftk=+F"l' lfrmi W.ry#t tr
f#fr!ffifinffie Fft,#16-+ it fr E ++h.gtr w.@E F,,e-w IE
tk LH T lfrtrf#+ ffie'fE - fi6+ Ftru*Et E F xil7#
ffimgJ?ffil{n IF- (l-Fi+#ffi) .
"
ffi- WFp(rgss-rgsg4 ) -E-pl&F9.frftfr++fih ffi- f;ff. ,8ffiHF
F,.]tH, I.F.ryT EEEHffitrAffiry,rfiJ&EEW , IEEiT
HEEHffiE,FS ffitEErt )6+nfrH'r+ffirymirr(27fr,
T H WE ie ffi,E7tg WRFS ffi 7 1fr.6, E frEtXtfr,ifr,Ar _ Dlh.w.@trtr tr zrfi ffi wR9?+ ;fr . f+ffiE EE
E Hffi ,E
D)+.ftH8*H,!trtitiEj r,t@WW_F,.]iffi
H+ffi, 1fr,ff1,8ffi -
ffi#EF! -fr H' E +trfid+xlfrffi f,!E H. #+Fg,B
s $f ; iiz fi , ( H { t E f i * f W . f f i r y> ( tiF , =m' lssS) ' f1 ' 2' 1 7 6 2'
6 John D. Godsey, The Theololqy oI Dietrich Bonhoelfer, (The Westminster Press, Philadelphia,

res8
) 4\Lft,g,ifr"
7 StanleyJ(irenz&RogcrEolson, #tjj,till{'{Lf'It'| ,ifl' (( . I lll:f;Jl4r+lJT;ft
- tffi4ffi
4 + f l ' J l l tfl ) (t{l {tl ' rri l i l i [ri l .' il) r ]x) ' f{ r 74 "
Dietrich B<rnhoclfcr,Sirnctorunr('omnrunio: A'l'lu<tlttgitul Strul.yol tht Srx:ioktgyof the Church.,
Edited by Clifford J (irccn 'l'rarrslatcdhy Rcinhard Krauss and Nancy Lukens (Fortress Press,
1996 )
((-fff#dffig-#ffi)
10 StanleyJGrenz&RogerE.olson, ' H17s ' 4E Ktrilf$ffi) HfE "
Dietrich Bonhocl'lcr, Att tnd Rting:T'rans<endentul Philo.tophy and Ontology in Systematic
11 John D. Godsey, The Theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, lEHt' Ht9z "
Theoktlqy, Edited by Wayne Whitson l.loyd. Jr Translated by Martin Rumscheidt (Fortress Press,
1996 )
RW.IRT.EffiH,,ftffiE )FRffi.Vl+E#.' (ffi-H . #fi;fr)

ffi '2Dlk*#'n?.ffie'' ffiA<ffiqftEfttrHft ' ,I--FEEH *ftffifr! - HFy'.f,.l+ffi{4 +fi*l==ffiFfrttFffi, ^ffitrrft


H+trFf[W.@nffi f Ll,ffi ffi€ ff'J
ltt/6.|U'iEfgZ+' I4 Zffi f! fSt ;fr{ D,tkW.ffi;fft y{ffi ;Hffi e r F # f,.l{E/.
{EHi$fiHx , }iJt ft ',H&tfi,*ftq F!frlatwl
frft.trlffiw.{"H E fHffi lD)W' my,Jffi;HiFry
+ # f[ +H*tr]fi it t 'o ft7i;If.;4
+H.t Rwtrlrf l\Xft lfr.El+tffi#,Vtt&E " ' 'o Eiffitr!tr,B4r/EirflSlJ tgst+ffi-KW E++gEHtfAY{ E
ffi-Mfr E ' EEtrHffi tr +*tilYW.TH H ifl(+
Vffiff ++,8fgF'!,8,4 " 'o
g E F,E"l,E,tF' 'fEAF
f,F' fulffiffi+* 9 7 ffi--n?+F
ffiA F"l,E' VrAffffi- IHfrE fr!#KHjX iFft - Hiffi WthRWft &
#{ffiAAffiH,T&F,,W{#aT +ft.A+++HffiE,ff' ' lgssFs WNREF$g'I-IE{tA E f;STE'FE ffiITtrf, W.EI\+NX
tr HH E"HffiAffrf4tg Fn?frfl;ffifs (Hg;fr) ' FFEfff tEiffil$ffi.RW.{HfttkffiTfi.] 4frt" " EIlEHffitr= i
fi {t W@EE fit #.$-nfftr! l-,K#{H ff!t ffi;fr,8tHI " 8"1;fr r IEffiEH f+frlW|+, I$ffiHt+Hqft # )\EA Hf++fE
s ' f'JltHH+ H H+#tF ry+D)fiLffiffi,8ffff (r'riearictrp.e. RE' MFfHEIE' fh{ffi E fil..F^7Yi- +]JF-E'F[{FE
Schreiermacher) ffi iF FFtrl l-,B*i+{4ff'Jffi.F-ffiA ) 'u ffi{t * " .
ffit trl#l+ +Ht ' fi'fHEftEf'iffiffi+#A " r" ffi
ffa1;Hffi,F iltrtr!ry +.ffi Fi ffi (AlbrechtRitsch ) F ffi Ftffi ftl H ftE, EEE.Hffitr tr,fiHig I-ffiffi8#I F"]gffiE+Ff EYf
+.tfiffi E (wittretmHerrmann ) ffiAT r !)(y'-fr'J^mFR{"H {Effi - H+
ft'lEltr fE {t H F + ffiffiFE' Ff,,ni&##++ Ffr'/ttfifft,
tr#RfiJ', il,Jf+F. tEEHEHffitr! ryTfuplEFP,HtrE€ v-flJ r tr H lfi E tr&TiE€fth tfr,W.W F'.1T frW.# il F'.14 g
ifi irrvl *Brg"fB H H ifrffi A fd€ # E FfrE
H'H+H ie,E,'F,F ^
ffi,frjEtrih^ffiffi ,IF.{tfr'Ef't€fnEfHE'.1 F'ffiE r E
rnfrH^i
rfiFE' m a 7 EHEHffi Ei#Ef"ltrE' E tr Lh.ffi trffi.. .". . IBlfr.ifi
iff#tr^+lt;+F,!FE' TE W.@frtF
HIF ({frIEg) H'+F'lrEEfrFFf I ils(nHW-^E€Htr'l g F'lHg W., friEc=fEEtr ffi.f'.]tr IEffiffi, r i€f€H'l,ffi
Ffiru" 18ffiH Hiftffiry4;i;.fr49-iffH+fEq[ffi WEg# Er J . " EXHy{tr18',tre.ffi+ffiUXy{tffi6!JFI==
Itpwwry;Hffi , DlE-ffil+trr8,['413Ftrro
FnhffiWRW. ,
12 #w.E frirrffieEHffittfrRt6ffigeE #ffi fi 6'.1)s{*rufi{SfftEffi MryffiffiEtfr.
+[, E&+Effim (Albrecht Ritschl tr f! +S€fiHfi t )€tll Affi , 1fr|lhftEktfll?W.
) flnAf;fr - tr FU ^sf6ffi FnffiE ffiR W.Wry + E t ffiflEHtrF,.l
i$ffl i$f
F+irrfr+@ E frE#?Se#E+ ifiH-F.ffin.' +H+*ft+ ' <Hl\EfiffiW++
4) ,H.z"
13 # tffif}: + trfrE- + + {t' v}F.w+ Itfr#Er)t* l ffi+'L'tr'J *ffi tFg' ;ttH € *FE 1+ 19 John D. Godsey, The Theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer IEJHf ' Fts "
Lffi 2E ( wordof coa) illE-*fiE#,, tfr,-ijfl Ll+ Lfi.2 i H + il'Ji+.'.,EW*ilD^&-fl'-ffi
20 i H t l E f f t E f g i l WW ( r e r g 4 &* F,.1( ( f,8 e ) f+# ) ) 'f.8 # 9 ft
;* ffiq l "j('[{ t}1r+Iill' +-fr Efr,v'L trlffiffi ' ryH
ffieEilt fi tLrEffitf +firy' ft m-aA , irlffi-.\.8+tHtF#E+&;f igFilTIFW. ...iBE
John D Godsey,The Theoktgy of Dietrit'h Bonhoeller, I'iJfii ' H l4 "
t('t #.h.Ftt7 '
ffiWilrt4^ & tr'f# H f'l ffi e X ( ffi -'aHM
&'EWffi 2H ^&W.*frW.W* E ryfB) - *.hEH (Friedrich
r.1 F*f1-' <<H|\ffili{tffil$l#)' ltri?" Gogarten) . frf ffiq (RudolfBultmann)f[#fUfi (PaulTillich) ' EfiqEEffiZffiF,l
rs EfrMY;' t'.1L, ;'#' (41 ''iiilittliliijll'.'ltr)(6i&'i4;F4g#i{1Lnfrfr,
'+lll.l/t. EffiXtl€ffiffi""' 4fl.mffi . *+frl#' HEtrH. ,1-"1)tiE ;+ ' ((:+g6d**n
F ftl l ',f'k' ::o o tl f: )' fi (i 7' l,g) (tiF , t.Wy'tEfrftfiff' 1e8e) ' IT4o0.
l6 l. ' [ir.7 .
Irt'J 2r H*fr+, KBI\Wfr*fiffiffiry> ' Flnrr"'Hoe.
t7 J r i lL ' fi T r " 22 EFEHffi' (Fi+=ffi) ' lElnrr" ' Hraa.
r8 EE HH frh i P ; ' /tl JI:l l l t ,iV , ( ifiir r llr i!) ( if i6 iq;EEg#f
' { I?' hfr ' ft'F nH ftF ' 1ee8 23 t&#,8++*'FtgE;+ , <y&fte++' tr^f'.:ffiEgffi.Hilr=Jtft>' fl H (flHtf!€H ,
+) ' f1 i r'
glt " t r *WE E f f i > ( ffi - ffi ,+F- fr ffi tt , 2 o o 4 +tF) 'H r s .
RW.IRTE,tr-H,{tffiF JFR#.WE-E#, (ffi-H . ffiffi)

E, DIEWryH^lt. ffi+fr.ffi6Lk, EfHf'lt ffiaFE2w. ffiffi ' D)&.8ff&ffiflr+{tH-8 tr!* HF"fi ' 4 i+&
iffi ' E IElfr.tr,R={J,ffir f'Jtr IE+ fi'.]tr IEiEffi iEffiH!ffitk HEE ' {Elfr,Fnl..flffiD}&.H#ffiEgffirfiffi ' FUm
trtfi,'FtE rftEf'filfiFftlffi+Ffft: I " 'olnRffitr,xil1 WW,EftEfg fl Hft +,L.' tEE{tf^]H#IE W. &
l-ffi ffi E # I fEi* E f'l H'H+/-,L'ft fuq F"l-ffiH HE{4 F!+]L g +,1.ffitr EEE Hffi il1#IF+ IFffi A 6 f[ fr i*f,! fH
;+ ' flJMEHEHffiE,.] I JF?ffi.il1*trffi.IFUtrE7 Etr E ffiAE,H91T4AVl . EIItr' EfFffits.FtrHtJHH
ffi.EIE{t fdg + tr €' trTtfr{fi fr IFffi-E f'Jtr{AIV" tftfr rntr&-Hffi;frffi+"
'Ht)tk )\ f.lHf 4{'+ffiE' +EH-fEl[{E]ffiffl*ft ffl' ( z ) ft#ATAftffiFfI#E " HEEHffi tr.],BfF#RFffiE
f'JE g.fEltlrtr1ffi---"p.'l'4
+E;#' E fr + ffiIE, | )FR W
HF flro mHMqffiffiL{r' Elft T lElffif, WEp^ffiE
ft,
trlEEffi.t ffi*ffitr'l;-f;fr " -t?ffiff- WFP+& IHfiffiill WWfft 4 trlYtBfrJF HE F "
4 { ft + il-# FtrfiffiFffrtrE{E',*ffi.HFH+' EE ( g) t4f"1f! WRfr trffi# " EIIEHffiTIEWEF\ffiE
EHffi FfifEfr tr1E-L.* E*ffif;gffiE' IEJ[+AF& E A Hfr ,g
IF+.#H4ffi ^ fHE . AT FJZTFZH€HfHIA
fi ' +ffi
'rkfrl| )FffiW.trtFtrW. t fi!ffi,A' t)lk@ffi ft ffiA Fnffi 4 ffi ID)tr1+ EF, IET E H FAtrlqfr.H
ffi;FJ R HT IEIf!
ffitr]-#ItJF"lffi' rfiffiff.lEfTl ' rItff{4J - l-g .
E # A 1 H Fttr iFE EbE ffiD}*frNfr HEEHffi,Ef.F
Dlh.IHEr S'
frSffinAfrT)Fffiffi.++ffiffit fHilTffiETEM.
m= Hff. il'f-ffifr lt, ffi ;frsJI A f! tFffi+-+ 4xIt M fi i*' ru FI* ffi ---#
EEEHffiV!# {Ftr T.-ft,M2s' E m'rufr"llF€,E fFifi (Theodor Adorno) #,, 4H,BffiE-fE,BMA FH ( H
TEfE{*_.{EIg;fr #ffi., &TE{€ IX-€.I=INWHF]J ' H ) FffizHYHffi#tJ,Bf,Ff^1E9i " 'uf+.FnHEEEHffiF'.1
mE ft'*-H+-B*I+FWET lEf"lfr'ft ' T lEf"l{EfrH' 4 lEl ,
IFFrIE EIiHH$fi/,1{ tr!ffiF SJ;f;ffi{# ' tr Ift , +fr,{fl
tl€'
(frStj
ff!f,t€ fnfl+f,H'I=o JEH ffiE It Ifr z trE f#--{E)Fffi HE E gH,ft E+fr,ZrrF.fr#=A E WIfr:trftVA
f[ ffift fil IEJ
w.wff € tEE , fi'{H-#;frffiw.HI+ItrH #, z #,#r.++ ft'l/. + mfr +.ffi HH illff 6f;fr+t fr?ffiJfiH ffi^,
qfr.,tkfffi,1H rtntfr,
frtrEfr.lI-=-$ItAHftMEFlJ z WtltfHrgrt' 4X{+ryffl -frE,Bffi t EFAISWTfr.H,!,E f.T' t, FJTE ffi\fr.HE - f* *
;{-ffiFtt{rT ' E+{eF!F"1ffi , #th.tH -#;.fttrelfr.ffl}E ffifrixf.lffi#tr!
Hf& o
(I ) frE.ffif+" EEEHffiF,.]FftH#TF
')IEg;frH+,1.ff.J
E ffi ff! E + ffi fi'.lg fr,tr"1ffi , 4 frth.ffitr'lF-Iql
F=ft
"-m*
24 lE t ' H 5 . 26 Theodor W Adorno, Negative Dialectics. (6ftHffii*) (Continuum International Publishing
25 Stanley J Grenz& RogerE. Olson'(-+EftElS€?+ffi) ' Httz ' 4[4ffi (Heinrich Group, 1983) "substantive thought - a thought of whose movement the thinker becomes aware
ott) fft-6' E1E,RffitrltFfiilT'#iftHffi €' EE.R€ *ls(n' frsft6ftWfr1 " only as [one] performs it". Elxix .
#- H
JF##h,frt] H g #h,FfrFE
ftEffi
ffi -frfr . + FfrHEEHffi g{H ffi ffi ry Ff,fEffi
tr,8
€'fHY& FlR f ;if *+H e e& i+ + 4"+*)#4f+ F\
tr 4' 6t rqfE6t;s ?d\,4E-,K.'
R#.IRTEffiH'{tffi€ jFRW.VleE#., lffi - H, )Fffiffiill+trW.Ffi
FEfrsffi
l

ffl ' {t tr iqH Wffi€ Hm


ft Kt1grffiftH> trlH.{FH+ ffifSffi ' lE[+ ' iflESFlnfrnT6EEffi (Edmund Gustav
f#' H# ftW.gtr E fr'lnfrft'' mE$$ftu
ffi tfrtre.ffi?trltr Albrecht Husserl'1859-1938) f[,FT . lFfHffiffi (Martin
32.
T -tfrH -#+Fry (a theology of consciousness
) ffi4 * ' ttrR Heidegger' 1889-1976) Ifrfrg# ft,ft?ffitr,ffi, f:'ffifi.n
w.th.HlF,w f,!,fHffi,+ ildffi I fF#'l+H!ftg{lH- corcurvum in ;#;frF'!t+- &r HH-rfl;dffifFil ,ft?A+€{*-fEIfr.A
se-y'.,L.ffiFJ AH 'ffiTf'Jt' ffiffia\ffiffi' &THfrffi f.lfdg,[+flE E,l4T tr]{fr
rEg' it fEfr tr E il1ft,wEry
llfHEF+ffrfiy. o 27Iefri:shtfr l-H-#) ' frFtE^AE f[trEf.]4frHffi . EqXy*f],8,f,5f1 ffi^H (theactivity
of
LE,(as itselfinherently
moral) " Elffi-ifl-#;.ff IFffiffinffilRgh thinking)flg{ftiffi W^ H W,E,ffi t& ( something
transcendent,
)1 , lfr./.ffieft* HM* ' E+f'+F ; /.ffi
Hh?net.ffiA einTranzendentes
) ' 4 HH;frr&f[ ,B#ft+ frghlfl ' it E TI*
ffi^ltfilH{ttrE{t AffifHE,ET-tF.n ffi,Afll
' EImru'ff5 EH' Ff,)tEEERffiffi-",H.tfrHffil-......21frWG8 r (beine
,,\.fFF,L.'EH^ff lf'lfffi l-ftl o 28Effi4rH EHEH between)HffiEffiMH'lFIE t#zE_t " 33
ffir'J/. ffi rflH E6fS{E{F{e€ +n- {EFEffiJfi.fttrnA iHt& ' n*, |.erezo+, EHE-Hffi ffiffi H-iHEt+ (Roland
lElE+HH y.IU,frffi fl te tfr^qfr,#is Ifra H ffi e f ffi ill fr it, Barthes, rgrs-1980) ff.J( q[ ffi r4RW.ffiFn> (Jesushas
- ;fr 2e . Ettr , IfrfrgtHryHl'.ffiJ4iF*frnz^+'laJr+{ttrlTE nothing
in common withreligion) toU&_E++ffi- frnF,.1 (ffi
A{RXE mf'jt. ffi ffir<7frfrt.B"lf FE- trffi | Wt<fr!frft ,Fgtr+# ), ifi,+fr.#
+ Fn+Fh.fr1
Hftrt ffi2Eifi ,,t{ru-iK
A,,X,rHE+.fbEHEffi-id'i*i-ff " I tofrlft'H'X'F+n ffiE RW.W#n D)l(h., l=o{[]f[
ffiW.Ef'JU tr]' t-tffi F,!
+-{Effi,AHEfr.hERtffifir E{ElFeffiH ' EFfE H Hr Y{Uf! r/.Fl?ffi.r , rRW._t3' f'JftEffimE
D9EIEEEHffiE +ffi ffi-iH+FeH!tr E ; ifi.ELAE IHItffi 36 .
Eft,EfrfHy{H,l '+sffiF.fiFnrkdlEIE+ffiyiEf+
+ , EEEHffi{RiFM.tfr,t4lfrf'1fi'R* ' '{reffiEffifEtF'!F"lffi TA fI ffiEH' EEEHffi E *fr4HiE ffi€ FFffi qfrI.r.Y{ffi 1+
F"lEfl f+trWE;fi' Effi EIffift'tfr'FEf'JTLWW
{fi ' Eliffi#tJffi EEFtrIEH. ruRTffiEffiruHffi. EM {AtrWHE.,
ryf[ffi -;H+FH ffifblfrA (otherness
) ffiffiE!.ffifl lElE "' s f [ € t J E # , Hs M ' /.xF H Er Effi L ffi?qy]ftE-
F F "fi
ry nFEf'l n?ft.frR f6ffitr
'feE ft,4F T ffiI+ffi1d1.4 ffi {Hf4E ffi 7 ++i6ffi6 (Ernstrroeltsch)
frl | ft,Xflffi. t
H A (pretensionr)
Hfr++fftrE lfu#EffiIE,['tH,.] TffiiE
s2 lFtgf6ffiffi(68fr8+Ffr) #*ftrczrF' EEEHffiEUftFItS+ffit, ffiffi#IffiffiX
H ( transgression ffi IF *W4 HH
) tr E Ifi,Affi n- FF' {F Ifr-#J T1HIF.
33 Bonhoeffer.<:IlgJ^ffiftH> , F1O . Bonhoeffer'sdialecticalclaim that " 'beins between'rhar
whichis transcendent is 'Dasein'g" .
27 Bonhoeffer.
KftglfrftH> 'H.7 ' 34 Karl Barth. Das Wort Gottesund die Theologie (tffiZEtrAFg) (Munich, I9Z4) ,H
28 lEl_L ' H 8 " sa " $sdl fiJohn w.de Gruchy.Bonhoefferfor a New Day: Theologyin a Timeof rransition (ffi
z s lEJ t . ' F z . lffiE+il1HEEFffi ' ffiHfl+{t+ffiffie)
: Paperspresentedat the SeventhInternational
BonhoefferCongress, CapeTown,ed. (Wm.B. Eerdmans PublishingCompany,1997) ' H61 .
30 lElt ' H 3 1 "
3t Charles Marsh. "Hans-Richard Reuter ffi{fE|" Reclaiming Dietrich Bonhoeffer: The Promise oJ
3s Karr Barth, <<LftZ=ffiffi$) ' EHfr , EIz2s "
Hisrheolosy.(€+iEffiEft' EH€Hffi ' {tfi':ffi€ft'l8#) ' F162-83' 36 F J L, H 2r z "
,RW.IRWFH,tM+ (ffi_F . tFRw.fr1*Eff
1FRW.VTEtrffi., rfiFErteiffi
)

a Priori)' m i;frffi-ififfil-7\' 8Hftfiffi,L'ffiH


(Retigious tFJ ftrY{H g I H {ir 18ffi FE+E# fF 4,['4E lE,tr]ffi {f +fi
-#,Ffrtr +t+H € ff'J"' " I E fEft,XRW.fFAt&Ef'ItFg H ryX,E,ffiEfnft#illHR Zffi , lEF+& nTDIHTEI.e (tai+ g
fi ffifr?.fr1' frill/.fFH'+ H -{HfHE' + t+ffizrtrlffiq ffi ) +' ff E++Wt\ffi|Ftr +jt;+F!- t:'vffiln' mff flEE
frdfi,!fi# " +frHifrifr. , W7rlI,rEFl,ffiRW.; flJH*' E E'Hm , Eg;ffiFftffiEF'l ' trgEtffifflE *FnffilAIF
F"]AHHH F[E f; #9." IEE{8ffiRfiftttr-ffif,H(Immanuel H I H Ifi r ET lEfflH+{t r){It M{# fr'.1
F fr ffi IE, +kfftril.
Kant)fifif+ffiffi+#StjI$ftf#B'! " ffitHH#tffi4ry'.fFIE [H/.E r,Jfi.]t ffi+ +n#lIqfr,
+ wft E fi[.l-']',ttr. a H w +.# ffi
ffigpFfll*Hftsffi ffiR' ffift8illwI#,frnrffi' H Hfn fffi" EIEffEHEHffi+EtrH! l-ffififr^1
(prome)-1n^lEg
Tt?, F.frtrf$/.ffi-rK-#fF fr TE )SftjB"lEE" HE EH tr - IflWil1ffitfr.++.Wffi fr ^EE'l+€i* ' ff ftH,ffi | )F
4.'['4
FF+tFU ffi IfrfEEffiffi I+ IE,W ryA#ET+16ffi 6 EE ff ftWR RW.f! E E W.r E -#,i* trl ntr iE# H tr+* fHEf,fr,.1 H
w.*.ft'.1-{E ffiFi+ffitr . iFffifitrtr F!FtEE EFn3ft ff'J' /. t
Ht " *Et.lfr{iFfrTtrlWfr., iFRW.Wffif+ F"Tffi
ff ftHE
xFFfHH Wft,ffiffiW.#ffim=&,ft.E , q[ g
E ffiE tr']t ffi ,
EHffimE€ ffiFnrfiE4[ffiEg F_ft8l.]JttuffiEff 4t3ffi
fr.JffiJ\' " fr tft-ffi trItrER HHH+EHEHffi n'lEf,fl {H Eg F'.1{=f[ " E F"lffi
ffiW+H H TE qFffi Eg' mEtffi
fr t. ffi 2f"1F"lffi iffit1HE E E t ffi ffi H+nB 4\ /F.-rt'EEtr'lilEl ,2E (word ofGod). H lfr,' Ifr,tre.FnHWffiW.ffinAH'+A
H, XlFfi'E,ffi4tr#{H H+FryH++€frtr']Bf,fi! | tffi2 WrnTff,ffi " )F?ffi.tr!ffiffiffiffiH+*frgiffi l#lfi,f,.llF
ryM.
E I E fF ' Elm ' fr+ffi X FA' EEEHffi Ef,ft*tr lfit& ,1.fr E ffi - (fufr,.]
E g.# " )FffiW.il1ffitrY-E.EHEHffi u
" tgffi)F=kHtr' mFf,EEg-#B'l ffiffio ) 3e
' Ey{E-r"1ffiff!TWW{?.
^HH'ltr,E,
ffi=Hfr. Hg;frffiPfiffi I-.) HgffiFf,ffiffiH*
fitrff, EEEHffi,E,tFg E++,8'*EWgi+E ' {E&rc- E g ;frrfiFE4 H tr W.€WffiXS f5 H'+ Dl+-kilillfr
Eg ffirfiFEtrl,B+ +' EIr)lhwfi ie q E ffiE{f
lfi.Fffift elEffiE ffiETtr {t illtil{fr." EHEHffiFnf€fr trt#.g;frrfi
ffi.ffi#BBtJtt/.ffi' /\f6Et!,L.4ffi4fr.trlxF . #/.ffi ft.trtkffiH+ , lre.'ilf.il1&w
FUtrF(ff€f,f'/.ff EqEE4.H " ffiHlnffilnf&6'.lEEU , trr4F#ttJ.;ffi"Z*if-€.
( r'Er F rFr ffi+Seflt.ftf4€e#E)
' qliZtrTEAHZEil;m*,ffiE
wffihFfttr (ffiF,t4. Rffi,t4. Etr,t4) fi!6* . g{n4FIffiHwHztrffiffitrHl+
E +fr.*H+.il1ffi4 A E tr!fHE H E " Ifrt&2ft.t7 +.fr T frffi mE A q zffi ffi
ry.E==il1EE 4 fr LEFft" ( 4 + # Wyt lfi& Wft.#, {t t8ffiEt ^'tfr.H'
H T itl {t f,!1 ffi#, r)l
=ia
E - #r\ fr Gffi fr 4 ffi f ffi ffiffiX f! aeffiffi f r 4 ffiffi ffi - n E E(' ffi ts ff F tf H
*[ftFf[-rJJI] rftt H8 .tt rWt f9ffJEfiJ " fbf ' €SrfEf#*.f#{f. ^
ffi : r {f f6E fF4 T lEtrl1i ffi frlE ffi fr!fr ElfF E 4 f! F Effi.-, E 4.H fEft b- tI fF
4 ffifrffi E E{ <++n\ frtfE ffi fr E\il HfrI, il-l*ft H,ffifl . rf & F A E g ffi .
37 JohnW. de Gruchy,Relrgiousless TegelTheology,<lFRWH'J8trffi'-
Christianity:Bonhoefier's €FlEff.ls+EErJ) ({frq+) (382_383/383), ^8 {r$dl H9FISHE, ^Kt?.*.rymB
EEEHffiffiffifEffiry) , E I H Bonhoefferfor a New Dav: Theologvin a Time of Transition ((ffi HtgTHl\Wfitr? z ) (Xi+ffgf+€, zoonFosffi)"
: Paperspresentedat the SeventhInternational Gerhard Ebeling. Word and Faith, (EF{E)
7+fiA+tr1ffippffi ' #t$ffi'{t+ffiffiF) ' Translated by James W. Leirch from the German
BonhoefferCongress, CapeTown,ed' ( Wm.B.Eerdmans PublishingCompany,tgSl ) 'H,62 " Wort und Glaube ( Fortress Press, 1963 ) ' FtOz
.
ffiw.tilT.gffiH{tffiry
lF?#.trr*tr#. , (ffi=H . jF?W.ffietr#.rfiFEftsrF
)

ffifftHx' itrEE ffiw.Le=af; ' m tr-ryE-ffiH-#*fr /.fl##ffi , zntrw. * ilTwE. f4g


f+e ftllF[ffitrlMm . 4 fr Et+B+
-'t/txFrs,l'4 *ltrlr*E+ + A rI-tR
#.' IEE Eg ;frTfiFE#RXEf5+ Ffrfr IEF!FS+FFfiXE^*fr
&+F.HH+tr +Fryn - {E{tF 4 ifi D}B-f't€ Hif; + Ffifr IEff'l tF tr liEfg,+F 1,ffiFa-trl
7 ++A ' 4E E {E ++A rc
rfiFE" lft,|, EHE.H F,tr.f#Ifi'{J,
ffi VAfbEE ffiffi:fi tr.]€tJ WAH Htrfr+J+HH+ fiF'XftT fr ft] . EIMA{r5EfrgE
ffi l-Eg-'affiFnffif"l
'Ef:-E{0trll'+- (sein)' mTE'run'l fHT ffi rm'fEIrffiffi' E{8ff,ffiffiiHE;4ftf!, E{Etr
11 (run) . +H*tfr,#ru' FtE ' EE-#f'lEffi ' T\fr.ft' F E fg^E. H 7 Mfr.AE Wi*Frif[ffi a,l4 . H
^ilT-tfr^
A fruE TlJilSIb + H-L'E H tr fE NE'W A H FNHH ffiFfiffi
Hilt ' Efxtrlq[ffi49HfunfiftEffifff ' I 'oEffiE
4t-afi E + &4 # ft fltqFffi mdl# {l*frr"1 ffiH+' /t{H{E?frM+= RE fEnE,l+fr 8 I*.
IfrTffi +EH F'.1r 3EFfiffi I
.
%H ff iI fL ' H A {ru^ f.Jfi fi,IE # tr fHE F!F+{F , HE
E g r lrnE {E+ g ffi ffi + * yfr )F'fH'fg E ftfix+B"lryfr'iil't
ffi ' ME EE +]JftTIFJ ffiffi.Ttr{E{EAfrEfU Xffi,AH+ 6+*firuie{8ffi ru'l'4f!ff -)L#' it H (fr,f+ffi# ( mtFffifiF
'f . EH F ( + EE-
# ) / . f H* f f iE f f i ftH H € tr ffi P"l ffi
FNIFtrffiff AHHHtrIETS. "
fEdFlr,
l-g-ift+fr,,
Iilffif+ilfil ' frffi+1,' Iirtr']ffiiffi'{EI'
. E{Eu [aft,1 w rr=8F"l l-3trI ilI ftIffi il! ffit,fr.ffi
ffi E " +fr,'+I
t+,8#fiWtr9ffi
IB#, , ?itrfr.r=ff
ffit*.fnffiFaf.J
Hffi' EImrl?x'l+ffi ,E,X,r1ffi1fr r#t 'ffmeFffii*
ffi I (diewer-Frase) ' E-EfEy'.+-EllHffilR+XRW.Ff,ffiZ
t*6f;o """EE/.f'J{e/.ZBffi-ifiFfi " ffiiftEf"lffif[H# ffr o """ R €' ?,8.-#JF"1
E f#-ilf, # A +kffizrtr ryiHT A #
&ffiflr+fF ,IHZEH'r&+Etrffift ^ " ff
r-i€r ffiffiffi
FfiFEFnH Fl,7H{fiF"lffi (diePersonfrase) ' EFnE;ft , ,,1
r-3EI f.l;fiF"1' #[Uffi E f! EXm Hfr +E" 't4
f f ii* E EE 6 n r ' ffF fi ffi"I H |.rcT fr? ffiAffiH' Hftffi
o'
WffiAHffi\ffiW'ifit1frHH +FRIEAH " -r Effiffihtrft',,\. ElE H;q*t& H + 4{4' fftm
tfr.ill
HHEHffi E ffi ft + ffi il A ft'IE € ff q ff U ffi & ff igf#7 rF.AE{Ef# +trJfrtFD}h.AE{Etrf1tiEff ffit+
( OFfEEg ) fHEH+' FfiE+-F"lff)\EEfr\HE f"lffi i*; IruEglFffig{U##tr(Logos) HrJEffiE tffi++.
o'
EEIE - F.+e*r.EEg;HIfl,r +ffiffiEfrF 2t
(Existenzfrase) ; D)k*HlBtrr=ft F"lffilBft'ftiie*k;frF"lffi
f.JT ffi 2E H'!= #.Hfi+E.
.
ftlrfiffi ' #/t fffifr{t'Ef,JErtfHE afHEFttEfE ^H +,
E ffi IHfrE X +ftT'T
I Fl';tE3ff z I g{EF"1FE' n€EffiHtli# " I ou ElmE
{EFfiffi E -ffi ff ;f;rt f'l{t E - /. ffi F tr A H ffii# tr]-
43 l E l t'Fe .

,FiffiHzz " 44 l E l t 'F13.


40 EEEHffi, (ffi-trH'4ffi-fr.H>
,18,20' 26
4s l E l -L'H 16 .
41 q RA L 'F 1 l ' ).2 , 1 3' 77 ' 31 ' 45 ' aa' zt lfr "
46 l E l t' F18 .
42 l E Jt ' F 1 2 .
#W.IRffiffiH,{tffiE (ffi-H - lFRW.ffiF-tr#F"iFEftsrffi
)FRW.trJ#EW., )

f6f't;fftf ' AIH Et-aEff | frf.{&t t!IEJH+ ' Eg In /r &+ F ' llt'
mK WTffi" FnD )+E- H e. zl (,]E trtE
IFffiEff FIffizt (DerMensch Gewordene)' +
mX \fi.frI fI E trt E EE EHffitrV
)FRW.il7Eg
ffi.ffiffi
fr!-{EfFA
ffi ' D}-ffr r H{fr.nt ffifr fiAE
+N , th.y'{F.ffift]t. Hf f E "
-'aE
ffi r IEfr t' E m ff.:.d.trlff;frffif# f! Ht+EEf'JEg fr! | . +trtrlHEf-Hft bro ne)#
,f=' 11€',S# E Mtt 4 HE t+fI tr E il1Erfi ' E {EF+lFt
Fffi7-"#-# r?EFfiffirilll€I+'
o' HEEHffi+EH ffiff +fr.,[$fftrEffi ' lfrffi T w H (frtrl
THffi" 'O
n fi ' E g -#rfiffitr ft,ft +e*k-#r"1ffiH H r E FJ
r 3EF"lffi fiirt,Hf,'W*t-#Xfrf!EEg flS
I B'l_.{E+ffi IE+tr.T+trI+Efr A H @A fFH H TNffi ft,WT4-rE ? EH
r ' SFltrl#g;fi*trflEt'ffiA HfflffiIEtrtt' TE tr HffiEffi fr.#+fr.,I4*iHiFE{Eil rfiffi '
rE f'Jt Sr 'm E rS W l S rtrl ffi fg-tr { E r f f i | +8,14FfE IEJ H+lEtfr,,fr,FFH' ffiE tE " ......8 E
It #H ' tfr.EHEHffim'L'ffif"lffi ' Eltr.' Ifr++FlJ+E Hq[ffiEgE /., {t,t HE r+HfflrtP.fi w+tr w . E El
H E {Ef"lffiE-€ tr'lE -iflffi -ifrt. frlEE
ffi ' rm/FrnH + tr'lffi ffiqFffiEgEtffi , IfrtffiH 'lE" r sI
m ' EfrletF€fiitffit. frl;={r=fi " " ^{8ff.J+|.
iHH fl E f! E fb Wi+.'ttr WRffiffifr!ghh;.ftfr EW E
[:) +trfr#trffJHg tr tr',4tr'tj )\ffitk* ffiX fll ffiffi " H H ffi fi'.]ffi# F.fi
FJtE
E{EFfEqFffiXEEgffiA " AA HHHffiE+4,[4ft]T
frnR| )FffiW.trt&trffi.t ffiffitrlAH, ' fr+g-#trl
ffiFl^{E'['SFtEEffir{E/.f'lI HIir Xffii*fl.J' EfEil
ffiffi , ffisM'4gfl | 1E'lIt f[ | Eft'Wt flsfr.l/.T
zFn DITE + g E F,l{E/t tr fblfr,TE[Hffi,E€ {E/. 4
tr1'ril\tffi{+" Elffi#gF'l | iE'Wt fr.EEEHffif'lEg
^H, UTE[€ffiAr+ +H+' mE[Hffi,tr | #Hft1trttft t
ffiPH rutg ffift H lfrfi'ltr# 4e, m|.rH+ 4 2+ ' fr'E
^ ",E{Eil r#Hil1trtf,.tFtEtr#H+f.]fft+"
'fTZ#ff " mHmA , #{H{H#E t+fr.l frl#g ' Ftl)F
RW.trJ#trW.ffitr+{Ftrft )\ffitE,Atr'lffiE ' W.kT (g fHff ,&' # g -ifftrlFf,ffi H rttIFXfr T Etr lFffit.
ftS)'fFffit ffi2E fl H tit'Y+ -F[#3{nEfi A H' +#9 ffiH'l
W4\' {FEftrHffif'l#Htrtfu?+ffiffiIE' it-ELEH
ffiDlk'{F.ifrtr!E g il1H fuZWrl E lE.lE#E I E & s €-{E/.ffi tEtrlH{U . f{ rfr,HInffiE- )t hffi , IF.fr
ffiEg ' FU )FRW.ilTEg #ffif+iFffildffi*-f;Er# ' pFD -fE rmftft#{ffi s3-tffi
Zffi (ActioDei) ffitffi ZE
7 TH_ (Praesentia
Dei) , f ff {fi frjtr X (DasDir-Dasei") ffi f }il
4g lFffiqFffi tr!ffiFffi Wt HHXt.TJ ' EiF,fffiE
5u o
l tr JI ' Fl ;z5
47 E -L 'F 1 8 " 51 o
l q JI ' Fi z6
48 I EJI'F 2 1 " s2 l E l I' H 28 "
4e l El t ' F 2 5 . s3 l E Jt 'H 3o .
RW.IRffiFH,{tISF )FRW.ftlEEffi.' lffi=H , )F?W.f,.1#g#{r"1FEftsffi
)

. I'
t (DasDir-Dasein)'m # rK'fLft.HH
ItfffijZE Ef6ffi Eg{ Fffi l - ffi +i t H '.1
tH l fr .t S{{E/.ffi ^4{'4f" 7
tr-{Elmffi tr (Dasein) HIIW
trlEtfu' ffiffi#tr-ffiW ffifr'.]
W'&.'TEffi H f! tr I+mtffiu illrfa I+.,mE
LffiF!H HHE,tr#H +fr,ItrF{ftHil11frE..++
f+ ' f;HTF.7 ^
EH1E,rrl-fr4{4t IFffitriEF!tglE'lLt 'f[ ttffr.
. EiFE EEEHffiWi*.HInft,M{4F!EE$"
(Kotingenz) {4J IFffitrHF'!r frEIL.t . ElJtr' EgB,!ffiff{'gE{E
+tr tr'lEgEffi | ffi+kft#{trr
ft!Ht-u)LftlFffiW- LHE WeEre{#,|.+E#, | )F?ffir,lEtrffi.ffitr# t 2
E.
E F'IOEFEffiftjtriEm ft,Mil7l-/.{tt H +' E fr.^
-D;ffil .
Y.ffiEHffitr'E
,1.' ffig=FUE^H+ Zffiffi , |nY{HEH"];ffis+ ' EEE
IFffiEirtzA , HH trIEF,.:ffiH ' E 55 2.Etr.ffJ#g
Hffi..{JffiEg
f6trTEZ<E HftAHE.F,.1. fl(f tr.]IEft 2E' M frEtr.f$ EE.F,!EgF fuqi*fi.] FfiFE' - fi A #ffi-HffFNE,
fHEf.lffiA ZF"f ifi8", tfr,tffiA t EEHEHffi:aiEE E Etrr'JH H t #+f Hil1ft&F"tr tr H!tr,B, E *fr+ *+ft.
{E/.WIFffi/.ff'lEgB! | HIfir 2F"1tr!fHE ' mEHH"l N ++.fll fflE g ;ffiDtE-re-#{'4
fi tr fr.,1'4 H g ffi F!F Hfi,
F'.1
I H [ii {FEt ffi2e " | AFRW.tr1#g #.ffiffit FnW t).dfi-a,flEgIFffiFFF W&lffiFE .
' UEE DlEgfl I HIil ffi+,1'trltffi2
ffii*..trlF"lFE
+ E ffi ' mE{ERfrH$'l'J'H fir,flt{'4
4 6 tr {'4fr!E €tffi '
e, DlltMF tt tr Hf,HF!'['HtH
FFfrEEtrFn&W,fntr ' E&tf Eifr., &EgE rffi+t +ft.+U{$ ff!E g -#f€A tr{4 ff.J ffiH.;ffi' E ffiEg -iffi
EU
friEr f!HtfET' H{Eil /.E5UroE ++f!F"lffi ffiif ffir* E r y F F ,* F . f r-FTffi fT F - trTHtM EziftF + # .i l"'l ' fE
H+' FitEEg twE+nHfttrtBfrx,ffi#,ft+kvlR|='ts6 ff r'.1' B=#,['4f!Eg;fiFtEz.WtfrfiKtr RH F,.]Hg;ff,
{F -Eg tfifr.+kH',
fr'.1H+ tfi ' e[ff i* ffif frl{fiE " IEIHv*t T ffir&EE [Ftr.J. 6 E{4 ft.]H g;ffi se,
ttrtt-",P,fr.t1
EFtiH # # W 7 D IrS H , fi l E fi I reH F n E F ' ! 4 E f # E g ; f r H HIF # H T EEEfr \+ .fr "M) JEE EH ffi H 4
+EffiEgffi F'lffif+Frt' {FEE E E*ft#ff Eg ;fiflffi
+fr,,+fr- I#ft ^mi* ffifteF'!tF[Er] ffim T " E {#F fftFtlffi
27fr, Wrfi.H+kR*fi+kZffi " fi ft HE'f#tTf;R s ' +EAEA {11tr.*frg1ffiTH.TE TfiEIE,f[FHffiEg IAMI+
E +krE+k
HtrIHE€frTilff.JFfiffi .
fHE fflH+ IR, "rfrP.#tl7 E'.+I'"' "' 4g B[Efi H E f'].F
F' IFJH+ XEfi f f '{FI+t1 +,1" i&E ftF fi 2lfH"l+ FAf*Y! r^1 fffi ( H H iftlF€ ) trnFft Wtr ifr(R
trt-ffi^E
,L., E +kffirffi zlflft.JF,L." " fffitrl;t';ftH+tr r ffi-/. t Vrf,l{$+ l-y'.t 91fiE ' EEf}

s4 lElt' E3r , FyFfitrE€ffi.ffilF'fFftltl" s8 lEIt ' H6o"


ss Flt ' H34. 5e tnt?Hn zffi& <ffi-#Hfr H - ffiH ) ft + ;+4 € F + Ff+EF|Jfrt,6 ft i4filEg
o
5C, ltrl't ' Jtr45 r/l o.* ;#f.tFrR F {t *' mreaq{4ffiE s ;6anE H ffi s * {H/t ffi sr . I HH.
57 l El t ' H4 s " * ;,
RW.IRTE9qH,ftffiE . Iffi- H . )FRW.tr.]EHff
)FRffiTlEtrW. r,NHE,tEiH
)

4g-{'4;ffifrHffiffifrjiffiEtffi ( f ffiWH' ffi{Hifr' * EgffiF"lFE' Elft"FnifiF$ffiiIn-{EEEt64' EE-


H ;ff#' F-€, ) Flit'-ifiR +A r ffi - /.r EE{fi
fr?=afrA + {E;{;frtr1FSffiF*fi-Y{ | W,rtI FfiFEF!ftIE .
riF t f f . J F H '
E lEY{+}t+II+.8g ;ffiF,.l= fEtr HtF,.:
+efr ' Hxffi I\ z
ffi -fE ^Etffi , D]-f6 iHf' +H ffi tEA fr - fE F'.lEffifE* Ert H!' lEft,f'Jfr fr'.J
FH ,
fr ?V,['4 E ##Effifr]T
++FUffi S{H;ff,8 ffi ffi#m ' HfrZ ^v?t frlre.frfiffi,8' fF ifit4. H AHffJfElsF ,ffiWfigETntrffiru , t*n{dF{ErtrH
f t f i' . ] t r t f f, i' r k # F tJE tffi q rf+7 l -4 { 4 I ' AFffi 6s
fitr ffi++fr.frtrffiMT -H tr T Hg-# + fr,!#E ++.W
_- 60
ffi 7 {e H'.1| # t tr! fE tr H H"llF'['4f[ tr',{t t1 trt o
^ V l y'. l-ffififif;ttr
t il'14trI'Sft.JEEm
"
EEE Hffi FnW4lWfr!' E Tnffiffi,Eftr ( schleiermacher, tg-iI{'4BgHHffi'
1168-1834 ) Fn++fr',.]ffi Hfi' E tfrft.ff {t 1,8ffiHfr EFtrl t,El
vl+++ffi t. ffi;ff,Effi t ffiE m ft tr'l r ,Eii+'['4 ff!fE fr-ffifiAI E - *ls(nF!;{ ;fr,SM# +tt'+\,['4
F!H g ffi Eflf#H zrF"T
( Geschichtsbegriff ) " tTE fft FHm,EfifrF"lffi Hfifr,"Ffr. fr !^7*Rt EEF'IFSHE.+ ' F[Eflf]c= (:uffi,fr
rW4# t XE I f+ffi
Et uuil1rEffFlffi)'.8-t 67
;ffn"lreIF' l.ef#EfEffiHfi-'nKffi/.{ru ftft'H7 -fEt+EB"l "
ffiw.]Ea, ffi,th.tH+EfEIEaFRSjfuq[ ffiHt " t ffi Fl, r E ff Ftffi)\A I 4 H F[t ffi E Eq[ fifiH g E frS
^E
u'ffi
f f i/ . ' 1 1 E/ . { f fi f# ffi E FAt H e n " l E+F " ] p .mE' H T /. F'.1
FfrH{E frH'['4f! Htr l+.D]h.)\F'! H H fr rt . + H
TE*TffiH!ffiHfiFIJH A7 qFffi^H FTE&T6iH,fEil1#ffi . l- Eff Ftffi H r i * f'/.qtffi i l l | l ffi Afi t' EE
t f f i F r , f f i ^ , E H ffi i rrr+F e +fi ffi T -fE /.ffiF"l t,) L%, ^Ar ,
EHEHffi-tr FfiVfli+f'!rtrzrt Ffiffi' trltt +ft,111-l"^-#il1
{4r ' + Et f f i F nffi y'.ffi ffi -fEl -F F tJI' mE' lA' [' AE J1HE E qFffi E g iE= y',,
{tr- IF-ft.aE t ffi ff.J
t)FRW.fr\#9W.fr4fr#t #HFn*trYf ff! ' Eittkffiffi
H, frTF.tr il1" {rR q[ffi4g
trfEFf;Htffi F,.14
(, ; + # f f i ) + EE fl f{ tR W.r f}L +\H ;6 s 62" m - tfi
ffir ffitr!;f;, ffisM
rc.H+fr.+ffitr FfT re.e*;tr
ffiffrFn;H
fi!r
trfffi9\ffi - f6^Efift trlBEtrfiAY,tr )\H t' ' {E&AQg-ili# f
F!E E\tr ft | ili a E#tlr /. F'.1q ffift,#{4' m I{AFIIild
{UEH+#y'.+tr!y.qt2L , ,j4'r7--,^1fr,f'.1K
u' + +,8{H.
* /. WE [F{'4-L . ffi =fE ^Erffiffi;t';fr#iD flJtY&ffi -=#.lfrfrr
rEE+ +N " {[R fnirufs#F.{ff ffitr!iF,['4,+tirl
Hfi' {EE H + ffi E F fi,.]-Hfi E f H4I=O{TF E Tffi fi!EI-H{'S
{4{A,r,tE=-,ft.;fr
{ewfukdn" 68
\ffiwftE*' mTE E ++4srtr!FHffi{'4EffiWftE* " g{E
60 l d t ' F 6 2 . 64 l E It ' F8s .

6r l E t ' F 6 7 " 65 l E t ' H e2 .

62 4 F . K n . l . F E f f i ) ' E n u "' F 1 3 1 ' ffi ft ltr -aR "#,# Wffi


# flft&.fl"fr L ry Wfr H.X-aR oo l tr l I ' Fl v6
o

fiM. 67 l E t ' Fgs "


63 E E € F f f i , < ( H - # . H WH- ffiH' ) . l t r l - f . J : l i r o od lu f
.
J=l y5 o

24
ffiw.rRwffiH'{tffie )F?#.ffiagffi.' lffi_H , )FfrW.t1etrW.r"1FErtEiH
)

E {HE ffi.th.w#',+I + iltft E /. ffit ffi+ H E ftsE tr ftF=-J


;fr+' EEEHffi WT E H {SffiH # t trl
tr,r\Flt.ffi ' E IHffizrEffi EEfl' Ff,EqFffi+g" m,rt HHffifrs+fri*t{- ' E)g H7 th.^ffifftFHE-#f+ry
[frtr#WE.F + I,fr.| # H illtr',Hft t [€ffi7 E{EH HE tr (Existentiate
Hermeneutik)" fltrffi ' EEf[HEEHffilh.
tr1ffiZi' EEERffifl-#:dW#ffiF"IEEfB1fi.ffiffi+Sf!'g ffiffiD r-g#9ffi,4V11FRW.ffiEtrffi.WF+r Hf,J#frt1
,:i ' E Dll+Mfrtt# L+*9tr1' E&FiE-trft;t'-#ffi ( ++FlIft)F IA',ftHtrH) ;,K;frE g ffi H fl , &.Wffry.ftSffi
Eg ffi8,.]+,1'Ffiffi - ft+ffiJEtrIg ffi;EH . ffiil1L* # tr ft -#/Fl=',ftfr,H?ffi
HHttuaA ffiE g f! rEfFE
FiEtx , I&F|Tft'+ffiiE fHrytrE" rftil- , ffif# r-F[FI fl ffiit E Eg;fr tr];.J;fr+
" E].E' E',lA{AE-tn$ffi
ffiFnfr" "' "' tril -ffiE g n=ft
Ffiffifl!E fE+' -eH'Ff,ffiH+ EEF"fi73' EF (Fi+#ffi) Fnffif[ffiffif]r-/.4 2E
*tl , ^Ffi€'tr0E.lfllti-
. EIIft , ffi4rft8EfuEiE ffi t f! ffi#,FnEt tr ffiEEEHffi f.J I jFffiW.ilT# g W.illrf
' E€ffi,il,ftftE
mffiM' Eg ffiffift&E+ffi.ffi'ffi,' i*
ffifii#fl
W&flfr.tuqffi trfr E ' F[E{^4rfltrtfr,) 74il....lF.'{FE.4HfrEf.]ffi
ffiiHlJ.
O' # " ,'HA' T,J€IJtr;dHT=HtrIffiffi, EHEHffi++ElJEE
if H H WnFFffiFE{ft' ff H ft H#ff /.ffi g{'Str!tr'ndFfi
FE;H" 'o |. E*lsffiF-{-iftft"1F
r E f'Jtr E fr"]IAMtH"J Honesty)'u " E = frffifiFq)FRffi.il1BtrW.
tE (Intelrectual
tA, EHEHffi tr E, IATTIWfrEitrFJIEgE 4H, MgE figffiF+trF]J, IeffiiffifrEE,['4
,Bffi FfiEH 6'.1g rfiffi f[ /. H!
EEEHtrt E-IfAffiftJA,fH H t. . EHEHffiFMffi ' gE H+4,J'4Ffiffi#flfHBf, "
ftl=^{ttj+ F'.1E D}H.
Wtfr,l:ufr.- Zf'J ' E tnXFRW.tr'l Eg
+,1.8-r9fr1 "
ffi.frqffiFnaffin'! I*) HHfrHtr
H g #kffiffiF!+njt H #t
m = f,tr. iFR#kfr+J lFE+rfit fl FF€ . ....../. {rufr,7#4r)I.
Tfrffiffi -#fFH
frt1ffi zffiffiTffi n'.1
frtr' EAfE^t Efg#fl' EIffi
fififf ' aEisffi F il-#F! (€|JtrFEH) fr!ffi-#r+ H HTEIEffi.,Tff ' Ffft*,H Hffiilft'!fl H H' FfET
f f i (r g s2 +iI1 e33+& ) ft (E gffi ) ( t g s e F s , E H H ' THE^tr8!ffiffi " Etf flFW7ffifrffiB!trmrg
3 Et) Ztri , IEE,Bf5WRte[E,fEfqrHE*ffffiry,8 ffi
ffi-{Effi-#rn 7I '&EAffiEtrEg-#;-f -#+ l-_L.ffi 72 Heinrich Ott. Existenziale Interpretation und anonyme Christlichkeit , ffiff Existentiale

Ftffi/. tr ffi-^BtliE €'Bfi' mW4F[ F E E Lh.ill€[ E E' Hermeneutik, , 1969, ffidlH (H-trHfrH-#H')
Benziser +;+4HE r frx1ix .
ffi E H ffi ' (H -#H Fffi -H H l . ' E [4s .
EE r i._-W4 trlHEF tttrlRffiF.*f;ft
' aA
E E E H ffi ' (ffi +€ffi) ' prz a "
75 t {Hf ( GerhardEbering) AEffi HEE Hffi f! ffi A E ffi F pE{Fffi ff g fiSffi,kil1 lF R #ffi
ffi ffi -{E FF\'4R . (FF{ E ) , H t4r-r47 (H ei nri c ott)
h
' D } & .^ffi ff t{ H ft
ffiftffi{Effittf.l+f lH ' F,HeinrichOtt,ReatityandFaith,Thetheologicat tegacyof Dietrich
6e t ' H r o 3 . Bonhoeffer, iEffi&ft . EEEFffifr.:ffi+#E)
<frtrfrtrfF- ' (Fortress Press
To lElt ' F1o4 . Philadelphia)' Fr18-120 .

Tt 4F. <n-nHffiffi-#'H) +#49= ' f,xlvi " 76 Hffi4+: GerhardEberling, (EF{E) ' Ftlo-120.

26
R#.IRWffiH{tffiP JFRW,ffiEE#., Iffi - H - )FRW.H,.]ES#TF{FEftEiH
)

H ERffiffifl II{4fffiit o "' "'T#fxt)t#i*FlJ ' t, l?.H D)&.Hft " ElItrEffi H H fr'lFffilfif+Ebt ffi ft H fl'
t)tfxh.i*
Fu ( wirkgesetz)
eI"HIfi.lIFIRtr " ffiE€UEA fr €tJ H ftft 'fe/.' H fi^mH ffi,Z+ " HtmfEffilfriFfi3Els:il&
#w zFf,#Etr . ElmHHEElEffifrfff . "
ffiz+HtrfltrT Hfllffith- ffi ffi {ft?E' ffith- ffi ffil{R*EnE-ffi6fr?
r-ffiI ftEEEHffiE*E l-4tr{4ff.JffiI (r,ttnit Etrl ft,# (Dasein) E -ffi +E)JffiEgE'l-t#t6f;ft!l[
o ft,ft. (sosein), l-/.4HTEAI\MilT ,\frffiE- zcffif,q
negativum)' fft]# rfitrft{+f']ffi1 @nn privativum) "
r ffiI Ef'JLZIRi.rn'Eff.J (Zweiheit),EE ffiff E -{Eut fl{& Fffft f,q+ ffieE )\
WR' €lJffH ^mftl H trlEf5-l[
tffi r-Effi Ftffi I fllEfE ' E{EilEfsEtffiW4f! H il]tfr.Effi{$(Geschdpflichkeit)
) " " EfE E'l+*F.re.T HH
^A Hte€lJE#,friHft(frill€Uifi tr.K!trtr.]HfrfETf Etr E.H-,*.ill' E{Eilft,!trFiE
ffiTqfr.
Hf,HIE " Elm rt.ffift,+,H 8J
.
AfriH H Et'EtrHtr.] H H' EilE{E ffiIfi.AffiEE{fi
)EWlRffiZft,4.F!
+ ffiHf'iieffiBlJ ElH . t' LffiHltrtrl
fr#F"fiE H H, IfrffiHtrI&EH H, ffiAftlWI+F1ffi7 ffiH 7Effi AfrtH?HE *trHEffiffifi "
/.f.lt.ffit th.AfiWftfr rffi7 rffiff'l/.t 80' ( - - .) AFIffiZH BIF F R

+Hffi z ffi ft+{tEH H ffi . .. . . . . t r f H


fi H
Hf!H1 EffiffiiEAffiiH Htr!frlR ,
f t (g^ Er
fi s)ffi+ifi/F/.ffi TH E mffi H i l TFt r ' m E ^ f f i zfrrfl." 'FFFflTfiffiffi
T IE/.mffiHF'.:HE. ......HHittF/.tr!ffH , fr/?- y''fr'.ltT
PEfxtfr,f!fttr 2+ H' mT ftE Efr*' E )',
tEWffi f'{0H'.1 H t mD/HfEF tt Wgrfr'.1FA )7''AH' F
o .....' ,
( H fr ) E-fEffilfi ffi.)FHIfr. F,.: E {Ef! A H ZffiBF'E Ifr.WW.'II,i
tr f, Fft+* fr!F FR 2
{4 t EE- Az
F"lFt-fEVf,lfr " ElHHffiE tffi7lfrLffiHHr Urei-
, Elm Ifr)\ffififfilfr H Effi# 7frE H . i&,trlJtrEAH2-FpE " EWtrfr*t1FEF'l;K;#+ 'm
sein-fur-den-anderen)
ft3tdH+E +.T nE $J^ffi pR
F ft ffi24H4I4' Eff trf' +
ft " 11€'EEF i e / t f r " l E E l f r \ + f r , tofr" "HHf!
" HHE
H trIF FR + fffr.T H {Eft,fr. . {f ,fEI4FEfuq
tr.]./J.# , 4 F,I
EtrHrnA- EtrW+-A.ElE1fr,),.m4+n,Ht' Frn# -im#,ZfSJ
LZftE f!ffiEl. Aftfx#n-FFf! ttufr- -
ff'JRE . 81
fr,fttr8 +.frZffi , E rftW+.ftflE HE . it'EF[Rffi
A frE EEEH ffi E X i tTE H fx 3,8 f l' m E - lEH+X E ft fflff.iIfr,EZ + Ful.
tfrffitlfrar fr!ElH " E{E tlfrat E+fifrrffi,1&^
77 EEEHffi , <ffi-frHffiffi-frH> ' lEfHfI'Hil8 "
T8 lElt ' Frle "
82 lEJt' F13s
7e l E l t ' H 1 2 3 "
83 E-ffii*A (H+€ffi) +tfitE)E' fi rttfllEll.trH'.1ffi{fi ' TEIE-{EAfiEW
80 l E l I ' F 1 4 6 - 1 4 2 . ,f:ffi tr E EtlE ffi ff f! F H r?tr w ( ilsfrffir! ffi ruffi ffi {HM,h,) ill R wffi .{ft rifE-E
'
8r l E t ' H 1 3 8 . iEE4FtffiZftft. ' F#fE,t.mif;trtffi*.tfrt" 4F.nnEHffi' (ht+Bffi) ' E
E t ' F 1 e 2"

28
RW.THWFH{t+p€ )FRW.illEtrW.,
lffi-H - /F#ffi.trrBtrffr"1EEftsiffi
)

Efr (l-Fi+Hffi)H'+Ef,ftRW.{4fr! )\trFfri?r/. fi! | nfi-{E/. r 88. ffiH WH-{+ tr!tsf,{ft4


Hffi.Effiffi
*.Efr* t trlH+ {Ft ftgfrg t ffif'.];frffifEH fHEE. * HHEHffi fr! (-fifn{r5 wlfrawEE{fi ) ' EH I n-{H/.Erffi
trht+ ff.1,8,ffiE ffitr f*' E H {etr# H +.ftHHffi 7 g fE ffi+kFfr+^ntrffitTFF, +i,FEt?t3Fit ffiT EfrIt W.mz<€
tTPF, EIJIL WffiEt 8e , fr [Ff'.]Hftnf#Bt ,
it,tr F ' ' E fLE F, F.lfr.H
+fr,ftgTE+-if;H"] Efr* , ffii64.if;f'.1+,1. trF,E,4 E ffiT 1fr.€U E W zrfi fr'l- fEVffifrffi
' E {Fh44il1
' T trW. .
4*+ ' m-. nFE+ ' EtmuffiTE trt1+tfU7 nffiW A tr
fr.J
+.frflFlthltrXaf--#tffi ^ffi#Ftrfrvltttr,
frizE/.H^] . Y{+kK#,, i.etrfr* t = ) /IF!trilI
FE" 85
rtr r+fr{frf+fi {ffifi'.]+"#' *ffi tr{E^ ffii*ff.JFfi (€UtrFE E ) ffi= H ffiffi-i#tr--EFIHffi , E,E+*+fr
+.yf;tr!Efr.XT
r tE# tr LID)f E * )S7 ia {E1fi.ffiF{' l-fr/. H!tr -iFI{$' Bf,f] l-# ff.1413
H * iffiI F"lFE# H {A{Ats
,l' H ;{ Ffr, IEH[fft ll\ffi{fr ++7 HtE Fn#,f'.]tFFFlE-l
H+& ,
eE#WftiF 2+ +frHi=f;3ft ,
FfE+,1.' 11E ('Fi+9ffi ) f!iEtH.#E7 /.{HE#W I-S,[.H
ifiT fr.f'+EH F"1FE' ME Etr FN+ftTfiE+E
fr + MK,+N7 +,1. , F,E fU PR
fU |3F F,!TARfrfi
'1 '18 'T , 'S ftsE.a EfH-#w8x...... a E {EF"l ffi+' E-IFEI+.1,fr.H
X
E+Uffi##ff!.Rffifi/.iru HE+niE+1tr
trffitrF'lS ' 4fr?'l+.tL# 7 trH{'+' {I1E)\Ff ffiffiFE
fn 'fH' EE+ n{ffi ffi €T=nK #z*fFf V l RH' m T ' H H H { t . I EJl t' Y{ D E{ Eff,F E
F E{ 4 ]1
I { r + lQ . HE
I
EHH " """ lTVfr!B +'I'F.1Et ' ifli# Zffifrrlt. EEEHffi-iKHE6TEIHAE riFfff. H{*fr.Jr" E#W
zffit" {tHNs+.frzf$f 4 RZ , +.frztfr H+*951Effi q r Wffi tr IEtfEf' JU ' l - R
E . F + ' l- _ Lffi fr .l tr IEt
na 2+Hw Eia " a als - * p fiJfrHfihfritr
u E T E frfrgh oei) ill)'-) q rffi_tffi (sicut
H Lffitrt* (Imago deus)ff!
F ! 'EEJ1 FFf[ +F"1 ' 87 eo
y'.t fHg{fi, :h.AD}i,,E,Eil1trtttE'fr.ili#. EIJIL,{[
H rtttl [F' / .{ruE +.7 ffi A i Fff!Z.f r ' r c .( € t J t r RF# E #gH +iffiffi T fr'.l/.tr!.Rff' E #F!trt? + +E4rE
;d) H +FEfEHH,'EEEfI ffi/fre.EfE4]Et.++fr,*i fr X ' Effi/. tftWt'&2HtitTfrE.Rff .
{E;ffiFitif€'EIHE
y{f}ffi ,1EHDF€Ur uA.AR'/.H I H Z nfr tW +'i N r e' o
ff.J' H mE E H_*+'f'Jf}fn{H mE Eqfn{rufHE

84 rH/.ffi,* fiFth (H HRHDf f i{ H) s llT#FF, f i. ##. Lf f iH f f i ) : # 2 H ' R #


'tt f! /. ffi# ru 7 t #, ru{n4 E H 7 FfteHW*4..FE ffit^ fi!tr E, *.ft lFffiLffi * tr
E+fi,.]E {r m tr 4 * H s, g E ffi ' f*E ffi ' ff€E fr t! /. ffi #xmfi. ffitt /. H ia ffi r+* H
Ert hina( ifi ,( €tJ
' ffi'H ft€E #l lffiDeusex mac i€ X fi H M il1fr 8tr1- ffi ffi *$9qE 88 F.l l ffi E ' l E It ' Hr63.
F)^fr"r 4 RffiEHff i, ( t r ' a{ + €f f i)' i{ 128. 8e l E It ' F166 .
8s FIt ' Hr2 8" 90 I ffi.ELFft UftlftftWffiE H E #ff FTtrEM+U E trEHi,fr E' E Eaft E ZTfi ff " I
86 ffi+lJrfr,ifr,fr.rj##ffi{fftffi+H ffiA " Itr l I ' Jl t/5
o

87 EEEHffi, (H-#H'frffi-4H> 'frtss " el l E Jt' H rsz .


ffi#9.RWq?-H,ft+Fg

iE= ffi H H ' Htr.f[ [FT"1


TEFN+EStJ ffi H ffiTA+E fU
fi!tr -'FFIH
AfrER' ftHEEHffiE *''1 /- fr!tr =,FIf"1ffi ftttr
€UtraJTF.+W-{EFft E R+NW,fr&ffiffi ' XEffi F fr! .

H ef ' E E 7 H {t Iii.W#Egh D}Xft.^E.ffi ffitH.+' /.{r1


y{{E HHftr"lffifi!trtre. /.{ru${rE,['4 . E {+ . E H
^a fIJHfr
F!EiF,E FN*H fr\H H' {EA fr\ Affif[ H H EAIE
I+lFH tr ffifr1tr+ L+refi! Ht+ET Ffi+E+Efi! , m-hffi
+ trfr TE'fEtr F" E 4fl Y .ffi Ffi t hffi 'A E r ' - h B -{$l,E
t+E ' +
t AHF'!EIE{'+'m4E y '.! e2 - ffffi Ef if t # HA
1, frH {t fEF + iEiE7 r?++.fr\ A ffi-E?,,t [! Hf+FtE - # =E =
ffr*fifr!IE{4ff.Jlfr.t+"' ' -FKffi H t+ fr\]E{$E it fi! H {EH H g #kfr\t
)Fffi#kfrtt rftU EflE
ft , ffrHH t H{+}E{'4 H fr.t1T E E tr E fi!Htr li. &
fr'.]
HHEHffi[!49;ffitFffiE-t';frfilHfr+E , tET EH+ffi
{EiFIfr,W{Hffin*Rtffil E rXffit+FIJfr!H H{A'lAE^
' ,,\,{PT
frTfrF.F,I
H H ' AiH AD}ffifi^]tr8fr,.]Htr.,IA,[AEffi^MF!H ffiEflt+Hfi&H,fF[E , D]ft,ffiffie€Hfi#{rE{t ,['4
fr\+lt+t]fi
.
E EH EHffi fr iE= ts E E FfiftHg ;ftfr BtJ tr il ffiE*fi fr4 ffidt/.i+ E ' r-fFifr.trffiryi8fi + in# &ufi! ' eFT
E r/ H g -6ft
ffi+,1.ff.J
ffi.e-#' f[H H H 1FE !$fftfr\ffi.
(iFPl|ftfr\{t{H)fn ({ffrEE)mg+Fn?ai+fr!rHHt== +E' m F--ILEF46{4fr!€Hi " r n'HEEHffi #&H-+.
{t[F"lffi' #FtrEHEr'\+g z&lF{tr#tr +Hi ' +FltL+fr e4
F {t' frF_&FtrrX7Fg
t4F!{t {H' ff fr {t {Hft\H+HEf}tE
H tTff[H E W€' E f6,Bffi qeHVEfH
H.r*#{ ft#A fr!+ tE.
EEffi )Fffiffi. ( Non-religious
ffi tE.ft^tk,HnVEf# )' E {A
'&
(Earthlines ( This-worldliness - Lq
) f[ J]LH'l'4 ) ffi ffi i* '
tr. (';fi+Hffi) -gH'+ ' EEERffiifHStJE{EFgFg
#E^FtF.lffi' 'fBl-E
H+ -F/fl
t dH H E F{4 '

e3 StanleyJ Grenz& RogerE. olson ( --ffffrdffig;+ffi) Htze , llXHeFW , 'Jft llff


1t1hre-tffir}Eit{4.rF'ffingttt"
s2 Cerhard Eberling ( jEl{=) ' lEHf ' [ .for it is not man himself but reason which, rightly s4 4,, n.trE yT;t'EE€ € ffi H!fiE+ +.#ffi lk* # *Ufi' ++S,11ffi tr1,i'rgghE fr ffi tr
understood,is autonomous I Hr r a - r r s " H F',f Efr ^H+ H,I&# ffiD}H+ g +, L'Y'J tr fr IFfr ff1ft FN
f HEE"
ffiw.rRwffiH{tffiry )Fffiffitrr*E#. , lffi=H - 1FffiW.tr1Btrffi.ff.JfiltBflif
)

t-......E-{
;ffH ifi + tr H ft'lHL+.'....fi g D}m, fi Elu, ffi-Fr . FHn9,EfrfrffifHffi,E
ts
EIE# lr E-fE g iflil1+.lfrZffi ' mMHEIfrT " EEAr
, +kHl (rl{ftF^]{t{H)" +X , +fi,H?#rF.E^g
el..e+' ffi H ft'.],8fr q ffi fHF'.1R fr ' E A E 4 -#EEtr
{Er#F*.
Hffi H &HBfrE trl ( iFF1'rrtVt{t{H) - g + 1,fr.6t ffif+ffi*
H - &fu,VfrZ'tfr , l#HfkUH1ffiffiffr,FnF.ffiHtr-#-ig " ) n'
ft!M{8ffiR . EE tr-HffiY{ft.FN IFV!+-Bhf{ffi' TEffi ffi
E {Eq E E ;ff#!EH EE E Hffi ,EfS# R trIE H,['4 tr #$ F'!lFH;t';ffEID]11Hfi.1FfH/.,1.ff!rxtR ' E mE EELngl
q ' E&E lfr.FnHIFffiZF.lfHBf,\ffitr!ffi'Hl " +fr,{PTT{H{HF '*E- lEEJttH 4 iff+ trTl tr,8 3 =.8 tr F!F H{'4.
it,e,*fll1fr.frfr,ffi,E.ffiH'+*f
fr! ' Hft{*il1#8 ' ffiEEEF
ffiGIfrI,8.4TffiE +8,8.^H, IF- I#ffi# . -{E tr FU
ffiE F tr {fr.,B ffifr'!frE
iFF t1ffiWWtr"illft,W++.+'* ffiffi
f[ -fE #H " E,e.* ffi# +Eff# trlH fgH {frffi-f,q E IS'
rc.FnH IFffi+iHWffift'fHilsttr-mf,eflf,qtr " fr tL, r +k ^ rffifiat " Iff.rEg
+Er'j_tffivrFEIFHEffi.trltffi tH
{HEID}t+ffi-{8fif; ;fr , <IFFT fEF'.1{t iH) fr'.lH€H++'tY!.Y{ EE e7."'..FnE#
Fitr-ffiA' a Hffi.trr)t !fr.#f+stl frtfr.o
EHffi*ffiEft 7 -IREP$' {EEfr-I*,X*ffiqffi ' H e8......z-EtrfEqfr.+k{H+ffi
/.TfE#m #AF,'tuffi # . ffi
Itrit{6{a HE ffif [ 14ffiffi# )FR W.
ffi+ffi fa]* + H fi ffi fi',.],8
nu # 97+frME^l r'J#ill fifr.fr." m,fHF!,E4 E fi iffiA epna a
ffif#ffiF"1FEffi€HEfrEXr " !ftrf , ({ffiIEg) E!EHfi nn
Efr!,K4' )
t, E ffiEH ffiE + VAffE'BrXWtr t? + /. Y{t ffiIFfr tr!
Etrg' ifrtr (l-Fi+#ffi)fE#lJ ' F Hf r l, Kq F l JEr i 6 r 7 A' r E-H tt+ + f.i l 1 l EE,
......fnH H H FtJ'+k+.tr + ffirrff.1 fr ,xrF+* F'l+Hrn'E/.,il'rE+[Hi tr]t Fl.... {eEffiF
H+ tttu+ E fts
E t ' t r Ht r + t r + ki r 5 *E[Eq [fi fr 4 9i.&8 ffi F fr !' E
iE* 7 , +krnE,z,r7lwill-tn ' FnE ft,F?,+kw ( {ffirE
ffiEF/. D]+.ftffi{t{H, 8 fr,Efr ' ElffiE,ffiLD}r,tr-
H) " ftm W*nE' Hfir{#ffif'.ln+ IR ' -ffiH4tr H
tr H +-ft. i0E ffiF H'.1,
H,.1 8 mtr,fr.#, E E,E,^ ' El
tkWT H t',g[H.ffi Ftt* T ++rLHft f! tr r)tfFffiil1iEg' Ff, .
g rfrfi+X*' E{EFF g lU+A/.E & ttuffi ffiE !fr.#/\tfff# ffiEF ffl, E zFnD)fr.ffiH ffl' EEI
frE(Hfr!) m
ffitriFtffi{t tr 7 H efi+V1Htrpff'l{tlH' r'ffi{f5EH
TE (*ffi!)
fHH XF'.1 r' tffi {t fr ffiH{tiHF!Rtr#ffn{f5*ffi4E
ia {EIPE FPH,.] E6ffi+ -# TF H F,.],8, fi. F ffi {HtrI,E -TT{E . FEFf,.]fr.' E,E,E.+' EIffit.ffi ifiT?E,Ifu
4r , rEItttrFHifrr ' r+grc.W&tFft.l#ffiryF
ITI +i€ -DHAffil EEEHffiY{EffiEgEAfr'1f!ffi s7 HEEHffi, ?-frt;+ ' (if Ht€ffi{tfH (H-ffi ) ) ( Elll,^.Rfrffiird' 2000)
Hss"
i* ' E&E tkxlfr.trlFiF,E,fgH,.l+F Ffiffi' 98 lEt' tr 34 " /.{4 iE,( XFIE't+tr + h Et8fttJ' # anK /. H fdg {H{H{HH 6'!& H mifi ffi
74Ef'! (Effi) H#' Efttgss4;t'4ft8trefrFfiffiH+E€'tE& . F.A{ffi-H'H
es EEEHffi, (l;i+€ffi) ' Hr83" =Hfi ffi---Rfitsf,tl,^.F!tr'df.lF={ffi
"
'
96 GerardEberling(Ffr'l=) ' frtoa " Itr l I ' FJb
o

34
RW.IRffiWH{tTH€ (m=F - 1FffiW.WEtr#.il'tftlrffiE)
)FffiW.WEtrW.'

v7t|+trbH , +EftEH+i{ffiF!4ft{t'H{tlH
' mE+Etr, 3n' FUE-{8,E,frJ 104'H'',\'fH+*q7g{Et)t#g g1+.fr
+ft.f;Afniffi
" ffiHffi,E,^ffiEtffiE FLAHo '* ) qHE4.ftlE&ffiffiH'E^],E ,
^ffi28+ # LttF,ftJfS# "
E M{EY{U N,.],fE[ A ffi tr = {HWA TAEEEH ffi fEH H! HA, E1gHffif'J,8.^ffiffi+ffi
' EIfr.JE.ffHH+HTF,fi!
| AF?ffi.trlBtr
ffi.-t fHEflff!F"1ffi, l-ffi{HtfuffirEEf[glH, T r"1,['H
H r& - ff l#fftfr,ffiH{EE
Xift+H,T:nll=+HE-H.Ifr /. E + #'['HB {Ffn
frt# " fli iruF'.1
H fL ' EEEHffi tF.tr+*|fr,#flE' ,E'f FtE if;H +,ffi
( -ofl
t-ffi 2E word) ' it tr EEEHffi ffi,K^mf"1EtrlFffiffitr 9Zfz{#affiefr,ET#f[TEfr!/.r 10s',Kfi-A
{H+E+F
W'RtrtEf+SlJ 7 ffiHEEEW# E' E MWIE,=#A {ruEK-iff
fU,E
q.{FffiFTAE*MZ<Effi+N
.fL' EEH n#trW.1?,il1ffi%-#/.{ruEE
| ffiffi.frThfr"
fEffiE l-tffiIFfrffI' MTE
101
)'.lFHfr.lr . E{Eilf'J Fltft.WgEEtr HEE.Hffitrdl fr 7 A {fr.RW.4HE ) 106,D)lF"ffi fr!lRte.ffiHv,K4 " E fER W.
g
f+f;s F'.1 fr!IrffiEyf tr E+EEillffiff#'0"
FfiFE' ff+ftsry frzN ^ffitr E tr.]Etr E M]E.HE EHffi E X E fEA Y{U ff.J'
-#
tr ffi+fr*gl+H frW.##H#, fr Vffift,K
ffiH tr.],8ft.F[EE fE+EE'ME fE+EE TE *EfiE ffI . +H ^ fr"fifr.#rfiffi
F'.1-ffif; ffi.*n-i#'E Ifr.lFF1{frFtffi& ffi,. .....' tz.H,iE
*il1trnw.#f.l ffiffieftstrFU'mE-f84 ft ff.ly{i.f; '
E g f'.1
F'.1 E g #t,I,tr g FIffilg.H{FFT1ft.il1 HE W., fri19.
E gf'J fn{Hffi;f;E &wru{H ( sf;s + fr'.] FlfE) ffi H IFl1tft.F'.]E E W.,X'f^E iq H Eg F'.j H g W.. E Ihffifr
;f;- tt " it T E ie {ruft,-'-R,-#ieE E g tr tht t+i\ie H'!ft -{E+fr*ff!ffift" 'o'
A' mE i0 iHfHIA|fi,fi"] Ff;f[ ft + tkt -'tury'i*d
ie E E g -
" iO{Hl?.H E fEUW.i#- ffifi - tr FUffi84 F'.1
+fr*WffiA tr
^gifr.$fii*,-a{;#Hg ' mrlEfR
^ffiEEfttrl - ftffiw.a\fiErffi |
' FitEFnnEHffiFn+Efr )FR#9.il1H9
ffileffi # H E f'.1;f;FE " FfrD)trtEXfr,E r'Jf! fi {ruT
EIHE-6fr;#Hg mE H+ X Tffi E ifr,*lHfi . "' W.t+ffi#{Uf,!.

E E E g ^ffi/. 1F1 -'tuq,;#


y{ ;fi ' /. {ffit H2tr4 EEf} _t ffi ffitk' ffiFffl,Effi2FE' -frffifr.t#Lffi t ffi7
zE.ffiA fi {HT,.] E' IEJ H+ E tr E ft.],8.
fr,t H?ffiJf;fl E,ft fn{rur ffiH H E ffin+' E E H+ F.ffi.+fr*ffiAF'.]
+ft.+[1
^ffi
Iff ' E ffiE.#{;f;tr.]IE]F+&Ff E Efi A H WA{ruE A H!H+ ffiiH,K4B!E*A' ElmEEEHffiffiE' l-t.ffiifr.ltug1
lR ' m r -Eq +gE fr"Ffr.H ffi E n* t|+ - EErtr-fi^]tffi*t*Jt+it,
" RWn fA/.-f6i;fiWryfr"
'my {f t B g { 8 f t
-fEF_nrwffiw.frTfrJf!. -{E ry'.I xilfr/.+r"1 .

1oo F J t ' F ' s s . 104 l E It ,8122e.


101 l E l t ' F 4 o . ros l E It ,H 44 "
102 l E l t , f i t t - t z . roo l dt ' H 3e .
ros lElt , fiztt " roz l E Jt ' Faa .

36
Rffi.IRWffiH,{tffiE )F#W.trlBtrW.' lffi =€ - )FRW.fi'lEg#.#'Jttf.fiEf,if
)

HH- {Htrt4' iOfr.J


€ {E/. fi13 H ffifr i0 ill +.ft AFffi FtH {EtrFfiIAFE$H#fr.J . ttz6Bf,f]frntTffii*.ultb'tuX ,E
tril17 t 108 " Htffift'.1 t!+D/4ftlY,,^frrZ.|.fr/.H ( {ffi}Ee) + y{fsi+ ft^1trFffiftffiE ffiift/. fr^sFH'
+' /.{ru tr J ftm I H ffit (H T +gtrl trt * ) ' E H+ F t
t.'ffi*,trrEtF
'r&t 7 tgfr.trt frlt#ffi- | E + +H t tE* E^]tr{H f*
10e ,
,flEr " EE n-frffiF!ffiH FtfrlFffi tHffir F!/. Xtr ffiE Hffi trlHR
ffiF ft1'{tu ,,t .
+ Z<E +AfttrtTt ff.J
*Effi Hg ' & FTEftTE E g-Y W f,I+ +N' E M + + W ' HAH++.+ffi'ffi^ ' mE+HFnH EtJ'{fuXf^lfRiF-
+ F'!IEfnft t'rF.tfrf[ f+EtJ'KWtrtE g trlH ffi +,K E'.1
^ffi L+
i,.t" r 110 " IFmft+ETEggFtrf,.] ++#ill/.if5 E*.If H 4ilillzKHE ft trftft7 E fEA iHfriE+.fr\Tffn"" E fEfi*
ft tr +*€ FJ/. tr!#E Z84 H# H,.l gE " {Eil/. fr WtfrH
tr 7 F ffiffiF F'!,ftH' {B{6'[A lElH+A t. ffi EXE F t tr]
UF.ffi- rffi.#qE{EUtTft.]#E ) Itt . fiHE2, fr+ffi f r ' I W A F I f lA' { EA9 7 AH # F 7 F .F WftEfE# 4 ,1
' { EE
H fr!,8fr FtE r)._hffi f,.]n+ F'.1
4 ft X f44x€ {E{E/. ffi+ 1A{A-;HH 7 H4LVltrffi,HE,trffirfE I EeEWTfl
,
fr D)trHF!4.ftfFHxtr +.ffi, F.HEt#tfrtr8
EE'.1 tr1Hfrq6fr.' fiftmL+.tfri'xffiffiffi+Effi. [HffiHfi q
W-ffiEft' ZFpJt ]14WFsAln
Afi{ffi44+8ffi (Gemeinschaft)
ElFE-#ffi EHEHffi- tr FnW++ffi tr iEfr'.]
E g {EMtWffi W. dtrfr7 .Rf;n*1,n*fi- r .Rf;nf[/t E t ffifi.]EE ,
Ifr^M,Vffi
.
f.JtrEtJ m FJ/.FA HffiFnlnHVffi r ..s.,RffiEfi /.q4iHfr'.]T
rtnErt , )\F'.1,Rxnilfr.H1t ffi F'lffi wR-'t , D]Hfnea-,#
ffi=f;fr. Bf,f}E{8tr'F F'lR H y{tr n-IFH fEFI,l'4f.J-#ff '
t - I tr4F!FIffi .Rff F'!ry14tr A fir'.1H{++ +nftJT trvl^ iHfl e F!E
E ({FFl|fril1{tiH)+' EE EHffi+€frtrt1Eftsfi L+" EffiAffiffi^ilREHEtrlH;frqff-#,t1ty+' rfrqE
H'ffiEr . Etf ffiFgHftr,Rfftrlr$H &ffi,I€in?ftfrffiH
' m#trt1FtFifl ' EgFffiEg 27fr
FJr#Ugiffi,il1H+{R
.
IEEfEHf+ E{#' lFtE Ifr,F'.:.4 f_---ffiH E +tSlJH'.1
Z.iE#,h tilflFF 4 g
ffi'turyF-finffi7l!,mH tr tTU € E l?n
tfr.' wft' iffiHEg fr"1 H ffiE ftqiRwE/.fr {a4.if;F'!fiE H , E l#t+i* Elr)t^ frgr&^n+
t+i*E^1fr! DlTHtrttrf,qH rE ' {E
H' {Bl-E F+E Hffifi E - A 2f"1f"lffiHeF-tr 8{REE ffi FffiiftruE,,-FI,F{.JHRft^HAHWI\IH" trc
F!' mH,trffrt&**8ffiffi " ftm, W-.E{EtrFf[t=&ffiE
rrz l E Jt ' H 2so , 2s4 , 2s r o
ro e l E l t ' H 2 8 6 " rrs E E E Fffi , ({ft4+) ' H rs .
10 e l d j t ' H 2 8 e . r14 IE I_I' F16 "
rr o l a -Ll ' H 2 8 8 . l15 l tr l I
.
FL r u .

t:_, n77 .
I r r ltr-J 116 l EJ t ' F 20e.

39
g
RW.IRTHtrH{tif )F#W.il1#trW.'lm= H . )F#ffi.il1+trffiil'Jrrtfl|*HiE
)

DtH t+ffilRI+, trn)F t)tffiIRI+ft1ifr.t+ffi


HtfEtr!.R F E Wtfr2= 9Q{Srft r&MA fHE F'.1
E Fn, IE Wttu
fi ' ffiTE e ft.E {Etrt1 +tr+_#illH ie{E/. ill# . tr,ffrl ^ft
Ath-wEtrt12t Ef'JreffiZ?' (Fm+.ftftft,tr+Ft
EE# AH I# H B !#H z ff'y '.tFTffi T T i& HHillE 2E F'.1
)\Fn{^Erffif,qH, Wfr&tfr HrnH#tr +*ffiffiW"
+tJA' EJ{+ fr,FtTLffif[it.y'.f'.1#'frJ# 1]7. Hy'.tEH
-t itrEffiEI#
7 E+rlZffift F.Dltk' -hni* fu€ /. , f +.ft F'!E-w
a[wffi,T'fuxffi tFtH.,frEfE ffirH.+' {t,,r,r1a# H
r"1 lElE f6tffiillffii{Wit ,
EEEH ffi+fr;{E-ffi{Eie eq,ffi
27fr1F frtEE++J II8, nntr-X' /.{ffiW+.ftffif5FtgFt E F iHiFE Y{H g 4 IEE H+A fi,.] f,qH . EIH itr€ WFIffi
7 f'JiE={Etr n-)FftFFtP.gl-{HE +glEfs' /. fl +IWUE aFE - fE/. iruff H g 4 lEE rEf.HI?,W#rF.' Effi --#Wfr
(EIL#n , R€{FYftr8ff.1+El=o$rtVlKffiHffiJLm '
ffi,}W , E{EtrFMtfi.EIFEffi hill " EE
E EE E Hffi -'aK'ffi
'ff.ffi€8h.7
E tl'ttuXff!fF4' #fr* # IE4uT '
ttriEV.JffiY*
z.wffi# ^ffi^wffia Raa{fr'4tfiz+' m EEBtfrz# +t1EFIJ{H^rt
EHFFA ( {ffIEe ) - g + ffiw"nY'(nE
+*T * EE lE Wtffi24 V,Jft,e + W " Wtfi2S lEllTx#&+frZHE ftEY{
| -
Y{ WtfrAffiKft&ffi#r E M{EEfiffi+tr!;{;frft E }, f
iFfrFF'.1'ttuX24HffiHEtrX . E'ft,, ft&ffiAftEHEH
-+IJlT^ftfrg.tl a'SE#f+gF.lffiff ' +g , tfrJ1frF
f6x,*#t;#E | # )\ff'lf$#t ..e' t,FFE
ffiEX, lff.ffi E ftSFIF*f+4 ,)t{ ftA,}!ktr!{,Hiol ' "'
, fr,"rt,ftfrr.mZ=
HfEFn+Fitlil7ffiEtrl,E,^ffi " '-*t#V!ffi{*,WE HUE '
tr FU t, #tfr 2E EF lTKf#fr&ffiA r^1-+lJ fttfr.h1fr
F'l-txil1ft,+.+ffi ' mHEEt+fr'l' F[Etre.xTEEftS ffl . {E4ftwt6 2+ {fr++^H{Et\ , wtfizs zi @ELH*"
fr XEF'.1 g1
E W A ffi*.,I' % Elfr.J' F-l0lEy{E E ftqfr ilEfi'! 4fu.&-E' fftTEFtrE ' ff"8*ffi ' 'tr'r!Y{tffiFftHl
E ffifi'!tw.E+ft.'ilwtzl&o 120 EffiE{Etrt?AF tfrlffi.lTabreffiz+" E ,r,r1+ffi,fl
rHHffill . ......ffi1k2-4ffifr&ft,44 HH HifitrttVfr ,
HftfHtrmxfHFnw,
f&ffi|Fffi#f IEE-uXW^{E-F#ffi ' ffifriLIfr,ifi*[.+
7 WrR
a, H f' #&tfra+ H v!fr&w.fri,r,'r7?fi.{ft ++- ffiwtfr2
-1Eg4ft+ffi{s^ftfrF.ffi
# - tx .
ill+ftw tre. ,nffi 2= 84. ,8,^ffiF!f+i* ' E
a H F'.:
= 7Fffi E E6' E {ffiE ffi + EflT ffiH trttr!tr t? . EIfL ' ff
Ed{H fr1-tll, qfr.zffi
#, m2,w.=-# "'"
r1 7 l E l t ' F r 8 "
^ftwt6a
rr8 [ E ] t ' F z o .
r1 e l E l t ' H r 0 4 " r21 FI_L' H ro8.
r2 o l E l t ' p r o + . rzz FIL 'H roe

40
RW.TRWffiH
{tffi€ , lffi=H , )F?#.il1F-tr#.ilutr
)FRW.ffiEtrW. ltffii+)

ffiE Hffi AEH' E M ffiTN#- EIE H {T5 f'If+E g ffi w.ffi- {E+ zHt ' {fiT E.I
H?,fr,Tffi#,#,ffiLk-{H
+ " +fi,
ffiH ftTIE f.]fr ffiftEffIU.T' E WftIfrF|'-{Jffi f,!' #g {ru#EE{stltrffi- IH+4if; ' mfi{r5fH{=FIh.-.tH+,
w.ilTffiAtrHr+trtHT RH , -fEWE F.118lfriffiHffiffi ZiE 4Fr r 124HEEHffi E=#E mI+E^ftfi3f6 ZHH+iE
4 . EIffi/.'fFlT{E'fHE#t#ftffiA , m-EL+fr'#fi}ffiAH -DW+'IHT WtfrZ#ff.1^iffi '
tkff l-FEt ff.]tlEA I ffi rfg{El 'lffEf #Afg\E FnD)&.HF 4 ffi{Hab freffi2_4, Bilfr.tr4 tr!* S
r ffi€uE7 fl.n#/. E ff.H+' f;FIEJ H+-#^HAt' #ill EIffiA Hffffi{HAfTffSfE 2#WWISH ' MEHSEIts
E&' y'.{ru;,K;frEtJ7
' e[^mi*ilgffiE{EftE ' f'Jrffi-ifr 2#t ffi,H{g
fr3t6 FIE#,, ftHS E ftS
-#rtE#f'J H E ffiffi'lRdrui+' ff EF ffifcf'lF&Ffft&7,1{' rzs
+.ffi.f!tr{Effiffi" ^Ic-rglffi.z_#'
Affif # A'lg{Ft ffiH!Hft' E m{OEtr tr nHtr tr!ffi.
feffi"&" fttr' )\ fl-#';trSlItffiV1ffi,ffiepW.H;d-#SIJt A trIEfr.f[ #,R, E.EHEHffi trI;frffiH,+ E M {+
ffitrl8., ffn{A{A{e{H11 il1*' e[T7F.FE
ffiH t ffif'Jru{ffi fHtrEf, ffi ' Em frE l#l+ilT$'['F' mff fr U&.)\A Hill
'ttuXtrl^lm'& 4 t){EFfr E MA Wh# Lm . Elffi?re
f'Jrffin^lgifly{H94.frf!)tF.fl"
rEH'zth.fi'ltrnxF, LftT-F'trfrH fi Hffiffi ' #.R4
ff€me 2' l&Ef #'lg{FH+rfi , Effi'lg'J'R^{E; lff
6 f'.1H FlJ E +?{fl' Etft#.R fi ffi 7 /. ftltjj+.wfrnw
iE+#fg'l'RA'm{' ' lffES#fg'lRgH'
4 Iffitg'lEi*ffi BW " IEtre.Eg ^ffi zth fr.lfrnEft ' IW#tr^Hffi,E#
' iffE+#{g'['RRH' Fmfflf{'R^mi*'fuE
EIffiffll{'RHft{ . F F U 4 E;E,' ,fi m SS'
f f l' m f f T E f R ffi ) .ffi ffi ,a
2W ' iffE+#tg'lEtrH2W , Efffi'lg\EgE ' """EI E 11H'{ref#ffi 2H frWt H."'..aA -#f+FU' E f E tr H F'!
DlESrl ' EffifEfuqH+HlEWfr rtiEH4ffi " tzs r-,,\.t rfS#t ff.l/." EffiEE8frJtr4f;nmT{H{HE
F-ffii^r fEH Y{t ffi trliEH ffi Xff H H ft....liE
H E FI ff f' trliltffi , =-aA{[,1.
H g LWH ffiFn+AFJ fl ^mE E
,
il1',ffiX.EEEHffi+RT/ttr!EE fr#.REm{+xt*tffi ^,L'
zth.fl tr E 4 !$ffi.+FfirE # Fn+Afi.] fflH_*fi' RT E --
2H ' ElmiEffigm {+4f;3f6 2# , EeT fr.WtrFfitr {H r-ffi;t*E{HtrlEFt/.ffi'fiffit126 ^,1.
" EEEHffi+Ffr 'E
Wft l-,,\.
tr fr'.1 I ffiT'lH,'{re.mHE iFtr tfr,P.Rfi3tfrZSE I#ffiffi E Will ffi tk?1gh, fr,-Ff.E fSKft # t624 ffi ffi th.
,nBtrtaxft wtfi2+ + fi fi a H ffl " Tsffitrftl-FU{S{effigE F'.:ltfr * ) 127,EE Ht ffiE
EEg IFffigE.f.J,['4 HFNiAEff.J .
H!-F_ftil#.H
H ftufi3tfr24 zHt f! -
lT^ft Wtffi2S E FnH HE
,E (,-Fi+#ffi)+€'F-anEEffiFiS
+JJ , tftltr#,H'fr|| r24 FEE,Ftffi'(H+€ffi) ' Hze .
rzs EEEHffi, ({frE+) ' Fr14 "
1 2 6l E l - t 'f i r r s "
r23 l E I t ' F r r r . r z 7 H L ' H l 1 9.
ffiw.tRT.E^ffiH{tffie , lH=H - lF?#WBtr#.trtttrEBflit
)FRW.ft1EE#. )

WE.fttr' EffiffiWl+ftfttr + trlA' {E


Effitr.]E tffiHtr n-tr-Jtr#rEffilfr,FnffiA trlffiHfl,KR ' {t,
affiEHffi ETEFH ffiE A +.ghTfr,ffi-L.ffi ffiffiEM' E tr,J,l+ff ffiE g EFffi#tJE{Efr F, H EItrIFfr EA-A{tr H
sffi E#gffi Afr tr E IRffiffitr.]EES " HEEHffiH ff F -
X., fr.trffiffiF'lE FEt' 4 /. {ffi lEetE IH+n
E tFil-J'tu Ffr
& g f,!E /. {ru- € -'atsffi
V1' f&ffiA q'fH Xft WtfrAffiffi ,sT ill#, Ire.fri&g#EFF,l HtrffiiHffitrn-W# "
I$ftH T [+4 qEAfflIEHHEN ffitr A trIE iT . E IEJ H+U E{EHffiflEfgffi' EEqFffiEgfIEFTAHFTffi
E-trtsffi#i0ffiftF-gF'!Hfwt- rFfl#f;f#r ftlffi rrtr ' fr/.{F1-Hft|.e,fr.+tr.HrE.#fltrFfnFf FHlt
f. HttEg n '.1l -ffl ) H {f., If,E FfLE f ' ll' f H+ lE J f'.1
Xft,fi u I*ffiffiE W- E g ft /. fr!* EIFA )SFtJ /.q #wlF frffioktrT4/\Ji^ ' iHwffiz+. ffi,ffitr H ffi , Dltr-tre.
t.ffiffiflw , 'rff.fri1v,ffiffinil1'{frx
" lfr,DlthE'rF.\fr
H'+ # fr n ffi,,tE ffi E t+Ht- tr ffifi # tr-J
sftr nfr\*. ++*. #{EEfEffi,r.trtffiSf frFF'!ilTtr.- &'+tlftH
=
f, ' A+EE-E\-F,D)ffiEEYilfr . EIEE{EIEfE, ry.il1^
fr. ({ffirEP)ffi;frs+ 'WIYffiEn',ffiXtr!82
H,t fr,Mtfi*y,ffitr X - ,,t{rug rHE fEBffiF rt 4l fr 7
EF"fitrX.mTfrtr frtT ' Elm{[R rtfl{fr'{tuXffiBTE
EEEHffi E.Thffi)FH E +NWH IT,Effi ' ;fiS H IAr"lFEtr!
#, m Bflffi{ffiZiff E lt M'{fiX' B.Hfxft ITFITfr ffitE
Elffl ' UFiEF ifr,ET/.{H *n[,]4ffi8#g + ' tffif.lH
H ' E F-lftlfrX.ffl4Ht 128 ' AE{EfrtTtE+.ftf'lI{f1
frIE]ffi'TtrlHfrfHE "
Y{
/.fl€ E{Eil ff tS' tr rtrfr tFt D}LFnF WE{Efi =\ft (-) FHtr+.ftf?ffiffi
tr ; tfltfr.,frnnrf-fE ' E{EilEtFF )'.{f1' trJ}tffiftE
t r f f if f / t n n l EEr H r ffi WW,T ' d F F Effi 1 IW
4
/.{r5H uffi F--trillt1ffiFnffi* WIEE ' mv}rF.AEIWfi
E.Eg + t. ffif,!H ftIiJfr fr!F tr.+HE ft,IXEfE'
&Ff,E
tt# E " ffi;fiE D5F_- tfrifr,i*A[T@E EEE'Hffi-a(ffi( g '1
r ffift /t* lEff tr ffiH ffi{ttH' r)tE ffiw +.frffiqxtr H
ftq) ffiE il1B, ElmErrffii* ffir#ffiTfr /. H Eff trtT w +.fr F'l-{E lEfE . 4.ft #f;{trit T E 6 It ME S fr F,.l F"l
VlEi* " M tr E illgRFEfrtrtrA E Atr qFffiEgIg trI ffi ' mE+HH qFffi Eg ffil:uffi' EIrtrE HHE.HffiBE ft +.
tffiffnffi " 130
ft fif;f#F'lF"lffi+ ' oI,)l.ffiH'l,t1HE E l-;trE +.fr r E {E
E H E^Eft$-vt ffi Ifr.W E# +.91{-$
IH-F, g, H m F"lffi' E#ttE Hslfi.tr q
Lill+.fr 2^' X E )\ffi Eez
+.G il7trt?
E WIffiE Lffi H Htfr E t-ffitEffifi H?.
# +fr.fv ,IglN-,fEA, RHfiEfr.T E{EHfr+8, tH EHEHffi {ffi
+ . fiftmtrTEy'.F'.1+rKE' mEt.ffiEETWL. "n t+F'lH,ff Ffiffif! +Efr ' H lltrT?n lr<Wfrt t+D]ffifr., ils
1 2 8 l E l t' F41 "
o
1 2 e l E -L ,H.4 2 . r Ju l tr Jl '
j1 16/
ffiffi.,]RffiffiH,{tffiE )F#Wil1EEW., lffi= € - /FRffiWg-trW.ffitIt
J#.BErf
)

ftnE/.f.JtffiwH Il, frft.t H IH/ty{Hfttr!' {E/.y{ F.larlE F ffifiy..Rf;n'E m r ffiffit+i*fr,.1.R ftrffi (


it/.ff! ' {Eil/.fftrFfrlH,fI. ifr,Ltrlfr**ftmE /. ie /. W# , H#,fr,i#{$ ^nTR
n-EtlffiJtrf+D)-=,H.
.
EEr "' ffitrlEX' EWEt+i*+fr!RffFUgl3trffiCH
tsn /15 +
-.

H l r4 ft F'.1fr#ftr' H m fi ffi i * 8, f r / . f [ _ h
f f iff+,ftH '.1ft'! tr (ntndung) , H H E 4. f t t r ! HH ffWt1gh. Ff,flrfE | +trfi@,trftfStr (Ncichstentiebe) mf/g
#, """ lfr.fniEHT +kF'l H HAdtfrEfi'.lF,ff
I 136, EHE
(Fr e ih e i t)" . ...rtrH E fi !tr + gFttr E H'+! - f rf f i
E f fi.tfl++i+.fr^ffi
ll '{s fi hfi
HH '.]+ " fr!F HH ' f t # Hffi 4IT ffKfH trIE},H]KIY#HiE#EVEJlEtr H ) ffiWH
( St e llvertretunI ) f I f+ e H ft ( wirklt chkei tsgemaBheit ) ff! ff', ffiwtn+ fily{;f;x inEA'fiffftItueRffitrtfHE fff}S{HA
(setbstprufuns) F!rutrfaffi;a;# , mTE D]ffiffi.TWF,rnffiHtfE '
8t ' H H#BEffi+.frtrnt1fiJJil1Hfn'fftffi fil
F f,Hft f+f'.1tr Fft'(wasnis)" ttt E ti.f+ffi(pylades)' ffi,t ffi.t&trlF
*E[effi H,!ra*{ff .
H{ f tr HH
T f f i Ef f i t r i # H H E H ffi ffH T A ffi ,R f;N. f f * HiE f f i (I p h i g e n i e ) , R H , L . f r e Z i P I h f r l i l H Y _
lfr ' --aK;fr
F'!Ef, /.4 H + FfitEHfr1fre" (GenieJSen)
AH "

1 . H ITffiIRf[ Efut+ffi, IitrEfiSia=ftrrt+EHE IF.'HEiFffiiE '


H ItF .R Z1frEEE - I#[HfiI,fr'.] F FF' E * iHfr] L it +t + d 'fr:, g+4\,1114" 4&, Ji ffi t* :
^r'J
EEEHffi- tr ^nfR5fi-iJfl
tr'lffiHfi' ff tTW'e* iFftf'l IfrA ffi € - ,s"i tR e ,r + + €"
+tr#E'E dI Wtrlth.xE /\. f! R rnffi 7 IxE H E fr'.1 fiftifl {'4 € {E&*.A4*.e",tb + +,)&,€ffi '
rtnft,#++ ffis4+#t4y{Ie#FfrHHVTHIA " EEEHffiit
4"*UEE it.lt re,(B#,t?€l+ '
Ttrftm6-;KR.*n"" mE ?Z+EWtr^m,RffF WEil1ffi,
-ffiryH13''o lElH+ - r kfr *;..# Afu f ,
' tE,r,rE;?;dEEERffiff!+,1.ryA
A H l+trlW[+E-#ill H ffi.r-ftf; f#' S{E{Eilr iffF"lffiI fr! 4, FtlU - *sft+h.u.. l+++gt ,fi . T i*.6 r3 "
tr+t
€* -tfiHHI+V1fttuq
ffl,llffiEAls€. ffiR rEg W.H0E d{n H e ;
+\,{P:.dr*-**fi+,J
ffitrf* - F84ffitr{A#{rc.A'FIB+&EHffiEf*- ffi 4 i W S.i ts i g- fr 4&-
W '61
,
EF WF-yiA) 134 . HlT.VlfrEifi TEffi 7 FRffitJ.Rfi ' ft-- lH 6 * int# ;
^61
13r t' Hre3" n R N,FF4+ EnEt&,4t 4+a+ ;
4Hre,Fn
tz2 r'l(E4rgr€HHEft!,Rfimftgr,EftYtf!'r lEt ' F208"
4{,E.E l&.#t , 4&.
9 € * Ft+o
I 33 r .Rfi E t? H d ffiH fi fr HE tr!4{4 ffi',$.H'rtr- IWRffi{S* {F,t$gEtJtT *8
Ftaqfrft.-tr'tr*4.I ' lEl.. ^ft1Ftr
134 ffif} E Ffi' flEE H ffiDIffiffi + E F,HtrW &+EIAfr ffi4hIFffilil+ #,HE 13s l E Jt 'H 210 "
^Eft,W.' FI
L , Hzoe, z1o" '} 136 [E l t ' H zrr "

46
+F€
#w.tRw^ffi-H,{t , (ffi=€ - )F?+*.Vl#trt'-trJtfr.lrBE#
)FRW.WEtrW. )

,4R z ^8'ttz A frFnk ,


FF l ,^ Effi , IfrH€.fftr'S ' fEilA D}K H fNffiHIr' AFI] I ffi
tk t H I:vFJ[^tr .
ttrf,ftfrE {Fffi 8ffi7 EEg + t ffi WHft
a E,4B *.6,*t ,
i*.6 EAIe,
98fr N-ffiHtr.fH 8 fr,!A f|l' H fr}E g B+ET ffi#f!fi!
6 ',F-6L- 4 lps-it*&. ft, A fi.48 "
F' Hfttr eH7ffi {#ff.J H H .
triFo'"{u'
:::#:;:; t = ) Ht r
K eA4rt,uS , lE&t+46tfrl hlF++ .
.-vlt E ( { f f iiE e )- g + ' tH tr r - ;fl ffi H + *F ,l ;{ ;ff
# + b f f iE # lt ( fi, r Eg - H Aq q #- t , 9 \ftffi ^ Sl 3 { r i
lre.+E E fr ' * ffifiy.tr!.RrnffiHIA 27frfr^1
H{ffiFffilrr.
-# TFHllflHftftf;{ffit;{-affiZHf '{E tHtrt -;ilf,.1
T ffi ilff' 11H frTby.1ffi.RrntFE F H I+illt1Bhffi
'ey{ cr1 HZE+trtr']ffi E e #DlT Idilltrtil fr IF.|tffiEHffiWEIF+ . ru4 ++ ^
lfrA+E#' E + t4 ft,Ft' H fLt frZ
(Henrich ott) FKffi' EEEFEHffi+ +.ft ^ffi 1FryW+l-E E
)S
trrtrtrH€'H 137o FE' Elffiie F-re.fiiru;e{Etr frEW+kiFl c={EH+{t ' H + ffi
Bftft H.RfffrlztHEffiJrRtEHIIt
- {Efrnft.i# tr ea;s - ff Ety{E {ErFw+k{rurEE F!- {E[H
Z .H ff-9H4H F,!tFryXf[ {E/. . ]3ew ffiH
ffi F!E 4 r"1ffi IWHfrnftiEl,J'H
hffiEl f;[' H H frfug/*E ffiA 27fr
H F {f ^ffiR ff E'.1 ,r,wtrffivffirEH + fi.Je# .
tTllFtr!I^ E{$ I*l+ ' ElfLH l+tr H H F"]EE ffi tr'l
l{rfr'E EF Eg W.Iffi}E ryffifr #RfiTE HfNfr,.]
HE' ZiE tr'1
f"lFE' tr!H E, {Efr.TE*EtrE^ffi {H{Eil1H8, frJF-T^q[
ffi+g
Hlrfr H HEy,Jffifi.1fiftff ' H'ffSHt - fitrftziE +ffi2\ft'ltffiffiH& " 'oo
H+F"lt.- tXH HHHtfE'm H Ht1fr?ftEft€ITz+ " +*TX, EEEHffid6-ijflE,rE trffi.{fr
IEeHFEE
HtffiftntrIa-Ftrft t ffifrffi a ffift!tr + B'.l/.E!
HH " "u tffiin#g+tsz.F'lHElEtffitrlEfnH+HIE) 141 ,
H H 8,.]
F.#,;FJE ft!tr, H I+ IU+ffiE H fET E Y{
/.ffift!F' ieEt* ID)+EHfHfr trffl' {Etr EHEHffi +EEEHffi-trE.,IF+RFIF"IFE ' D}HTE-+ffi
H t&EU/i
DlEg ffi+,1'ffiffiHfi+' ft!F eFT fr?+,frffi ffiffi 'lEZ<
T HT #M' E t r f H H g . M EL fr( { ffi } EH )+ ' EftST W
fly{ H E,4 AWie/.ft!trfr'.ltE ,
)r WffiH E 9\ltu/.A[E t&+€EE t Htr r Etr t RW.t Ffi+frVrf,l#mflill r-ffiA-
DlEgn'.1 rffifi t H|fiffi*ffiil1,FnU.ffifreffift!trfr#
139 Henrich Ott Reality and Faith, p.316.

r3z l E l t , H 2 t z ' 2 1 3 . 140 HFEiHffi, ({ftIEg) , F161 .


r38 F J t , E I z t + " r41 JElt ' H16s " #Affi.ffifFg-FfiH "
RW.IRTEffiH,{tffiE , (H=H - )FRffiWEtrW.f.1Itt
)FffiW.ill#trW. FtBEit
)

IEfF. *Ef;ErS+ifiT3461t+z' mE-fEre,^.trt+fr'.lF'.1 ]E+ ffiL|E E W.iFg,B fFffJHr^k++.'


D]1fr.#U ff ffiFtE Y'j
E#: ft iHH+{t mE - H frUffiTfit.fr'lH tr tr-iRtrlEli='l'4F"lFE"
+fr,*hre F,FU tr t1f'.1HE fr Lffi r.lHtr.+ 1,fr.8+E - Ef rf FE- HE, E +FrfFrf,ltfrEll=.++.rf f fHEfF,.l
-6q rH[tfH ffiFE' r
FitE iEF n'.]E.'fE 14s
ff l#.-alflf[
+fr.+*ftru ,
' "' "' F F"lf"]tr'fftlE fr.|. rnl,lIFffi
IHEtr Eff.lffiftEiFH, *"# ifr., --n,ffif'l4.if;A H tr 2 iEdt ft-4+
€ P": ffi T xI E R rE- *-hlrP"IFA
"
+ . S Fffift€' H[ffi+g + t.ffi tr']fntrFF"lH&, (ntrE
f f i= Hf t BF
. f!trH
HE H+T g T frH,ffi
iAfTff.J,fiflH,ffi5Ut ffi F,.] SUtr F F,!H
,ffiStJEfT
E, +fi,ffi trlH f+.H+T @4ffi,ffi#tJ
t ffitrlH & "'o'
fSI tr!+ntH#t+' Dl (BUtr-Et E#) IFRHftqfrnAF'.:
EIEf'JH8.il1Ef6ffi M, EHEHffi ffiH ffiH ft,frT'
)Fffiffi.ffif+ffi -{E H ;rtH+' E,ftSFn tr!tr -iFI
ff,FEIF7 tH
IYffit ffitr fr {AiE-ffi{EfH+Effiffi,A' U FltE+*8k7F,g FE ({f ({ffiIEg)
-drfl Ef,;ffs" IEI t#il7,ft FTiftil1{tiH)fr m
H+ tfiA E M{EiFtuitgff.]^{E'ffiXfi.1/." EIlEHffi 5fi ' g + fr,ElstfrE-trIE . F;f; . F-nFIfr^1ffi
FE, trIF.EEEHffi
I RH-fE Htr' EFt ftEfr F Hin+ ffiz\E tr 2+ F'.1
ff E{EFf,FEfr^]EIE.
_tffiH'!HE" ..'...Eg f'.]Htr EEtrF trtHE . """ E
fEfiHr4 ' mRH - {E+ g Hrnf'.1tF bfr, (fFFTtftil1{t{H ) -g + rff FT'fttr1il{.trr -HE
ft,19.€'m ' ftE {E
146
E+f,g/.;€F"lqFffiEEf','i4.f"lffifr"1fift+
fHlrjtf 'tffif!HEf[fffr-frlRl'+.4ffi-fi€l " I '* oI ' fEHT tr-id
E' ff tTF!'ttu X"Fn#rilft.tr t?F'!H fr.ffi.;# t ffifr!H E, ryIlF " EF Xfr#rHE r-ff{E+ffi/.ffiffEF
1re.illFf,ffi
t F -# r EH ff'lI X tr Y{ r tr F ,llF-[frta[rfi7n\wrfiffio ]48
EEEHffi-'tu('ffi1trfFA rfiH{Hrfiffi147 Ef#'
14e .
ieFfFtrhrt#ffi7trEft'.181ffi I Aia{EfiftSH'!ffith
F!r rc.Ar'(re.fl"IA++.z\+ F,tE ffifEfiHtq.]."2-
tfr?ffiJtF-+'tfr,iH
,i, Et0E H +nwt_#.,tr Rw.lF.+H+ tr fr,.]
* JJ, EHE,Hffi3fr ' TfETfiffiE I?.HH F,.]' EIMIER€'ExEIrF
Is,
rc?ft?ry€trIEr o ?ffifb+F3/. #Hfttrf'lFfiFE'E
Eflf! HA H!^H+ -{E Effi FU
E EFf} r tr H I H!TE.I
fft€Ft T Y{tr H E!tfrr.n' ffiqFffiY{itr
ie$i H ft +,1.ff.JIIF
,8.;#' EYff$EltrHffif[€-{E Aft ffiAIEtr Ftr MX T
E 6' EE #{eEEIrFttr*{H f+fHiEHfn+,1'r).{,NVT
F'.1
EllEiHF'.:f"lFE" E {[ E f+FnA, I tff.+F
ryH F + E, lE-]
+ ff IFf+n iHrF,H+f2fJ+*It1 H #t E, +f,fHi= +i {HE 145 Reality and Faith, p.320.

trc 4HFAE'Hffi' ({FF1fttrl{tlH)' H60-66.


142 r. .. 'ttrtrlF#TE-'fHffiA . &q[ffiEg+ ' tffiflH&E,\E'{EEFffiHlI .
,f'];E F,ffi F1]
H tr.D}h-I"I;HtrfrtrIH.fX' E ffi{EffiTfiA - ffiffial$ +' qFffiE g' E,fE I47 +{881ffi, Ff,r}'flME'i4.ffif"lffi- +f,Effiffi' trEff.lffiFE l=ffitn#& (H
Z EE * L#ru ft A " "' "' T trIroqFffi EEEHS IFJ-€4ffi ' -t6f.Fffi*"ArEFft A) ffiFfiffi.
#.tr'J++n " -t 4R ({fr4+) ' frr6s " ZE.9.RIRtFfrH. r+e EUf!Hffi . tnlilth?l+tll^4ffi ffiffi ' HFfiffrffi .
i43 lElt ' flro s " ffitr efif"]Ffiffi I . F, ( iFFl{ftfi .ft'{H
| 4s r fr H1ltrtFttr!fr,! Hfl +,1'fl.1€' )' i{ 60 .
1 4 4 fa l L 'H te ;s. rso EEEHffi' ({fFlftF.l{tfH) ' H66.

50
RW.rRwr4H'{tffie

ffi.A, tT+^H 2#,' A{H{AEEETITIF rcHHffiH E.


" EH'+ #HA+Fg/. tr!E-
ffi{trH ffiiHft'!,84N A +fr,trfr.fr.
H E T#ffi , HH
fE+Effi.ft;F,E ftft.fr!;H +ffi, IMTWTfr.ffi
FTEtr.HEfr H fi,.]tr ;FT'E f6fu.[ff I trEJ;frAF
* H # 1,ffifr!E '1HEEE -iFI
- ;fir X fr1i*', Wffi& | Fsflfttr fi!f"lfE
t ' ffi€4fi!E ' rc,H|tLffiEHTRffiAVIMIWGfr.,
tr+frieF"] H' "' "' + +R E i,ffi F.rflffft
e ff 4lJ {Hffitr
lE' Eltf,' EE {F+fi,ff1tr ntr-
;FIF'.1 )l E t o t5l

tr ({ftr E H ) E !Fff
frefr\ffi tk -#r , (rnF l; H; f t t r #EgE=
afrz t +' EEEHffitr+*+fttr |Wtr;f;;Etgffi,tHfrZ
)Fffi#nfrrt#g
W.trrRffi
Htr
o "" "Htr EtnlEft.-tffi 2+
(Daswirktiche) . EE-tffi
DlkffiFrt ffi " I "' WIft' tr;f;fi!EF ++trtt$sEtffi E ffiff EEE Hffi fHEE { A W}FR #'.fi!E tr W.,8. fS
ffiffifE,I h.TEHEF TETA, ffiE W)FR#'.H,.]
tr F,Iffi E
zEftffiF + ffiHffiE, Yttr ;fifl'.]H#+ +trffi.*.# tr y{
tr ;f;AFE E Fit. ffiF /. ' ff.F 9q/. ' /.9q^ffi
In1ttr. )\2 F"liFi EW,Rffi#ffF'l(l-at+9ffi)-gF'lfEfEff,FE " Erft
ef!ffiffi r + + ztkr ' EIIEF ffi ;,{ H r ;E,H 'g { fi
xtrlF El "
{flFfrfFP frl#krrfl
ffiFl'[,H'eE F H W*.{fr+ f,l-{E A
EEEHffi fr.+*TXF;.{ffi (Ft + gffi ) -g +'
F'.1 Iss'
HK#r EIft , ft,EffiH eFn€ffi.ff.J . F HIfl
r&ffi t1WX H 'tfrf.lfr.E
EEb)J E tr ;frH thhflft Y{F E A n'.1IrlF w +.ft ff;ttr* *EHfrH ffifnE *f ad# /. #Hrfr*.fvE fE,
tr#H F!+frffi.
trertnyttr .
Effi Ifr,WfrSmf[ffi R E_iFfe,ffist3rrE,[,ss##I \
rEfHtrIffi#t - l-+i,4+.H,r-.#t- l-EE#ffifr!
,,fr rffiEHffiflAt - rlEWfrfrtFfr'll) Is4#tj*
kT th-wftE{EU.FfrlfEE .

ll-rl l " l l . ' H i ' 2 6 ' 1 2 7 " E€ ffi.ffilRX,F ftH " t s g E E E F f f,i ( F t $ € ffi ) ,H r .
15 : l l l l l l i t ' i f t l r i ,( f i i h I EF /) ' H3 1 3 . rsa lEt , flz-a "
{t+Hry
ffiW,IRWtrH , lffiEH - )FffiW.f.1+g#fflR€Hffi#
)FKW.WEtrW. l

/. ffirft lfli-a:-
E )\ffi ffiF F!Efs +, nEHl?.HWF-'ft F{r+f!q t+mtrrft^H HrAE n'.1'Ff,E -#,, hEEffitt
, iEHftEEtr
FlSiEtfi"ffiffl4 EfrXr+XHEt/.trl IHDeus^
XAlsFJt*t&TE E.9. "r "'HfE*fifrlFEEtr'ffi+.' ffn& exmachinalsT , H\,1HA
' ,X,#,tfr, #fu fU/\frTffiJffiAeffih
HF+F'lmfEEi+ 2+ ' E,-m-i*+Eie{f5 *#-'aK,HX rl
tr*+gtr @ffifitfit+tr8[+Hrt , ElJlt, IFm-ffiDeusex
""
machinafi'ltffi E Fi T & #,ffi o rss
RH trf€r'JE{EtrtlfrtffilEJE+F HIAfr"l/., n*
{FH E fr"lg{E 4.fF'' fi ffi#ft. ffitr!f"lFEf[ E+trffi-{E E trMAfFE 7 -IH^ffiiFtrIF+{t ' EEtr AIU,F,.]ffi
)'. , t HE
rHfr'.] tr E-aK;##IJffi.fr-WRH!F l-fu" ;/'.++Hfi' l-^ffilF I ifi Zi{t #*n + +'ft tr {Arc,+F ryFn-'a$,
.iFT ^
ffitr! rtffi E.ni' mEtffilfr.ffiE\TLXF4yfi tr!f;EH
ff , TN+F.Tr,IE SiE"]F A Ffiffi E tr.TE.,ftft €' +gT
A tr!& A +j\E' ifi H ft ffiXtrl'fH
lEl'fH'fEffi /. +.#H #tT 2r[' F[iF/.{f5 W+.if; |
EffiHTIAMfi,il7Rffi'14 t o
pFH'.1{Hffi' EEr'J,,t#-.t2H#ffi F tf/bHi' mE 8 H H ft , EEEHffiH# gtJEWfil,['g{Sff +' +Iffl ffiln
e E ff ft3f6F E tl- {E#KHi . E r'i f} ffi;frE + g w.Ew 8 { E/.n n F IH y{ t' ffi"l 1 5Le
f ih + & 7 ' f f if t f fi r "1 ffit-
Ef,,1.+.ft Ef+.H# fi'!- ffft{E/. m
tr!ffi+L' E E tf *13
*13 ffitrtrtTE'ffMYffil{r z 4Ftrlt&{-yEIE{tfdgffiHY{6fE
^ ffifE#[trfb/. fffi4F h?ffiJrFtu9
E' rftSffirEI ffie#' #KHi , E+fr7 lF n! /. ffi It ' yi iF fft l=o{fi ffi z<lEy.IV,H
|
ffiEFStF++tffiftEt ffifr.] tEft t Fftffi * E!ffiff fr/.F"l F Zffi fr'V'{tuX' iFff!ffi'f+tr',ttrTffiUf[H H S S . fiffff
156.E Tfr{fr.NBE')I
TFfr,.J I IfrA I ff!H ft frTR' ETEtr FT,ffi E"]tr
Hfi fS# . 4 FfE HE EHffi FN fEH tr"]I )F?ffiffiffi
ffsr ffia+k{fi+Ez\ frJ"
rtnffiffift1+F.Wffnfr tFts' Ef,JEtrH!+EH,HffifrHfl 8.1#,trtr -frm
El\ lFffiHtr+frH'+ElF fr.lrg fUEEfr,.ltr
frTffirc frx' ffi
ffi-Fff ' Ffr : P|*ffi
ffiffV#*ro H9trrF A H#fr.WH'T'['44x{t 7 | Ifr,At f+8 trlrk'lE'14' fl -
EEEHffi-'nK,ffiIEH+'ftE
r-fi ffifr!trf1r' /'{ru4H frffiE/. lFffiHfx+frH' Hff SFffi{# I+rtn^ffi{fr ffitft?fr
RWTfiIFffiffi +UWf[4#H#trl#ffiE. EIffi'
I&ffil"H{H fl' +*AT FJH+{tTlEuF,ffi.+'i{EF! | Ifr,AlE;ff "
r ffiE ftsfiffi*ffi,il17: ffia#FEEEEHffi-HEfi,L'ffl+fifie (Fi+#ffi )
( ffiH11Hf!ffil{E) stl7 #9F, fr. ffiI+gJ7ffitr'.lH# .
H /.f.lH
^n4?h , RW\4ffl/.tf-#tgT Lffi , (fr,
Aifr./'fFtrffi)J4'*z.H+ ifrtr rfiffi F'.1trf?
r tgF'!HE A ffiEEffi
Vt#rH, fr.
-ifr
TF ;#frrEffiLffi 2E - gftS ffiEE
E .

r55 lql I : o
' J = lz

1s6 f+ffii6 fftfr #4, D #fr1\ ffi{Hf E, - ft lFffitr+ + * Lffi +t{l1ffi# f! E g fr t # F! ts7 -ffi&ffirFJ#lF+HHlJ'tH#F, ffiUtj..H^+nftE$1ffi*$' lrHWiltfrE "
'tl.w,'- fr:tF.ifr' 7?/.,L.A #i ffiffi{Fi6 ffiR&E tl+.H, 4 F.ffiEHffi ffi r-4 g rsa EEEHffi, (ffi+€ffi) 'Frze "
3fir f-];frit t ((H-#H'ftH-ft€') ) '! 15eHeinrichon. ((H&E{E.f4r)'
lElHt'H.sz.

55
RW.IRffiffiH{tffiE jFffiWil1*Effi , (ffiw-F ' )F?W.ill#tr#.ff'JRfigffie
)

A HA ffiJffiE EilaE' T;ft E ffi E;E = E E tr.iFlffi;f;;E tr ill " l-f; W'Wf.lHfrfEI fHfr'.lErftr-{HE;FHF-
ft ffi ffi-E--I+# E"lH+{t ft,ffi7' ft ,L.f[,R,1' fflH+'ft( E T ffi E.D}Affi + frHtrIH #,ffitr+A ffi.+EE- {EFf,ffi trIM,
{t rtr-#,ifr,E
f6H+ f; W.+H WH+
{t ) fr,ft,tr"7 " fi'fruE-E A' E ffi E]')(TEWtrIE.f; ;Effir ffiq fr N IFffiMHH E f*
-{E ft,4.19H#W.H'!
fr ffiJ H+{t ' tEftffi /.'fHffiH TF EI ftEX' mTEF€- lHEffifr'.1W|+Ef* " ElJlL,tre.H#1
Ha^E. H RW.-FiH. FFiHE ffiS rt5tr-#Ite+EH E ffiFtE r ff + ^Efrg fl +F, #E FU *filfi + f€lFIt T H'!/. f6+F, E[flfrft,
ffi'\Iil tl /. ' F.''rfrl 9.H H 11E ,,FnD ) ' Hlt u { f 5 f f if lj -#
+Fe ff iFff.1fn n'.1Me' g {EIgfiSffiffi fr iFe H frM Flfi,
I Rffi.{tff!I HS {F ' mtr E |'t+ftHfEft,+T lEH!F E " 7 -fEq EFffiVlf,\ffi,ffifffi f,F' FtJEtrfrffi.
' m ffiffifr'.l,E
fn{HH {HillH 1eo0+!&,7-ffiEtr!E g W.W{€ ;#fr ffiry' F,.],8 Bf,I#, D}'gre f'J+FH,.]
ffiftrFTE.?.ffi B ++ffIIE
ffi " EE
I&frHtr!EE ffi | RW.{4ff'JHfr f€I " fi{f5fffffiEE Wtrl EH ffifl ff,ffiftff ' 4tlR E fE#ffi.tr1ftf; -
f#T H €' -,x9.
R E - tr #[ E Rffi.F,.:-fEfHfr ' & ;+E - fEtr iEffI{F ffi;ffiEfi#ffiHfr.W6 . fr[4/.irurgffiE{8fi#f#^ffi6 -
fr'{BE'fiR H F-E -E 'E fE fr,W i l lrH f r +t Ef t ' a T E g R W,#H F!* IfiJ X € *EIAI Z
EfxT' mTEefisE /.XFHft*E tr!-fEffifr-ff! fr g ffiiEFtffitEFtfl' /.{ruffirtu| D}frfr.Affifr #F.hft
H+ f! tr,it' ruRfi,fHEstj7'ffi.trTH fi w.glwFp'ffir'J 8 tfr,ffiffit ffi DlEg ftgtr!;f;eEIFH *ffi ffi Htr' f+/.^F
fb r F^trffi. t HqfrZItWWt,z'* EE^H trl{H{E ffffi7 ffiffiflf,+H) 162
" +HHtr!fi#ffiffiFE
4 B,Eg W.tr)FRW.trlH+ {t FnW++ fr E, ffiW4
ft.] TtrIffift,'&fr,Rtr.EEEHffi +R I RW.IffiAff.JIE,Sf Ig'
*Etr W.t*,a,^6 K # s' E A ffw.ftq6f;;Etr!ffiffiFH
ffi=Hft. BFffffiWfrtt++Wn-fr.
;# " r-9ftsfr'.1EEfiE++Hrffr.r4 Iwfiffi ' tf
, =;#
^4ffio 161
=4-#F'l+ FP.IF | ffiW. r , i. EHEHffi ffift-{E W.Wft.El=o &ffi ,
;il egff!+ F9. frtr trlE ,L'F!fn I ffi
-T,illft
iffiE tr { {ftff.]r F HH - fr.F'.1 + E'['4WnFfr.l+'mE A A[XEier-{;frtr]+,1.ffiffi " i&f'JI RW.t f!-#s H 0REE
E {Etr tT+trl?.H l+'l-'ltFg f,'l;EF T E E E /. trl;EE X# f f it r l+ + ' t f f - , H ft,Etr f' Jg l WH|RffiW.t ff.1
ffi .F .;{
ruH'.1, FnDlgftSfr!;f;--#IFffir ffi2E E{EHt+EE t ffiF a, Ifr,W tRW.r ffl#+ilF-|+-{El-fiffiff.lEf1rZffi
+ET H # ft1' ffi fEf+F"fi = FU E IfrH.sEg f; Frt^mfi W.fi!..E
r {EUF n'!'f+ /| ' H Itr' ff I-=. MtI4 ilTffif#frE/* E IFffi
f'Jfi trJffitr8 ' E tn.trA#,,tE Fl,-tfiffiH., ==,K.ffiE
f!' FtJE Efr\,l.8!fi;ff" EffiFATE-ffiilftj(gftS) EE
+B'.1tffi ^ B+' SH,e,*#trlEAffi'lH,
2= ffi.*.#+-trll#l+ EHffi f'!;frff +' E tr W.t frtr E ffif; W.fri^H {eRW.HIJ
= E ffi iHH,! ,RW 163 . EI
E DIE ifrAlfrg_fllKqB,ffit+i* F TEE
'WDlF-+.EHtrIHffi FfiFEE+F!ffiflt.'l+ A 2F"18W-'nH.Ifr'ft
F'l;frtrFttfil*BtW, Dlh.E++fr. ( (ffi,8e) ffi#) H'
roo EEEHffi, (Ft+9fl6) ,Htzt " 162 H enr i c hott.( ( H &f{Ef F) 'H at.

161 Heinrichott.(H#4'fEflJ) , (fift{E)


163 GerhardEbeling.
'lElnrl- 8127" 'Ftsa.

57
RW.IRTEffiH,{tiSE )FffiW.A\#gffi.' lffiw# - /F#ffi.W*tr#tr]RflHffi# )

+FnEffiftl rEg I=-MtZ<E t tr!


ffiffi., HeFEF.ffiffi. ;t f4f[ 4.if; U frft,e E]HE . E € '{trffi!+D}X , Lffi Ff
fr'.1
-{E;f sHfi+€. ^
gt ( Hf f iE r A- # )fr ,T Effi g Ef*- fEtffi 7 " AE
IEFN€'E TlW'H'.( 4;f E €'F-* ) ' A[ffiT HE ffi
?{fl' +FfrgH$Ffi,lATT€ffi ffiWFfi' ff Iff ' E H ItMTfrM
H rt tLfrqffi, ta.{t/.FtE )F?#kil1' E g #r.E{X|TEff 168
W{#f ffiEE,zt
w.' w ft,rL,ft/. FfE E g w.E ltltill' E fEw$EffiiHH tk
ft)F?W.l?ffsFnF-trff
Etr F'.1F"lffi'[A'JAFt il! 164
" {{84 - . I RW.t E'#.'nB,ffiffi h.trtml.FH!frtr flflffifti
E (EFIF) T = {H
(wordandFaith)?SFtE{EffiFE+EH tr{+ : r- frffi'ftYtmtgf! frEX=#, H-fiffi'rtrlW
ffffiil7frFl, /.+ # f! fr HX=#' mE ffiffifr tr Wffl''l- ffiA]|frg ftg
tr7Ainfi+Xtrllffiffi " I 16e
ffi- {HTfiFEE ' 4t1RR,W.TF E
Y.i;frfA8,.] ffi A H
= \ | ffiW.tffilEz\'f?EIFEf4' ffiftiMffiWby.EA
( E*"fr& fE^HIfrRW.)illrf #rE,z ffi-{E rfiffiEft , # E f f liE f f i' t E+ x' F *tr /.{ F l ffi fT F H ' ffr r l t,
ruR#,EE W.HK t f[ RW.^ffi EE,ilsEtrffirnf,]& r f; W,+THTEW# F!H#,{lEtTN#E'}ft E tr E illafrX
W.ilTtrtittT #-ftrntr,Rktr'lE+FfirEz H'EE EHffi ffif; .FFFEffi ? E+fr,E* , +fi,{f1=dfr.FfrE/i*, lE{SEfrftftAtffi
7 gfisW'Hil ' Elft.WgftsglH;Rifi 170
W.trtfr4ffiffiWK.W #fr-ffiZtfi," t ' rmffite&+fref;EttrLSiEf;*{'H
T fHtr+, ilswg.f$H#[E trtr 8 g W.il1ffi fr-t ffiX.E+ F trlffiffi + E +.fl.J" mH g'fiXE E L4.yfrtr!+,1'+Effil+.
[E? E€fi7ffi= {ET"1FE I7I
' ffItIfrIF_trEF,.]g#9il1-H ,r\.fr! " I

#t z wEr t&H;Rffi lF.HW.LffiW.W9l& ? 'o' E . A rffiffi..rE!ffiHilt' lffiW.ElFE-{E l-fr[


-#fn{r:ffiEy.{HfF!F"lffixEffiEHffiEy{trl I R ft A!t$.EFfi
t, fF {HH!{x,*lFtHffiF r ffitr!ffiffi :
'1''l'E4 Ifr,E+-fr + ffitk-+tg H ffiill | )F
W.t Fn+frffi -#frg
I RW.,E|fr.J/.Ff r t^ffi ' ru,{ffi*Effi7 Fn;j?ffii*.T
RW.{T#-tr W.t H It Mtr+XillBfim' HZWr^H'!ffiffi' 4E IFffi/.fFkFf..r+f!{ftfritr@XH
IRffit lfr.-rtH- ,-*[J0frffifift,,\ffi WrAeff!' ffi 'q-A' ft€Efr f'lftl#X.nn*,ffif'l +.Bfr*
'F-
r
f ffi ' IEI&t+HfiF W,-tX, E-ffqffi/.ffiS J 172, lE
ffiXHFnu\.ffi , n?Hh{ft.ilSltrotusexmachina"
ffitftHftfr
r E +.
ffiH+' ft{rufffffi t'ffi I frlHtr E IEruXM+fr.ffi
166' 167 IE J-L ' I{167 .
ifr ' UXft&X*f&ffi t . rl{Pl-a(m,lTHLffi ' 168 l E l t ' Frz6 .
roy ltrl-I ' Jtr lJl o

164 Et' F tss-tso. rzo l E Jt ' Fl 28 .


ros lE J t ' F r 3 7 - 1 3 8. rzr l E It ' H 164 .
roo E E E F f f i , ( , A t + € f f i ) ' Hr ss . 172 H L, H r28 "
#w.rRw4H{tffie . (ffiWH - )FRW.trlEtr#ff,JRfrHffi#
AFffiW.ftlEE#. )

( ffi^ifr g ) qfr.+tffi
w rHryr.ltrt1ffiB'.1
i+H vffitr. a ffir&fH E H*Rnn fr zth , t HE
zffifr {EH+,zffiE\,fr.E +Elfr.tFffi
,fF' +EtffilFffi-{Etffi ffiffiFE' H *ffi ffifn,fF5fnffi fl -{E#L*ff Zffi,if;" -r 177
TE ' EEf'I+illffi# " Elffi^nffiffiEn-T4#4.rytfr. A. IRffi I IF H - ffi M Effi T {F ffi F !AF N f[H ,
t+thru+ftru8 ' EFtHffi# , Iirf#{H+8tffiffi FtT-{E t tr tr?,84frfif,7,8,fr ffi ffi *Iffi,ffi# t&ft.# fr EE " fr.
fitrH,!RE " I&el#.t+.1h.ruffi
+ffi ruE' m4 & *.,, ftfrft =#,'
FTE T{B ffi trI E F[flj H RffiIF ffiiEffi iE{Efr F E!
Effiilltkfffi.ZF.r 173 , r (f'JfliE{tft€/.flRW. IR : IIEtr LPEIVIUEHj ' EWE -{ET'fEiFflEF
ffi ) ftEtffi gfi 7 w +.ifrffiffif! rfi6' f{4.if; f.],iF'['ffi tr!+1tr4Wt ffiffiv-W" ElJtr, L'Z,rE+*.Hf$-{ETl=-
o ....--+rBhlfr,
frn'ffixillffiix. ( rE{t/. ) fr!ffi-fi i* ' E lFtrltrFW+.tfr2+' TF ;ttH H ft W.tTHgfr*ffi #tr
Hie#EA, ltrfrH#FnHE&ffiffi . ffi*rtn'ttuX , RT f.lT{ElH,fr"AlH*tIV,E " -t 178
, f +friru/*TFEffi
+E8 Rffifr.*fig1II
H E {Etr N-WTE IFfr!++.H' fHE StJ
fi . A ttr ,#k r H !frE E X 'E ef {E{ I T J A f f iW B k EZF . r I7e

F!EF,fr ffiffii\tew.F!{E fr&lt *,a ffiM{;u,,f E HE^HfiffiTft,aE^1ffifiruffihtfr "o ' Irltl EEIEEE
^lu.,
H ffi Efi,1.trlE HfiT {H{gtr ft/. XF4{'4q f; W.gi?rf, Ifr ' fr,
ffitkt H4HaFJ-{E /.-#;ftrffi .. ...tr m' ffiR E-Rfi T{H{HE#€ I==Mt ,
frft #.Ytfrf ffi'BX M,+frirt.* , ffi
I?.HIffiET'4t]R-,fE A T FFH E E\iE$]+ TEHH N frW W.ef;gEI RI|.,t 7 trlEMt' Eg I=-{fiffi Fffi ffif!EE
, lfr,ill|Hffi^H
-tffi, Hfrft{R,m , (frfr'lyfr )J^HH11frfftis, Rffiil7ffIiI, tr JIL' € HfiE.Y.IfrIA{Efr tr-Jffi= {EIT"1 FE'
4rR - {E/. T F,F H +Ec=- tn FtffiE ll1{ F Fnfrffl F tr' ffftr{EFlffittrltrn- , ffMt EtrEfflgftgWA-;R ' E
ffisM,1firyXfr,FtHffit#7 . ) I7s, r *nRffitffi+fr. f f i+ f r ( , F i+ 9 ffi ) + ;d tr tr !r e 4 4 4 a E3 0El' 5 ,8s El
uf r7 tr# , g tr 7/. +.trl a+f'l -ffi ' #t w, L f r u u +frAEEE ffi{=+ "
8rc ffi # h ,E'}W E n{E i l /.f!l- FroE f t ' , J 4 . if' r 1
F[fA4 i6 tr']iFIp.].,lF.-W
Lffi ' mEL, F'fitr €{E/.fi[E H -
fHf/^y'.F'.1 y'.iHtfg-a8ffi
ftEtqj.,' )',E r-F.fit'Etr ffiWedE
ff.J" ,1,HHhHlffi)\t frEWf,XM"' E#gffi,1tE{t
fi'.]fH+F,mffi t7tfr,. -t
+-V7l+lffi 176, r Wie4ffi-{Ey'.tl€' r77 F!L ' Frzl .
128 l E It , F18o "
rzg l E t ' H r82 .
rz 3 l E l t ' F l 4 s " tso i e4fl fr.1ffi ffi 447ttE f F' !+ S +' t{ H .f fl ffi ffrE ffi R ffi tr#ffi ,4* Gerhard
rr4 H L ' F r o z . Eberring'(EF'fE) ' lElfif' Htae-tso " $++ffittfit It r*#.t ffi.fr,{1+gflffiI!,
HIF,S . r - ffifitEill' 2 - {E/1+#ffi , s . {ffi_Rff! ; 4 . Deusexmachina (f€'++
175 l E J t ' H r a z .
ft1fret!ffi W)' s . ^E E ffi E (,K 46^1ffi { +o' . * rl frtffi W ftl ^, t - R #.ft.4H 4
iz o l E J t ' F r z o .
ffiff! , 4fuu"inrichott. (HAF{F{fl) ' Frss , l+24 "

61
ffiw.rRI.EwH{tffi€ nfiHffi# )
)F##.ffiE{g#., lffiw€ - /FRW.il]E*tr#V't

m= frff. )F##kfrrtH
€fffi.trlHtr fr IAT+E il1fr #Ire.fF4L#.EEHE ffi EEfrIfr iT, ( EIIffi,fI
? E E) ' M f TFfi]J@/fr e ffi € fr H XE,4
"' *
r-Tffi 'ffiffiE+kEff
H tr!FfiffiE, +X.' f'Jflir5*ffi
I I M EEHffi.' EE ITME E H z I
181 H fL ETE , HE fr E LH FI,frTA++E 8,.]
E H ffi Ttr- E
fr t t+E fifitr yL+Efr
+, IEfrttrfr t* t lfr,-a{ffi T ffif+{E
EEEHffi frIftHFT+Etr ffi Tfiffi fr!fff$I -#T, .HIIR' EJEifi IgH ft,E ffi # . FND}t+EH
flHIEWilTF"l
FE
T E F E irfi/'ffi trlFtHrEfE' it -Eltr ffi*-E€ts E fn#tJ interpretation), DllW#Hf'J
7 )FKW.ilTffiffi (non-religious
-{EE {*ffir+fr'.]flr# ' mfr+Rf]\^TFffiFrffiF'lfts
. E*+A$JffifEWtr+Ftt- frf t+ fflE *f -nd;fr
tu1ffi H+Wft'fE/. + # tt f! rfi lffi " "'
ffi lE-J
ffiE4['l-"]trtBR,F!
F.D}N.E++ffiEJtrg "
w.il1ffi-{E+F ryX (mE,fh#E{UtrEi+tfrlFtr) ,
E.W{EFfiFEf+fUE - D tr.]HflAzHT' trH'#,1ffi.1+ffifT
EEftffi,rrfflH;H
IEIfr,ffi ry#,tr{t 7 Rffitrl{fuE' EFFtr
ffiT{'H' ffiEfl+fi{HFJf+Xts* E, tgfr.ED}ltfi]++
ffituq
t'Effi ' t WM+*9.8.,9-Wbt.#tr1"""Wz...fr"]H;H
€ H+ffiE^1+ H FIFi2 L, mT E i+ -wEHffi+fr*ft'.1ffi E
ttz ryffi ' E{[ lfrEfrelffit]tfr + Fnffffi tr t:n,'fi+fi7 -fE Ef,
wryl "
f#E Itr:ffii*HU,W&7 ],&ffi4 g E fi A q mWnffifn iffiF'.1
Effi ttrtfr i t€-t ' l -X ffi r ' r{E y ' . + # r S H+nfi^14*ffim. , tff.m{H{U+ t}6A#FIEffr#iH " ffi
I Rffi.r f!ffiffi#[TEEEEHffiFftRqffiE! , Ifr.m,L.frl € Hx{t 7 f; W.Wtfr{-u ( F[ffig ftS#t€ il1tr H M=#,tr] fll
iij
E H4 H # +, /. fflHtrfr g frg€-in fHEfr'!FfiFE" t ffi ,
f# ) {EaF !fr.t+trt+ I&FHfttr,a ^
H ' +8trn-wf#71tu4
2A qAF,.lfHE' EEHEHffiffiTEE{EFf,ffiWTX tto
lti
tl
rl Hfi" "' EH'IAXH, E "Etft,ef# J .
{t;frE '
ttr.HEEH tr Tfr#,, Ifr.F.f{g ++,Kffi + f!
ffi F,!f,qH ffiN
(-'drtglfrt ffiqVrf,ft(*f ft!) *lFifrI?,ffiffiI) + *fiE #ft+.# fr!*lsln, m I frElF#k#,{<fft.F'! - fkl+., frifiY
X' fl ViEi*T fr.ffi*.&tr/.-'nKffiiefr f+;tiE7' mE
-iflffiitft f+E TfrJE " T11E " "' lF;=fr tr!ffiAfi f"lffi ' E ;t f"1ffi )811H+tf! + ;ff " E e E ffi ffi++E tr!EFA€# a{
frilHE€'&tfirRffi.ftl t ffiA+Hfr,FtF"lffi " Elufrt ffi E ++fI E fFI?.Htr E Tfr,TLffiffiffi
ryffi 4 H F"1 FEN,!iH9F
++E -#ffifi'.]ffi
t#, IiTTEHE+Et ffiil6 ffi,,'rFf,
' {E{fi6F FnE ' EEEHffi-aKffi fr+ ++E E#tJT Ef+,E,fg+ F'.1'fX+
,I,AEH?$EJE r)FRW.tF'.1H#t' fr1fr#f[tflAm{fi-4. .---.ffi:

rsr EEEHffi' (,at+€ffi) ,Htzz " rsa E E €Fffi , (H +€ ffi ) ' F130.
182lFJt' Hrrz " ott ((H4fri={41) ' Hsg "
r 85 Heinrich
rss Et!,EfEEHffi,KfFf,!A&fffi fEHF,L.ffir F!-{EgtEf rt " ra6 E E trFffi ' (ffi +e ffi ) ' Frs t-rs z .

63
RW.TRW^ffiH{t+Se )F?#fr1atr W., lm ZqH - jFffiffif.]Hg ffifll ^trffi ffit{ )

E++E ffi {Effiffii+# E{#,8 E6,B4 VlA . fiff fEffiEf'.Rfntr!fr9f+EET fil'ffi.E


F'.1tr
tr FnE'*' /. 11!
ffilfr,lh+E FtJ ;ff ' {E{UE E FU7 Wr\ffi H-iH+
H WFEftf; HE f[.R#TEH {fi ' mEH'+e*r.s.I+ft.]trF,['4E-glB
# EffrHr=H.#AH LI9E-tfr'r?ffi " ttz
, LHtFtHSHtrlH+'fF t F-_FEFH'.1" +frA2, | )F.R
t ffi#tr:J^E
ffi.illtuYffi #Eftf'Jt ffi;f;;Etr!ffiffiTlre.Efr.
fHY{m-a , frtfr++q E.l| ffi+F]fr1 (Demythologizing )
A (FfrHHEfi'l{E/.) frW*IEffi , frT'rtr.+fr*WftE
E r f f i EE rf r ! " E IIE H ffi -'n K ,ffi i $ e {l R*EH1ff' l' ffE
, T+tV".
(trtfrifHfrE^]ffi4 ) XJEffi,firEff #EWa.H ( Dt
HH ff.J' lh7{EfrHtrltEfi4f"lFEf[-Lffiil1$rrt$
qFffi4g m +,L.WHE ) flliFtFfrTsrEffi"
IffiITF'.Itf tTL+W . Ifr-a{ffi fr t f+ E E El7 E t+ ffl l3F ftU'
{Exfft H H +#+frryffJfrH-#WT Ef+ . 18866ERffi;fl fitrft Et+ E ftSE ft 7 t ffiEtr H Dlh.)\ffi t' ffi H"l
H' lF;f;f,.lE*ffi F IRW' Etm*fr{fitrmffiZ<EtrHtr #E+fr.t RW.F!tf&2f"1F'!trFlJ ^ IEfr.Fn;HF"l
" 'o' I WrI\
Fffil+i=f;rf&.' mEffi;f;FtE+'['H+H o ]8efr+ t+E H ;€# l (Revelat ional
Posit ivismI)*. t 88Ff f '
F EEEHffi EE,L.fr.J F"lffiTRfHIU , AISE Y{g ftqE;E E.TH Y{f! ^m. f; WVII E *-ffi /. *#,, ITFIHA E fi H H
F+{t ff.1 rEffirtn-#ff+, IEIfr,{r5 ffi T lEzffiE fb H # Hfifr tuq EFUtrIRE, #[TE ffiE I+ilff! ffiF E SF,.:. TfiFEH,tr
E , f r f + + E i f € 'g +++f g fr'l H +{'4 'mEf+ Ff,FE.ftft!
f r , 8 - { E ) F R W.Wtr F + , W.€ tr !H # E{ tM? i F .H
ffivffitr-Faillffi+F' {Eil/.BEf}Htrf.lrEffiffi,ffi1+e*{+ ffiW.' FFlqH ff't e f[ ffi{4+ + B"] E HE*+ 9-id*ErWfr1
I+W+ F Wf',,1.,ff ff . E&FJIEEE EHffi fEH trI I ffiW HfrfEI*l+ ' +i'fFl lr fHIFfffit. ffi xE,? fi{f: ruInlD}E{Atrlfr
{S.i trl--{E#rE , RW.'WF'I,,\.ffi,,! +-trfr*I?,, D}W.ftffi rt#;fftffiEE ? 'n'
t f fi E# *I Y " Wm' Y {E H E H ffi mE ' r/. +tr 1&fr &t
E X, ffifiH ;H+ # t?.HWi*,i6# H {H
fftE F9;fr
4 H H nEEH!H # ' /. ff.Jrt aH26 Fnffi /. fi'.1 En- E ffi t).
-# EgffiH-inF'.1&Mfls(nDlF-&ffifgH " nfi' EfEFfr
ffii^f'.1Ffiffi ' f;At ffi fr -ffi 21fr,8f+t ffi fiY.tr,,tXF4
D/ftrt{E r-ffi Ztfi,t 4
E rx-f6la /iqfr! +EH X ff.J'E E 6 Ftffi7 -fEI+*k
H FrJ
ftH^inZtT ' m/.f'.iTnEft_l+.E
ill, TEIgH'!*ff{#{f i EfEffiF,.fi A EHEHffi EX' E
+i
++EiF R W.WfrtT+ 7 t ffi q /t Wft tr 2f"1fi!qtr
W " fr,F++EtrlrF4ffiif;rffi##fr'\EEHEHffiEKffif' -sU,4
#' fftF{fr.#A H#E, tlflffi€*7 .
t ffitr Ffrft.J,e,*#
ffiH' /.ff.JHtr VtnEff {$F"lffi' Ftffi7'ttrA Hffiffiil1+8*{
ffi#tr! - {E/. GE fr'.]tr H{+ F"lFE. {Bff f} EEEH m ' E
reo EI46yffi = Hffift R.fi *ll,(,lH!ffiiE .
1e1 Ar, E ++#E\RW.E pFf! Ffr
E ffiHE r fi {r:ffift+ft,{nFfr
4fr.f1' ffiE €TE fi f! ft /fl
1 8 ? l E l f- , H tzt " t r E t r ! H H 'f f i EH ttttr H 'l EH . r +. E++# '# f,H € ;+' ( ffi ,Fe ffi # ) ( E
188 Heinrichon (H]T4'fE'ft|]) ' F114. - # a t r # Y l L f f i nFfi r e e s) ' fr a o 8.
'
r 8 e (F i +9 ffi ) ' fl rsz " 1s2 EEEFffi' (Et+#ffi) ,Htzz "
RffitilfrffiH{tffiE , lffiwF , )FRffiWEtrW.f.1RfiHffi#
1F#W.ffiEEW. )

frft+frTilh ffi 7 EEEHffiff E ffifEffitr+f fr ff.J


E]trH' {e€E +*I Lffi E ftSFlffittr E E' mir
01+..Til1trrE
FfiFET&f! EE EH ffi€' I?.HlR+ H F,.:;+ iH7 E MfE,Bffi T-;Kffifl+/. {f5tr'lf RqfEE tr €' trl+-H flfttuq€ H-fi' E fL
Ftt ' mEi6lEieY'JTEtrtit$ffiffififr{Ffrfr'.1;+lH ' Ifrt'g' r"1f'Jf' r ffi xifr.E {Effi tTT F ffi F t ffi f.]H # E
x E p"1 ie a H FfrFffi tnF^] -#
rf,ffi " i&ffi FEE+*ltF.H "ffiffi
E ItM t'fES{f$-fEED}^A++F.g{EtrFF-ftE ' ftj)S++
gs l+wHtrw\ffiw"
ffiwFfr. + 4 BF
WfrrJ
$$rfiJ HA# E ifi {FAHH-R" EIJtr' ETEfEH trIffi{AI?,fr.T{H
ffiffiffi ' E E E -{E T ft,+.H# t F'llfr.W.ffi
IHI,B.-'{JffiE
HHEHffi F-E ft-{E/.{fSTHfHI=o tffi ' l?.HffiW. ff.ltffi+' f'Jf'+E€fflrEffiwE & yt'az€w fr E, . 16l
ff!H+'ft' Egtr] 'H;nHffiZItM z ifi.frlF.€ffiHtre.+fr F+' EIlEHffi FfiEf,,1.fr'.]it T E ruf'l ffi Htr'1ft.€+t- IH?-
fidffiffi- tr fUft ff WffiH'!
/. {FFt+ffi ' E,Eo WE ,,t'fHg +.ffiFN'ffiE4lfiItrEg E E{EfrN-H. =h,HHA FE
FU U X ru* ffirEE {EH tTtr!ff ;#fr 6 fSm ffirF- {Er ffi {EUfrV1#Htr ' m-Att-'ft+E{8trt1*ft8 Ifr " Eff ' HEE
E'!,fH#'ffi;fr8tr+.ftffifrffi'EEPffittnt ff.JFE" Hffi ={J,ffiXW.ft FU7 E fr'.]#flE, Etr W.ffiF ffi- tfrX1#
mruft)F H E Wffi€ ffi 14ffi.t1fr i* * ffirEEl}rffi.in, +E wt1tr"i\*ffif+ . EE (Fi+gffi ),8 ffiffiEHfi' {t,ffi
7,q/.,fruyfr ffiil1ffi.w,* n ffi.^{HfH,f= {e{ruTFEFtrhw E tr E f! ffiU A ffiffiT,X*fi.]rsWil1ft,i*t*{+' i&g f+
EEEHE' ++t +.fr + {eiHffii*XH.WWfiFirl' ffiH Jttftft ffi{HfvTff.lt ffi , D}fdfrtff&' E frA q[ffi49 + RFlE,
fr IEEtr!ER " Ifr='nKffi ETE D)#gH +,1'Wfr l-fu' m A H WA' MZ<EHS&T,X'F f.]ffiffiEffif;gTtr
" EHEH
tr fi/.H4.Hx#,&ETA+ffV ' ffiFfHffi97, A#-tE r-t ffieYEffiry t' IEieHffi4
+g w.'##\##{trnzffi+FnlF F^]++ry ' fi;frffits' WAISWH WtXF'!{=lilt, Etr Il\ft E it E fStrl+,1. . H {t'
, =
ft,frnt+F tFfr! ' ts /.ft4 H+fr\ m E 1FEEW.W. f
zFND}ZKT+*iF ' EEffifr{'N,ER , E,@EAE+g-{E *LtrIEgiF lvfr?ffiJE.Itrtr .
RGFTffiE]FE
Ft+ Lfii..EFU't'+H+{t*, "FftEffi ' A H !fr.tr{&FHbtr nHE LffiH'tfl' mTEfr.Vffib+erurufE/t+.#W.
S H-L 'TE{&F H Fl Ftr , +E E+E E ffD E + Ht E T E
# + ,tHE# " E ,Wfni ruE E E ffi *trffi F5'
mW+fr.H J
2+ " ZFnD)fr4F+ff'J
EFfiffifi"lf"1FE ' 8EIffitr,+flE .
E ?E#ff++.4HEttrt+i* - F?.ffiH
- FEi;ftillE{ErttE
ffii - ttyLffiFnTffffiE fr!, fr.JFH /.{HH E H HttE (worrdliness)€Flf," &?EE+ , EtrtT2LA ,+fr.-'rK,ffi
fr.trlE r'!ma H fuH /. F'.1+i
44" LFnD)fr)F+9wil1, Flt4ffiia{EUF mEE - fnTE fftH H ilxE'!- E;plifir
E tr ffi+ g 4 Lifi.+frFtT)\ffi fi W'W+ H"l -'fE ++E lPf fr! - {frrEtF
ryffir)t/.ffi+,1.ff!H#rffi ffl' mft.rc.rffi
T+i*,. ,,'
FA' FFA Ffi8,.1
re3 E t ' F1s4 .

67
.
ffiw:tRw4H{t1fi€ ' (ffiEH JFffiW.ffi+trW.WRHHffi#
)FRW,ft1EtrW. )

fl tr Dlh.q[ffiE g E'.]
E FtA H - + +* 9.frilR'{F.y6
tr'{E t r + + Nt ' IF EEEH ffi t\HEE e # ffi fr H ff' J
# : [ -_E' lFW# L 2F., ntrEt-ffifr'.]
,e,* t|+{t +n{f5
ftEHEHffiFf#,ill r-Ftffit
ft!frfTI ?S' Htrffi.tFffi eHgft1# ' m€frE++HH'!fftJ ffi28+I#.--nR;# ' :E '
FfrH/.XFW#W+ft
)FRW.illMfr"EEisF'!E ftu' Ef'Jfr!f"1 i-e + +R + wffifrltF F,,tr,r1Efiiru H H H E tr!++
1e5 HH+IHT+#.HE ") lee
++NtH'.1ffifil[EEEHm='
ffiEE++t-f'.1 H ftffi# (self-justification) ' EEEH
ffiA (,at+9ffi) +-E E.+EHfr!^ffi*frrfiffiEE Ifr1e6 , H'.1
H |,fr.Fl,*Httr tTH'+ H'.1 ft1fi tfrI:
/. {ruIEffi ffiffi fET IEJ
^I H ++#mffi E' Affim^ffi,++H (cross withoutwordor
Ie4 H € fi! F"lA ffiE ft HEE/t {r5g{*filfi E'Elfr?H&ffi-#
wordwithour
cross)I " '* H++4m^mEF'!ffiHfiXEf! E+n
ffi , E fE-#ffi W*frW.W. @Dlh.I=.tft.y{f; ffi.^FH
I=-MrEE{fi H!
-iK;#Htr+*fr!ffiw " EHEHffiEX' r/| +fltffi9? +Rtr!E+E,friK.+ntffiFffiftlE€il....?ffi7r ,&c={E I Fi
. I mAt f f ig ? t r t F r+ EY{ t# - t F n ffi Xffi F f,ffi H + ' F ft7 tr
/-{HftEZffiffi+Feffim -. ' Ff,EIE/ffitrlMA
-fffit' | *frHffi '{fr, ++FtJE)FI=-',rft#f\fr?ffiJ+*pWfi =t ' ffiE'Em,-ft^ ++
ft'!......
ffi-fr'.ltrEtlEft, EHf,.!+'
E+EIEEA#+++'mfr*frft!+'
FUE++NEe# R F,.1ffiE ilEfr!E+F.;fr;E# H , D}EffH FE+ +*F^] 6f;FT
201
T ttrffiillW.I*t " =ffifEEE{fitr]#streErf-lBfrtr
j6lE?rflfttffitr,,\#FfrEz
IEIE" t 'n' EHEHffi-'aK.ffi'
tllxi )F#ffi.trl#gW.Fn Ffi4/^trln&F"lFE .
f"lEH | ffil6r F ++HFfrE+tfr'.lEE Ifr , 4tH H ++*
tr!,8,
ffi{Fffi lfrF^] Mfr E E--fEnfrft,tr FtJ,Xh Jfn
- fE,E, EE E Hffi Fnffiffffir"1 fE, tff.++N# HH # V1'iffi
ft , rc.ffii{*;{iU
fr {eIY+ ilI I RW.r ffift tre.Tlalfr
EX# E]'DT+TFU WffiF,.]Zi I_E] H " F,H {t # T A XFF"]Eg fr"]8
I-fu
EEtrl t)FRW.il1EtrW.t o te8 F-|1ffiFTffiTRH'A {fitFEH 4HF frE+NiH H E fr'']
++
1e4lEJt' Hr3l . NilI A # " E EEH ffi F N ffi HTf!) F # ,ffi WEtr ffi :F E
1e5 | t ffi lrA+lfi.HE ?fi+EHE'fEfrtF, bfr.W t T + +* " t##E IWff. t ftVl.d+ffi
ffi)1 rnffi' EEfn{ffiffi+il188fi fr ' fff{E/.trf'Jtffi H+'
6! ' m,sEE ElLh?frJffitillllE#trHErfllf5f-lFrt ' ffi-ffi,Frt . r lElt , Htzz .
1e6 rftfl!,B,tHfr1Hts{U*ru*ru#ff€frlgf,g ' €T6{+ ' AE*+E{EE+ ' fn#€fi'! fiSUEAHfi'.]f;#t#. EfE^ffirrc.Ar fHEf.lfif;ffi ,ffil#.
fr74w.tr#ffi*18*" _t rtrFfE{UA (€ft'!) +EEtrrfi7\ '4EfEH#r'ft
lll UE t{1ffi+ffi 4 ffi*f fr!f}ft H fSJr,}' " r, r +*,8tr + R.E'fEf"lffi , +},ff1rt
[i]h7ffi tr r fi ffiff.]ffF r ts,ffiI Lffi tr!)',Ffr+$Etr!+
+HE.ilfr
U rE{EEFf.lr tril-Ep&. (€filgfig) ffiH#fr (fgm?EE) HtH.ffitaffiil....? ,
H#t - *A*n@f+ffi'lE' {E{4' fE# . Es . 4'ftSSffiA . r r#fi{P1*E ffifiY.,ia€#..frfr.t.,l.fiff " EIJIL EEg-Hffif!
E.il1fififfi
ffift ft ffift E ft!ff!,B4 rE " H H leF-frR #4 - t#, & Kril,rtr UIT ft - tfiffib W*ktr! D]#,8' {E/.Eff t ffi ' E 4H
RW." #H, 8trW.ffift1fi.+nffi-fg+&*h.t1?W. " {EE' ro4gE€frlr}EjffiX' fi
)FRffi.EtrW.trl Pyi6EI
fRffi#] ffifi'+4*ff.]ffiFf;*WH&E' ETE-{Eil^ffi#cE z I lEIt , H78, r28, ti*tr HfnGEf iEffl+,1. Fl,h"
i33 ' 164 .
l e 7 F lt ' H t8 8 "
re8 tfHf iEiE r'{+iIftlEEt fr7fttr-*E'{+HEE'HffiB!-'fEdl+frFt,-H. (E4{E) '
=-rKffirfr
H t 43- t 47' Heinrich.
ott E <HE ^ffi fAffi> + ffitfi4 EEE Fffi trlE E6T lEl' -F. 199 CharlesS. Anderson,(ffif,gtrl+*1F+) (Luther's theologyof the Cross ( FacetBooks)
( H f {='ftlr )' H 118- 1zo, IfF-HFJ++ * E f f,fHEEHf"hfE fgF'.1 g, q'
R7 1971) , H3 .
Historicalseries-17( Reformation) , FortressPress,Philadephia,
rcffi | + fr #.&tr #.-t A{;ftfr.:fteHfitt e-N}#tr ffi +,1'mr} ffi t ffi fl1#ffitr1ffiEH ffiE
,ffi=H ' prro-rrz " 200 l EIt ' v i i .
ffHBlflff't6pfi" H <<Hftq\l=.ffi>
201 l EJ t 'F 6 "
RW.IRTEftH{tffiry (##;E)
)F?ffi.ffieE#.'

: ,,\F!4FH#)
tfiSFB fflF H qFZ H *E{E H ffiiTTE _fE H ffi+ #4 A TJJTU
E#tr!+Hffrr" EH' t'ffiE H +IU+TE fr?ffiJH ie/.;ffi
Effi fr.tr- /L- t+FU IFillh FP( E + tlF A W#
s7 . fi,--'#.-#tffi, EEHEHffiEXfr,"Ffi
{ E) +H E, r.-....i t(E g) ffi y {fi {ff { & f t t wz f f ia f t ^n{{th?n*f
E 4[{'JE tr tfr,---#.-#/.
ffi H "
iEf.FHErtftiru ' Y{ ' E'8fr.+K{ffif* , Ifrffif+f+Flj^MHE ^
ffin . """.r fiJtHE(8ffifr.W#W.W> -B +,nffifU trJtr, EEE.Hffi '{Affitr!I )F?ffi.{l*trffi.I Effi H
r EffiHR gi\M E ffiflEffi. ...+.HI#I+W+.TfRAg IFE -ffrE r-fr Hfi' ETr)lf'Jz<
ffiffi.'Wffi E E#H' &
T lEE'.1ffi,ft ^*fr'l
E tH.2Ttr, Fl,H *ih.trlg{;f;
' 4 X t1E l3F
f} E
8ifr ( Eg ) rntr€ffiJftiH'ffiX?EF' lA,l'H
It -.-...{ff
^my'.ed-#ifr, " -t zozE.ffiHftHEEHffiffiEB-n${t' 4 E fi HHEHffi # IFtr!ffiIE').E.4tr H ZiIE# IF21fr+H
ffi fr wHfiit T -" ft, EIE ie,fru
a+Ifr{r5 F w #lsEf,J# tElft ftlFJifr , D]trffi.aE r4,E,FSr'lF6 +' /.{HFt'ffi ff E-f; ffl
trlrfiFE, ),.-.trn+trtF+ffi4FH# ' EIHE{4,ifi H ft tr Et&-at;fr /.+F+.frF"]HH'9€i# jF' m
ifi A FJEEEHffi trI,8.ffi F U F E ffiY+;f;E - fr ffi IFH ;fr
nnEF ffir":, *,,frl4nf*E Ifltg z
il " FtrD), H4| lFffiWV1Etrffi.t ,E'fFqeH ie,E'tFS f'l q
fi iH- tr E fEtfi#H llfs F!ifiF,iill F.;H/t . fi iruft FE,['4S{;trtrff $RrtJ-- .
FFt E f;giFlE7 A+e+ & & tr7m# . fi{ffiE ftS#!ffi 7 W.--nF
E ft , D}Eg ffi+,1'tr.],8 ffiE EEE-Hffi,E f58,.18Hfi
f[ {Fffi mE]fr'.];#E-f;
+9.fr" ftgm [fr.+fr,{ru
{'xFftltu/.' iFf} {r1
' 1#.Wt+-at,fE EEEHf | )FfW.UtEEW. t,E,,F,F
F ft 7 ffi H Efr tE.,H4 H +mffin+' E fF f n { r u E 6 iH ^ +,1'ftRW.ttH DlKtr!+ +H,B,F,F
. fi{1101ffH ftl il7E-ghfriE+ V7*fi
n,EantrT* HqFz {*,{flFfiffigffl' .
IHR HHEHffi tr!+ ++,E,F.H tr.ffi8.M7 WltE D}XtrI+
TE Xt ' Z.ENtrT# A , TEiHtrWTAA' Z<E{# ,
+H++9ill#E ' {EEffiX4ill+* D}rnEEE
+fr,'fruEl
ffitr!ffi.WX, rtnEtr +F'! - lBFFIF!/'. F{Ffn,fru fr7frJ+f.
EHffi A Hy{+ ++H fgr'.1 H #, ffiA^H E #g +,1';fr
FUEEffftf*4tr-iFIfrlEW ' +fr,{Htrlffi+F
EEEE ffiJtfrfi. -#E'Htrffi++
,i, +fr,ffi ,lfrnffi E'.1;{ Zffi - h ffi'LffiffiEn4' + ++fr.t ffi
a HffiEtr BffiJrurf,,L.ffi ?'o'
fi^lffiEEtrlWr^m/FEtr{fiFHffiH"l Lffi 204 ' e}"Affi++N
'tre.H1FRffi-tr;ffi#,WEH
r-ffifl#f;{trrf.JI Hli #HEEffiqErrag-r? , XffirE,trH +.frff!{H,fE
' tr
nt *8 , IFmI=.'{ft.fr"AJFI=.rcAlsE4
Htr EfEtrtFt f
tr]/.ff1" FnH)\A$re.EffiEf
+4ftH'.lifrEY{Ff;frf;fff
' fiff tr tftHF'.1Hft' E oIt)tf[ tr XE IF+ r-E'ffi- t)JiH'fE I
*TE lEl-,H#Hfi' {EA[EE H+r&Ffi SU,tffi iltff'r,Jfi
204 rffi H*ffi , HEEHffi&9Y:tffiHftffi1EH€F!+++1S€' {EE' W'Rlfrffi+fr.frr
+
202 gffifr $rtr+ #'f fr;+ , (flF#FflftFrE{t#g#,e,ffi) ( ttF=ffiHfiFfd +*ft?&tr , Zi,fg,fgEtffi{t$r^, UEEzrffltffiA.* (Deusrevetatus), FfiD}#.
tss7+tFffi-h E.)' Hr 13. :e{ntffiEerr-H-=&l+MnHf}Bttffil (Deusabscondtrus)
' FfEET&.# " "'l -F,
203 FfrEHffi' (Fi+effi) ' Frz " <H -frH ffi ffi -fi H) + ;+ 4€E ' H "l "
ffiffirHwffiH{t+He )FRW.trJ+E#'(ftfr;E)

Dlh. l-tffi ZtEr ff.l,E


fHE+-Y{;f;' {t'{ru8 ffiHff trlE HE EH ffi f'.1E fFq ft ghfr.tj tfr#ffi ffi /. f.]+.H H
tffi +fr.6H -{E
E# ffi thrT{ttrrH.,Hg tr]ffin wI w #TfH{g F--t/. E'.1 Hfnfif; ffi2+' mHEaf'J ffiafi'!ffi
trRtrH'l+.fr/lE'[A'[AEfHtrfHfitr]#il . fE+ Ffr)sftl ff! . /t ffiEtr t1ffi F E fE+ {Hfi iHi€
fiy.trltE
-
Ha' r-HftgffiftAtr! )F?#.ffiffit E-'#f+gFEF
Ht7 *fiV1f": .
FE iE{E4flffiillfr EE W++E * ' E Y+'fE [[ H H JJg'E'.]+f
E nE(frfr.iffi *tKj$tE /. iruH E H DIXH^]+
;E= fE{+- fE*fiWtr fi"F rEffi , friT{H{HE ffii+illfi it, 4* , D)/.iHFH Irfr7+.ffiffit#X*{,ffi{t fi.J
^ffiFE4.fr' ' El
ffiFE*"A frffi;+tr!ili;E|tt.A + trlH# ffiFEm E " 205 ili f
ff*fitr!ffiffifrHEEHEHffi ,
tffi fra-ftEg IFffirffifl r-fffFI t. ' mtrFnH
nE F!Ftr?i[4fx+FH
7 tFF'.1
q
HE fr tFH'lH&fH E F'.1-f6fr4ff+ iEP$' ElJltElD)ffiR
-at
W.*)t+.# ffifr! , ffiffi.ffiF'.1H E{4 F A lfl{4€ ikilT#, W
Elffiift+EnEeA['f€EftA7
Eif H nE' + n1ffiHE'
W.Wffi Lill & )L'WW (V,ftTffi
4 Ffiffi ' m a +ft.+\
I+91h {EEfT " I
207

Et" ruf+EwFne ,
H t. -iffi, fi mtr ff )F-E F *"4 +*t*"4 +tr
'qre:"&tr+
fr Ir l4 ftfr! r'l;f;fr!ffiw.++F. {Elr R fi F rEtu+rtn'lH f+ff
- E $F' fi "8ft.'r,r*+tr.+Irfr,q
E ffi-.fEs H' F[ffiffi#'J tr
rEfr^1{+F hfr^H#ffi-{E frHdtflS(n#ft-E +Sn' F
f,FrEffiRw.illftS ^ffi' fi FnTfr?ffifteE WE,ytfnF'!tr rEffi
f€fr r'.1flb El
Hi " fr #\zftsfr rxrl E ffiH ttu(x.ffi T n- fE
;EEXirtHfi{ruEffEtrItrIE " ' fIFf,rc,#
;HEE +tHffiIt ME E E {*' ff #9.z.ftS4& '{NREEf#E HEE4\ HH
fEZ<IE_J -
F,!H E. EE E.l.H T IFJ i& + Tfr,U
fr}FH tr f} fi E
t*
HF":{=o#'"

ffitrHffiD)+g ffi+,1.F'!{Ellfi#r*,{A'[AE g{tr fE


-idffi ffiffiY{;f;E F E fi X fEfEtr t tr!+ ;# . 4 + +tffi ft&
ft & R ffi.ztfr fr\wtfiHE tr!E it[! g EE.
ou. <Hlfqtrlf.tl>' Fr00 .
zos $fl*teinrich
206++€ffi# ' iE/tt;+' (-*f+e . *&- frV. ' &ru'WffiAtil't+)( -tiE , =ffi ,
1998)
207 RIfr' Effifi* ' f,'!fi{F;+, <lFtrEfi'tp.>
( +Er/tfrffiftL, rcet) ' H17'
' I=ils9 "
RW.TRWffiH{tffi€ )FRW.il?EE#.'tpf{t*)

F ffi++F.#, [nffi+ ;+, K\fr.$] t ffi) ( t


+ +Nfr'.1 tFff$*-)
i€ , =\ffi, tggz) o
tHtffis
i ,E ;+' (-+E f f d f f iW .
ftfr ffi'*+.f\# ' H H mS '{ol /e E E E Hf f iH! + H # IF ,
(tiF
,B7F.F) , ti€/tEHffEf,f , 1e8e) o
E.H* E X, EEEHffi F,I
# TF1FH gKi[' ^M;fr E
. i^f f fr
Etfr J t rFF i . # , m # f f i + E + ' ( 4 t r w.€ E) , ffiE)FI=.hfr.#Fg
ryn-- W@EE I=.,{ft.#[y{^H+']}E+F,
( J t H' + E f ' t € f + r y H f r F ri lo' to' t) o
f+EE EH ffifl #ls(nff F,EIFE t ryZ IF , +,fr.H+ W'tffiW
, - l g t r + ; +(, f f f i r f fEi H , E,*^ m Eg
l &##+++E: F /.'[4 yLWf[ .
tr +H/.,L.ffl+ H FnffiF, T ffi&ffi H ffi# E
' 2oo4)o
W.>( JtH ' +H-frHEfd Dlh.EffFtgfl+f"1lF-ffis' DllFE4\^Hhffi.,

H *fi +E' ( H {ttrfr'i fi ffi W ry > ( ti F , =ffi , t . € f f lq f f if( ft is zT - l e ss+ )


.
tgg g) I . I ( g tt fH iE ) $anctorum Communio)

HIffitr. 4ffiiF# ' gtj,Rifx . 'ff+16i,Y.


, (:+trfrdif EEtrH ffi --tu.?. tHFEffi r _ fEW.€ il,ig e F!
ffi iE *[ E=tJ
e ;+;ffi ) (A )L' ti E IH H F'teos )' iF H nfrft,I ( A TheologicalStudy of the Sociologyof the

church) E-*[tF ryWfri]Ff'f gHE^1nfrft, , ffiei H


. FHffi
ffiS/lE)E ( 6?E . 4H
ffifffi' ( Ef+-EEEEEiFH)
W.*.I? ,nfrnFfr'z ooo)o Ifr , ++iaffi6' E++' flit.ffi€Emffi|affifr,.lffiHfiy{
W@ffiA #t1lYffif[gfffi. +4ffiHfiffi' /.Ef'19
Effifr,'qJr€+# ,t H;+ : ( <trrffi-#F$i) trtF,'ft frF Hl+fr1#it , frEf# | tk- Itrt VffilfrF!-{H
+trAHfF ) (tl € , =ffi , toot) o
fHtrffiW" tHgmAtffiH4 (community) Hf!#H'!
fr*w.+fr.EE tF , ft fr.IHU {E t * In , IE
++EW#, mJI[;+' ( -#ff+
H ' RW.' frH ' & )L++.ffi
, (ti€ , =ffi#ffi , root) o #Hpfrf FH -{E ^trl#fitr ^H
' F[fftHH'E{EiFeFm* " W.@
aiE,[,4)
F]IEE g W,frillTfufi , IEEEEHffi tr H fjlJIFffiI-f;
W.WHFHr 4IFffi rtffifr.]trHr 27frf'.1ffi+-FH9F
lr . E gl5 + ffiIF Fait- fr.fEtr t tr frRTIAF.TAlfl'{ffi
IE
E^1ffi g
ffiffiHfi,X&-Htkffii+fi!f'l +Fryfi fri, + g +
,l.;frUEH+H7ffi# "

81
RW.IR}EftH{tffiE )FRW.?IEE#. ' t F{ffift)

| .2 KTtfitW#H) 6ct andBeing) f f it ' f f iM *t ( € U t:2 6 ) " ) ,.+ fr .Effi H H n .l # fr .


W , TEH HTfHEEf'JAHffiitr.EFJ{EA " A9qT
E *I3W.frffi,A
T&;fr{ H + E R 7 HH EHffi gf H H+iF
ffitrlfH{UZffitr b, LZF"Ifr!ffi lfi"Efr,nn+F tr /. F'!Efi
ry , w ry Dlh.x.Iuffi g F'.1-{E#rn . H'F+ E t+f[ H
'{fi" Ellft, LI4..W1F{'4EfHE-trl tFffil{rtffiT{H'fH
;€iFryFnEE it H"]/.Wrlfl t IU,2f"1E"lFffilfrWWi EE
E t # t r r ,i . ;a fEBE' ffi + ' H H El fr .ffi a"E ill
EHm' i0 DIAHfiliFry{Sffi fnffiHFnffiz\fr X trl
ffiffiM= H H+, IfrF-FFH +EE #f$ffi -fE q t ffif;A
ffi++E +ftA7 7 ^E.frgff.J
atff+"
A f f iHf r . t1 ' ,i ffi ,m r ffi H Etr # ,"""t ( € l Js:
r.z.trftfih-tiL tft,Wt tFH ' tffi&HI++EffiIEAHrtn t ) +fr.-'{J,ffiE ffi-lB I Rffiff.lFfiFEr' /. El6E{EF"l
fr.)\Hfrf#H+ IRffifrtrnft" EHEHffi+H+ffi Et+,E'ffi ffiHWH/.iF H EFIg ' lfr.trfr+trHffi'tF#t ffi
-aK,ffi
ffi6E ftftr+ft ghtrt+*I' E mK.+n7 t ffiH'.1 H ffifrE . qFMIFffiffi-trHEfffi tr'FH,!H fi.]' E+E
ffiF"lHHE&HtrftU ' Tfr19.HEW.
H "'ft,-'nK'ffi't
{4 ' ffiEA HffiHil1' EW.€'iSHE]r){+9ffi.#[tffiffi EA IfrEX,T''ETtr.Egffi*{ffiXffiffi " EE EHEH
;f;;E . EtgElrXEfr EEEHffi tr lF-iet ffiMfi T /.ffi ffif'J-L'ffiIFffiE'1 H,.J
+,1.ffiT E E fr&VT_ {H+ ffi#
ffiH HffiHfirE*fr7Et+F.lffiHfi , {E+FEfrffi&7 ig - t ffiTE EHtIsH++WRW.ffi* r+{Ft tAL
rtffiEffift{ffiE"lt.ffi i ff!ffiHfi'
WtH,-"aE'ffi
rEH t ii" rAffHt tFH-iKffiExE#ffiffi'6f$
1.2.2 ' F[ 1.4 Kffi-ffiHfrffi-HH) (Egffi - christotogy)
/.ElE H E,ff.1ff;#Elt)tfi Et ffi " EEEHffietffit€
E - )' -ffitr7 IFffiHtr.Hffi F,IE g tr.]fEHE,IEfr'ltr.
E E fFffiHfif'.1{t#' I&lElH+fr,+frfr 7 ffif ++
tR,t&ffi
+ffiEIFFffiftEHtr rfd€ t il" r-frFr ff.lEE$$
E (RudolfBultmann)'t+EIJEffifIJfr (PaulTillich)'
-;fr FtTEtrlFffi | I f!EE - rc.Egfrnl^tffi,
H r ffi frFnH |rtrWfEffi ' E fF+Fe ft?ffiJ{fr
++tr
, &ffi{4f[frAAI+'{EE tHH I FIBI E iFXE /.F$r-fr7^/r&Eg E --,trWFfiffi ' E IEIB+U$Sftu
z\ffl)SffH'l+
Y{Eg*iffiflBf,l+.rtrg€'ffi{E+ffi ' -EEHE
ffiT ffi.|* , Rffifrg,ffifn
w.@trlf#f# " EEEHffiffitk
E.++#v-WifiE +.V,J ; -EEg IFffiAffiWE.W
EEEfU 7 (gI€fHE) F,!ffiHfi ' Jl HHtr-FE.fT g " EE
g fr + t fr?ffiJffi|^ EHffi +Etr.W.EHEg FlAHHffi ftEIHE IFfr
mfEffiHfif.JTE " -
r ffifjiF'!r Eg T'fE'f€nnlfr.Fn fr ' mflE f[#i
1 . 3 (€]JEfr EW)- GreationandFall) H?ffilfi{l'E +,1.' E^ffi &HWft& . #,1h.,qfr,
HHEHffi -i{ffi BUE fidH'!E!- StJ
= H #f ff Eg ffi X ffi ; f r r u7 & B f fi EW= f6 6 f$ , + fr tr l # g ' H fr .tr l
yn'e#i^fr.'f+ffiffie, " + -{E + ffi8 | E LH' +
^H
E g f[ r'i({E fr!+g " + &H'!E g iE- tt ?,fr.hffi ffi{E

82
RW.IRffiffiH,{t+FE )F?ffiW+trffi, ( Bff
flft)

"fr1sffi
' gE' giHf[H 4 " +*#, +g-#tr!ffi-#l] xHyi wftI a H fr E ffr',Hffih wt6z,r{
iE* ffiryn + fr4
h #s 7 E g ft'.l t&{U' E ilEf'J Hl3 ffi4 g /.f6 F'.:
fHm ffiffift " EXEAg' it+€H 7 Eg +,1.f[IfuA+,1.
=
H IHtrtf,q, E tr lFffi,,tffiH fttrl+,l'' Hg IFffi fFrt ' E F+E DIEHie f-i\4ffi H R Bflil.Wt$nfr
ff.J
+,1'' EtrlFffit ffiq Hft ffi+,1.. m- #ls
ffi.fr.ffi ft,fr\ww "
tn+ffiil 7 ffiF t F^lEg, m 7 PnFffiffiFEE={;ft T+ 2 . 2 ( E [ 4 4 if ;)
ffifr H,ft iFe xyi] E g;fr E!IFffiHE + ,1.ff.];.f ;fr '
(n
e E-stl +.F ;{;frEg ilfi]ffiE /.x E +F' EEE
EieY{ffi@F{E/.fr!Bfliifrreft7 . *nlfr,A
)E'ffir,Vtt}tft
Hffi -'rK,ffiEE +fr.+I'f+fr"Atr{4 ff'JE g n=ff' mru H E
ffi#E-fE l-i$Eft{4t fl#g;.ffi 'e."ft,' it,dfi-iJflE e.Fn=,4H2MffiH^l/.FH,L. H4if;gh, TH?rymH
gFtffi/.' t&Effi+k{ru-ffi Ftffi/.F'!rffi ' I&+ftH AF H,L.Mffi. EEES H4 fr,I+A*EFU
Tifrfihffi .

AHEH WFN HH .
tr H A ' E gE ffi 4f NT f I ' E Hg +,b;ftDIHF*F,.]Ffr#HIEfr.AgH +.
E t. ffiIFffiy'.#tr Wfr il' FJt @WIH,-t*n,'Ifr'-"#'ffi s . trfi6r+ffi ( lese-le4s
)
r ffi- /.t trlEgEHffi E )'.ffiH +' E *lslFffi A s. r ({ffiIEe)
{effiry#E + IEHE F .fr,{:u' E mE +Eit tFryffiE
,
frEgetr-ftE ffi'{kXF!WR{F7 ffifl ' {frtEEE-*l3 *ft,fiE^]#lF' iEEHEW-.H',fr!,B,ffifl
W*#f"l + ffi ' 4g W.lffirE g illltffiE E * E tr W4rE!
2 . eBEW.€(Confessing H+ff ( 1933-1939
Churcrr) ) :
H E, iTtr.EE ff il1Htr.WEg ffiAilJH
E Hffi5fi;if;J
2 . | ( fF Fl ',{ftfrr1{t
{H} Qhecostof Discipteship) tr frfrft*z<Elh il1' {ffrEH 'FF,!= il7trttW.EF'.1 F+ffi,l'4
49ffi EF F'!ffi {Hfrf;AErffifHf.l,Ktsr fr rffiH I&, W{EEfEE A F!H ITEffi^ffi _LffiillTfifr- #{q[
ffi,Kftr . E{&trtr ffi# Eg +,1.;ffi - -#EEg ' Hg trlE rg- ffiHIilW . -iK;#EgW41il1HfrH'
ffifr
Dlh.FT {ftWH ln - E g * It M z ffi.iHB'l,Kfr H tffiffi r,Kqr fltffitr] I-iErF-fr*ffiff.lEL+' IEF1
!fr # E r # t fE #m/Ftr t#)\ I ffi # ' t f f iE lt ) t €'E=Iw4lsB.trlTKfr&ffi# F'lm+eT t E ESU' y{lFF!
-a{-#rlHEE,,ttrEg fr'.]fHE, E €t fr 7 n fiffi {EE 4
IFffitrf#Rtr tr!ffin' ftf;R FtffiT)\+F+tEltrlFnH
F'l{ffi l-Hr fn tF.t " WtfrflEtEH-HUtr-^
V7J" ffiHF'.1,K4,e,*DtE )\*fiy.#FnHXEFffi4g'
FFtrftrffiB'.l,ft,{HE lfr.n+il7+.ft. nrf -*ls(n k , IH4fi&Mil7fr1Hfr'-f;t[E-H+f"1FFE ' Egffi.EH
E y{H rl-rH -ililH'.1-#ff+'
ffi fr T'l#,[H' + f[ F A # H'.] A fr /. F!ffia + H frnR h"ffitfr4Rif T H+, F,H+
. g g
H E + i ffiv1H ft.fr /. F!H ft.t frfreM^ffi Kfr&+frW
+ FE Y{ ftStr!-nef+ ffi IEH EEEHffi Y{+EEF!E
g vflffizffi o '
+F.- FH ftSth?-# /. rc.Wt ffih"ffiffi,-m- 9rtffi)\

84
#W.IRTEffiH{tffiE , ( Flf$ft)
)FRW.trJ+trW.

3.2 (Ft+g ffi) H tfr # Z ) tr " F fr D' {] fF f4 ffi ,L ' f} ffi tr # r fr


F ' . 1 - f E HV
ffi- Effi^ffin=fr rEEff.lr EE rffi.#.fr7t Hf+F#Ef,
.
,1ErHffiEf5+F'.lF+-E i&flffir+ryffiffi , +.Fft
,l(fr!# {F2-, E E 7 Etr W.trrE.{tft g F,.:
tfi,ffitrn
+tr lEEf'JrE,,ft/-tr]H#t " aE-Hfit ' i&+ +;f ;fr
IFffi ' + FEEBEf)trffiIV,'frff ++.Dlh- Lffi H+4
Tr-
'W. R+;{-#T rFIffitrltrf1rD}&.t)FffiW.ftl#-
. tRffi.-ttrtr{/dlt frlHFT+fr.-'d(, TIA I S{ffi " {&--aK,ffifEEH?ffiJ-#/.-rK# Ae,Ffrthfrill
trffi.r ff']fiftA ,EFfi;H
{fitr' ElJtr rffiffir fflH+{t'IEEF'lifttrW-fr?
ffiE - f6ffifr_rn+-,ffiiJFtffiftAry /. fi,.l-fEfrtr frv, *H',ffi ' E 4 E IFEt)lE IFfr.f+.EHEH ffi | )FRWA\#g
fi " HHEHffir )Fffi#LtrtgfS ffiffit l#.tr8#rE{t
ffi.-t fHEE E ffl ftT$# T , Dlm++ft!+nH,HA lEE ffiH tr
l'.IEffi*n{,I4q4g(t' ffi) ffiHfr,tre.mffiie/.
+++ FffiLfrF^]-fE H # " H + F,I,B ffi#[E RW.fIffi ryNfr ft,H +
fflfa ,(l "
g { |
T E I W f fFi ! € F F "l F E' ) F R ffi WEtr W. t,E ffii l 1 ffi
f' | )F##r.fr\Htrffi.
Bf, t ,8,fgffim644# IF tr+HTRtrH f!,gE IFffi'
trWfr ryn-DIEHE | lFRW.WEtrffi.
HffiF'.1 t E I,F KHE^ffi'fE fi[) E 4 ++D]HHEHffi F'.]+F
e iEEffi+,
ffi+ ffif! nfrft,# lFffiE T',' H + ft,WXfrtrlFtEft A ffin'.1s ,
ffi 'l+E,fF" H ffi-flsfn r EEEHffi DtkH,ft iF
y.+&a1lHSIJ[l]tfHf flwordandFaith ( (E^{=) ) Hrffiffi.t' l-EE EHffin'!EEDlE-ffi EE t, ffi- #f,(l,
( (HftffiBffi> ) Effi*ll "
Dlk4++ffiRealityandFaith t ) F RW . W# Eff,B;tF' t r q F ffi + g q H &t , l - g
( = tr'fE) f F ;frff *BrW{ 4Hf lF ry,8,ffi Fl - fti,, f € f HE r , f Iffi IEF fi ffi' t l - tffi tr l E,e .*t' ffi = # l s
fi.IEf[ ffi F"fi' D]tfr,W+Eq t,{lF ffi f'JH'{t 1Fe E rc.ffi'H (t, I rHfxt {FffiEHEHffiD}kf}{ffif!{ffit ' rt
lF ' st fty.fHf4 R#, , ifr,-frffi Ef,i*Rw.e,t#EF, xlx. ffiW.#F'!*X t J:)k rEg;frF'.:^Xt Ffr#EFt. E4#
trIiFryffitr+EW , E-fi E;,1Eil+Effi ffi 1DHE.W'E{tIE
W ( | i l *n ' r + F€ ftH # r . rfftT IF ffi ffi.F- rSif; tfr,#ffit' tr ie f.l,Ef.H fqffi + ffi ' r +E IFffiT
n 1flfrf..F"]
E f,JEE ,['f
E H ffi E fFF!- fEffifi+fr ft1ffi*-hfrNfr"Y'JEE EH
ffi )' i&FKffi ifilQ.H,X*trRffi.tkEqiE{tEfEZ F"1ttr
l#-fE Fffi HrW4 E +*ffi ' m E rc.=-arE tfEEiHE + tr # S{ ffiE IFil!f€ffi 'Wffiff+' E ffiffi# IFF'!T ft,W{'4€ 5ft7 E
fi " wrfr., 4.9tr!ffiffiffi8;{;fr
ttriJfrffi.+ww.@h.+fr E{ETE]'HEtrIITffi " M-EL'f'Jf}4++ffi=,HEEHffifr!
*-nfrnfri*F!H#r . ffiF(frit, E+Frynfrft,ffi
ryZ.ffi E IFfHH'flE - fEfr 4 ++A H,Bfg trE?Atr!,8fFiHfr '
1 4 + ' X, %G f t . #rffi E H '!t F r# .# ,i l 7 t 2 7fr ft1*E " tr rtr ' E SllZ IFfr# E {efr EEEHffi 2f'1ft"]S{ i-f;IEFfi"
(fr.-'ftRffiE
ftWW+x+FHry',{funfrfr,
' ffiF-/ial+fie#E E * I J E I F E R+ E g 7 L ffi 2 A,[.4 4 HF IIFr y# ffE'E

86
ffiffitHffi^ffiH{tffiry $fr)
)F#W.ffi+E#.' t Ff'f

*nf,l4/. Z+-ft 8'.1


{E/. h-Gfr.##H
fHffie tl D}e.+* r s 2 r , TF , m - xffi + ffi . E+ + € T { 8 ,8; ,8 .8 , ? fr m
- fE)F-'aft#1F! (non-casuistic ) f! . ,)lE g ffi H i* fr tr fr F'! frtfrt +FHWW.#; e.EI 1Elss Fl ' gqfitJtffiafin
{ffiIEg E fi 'f-"1 E EEEHffi Hfr.trfi,B
ffi E ff.J" E ffi {Ef"lFE#13 t r t T ffi ffi /tg,+ EIIH + H fS; r r E r sE ,+ !+ F .
-# 4lH , &4tr tfrf^+FryWffi7 ffiF1=# : r 20fffrf,
fS+ +;t' fr'.1Ffi FE' EIrtr ' E *lJ# lFffft | )FR#9.il18
fn t*frW.tFHWWH{flftAr " AfF
trW.r,EfFEfrnfr,H)FH
EF W*4{HIE" ^frftfFHFr (wedding
+^'ffi,T tr ) ffrW#f"IE!)I "
t Fff$*= )
| #t@fi.14H
rs27, *fiffiHtrlfrfifrtr=+fE I t€ FnaF'ill
EEEHffi+^+#dS+#, 208 E g W.l ffi IEuz r,F.*Wg fr W.@F !;+ &@i # '
1e 0 6 ,zE 4 3 ' E f+Itrfr . E E p-.Hflffi
g + . M , r r t ir H. & X . Xffi *f;+ fE' l - f{ ttF € r ' r ffi e fl /.€
. .
ffi EEEHffi:i1L+ftfrilffi'ffi I .
ff! FfiFE

r s28' FIH+ tr +i fi ;tr , l - f{ r fF ffi t ffi AF 'l tY.W ri 4


rer2' QtHfgq€TfEf F XEEfHt .
t ryrc-6+'
tr ' ffiH I W.@ f[tr8)\W.f"1FE] -t
' e,E ' f[
re2s' Ffr16TflHfF .
Xry[ff-iFlFg H tr fih+kEm-ftEH |
ffif +Y.AH f; H+ffi Bffiffi" t fr\E
ffi ; 10fi 'HtfIIffii-t+EI+&Hm "
.
re24, frtfr4 fiff;Effiry
rs2s, *ff EFrg;#E itffi Fanoe tr ffi , EHEHffi+EI1
€T ft,Fn;fid ( g f E f H
r e 2r , ftffi .€ F K p.. S eebergfff rEif; ffir(F t flFltr EFs,E , -'tuT,lAW.@#
'
E)o #7 T EH H Et ' r r Es E ,l fr " F r ffi W +F .fr Er S
=IK,IEWWXW.@ "
re2g' t.E rrA ' EEffi-/.+frry6iil " zE rs Bfrg' #tj
.
EFFAfrftITEtJ+{ 1e30, 3.E ' ;bF fi fttr tr € ,ffnE ut6'ffi f..ffi +++W .F ffi
M.W, F(H'.i
W--d^ " fHEtfr\tfr,TlF ryWft + E ffi ffi
re2e , f^tfrt +E,ffw.Luetgert+tHFillHJIH
"
ft9R #0* ( Z i nes hof) ,'r h.x &Ei \+fF tr ffi fH
re 3 0 : T E 1 8 8 ,D ) K tl g h l 4 frH >-g E l Ef...r y;EBF (Finkenwalde ) , ##ffit , ( -rfr l=ffiEf[ EtrW.
'Ht&tfi€ ; gE s El , ffi'r+^fififilFri-iHI#,frniFryl3fi
" g)gFr) itEUfiU-{H rffiF.ZX.t ' {FES{E
'
tfiKHrfr'.1+
{stFry/.El H xffifflHifr. E
DtxE#+
H IEft']| 16@-t "
ElDtffiE*nffiWIH#,-)Lffi-{H

zoe TH{.T.[d {Affi , ( EEE€f f if ! , t . Ft r F) ( Aj( . , f f iHf f r f f i . i t ,r e e 3 )


t++, frtV#)t"

88
ffiw.tRw^ffiH{t+Fg lF#W.VtEEffi.'(Ff{fft)

Ie27' 2E ,Etgf tFryW-i#fiffitk-=#|!fr.'qftfi!ffi f . 3fi , 1,fr.Xrt


rszs, z H, ffii;(+Iffi ffifrnfi.Ep1:I+.lrlIF
; ffifiFry+.{f58tr4
iIt " ft#fFtrffi1Hffi;+ -
--aK,lEW.@EfH+ ffi ' g, E 'H Effi 'tti ffi + ,W B* f+- ftgH 'f=tf
Iffi4+|fr,' E)S (Dahlem) ' EH ,
ffi tW.@rtn/;frt*ffit '10.E F5-+ft.ffit/.1#.6
fih+kHmB!ffiw, 411ffi"4^@ "
ffifFf .
rezT, r E 1B, ffi .tk -aE Iffi Fk 4mg trff i. g E g r € . 1930 +H10 E Ela g' fflHelmutvonMoltke--tEfltJ+ilffi,
z ,
i# ' tr EHfih+kHffitEffi g,E' #fFtrffi{Htr!
' f[Iffi4 ' s.E ,ffi=^fltJIffi+ " ftffifHHffiFfl
J, z7IEry+.Tfr.+H
EEFF " FEE
'TT+HryW,Ifr.Hfi tr ffi+.#krg-#.
Hffiffi46Etr'frE*frf+,BfffiTtNUAH " H
{H) .
HF( IF1\tftil1,ft ; 3 Ftr AE
1931, t.E i7 El' fltnt*iavonWedemey"tETfE
+,8s E' ?fi+ffi
sTztfl ' ;+ElJ-#frtJfr++Ht' '
re28' r .E1 1 El'? fi E ffi trffi fFf
'mmfl #ffi - # * t jf r f + ^l
f'++f6 (regel) ffi'H&
ffiFi' IEH+lHlEf[{E*ff
ff ffiFHlfrHS,,tX,t+.: THzoA , ERE*F! rH-#'ffiffi-t
| 4F2eA''ru{HAfsi,fr.W#
tfi+H "
4 fFtr ffi fH-LE ;* F,I -frE ffi€ " ffifHtr& IffilF
;ffi. Hgftg6ffffi(#tffi) . rslz , F-ffi.EF, ilT#nef&{FRftJ E XffiH*Affiffi '
3 , 86 H' + + f6 tfr fi ffi - 4 i H # tJr;y.H
4 ,83 0B,
rezr,'r +.Htr 'f+ffi trffi
+.W .'+E l i Fgfl tr,f r t , + d F ; THzofl , m . fiiE
trfr ffi-ffi il;fr tHeF,.lI-=o
ff g+EEillEt++ (vissret Hooft)(* trW.gE
ghglffigh#) , Dlh.Wt9frHffiffin? H {EffiH# frUA++Wr#-W.' E ffiE gfitr!ftE f#ffi
: 6H , ffii'r*-
lf ; 10fi , EnEHffif[ EEts-;+EIIftE,at' {EfftEfsfil.
*E ; 6820A,+EftEHHts-{Hfr,.lH*;tElI ' zFzz #' EffiRHH'ffiffi. EEEHffi. {E*fffiXES
B ' EFIJTH4A " toE s B, EEEHffi
u\tEfilstE{H' I,fr.&FUHfrlt
re2g' 3,E15 E' Eff EXf[f+,8f4ffi,&f,.];+tEE *Fp. lF.-Fn++fttJ {frg tr tEI thWf.qWFn'
ffiP-'l
l& , l,E#trt{ftfilJ+{+lht;+ ; 8.E' f[mtrf+ - 1 e s 3, z F r X ,+ fr .f&EftF ft+ n ff " m M + fr .$ Si 8 &ffi
ftffi'HS/.ffi;{+8ffi.Z ' e HtA , l,fr.#rtAffi
f f ir a,iffi .th' .ftJi + t&+ :tF+; ft2 fl ' f[l EI XV!
iF;# ' ifiF€ffiI-frgfr+jF^Er1qti.
FfrMHIFKIffiffi
g) ; loEsoEl, ffiErtHtrfr.frlEffi;€Fh" lEf, 'fH- {E*flffi tH+/.-ftE?fiffin ; +fi 23
B ,fr'ffiffi. EEEHffifrfiEf.-e+ n-+jt/.Etfr
t ?frlffin"

90
RW.IRTEffiH,{tffiE ' UhAt)
)FRW.WeEffi.

uh.Fil,) TE#t fr?ffi A FE H'Tf,HTE, fr E A HffiA H " EE- IWt


tr H'.1ffi fE ' yf iE4+.wTe E F+f+[EHwrnrwb {'fr' y{
fr.Af+E H EFH? fr#R' EA € NfrN +.ryHffiFfi Ffi,
tflftVTb'l'tr H+
IEJ f+ffi# Yi* * H"l ffiVt" ft IftH+' tk ^ffi
T EEEHffi ffi (Fi + gffi ) " ifr^Ef#(frfft
ffi-/..1fr-FE
ffi - y{trt1 - r,iH+nffi-fEFHHffift,ft,afH^Efr,.]# FfiE F,trl'-p- I:IZHFfr IFJ € A[T E fEtr ttuf#Fi 7 fHEz
ff iE= fETfr+- tr refrHflL(=. ffifi'.]rEHftf;{ffi r' ffmE +' ltr{EfiHtffi +AFEie{F5
# fi lFH Wiltf€ig H fS+
(Dr. Karl-Hermann ff ft fr^] {f H ffii* {fitr ttu?f$+ntrie {Hft'.] {'f fr " 1ff.^f++
) B! ftlX . ;d f+ # {E H X E
Muehlhaus
# ;frt FIJ -# -
nfrn4 + # t' tFffizHm ffiElr+kfr'!+H €
F . JHHiEffiF,!EB, E.IEfS+trIffi TFTfT{ffift E 7 E
ZEfr , ftIfrH T., +fr,FNR gflJ F,.]T{H{HE {SE TtXffi *
IN+K-H D}ffiE-E? HH ffi A fHE F,!IFH Xtrr,Bffi +.ft
+ " mH ifr.trH E'mx i#r+w+.fr-Rfi HfiJ&E +k{ru WW.Hffiffi h , F-*trtE#{ H'rtiE* il1+9./.fr#{4.ftffi#
H Ht
t r ] f t { f + F +E " Iftr l ,Wr y^ i l 1 F n H Z Efr AEt' + H +
B+'
E ffi fiiruF'.1+ fr fr,Tf;[T H,tfr,E ft + FlF .
Ifr.F,.]t
. EJ|L' EEffiZH+' F4EErlT (tr-Ft+#ffi)iE=
W-iifi A$H ffih Tsqfi,ffi a ft ffi tLill EFi'#fr +H€ ' A l€Mf'HPSt
r{ffi H'rtiZWEY{iO{ru RWF!E+F '
49, +klE./E,e.* *iF,'\EfE4.ftfi'.] h E, itE ffi.AH "
H -#WA +k+.fttr]q tr, tre. +.if;E'!E.rtffrg # +
E TfE E TA, IF.T+AT1 6 ?EH ;EE g W.Y.K,Nfi 'ft,Fft -#ft H g gl+-ft E"ltr H' B #ltr +k+-ffi + E FU n'!tr- {E
{trg ftj6 iE#t1H f++gRD}&.EI=o
fE{+H,.t # f; +FryWit
EfHEEft'.];+fE )\, lff.fHE + -#ft-iK-i*StJ # F'l*#' H E F fH
ft tr tr'],ffi
" EtrWgF*.' [,t7 +*frfrfljfHE6tr]tffi-HW
D}I]IW-IN HffiffigftjEE E HffifESIJF,!g=, gIH, gEI IEJ ' ffiIWWtrH..
wwntre#. Elrfr,,*H;$f t-i4EEI , - oon+-ntr +Xtffi
ff.]taR{ffiftHffi
VRXE' fS+ DlkFn€'E I #{fnlruryH4 yf;ffiq ffi , rfr,E - oot ++tr +/L B ltrtY.+F.ffiffiilt946ffi
-#
R {E# fr +FryWFn H zf,fr . IEIE fr ffitr yt'fi ir5ffi,ffi.T
E fr"HWf[EflF
] " l ei 6ffi f"l'8qfl T& l nff i+ g ' r y
a- Hx,ffizEm - HBFHZEfr. iH{+WW.+q .H[frHft,
fs+. frHfzEfr- T#i+ZHF+f{Effi;fry.FnfEfr,lig-#
F, , i#?HH , -lffit-# .
'[S,E-
E + X.t +fr\ HH4 if;+H T rF.Eiltfi, m riltr il7
+tX,I,rEflA t * * F!E E&' E t,+,+ +ifr!WryryHFR +.
ififtgffi+H 7 rnE ;effi;frX' mE ffiafit y_,tr,'r?+fr.
A
-

You might also like