Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'
I tffiF)
t +tffiF ) I Abstract)
4 t + + ;={-ffiEEE-Hffi ( pietrich Bonhoeffer, "Non-Religious Interpretation of christianity" is an important
1e06- re4s)Lkffifr1| )FRW.tr1HtrW.t ,Ufll , D])*.tflff# theme of the late thought of Bonhoeffer and it also led to ambiguous
wffir,ftFnE ffi fl'.]- ArtJ rfiftE' l-FIffitft{Jilt:li I r ft ff understandings in modern era, therefore it is necessary to discuss
{4r ' rgf;g{flftAF'.])FRW'Wfr4tr+ t DI)*.t'si|1,:.1+ ' some of the main subject-matters, such as the world of coming
e t H n *[ ffi#EFl," m- ff ln ffift#;fr tr!
ft ft,fl)lll'fBRffi Age, This-worldliness, Non-Religious Interpretation of the Bible
EfFWRq,BffiHR , D)&.fr-ft4{ffJ i'f,ifrliiJ: . ffi- concept, and Reality, etc. to clarify the exact meaning behind the
#ls(n- E E FEtrH ffi F ffi y{ *,rrtt}+\trl\lJ,.l fL{lU)y-,8g?4 theme.
g -iffffi FEffi;={--nfr
' 4 H H r )l ',t::W.lHJ,\4\ v+tl llllftEF'!ftE
In this paper, the first part is to introduce the development of
'lR" m= *Y'(t ffi iUY'l | )1",'it\ -t ' l il'[,ltl'[ul' I y]k
Bonhoeffer's thoughts and its relevant background in this period,
r tr H I+ +,ft ff.Jftii,ffl'
: $ 4iJi llj'fTlil'li li llljlUf/'Jtft,lE' H
lir1
which lead to the definition of discussion methods. The next part
EEEtH f EFlir fJ I' 'il"2'lt f'Uillll'tT2'1't/r'fut F'.1T E
begins to reflect the influence of liberal theology and dialectical
t-fuH " ffiv!*\|$J 'f'li{a.$Jl'lil't: (1,i,('[,,rf m) +Eflf] t)F
theology on Bonhoffer and restates the problem of christology in a
Rffi.tr]# tr #xt l&lflt ffJI t ifttlftl,ff ,' lfii,1iiirlsltJ - frt | )F#
new perspective, through which to review the origin of the statement
W.WEtr ffi.t ,EfHliil l'ty.'lul''ft irjilldI|i t^l^i
{lrl"J'{JtH'j;fi fi"]EIHE
of "Non-Religious Interpretation of christianity". In the third part,
fi frJ ' it fiHfi#EEtrH frl{J&l/[{,tfi,li&{ul,1,"[l ryi{ Jl'L[t {+E5',l'F
F!
the emphasis of the subject-matter turns to the concern in this world
g E E{4 .
along with the same theme-Bonhoffer emphasizes the dimension of
encounter between the reality of God and the reality of this world.
In the fourth part, the topic will concentrate on the explanation from
I H;'i )
t'( lAti( I)ietrichllonhoefl'er,
U f+ 14ft ' HIIa]F. 1906-
t945) '
fHE +frryX - F;]fi,v.r*. $tfl.J+kfil|j,,/lttJ,l{,1i,C EIffitr ffi - -R.
trFtHIrl$fj!ui?fit tr;tr:itr\'ltffJ,il ' ririftffi+ftf;trHf
l,qlj -
liljililil /d iI ' , lill,(ti.f'ilrldMry,B,tFfr!e4E
M F /i. ,frff.Jtl,?
h.Hfttwll".t w Lllli IrL fil fl{{5t" ll lNltltY., lrrureg aFH
HF!/.Hrl?t?qtffif tr t- ('rttwtkfu.& It ffi+FEEE,
i /.{ruet.HA T g fUffin ff i€ E, Irl|rE4{ g F ft E'f'niE
E -t o 2 | *"A+' F El-rfr.frfr!- , (fr.fr\+-fr IF ffifEJ EA ffi
tF€ XHs- fE,E, tfFfntaffitrlT "=H n'.1 fi#A' il"?T, ru,H H - ==
ft ltuwa H Fnffifi! x It trnt$fifr.tr fE+ /. I,ktffi, F!EX ++-6q H
--6Fi,,
J:)h-Htr & HrcIffi.gh +&H+'I&+H f[ ifi fr B'l- fEffi
Irfr.3/L
M€ FHT
r llll t l i / ' i l r l r r / ; r t r r ' 1 l . r l l ,ll0 ' lktit jtlF lu ( l1 :l,,tl' j( r lr i,; r iil( f/.j{l.al,,'il l i rer,,'+.,E s
| | t't!fl! fit I i liif I I
l)) l l l i l . t l tl t4 ' r l l j t ' t r l r l f.i ,i'1 "1 : (tJ,ilr lr ,tf
fl ) ,r ' il,l1 iiil) l/r llll/.J( lliliir ,ri' l rgei I 9rj #,fr,F
f t l {i lt r ' r i t , i ' l t l l ' t r r i i r l LI l r lll/t
illfi[: Ill,lI/r,lttt' Illi'/rI],t,l'14J'I
rr'i
res8
) 4\Lft,g,ifr"
7 StanleyJ(irenz&RogcrEolson, #tjj,till{'{Lf'It'| ,ifl' (( . I lll:f;Jl4r+lJT;ft
- tffi4ffi
4 + f l ' J l l tfl ) (t{l {tl ' rri l i l i [ri l .' il) r ]x) ' f{ r 74 "
Dietrich B<rnhoclfcr,Sirnctorunr('omnrunio: A'l'lu<tlttgitul Strul.yol tht Srx:ioktgyof the Church.,
Edited by Clifford J (irccn 'l'rarrslatcdhy Rcinhard Krauss and Nancy Lukens (Fortress Press,
1996 )
((-fff#dffig-#ffi)
10 StanleyJGrenz&RogerE.olson, ' H17s ' 4E Ktrilf$ffi) HfE "
Dietrich Bonhocl'lcr, Att tnd Rting:T'rans<endentul Philo.tophy and Ontology in Systematic
11 John D. Godsey, The Theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, lEHt' Ht9z "
Theoktlqy, Edited by Wayne Whitson l.loyd. Jr Translated by Martin Rumscheidt (Fortress Press,
1996 )
RW.IRT.EffiH,,ftffiE )FRffi.Vl+E#.' (ffi-H . #fi;fr)
E, DIEWryH^lt. ffi+fr.ffi6Lk, EfHf'lt ffiaFE2w. ffiffi ' D)&.8ff&ffiflr+{tH-8 tr!* HF"fi ' 4 i+&
iffi ' E IElfr.tr,R={J,ffir f'Jtr IE+ fi'.]tr IEiEffi iEffiH!ffitk HEE ' {Elfr,Fnl..flffiD}&.H#ffiEgffirfiffi ' FUm
trtfi,'FtE rftEf'filfiFftlffi+Ffft: I " 'olnRffitr,xil1 WW,EftEfg fl Hft +,L.' tEE{tf^]H#IE W. &
l-ffi ffi E # I fEi* E f'l H'H+/-,L'ft fuq F"l-ffiH HE{4 F!+]L g +,1.ffitr EEE Hffi il1#IF+ IFffi A 6 f[ fr i*f,! fH
;+ ' flJMEHEHffiE,.] I JF?ffi.il1*trffi.IFUtrE7 Etr E ffiAE,H91T4AVl . EIItr' EfFffits.FtrHtJHH
ffi.EIE{t fdg + tr €' trTtfr{fi fr IFffi-E f'Jtr{AIV" tftfr rntr&-Hffi;frffi+"
'Ht)tk )\ f.lHf 4{'+ffiE' +EH-fEl[{E]ffiffl*ft ffl' ( z ) ft#ATAftffiFfI#E " HEEHffi tr.],BfF#RFffiE
f'JE g.fEltlrtr1ffi---"p.'l'4
+E;#' E fr + ffiIE, | )FR W
HF flro mHMqffiffiL{r' Elft T lElffif, WEp^ffiE
ft,
trlEEffi.t ffi*ffitr'l;-f;fr " -t?ffiff- WFP+& IHfiffiill WWfft 4 trlYtBfrJF HE F "
4 { ft + il-# FtrfiffiFffrtrE{E',*ffi.HFH+' EE ( g) t4f"1f! WRfr trffi# " EIIEHffiTIEWEF\ffiE
EHffi FfifEfr tr1E-L.* E*ffif;gffiE' IEJ[+AF& E A Hfr ,g
IF+.#H4ffi ^ fHE . AT FJZTFZH€HfHIA
fi ' +ffi
'rkfrl| )FffiW.trtFtrW. t fi!ffi,A' t)lk@ffi ft ffiA Fnffi 4 ffi ID)tr1+ EF, IET E H FAtrlqfr.H
ffi;FJ R HT IEIf!
ffitr]-#ItJF"lffi' rfiffiff.lEfTl ' rItff{4J - l-g .
E # A 1 H Fttr iFE EbE ffiD}*frNfr HEEHffi,Ef.F
Dlh.IHEr S'
frSffinAfrT)Fffiffi.++ffiffit fHilTffiETEM.
m= Hff. il'f-ffifr lt, ffi ;frsJI A f! tFffi+-+ 4xIt M fi i*' ru FI* ffi ---#
EEEHffiV!# {Ftr T.-ft,M2s' E m'rufr"llF€,E fFifi (Theodor Adorno) #,, 4H,BffiE-fE,BMA FH ( H
TEfE{*_.{EIg;fr #ffi., &TE{€ IX-€.I=INWHF]J ' H ) FffizHYHffi#tJ,Bf,Ff^1E9i " 'uf+.FnHEEEHffiF'.1
mE ft'*-H+-B*I+FWET lEf"lfr'ft ' T lEf"l{EfrH' 4 lEl ,
IFFrIE EIiHH$fi/,1{ tr!ffiF SJ;f;ffi{# ' tr Ift , +fr,{fl
tl€'
(frStj
ff!f,t€ fnfl+f,H'I=o JEH ffiE It Ifr z trE f#--{E)Fffi HE E gH,ft E+fr,ZrrF.fr#=A E WIfr:trftVA
f[ ffift fil IEJ
w.wff € tEE , fi'{H-#;frffiw.HI+ItrH #, z #,#r.++ ft'l/. + mfr +.ffi HH illff 6f;fr+t fr?ffiJfiH ffi^,
qfr.,tkfffi,1H rtntfr,
frtrEfr.lI-=-$ItAHftMEFlJ z WtltfHrgrt' 4X{+ryffl -frE,Bffi t EFAISWTfr.H,!,E f.T' t, FJTE ffi\fr.HE - f* *
;{-ffiFtt{rT ' E+{eF!F"1ffi , #th.tH -#;.fttrelfr.ffl}E ffifrixf.lffi#tr!
Hf& o
(I ) frE.ffif+" EEEHffiF,.]FftH#TF
')IEg;frH+,1.ff.J
E ffi ff! E + ffi fi'.lg fr,tr"1ffi , 4 frth.ffitr'lF-Iql
F=ft
"-m*
24 lE t ' H 5 . 26 Theodor W Adorno, Negative Dialectics. (6ftHffii*) (Continuum International Publishing
25 Stanley J Grenz& RogerE. Olson'(-+EftElS€?+ffi) ' Httz ' 4[4ffi (Heinrich Group, 1983) "substantive thought - a thought of whose movement the thinker becomes aware
ott) fft-6' E1E,RffitrltFfiilT'#iftHffi €' EE.R€ *ls(n' frsft6ftWfr1 " only as [one] performs it". Elxix .
#- H
JF##h,frt] H g #h,FfrFE
ftEffi
ffi -frfr . + FfrHEEHffi g{H ffi ffi ry Ff,fEffi
tr,8
€'fHY& FlR f ;if *+H e e& i+ + 4"+*)#4f+ F\
tr 4' 6t rqfE6t;s ?d\,4E-,K.'
R#.IRTEffiH'{tffi€ jFRW.VleE#., lffi - H, )Fffiffiill+trW.Ffi
FEfrsffi
l
f6f't;fftf ' AIH Et-aEff | frf.{&t t!IEJH+ ' Eg In /r &+ F ' llt'
mK WTffi" FnD )+E- H e. zl (,]E trtE
IFffiEff FIffizt (DerMensch Gewordene)' +
mX \fi.frI fI E trt E EE EHffitrV
)FRW.il7Eg
ffi.ffiffi
fr!-{EfFA
ffi ' D}-ffr r H{fr.nt ffifr fiAE
+N , th.y'{F.ffift]t. Hf f E "
-'aE
ffi r IEfr t' E m ff.:.d.trlff;frffif# f! Ht+EEf'JEg fr! | . +trtrlHEf-Hft bro ne)#
,f=' 11€',S# E Mtt 4 HE t+fI tr E il1Erfi ' E {EF+lFt
Fffi7-"#-# r?EFfiffirilll€I+'
o' HEEHffi+EH ffiff +fr.,[$fftrEffi ' lfrffi T w H (frtrl
THffi" 'O
n fi ' E g -#rfiffitr ft,ft +e*k-#r"1ffiH H r E FJ
r 3EF"lffi fiirt,Hf,'W*t-#Xfrf!EEg flS
I B'l_.{E+ffi IE+tr.T+trI+Efr A H @A fFH H TNffi ft,WT4-rE ? EH
r ' SFltrl#g;fi*trflEt'ffiA HfflffiIEtrtt' TE tr HffiEffi fr.#+fr.,I4*iHiFE{Eil rfiffi '
rE f'Jt Sr 'm E rS W l S rtrl ffi fg-tr { E r f f i | +8,14FfE IEJ H+lEtfr,,fr,FFH' ffiE tE " ......8 E
It #H ' tfr.EHEHffim'L'ffif"lffi ' Eltr.' Ifr++FlJ+E Hq[ffiEgE /., {t,t HE r+HfflrtP.fi w+tr w . E El
H E {Ef"lffiE-€ tr'lE -iflffi -ifrt. frlEE
ffi ' rm/FrnH + tr'lffi ffiqFffiEgEtffi , IfrtffiH 'lE" r sI
m ' EfrletF€fiitffit. frl;={r=fi " " ^{8ff.J+|.
iHH fl E f! E fb Wi+.'ttr WRffiffifr!ghh;.ftfr EW E
[:) +trfr#trffJHg tr tr',4tr'tj )\ffitk* ffiX fll ffiffi " H H ffi fi'.]ffi# F.fi
FJtE
E{EFfEqFffiXEEgffiA " AA HHHffiE+4,[4ft]T
frnR| )FffiW.trt&trffi.t ffiffitrlAH, ' fr+g-#trl
ffiFl^{E'['SFtEEffir{E/.f'lI HIir Xffii*fl.J' EfEil
ffiffi , ffisM'4gfl | 1E'lIt f[ | Eft'Wt flsfr.l/.T
zFn DITE + g E F,l{E/t tr fblfr,TE[Hffi,E€ {E/. 4
tr1'ril\tffi{+" Elffi#gF'l | iE'Wt fr.EEEHffif'lEg
^H, UTE[€ffiAr+ +H+' mE[Hffi,tr | #Hft1trttft t
ffiPH rutg ffift H lfrfi'ltr# 4e, m|.rH+ 4 2+ ' fr'E
^ ",E{Eil r#Hil1trtf,.tFtEtr#H+f.]fft+"
'fTZ#ff " mHmA , #{H{H#E t+fr.l frl#g ' Ftl)F
RW.trJ#trW.ffitr+{Ftrft )\ffitE,Atr'lffiE ' W.kT (g fHff ,&' # g -ifftrlFf,ffi H rttIFXfr T Etr lFffit.
ftS)'fFffit ffi2E fl H tit'Y+ -F[#3{nEfi A H' +#9 ffiH'l
W4\' {FEftrHffif'l#Htrtfu?+ffiffiIE' it-ELEH
ffiDlk'{F.ifrtr!E g il1H fuZWrl E lE.lE#E I E & s €-{E/.ffi tEtrlH{U . f{ rfr,HInffiE- )t hffi , IF.fr
ffiEg ' FU )FRW.ilTEg #ffif+iFffildffi*-f;Er# ' pFD -fE rmftft#{ffi s3-tffi
Zffi (ActioDei) ffitffi ZE
7 TH_ (Praesentia
Dei) , f ff {fi frjtr X (DasDir-Dasei") ffi f }il
4g lFffiqFffi tr!ffiFffi Wt HHXt.TJ ' EiF,fffiE
5u o
l tr JI ' Fl ;z5
47 E -L 'F 1 8 " 51 o
l q JI ' Fi z6
48 I EJI'F 2 1 " s2 l E l I' H 28 "
4e l El t ' F 2 5 . s3 l E Jt 'H 3o .
RW.IRffiFH,{tISF )FRW.ftlEEffi.' lffi=H , )F?W.f,.1#g#{r"1FEftsffi
)
. I'
t (DasDir-Dasein)'m # rK'fLft.HH
ItfffijZE Ef6ffi Eg{ Fffi l - ffi +i t H '.1
tH l fr .t S{{E/.ffi ^4{'4f" 7
tr-{Elmffi tr (Dasein) HIIW
trlEtfu' ffiffi#tr-ffiW ffifr'.]
W'&.'TEffi H f! tr I+mtffiu illrfa I+.,mE
LffiF!H HHE,tr#H +fr,ItrF{ftHil11frE..++
f+ ' f;HTF.7 ^
EH1E,rrl-fr4{4t IFffitriEF!tglE'lLt 'f[ ttffr.
. EiFE EEEHffiWi*.HInft,M{4F!EE$"
(Kotingenz) {4J IFffitrHF'!r frEIL.t . ElJtr' EgB,!ffiff{'gE{E
+tr tr'lEgEffi | ffi+kft#{trr
ft!Ht-u)LftlFffiW- LHE WeEre{#,|.+E#, | )F?ffir,lEtrffi.ffitr# t 2
E.
E F'IOEFEffiftjtriEm ft,Mil7l-/.{tt H +' E fr.^
-D;ffil .
Y.ffiEHffitr'E
,1.' ffig=FUE^H+ Zffiffi , |nY{HEH"];ffis+ ' EEE
IFffiEirtzA , HH trIEF,.:ffiH ' E 55 2.Etr.ffJ#g
Hffi..{JffiEg
f6trTEZ<E HftAHE.F,.1. fl(f tr.]IEft 2E' M frEtr.f$ EE.F,!EgF fuqi*fi.] FfiFE' - fi A #ffi-HffFNE,
fHEf.lffiA ZF"f ifi8", tfr,tffiA t EEHEHffi:aiEE E Etrr'JH H t #+f Hil1ft&F"tr tr H!tr,B, E *fr+ *+ft.
{E/.WIFffi/.ff'lEgB! | HIfir 2F"1tr!fHE ' mEHH"l N ++.fll fflE g ;ffiDtE-re-#{'4
fi tr fr.,1'4 H g ffi F!F Hfi,
F'.1
I H [ii {FEt ffi2e " | AFRW.tr1#g #.ffiffit FnW t).dfi-a,flEgIFffiFFF W&lffiFE .
' UEE DlEgfl I HIil ffi+,1'trltffi2
ffii*..trlF"lFE
+ E ffi ' mE{ERfrH$'l'J'H fir,flt{'4
4 6 tr {'4fr!E €tffi '
e, DlltMF tt tr Hf,HF!'['HtH
FFfrEEtrFn&W,fntr ' E&tf Eifr., &EgE rffi+t +ft.+U{$ ff!E g -#f€A tr{4 ff.J ffiH.;ffi' E ffiEg -iffi
EU
friEr f!HtfET' H{Eil /.E5UroE ++f!F"lffi ffiif ffir* E r y F F ,* F . f r-FTffi fT F - trTHtM EziftF + # .i l"'l ' fE
H+' FitEEg twE+nHfttrtBfrx,ffi#,ft+kvlR|='ts6 ff r'.1' B=#,['4f!Eg;fiFtEz.WtfrfiKtr RH F,.]Hg;ff,
{F -Eg tfifr.+kH',
fr'.1H+ tfi ' e[ff i* ffif frl{fiE " IEIHv*t T ffir&EE [Ftr.J. 6 E{4 ft.]H g;ffi se,
ttrtt-",P,fr.t1
EFtiH # # W 7 D IrS H , fi l E fi I reH F n E F ' ! 4 E f # E g ; f r H HIF # H T EEEfr \+ .fr "M) JEE EH ffi H 4
+EffiEgffi F'lffif+Frt' {FEE E E*ft#ff Eg ;fiflffi
+fr,,+fr- I#ft ^mi* ffifteF'!tF[Er] ffim T " E {#F fftFtlffi
27fr, Wrfi.H+kR*fi+kZffi " fi ft HE'f#tTf;R s ' +EAEA {11tr.*frg1ffiTH.TE TfiEIE,f[FHffiEg IAMI+
E +krE+k
HtrIHE€frTilff.JFfiffi .
fHE fflH+ IR, "rfrP.#tl7 E'.+I'"' "' 4g B[Efi H E f'].F
F' IFJH+ XEfi f f '{FI+t1 +,1" i&E ftF fi 2lfH"l+ FAf*Y! r^1 fffi ( H H iftlF€ ) trnFft Wtr ifr(R
trt-ffi^E
,L., E +kffirffi zlflft.JF,L." " fffitrl;t';ftH+tr r ffi-/. t Vrf,l{$+ l-y'.t 91fiE ' EEf}
24
ffiw.rRwffiH'{tffie )F?#.ffiagffi.' lffi_H , )FfrW.t1etrW.r"1FErtEiH
)
Ftffi/. tr ffi-^BtliE €'Bfi' mW4F[ F E E Lh.ill€[ E E' Hermeneutik, , 1969, ffidlH (H-trHfrH-#H')
Benziser +;+4HE r frx1ix .
ffi E H ffi ' (H -#H Fffi -H H l . ' E [4s .
EE r i._-W4 trlHEF tttrlRffiF.*f;ft
' aA
E E E H ffi ' (ffi +€ffi) ' prz a "
75 t {Hf ( GerhardEbering) AEffi HEE Hffi f! ffi A E ffi F pE{Fffi ff g fiSffi,kil1 lF R #ffi
ffi ffi -{E FF\'4R . (FF{ E ) , H t4r-r47 (H ei nri c ott)
h
' D } & .^ffi ff t{ H ft
ffiftffi{Effittf.l+f lH ' F,HeinrichOtt,ReatityandFaith,Thetheologicat tegacyof Dietrich
6e t ' H r o 3 . Bonhoeffer, iEffi&ft . EEEFffifr.:ffi+#E)
<frtrfrtrfF- ' (Fortress Press
To lElt ' F1o4 . Philadelphia)' Fr18-120 .
Tt 4F. <n-nHffiffi-#'H) +#49= ' f,xlvi " 76 Hffi4+: GerhardEberling, (EF{E) ' Ftlo-120.
26
R#.IRWffiH{tffiP JFRW,ffiEE#., Iffi - H - )FRW.H,.]ES#TF{FEftEiH
)
H ERffiffifl II{4fffiit o "' "'T#fxt)t#i*FlJ ' t, l?.H D)&.Hft " ElItrEffi H H fr'lFffilfif+Ebt ffi ft H fl'
t)tfxh.i*
Fu ( wirkgesetz)
eI"HIfi.lIFIRtr " ffiE€UEA fr €tJ H ftft 'fe/.' H fi^mH ffi,Z+ " HtmfEffilfriFfi3Els:il&
#w zFf,#Etr . ElmHHEElEffifrfff . "
ffiz+HtrfltrT Hfllffith- ffi ffi {ft?E' ffith- ffi ffil{R*EnE-ffi6fr?
r-ffiI ftEEEHffiE*E l-4tr{4ff.JffiI (r,ttnit Etrl ft,# (Dasein) E -ffi +E)JffiEgE'l-t#t6f;ft!l[
o ft,ft. (sosein), l-/.4HTEAI\MilT ,\frffiE- zcffif,q
negativum)' fft]# rfitrft{+f']ffi1 @nn privativum) "
r ffiI Ef'JLZIRi.rn'Eff.J (Zweiheit),EE ffiff E -{Eut fl{& Fffft f,q+ ffieE )\
WR' €lJffH ^mftl H trlEf5-l[
tffi r-Effi Ftffi I fllEfE ' E{EilEfsEtffiW4f! H il]tfr.Effi{$(Geschdpflichkeit)
) " " EfE E'l+*F.re.T HH
^A Hte€lJE#,friHft(frill€Uifi tr.K!trtr.]HfrfETf Etr E.H-,*.ill' E{Eilft,!trFiE
ffiTqfr.
Hf,HIE " Elm rt.ffift,+,H 8J
.
AfriH H Et'EtrHtr.] H H' EilE{E ffiIfi.AffiEE{fi
)EWlRffiZft,4.F!
+ ffiHf'iieffiBlJ ElH . t' LffiHltrtrl
fr#F"fiE H H, IfrffiHtrI&EH H, ffiAftlWI+F1ffi7 ffiH 7Effi AfrtH?HE *trHEffiffifi "
/.f.lt.ffit th.AfiWftfr rffi7 rffiff'l/.t 80' ( - - .) AFIffiZH BIF F R
28
RW.THWFH{t+p€ )FRW.illEtrW.,
lffi-H - /F#ffi.trrBtrffr"1EEftsiffi
)
t-......E-{
;ffH ifi + tr H ft'lHL+.'....fi g D}m, fi Elu, ffi-Fr . FHn9,EfrfrffifHffi,E
ts
EIE# lr E-fE g iflil1+.lfrZffi ' mMHEIfrT " EEAr
, +kHl (rl{ftF^]{t{H)" +X , +fi,H?#rF.E^g
el..e+' ffi H ft'.],8fr q ffi fHF'.1R fr ' E A E 4 -#EEtr
{Er#F*.
Hffi H &HBfrE trl ( iFF1'rrtVt{t{H) - g + 1,fr.6t ffif+ffi*
H - &fu,VfrZ'tfr , l#HfkUH1ffiffiffr,FnF.ffiHtr-#-ig " ) n'
ft!M{8ffiR . EE tr-HffiY{ft.FN IFV!+-Bhf{ffi' TEffi ffi
E {Eq E E ;ff#!EH EE E Hffi ,EfS# R trIE H,['4 tr #$ F'!lFH;t';ffEID]11Hfi.1FfH/.,1.ff!rxtR ' E mE EELngl
q ' E&E lfr.FnHIFffiZF.lfHBf,\ffitr!ffi'Hl " +fr,{PTT{H{HF '*E- lEEJttH 4 iff+ trTl tr,8 3 =.8 tr F!F H{'4.
it,e,*fll1fr.frfr,ffi,E.ffiH'+*f
fr! ' Hft{*il1#8 ' ffiEEEF
ffiGIfrI,8.4TffiE +8,8.^H, IF- I#ffi# . -{E tr FU
ffiE F tr {fr.,B ffifr'!frE
iFF t1ffiWWtr"illft,W++.+'* ffiffi
f[ -fE #H " E,e.* ffi# +Eff# trlH fgH {frffi-f,q E IS'
rc.FnH IFffi+iHWffift'fHilsttr-mf,eflf,qtr " fr tL, r +k ^ rffifiat " Iff.rEg
+Er'j_tffivrFEIFHEffi.trltffi tH
{HEID}t+ffi-{8fif; ;fr , <IFFT fEF'.1{t iH) fr'.lH€H++'tY!.Y{ EE e7."'..FnE#
Fitr-ffiA' a Hffi.trr)t !fr.#f+stl frtfr.o
EHffi*ffiEft 7 -IREP$' {EEfr-I*,X*ffiqffi ' H e8......z-EtrfEqfr.+k{H+ffi
/.TfE#m #AF,'tuffi # . ffi
Itrit{6{a HE ffif [ 14ffiffi# )FR W.
ffi+ffi fa]* + H fi ffi fi',.],8
nu # 97+frME^l r'J#ill fifr.fr." m,fHF!,E4 E fi iffiA epna a
ffif#ffiF"1FEffi€HEfrEXr " !ftrf , ({ffiIEg) E!EHfi nn
Efr!,K4' )
t, E ffiEH ffiE + VAffE'BrXWtr t? + /. Y{t ffiIFfr tr!
Etrg' ifrtr (l-Fi+#ffi)fE#lJ ' F Hf r l, Kq F l JEr i 6 r 7 A' r E-H tt+ + f.i l 1 l EE,
......fnH H H FtJ'+k+.tr + ffirrff.1 fr ,xrF+* F'l+Hrn'E/.,il'rE+[Hi tr]t Fl.... {eEffiF
H+ tttu+ E fts
E t ' t r Ht r + t r + ki r 5 *E[Eq [fi fr 4 9i.&8 ffi F fr !' E
iE* 7 , +krnE,z,r7lwill-tn ' FnE ft,F?,+kw ( {ffirE
ffiEF/. D]+.ftffi{t{H, 8 fr,Efr ' ElffiE,ffiLD}r,tr-
H) " ftm W*nE' Hfir{#ffif'.ln+ IR ' -ffiH4tr H
tr H +-ft. i0E ffiF H'.1,
H,.1 8 mtr,fr.#, E E,E,^ ' El
tkWT H t',g[H.ffi Ftt* T ++rLHft f! tr r)tfFffiil1iEg' Ff, .
g rfrfi+X*' E{EFF g lU+A/.E & ttuffi ffiE !fr.#/\tfff# ffiEF ffl, E zFnD)fr.ffiH ffl' EEI
frE(Hfr!) m
ffitriFtffi{t tr 7 H efi+V1Htrpff'l{tlH' r'ffi{f5EH
TE (*ffi!)
fHH XF'.1 r' tffi {t fr ffiH{tiHF!Rtr#ffn{f5*ffi4E
ia {EIPE FPH,.] E6ffi+ -# TF H F,.],8, fi. F ffi {HtrI,E -TT{E . FEFf,.]fr.' E,E,E.+' EIffit.ffi ifiT?E,Ifu
4r , rEItttrFHifrr ' r+grc.W&tFft.l#ffiryF
ITI +i€ -DHAffil EEEHffiY{EffiEgEAfr'1f!ffi s7 HEEHffi, ?-frt;+ ' (if Ht€ffi{tfH (H-ffi ) ) ( Elll,^.Rfrffiird' 2000)
Hss"
i* ' E&E tkxlfr.trlFiF,E,fgH,.l+F Ffiffi' 98 lEt' tr 34 " /.{4 iE,( XFIE't+tr + h Et8fttJ' # anK /. H fdg {H{H{HH 6'!& H mifi ffi
74Ef'! (Effi) H#' Efttgss4;t'4ft8trefrFfiffiH+E€'tE& . F.A{ffi-H'H
es EEEHffi, (l;i+€ffi) ' Hr83" =Hfi ffi---Rfitsf,tl,^.F!tr'df.lF={ffi
"
'
96 GerardEberling(Ffr'l=) ' frtoa " Itr l I ' FJb
o
34
RW.IRffiWH{tTH€ (m=F - 1FffiW.WEtr#.il'tftlrffiE)
)FffiW.WEtrW.'
v7t|+trbH , +EftEH+i{ffiF!4ft{t'H{tlH
' mE+Etr, 3n' FUE-{8,E,frJ 104'H'',\'fH+*q7g{Et)t#g g1+.fr
+ft.f;Afniffi
" ffiHffi,E,^ffiEtffiE FLAHo '* ) qHE4.ftlE&ffiffiH'E^],E ,
^ffi28+ # LttF,ftJfS# "
E M{EY{U N,.],fE[ A ffi tr = {HWA TAEEEH ffi fEH H! HA, E1gHffif'J,8.^ffiffi+ffi
' EIfr.JE.ffHH+HTF,fi!
| AF?ffi.trlBtr
ffi.-t fHEflff!F"1ffi, l-ffi{HtfuffirEEf[glH, T r"1,['H
H r& - ff l#fftfr,ffiH{EE
Xift+H,T:nll=+HE-H.Ifr /. E + #'['HB {Ffn
frt# " fli iruF'.1
H fL ' EEEHffi tF.tr+*|fr,#flE' ,E'f FtE if;H +,ffi
( -ofl
t-ffi 2E word) ' it tr EEEHffi ffi,K^mf"1EtrlFffiffitr 9Zfz{#affiefr,ET#f[TEfr!/.r 10s',Kfi-A
{H+E+F
W'RtrtEf+SlJ 7 ffiHEEEW# E' E MWIE,=#A {ruEK-iff
fU,E
q.{FffiFTAE*MZ<Effi+N
.fL' EEH n#trW.1?,il1ffi%-#/.{ruEE
| ffiffi.frThfr"
fEffiE l-tffiIFfrffI' MTE
101
)'.lFHfr.lr . E{Eilf'J Fltft.WgEEtr HEE.Hffitrdl fr 7 A {fr.RW.4HE ) 106,D)lF"ffi fr!lRte.ffiHv,K4 " E fER W.
g
f+f;s F'.1 fr!IrffiEyf tr E+EEillffiff#'0"
FfiFE' ff+ftsry frzN ^ffitr E tr.]Etr E M]E.HE EHffi E X E fEA Y{U ff.J'
-#
tr ffi+fr*gl+H frW.##H#, fr Vffift,K
ffiH tr.],8ft.F[EE fE+EE'ME fE+EE TE *EfiE ffI . +H ^ fr"fifr.#rfiffi
F'.1-ffif; ffi.*n-i#'E Ifr.lFF1{frFtffi& ffi,. .....' tz.H,iE
*il1trnw.#f.l ffiffieftstrFU'mE-f84 ft ff.ly{i.f; '
E g f'.1
F'.1 E g #t,I,tr g FIffilg.H{FFT1ft.il1 HE W., fri19.
E gf'J fn{Hffi;f;E &wru{H ( sf;s + fr'.] FlfE) ffi H IFl1tft.F'.]E E W.,X'f^E iq H Eg F'.j H g W.. E Ihffifr
;f;- tt " it T E ie {ruft,-'-R,-#ieE E g tr tht t+i\ie H'!ft -{E+fr*ff!ffift" 'o'
A' mE i0 iHfHIA|fi,fi"] Ff;f[ ft + tkt -'tury'i*d
ie E E g -
" iO{Hl?.H E fEUW.i#- ffifi - tr FUffi84 F'.1
+fr*WffiA tr
^gifr.$fii*,-a{;#Hg ' mrlEfR
^ffiEEfttrl - ftffiw.a\fiErffi |
' FitEFnnEHffiFn+Efr )FR#9.il1H9
ffileffi # H E f'.1;f;FE " FfrD)trtEXfr,E r'Jf! fi {ruT
EIHE-6fr;#Hg mE H+ X Tffi E ifr,*lHfi . "' W.t+ffi#{Uf,!.
36
Rffi.IRWffiH,{tffiE )F#W.trlBtrW.' lffi =€ - )FRW.fi'lEg#.#'Jttf.fiEf,if
)
t:_, n77 .
I r r ltr-J 116 l EJ t ' F 20e.
39
g
RW.IRTHtrH{tif )F#W.il1#trW.'lm= H . )F#ffi.il1+trffiil'Jrrtfl|*HiE
)
40
RW.TRWffiH
{tffi€ , lffi=H , )F?#.il1F-tr#.ilutr
)FRW.ffiEtrW. ltffii+)
ffiE Hffi AEH' E M ffiTN#- EIE H {T5 f'If+E g ffi w.ffi- {E+ zHt ' {fiT E.I
H?,fr,Tffi#,#,ffiLk-{H
+ " +fi,
ffiH ftTIE f.]fr ffiftEffIU.T' E WftIfrF|'-{Jffi f,!' #g {ru#EE{stltrffi- IH+4if; ' mfi{r5fH{=FIh.-.tH+,
w.ilTffiAtrHr+trtHT RH , -fEWE F.118lfriffiHffiffi ZiE 4Fr r 124HEEHffi E=#E mI+E^ftfi3f6 ZHH+iE
4 . EIffi/.'fFlT{E'fHE#t#ftffiA , m-EL+fr'#fi}ffiAH -DW+'IHT WtfrZ#ff.1^iffi '
tkff l-FEt ff.]tlEA I ffi rfg{El 'lffEf #Afg\E FnD)&.HF 4 ffi{Hab freffi2_4, Bilfr.tr4 tr!* S
r ffi€uE7 fl.n#/. E ff.H+' f;FIEJ H+-#^HAt' #ill EIffiA Hffffi{HAfTffSfE 2#WWISH ' MEHSEIts
E&' y'.{ru;,K;frEtJ7
' e[^mi*ilgffiE{EftE ' f'Jrffi-ifr 2#t ffi,H{g
fr3t6 FIE#,, ftHS E ftS
-#rtE#f'J H E ffiffi'lRdrui+' ff EF ffifcf'lF&Ffft&7,1{' rzs
+.ffi.f!tr{Effiffi" ^Ic-rglffi.z_#'
Affif # A'lg{Ft ffiH!Hft' E m{OEtr tr nHtr tr!ffi.
feffi"&" fttr' )\ fl-#';trSlItffiV1ffi,ffiepW.H;d-#SIJt A trIEfr.f[ #,R, E.EHEHffi trI;frffiH,+ E M {+
ffitrl8., ffn{A{A{e{H11 il1*' e[T7F.FE
ffiH t ffif'Jru{ffi fHtrEf, ffi ' Em frE l#l+ilT$'['F' mff fr U&.)\A Hill
'ttuXtrl^lm'& 4 t){EFfr E MA Wh# Lm . Elffi?re
f'Jrffin^lgifly{H94.frf!)tF.fl"
rEH'zth.fi'ltrnxF, LftT-F'trfrH fi Hffiffi ' #.R4
ff€me 2' l&Ef #'lg{FH+rfi , Effi'lg'J'R^{E; lff
6 f'.1H FlJ E +?{fl' Etft#.R fi ffi 7 /. ftltjj+.wfrnw
iE+#fg'l'RA'm{' ' lffES#fg'lRgH'
4 Iffitg'lEi*ffi BW " IEtre.Eg ^ffi zth fr.lfrnEft ' IW#tr^Hffi,E#
' iffE+#{g'['RRH' Fmfflf{'R^mi*'fuE
EIffiffll{'RHft{ . F F U 4 E;E,' ,fi m SS'
f f l' m f f T E f R ffi ) .ffi ffi ,a
2W ' iffE+#tg'lEtrH2W , Efffi'lg\EgE ' """EI E 11H'{ref#ffi 2H frWt H."'..aA -#f+FU' E f E tr H F'!
DlESrl ' EffifEfuqH+HlEWfr rtiEH4ffi " tzs r-,,\.t rfS#t ff.l/." EffiEE8frJtr4f;nmT{H{HE
F-ffii^r fEH Y{t ffi trliEH ffi Xff H H ft....liE
H E FI ff f' trliltffi , =-aA{[,1.
H g LWH ffiFn+AFJ fl ^mE E
,
il1',ffiX.EEEHffi+RT/ttr!EE fr#.REm{+xt*tffi ^,L'
zth.fl tr E 4 !$ffi.+FfirE # Fn+Afi.] fflH_*fi' RT E --
2H ' ElmiEffigm {+4f;3f6 2# , EeT fr.WtrFfitr {H r-ffi;t*E{HtrlEFt/.ffi'fiffit126 ^,1.
" EEEHffi+Ffr 'E
Wft l-,,\.
tr fr'.1 I ffiT'lH,'{re.mHE iFtr tfr,P.Rfi3tfrZSE I#ffiffi E Will ffi tk?1gh, fr,-Ff.E fSKft # t624 ffi ffi th.
,nBtrtaxft wtfi2+ + fi fi a H ffl " Tsffitrftl-FU{S{effigE F'.:ltfr * ) 127,EE Ht ffiE
EEg IFffigE.f.J,['4 HFNiAEff.J .
H!-F_ftil#.H
H ftufi3tfr24 zHt f! -
lT^ft Wtffi2S E FnH HE
,E (,-Fi+#ffi)+€'F-anEEffiFiS
+JJ , tftltr#,H'fr|| r24 FEE,Ftffi'(H+€ffi) ' Hze .
rzs EEEHffi, ({frE+) ' Fr14 "
1 2 6l E l - t 'f i r r s "
r23 l E I t ' F r r r . r z 7 H L ' H l 1 9.
ffiw.tRT.E^ffiH{tffie , lH=H - lF?#WBtr#.trtttrEBflit
)FRW.ft1EE#. )
H l r4 ft F'.1fr#ftr' H m fi ffi i * 8, f r / . f [ _ h
f f iff+,ftH '.1ft'! tr (ntndung) , H H E 4. f t t r ! HH ffWt1gh. Ff,flrfE | +trfi@,trftfStr (Ncichstentiebe) mf/g
#, """ lfr.fniEHT +kF'l H HAdtfrEfi'.lF,ff
I 136, EHE
(Fr e ih e i t)" . ...rtrH E fi !tr + gFttr E H'+! - f rf f i
E f fi.tfl++i+.fr^ffi
ll '{s fi hfi
HH '.]+ " fr!F HH ' f t # Hffi 4IT ffKfH trIE},H]KIY#HiE#EVEJlEtr H ) ffiWH
( St e llvertretunI ) f I f+ e H ft ( wirklt chkei tsgemaBheit ) ff! ff', ffiwtn+ fily{;f;x inEA'fiffftItueRffitrtfHE fff}S{HA
(setbstprufuns) F!rutrfaffi;a;# , mTE D]ffiffi.TWF,rnffiHtfE '
8t ' H H#BEffi+.frtrnt1fiJJil1Hfn'fftffi fil
F f,Hft f+f'.1tr Fft'(wasnis)" ttt E ti.f+ffi(pylades)' ffi,t ffi.t&trlF
*E[effi H,!ra*{ff .
H{ f tr HH
T f f i Ef f i t r i # H H E H ffi ffH T A ffi ,R f;N. f f * HiE f f i (I p h i g e n i e ) , R H , L . f r e Z i P I h f r l i l H Y _
lfr ' --aK;fr
F'!Ef, /.4 H + FfitEHfr1fre" (GenieJSen)
AH "
46
+F€
#w.tRw^ffi-H,{t , (ffi=€ - )F?+*.Vl#trt'-trJtfr.lrBE#
)FRW.WEtrW. )
50
RW.rRwr4H'{tffie
tr ({ftr E H ) E !Fff
frefr\ffi tk -#r , (rnF l; H; f t t r #EgE=
afrz t +' EEEHffitr+*+fttr |Wtr;f;;Etgffi,tHfrZ
)Fffi#nfrrt#g
W.trrRffi
Htr
o "" "Htr EtnlEft.-tffi 2+
(Daswirktiche) . EE-tffi
DlkffiFrt ffi " I "' WIft' tr;f;fi!EF ++trtt$sEtffi E ffiff EEE Hffi fHEE { A W}FR #'.fi!E tr W.,8. fS
ffiffifE,I h.TEHEF TETA, ffiE W)FR#'.H,.]
tr F,Iffi E
zEftffiF + ffiHffiE, Yttr ;fifl'.]H#+ +trffi.*.# tr y{
tr ;f;AFE E Fit. ffiF /. ' ff.F 9q/. ' /.9q^ffi
In1ttr. )\2 F"liFi EW,Rffi#ffF'l(l-at+9ffi)-gF'lfEfEff,FE " Erft
ef!ffiffi r + + ztkr ' EIIEF ffi ;,{ H r ;E,H 'g { fi
xtrlF El "
{flFfrfFP frl#krrfl
ffiFl'[,H'eE F H W*.{fr+ f,l-{E A
EEEHffi fr.+*TXF;.{ffi (Ft + gffi ) -g +'
F'.1 Iss'
HK#r EIft , ft,EffiH eFn€ffi.ff.J . F HIfl
r&ffi t1WX H 'tfrf.lfr.E
EEb)J E tr ;frH thhflft Y{F E A n'.1IrlF w +.ft ff;ttr* *EHfrH ffifnE *f ad# /. #Hrfr*.fvE fE,
tr#H F!+frffi.
trertnyttr .
Effi Ifr,WfrSmf[ffi R E_iFfe,ffist3rrE,[,ss##I \
rEfHtrIffi#t - l-+i,4+.H,r-.#t- l-EE#ffifr!
,,fr rffiEHffiflAt - rlEWfrfrtFfr'll) Is4#tj*
kT th-wftE{EU.FfrlfEE .
ll-rl l " l l . ' H i ' 2 6 ' 1 2 7 " E€ ffi.ffilRX,F ftH " t s g E E E F f f,i ( F t $ € ffi ) ,H r .
15 : l l l l l l i t ' i f t l r i ,( f i i h I EF /) ' H3 1 3 . rsa lEt , flz-a "
{t+Hry
ffiW,IRWtrH , lffiEH - )FffiW.f.1+g#fflR€Hffi#
)FKW.WEtrW. l
/. ffirft lfli-a:-
E )\ffi ffiF F!Efs +, nEHl?.HWF-'ft F{r+f!q t+mtrrft^H HrAE n'.1'Ff,E -#,, hEEffitt
, iEHftEEtr
FlSiEtfi"ffiffl4 EfrXr+XHEt/.trl IHDeus^
XAlsFJt*t&TE E.9. "r "'HfE*fifrlFEEtr'ffi+.' ffn& exmachinalsT , H\,1HA
' ,X,#,tfr, #fu fU/\frTffiJffiAeffih
HF+F'lmfEEi+ 2+ ' E,-m-i*+Eie{f5 *#-'aK,HX rl
tr*+gtr @ffifitfit+tr8[+Hrt , ElJlt, IFm-ffiDeusex
""
machinafi'ltffi E Fi T & #,ffi o rss
RH trf€r'JE{EtrtlfrtffilEJE+F HIAfr"l/., n*
{FH E fr"lg{E 4.fF'' fi ffi#ft. ffitr!f"lFEf[ E+trffi-{E E trMAfFE 7 -IH^ffiiFtrIF+{t ' EEtr AIU,F,.]ffi
)'. , t HE
rHfr'.] tr E-aK;##IJffi.fr-WRH!F l-fu" ;/'.++Hfi' l-^ffilF I ifi Zi{t #*n + +'ft tr {Arc,+F ryFn-'a$,
.iFT ^
ffitr! rtffi E.ni' mEtffilfr.ffiE\TLXF4yfi tr!f;EH
ff , TN+F.Tr,IE SiE"]F A Ffiffi E tr.TE.,ftft €' +gT
A tr!& A +j\E' ifi H ft ffiXtrl'fH
lEl'fH'fEffi /. +.#H #tT 2r[' F[iF/.{f5 W+.if; |
EffiHTIAMfi,il7Rffi'14 t o
pFH'.1{Hffi' EEr'J,,t#-.t2H#ffi F tf/bHi' mE 8 H H ft , EEEHffiH# gtJEWfil,['g{Sff +' +Iffl ffiln
e E ff ft3f6F E tl- {E#KHi . E r'i f} ffi;frE + g w.Ew 8 { E/.n n F IH y{ t' ffi"l 1 5Le
f ih + & 7 ' f f if t f fi r "1 ffit-
Ef,,1.+.ft Ef+.H# fi'!- ffft{E/. m
tr!ffi+L' E E tf *13
*13 ffitrtrtTE'ffMYffil{r z 4Ftrlt&{-yEIE{tfdgffiHY{6fE
^ ffifE#[trfb/. fffi4F h?ffiJrFtu9
E' rftSffirEI ffie#' #KHi , E+fr7 lF n! /. ffi It ' yi iF fft l=o{fi ffi z<lEy.IV,H
|
ffiEFStF++tffiftEt ffifr.] tEft t Fftffi * E!ffiff fr/.F"l F Zffi fr'V'{tuX' iFff!ffi'f+tr',ttrTffiUf[H H S S . fiffff
156.E Tfr{fr.NBE')I
TFfr,.J I IfrA I ff!H ft frTR' ETEtr FT,ffi E"]tr
Hfi fS# . 4 FfE HE EHffi FN fEH tr"]I )F?ffiffiffi
ffsr ffia+k{fi+Ez\ frJ"
rtnffiffift1+F.Wffnfr tFts' Ef,JEtrH!+EH,HffifrHfl 8.1#,trtr -frm
El\ lFffiHtr+frH'+ElF fr.lrg fUEEfr,.ltr
frTffirc frx' ffi
ffi-Fff ' Ffr : P|*ffi
ffiffV#*ro H9trrF A H#fr.WH'T'['44x{t 7 | Ifr,At f+8 trlrk'lE'14' fl -
EEEHffi-'nK,ffiIEH+'ftE
r-fi ffifr!trf1r' /'{ru4H frffiE/. lFffiHfx+frH' Hff SFffi{# I+rtn^ffi{fr ffitft?fr
RWTfiIFffiffi +UWf[4#H#trl#ffiE. EIffi'
I&ffil"H{H fl' +*AT FJH+{tTlEuF,ffi.+'i{EF! | Ifr,AlE;ff "
r ffiE ftsfiffi*ffi,il17: ffia#FEEEEHffi-HEfi,L'ffl+fifie (Fi+#ffi )
( ffiH11Hf!ffil{E) stl7 #9F, fr. ffiI+gJ7ffitr'.lH# .
H /.f.lH
^n4?h , RW\4ffl/.tf-#tgT Lffi , (fr,
Aifr./'fFtrffi)J4'*z.H+ ifrtr rfiffi F'.1trf?
r tgF'!HE A ffiEEffi
Vt#rH, fr.
-ifr
TF ;#frrEffiLffi 2E - gftS ffiEE
E .
r55 lql I : o
' J = lz
1s6 f+ffii6 fftfr #4, D #fr1\ ffi{Hf E, - ft lFffitr+ + * Lffi +t{l1ffi# f! E g fr t # F! ts7 -ffi&ffirFJ#lF+HHlJ'tH#F, ffiUtj..H^+nftE$1ffi*$' lrHWiltfrE "
'tl.w,'- fr:tF.ifr' 7?/.,L.A #i ffiffi{Fi6 ffiR&E tl+.H, 4 F.ffiEHffi ffi r-4 g rsa EEEHffi, (ffi+€ffi) 'Frze "
3fir f-];frit t ((H-#H'ftH-ft€') ) '! 15eHeinrichon. ((H&E{E.f4r)'
lElHt'H.sz.
55
RW.IRffiffiH{tffiE jFffiWil1*Effi , (ffiw-F ' )F?W.ill#tr#.ff'JRfigffie
)
A HA ffiJffiE EilaE' T;ft E ffi E;E = E E tr.iFlffi;f;;E tr ill " l-f; W'Wf.lHfrfEI fHfr'.lErftr-{HE;FHF-
ft ffi ffi-E--I+# E"lH+{t ft,ffi7' ft ,L.f[,R,1' fflH+'ft( E T ffi E.D}Affi + frHtrIH #,ffitr+A ffi.+EE- {EFf,ffi trIM,
{t rtr-#,ifr,E
f6H+ f; W.+H WH+
{t ) fr,ft,tr"7 " fi'fruE-E A' E ffi E]')(TEWtrIE.f; ;Effir ffiq fr N IFffiMHH E f*
-{E ft,4.19H#W.H'!
fr ffiJ H+{t ' tEftffi /.'fHffiH TF EI ftEX' mTEF€- lHEffifr'.1W|+Ef* " ElJlL,tre.H#1
Ha^E. H RW.-FiH. FFiHE ffiS rt5tr-#Ite+EH E ffiFtE r ff + ^Efrg fl +F, #E FU *filfi + f€lFIt T H'!/. f6+F, E[flfrft,
ffi'\Iil tl /. ' F.''rfrl 9.H H 11E ,,FnD ) ' Hlt u { f 5 f f if lj -#
+Fe ff iFff.1fn n'.1Me' g {EIgfiSffiffi fr iFe H frM Flfi,
I Rffi.{tff!I HS {F ' mtr E |'t+ftHfEft,+T lEH!F E " 7 -fEq EFffiVlf,\ffi,ffifffi f,F' FtJEtrfrffi.
' m ffiffifr'.l,E
fn{HH {HillH 1eo0+!&,7-ffiEtr!E g W.W{€ ;#fr ffiry' F,.],8 Bf,I#, D}'gre f'J+FH,.]
ffiftrFTE.?.ffi B ++ffIIE
ffi " EE
I&frHtr!EE ffi | RW.{4ff'JHfr f€I " fi{f5fffffiEE Wtrl EH ffifl ff,ffiftff ' 4tlR E fE#ffi.tr1ftf; -
f#T H €' -,x9.
R E - tr #[ E Rffi.F,.:-fEfHfr ' & ;+E - fEtr iEffI{F ffi;ffiEfi#ffiHfr.W6 . fr[4/.irurgffiE{8fi#f#^ffi6 -
fr'{BE'fiR H F-E -E 'E fE fr,W i l lrH f r +t Ef t ' a T E g R W,#H F!* IfiJ X € *EIAI Z
EfxT' mTEefisE /.XFHft*E tr!-fEffifr-ff! fr g ffiiEFtffitEFtfl' /.{ruffirtu| D}frfr.Affifr #F.hft
H+ f! tr,it' ruRfi,fHEstj7'ffi.trTH fi w.glwFp'ffir'J 8 tfr,ffiffit ffi DlEg ftgtr!;f;eEIFH *ffi ffi Htr' f+/.^F
fb r F^trffi. t HqfrZItWWt,z'* EE^H trl{H{E ffffi7 ffiffiflf,+H) 162
" +HHtr!fi#ffiffiFE
4 B,Eg W.tr)FRW.trlH+ {t FnW++ fr E, ffiW4
ft.] TtrIffift,'&fr,Rtr.EEEHffi +R I RW.IffiAff.JIE,Sf Ig'
*Etr W.t*,a,^6 K # s' E A ffw.ftq6f;;Etr!ffiffiFH
ffi=Hft. BFffffiWfrtt++Wn-fr.
;# " r-9ftsfr'.1EEfiE++Hrffr.r4 Iwfiffi ' tf
, =;#
^4ffio 161
=4-#F'l+ FP.IF | ffiW. r , i. EHEHffi ffift-{E W.Wft.El=o &ffi ,
;il egff!+ F9. frtr trlE ,L'F!fn I ffi
-T,illft
iffiE tr { {ftff.]r F HH - fr.F'.1 + E'['4WnFfr.l+'mE A A[XEier-{;frtr]+,1.ffiffi " i&f'JI RW.t f!-#s H 0REE
E {Etr tT+trl?.H l+'l-'ltFg f,'l;EF T E E E /. trl;EE X# f f it r l+ + ' t f f - , H ft,Etr f' Jg l WH|RffiW.t ff.1
ffi .F .;{
ruH'.1, FnDlgftSfr!;f;--#IFffir ffi2E E{EHt+EE t ffiF a, Ifr,W tRW.r ffl#+ilF-|+-{El-fiffiff.lEf1rZffi
+ET H # ft1' ffi fEf+F"fi = FU E IfrH.sEg f; Frt^mfi W.fi!..E
r {EUF n'!'f+ /| ' H Itr' ff I-=. MtI4 ilTffif#frE/* E IFffi
f'Jfi trJffitr8 ' E tn.trA#,,tE Fl,-tfiffiH., ==,K.ffiE
f!' FtJE Efr\,l.8!fi;ff" EffiFATE-ffiilftj(gftS) EE
+B'.1tffi ^ B+' SH,e,*#trlEAffi'lH,
2= ffi.*.#+-trll#l+ EHffi f'!;frff +' E tr W.t frtr E ffif; W.fri^H {eRW.HIJ
= E ffi iHH,! ,RW 163 . EI
E DIE ifrAlfrg_fllKqB,ffit+i* F TEE
'WDlF-+.EHtrIHffi FfiFEE+F!ffiflt.'l+ A 2F"18W-'nH.Ifr'ft
F'l;frtrFttfil*BtW, Dlh.E++fr. ( (ffi,8e) ffi#) H'
roo EEEHffi, (Ft+9fl6) ,Htzt " 162 H enr i c hott.( ( H &f{Ef F) 'H at.
57
RW.IRTEffiH,{tiSE )FffiW.A\#gffi.' lffiw# - /F#ffi.W*tr#tr]RflHffi# )
( ffi^ifr g ) qfr.+tffi
w rHryr.ltrt1ffiB'.1
i+H vffitr. a ffir&fH E H*Rnn fr zth , t HE
zffifr {EH+,zffiE\,fr.E +Elfr.tFffi
,fF' +EtffilFffi-{Etffi ffiffiFE' H *ffi ffifn,fF5fnffi fl -{E#L*ff Zffi,if;" -r 177
TE ' EEf'I+illffi# " Elffi^nffiffiEn-T4#4.rytfr. A. IRffi I IF H - ffi M Effi T {F ffi F !AF N f[H ,
t+thru+ftru8 ' EFtHffi# , Iirf#{H+8tffiffi FtT-{E t tr tr?,84frfif,7,8,fr ffi ffi *Iffi,ffi# t&ft.# fr EE " fr.
fitrH,!RE " I&el#.t+.1h.ruffi
+ffi ruE' m4 & *.,, ftfrft =#,'
FTE T{B ffi trI E F[flj H RffiIF ffiiEffi iE{Efr F E!
Effiilltkfffi.ZF.r 173 , r (f'JfliE{tft€/.flRW. IR : IIEtr LPEIVIUEHj ' EWE -{ET'fEiFflEF
ffi ) ftEtffi gfi 7 w +.ifrffiffif! rfi6' f{4.if; f.],iF'['ffi tr!+1tr4Wt ffiffiv-W" ElJtr, L'Z,rE+*.Hf$-{ETl=-
o ....--+rBhlfr,
frn'ffixillffiix. ( rE{t/. ) fr!ffi-fi i* ' E lFtrltrFW+.tfr2+' TF ;ttH H ft W.tTHgfr*ffi #tr
Hie#EA, ltrfrH#FnHE&ffiffi . ffi*rtn'ttuX , RT f.lT{ElH,fr"AlH*tIV,E " -t 178
, f +friru/*TFEffi
+E8 Rffifr.*fig1II
H E {Etr N-WTE IFfr!++.H' fHE StJ
fi . A ttr ,#k r H !frE E X 'E ef {E{ I T J A f f iW B k EZF . r I7e
F!EF,fr ffiffii\tew.F!{E fr< *,a ffiM{;u,,f E HE^HfiffiTft,aE^1ffifiruffihtfr "o ' Irltl EEIEEE
^lu.,
H ffi Efi,1.trlE HfiT {H{gtr ft/. XF4{'4q f; W.gi?rf, Ifr ' fr,
ffitkt H4HaFJ-{E /.-#;ftrffi .. ...tr m' ffiR E-Rfi T{H{HE#€ I==Mt ,
frft #.Ytfrf ffi'BX M,+frirt.* , ffi
I?.HIffiET'4t]R-,fE A T FFH E E\iE$]+ TEHH N frW W.ef;gEI RI|.,t 7 trlEMt' Eg I=-{fiffi Fffi ffif!EE
, lfr,ill|Hffi^H
-tffi, Hfrft{R,m , (frfr'lyfr )J^HH11frfftis, Rffiil7ffIiI, tr JIL' € HfiE.Y.IfrIA{Efr tr-Jffi= {EIT"1 FE'
4rR - {E/. T F,F H +Ec=- tn FtffiE ll1{ F Fnfrffl F tr' ffftr{EFlffittrltrn- , ffMt EtrEfflgftgWA-;R ' E
ffisM,1firyXfr,FtHffit#7 . ) I7s, r *nRffitffi+fr. f f i+ f r ( , F i+ 9 ffi ) + ;d tr tr !r e 4 4 4 a E3 0El' 5 ,8s El
uf r7 tr# , g tr 7/. +.trl a+f'l -ffi ' #t w, L f r u u +frAEEE ffi{=+ "
8rc ffi # h ,E'}W E n{E i l /.f!l- FroE f t ' , J 4 . if' r 1
F[fA4 i6 tr']iFIp.].,lF.-W
Lffi ' mEL, F'fitr €{E/.fi[E H -
fHf/^y'.F'.1 y'.iHtfg-a8ffi
ftEtqj.,' )',E r-F.fit'Etr ffiWedE
ff.J" ,1,HHhHlffi)\t frEWf,XM"' E#gffi,1tE{t
fi'.]fH+F,mffi t7tfr,. -t
+-V7l+lffi 176, r Wie4ffi-{Ey'.tl€' r77 F!L ' Frzl .
128 l E It , F18o "
rzg l E t ' H r82 .
rz 3 l E l t ' F l 4 s " tso i e4fl fr.1ffi ffi 447ttE f F' !+ S +' t{ H .f fl ffi ffrE ffi R ffi tr#ffi ,4* Gerhard
rr4 H L ' F r o z . Eberring'(EF'fE) ' lElfif' Htae-tso " $++ffittfit It r*#.t ffi.fr,{1+gflffiI!,
HIF,S . r - ffifitEill' 2 - {E/1+#ffi , s . {ffi_Rff! ; 4 . Deusexmachina (f€'++
175 l E J t ' H r a z .
ft1fret!ffi W)' s . ^E E ffi E (,K 46^1ffi { +o' . * rl frtffi W ftl ^, t - R #.ft.4H 4
iz o l E J t ' F r z o .
ffiff! , 4fuu"inrichott. (HAF{F{fl) ' Frss , l+24 "
61
ffiw.rRI.EwH{tffi€ nfiHffi# )
)F##.ffiE{g#., lffiw€ - /FRW.il]E*tr#V't
m= frff. )F##kfrrtH
€fffi.trlHtr fr IAT+E il1fr #Ire.fF4L#.EEHE ffi EEfrIfr iT, ( EIIffi,fI
? E E) ' M f TFfi]J@/fr e ffi € fr H XE,4
"' *
r-Tffi 'ffiffiE+kEff
H tr!FfiffiE, +X.' f'Jflir5*ffi
I I M EEHffi.' EE ITME E H z I
181 H fL ETE , HE fr E LH FI,frTA++E 8,.]
E H ffi Ttr- E
fr t t+E fifitr yL+Efr
+, IEfrttrfr t* t lfr,-a{ffi T ffif+{E
EEEHffi frIftHFT+Etr ffi Tfiffi fr!fff$I -#T, .HIIR' EJEifi IgH ft,E ffi # . FND}t+EH
flHIEWilTF"l
FE
T E F E irfi/'ffi trlFtHrEfE' it -Eltr ffi*-E€ts E fn#tJ interpretation), DllW#Hf'J
7 )FKW.ilTffiffi (non-religious
-{EE {*ffir+fr'.]flr# ' mfr+Rf]\^TFffiFrffiF'lfts
. E*+A$JffifEWtr+Ftt- frf t+ fflE *f -nd;fr
tu1ffi H+Wft'fE/. + # tt f! rfi lffi " "'
ffi lE-J
ffiE4['l-"]trtBR,F!
F.D}N.E++ffiEJtrg "
w.il1ffi-{E+F ryX (mE,fh#E{UtrEi+tfrlFtr) ,
E.W{EFfiFEf+fUE - D tr.]HflAzHT' trH'#,1ffi.1+ffifT
EEftffi,rrfflH;H
IEIfr,ffi ry#,tr{t 7 Rffitrl{fuE' EFFtr
ffiT{'H' ffiEfl+fi{HFJf+Xts* E, tgfr.ED}ltfi]++
ffituq
t'Effi ' t WM+*9.8.,9-Wbt.#tr1"""Wz...fr"]H;H
€ H+ffiE^1+ H FIFi2 L, mT E i+ -wEHffi+fr*ft'.1ffi E
ttz ryffi ' E{[ lfrEfrelffit]tfr + Fnffffi tr t:n,'fi+fi7 -fE Ef,
wryl "
f#E Itr:ffii*HU,W&7 ],&ffi4 g E fi A q mWnffifn iffiF'.1
Effi ttrtfr i t€-t ' l -X ffi r ' r{E y ' . + # r S H+nfi^14*ffim. , tff.m{H{U+ t}6A#FIEffr#iH " ffi
I Rffi.r f!ffiffi#[TEEEEHffiFftRqffiE! , Ifr.m,L.frl € Hx{t 7 f; W.Wtfr{-u ( F[ffig ftS#t€ il1tr H M=#,tr] fll
iij
E H4 H # +, /. fflHtrfr g frg€-in fHEfr'!FfiFE" t ffi ,
f# ) {EaF !fr.t+trt+ I&FHfttr,a ^
H ' +8trn-wf#71tu4
2A qAF,.lfHE' EEHEHffiffiTEE{EFf,ffiWTX tto
lti
tl
rl Hfi" "' EH'IAXH, E "Etft,ef# J .
{t;frE '
ttr.HEEH tr Tfr#,, Ifr.F.f{g ++,Kffi + f!
ffi F,!f,qH ffiN
(-'drtglfrt ffiqVrf,ft(*f ft!) *lFifrI?,ffiffiI) + *fiE #ft+.# fr!*lsln, m I frElF#k#,{<fft.F'! - fkl+., frifiY
X' fl ViEi*T fr.ffi*.&tr/.-'nKffiiefr f+;tiE7' mE
-iflffiitft f+E TfrJE " T11E " "' lF;=fr tr!ffiAfi f"lffi ' E ;t f"1ffi )811H+tf! + ;ff " E e E ffi ffi++E tr!EFA€# a{
frilHE€'&tfirRffi.ftl t ffiA+Hfr,FtF"lffi " Elufrt ffi E ++fI E fFI?.Htr E Tfr,TLffiffiffi
ryffi 4 H F"1 FEN,!iH9F
++E -#ffifi'.]ffi
t#, IiTTEHE+Et ffiil6 ffi,,'rFf,
' {E{fi6F FnE ' EEEHffi-aKffi fr+ ++E E#tJT Ef+,E,fg+ F'.1'fX+
,I,AEH?$EJE r)FRW.tF'.1H#t' fr1fr#f[tflAm{fi-4. .---.ffi:
rsr EEEHffi' (,at+€ffi) ,Htzz " rsa E E €Fffi , (H +€ ffi ) ' F130.
182lFJt' Hrrz " ott ((H4fri={41) ' Hsg "
r 85 Heinrich
rss Et!,EfEEHffi,KfFf,!A&fffi fEHF,L.ffir F!-{EgtEf rt " ra6 E E trFffi ' (ffi +e ffi ) ' Frs t-rs z .
63
RW.TRW^ffiH{t+Se )F?#fr1atr W., lm ZqH - jFffiffif.]Hg ffifll ^trffi ffit{ )
67
.
ffiw:tRw4H{t1fi€ ' (ffiEH JFffiW.ffi+trW.WRHHffi#
)FRW,ft1EtrW. )
fl tr Dlh.q[ffiE g E'.]
E FtA H - + +* 9.frilR'{F.y6
tr'{E t r + + Nt ' IF EEEH ffi t\HEE e # ffi fr H ff' J
# : [ -_E' lFW# L 2F., ntrEt-ffifr'.]
,e,* t|+{t +n{f5
ftEHEHffiFf#,ill r-Ftffit
ft!frfTI ?S' Htrffi.tFffi eHgft1# ' m€frE++HH'!fftJ ffi28+I#.--nR;# ' :E '
FfrH/.XFW#W+ft
)FRW.illMfr"EEisF'!E ftu' Ef'Jfr!f"1 i-e + +R + wffifrltF F,,tr,r1Efiiru H H H E tr!++
1e5 HH+IHT+#.HE ") lee
++NtH'.1ffifil[EEEHm='
ffiEE++t-f'.1 H ftffi# (self-justification) ' EEEH
ffiA (,at+9ffi) +-E E.+EHfr!^ffi*frrfiffiEE Ifr1e6 , H'.1
H |,fr.Fl,*Httr tTH'+ H'.1 ft1fi tfrI:
/. {ruIEffi ffiffi fET IEJ
^I H ++#mffi E' Affim^ffi,++H (cross withoutwordor
Ie4 H € fi! F"lA ffiE ft HEE/t {r5g{*filfi E'Elfr?H&ffi-#
wordwithour
cross)I " '* H++4m^mEF'!ffiHfiXEf! E+n
ffi , E fE-#ffi W*frW.W. @Dlh.I=.tft.y{f; ffi.^FH
I=-MrEE{fi H!
-iK;#Htr+*fr!ffiw " EHEHffiEX' r/| +fltffi9? +Rtr!E+E,friK.+ntffiFffiftlE€il....?ffi7r ,&c={E I Fi
. I mAt f f ig ? t r t F r+ EY{ t# - t F n ffi Xffi F f,ffi H + ' F ft7 tr
/-{HftEZffiffi+Feffim -. ' Ff,EIE/ffitrlMA
-fffit' | *frHffi '{fr, ++FtJE)FI=-',rft#f\fr?ffiJ+*pWfi =t ' ffiE'Em,-ft^ ++
ft'!......
ffi-fr'.ltrEtlEft, EHf,.!+'
E+EIEEA#+++'mfr*frft!+'
FUE++NEe# R F,.1ffiE ilEfr!E+F.;fr;E# H , D}EffH FE+ +*F^] 6f;FT
201
T ttrffiillW.I*t " =ffifEEE{fitr]#streErf-lBfrtr
j6lE?rflfttffitr,,\#FfrEz
IEIE" t 'n' EHEHffi-'aK.ffi'
tllxi )F#ffi.trl#gW.Fn Ffi4/^trln&F"lFE .
f"lEH | ffil6r F ++HFfrE+tfr'.lEE Ifr , 4tH H ++*
tr!,8,
ffi{Fffi lfrF^] Mfr E E--fEnfrft,tr FtJ,Xh Jfn
- fE,E, EE E Hffi Fnffiffffir"1 fE, tff.++N# HH # V1'iffi
ft , rc.ffii{*;{iU
fr {eIY+ ilI I RW.r ffift tre.Tlalfr
EX# E]'DT+TFU WffiF,.]Zi I_E] H " F,H {t # T A XFF"]Eg fr"]8
I-fu
EEtrl t)FRW.il1EtrW.t o te8 F-|1ffiFTffiTRH'A {fitFEH 4HF frE+NiH H E fr'']
++
1e4lEJt' Hr3l . NilI A # " E EEH ffi F N ffi HTf!) F # ,ffi WEtr ffi :F E
1e5 | t ffi lrA+lfi.HE ?fi+EHE'fEfrtF, bfr.W t T + +* " t##E IWff. t ftVl.d+ffi
ffi)1 rnffi' EEfn{ffiffi+il188fi fr ' fff{E/.trf'Jtffi H+'
6! ' m,sEE ElLh?frJffitillllE#trHErfllf5f-lFrt ' ffi-ffi,Frt . r lElt , Htzz .
1e6 rftfl!,B,tHfr1Hts{U*ru*ru#ff€frlgf,g ' €T6{+ ' AE*+E{EE+ ' fn#€fi'! fiSUEAHfi'.]f;#t#. EfE^ffirrc.Ar fHEf.lfif;ffi ,ffil#.
fr74w.tr#ffi*18*" _t rtrFfE{UA (€ft'!) +EEtrrfi7\ '4EfEH#r'ft
lll UE t{1ffi+ffi 4 ffi*f fr!f}ft H fSJr,}' " r, r +*,8tr + R.E'fEf"lffi , +},ff1rt
[i]h7ffi tr r fi ffiff.]ffF r ts,ffiI Lffi tr!)',Ffr+$Etr!+
+HE.ilfr
U rE{EEFf.lr tril-Ep&. (€filgfig) ffiH#fr (fgm?EE) HtH.ffitaffiil....? ,
H#t - *A*n@f+ffi'lE' {E{4' fE# . Es . 4'ftSSffiA . r r#fi{P1*E ffifiY.,ia€#..frfr.t.,l.fiff " EIJIL EEg-Hffif!
E.il1fififfi
ffift ft ffift E ft!ff!,B4 rE " H H leF-frR #4 - t#, & Kril,rtr UIT ft - tfiffib W*ktr! D]#,8' {E/.Eff t ffi ' E 4H
RW." #H, 8trW.ffift1fi.+nffi-fg+&*h.t1?W. " {EE' ro4gE€frlr}EjffiX' fi
)FRffi.EtrW.trl Pyi6EI
fRffi#] ffifi'+4*ff.]ffiFf;*WH&E' ETE-{Eil^ffi#cE z I lEIt , H78, r28, ti*tr HfnGEf iEffl+,1. Fl,h"
i33 ' 164 .
l e 7 F lt ' H t8 8 "
re8 tfHf iEiE r'{+iIftlEEt fr7fttr-*E'{+HEE'HffiB!-'fEdl+frFt,-H. (E4{E) '
=-rKffirfr
H t 43- t 47' Heinrich.
ott E <HE ^ffi fAffi> + ffitfi4 EEE Fffi trlE E6T lEl' -F. 199 CharlesS. Anderson,(ffif,gtrl+*1F+) (Luther's theologyof the Cross ( FacetBooks)
( H f {='ftlr )' H 118- 1zo, IfF-HFJ++ * E f f,fHEEHf"hfE fgF'.1 g, q'
R7 1971) , H3 .
Historicalseries-17( Reformation) , FortressPress,Philadephia,
rcffi | + fr #.&tr #.-t A{;ftfr.:fteHfitt e-N}#tr ffi +,1'mr} ffi t ffi fl1#ffitr1ffiEH ffiE
,ffi=H ' prro-rrz " 200 l EIt ' v i i .
ffHBlflff't6pfi" H <<Hftq\l=.ffi>
201 l EJ t 'F 6 "
RW.IRTEftH{tffiry (##;E)
)F?ffi.ffieE#.'
: ,,\F!4FH#)
tfiSFB fflF H qFZ H *E{E H ffiiTTE _fE H ffi+ #4 A TJJTU
E#tr!+Hffrr" EH' t'ffiE H +IU+TE fr?ffiJH ie/.;ffi
Effi fr.tr- /L- t+FU IFillh FP( E + tlF A W#
s7 . fi,--'#.-#tffi, EEHEHffiEXfr,"Ffi
{ E) +H E, r.-....i t(E g) ffi y {fi {ff { & f t t wz f f ia f t ^n{{th?n*f
E 4[{'JE tr tfr,---#.-#/.
ffi H "
iEf.FHErtftiru ' Y{ ' E'8fr.+K{ffif* , Ifrffif+f+Flj^MHE ^
ffin . """.r fiJtHE(8ffifr.W#W.W> -B +,nffifU trJtr, EEE.Hffi '{Affitr!I )F?ffi.{l*trffi.I Effi H
r EffiHR gi\M E ffiflEffi. ...+.HI#I+W+.TfRAg IFE -ffrE r-fr Hfi' ETr)lf'Jz<
ffiffi.'Wffi E E#H' &
T lEE'.1ffi,ft ^*fr'l
E tH.2Ttr, Fl,H *ih.trlg{;f;
' 4 X t1E l3F
f} E
8ifr ( Eg ) rntr€ffiJftiH'ffiX?EF' lA,l'H
It -.-...{ff
^my'.ed-#ifr, " -t zozE.ffiHftHEEHffiffiEB-n${t' 4 E fi HHEHffi # IFtr!ffiIE').E.4tr H ZiIE# IF21fr+H
ffi fr wHfiit T -" ft, EIE ie,fru
a+Ifr{r5 F w #lsEf,J# tElft ftlFJifr , D]trffi.aE r4,E,FSr'lF6 +' /.{HFt'ffi ff E-f; ffl
trlrfiFE, ),.-.trn+trtF+ffi4FH# ' EIHE{4,ifi H ft tr Et&-at;fr /.+F+.frF"]HH'9€i# jF' m
ifi A FJEEEHffi trI,8.ffi F U F E ffiY+;f;E - fr ffi IFH ;fr
nnEF ffir":, *,,frl4nf*E Ifltg z
il " FtrD), H4| lFffiWV1Etrffi.t ,E'fFqeH ie,E'tFS f'l q
fi iH- tr E fEtfi#H llfs F!ifiF,iill F.;H/t . fi iruft FE,['4S{;trtrff $RrtJ-- .
FFt E f;giFlE7 A+e+ & & tr7m# . fi{ffiE ftS#!ffi 7 W.--nF
E ft , D}Eg ffi+,1'tr.],8 ffiE EEE-Hffi,E f58,.18Hfi
f[ {Fffi mE]fr'.];#E-f;
+9.fr" ftgm [fr.+fr,{ru
{'xFftltu/.' iFf} {r1
' 1#.Wt+-at,fE EEEHf | )FfW.UtEEW. t,E,,F,F
F ft 7 ffi H Efr tE.,H4 H +mffin+' E fF f n { r u E 6 iH ^ +,1'ftRW.ttH DlKtr!+ +H,B,F,F
. fi{1101ffH ftl il7E-ghfriE+ V7*fi
n,EantrT* HqFz {*,{flFfiffigffl' .
IHR HHEHffi tr!+ ++,E,F.H tr.ffi8.M7 WltE D}XtrI+
TE Xt ' Z.ENtrT# A , TEiHtrWTAA' Z<E{# ,
+H++9ill#E ' {EEffiX4ill+* D}rnEEE
+fr,'fruEl
ffitr!ffi.WX, rtnEtr +F'! - lBFFIF!/'. F{Ffn,fru fr7frJ+f.
EHffi A Hy{+ ++H fgr'.1 H #, ffiA^H E #g +,1';fr
FUEEffftf*4tr-iFIfrlEW ' +fr,{Htrlffi+F
EEEE ffiJtfrfi. -#E'Htrffi++
,i, +fr,ffi ,lfrnffi E'.1;{ Zffi - h ffi'LffiffiEn4' + ++fr.t ffi
a HffiEtr BffiJrurf,,L.ffi ?'o'
fi^lffiEEtrlWr^m/FEtr{fiFHffiH"l Lffi 204 ' e}"Affi++N
'tre.H1FRffi-tr;ffi#,WEH
r-ffifl#f;{trrf.JI Hli #HEEffiqErrag-r? , XffirE,trH +.frff!{H,fE
' tr
nt *8 , IFmI=.'{ft.fr"AJFI=.rcAlsE4
Htr EfEtrtFt f
tr]/.ff1" FnH)\A$re.EffiEf
+4ftH'.lifrEY{Ff;frf;fff
' fiff tr tftHF'.1Hft' E oIt)tf[ tr XE IF+ r-E'ffi- t)JiH'fE I
*TE lEl-,H#Hfi' {EA[EE H+r&Ffi SU,tffi iltff'r,Jfi
204 rffi H*ffi , HEEHffi&9Y:tffiHftffi1EH€F!+++1S€' {EE' W'Rlfrffi+fr.frr
+
202 gffifr $rtr+ #'f fr;+ , (flF#FflftFrE{t#g#,e,ffi) ( ttF=ffiHfiFfd +*ft?&tr , Zi,fg,fgEtffi{t$r^, UEEzrffltffiA.* (Deusrevetatus), FfiD}#.
tss7+tFffi-h E.)' Hr 13. :e{ntffiEerr-H-=&l+MnHf}Bttffil (Deusabscondtrus)
' FfEET&.# " "'l -F,
203 FfrEHffi' (Fi+effi) ' Frz " <H -frH ffi ffi -fi H) + ;+ 4€E ' H "l "
ffiffirHwffiH{t+He )FRW.trJ+E#'(ftfr;E)
Et" ruf+EwFne ,
H t. -iffi, fi mtr ff )F-E F *"4 +*t*"4 +tr
'qre:"&tr+
fr Ir l4 ftfr! r'l;f;fr!ffiw.++F. {Elr R fi F rEtu+rtn'lH f+ff
- E $F' fi "8ft.'r,r*+tr.+Irfr,q
E ffi-.fEs H' F[ffiffi#'J tr
rEfr^1{+F hfr^H#ffi-{E frHdtflS(n#ft-E +Sn' F
f,FrEffiRw.illftS ^ffi' fi FnTfr?ffifteE WE,ytfnF'!tr rEffi
f€fr r'.1flb El
Hi " fr #\zftsfr rxrl E ffiH ttu(x.ffi T n- fE
;EEXirtHfi{ruEffEtrItrIE " ' fIFf,rc,#
;HEE +tHffiIt ME E E {*' ff #9.z.ftS4& '{NREEf#E HEE4\ HH
fEZ<IE_J -
F,!H E. EE E.l.H T IFJ i& + Tfr,U
fr}FH tr f} fi E
t*
HF":{=o#'"
81
RW.IR}EftH{tffiE )FRW.?IEE#. ' t F{ffift)
82
RW.IRffiffiH,{t+FE )F?ffiW+trffi, ( Bff
flft)
"fr1sffi
' gE' giHf[H 4 " +*#, +g-#tr!ffi-#l] xHyi wftI a H fr E ffr',Hffih wt6z,r{
iE* ffiryn + fr4
h #s 7 E g ft'.l t&{U' E ilEf'J Hl3 ffi4 g /.f6 F'.:
fHm ffiffift " EXEAg' it+€H 7 Eg +,1.f[IfuA+,1.
=
H IHtrtf,q, E tr lFffi,,tffiH fttrl+,l'' Hg IFffi fFrt ' E F+E DIEHie f-i\4ffi H R Bflil.Wt$nfr
ff.J
+,1'' EtrlFffit ffiq Hft ffi+,1.. m- #ls
ffi.fr.ffi ft,fr\ww "
tn+ffiil 7 ffiF t F^lEg, m 7 PnFffiffiFEE={;ft T+ 2 . 2 ( E [ 4 4 if ;)
ffifr H,ft iFe xyi] E g;fr E!IFffiHE + ,1.ff.];.f ;fr '
(n
e E-stl +.F ;{;frEg ilfi]ffiE /.x E +F' EEE
EieY{ffi@F{E/.fr!Bfliifrreft7 . *nlfr,A
)E'ffir,Vtt}tft
Hffi -'rK,ffiEE +fr.+I'f+fr"Atr{4 ff'JE g n=ff' mru H E
ffi#E-fE l-i$Eft{4t fl#g;.ffi 'e."ft,' it,dfi-iJflE e.Fn=,4H2MffiH^l/.FH,L. H4if;gh, TH?rymH
gFtffi/.' t&Effi+k{ru-ffi Ftffi/.F'!rffi ' I&+ftH AF H,L.Mffi. EEES H4 fr,I+A*EFU
Tifrfihffi .
AHEH WFN HH .
tr H A ' E gE ffi 4f NT f I ' E Hg +,b;ftDIHF*F,.]Ffr#HIEfr.AgH +.
E t. ffiIFffiy'.#tr Wfr il' FJt @WIH,-t*n,'Ifr'-"#'ffi s . trfi6r+ffi ( lese-le4s
)
r ffi- /.t trlEgEHffi E )'.ffiH +' E *lslFffi A s. r ({ffiIEe)
{effiry#E + IEHE F .fr,{:u' E mE +Eit tFryffiE
,
frEgetr-ftE ffi'{kXF!WR{F7 ffifl ' {frtEEE-*l3 *ft,fiE^]#lF' iEEHEW-.H',fr!,B,ffifl
W*#f"l + ffi ' 4g W.lffirE g illltffiE E * E tr W4rE!
2 . eBEW.€(Confessing H+ff ( 1933-1939
Churcrr) ) :
H E, iTtr.EE ff il1Htr.WEg ffiAilJH
E Hffi5fi;if;J
2 . | ( fF Fl ',{ftfrr1{t
{H} Qhecostof Discipteship) tr frfrft*z<Elh il1' {ffrEH 'FF,!= il7trttW.EF'.1 F+ffi,l'4
49ffi EF F'!ffi {Hfrf;AErffifHf.l,Ktsr fr rffiH I&, W{EEfEE A F!H ITEffi^ffi _LffiillTfifr- #{q[
ffi,Kftr . E{&trtr ffi# Eg +,1.;ffi - -#EEg ' Hg trlE rg- ffiHIilW . -iK;#EgW41il1HfrH'
ffifr
Dlh.FT {ftWH ln - E g * It M z ffi.iHB'l,Kfr H tffiffi r,Kqr fltffitr] I-iErF-fr*ffiff.lEL+' IEF1
!fr # E r # t fE #m/Ftr t#)\ I ffi # ' t f f iE lt ) t €'E=Iw4lsB.trlTKfr&ffi# F'lm+eT t E ESU' y{lFF!
-a{-#rlHEE,,ttrEg fr'.]fHE, E €t fr 7 n fiffi {EE 4
IFffitrf#Rtr tr!ffin' ftf;R FtffiT)\+F+tEltrlFnH
F'l{ffi l-Hr fn tF.t " WtfrflEtEH-HUtr-^
V7J" ffiHF'.1,K4,e,*DtE )\*fiy.#FnHXEFffi4g'
FFtrftrffiB'.l,ft,{HE lfr.n+il7+.ft. nrf -*ls(n k , IH4fi&Mil7fr1Hfr'-f;t[E-H+f"1FFE ' Egffi.EH
E y{H rl-rH -ililH'.1-#ff+'
ffi fr T'l#,[H' + f[ F A # H'.] A fr /. F!ffia + H frnR h"ffitfr4Rif T H+, F,H+
. g g
H E + i ffiv1H ft.fr /. F!H ft.t frfreM^ffi Kfr&+frW
+ FE Y{ ftStr!-nef+ ffi IEH EEEHffi Y{+EEF!E
g vflffizffi o '
+F.- FH ftSth?-# /. rc.Wt ffih"ffiffi,-m- 9rtffi)\
84
#W.IRTEffiH{tffiE , ( Flf$ft)
)FRW.trJ+trW.
86
ffiffitHffi^ffiH{tffiry $fr)
)F#W.ffi+E#.' t Ff'f
88
ffiw.tRw^ffiH{t+Fg lF#W.VtEEffi.'(Ff{fft)
90
RW.IRTEffiH,{tffiE ' UhAt)
)FRW.WeEffi.