Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
POWER OF ATTORNEY – CHAPTER 36
For Property (473) For Personal Care (477R)
Scope of SDA, s7(2): A grantor may authorize the Personal care encompasses health
Authority attorney to do anything in respect of care under the HCCA, nutrition,
property that grantor could do. shelter, clothing, hygiene, and safety.
EXCEPT make a will for the grantor Power of attorney for personal
But no jurisprudence on other care places the attorney head of
testamentary dispositions the grantor’s relatives for the
SUBJECT to any conditions or purposes of giving or withholding
restrictions set out by the grantor consent to health treatment.
SDA, s35.1(1): The attorney is prohibited Effective whengrantor becomes
from disposing of property specifically incapable, AND either
given in the will (i) HCCA applies and authorizes
UNLESS the disposition is required to the attorney to decide; OR
comply with the grantor’s duties OR the (ii) HCCA does not apply, and the
gift and loans sections (below) attorney has reasonable belief that
the grantor is incapable to make the
decision
Under s 21(1) of the HCCA, a dispute
between co-attorneys results in the
Public Guardian & Trustee making the
decision.
Capacity SDA, s4: Grantor should be at least 18yo SDA, s43: Grantor should be at least
when the power of attorney document is 16yo when the power of attorney
signed for legislation to apply. document is signed for legislation to
apply.
SDA, s5: Attorney must be at least 18yo to
act. SDA, s44: Attorney must be at least
16yo to act.
SDA, s8: Seven sufficient (but not
necessary) conditions for a grantor to be Persons providing health care
capable of granting a continuing power of services to the grantor for
attorney compensation cannot act as
attorney for personal care.
SDA, s9(1): A person may be incapable of UNLESS spouse, partner, or
managing his own property AND yet be relative
capable of giving a continuing power of
attorney. SDA, s47(1): The grantor must (i) be
able to understand whether the
proposed attorney has a genuine
concern for the grantor’s welfare,
AND (ii) appreciate that the proposed
attorney may need to make decisions
for the grantor.
SDA, s47(2): A person may be
incapable of personal care AND yet
be capable of giving a power of
attorney for personal care.
Form No specific form is necessary, but it must No specific form is necessary, but it
be referred to as a continuing power of must be referred to as a power of
2
attorney OR express the intention attorney for personal care OR
express the intention
5
unless the applicant intends to call
viva voce evidence
But affidavit evidence is not to be
on “information and belief”,
except for uncontentious facts.
See page 483R for what it should
include.
4. Separate management plans for
guardianship of property, and
guardianship of the person.
5. Medical affidavits are generally
required as a practical matter:
EITHER a capacity assessment by a
duly-qualified assessor, OR at least
two affidavits from physicians.
Service of Personal service is required upon Notice of application issued after
Application Record respondents. assessment.
Ordinary mail is required upon Procedure same as standard.
specified relatives (484R)
Response to Respondent must deliver a notice of Procedure same as standard.
Service of appearance.
Application Record Specified Relatives can become
parties at any stage.
Court Hearing and Need finding that person is Judges are reluctant to declare
Judgment incapable, and, consequently, it is incapacity without a hearing.
necessary for decisions to be made After time for delivery expired, applicant
on person’s behalf. can require that the registrar submit the
Judgment should include specific documents directly to a judge, and the
statement appointing guarding. Joint judge may make a judgment without a
or separate guardians are possible. hearing.
Judgment must detail any security to The registrar must do so IF the applicant
be posted. certifies that
Guardian of property must adhere to no notice of appearance has been
management plan, but guardian can delivered;
apply to court for directions. appropriate documents have been
submitted; AND
Judgment should address costs. at least one statement says
incapacity and need agent.
NOTE that notice of appearance must be
filed “forthwith”, so hard to know when to
certify that it has not been filed.
Draft judgment is not necessary.
But if applicant is seeking costs
payable out of the property, it must
be set out in a draft judgment.
Three possible dispositions: judgment
6
without a hearing; additional evidence or
hearing required; OR order a trial.
8
GUARDIANS, CUSTODIANS, AND THE CHILDREN’S LAW REFORM ACT – CHAPTER 38
Custody Guardian: Person who has guardianship of the property of the minor.
under the Custodian: Not defined in theCLRA, but it is the person appointed in willto have
CLRA (491) custody.
The father and the mother are equally entitled to custody of the child.
Permits the sole living parent of a minor child to “pass-on” the statutory right to
custody.
In a common disaster, only a common appointment will be effective.
A parent’s appointment is at all times subordinate to the court’s supervisory role.
The child’s best interests must prevail.
Testamentary custodial appointment is temporary. It expires 90 days after the
appointment becomes effective.
Appointed custodian may apply for a “more permanent” custody order.
Any person at anytime is entitled to apply for custody of a minor child.
Testamentary capacity is subordinate to the outcome of a s 21 application for
custody.
Guardian No inherent right to possess or control property of minor, not even parents. Apply to
of Property court for appointment as guardian.
(492L) CLRA, s 47: Anyone may apply to court to be appointed as guardian of a minor
child’s property.
Notice must be given to the Children’s Lawyer.
A court-appointed guardian of a minor child’s property may “pass on” the
guardianship through a testamentary appointment.
Testamentary appointment is also temporary. It expires at 90 days.
Any person at any time is entitled to apply for guardianship of a minor child’s
property.
Only an appointed trustee may possess and spend trust funds on a minor child’s
behalf.
The estate trustee- is generally required to pay into court the estate funds to which
the child is entitled.
Absent a court appointment of guardian, minor’s property paid into court to credit of
minor and held during child’s minority or until subsequent appointment of a
guardian.
Where no guardian of a child’s property has been appointed, the estate trustee may
pay to a custodian for the benefit of the minor child up to an all inclusive maximum
value of $10,000.
9
TAX ISSUES– CHAPTERS35, 39, 40 & 42
Two 1. When a person dies, there is a T1 “terminal return” for earned or deemed income
Taxpayers between January 1st and death (495L
(495, 500) In the year of death, periodically payable income is deemed to accrue on a daily
basis (495L)
Dues dates for terminal return (500R)
If death prior to November, then terminal return is due by next following April
30, OR June 15th, if business income
If death in November or December, the terminal return is due six months from
death
If qualifying spousal trust is created, no late filing penalty for 18 months after
death, but interest runs normally
If rights and things return, the later of one year from death OR 90 days after
terminal return assessment
Due dates for return for year preceding the year of death (500R)
If death prior to May, the prior year’s return is due six months after death
If death in May or after, the prior year’s return was due on April 30 in year of
death, and no extension is given
2. On the day after the taxpayer’s death, the deceased’s estate becomes a new
taxpayer, filing a T3 trust returnfor income earned by the estate between the
deceased’s death, and the distribution of the estate to the beneficiaries (495L)
CRA administrative policy does not insist on a trust return where (i) the total taxable
income of the estate does not exceed $500, (ii) no beneficiary’s share in that
taxable income exceeds $100, (iii) all of the income is taxable in the hands of the
beneficiaries, AND (iv) there are no non-resident beneficiaries (500L)
T3 return is due 90 days after the expiry of the trust’s year-end (500R)
Estate as trust functions as a conduit, flowing paid and payable income out to its
beneficiaries (505R)
Testamentary trust taxed at same graduated rate as individuals, but inter vivos
trusts taxed at highest marginal rate (506L)
Taxation of beneficiaries (510)
ITA, s159(3): Personal representative must obtain a clearance certificate certifying
taxes, interest and penalties have been paid prior for the tax year relevant to the
distribution BEFORE distributing any property. Personal representative is personally
liable for the payment of those amounts to the extent of the distributed property’s value
(496R; 506L)
But, as a practical matter, most personal representatives assume the personal
liability, and retain a reserve to meet the anticipated taxes. (496R)
Income ITA, s70(5): Immediately before death, the deceased is deemed to have disposed of
Tax non-depreciable and depreciable capital property, and RRSPs at fair market value
(495R)
Only 50% of a capital gain is taxable (495R)
Capital loss cannot be triggered by disposition or deemed disposition of personal
use property (495R)
Registered pension plans are taxed on a cash basis. They are taxable to the estate
or its beneficiaries (496L)
But death will not cause a deemed realization of depreciable or non-depreciable capital
property where there is (i) outright transfer to a spouse or qualifying spousal trust, OR
10
(ii) intergenerational transfer of farm or fishing property (496L-497R)
Spousal rollover for RRSPs is available (499R)
For “rollover” to a surviving spouse, the property must become “indefeasibly vested”
within 36 months of the death (497R)
“Surviving spouse” covers married spouses, common-law spouses, and common-
law partners (497R)
“Qualifying spousal trust” meets two conditions: (i) spouse is entitled to receive all
of the trust income, AND (ii) only the spouse may obtain use of any trust income or
capital during the spouse’s lifetime (498L)
Additional conditions for qualifying testamentary spousal trusts (507L), and
qualifying inter vivosspousal trusts (508L)
Election to avoid a spousal rollover on only some assets is possible (499L)
Principal residence exemption: Any capital gain on actual or deemed disposition is fully
sheltered for one residence per family per year, but change in use may trigger a
deferrable deemed disposition (500L-501R)
“Income splitting” is shifting property from a high-income taxpayer to lower-income
taxpayer (501L)
Prohibited income splitting leading to attribution to transferor (501)
(i) spousal transfer of property other than sale at fair market value;
(ii) transfer or loan to minor with whom the person does not deal at arm’s length or
a nephew/niece;
(iii) transfer to trust and transferor retains capacity to benefit;
(iv) loan to non-arm’s length individual and one of the main reasons is to reduce or
avoid tax.
New incoming splitting rules fordisproportionate business or private corporation
dividends to family members (502)
Special income tax rules (460L)
1. Capital gains from a deemed disposition of (i) qualifying small business corporation
shares; (ii) qualified farm property; OR (iii) qualified fishing property may be
sheltered under an individual’s lifetime capital gains deduction
the maximum is indexed annually: $883,384for 2020
2. Charitable gifts made by will give rise to a tax credit for taxable income in the year
of death, and the preceding year
3. For a long-running trust, fiction of a deemed disposition every 21 years
11
THE IMPACT OF THE FAMILY LAW ACT– CHAPTER 41
Family Law Only deaths ON or AFTER 1 March 1986 give rise to a surviving spouse’s right to
Equalization make an equalization claim
Claim (514) When a spouse dies, if the deceased spouse’s net family property (NFP) exceeds
the surviving spouse’s NFP, the latter is entitled to 1/2 the difference between them
* see solicitor’s
Courts have discretion to award more or less, if it would be unconscionable to
checklist (524-
do otherwise based on the six factors enumerated in s5(6)
5)
A court has the authority to award an amount up to 100% of the NFP value of
the spouse with the higher NFP
If the surviving spouse’s NFP is larger, the deceased spouse’s estate has no claim
against the surviving spouse
On an application for an equalization claim, each party is required to serve on the
other party and file in court a statement, verified by oath or statutory declaration,
disclosing particulars of debts and liabilities as of (i) marriage date, (ii) valuation
date, and (iii) statement date (519R)
Election (514) Election is between EITHER an equalization claim OR
(i) where there is a will, the entitlement under the will;
(ii) where there is no will, the entitlement according to Ontario’s SLRA;
(iii) on a partial intestacy, entitlement under the will and the provincial intestacy
rules;
But NOT BOTH … UNLESS the will expressly provides for it (514-515)
Election must be filed within 6 monthsof the deceased spouse’s death, in the
prescribed form, and at the office of the Estate Registrar for Ontario in Toronto
(515R)
Otherwise, the surviving spouse is deemed to have elected the non-
equalization option
UNLESS the court orders otherwise on application
Election may be filed by (i) attorney with validly executed power of attorney for the
surviving spouse, (ii) PGT as a statutory guardian of property for the surviving
spouse, OR (iii) a guardian of property (statutory or court-appointed)
But not a personal representative for a surviving spouse who died within the 6-
month limitation period without electing
Generally, an election should be treated as irrevocable (515)
But Iasenza v Iasenza Estate held the court has a residual discretion to
authorize revocation in restrictive circumstances where (i) the interests of
justice so require, AND (ii) it is warranted by a balancing of the affected parties’
interests
Effect of If the surviving spouse elects to take under the will or on intestacy, the surviving
Election (516) spouse’s entitlement will be unaffected, and the surviving spouse will receive all
insurance proceeds, death or survivorship benefits, and the right to survivorship
associated with any property jointly own be the spouses(516)
If the surviving spouse elects to take under the FLA, the election results in
the forfeiture of all entitlement under the will;
interpretation of the will as if the surviving spouse had predeceased the
testator;
12
including inability of the surviving spouse to act as executor (Reid Martin v
Reid)
with partial or total intestacy, forfeiture of the entitlement under Part II of the
SLRA, even if the will allows for entitlement under the will, and the equalization
claim;
a need to set-off against the equalization claim
benefits as a named beneficiary under insurance or similar policy;
benefits as named beneficiary of a lump-sum payment under pension or
similar plan; AND
value of any property to which spouse becomes entitled by right of
survivorship
property that was established by a third person that the deceased spouse was
never entitled to
UNLESS the will expressly provides that the surviving spouse is entitled to receive
under the will AND under the FLA
Priority (518) The equalization claim has priority over
gifts made under the will UNLESS made for valuable consideration;
Except where the court finds that the gift’s value exceeds the consideration
a person’s right to a share of the estate under Part II of the SLRA; AND
orders made against the estate, except those in favour of a child of deceased
BUT NOT NECESSARILY over secured creditors, or others preferred by law
Restrictions NO distributions can be made out of the estate during the 6 month period
on immediately following the deceased spouse’s death without (i) the surviving
Distribution spouse’s written consent, OR (ii) court authorization.
(518) But, generally, reasonable advances to dependants for their support are
permitted
Possible practical exceptions on six-month moratorium where (i) the surviving
spouse has entered into a domestic contract with the deceased spouse,
potentially waiving the right to make an equalization claim, and (ii) where the
will leaves the deceased spouse’s entire estate to the surviving spouse (519)
Duty to The personal representative should (i) not treat the surviving spouse as a creditor,
Surviving (ii) advise that the surviving spouse may have rights under the FLA, (iii) suggest
Spouse (524) that independent counsel be retained to explain those rights, AND (iv) stress the
importance of doing so in a timely manner in order to preserve those rights
But the personal representative has duties to uphold the will, and act in the
beneficiaries’ best interests
13
DISTRIBUTION ON INTESTACY (544R-545)
1. If spouse but no issue survive, then section 44 of the SLRA states that the spouse is entitled to
the entire estate absolutely.
2. If spouse and issue survive, then
(i) the spouse is entitled to a preferential share, currently fixed at $200,000; AND
Preferential share is calculated only on the assets in the deceased’s estate, and only after
debts and liabilities have been deducted
The preferential share is calculated according to the following rules:
(a) If the deceased died partially intestate, the benefits received by the spouse under the
terms of the will are taken into account in computing the preferential share: SLRA, s 45(3)
(a)
(b) If the net value of the estate is less than the preferential share, the entire estate passes to
the spouse, whether or not there were surviving issue: SLRA, s 45(1)
(c) If the net value of the estate is greater than the preferential share, the preferential share
passes to the spouse:SLRA, s 45(2)
(ii)the spouse is entitled to a distributive share, which varies with the number of issue surviving,
under section 46 of the SLRA
(a) If the deceased leaves a spouse and one child, then the spouse and child are each entitled
to ½ of the residue:SLRA, s 46(1)
(b) If the deceased leaves a spouse and more than one child, then the spouse is entitled to ⅓,
and the rest is divided equally among the children on a per stirpes basis:SLRA, s 46(2)
3. If issue but no spouse survive, each child gets an equal share of what is left on a modifiedper
stirpes.
If at least one child is living, then the estate is distributed equally among the children, and the
surviving children of any predeceased child stand in the predeceased child’s place
If no surviving children, then the estate is distributed equally among the grandchildren
4. If neither spouse nor issue survive, then section 47 of the SLRA dictates who will recover:
(i) Surviving parents take the entire estate equally.
(ii) If there are no surviving parents, then the estate passes equally among any siblings, with any
surviving children of a deceased sibling taking an equal share of the deceased sibling’s share.
(iii) If there are no surviving siblings, then nieces and nephews share equally on a per
capita basis.
(iv)If none of the above survives, then the nearest next-of-kin of equal degree will share on a per
capita basis.
(v) If there is no surviving next-of-kin, the estate becomes the property of the Crown.
14