206 The Seda Iagition
eclectic of memento impinge the enue be we than ie
{leechers ths the mec ffm Leal so Gt
aman ec a creas engaged aan penn fa could ote chi hy
‘arledng ileal onsen tnt bundle of pecan
‘Seween ier olan a art moh eld mies Th exper rt
ew vertd fet bing eve font weno feelers ep tees
fm he moe of wife eerie meal be sober i nile the
ttn of a yh Rp Adee feo dg em oo
in Adon they noe ror cain of ch meer en vide nde
Shy fate, povided ey dd cmp ake er he response 0 Hr
Tul Sei ws an igi emmy by Adorno on the its a he il
wo sansa of yl tera acne Sable binge
Sack to eds rug f Minimal eras ta bez hs gtr aba
‘co peste the lech spear clon ol ley eee ae
‘rene wos sme tke ne by he compromise othe se
‘itn mail hd tn mid her i930 Garman New Sulss (New Orit
Box sao tihing tess comer aya opt of work
thu eed eveything ep theme be ae tad te ad eae
ltr wiring 0 Statue and Cages meal experi” His weit 09 te
dency inigungl comers wth Frade cmmencry on Minimal, He mul
(tue Incl ection ef ry em eran and of ay emblem,
‘roid et sittin wee thee wk ha 0 i 6 ae ental
[Re blocs aaron everchng fom, wil ined enue al ate me
lye wil amet sre ogee This a el al poeds Bi
fat ck tage the han term ie spp —mberby dil
Ine oe lel peice ance ey al ee tht ton
teat cere woul bedi byte abso ong he cee
(Seal eakng fm he iat ny Inigo ode
Like el, Ad we exeng it anny ab ti imerenos ta ied
‘aban compln aes ar ane nthe dering em of ms
“tein, nd ur sagt ode say wih he hal iy ovary al ected
‘tebe meu el downer wrk. Hoth wee ily ciclo 2 ha sed
teoseseapable py efor seplcing thu heya eh aged o
Salo ison of whens. In mating sah ase, Schwere hi fee 9
tmtraed by» subiy iecply cine of mock ht semed wo Be cried
‘Brosh pol sng dt vters ters ps arerctin -A
{eae eat shou condos ine tee fea br eh
‘hey eave the t wck 4 plenonenoneering the ber o ee
{nprcenn fit do id lng forth ns ope vad
‘fen acy eh general sbi of ewe aed rae epee
6 The Phenomenological Turn
1 there wis ene won! ich domiaued dicaoe 06 sew depuis
ienona sn th gia te ajc Whae hind ofan aye could sel nan
‘Sre Gr mos etal bow migh wk be ped ta eciped the cts of
‘voter ceneptos of the obje” Minimalism, aly wih the NeoDada and
‘os mally Bae ewok vot orient bd pci quien Tat
{hae nee he ous ower amo psp megs wih spon cy
ished Wolcinscpnpmoue Minimal Area of 1955" Recency pt
eee thir scune Mina gen ty Romlnd Rr a
‘Nar San be 77 enc Maa a
Inaing pre of ving nd tthe tation Cee when the ewe ete
pee coped by the wer, ear aly inthe rater cg fan ples
Mlahcnat wots You ge god eee th lacing toh Dc etiology
nia! pubis #968 Onl ew te sand nt aking oh es ce
Finda sd Objethon? 1967s Roe Moises om Saja o 968
Sculre and Phenomenological Theory
In eedcing Mes. Foy it his dcunion of new utdeanlings owe
‘hich mead i he 1905, an fli eo dee legs ta may ae Be
{hy oe wich owe sor Fly ol eemot, hic epi von pa of
‘hese iserncon withthe wos oe big te ha py se
‘mec of wl mapping and ceprising and contl orcs «fel freer
‘ling we of heme sepa imaginary sania wih Mn, Ely
‘Scr de his append hd aston spree Teste ices eng eh
Sal fe signe out atest, tee Ta Mor Ande, Hee an Sr ea
hw call lly when ff bcm ale io Ung Hwee sing the
isis terween sconces ad thes mia Wo See Moro he ses
Penumvecogy at mts to Meera Ponty The more chal php
‘wings ase he ‘athe of mate rool, pricy hs Th Phe
‘lg Ira Tne Cnc Grated 9h a enjoyed shea
288 The Sedan! nageason
Ang tne cee nat, Mec Poy’ ne widely known pee of wing
satis bok Te Pasay of Prion pel sp Bact 7045 ted
Irigts hough ew images crt edhe 36h) aed ge neinneet
“hore were a sew shor ena pcaly cnet wth he al
srala in Engl clacton by 1964 tes eaay ‘CEs Do pub
Tita in 948 an wo mare ended wera, Indice Lange an the Was ok
‘Senet fi apgee 1953 awa snp nh aa San ye
sud Ne pb oo and made salem Engl ste
‘Siti of eye ed Te Pia of Pope Hee thc te pc
iter mu by Fach sacar ad pose seaceut thik nthe Ase Son
wold wee aco inn cng Na en Men Py de ree
Bs witngs one ard sal ponepton pepe tae the steno of Eagle
‘Tolngirbr Phman Popeater wen se
are gue cpr He feds acne of thing iwi nd opr
iowng we evap by ha, tr te accomadation oe,
tarts ened witha te baal nssy bed pth dr sing
‘he bn wknd py eves Asch eu dle ani
‘ekg ote clpnl ober a aereton he paial sera e withthe
Tif wee shout Nor cleare cra Maden at fr hi was pve all a
Scam cay sake Euan png the of Mai, Ke of Re
‘elm amd swe al Cerne, As Kas, wh dl more than spent sae
Inn withthe new sie protier ofthe 19G pened of ot ey
Sein abe wre ors Fenh aan in 18 th kept peony he
Ergo Sordi ith enor hat weep a oe wih he
Minimal and expel let, inpencis ta prcoped e
ering nee» mane of chs who cong eden a il enely
caged wih tno sprunaon and who wee pricy fea wh he
‘ene fgutie work of arta sch Gacomere Dard Svat asf
‘Gansu, nea wich gor kk be sggon iin couched i
‘enuncnolgal mal aes ngage td pes oe Mea Pony it
{ilriring anl afc somes yc ae by Cac Ses ba
Presence inulancnaly memny in ncingthemele fm he eee ese
‘Sinead fw ta spe sien ened the ver ce of
Nore ome ya se cd pro a ete sme pet
“Tice! appapiain of Neves-Pny & ped ous inthe opened
stony th ee Asin ccs whe mae fal chee ingen af
Sen Poty fr tir ey tng on scp, cul Kes and Fo Fed
agence ith Teach heemensogy a erie See. Mees ony
‘te hn sway of lig aba bow spa sacha Car ug osreb
‘Si a ipso mode of bing inthe wold tat mol be eho the wwe
“The PhenonenlegalTum 209
‘i Sa yn Be el eo a
Sogo getinine cates arena ecnpecetean
Cesc trina leapt ad fondle ik
Ms Smet lcnred i einer an ae maton ad
‘Pelco purus wactton ear ci earaen to
eee OT a es trttaen seated ape
Sieg iret ectamah een tera
ff te Feoch eestentalpheoomeolgs Meo wes) Nott
Bfee ony ea ued t ese se oly pet o Ca at
evel. Bue Mew Poy proved phlophal satin fr ting the
Keg seul nd eag to dcver het 0 eh
Merion Pony wt alealy Surg pemieny in Kens’ ety ey o9 Dal
Sd ing or 1965, Ths coat ono the fe and abo more sop
(Giecrmerue by Murale werk Ie comes wel ee her beer ves
Pana Madey Snore” For Kens, ting on Judd i 196, dey se was
cl sr ta high nF sa Cay Whas cnc bet
‘Jot stro the sop br ir the bly smo rece io che
err ye dope spp hd ans te
tod Greats moemam, she was sey ies, by wey of» uae for
seus Pony wtp af een wich she lace peed Seine fe ar
‘Gcelngin olen, What ae rs being von tthe ever ne per
‘cr afte clea works she amie war nut some manent soa cen si
‘ers of pespctnl ews ine af whch he abe gee bu mea wh
"When io Peg Maden Spe se ie ee concep of» cote
hind by pee ves poll ee ed a es De
‘eet jet ad ee Detiike sey fo a att fee wrk 3 90
‘sonore woe !"Thic new feito aula dal ghee er ety
‘Seo Ju ode eshte ower mend in the ed expec lp fc
1S tania, le pss by atending cay the once pr ews
he ely pee eles tothe ey an eae wh nigh been a et
‘edhe inept lagi tenth roecdne and whens ipl nach210 The Sapa! nageatn
4 Me For wig, a in, Ka ha oie
‘hee init kg, oa the ptm bet est
Lay wggeioe poe oy ar fs whe ng esig inl Sart
Siw; bweer ei sl pono, il as mh the Seca er a
Sex fer href rations i gl in he mids red ar with he
foniunor pcre Eng th lace Tr Wis ea 9
Mca-Ponys nok began ne fom ube view. Penance ms lacey
stern’ isn porscuculsm,sa he ings oh Oy papa hr
fs nln oes mae on pepper se ny
Erne Bp tte cn af se tgoy tre or a cer oligo gant het
thy phlei nd ekg derive Yo eon anal so
onesie With hese onthe etal ofan unending urge so
‘tics pile
Thur cea ning abut ring he ld semen pcs
coogy sod scala parse when a ve loot the ston es
‘Spon an many ah wo ars ne she Me et fe
{ean ten-St sutra sph o showing my Bye th ion
Toreng of wb sd objet tha aed mer pny Hine
tne pects on hg he ner Pe tra ere lo See
‘Siaph com ih ps ewe pnd a eae a if gage
Sct pcoo of ec, ta he was su ener Eee, he
fennel spur sc sry ml and wre ifn, ot gh ost
erly Sco spc othe at word which made fememeadopod
Snccnundng of he sewer engagement rs wok of atom cag
{cane Anaemia the rtm asa ih moderns pet pian
‘Eton he noah abe ned mina ar ar ep ts
any pvlegng a va cn psc nena t pos work
Schemes tone em ep npn bun phoney eure
fntverat decaton oe arn sepia
Tomsk net eae npr nom By gig 4
cannoli ronding inte boy dase of ving. ltd yo
um aug do, ut by eiking of fal ues eine ca weak
percolation ta pce pic auton Moe Neato
‘SSvrtng aco ey brenden cnahond pf pet
‘heat aut ad youll ron pct Howe dey eee
ston fhe ac eit precy eh bp ea a
‘The PhenomeslpelTien 211
eran parce sain oy ~ at + copey eg cough erate ote pe
‘mpeg wh eed eo tad uy cle enero othe Vial od
prcepil direst engages wih wake fa. Nett sone pai
Enya sere hosed alk about te mec mane he vil ta
‘moe reed guile ree atid ta sal ey
sles ld wth Merenuony oe compen uderaning the atv se
{he el a ia
“Thee anne moe emighowally pla iu dh es bong et
se if we et undeand te clap fea in Me Bony nemo)
‘tthe tro ae wo gale i Raber Mi aid ommvat have que
butte pial wd tanks ama plc ins phevomenlg sye of
‘Biking ws petlgig ef aching he pee ewok of ded
‘ming une othe poe mainly teed ul ode cet sp
Nesen-Pat sagen psa eer codes miner aig
‘oli gh itera harm. Mees any se on a
‘ea ean uc fier Fach hots sch Darth sl Fe ab beth
Inter scmingyewusmined opens! her. Hwee ie lt get
‘Ploy anaes dg of poli dt thot tr ce fo em imperae t
Siang» note) oppostional crea, be was much ure el pla
tele nde an-capalithun fhe srac sol ps-rcua hin ho
‘pum hie pene of re alec lo king the Age
“Mees Pty wart mich «plc comme asx cw eda
headed on tt + pose and pheoomconlogst. Maret oe aso
snderining fh sj sa, Te Plowman Pops sea ing
Ite hamanst The wa ey concen geoundng the Hegel Mactan
‘ters pls thease in mitral Fees, eaiasing conse at
Srl nthe pleco a an eu! ts esd eed
"He aw chr anata inti etre pal ad abe all elton
it wll at ewerdey peep fay scan the let coer of the
Pmeniag ae ey eeie
Ter theake-p of Merl Foo inking ie he at wd ha cde der
ous te pleat danemson nga 0 ln whl they ply on
tnbutedo te dome oh pation nth ply ceo od the es
li inthe sow ob Ca War ebay ued omaha eee ae
thle wos leeliben lige tha wold othe mame thi ey ol
‘epuation inthe Eaglakopeaing mela ething of «hale Coren
Maree thug emt neve actly reer he ach Commune ar Hee
tally end quien i case tae to ty dentin the eed
Inna tpt a work i the canon of promot Balheva a the Sala how
ea Ths wat sc by aya thee an tiaheSaism” AT the ome ie, he
India othe ingore voles lt te aae-Commansn jane
the Une Sate gonsmment woult nt hae coated hin macy Ames212 The Seip! nagation
locas, een than of srl pesaton oto td hs cae he hl «
Frobemace mpuctn at + dare Beshok Commun, inl mt ask
‘ae os pion the esol eng hi
By te ie of his ety and unnpcid duh 1, Mere Pony public
pala same td shed someway beh emda something
[ihe Te his dipue mith Se inthe 19h, Be mee erp pe st ef
seesaw os leony olntati » tat wed 0 Be led le enn
{Foe sty speaking nt-Commanist, bee mock mor say ceo he
Salsa lng he Sos Unions the Een Eropnn Popes Republi i
Ie wast anything 8 Weer captasm and ie dermerary Foe, Sie srbee
‘Shin pb nth jurado Temp Madr in 961 en ame cee
te sotber Her Ie! Sate caugh something eset abot ehe eth ed peli
Imps ef Mere Poy work
‘Ging ough he es tht Rnd ou canter, he upc tc ut
‘pinche oan of pte de and dees with sate tke mda
‘malas whan Ray abe dng hele fos eam oe ee
Though Mee me mover sunelessgulr ho he ontingecy at
|emtage inns in sony, hrs hugh tar neritic
sweated) tthe hee he ama aenate
Sige, the beak of nay be bled jt efit death, Mese-ony con
hac to gay worn fe theca tcl ho had ned tle
bees on he Mar hon bl nome th hang and eh pls oe
‘is Maio al lt nde inks vhs eile meh pln ll
‘cine or bia idseble way of ising tow and wnranding the wt
‘Minsosbe pha ere dt i ema ply nnd the
Lar of contemporary cata” He aso res the ena nce ve of
lecoving entation: Deer suiog ie orion hrc ipa
‘or mvauonary charge which He oct bed oad puter elo the wae of he
stage sit fiom Na comply cls ad edie ben ep, be
sellsited cone old ngs ich ak apd ao heey a
tinge peste on tings
Woe we cll dre une, younger thant epcece amt ad
‘eupty wil ne be ngeuty to damit x pce athe enge
Ses the pts et rence wht we took outs Te hen of cemaion, a
‘porn on, many ypuciy and lacs any se dn a So
‘a co, Who woul have oped ths en yen ao? Phage we arate thse
‘mameees ben har pases om. Weare Js yee ee in Fee (he
‘Agen cis othe was esos ef ipomay ee Cold Wa). Bac boat al
‘hoi, thee emeting sence, an sang, Why shal th no be hp”
“The poe ore of he 60 n+ way br thi
[Ab imporaor impetus behind Met Port'sexplaton of the inesbjsive
ssn costed in inacae psi ines boc bodied sand
the weed aul wa he des tthe Sa sch ape. He
The Penemercopal en 213
gue chroughot Bis cer ce the elation Beweeh se and eer wat not os
‘eyo Heitesan elstin feonfnetion ad oi, whieh we mighe fe Ie 0
ER watt aicrating, nde censtestion coc lane a mode
Spat wi hm the opps regimes fc conta the sl Ca
eensesutes He sac pe tsa haa een of yon of ne gen
‘invasion cc bn pone wherdy «ars ect nde way ce
sian wh he te es muy, ey Bart, Sor oe be
enh prs Mi intellrais who hae donated so mach sabequent caer
‘Berg dor whe Sure (ih wham Menu Pory wa engaged at
npnng ec) he Sc lin of ls ee a sl a weld scam of
(Seer iba! wih poaidechsid impulses. When comeing the Hinde
‘nena papel out ermee vewing subject ad viewed objet in een dhe
Senin were ald taht ites play ded udetsundng
Sujet an ae pty spartan hey ay ded he ub fhe se
Perception and Presence
ei of he mj pubiron here Mains Poty said th compen of
‘ering and vl wats whet hs Ploeg of apn ase Thee
(lta dee ey wih vital eter In thee hema cncered sore
explore the ramets of tay ssa ascents the mee
‘sconesu and debently fed process of ening ec by works of 1s
rime anbiden «poner wat to move rod the chro, reply gd in
‘der hong, bcwen an epic er pn concen a igs jet
[Bre cot pevling ia olen scien, sad's tad pio lino
{eh inthe opentansof min and ene tought By eleng meebo oe
splewon how shaaenec sad sae of thige wee geese nee
tos bern psa he ae eel ih meat, Be ws
stay anng vo tum plop Bead ie av Ma ha Sone! Hi ge
‘omc wet tat kre pvc ¢acber fr hihey St tS he
fest cnr ad mot eying ee fo abe some specie ae Se ih a
thing sor eh dniecove mode of wing ined by at He pent 88
‘eval susan i unanaly ence vl tem and he dang 0 we
ray shaped yao tert a pti ht Ul be desing he ease
one eraruteheagh te ety Pol of Papin he copie sd
puto pid Th Yandel ang rue flow clr
haa die ne tne where many eran hae te aeons Bos of
‘eal isenuy oa pg On the ewig ef hinge pc ad ieee
sr saggy baste nds oh comet tal gin ich
‘Mee Ponty mig wer co lolged iene ke hs wigs on ein slo.
His amis ts» pareaar besig c salprebease ew Suge mae
thin evenly proces af uewang abet in the we tha sewing using.
Medes Ponty at ecoeeeulng of veins 2 ppc lee hat214 The Seda! agson
ery eu of war wet 0 ete econ of pe ince decd og
ior de
Inhs Placmabe of Poop Mees Posy Nghe ious a pein
teaser made owing, For oe hing hes ama heme cao nen
fhe compo sess we he ef ar mest ce camer rand wy belong
save py opel lee of sey swans Sing nega wih ia
etait at sacle dims of pence. When me kw Wing, west
Staten her ced ove wut! aoe tem, sd st ing the ed
Mela mate bout he mein nde
formal aalss of a elk above the aeity conveyed i paintings distin em
‘tin padi by ameter ese ope tare
‘When onmten with ain unig, tb yong Been ted ue te
ato fect vals, coal mt ne ben move wrt puting dent ee
ng sod nobly atte tact, do ing gue dee sen he
‘eves ver ie ete to what een elie oe ile
‘esther weds ed clr winner thea
ee word”
Hs cig of puety opel moe of viewing mas ply ll by the ced
he fe comer tmilcingl sbprying udenndig ef peeps fs ede
ough sedon eiorl made feng, whee things ected well ae
‘ct to dn th ioe he thn rons king shape wb et
ecules tok etary fs purl ttle engagement eh ig
‘al pilin ass of tein bce byscovetol ern sing
In at exper which puseebjeceicton ate than dos cele epee
sree at ue a fisher orale ht we cnc ewok, De
Fcc with cule pra ont Bet + ace, ad ie othe he
Son of bei imiedly pont cere aad beng sited tobe te
‘peracon the eker hn be the rice ub we cnn deploy
Iefre s nd ver te brome a abjece, Carpe, the bjs of
touch, Ino ete mysl ht Lam evry an (ate towie Tn
eget hat hang (br men ay bye go ate
‘wot an hc act experince camesima eae ao en aot ete
Men Foty’weting on peneption cane a mest wien ar develope in
she srchning of ecepion wer pug genie cones mec he
‘senda sol shen onesie pl ena model nee eng eg how
Sroqueon What er cameto be called eclgieal appaxts were begins ik
{feud Tate, td Knnchet an piea opprros mee ed ot
aren ge ern wih st enrmanene ant ett Sse
Ince wa MerinPney wos ming va me when a major eine oe
«pnp akng places be warn el Seige eee es
———————
‘he PenonenslgalTom 215
foal his Gombich, wig decide ca ate li fod it a ond ment
ethining stow te new mode eng Seve by scientist he
‘eit spc wa cy fe um Meta Pocy ha a ter ely
[leet cmenonl uneptndngs of te tae ee wel male dle af
‘itt eecel spy apical level of apeception rm pecs of ppg
‘thing ply cma withthe wee
"The men cnc dy onal percep! Ba vege dearly since
Mens ory female! hs ees. eee of te Simlus pod
Ijcompttiel smlaconndetlpingacw model how pepe igh pert
none time, Mera Poey was ey uch up fate With sch scent
Arylopmencs te sa of tar eer he lp shen ier teeters
‘Soenmuon eeoh un een ak sane nice vgs te fol ppepriaton
Becerra ‘geen’ med tee wee ere be epleyed ith or he
{ie aporia te cla des of peepon whi). J Gta ws malting.”
‘Thien nmol epee femme wo ed tu hang ned pet
{Be neice bres th pycal so he mec and wo deve ona my
{osalnpng th ella sd dem ofthe tee Kanan then dominst
‘tical phibwby so calunl son swell the mabe othe
‘seen DE Sue His eiue was del sch a the mew consid
(hs of psp seat cna a he leven ply ie see
"Wh ison we shaped by it redings in Gate prog chef hike
sng wh ow ger opis sande pr om senemporay wres
tan who im wok nie in Gt ypeelgy chs Are rat
Sipe wneraning ofthe on f Geta, he re popaleSree
‘iv Gotal wey that guna! + hold biking sat mer ace nk
‘her coaagd he certian edepnning of fern rede te goer
Parris ftv fl. He na ety sai ti sper ae
Tang niece ging eo lk so he Serpsrace shat mae pees
Ponts ach at density shoe wert of ths ey naa ube sd old ee
Tipened dagaemeescl®
every cere same fhe ile ad mon aggesve nis ins viewing in
‘he Pham of Pree wie esas the pcan epi near
Inve and Suc the acy of tana as modes e deg th
tho dmencs of al expeceace. A getaten theme hi iano pee
‘ul ewes ta the space me actualy ses nota sce Cartes pace within
hich me mip ote pining hig we wees demu ee overecng
hem, Rae eas be pce wees alm fn Which we ue ewe
arian of vewie: Dep he also mutts, dinesine ef he word aod
hich meas arc ar any ether pct of. Wed ne ee nice om 4
"ae rina at paren oo Blof won At we have ee th carer
{218 The Sapa! nest
yee ae Bing rote and resnigue in wae we acl ve 0 agai
Fovhee aque dient on sata eel og oe wddestoar
ch ey la ea sa ap
Tv rick aap works a hat co with «cera dang sel eon
Aipucemec. At fe a il swat of on anton, mt ja imme
‘Enos fing blocker towed or We dont have to bet the ley
Sth sleet abo leven when wea tee, een ech
Proeting ences ine e Fogg wth ee clearest he wry ba el ef
sour memento coniiceed by adisaning nb e peo eng
10 we wer rund dk Set Gnas we ae popes apn tae
eal Be ike o move in he paces wes opening ae of a oma wich
{5 oul we don nee Oo my eneing te mm wie sea
I fue we woud sm Ecomatcay be wn oth ey mille sod he pe
Cone we gt here ral ices by nt we peony aged we mii eo
(G2.015) anripae af ne wou be hte mow nay gin note er
Ectoow Pat samc of ings da tony! pg of opr ei dete
of omrienetiay i ot mitts veg of wa es ek tap ee
Tener able cca wo Meas-Pony's uedeinding of ial ape
«qn He ening rep vac toate nan re cfg proce,
i me me make nl care wat we prety pre dey ut wat
‘weep nthe imac prose aps ww smut
Seine med ue What wee he einen ned
‘econ se wah ike upand afte wih”
{Sine a empl vats ad ue ch ene be mea pe oa
ovine Became tae oh ay ig ne ay a the ame ne hat
‘hin teu enced nthe medi one * What man ht don
tnagrste w the mamas wo gee compli of Homers ed Hoses}
toc on the tong hero enantio
icy smug i up on fees of eng
“Tas pnd yout eo merase pommel slp pti a ail vew,
bic wat ae i elton fo the nomena cesta of Eos th
Seance 9 whe ce fr when we ony me ts of pul ew.
NevePoc ns ht he whe hg we append ox the maa
Imei tem arial ewe we have fe no mee he crate ef
{can of dixcmcted ina seta dpe ee tine tan i sone al
toley meade ut mind tw sya the a is soe a
iSGterewew eich uly mec ie dg we ne okig wae romper)
‘Rn Msn vy sn th he ing epee be en
Intern sles of wat une mat pena ve an ace
‘Tre PheaenolpealTin 219
eta il ce sii if we i heron ot fon. te shin
‘Neesoe a asl el within the tpl Sow ef ea etal sing sod
‘Jatsng rua mpc Thr foes he He cent oo erin
ether of re rar fo, he we spend hing nt iy a aly debe
supe an eel nonsae:
Hw a ny hing ee ely Ad rly ro: al wn is es ave
ample pcos, any ements osble might be down
nt al eo th at of eee iw? Yer tee ameting snd no ting
en ifthe ne ee ane a ate owe ofthe sone Ee mld thik
‘has sult) ad ven fy olde reais me ep by Step
Sango tie nd canna ee be comp the it ema ta Freed
Sone eee Teco hat overlap cern
Techer of recs svt Tho erst we ld ts scott he
tC he hing an te weld an oly mea poring a completes =
lyr this complecion wend! rpsble By the wy ear of she pee
es ohich hee be crcl et ch ne Cf nls bye srs
to eter pony The conten come or ir fe qc fol
Conn wit he reves condo ow expend ies withthe ey
iy of Ling at hiking i we oper in ime, ced undead
[Bp me the mes fb”
king t= scape cold be taupe ofa inte kind of exe es
nae ere sly sare th venipny lle ino see gs han
even longa abject We ge ron aking king te ieee ps
‘heen pont an he unable, sing soe we ha ofr mediates |
‘ther tuh tly king te of ad este Is apeopatenes a8 De
{ieee plea We won gocty if we opened pou eeyy apprehension of ths
‘he ayer pac purse ssc ne ean jee Mo
dhaling withthe hing oe encour spt wth ie ecto pepe that
sac wk ayo he al wi ne me nt, ty me |
‘ately be Bech heen no apes ef he ae abe te
arg i ime Tes Mets one fn ht ae never aang lj
‘ewe thing canna ue beaten hci oe pct em =
Thee nobel of hing in themes tha erate iw eh wy Rate
There eehng 2 be en eyed ut tens Bue ecape abd tebe
‘we thoi bath bed upon and waned by tempor The med nthe all.
Sete the wa at a objec, rth a a nlp a ec and
‘eumiat best as a Sse tsps so wach sabeeNes i and
Inge hemes ate hey ae hse betes healer =
“he things sound w aod our bi cant be ly copa i ou eae of
lem areca eae theta me he or tring Cree{220 The Sep inagenson
are word he af, ja eo Mesos ony ekg abo ho we ape
end things aot to him, pence mpngine on oar seater
ings whole hing, a wholeness tage Be et formal resale,
‘he escnsbw bod eeevely Rater scale te setting wl be
{the matin an oningenis of ch xa tL exe thing tae
is kscanrncingly peeing tel toc eben thatthe rena mmc. hoa
1 fonber pce of Betoun ana ha peicly epee fo
rnhiaking of ster viewing ite nscence on she enuaine le fey ie
‘Gio bythe viewers avant hs or her ova weving ty hit het own cy
Suge mother worl Fr him sing oething soles wing oly
‘tg ane athe od lng ith he thngs we ea nut ew Whe he
vigor bc image aing ene sewing af ng shen be dst
fur ae ally aoa wl tioal eerie modes. Sich eds
‘charac oe inagiing then cos ke ing ale, Tc sage at peer
ie popted at Bang ain ohn of sme gure’ Te body age ene Psy
{ERO sve i cen tetrad ene arf ar onl te pe
el hing he wo rnd Ween bce ctl woe fs bcp age
sen ne loo lly a objec sacha apres bch hey inpge ny
‘nh ube cen wh out od ed
1 hs by ange Emel loge En tv rue vee
cee pact fe ant been dre a2 ble ie ot ie
|stome mae mick hd oe remapped nt Tao ape oe
ieee de thee ae we vee pring Ey
‘nae the fo the esd unde nies ete hos ple We a ae
thereat image tha cess ts af ee afte Ry ota
Teng cn oor ath the wel rin cee at a i ae eit
shou Sul a swcenen adore fil aco ht ces wel eon the its
the aly as tonal ei:
“The lyon ion he Bay tae meri an acre mas. We only eee i
pret a tie beg we pol al ova someting at it
‘mach pret stall ome he oie wd al ene ely
comer ate tat cote fone ta che magi on conse
‘hc o wich cea by hg nd he mel
Some Mens Pony mat hues a ageivedesitos nti
sal seme of vil sce coc we wd ci hi eh le
Tie pe cape hin lth hers af eing tl
‘Shes fing wien had ne a nds tie oeing. Here he cot
{feeclaely wep aod fd eiore wee of car bc oing ae ad
‘oui npn, with the et amines ey ee ching we el em he
nese He compute his wth tbe dupe Between ca ites ese ely
“he enomenclepialTum 21
ekg sto ad uc ese he ye at an aga plac in ur boy an imple
iRise scanning by he an of at se
i un hat my one hand eae ove the tet, hte i ach dee
‘Sbrone she mavens omy ya he change hee pace the ile
Sah dug bree cand, rend! manivenes and « Bid epennee
‘ha ches the nerd ty image we hve ef ese exes how we
Inpro te orl snd ur he poco ing, he eter ii af he
(iiigr wee aan mth he intern Iie a eu Sc Ue
My lsh hi i of what ac 4d hat the odd ea ithe woe nar
at ny wei of can thew ef dear oe of openings ound wc oe
‘pert The fin order wl the oe etry ‘a Canal he mere
Bntrsemingl stevia sertion) ad tng, dosnt pred ist
col ore] way, tht fie fc and dimen, he mute Se
‘cnn a stl yt metry body witan« glonaar bed *
Sac dy coldwell decries happens when we ae dew in oki a
‘os ferences tore era mpy 4h, ner, aan it
open yp someway, comag vo ie peemenen that once fli he
yumi or egehenne
“oe main sift at cued in Melu-Poiy thinking Comittee ft
care na ley romped by bs wang to ge ton the velance one of
pect ae snd coos sl opeting a sei wing In is
‘ogc, le jc cor hat acre ee mj mentary ies
fcc Hedcegen by whom be wa very mach duce, nh wer hing fo a2
{ioe be it the dominant me f sje aod ce im Wester tt
‘ig abs ulin Black af the word sme Knows hk and he sabe
{ie elecomning agen of cocina od age The ppl sine
‘fe mane tos made: me aint ler tara eng lene
‘simp perp, bowen th tb iret loving twice pr,
endl sl and the pyc win which was edd, he ue to evige
Seeing proces comply cme the pal eo what eh
nT Von mae eng, conc rc pie oa dein of
| viewing bj ee a ewe bj rece i consciones, Du 0 gap hat
ages thet fem pay of hing che ete ie teeta SE Pe
Sve Subj sel pes estan, ot» deal ey, ba ake of
tn ting”scrain ethingnen end ins naan tempor ae Sg
nd lng inital ea the king of Seng at aig’ Ath point
Mera Pay ssking to deine «vere of wig eter than a dictmoderssculpeua sensibly terween a made of viewing focused en denon of space
See tal eee ere ee
wih tar died by woo ncn Red Sens ip. nea Moving Te Wo
Sapecia h cloe gtemiol by swing Ee
‘eect fecha esting woe promicy bong Howtos,
{FNereurfesys her amis imme sorig 0 Pyeologil afc: he doe no
‘haoly pachloge vial evans When be dcrib the cenit te
tenes, te rien tar ne evs is a fda comitn exe
Fijced by Se wi is cocepon of teal ew maingnen” Teplice
ef elie he pn pola ne xprenced aa at ef mid
itt cons ny ste mind, Whe be woe word he meh of oe
‘perce world obliga eactiy to beers non
Sires Ler] whichis et epranmrvn cress [or Spice] sane
gen whch ello ck hich coi aac sate ge
tinted che ut, ame aod hte Ts mks Mele Poy ch
sels ike rhe go pil he we epee cag enn preps
{FEow ans engrmen ith hing tht aes plc ret any meet By deer
nd ppc sil hol gna gin wath he wo By ing el a
Tnoviteincorndings But fore aba ir woing ase whe td ed xi
tipo pereptn seme eng i har tas be neves bck he
‘incon ode, Fen ud lyse che gs ches, one
falerand more compelling mel for ehinking about de viewing ected by weeks of
‘ethan ne wk! hve fade siply rose hi wing i ke pei, he
lnmson otic A peeling of emer pone ca ly doce athe
Femarlting of he flange ewer el nat objec eigen inter
Tebece dm wie ean in rer on ee ari er
‘otk inns ca or amutens ms emory phewoneage wl be rca forthe kd
{Be ow pr co Thy yb fart ot big ie
‘Ove mo ange at hy we heeft in ato oe eesenaie xen
Yee ene the pect set f the bsprcece he
‘eld ed the words peenc ote by Reo sl ee wih ts ren24 The Spal magaton
Merlea-Ponty and cheViewng of Are
Se eae
rah nes es sagt ptane nt es ce
tS rete cnerreremaenarpaes’
Savane attghcoateaynsemoeeet
meneame as tn ina ance
bsetnicds
ac ii ata ma fay
spat caagics e cebe GySege at
Leena tpee oer cole
A Reveaiicranumetinacs Siren
diag Cer wen cps ige r nay
igre ha Rep nhs eat ae
mire cciogaumerteewarongracrmiris
Seo is eo ade dames
en them eny to Be epcced chit his views oo the vila esd fam coven
pigeon ect a
phase at ain mel imino
aemuernte i ee rere
sine re can po tieslgear reece
tbat mentieacecwareege’ teen seat
sSeutar die cmaurabeagree ee
Shinashck ofan hicterwring Hs eonceeong of ewingsieeered
ptt se ciao eta
iter ue moped nw trp a
thee thacn a eta ien eg roe cocci
ree ee eer
isc na cs cat octiea
Gach teiora uentyamrecrieceeeat
ange dade ili
lap odince cs parent a iy pest me pe
‘The PrenonenclpalTem 25
ge ig la emg nee no
Secu sting peng tees rp ool meagre A
Foe RT TS Shy Vn cl |
‘Seam became wet tae eo nd We ee pe
Shieh otic tema enone eg es
Somer we wes nee an ond ce
‘te enna ie pergcnw iner sd
The cy ‘Cl Do ed a pete me
Tene nel eens cre roe og
‘an Une Sa gs ee
SUSE fe paul ngs nme ont
Tern yo i a ved ego
sett ol nq ah ey er
ity ont a in
Meir tha fh mal aya yar ee
Sian teens ore!
Noro i eso Min eh ly al ee
xia a ene geo tt py ca
Sataraie teltteDec indeed micah
‘Seg ptnins tyme oes ue yt
Prenat Apna ee any clon
ere we m peter et narra cont
Sie erate wa pe oy ecg ag
Teck apc wn com pi ett ie ain
cn Re nee pon ey he et
‘Sisto ene putter amd pos cee aa
SEER cae cap any rf pn
Sith Pape eon ae
Scbstuctar tgal psopid ei e
Rites ape psy sha Sami ne ma
SOSEE peste al cr ne a‘he peti. At we he sen be ao engaged incresingy wih he he ieee
Botti many af ha wo nemporacs Bur 2 parcigmace ur othe
tmnkrn at werd fhe ee wt teed one lu ceive rveng eon
isc podem nt pple caged nero edwin and pe dete,
nd oo in capa ra, Ineed we 4 pie ur att spo, a
Meveu-Poiy hse ued Gisomer mane ri.
ofthe move inte cotengtay rages ate Abst Eset puting De
fo lave kn, nd ner of wht, jg om hs aod ae American
Cermmert® he would ply hve mapa pserly Bar» Medea Pot ike
{Grea posul pining embodied ee tre ete aes enc
eT ru Porys xine oping depcion wa cnet sn, a woth
lingeing on rt nomen cee made oer sae woking le
{otro th ysl io uri In parti he ld what waa wok
‘Bs supine he owe teres ee ping ety edi pet
Te pees pitng ind the weer n rem he pot hwagh whch [he
Peiminel wu enc othr, djeraing whined, having no gid the
‘type nar Lane ah ce of Shee
‘lcubng vs sapgesive ney the comple neo what apps when week
cent ant inorder Soe ot selon bw te poet
{png ssa sty whch sancanly pel ad ger! plays Se
{sl ee nating cry she meld 9 bj me 1 di ot ie ay
{Tend hc ws reg] the By apace wht wee 5 fo
Frocton, whith bag it bx the eta mmc ahd eros
{eur intial pps mold ee Be moda pci noah f hey a to
theme! cn a acl eaten offers. Ones schavwedge the at
Site iganon of lk hind ain gee ef body eee te
Shoes eet npn wars be tein ae, pea
chase be pre lng mi he ncn Hanes oe
Spi cucrd flected movement
‘Kegan nly das he byl poe
re
HR RRR A
The henonenepalTury 227
Iie Al he mor roe ten te geste of expen Cee pues maine
{he cava hh onderakes ew dw or deo olf a make ely
Ippon a hu cng sigh of wl epee woe
iovnd uoetnding ef om a ecko a ected. K oly the ce
‘Shine weet ach sd uy scons ordain eed bree a8
Pinch dee is lnraly greg be te met ef daeing wien ong 6
‘Shaisng an he ger faking ot abising ste st mone ashe
sos dacanege of aparece weighs subs o l Gomt
Tse pcr Greer oer see snd ce aecaoneael
Mone ne sos caing icy into «Bae amp wont he gestae in
Tire tc th ptrogn sy cmc tail stig of af making
The machin to se of sae aki he Eoin, oly fo oat
Nese Pou srmbioric view of the proces atic ibecton made sense
Palo fa exumple wer ined nthe ae of pene apiecr of tl.
Primer gel pling, he ahs rl dregs ee a
foe infard wh he arta’ ceive mpulie wee thx mote conscouly dbo
Tinea wok, + Key sce tose at ten singly asamp
only sls Jus mela pope ape wh ken
feetne nurse (ig. 1021 At the teste any tac of gest srons betwen
lay beeween sing and making ws pebably a fori ging the mote poplar nd
tio seem unduly wedded vos lnw-standne modernist assrpsion which was 5008 10
‘Ste anoning wien he me commen ket wel othe piers ewe,‘The ay Tne Langage nh ei Sic hi poem fad
Luque om ster den, ue omental engine He Me tuc
‘sre ttm cen brwern he macy at poy oval tetas
{etc cmplr eli sone ue of nd gue wees Ta
ftom pricing «poral ee of te ad pelagic pce, Be gut
ten he pony ef rguagesssoryesdcrandog cert or ba et
‘our sin begs nt phys wot. angus, We she emt et
‘gute olson as wey ft pcs secng ta. Te whl oping
fen occ iad lr ay ong Chick sey ig
twlcond: Sayin the opesded mpc oflangnge eh coating mag
Foul 4 Inga scan, by anes With te sg aod ee hae
Foelca se wane foe nal sang sxsoning pe
Source Is posed fn ite Nida a ra
Exng a ag rege aly poe vo he ewe” Al hi some fos dn
Thc innit acs co ome ating wich pain cli rl ae
(irc cued oy bring des mich tha wing theron of Ca
“pth exe 1 acces he hyprsisa eriy ata ely
confor i, htt ma tie ton eth srg i vague
merger victors icons ine witha signin Thess Opa, wich
‘Dwcmmch ede uese Greece oun inthe rin in ch chy hve
‘Se dowa us wie, Sen, detached fo he whee wok ~ st
‘ape Groce. They came ee tne ene manent drs eve han nce
Fite, om anon gle Heche Gaga] ee ows et umn t
arsarae ren i ers cin, bcs spine dposted there
(over cbervns noni thee ed bea etng ne
‘lithe nfo he ed lapiage sys omer lee wes ating
Seon of hae
{re Neven-Peny, + work ofa, while isnbly deetig oe ie Le alt
ira ings Worse co mina the eenyriny w aBche tbesa
Teun To lig hp Men nyo sagt th tnd
wit des wok aan sesso luc, tie ng sharin lt
{ies incon ad ein ley o tac something er bed
‘linus aes ry dey ed ohne emia
vine enue ay spe ag eb eval et
[ings fede se feel and Ss expert ht Peed
Tschace wit we ote aspect ema bing pce WY
Inve psy ef ici Ml’ ie fs mucu isha wl, Me Py
voted sTangssmdg pene of tans sma Saya 8
ena sh wey cn Hep sh mon ote Spel
Syevaateaen hse wis mi ve cs ed eget with
USS ns del cr nd pn sch mo wen ge
‘he hr une sour he ua esl arse duplyng md err
The PrnenrlolTom 2
eing of telated frm at moe exe eager wth igs, he sel» pl
iaredge uc susequely pied an incopy peminet lei ate gale
ude the ae gee Take ths pose:
‘Wego [co muvn] wih avr which nt completly ein. The mun
Ike fe ar we ae Bug The 1c comes ew te fo ee a all
{hein dhe wel wore ct mae fb phi thse mre wall force
Please of Sandy romenaes or Noniy inelcuns, We ae well ae th htt
[Stata nthe comemplnine epee evel he te ac
ae 10 many ples sn pain 3 man ange v0 mh werk, wee
Sod ce oe day hal ih ache au The mau ae le
pate becuse cf wrk by denching hr Gn th ef the en
‘Wot x nigh ea akeacve made of vowing > eight be he viewing
ef are woks ste ira ote othe arts ste ftps comming i
elec compress nfl Malin ering: Bo hn wl lees et of
‘out nes Pry mae nian ge he wy pe
[Seok when excunted nome ind of pb epg sng
“Tha ober waste nna wich mot mr wa te ae
‘aged o be ewe, But theta something mode at Mee Poy
“The melons ive in making a wk ofa eval rs pute ny
slic ine yoy mah pats o-te tno witht The comping
‘ri soe one hr eka agua thee emend the ater cand 2
teme an objee oily. wee wo sting that one cone ivan
thecamet ef sewing. Rate Ad me ae en work tae the
rein wen crema the oder ws apd mas hrm ral the
trol sed de mopar acti If we ve turns wth wl Bere
The museum ambience permenant any coer mith an otk, cen to
the pou telpng ro meat th ancy thal when mor cms obra
once pe ont
|p el peso, ey Ho ee ae
Seer be prtclarty concn otc he yee hich de me ping
ier ales nal fences Lindo valiny een when it ange
‘petal but ‘ualpustne' ora He fw issue of bow potcing
Iss mock co do wich viewing ulna at mith ening seme ane he ise
‘rund how he gen ve fn cna eps mock ves #
Sabo ereen te oweMo sekinly sew ae she ihe aie it he ambit of depth ad ee
sveulacns of vty pode by leat pu ‘Incaning bow thee
Septet intial ets can cee sate pence, Tae fot empl ta
Sisey of dimesves, of gla “loli” where everyting ae ond
{hes tine fem hit ig wh and ence bce, he cpg
fC slaminesiy wach coe execs ia wer by saying Ga ing her
svahn sae en iene ete, ately, tng Tai er
‘Sten of sn emlping values ee iy ped eeeen te soe
‘hiking abn eng theedinenonl wade ar nella pasting,
‘Nereu-Poey nese nein of ping at be rend oe Wewing of
scalps bon he nse ite dle of ving led by pi
Brag im play eteae mel opal mess bere oes Sey an
rll nob eis tna Viewing camo be nceeeed arn ope of pt
hich soc asemen ofp, band pace cin, bac wih inte
Tring of van and moremen. Thi extn etal ecco
‘isn word su whch oe doc oe tn snongh, fds oes cece of
whee nef ot hw in deans che mos bse tf aerating eases oe
‘Rit f he sre we pln ling sunny ad oping
‘espa Kind of hoe deed ino the vio, a ceria cstv empeinen The
Thi echo» comment f itn The Vi andthe vison how stein con
‘aa, the envelope ff hing) seca, dced is oe wi makes 2
‘hing em, Ope bt hell of ce aah eit dhs pe
“Thea cnoet erre am, but i he theese depth cola which
“Ts beings net the caval pie: what in scuprace might be ee equivalent the
[nat ring ch subject" but i ale proved oe suggestive er acer
{FoatgeueGoe mighty da eer + povcin ott caper that
the suai nell woul be opie snd wl wing ea i. he
‘evs eons ary work eo way bce te costrce line ea seule
el ene empy sce. A me get pre wold be hn he wasn
‘soqulibeiun’ eps up in anes apeeension oft 5 the aegis somethin of he
fain eenly ced ic ans mel aed and pm peer wing
Slice wk one tare ssly swe th Vis Men Poty 9
Ieckapin theme pen tree see fn ysl pect fi
Satin Bg cel peck lk
bins way wha he we sr! ait woking in hve denne he
Fast sense of andr, tn see meio he sae wn isl pec eps
2 Psa past tae way de