Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Shalom Yacob Research Management Final
Shalom Yacob Research Management Final
By:
Advisor:
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION .........................................................................................................................................................2
1. 1 Background Of The Study .......................................................................................................................................... 2
1. 2 Statement Of The Problem ........................................................................................................................................ 3
1.3 Objective Of The Study ............................................................................................................................................. 4
1.4 Research Question ...................................................................................................................................................... 4
2. REVIEW LITERATURE ...................................................................................................................................................5
2.1 The Concept Of Work-Life Balance ........................................................................................................................... 5
2.2 Why Is The Wlb Concept Still An Issue? ...................................................................................................................... 6
2.3 Definitions And Implications ......................................................................................................................................... 7
2.4 The Scope Of Work Life Balance ................................................................................................................................. 8
2.5 Work Life Balance And The Challnges Ahead ........................................................................................................ 8
2.6 The Influencing Elements In Work Life Balance ....................................................................................................... 8
2.7 The Global Scenario Of Work Life Balance .............................................................................................................. 8
2.8 Work/Life Discourses........................................................................................................................................................ 9
2.9 Changes In The Discourse ............................................................................................................................................. 9
2.10Work/Life Theories ..........................................................................................................................................................10
3. R E S E A R C H METHODOLOGY ...............................................................................................................................13
3.1 Research Type And Approach ...............................................................................................................................13
3.2 Research Population ..................................................................................................................................................13
3.3 Research Design ...........................................................................................................................................................13
3.4 Research Plan .............................................................................................................................................................14
3.5 Expected Outputs .......................................................................................................................................................14
3.8 Budget Breakdown/Details Of Expenditure .......................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
3.9 Work Plan/Activity Time ................................................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................................................................15
1
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
1 INTRODUCTION
Human resource is the most strategic resource as no other resource can be fully utilized to generate
income and wealth of a nation without the active involvement of this resource. In fact, the differences
in the levels of economic development of the countries are largely a reflection of the differences in the
quality of their human resources and their involvement in national building. The key elements such as
values, attitudes, general orientation and the quality of the people of a country determine its economic
development. However, human resources are being wasted through unemployment, disguised
unemployment, obsolescence of skills, and lack of work opportunities, poor personnel practices and the
hurdles of adjusting to change. Human resource accounts for a large part of national output and there
exists a wide scope for increasing national wealth through their proper development. Human factor
provides value to physical resource and necessary dynamism in the economy.
Dynamic people can build dynamic organizations. Effective employees can contribute to the
effectiveness of their organization. Competent and motivated people can make things happen and enable
an organization to achieve its goals. Hence, organizations should continuously ensure that the
dynamism, competency, motivation and effectiveness of the employees remain at high levels.
Human resource is even the most critical factor for determining the efficiency and effectiveness of an
organization because it is precisely the people who will decide when and how to acquire and utilize
various resources, including human resources, in the best interest of the organization. The ultimate
success and survival of an organization will invariably be determined by the quality and competence of
its human resources.
Work-life balance practices are deliberate organizational changes in programs or organizational culture
that are designed to reduce work-life conflict and enable employees to be more effective at work and in
other roles. The transition from viewing work-life balance practices solely as a means of accommodating
individual employees with care giving responsibilities to recognizing their contribution to organizational
performance and employee engagement is an important paradigm shift that is still very much ‘in process.’
2
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
It is visible that less attention is given to the concept of work-life balances in developing countries like
Ethiopia. This study will assess the current practices concerning this matter and suggest some
professional recommendations.
A lack of work-life balance is associated with emotional and behavioral problems such as: anxiety,
depression, guilt, decreased productivity, and problematic drinking (Kalliath & Brough, 2008).
Additionally, a lack of work-life balance can lead to increased stress and a sense of burnout (Ten
Brummelhuis & Van Der Lippe, 2010). Regardless of sex, gender identity, or marital status, both men
and women struggle with work life balance (Powell & Greenhaus, 2010).
Over the years a number of work-life balance initiatives have been implemented in the workplace with
the goal of creating better balance for employees (Zacharious, 2005). However, these initiatives have
largely been geared towards women in the workplace and tend to be underutilized, especially by men
and pre-retirement employees (Darcy et al., 2012). As a starting point, it is important to understand
what the term work-life balance means and how it is defined. A cohesive, definite and consistent
definition of work-life balance has not been adequately defined in the literature (Greenhaus, Collins, &
Shaw, 2003; Reiter, 2007)
There is a lot of problems concerning this work-life balance concept which are sated above. And it is
known than higher education and academic institutions need a better focus concerning this concept
since higher academic institutions have a lot to contribute in shaping the a certain country. And the
success of Academic institutions will be the success of a nation. This study studies the work-life balance
practices and trend in one of the universities in Ethiopia and tries to see which practices are harmful
and which should be motived for further improvement.
3
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
4
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
2. REVIEW LITERATURE
The importance of managing an employee’s WLB has increased markedly over the past 20 years (De
Bruin & Dupuis, 2004). Changes in the definition of ‘normal working hours’, the demographic make-
up of the labour force (i.e. gender, ethnicity, dual career couples, and religion), and the very nature of
the employment contract have necessitated an increased organisational concern for their employees’
wellbeing (Greenhaus & Powell, 2006). In order to achieve a WLB, leading western organisations have
tended to adopt policies such as on-site child-care facilities, on-site gymnasiums, telecommuting
opportunities, and even on-site sleeping quarters for the employee and their family (Hacker & Doolen,
2003; Hyman & Summers, 2004). Each has attempted to increase the flexibility by which employees
can effectively enact their work-roles whilst simultaneously enabling them to enact their family-based
roles to the extent necessary. Ideally, the WLB concept requires organisations to effectively integrate
employees’ work and non-work roles such that levels of multiple-role conflict, and the associated stress
and job-dissatisfaction, are minimised or avoided (De Bruin & Dupuis, 2004; Greenblatt, 2002).
5
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
Despite the best intentions of organisations to implement WLB policies, there remains considerable
contention about their effectiveness in delivering flexibility and reducing stress and job-dissatisfaction in
the workplace (Eates, 2004; Kirrane & Buckley, 2004). Researchers have identified two empirical
shortcomings within the WLB literature that have served to undermine its theoretical usefulness. The
first relates to the WLB literature’s almost exclusive focus on the work-family interface. Buzzanell et al,
(2005) notes that the WLB literature typically portrays role conflicts for white, married, professional
and managerial women, with little reference to the many other demographics represented in the modern
organisation. Shorthose (2004) and Wise and Bond (2003) go so far as to state that the WLB discipline
is essentially flawed, as it is ‘one-dimensional’, assumes a unitary perspective, and that its underlying
management has been one of maintaining status-quo rather than supporting the development.
The second relates to the literature’s inability to clearly define the array of non-work roles that impact
employees’ working-life. Elloy and Smith (2004) and Spinks (2004), for example, state that because an
individual’s non-work roles are inherently ambiguous and idiosyncratic, organisations are incapable of
understanding how their enactment (or otherwise) impacts each individual. Spinks (2004), in particular,
suggests that organisations are either incapable (or unwilling) to understand their workforce in sufficient
detail, and have instead defaulted to a ‘one-size-fits-all’ policy regime that has simply enabled employees
to ‘stay at work longer’ rather than enable them to enact their non-work roles.
The inadequacy of current WLB policy regimes is highlighted by Kiger’s (2005) study that revealed that
less than two percent of employees actually participate in available WLB programs. Dex and Smith
(2002) cite two main causes for this low figure. The first relates to equity, with many employees
reporting that they did not wish to appear a ‘special case’ or to require ‘special treatment’ to their
colleagues. The second is that the wide range of policies adopted by organisations have been based on
an ill-informed conceptualisation of contemporary WLB, and that this has led to its ineffective
formalisation in human resource management practices.
The contribution of the WLB literature, therefore, appears limited in its ability to provide a useful
framework for both academics and practitioners alike (Hyman & Summers, 2004). Despite its name, the
WLB literature remains largely focused on the work-family interface and fails to accurately identify and
define the array of non-family roles that impact on an individual’s working-life (Hacker & Doolen, 2003;
Mellor, Mathieu, Barnes-Farrell & Rogelberg, 2001; Noor, 2004; Pocock, 2005).
6
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
The word Work-Life Balance is sometimes considered as interwoven with Work-family conflict.
However, it can be argued that the latter is more limited in scope than the former because the focus in
work-family conflict is more on the relations between work & family. It is also referred to as family
friendly work arrangements, (FFWA), and in international literature, as alternative work arrangements
(AWA).
Work-Life Balance is the relationship between time and space of work & non-work in societies where
income is predominantly generated and distributed through labor markets. Work-Life Balance is being
aware of different demands on time and energy saving the ability to make choices in the allocation of
time and energy knowing what values to apply. Much confusion and ambiguity surrounds in
understanding and defining the term Work –Life Balance. As a term in its own right Work-Life Balance
is rarely defined for reasons that will become clearer as the discussion progresses. Many authors attempt
to define Work-Life Balance policy or Work-Life Balance arrangements. Nevertheless it is possible to
discern a number of distinct strands in the literature in relation to definitional and conceptual issues.
The first of these themes concerns the contention area of family friendly versus Work-Life family in
order to reflect a broader and more inclusive way of conceptualizing the issue and to enable men and
those without children, for example to identify with them . However the perception that Work-Life
Balance policies are a family matter and aimed solely at women with children is still held by many
employees & employers.
Despite the worldwide quest for Work-Life Balance very few have found an acceptable definition of
the concept: here are some proven definitions that will positively impact one’s every day value & balance.
Best individual Work-Life Balance will vary overtime, often on a daily basis. The right balance today
will probably be different for tomorrow. The right balance when one is single will be different when
after marriage and having children; when one is on a start to new career versus when one is nearing to
retirement. There is no perfect, one size fits all, as balance is different for each of us because we all have
different priorities and different lives. However, at the core of an effective Work-Life Balance definition
are two key everyday concepts that are relevant, they are daily achievement and enjoyment, ideas, almost
deceptive in their simplicity. Enlarging a fuller meaning of these two concepts takes us to most of the
ways a positive
Work-Life Balance achievement. Achievement means finish something successfully, especially after
trying hard or receiving what one wants. Enjoyment does not mean happiness but it means pride,
satisfaction, happiness, celebration, love a sense of wellbeing and all the joys of living. Achievement and
enjoyment are the two sides of the coin value in life. One can’t have one without the other. Trying to
live a one sided life is why so many “successful” people are not happy or not nearly as happy as they
should be.
7
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
8
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
to the unhealthy choices that many Americans were making in favor of the work place as they opted to
neglect family, friends and leisure activities in the pursuit of corporate goals. Articles of the time
suggested a sharp increase in the working hours of the Americans. This had started to affect their families
and individual health. Work life balance slowly was gaining grounds in the various organizations. By the
end of the decade, work life balance was seen as more than just a women’s issue, affecting men, families,
organizations and cultures.
In 1990s solidified the recognition of work-life balance as a vital issue for everyone women, men,
parents and non-parents, singles and couples. The 1990s saw a rise in the number of working women
and dual-income families. A second family configuration, the lone parent household also became
prevalent in the 1990s.The labor force experienced considerable challenges in balancing the work and
family responsibilities. This growing awareness of the central importance of the issue resulted in major
growth in attempted work-life solutions during this decade. Numerous studies showed that the
generations from baby boomers to new college graduates were making job choices based on their own
work-life issues and employer’s cultures.
Developments in the work/life discourse have increasingly paid attention to workplace practices,
structures and cultures (Fletcher, 1996, 2002; Rapoport, 1996, 2000) and to consideration of an
“expansionist/enrichment” perspective with a focus on concepts of reciprocity and facilitation (Barnett
& Hyde, 2001; Greenhaus, 2006; Grzywacz, 2002).Barnett (2001) explores an expansionist model in
which multiple roles are seen to bebeneficial for men and women, in that performance in one role can
facilitate performance in other roles. On this, Voydanoff & Donnelly (1999) suggests that there is an
upper limit of roles beyond which overload or conflict may occur, but that importantly, it is the quality
9
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
of the role that has significance in terms of stress and work/life balance. Barnett (2001) also questions
some views on gender and contends that opportunity structures at work shape work behaviors and that
role quality is associated with stress, which did not differ by gender.
Other related areas of research that have paid attention to expansion and enrichment dimensions have
indicated that the number and range of work and non-work roles can enhance feelings of well-being in
both work and non-work domains (Bailyn, 1993; Friedman, 2000; Rothbard, 1999). They also argue
that contextual factors, such as emotional support (Epstein, 1987, 2000), work challenge, life/career
priorities and gender equity (Rapoport, 2002), can play a positive role in supporting work/life balance.
Related to this dimension of research is the literature on the effects of individual agency. This recognizes
that individuals, particularly those in managerial and professional roles, have an opportunity to exercise
some control, discretion or capacity for negotiation in relation to work and non-work activities
(Poelmans, 2004).
The concept of the dual agenda (Rapoport, 2002) is increasingly a feature of work/life commentary.
The theoretical underpinnings in DoE’s Flexible Work Options: achieving work/life balance program
(DET, 1998, Palamara, 1999), indicate a commitment to a dual agenda—of meeting individuals’ needs
for work/life balance and improving organizational, work unit, and individual performance in a climate
of devolved responsibility for human resource management in schools.
1. Physical
2. Temporal
3. Psychological.
10
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
Clark’s (2000) theory offers a set of eight propositions relating to the strength and weakness of borders
and the similarity and differences of domains. It contends that borders and domains must work in
tandem for balance to take place and those changes to borders (e.g. flexibility)require analogous changes
to the domain’s culture and values (accountability, deadlines,support). Other propositions are that
control and influence within a domain increase controlover borders, and levels of in-domain support
increase work/life balance. It draws on the work of Nippert-Eng (1996) which explores issues of control
over placement and transcendence ofwork and non-work boundaries and Perlow (1998). Perlow (1998),
in a study of a work unit comprising seventeen professionals in a high-technology firm, explored the
nature of thetemporal boundary between work and life outside of work. Whilst the study focused on
the imposition of temporal demands at work, it also considered the effects on the structuring ofboth
work time and non-work time and made the observation that while all employees in thestudy faced
boundary control, some were acceptors and others resistors. Spouses, also included in the study, had
either acceptor or resistor reactions.
Singh (2002) uses Clark’s (2000) Work/Family Border Theory, repositioned as Work/Life Border
Theory, to underpin research into managers’ strategies for work/life balance and maps these strategies
according to levels of accommodation or negotiation with the organization or with the family—an
approach which draws on Perlow’s (1998) categorizations (above). This line of research appears to offer
insight into both the action of management and the process of effecting work/life balance, and, as such,
offers useful insights into the research questions.
Barnett (2001) proposes a Work Family Expansionist Theory in which multiple roles are seen to be
beneficial for men and women. Performance in one role, it is argued, can facilitate performance in other
roles. Barnett also questions whether some gender and work/life balance theories may be outdated,
contending that opportunity structures at work and role quality, which did not differ by gender, are
associated with stress and work/life balance.
11
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
This theory also identifies the paths by which resources create an effect in work and non-work roles and
identifies the factors that moderate the effect of the above resources—salience of the role (perceived
importance of the role to an individual); perceived importance of resources to the role in question, and
the match between the resources and the requirements and norms of the work or non-work role.
One example of a theory or approach which deals with the process of managing the work/life interface
is presented by Limoges (2003). The theory describes the following actions as those determining the
successful balancing of work and personal life:
• drawing on a wide range of managerial and personal strategies and applying them in the work
and non-work domains
• Ensuring workload is manageable and off-setting new tasks by letting go of less important ones
• Placing importance on nurturing relationships and involvement in non-work activities
• engaging fully in work and non-work domains. Limoges (2003) approaches the issue from a
career planning perspective and includes taxonomy of work/life strategies
12
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The Researcher will use this procedures will utilizing this research Methods.
• First gathers data on a one-shot basis
• represents a wide target population
• generates numerical data;
• provides descriptive, inferential and explanatory information;
• manipulates key factors and variables to derive frequencies;
• presents material which is uncluttered by specific contextual factors.
It is known that there are two main types of survey: a descriptive survey: concerned with identifying
& counting the frequency of a particular response among the survey group, or an analytical
survey: to analyses the relationship between different elements (variables) in a sample group.so the
researcher will use a mixed type of methods to collect the necessary information and the type of the
survey will be a descriptive one.
13
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
3.4.1 D a t a collection
Data will be collected from selected samples from the population which will be Dire Dawa University
academic staffs using those methods. During data collection and analysis, quantitative research
method will be performed which involve some numerical and statistical analysis of data.
3.4.2 A n a l y s i s of data
The Data analysis for this study is made using regression analysis. And finally the result will be clearly
presented using tables and plots of charts. The reason why the researcher chooses regression analysis is
because it gives the best result in analyzing relationships between two independent and one dependent
variable. And it is one of the most frequently used tools in researches. In its simplest form, regression
analysis allows researchers to analyze relationships between one independent and one dependent variable.
In its applications, the dependent variable is usually the outcome we care about (e.g., time), while the
independent variables are the instruments we have to achieve those outcomes with (e.g., scheduling).
Regression analysis can provide insights that few other techniques can. The key benefits of using
regression analysis are that it can:
14
ASSESSMENT OF WORK-LIFE BALANCE PRACTICES (IN CASE OF DIRE DAWA UNIVERSITY STAFFS) BY SHALOM YACOB
REFERENCES
Publication in: New Ways to Work and the Working Mother's Association in the United Kingdom
Alterman, T; Luckhaupt, SE; Dahlhamer, JM; Ward, BW; Calvert, GM (June 2013). "Job insecurity, work-family
imbalance, and hostile work environment: Prevalence data from the 2010 National Health Interview Survey". Am J Ind
Med 56 (6): 660–669. doi:10.1002/ajim.22123. PMID 23023603.
-definition, Social
Exchange, and Job Attitudes." Journal of Organizational Behavior 27.5 (2006): 571.
agement Communication Quarterly 14.1 (2000): 90-
128. Print.
-family conflict the poor, the professionals, and the
missing middle center. Center for American Progress, Hastings College of the Law.
15