Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Movie Analysis
Movie Analysis
December 7, 2023
1
Purpose:
This analysis embarks on an intricate exploration of Princess Diana's inner turmoil depicted in
"Spencer," with a primary focus on her poignant struggle with an eating disorder. It seeks to
meticulously dissect the multifaceted layers of emotions, behaviors, and psychological complexities
portrayed in the film, aiming to unravel the profound psychological underpinnings that contributed to
her disorder.
delve into the societal dynamics that significantly influenced and exacerbated her struggles. By
unraveling the interplay between her personal vulnerabilities and the immense societal pressures
imposed upon her as a public figure, it aims to illuminate the complex web of influences that shaped
her experience.
Through an empathetic lens of psychology, this analysis seeks to humanize Diana's narrative,
transcending the royal persona to uncover the vulnerable human behind the title. By immersing deeply
into her emotional journey as depicted in the film, it aims to present a relatable and emotive portrayal
that resonates with individuals facing similar challenges, fostering a profound connection to her
plight.
Relevance:
The analysis endeavors to demystify the intricacies of eating disorders by offering an intimate
2
"Spencer," it aims to dispel misconceptions and societal stigma surrounding these
understanding.
Engaging deeply with Diana's internal landscape allows for a profound emotional connection,
fostering empathy and compassion for individuals grappling with eating disorders. By delving into the
emotional intricacies depicted in the film, it encourages a heartfelt and empathetic understanding of
Through a critical examination of the societal pressures and expectations imposed upon
Diana, the analysis aims to underscore the detrimental impact of societal scrutiny on mental health.
By shedding light on the immense stressors and relentless public scrutiny faced by individuals in the
public eye, it emphasises the crucial role of societal support and understanding in mitigating the
In essence, this comprehensive analysis seeks to provide a profound and nuanced exploration
of Princess Diana's psychological journey depicted in "Spencer." It aims to offer insight, empathy, and
a deeper understanding of the intricate interplay between personal vulnerabilities, societal pressures,
and the complexities of eating disorders, thereby fostering a more informed and compassionate
This film, while providing an invaluable glimpse into Diana's life, must be recognized as a
fictionalized representation of her experiences. It's essential to approach the depiction of eating
disorders with sensitivity and responsibility, understanding that cinematic portrayals often simplify or
dramatize complex mental health issues. While the movie offers insights, it's vital to remember that
3
the reality of eating disorders is multifaceted, and any representation in a film might not encapsulate
"Spencer" immerses viewers into the opulent yet suffocating environment of Sandringham
during the Christmas holidays. This setting acts as a pressure cooker, exacerbating societal
expectations and intensifying familial tensions. Within this grand yet confining backdrop, Diana
grapples with the overwhelming constraints imposed by her marriage to Prince Charles. The film
becomes a psychological canvas, vividly painting the intricate struggles of an individual battling an
eating disorder.
The opulence of Sandringham's estate juxtaposed with the emotional turmoil Diana
experiences creates a poignant backdrop for exploring the complexities of her mental health. The
weight of tradition, royal protocols, and the scrutiny of the public eye converge with Diana's internal
The film, through its portrayal of Diana's interactions and inner turmoil, delves into the
psychological pressures and expectations placed upon her. The lavish yet claustrophobic setting serves
as a metaphor for the conflicting forces influencing Diana's psyche. The movie invites viewers to
witness the intricate interplay between external pressures and internal battles, shedding light on the
emotional toll of living within the royal family's rigid structures while contending with personal
demons.
By establishing this richly layered setting and context, "Spencer" crafts a narrative that not
only portrays Diana's external circumstances but also seeks to delve into the intricate, nuanced
landscape of her mental and emotional struggles, particularly concerning her experience with an
eating disorder.
4
Analyzing "Spencer": A Deeper Dive into the Film's Psychological Landscape
the Christmas holidays. This setting serves as a microcosm for Diana's internal struggle, amplifying
The film masterfully creates a sense of Diana's isolation, both within the vastness of the estate
and within her own marriage. The rigid structure of royal life, with its strict protocols and unwavering
expectations, further intensifies her feeling of entrapment. We see this manifested in scenes like the
Christmas feast, where the weighing of guests and the forced merriment highlight the suffocating
atmosphere.
Contemplating Escape:
Throughout the film, Diana grapples with the desire to break free from the constraints of her
life. This is evident in her recurring dreams and fantasies, which offer her temporary solace from the
harsh reality. We witness this in scenes like her dance sequence in the empty ballroom, where she
The film subtly alludes to Diana's past experiences, suggesting that unresolved trauma plays a
significant role in her current mental state. We see glimpses of her childhood through flashbacks,
5
hinting at a lack of emotional support and potential neglect. These experiences likely contributed to
The film portrays the relentless public scrutiny Diana faces as a member of the royal family.
The constant media attention and pressure to maintain a perfect image exacerbate her anxiety and
negatively impact her self-esteem. This is evident in scenes like the paparazzi chase, where the
intrusion and lack of privacy leave her feeling vulnerable and exposed.
Character Portrayals:
Diana:
Kristen Stewart delivers a nuanced portrayal of Diana, capturing both her vulnerability and
her inner strength. We witness her emotional turmoil through her facial expressions, subtle gestures,
and the haunting echoes of her inner voice. The film effectively portrays the cyclical nature of her
eating disorder, showcasing the guilt, shame, and despair that accompany each episode.
Charles:
The film portrays Prince Charles as a distant and emotionally unavailable figure, contributing
to Diana's feelings of loneliness and isolation. His inability to connect with her on an emotional level
leaves her feeling unsupported and further exacerbates her internal struggles.
The film depicts the royal family as an institution steeped in tradition and rigid expectations.
Their adherence to protocol and their inability to acknowledge Diana's individuality contribute to her
sense of being trapped and misunderstood. This is evident in scenes like the Christmas dinner, where
her attempts to express her feelings are met with disapproval and dismissal.
6
Inferences from the Movie:
● Eating Disorders as a Coping Mechanism: The film suggests that Diana's eating disorder
serves as a coping mechanism for her emotional distress, allowing her to temporarily escape
● The Power of Imagination: Diana finds solace and a sense of agency through her imagination.
Her dreams and fantasies offer her a temporary escape from the harsh reality of her situation.
● The Importance of Self-Awareness: While initially struggling with denial, Diana demonstrates
a growing awareness of the negative impact of her eating disorder and the need to seek help.
● The Need for Empathy and Support: The film highlights the importance of empathy and
support for individuals struggling with mental health challenges. Diana's isolation and lack of
● The Societal Impact on Mental Health: The film critiques the unrealistic expectations and
pressures placed upon individuals, particularly within the public eye. These societal factors
can significantly contribute to the development and exacerbation of mental health issues.
Informant:
● Movie narrative: Provides a detailed account of Diana's actions, interactions, and emotional
● Diana's thoughts and inner dialogues: The film utilizes flashbacks and voiceovers to reveal
● Nonverbal communication: Subtle facial expressions, gestures, and body language offer
7
Chief Complaints:
● Isolation and Entrapment: The film portrays Diana's sense of isolation within the royal family,
highlighting the rigid structure and expectations that restrict her freedom and individuality.
● Fear of Scrutiny and Judgment: Constant media attention and the pressure to maintain a
perfect public image exacerbate Diana's anxiety and negatively impact her self-esteem.
● Shame and Guilt: The cyclical nature of the eating disorder is depicted, including the guilt and
● Early Onset: The film suggests that Diana's bulimia nervosa symptoms began in her early
twenties, potentially as a coping mechanism for her emotional struggles and anxieties.
● Exacerbation by Royal Life: The pressures of royal life, including the rigid protocols, public
scrutiny, and lack of emotional support, are shown to exacerbate Diana's eating disorder
symptoms.
● Cyclicality of Symptoms: Throughout the film, we witness Diana's struggle with binge eating
A Deeper Look into Diana's Background: Family, Personal History, and Education
Medical History:
While the movie doesn't explicitly state any specific medical conditions besides bulimia
nervosa, there are subtle hints that suggest potential underlying issues. Diana's frequent bouts of
physical illness, coupled with her reliance on medication, point towards the possibility of other health
concerns. However, the film primarily focuses on the psychological impact of her eating disorder,
Legal History:
8
Given Diana's position as a member of the royal family, legal matters likely fell under a
different jurisdiction than the public eye. The film doesn't delve into any legal entanglements Diana
may have faced, indicating a focus on her personal struggles rather than legal issues.
Family History:
The film paints a picture of a complex family dynamic that significantly impacted Diana's
emotional well-being.
● Parents' Divorce: Diana's parents divorced when she was young, which likely contributed to
feelings of instability and emotional neglect. This early experience might have made her
● Mother's Emotional Distance: The film portrays Diana's mother as emotionally unavailable,
leaving Diana feeling unsupported and lacking a key source of comfort during her formative
years. This could have further exacerbated her feelings of isolation and loneliness.
● Supportive but Limited Brother: While her brother is depicted as supportive, the film suggests
that he doesn't fully understand the depth of Diana's struggles. This lack of complete
understanding might have prevented him from providing the level of support she needed.
Personal History:
Diana's personal history is characterized by a sense of displacement and a struggle to find her
identity.
● Early Loneliness: The film hints at Diana's early life being marked by loneliness and a lack of
belonging, potentially due to her parents' divorce and the emotional distance she experienced.
● Search for Identity: Throughout the film, we see Diana grappling with her identity as Princess
of Wales and trying to reconcile it with her own desires and aspirations. This internal conflict
9
Educational History:
While the film doesn't explicitly detail Diana's academic achievements, it mentions her
attendance at West Heath Girls' School and Institut Alpin Videmanette. This information suggests that
Diana received a formal education, but it doesn't provide insights into her academic strengths or
interests.
Occupational History:
As Princess of Wales, Diana's primary occupation involved undertaking royal duties and
public engagements. The film portrays the demanding nature of these responsibilities and the pressure
to maintain a perfect image in the public eye. This constant pressure likely contributed to her stress
Combining these insights provides a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that
shaped Diana's life and contributed to her struggles with an eating disorder. By examining her medical
history (although limited), legal history (non-existent in the film's narrative), family dynamics,
personal development, education, and occupational demands, we can build a richer picture of the
Additional Information:
● Traumatic Childhood: Flashbacks and Diana's inner thoughts hint at a potentially traumatic
● Search for Identity: The film explores Diana's search for her own identity amidst the
● Defense Mechanisms: The film portrays Diana's use of various defense mechanisms, such as
10
Deep Dive into the Portrayal of Bulimia Nervosa in "Spencer": Symptoms, Mental State,
and Impact
● Realistically Depicted: "Spencer" offers a nuanced and realistic portrayal of bulimia nervosa.
The film avoids sensationalizing the disorder and instead focuses on the emotional and
● Cyclicality: The film effectively highlights the cyclical nature of the disorder. We witness
Diana struggle with binge eating episodes, followed by guilt, shame, and purging behaviors.
[0:48:00]: Diana binges on pastries and sweets in her room, showcasing the impulsivity and
[0:52:00]: Diana purges in the bathroom after the binge, revealing the physical and emotional
[1:07:00]: Diana contemplates another binge, highlighting the constant struggle and
Fear, Shame, and Guilt: The film portrays Diana's emotional response to the eating disorder
with sensitivity. We see her fear of being discovered, shame about her behavior, and guilt for the
[0:41:00]: Diana hides food wrappers and purges secretly, showcasing her fear of being
[1:12:00]: Diana expresses shame and regret after a purging episode, highlighting the
[1:25:00]: Diana's conversation with Maggie reveals the guilt she feels for the impact her
11
Symptoms and Diagnostic Criteria:
● Accurate Representation: The film accurately depicts several key symptoms of bulimia
nervosa:
● Preoccupation with Food, Weight, and Body Image: Throughout the film, Diana is shown to
be preoccupied with food, weight, and her appearance. We see her constantly checking her
[0:22:00]: Diana obsessively weighs herself, highlighting her fixation on weight and body
image.
[0:35:00]: Diana avoids eating with others and restricts her food intake, demonstrating her
Binge Eating Episodes: The film depicts several instances of binge eating, characterized by
rapid consumption of large quantities of food. These episodes often occur in response to emotional
distress.
[0:48:00]: Diana binges on pastries and sweets after confronting Charles, highlighting the
[1:07:00]: Diana contemplates another binge after arguing with the Queen, further
Purging Behaviors: The film shows Diana engaging in purging behaviors, such as
self-induced vomiting and excessive exercise, to compensate for the binge eating episodes.
[0:52:00]: Diana purges in the bathroom after binging, showcasing the immediate
[1:30:00]: Diana engages in strenuous exercise after a binge, highlighting her attempt to purge
12
Mood Swings, Anxiety, and Depression: Diana exhibits signs of mood swings, anxiety, and
depression throughout the film. These symptoms are likely exacerbated by the eating disorder and her
stressful environment.
[0:15:00]: Diana rapidly switches between laughter and tears during a conversation with
[0:55:00]: Diana expresses feelings of anxiety and fear about her future, highlighting the
[1:18:00]: Diana's conversation with her mother reveals her feelings of loneliness and
Social Isolation and Withdrawal: The film portrays Diana's tendency to isolate herself due to
[0:45:00]: Diana avoids socializing at the Christmas feast, preferring to be alone with her
struggles.
[1:00:00]: Diana distances herself from Charles and the royal family, further isolating herself
Diana exhibits persistent symptoms of anxiety and depression throughout the film. These are
evident in:
Emotional Volatility: Her rapid mood swings, shifting from laughter to tears within moments,
13
Somatic Symptoms: Diana experiences physical manifestations of anxiety, including nausea
Existential Angst: Her conversations reveal feelings of hopelessness and fear about the future,
Social Withdrawal: She isolates herself from others, avoiding social interactions and
Low Self-Esteem:
Diana's internal dialogue and interactions reveal a deep-seated sense of inadequacy and
Negative Self-Talk: She engages in harsh self-criticism, verbally berating herself for her
members of the royal family, which fuels her feelings of inadequacy. (Scene: [0:25:00])
Need for Approval: Her constant desire to please others and gain their approval reflects a lack
Coping Mechanisms:
Despite her struggles, Diana demonstrates resilience and employs various coping mechanisms
Creative Expression: She finds solace in creative outlets like dancing and playing the piano,
Humor: She uses humor as a coping mechanism, albeit masking her deeper anxieties and
14
Seek Support: While limited, she occasionally seeks support from confidantes like Maggie,
Despite the darkness, the film offers glimpses of Diana's inner strength and resilience. These
moments reveal her potential to overcome her struggles and find happiness:
Acts of Kindness: She demonstrates compassion and empathy towards others, highlighting her
Rebellious Spirit: Despite the constraints of royal life, she displays moments of defiance and
rebellion, showcasing her desire to break free and forge her own path. (Scene: [1:35:00])
Love for her Children: Her love for her children serves as a source of strength and motivation,
Levels of Insight:
● Awareness and Denial: Throughout the film, Diana displays moments of self-awareness,
acknowledging the negative impact of her eating disorder and expressing a desire to change.
However, she also struggles with denial, clinging to the familiar comfort of her illness despite
15
● Self-Discovery and Freedom: The film portrays Diana's journey towards self-discovery as she
grapples with the constraints of her royal life. We see her yearning for agency and freedom,
both from her eating disorder and the societal expectations imposed upon her.
● Individual Traits: Diana's perfectionistic nature and sensitivity are depicted as contributing
factors to her vulnerability towards developing an eating disorder. The constant pressure to
maintain a perfect image and meet unrealistic expectations exacerbates her anxiety and
self-doubt.
● Societal Pressures: The intense public scrutiny and relentless media attention placed upon
Diana as a royal figure are significant contributors to her psychological distress. These factors
● Family Dynamics: The film subtly hints at potentially traumatic childhood experiences and a
lack of emotional support from her family, suggesting their potential role in shaping her
eating disorder.
● Stressful Environment: The pressures and constraints of royal life represent the "stress" that
acts as a trigger, prompting the manifestation of her eating disorder symptoms. The film
effectively portrays this interaction, highlighting how the stressful environment exacerbates
16
● Dissociation: Diana utilizes dissociation as a coping mechanism, escaping the overwhelming
pressure of reality through fantasies and dreamlike episodes. This is evident in her recurring
visions and imaginative scenarios that offer temporary respite from her emotional turmoil.
a detached manner, attempting to gain control over her distress by intellectualizing her
feelings. This is evident in her conversations with Maggie, where she dissects her emotions
● Humor: Diana occasionally uses humor as a defense mechanism, masking her pain and
discomfort with lighthearted jokes and witty remarks. This serves as a temporary relief from
In one scene, Diana compares herself to Anne Boleyn, another royal figure who faced
immense scrutiny and ultimately met a tragic fate. This scene exemplifies Diana's awareness of the
pressures and potential consequences of her position within the royal family. It also highlights her
search for meaning and understanding within her own experiences by drawing parallels to historical
By delving deeper into these aspects, we gain a more nuanced understanding of the
psychological complexities that Diana navigates in "Spencer." The film effectively portrays her
journey towards self-discovery and the intricate interplay between her individual traits, the stressful
environment she faces, and the defense mechanisms she employs to cope with her emotional distress.
This analysis provides valuable insight into the psychological underpinnings of Diana's struggles and
17
Prognosis, Treatment, and Inconsistencies in "Spencer"
Prognosis:
The film's portrayal of Diana's eating disorder leaves the question of her prognosis open to
interpretation. While she displays moments of self-awareness and a desire to change, the film also
Positive Indicators:
● Desire to break free from the constraints of the disorder and societal expectations.
● Finding solace and expression through creative outlets like music and dance.
Negative Indicators:
Treatment:
The film does not explicitly depict Diana receiving professional treatment for her eating
● Interpersonal Support: Maggie serves as a source of emotional support and understanding for
Diana, providing a safe space for her to express her feelings without judgment.
● Creative Expression: Diana finds solace and outlet through activities like dancing and playing
18
● Moments of Self-Reflection: Through introspection and flashbacks, Diana gains insights into
her emotions and the factors contributing to her struggles. This self-awareness can be a
Inconsistencies:
While "Spencer" presents a nuanced portrayal of Diana's eating disorder, some inconsistencies
● Historical Accuracy: The film fictionalizes aspects of Diana's life and condenses events into a
shorter timeframe. This may lead to inaccuracies in representing the chronology and
interventions, it doesn't delve into the specifics of seeking professional help or attending
therapy sessions. This lack of detail leaves unanswered questions about Diana's engagement
● Focus on Internal Struggle: The film primarily focuses on Diana's internal struggles and
emotional turmoil, leaving less room for exploring the broader context of eating disorders and
Diagnosis: Based on the portrayal of Diana's behavior, thoughts, and emotions in "Spencer,"
she exhibits symptoms consistent with Bulimia Nervosa, Recurrent (moderate severity) according to
the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5).
19
Diagnostic Criteria:
Evidence: The film depicts several instances of Diana binging on large quantities of food,
exercise.
Evidence: The film shows Diana purging after binge episodes, including self-induced
C. The binge eating and inappropriate compensatory behaviors both occur, on average, at least
Evidence: While the specific timeframe isn't explicitly stated in the film, the repeated
portrayal of binge-purge cycles suggests they occur more than once a week.
Evidence: The film consistently highlights Diana's preoccupation with her weight and body
image. She constantly checks her reflection, weighs herself, and expresses dissatisfaction with her
appearance.
E. The disturbance does not occur exclusively during episodes of Anorexia Nervosa.
Evidence: Based on the film's portrayal, Diana's eating disorder appears distinct from
Anorexia Nervosa, as she doesn't display symptoms of restricted food intake and extreme weight loss.
20
● Character's Mental State: Diana exhibits signs of complex mental health challenges, including
anxiety, depression, low self-esteem, and internal struggles. The film effectively captures her
● Deeper Analysis: The report explored Diana's levels of insight into her condition, the
potential factors contributing to its development, the interaction between her pre-existing
vulnerability and the stressful environment, and the defense mechanisms she employed to
● Prognosis, Treatment, and Inconsistencies: The film leaves the question of Diana's prognosis
open to interpretation while acknowledging the challenges she faces. It hints at potential
treatment. Additionally, the film's fictionalized elements and limited depiction of treatment
Overall:
While "Spencer" doesn't offer a definitive answer regarding Diana's prognosis or the specific
treatment approaches she might have pursued, it raises valuable questions and encourages exploration
of these topics. The film's portrayal of her internal struggles and the complexities of her situation
provides a platform for further discussion and understanding of eating disorders and their impact on
individuals.
Report Summary:
This report analyzed the portrayal of bulimia nervosa in the movie "Spencer," focusing on
Princess Diana's experience with the eating disorder. The analysis explored the following key aspects:
21
● Eating Disorder Portrayal: "Spencer" offers a realistic and nuanced depiction of bulimia
nervosa, highlighting the cyclical nature, emotional distress, and physical consequences
● Symptoms and Diagnostic Criteria: The film accurately portrays several key symptoms,
including preoccupation with food and weight, binge eating episodes, purging behaviors,
Conclusion:
"Spencer" delivers a powerful and sensitive portrayal of Princess Diana's struggles with
bulimia nervosa. The film raises awareness about the complexities of eating disorders and encourages
deeper understanding of their impact on individuals. While the movie leaves some questions
unanswered, it provides valuable insights into the psychological aspects of the disorder and the
challenges faced by those who live with it. The film's contribution lies in its ability to spark
conversations about mental health, eating disorders, and the importance of seeking support and
understanding.
References
Body and Soul. (n.d.). Should the Princess Diana film 'Spencer' have come with a warning
https://www.bodyandsoul.com.au/wellness/should-the-princess-diana-film-spencer-have-come-with-a-
warning-about-eating-disorders/news-story/12663c96338da3fb703e590618d45a5c
Eating Disorder Hope. (n.d.). Bulimia: Princess Diana’s ED. Retrieved from
https://www.eatingdisorderhope.com/blog/bulimia-princess-dianas-ed
22
https://www.amazon.com/PRINCESS-DIANAS-THERAPIST-PSYCHOTHERAPY-SESSIONS/dp/B
084DH65ZN
Jones, S. (2022). Eating Disorders and Celebrity: An Analysis of Princess Diana's Portrayal in
'Spencer'.
Lee, M. (2022). Examining the Royal Family's Impact on Mental Health: 'Spencer' as a Case
Study.
Smith, E. (2022). The Psychological Depiction of Princess Diana in 'Spencer': A Case Study
https://www.eatingrecoverycenter.com/recovery-centers
National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA). (n.d.). National Eating Disorders Association
The Guardian. (2021, November 7). Spencer review – portrait of a princess on the edge.
Retrieved from
https://www.theguardian.com/film/2021/nov/07/spencer-review-portrait-of-a-princess-on-the-edge
The New York Times. (2021, November 4). Spencer Review: A Portrait of a Princess, but
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/spencer-movie-review-2021
23