Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Printer Final
Printer Final
Dinajpur, Bangladesh
A thesis report on
Optimal Sizing and Techno-Economic Analysis of Stand-alone
Hybrid Energy System for Kutubdia Island Bangladesh
Supervised by Submitted by
Md. Imran Hossain
Md. Mizanur Rahman Student ID: 1702208
Assistant Professor K.M. Iftekharul Alam
Department of Electrical and Electronic Student ID: 1702215
Engineering Rajib Shuvrah Datta
Hajee Mohammad Danesh Science and Student ID: 1702252
Technology University
NOVEMBER, 2022
Hajee Mohammad Danesh Science and Technology University
Dinajpur, Bangladesh
A thesis report on
Optimal Sizing and Techno-Economic Analysis of Stand-alone
Hybrid Energy System for Kutubdia Island Bangladesh
This report is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
Bachelor of Engineering in Electrical and Electronic Engineering at Hajee Mohammad
Danesh Science and Technology University, Dinajpur, Bangladesh.
Supervised by Submitted by
Md. Imran Hossain
Md. Mizanur Rahman
Student ID: 1702208
Assistant Professor
K.M. Iftekharul Alam
Department of Electrical and Electronic
Student ID: 1702215
Engineering
Rajib Shuvrah Datta
Hajee Mohammad Danesh Science and
Student ID: 1702252
Technology University.
Hajee Mohammad Danesh Science and Technology University
Dinajpur, Bangladesh
This is to certify that the thesis entitled “Optimal Sizing and Techno-Economic Analysis
of Stand-alone Hybrid Energy System for Kutubdia Island Bangladesh” has been
carried out by Md. Imran Hossain, ID: 1702208, K.M. Iftekharul Alam, ID: 1702215 and
Rajib Shuvrah Datta, ID: 1702252 and complies with the regulations of this university and
meets the accepted standards with respect to originality and quality.
……………………………………………………………………
Chairman
……………………………………………………………………
External
……………………………………………………………………
Internal
……………………………………………………………………
Supervisor
…………………………………………………………………
Co-Supervisor
i
Hajee Mohammad Danesh Science and Technology University
Dinajpur, Bangladesh
Certificate
This is to certify that the thesis work entitled “Optimal Sizing and Techno-Economic
Analysis of Stand-alone Hybrid Energy System for KUTUBDIA Island, Bangladesh”
carried out by the Student ID: 1702208, Student ID: 1702215, Student ID: 1702252,
under our supervisor as a requirement for the award of Bachelor of Science in Electrical
and Electronic Engineering.
………………………………………….. …………………………………………..
Rony Tota Md. Mizanur Rahman
Assistant Professor Assistant Professor
Department of Electrical and Department of Electrical and
Electronic Engineering Electronic Engineering
HSTU, Dinajpur-5200. HSTU, Dinajpur-5200.
i
DEDICATED TO
OUR BELOVED PARENTS AND RESPECTABLE
TEACHERS
ii
Acknowledgements
Firstly, we are grateful to the God for the good health and wellbeing that were necessary
to complete this thesis. Then we are honored to express our deepest and sincerest gratitude
to our parents who supported us all the time and helped us all the way they could to
continue our work.
Foremost I would like to express my sincere gratitude to our respected Supervisor Md.
Mizanur Rahman, Assistant Professor, Department of Electrical and Electronic
Engineering and Co-Supervisor, Rony Tota, Assistant Professor, Department of Electrical
and Electronic Engineering, for their continuous support during our thesis work. Their
patience, motivation, enthusiasm and immense knowledge have helped us to make our
work successful and so we are extremely grateful to them. Anytime when we had
difficulties in our research, they were always there to help with their intelligence,
diligence and patience.
Finally, we also thank our group members and friends for their dedication and hard work
to complete the thesis.
iii
ABSTRACT
This research examines the technological and financial viability of developing hybrid
energy systems for use in remote areas without grid access, such as Kutubdia Island in
Bangladesh. This study examines the feasibility of electrifying Kutubdia Island using
several hybrid setups. To meet the peak load demand, the program HOMER Pro calculates
the ideal size of the available resources and analyzes the technological and economic
factors involved in meeting that demand. By optimizing the performance of many energy
sources, HOMER can evaluate and compare a wide range of hybrid energy system
designs. With the use of the Levelized cost of energy (LCOE) and the net present cost
(NPC), the optimal system size may be created (LCOE). The results of this study point to
solar photovoltaic (PV) as the primary energy source, battery as the storage medium, and
diesel generator as the backup energy source because of the declining availability and
increasing expense of wind energy. When comparing LCOE, PV/Wind/Battery/DG (0.146
USD/kWh) is much less expensive than Wind/Battery/DG (0.152 USD/kWh),
PV/Battery/DG (0.293 USD/kWh), PV/Wind/Battery (0.197 USD/kWh), and DG-Based
(0.380 USD/kWh).
iv
Contents
Certificate i
Acknowledgements iii
Abstract iv
Contents v
List of Figures vii
List of Tables viii
List of Abbreviation ix
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 An overview of Bangladesh Power Generation 2
Industry
1.3 Objectives 3
2 Literature Review 5
2.1 Literature Review 5
2.2 Prior Research on the Techno-Economic 7
Discussion on Different Hybrid Systems of
Energy
3 Methodology 9
3.1 Our Proposed System Description 9
3.2 Homer 10
3.3 Site of Location 11
3.4 Load of case study 12
3.5 Daily Load Profile 13
3.6 Hardware Components for Power Generation and 13
Storage
3.6.1 PV modeling 13
3.6.2 Wind Turbine Modeling 15
3.6.3 Modeling of Diesel Generator 17
3.6.4 Battery Modeling 20
v
3.6.5 Bi-Directional Converter 20
4 Design analysis of proposed system 22
4.1 Case I: (Only DG Based) 22
4.2 Case II: (PV/Wind/Battery) 22
4.3 Case III: (PV/DG/Battery) 23
4.4 Case IV: (WIND/DG/Battery) 23
4.5 Case V: (PV/WIND/DG/Battery) 24
5 Result and Analysis 25
5.1 Simulation Result of Individual Combination 25
Types of Equipment
5.1.1 Result of Case I: (Only DG-Based) 26
5.1.2 Result of Case II: (PV/Wind/Battery) 27
5.1.3 Result of Case III: (PV/DG/Battery) 28
5.1.4 Result of Case IV: (Wind/DG/Battery) 29
5.1.5 Result of Case V: (PV/Wind/DG/Battery) 30
5.2 Emission Analysis 31
5.3 Sensitivity Analysis 32
5.3.1 The effects of rising Diesel Price 32
5.3.2 The effects of Wind Speed 33
5.3.3 The effects of Solar Radiation 33
5.4 Proposed Optimized system vs Present Energy 34
System
6 Conclusion 35
6.1 Conclusion 35
6.2 Future Recommendation 35
References 36
vi
List of Figures
Chapter Figure Name Page
1.1 Rate of installed capacity of electricity produced from different 3
sources of energy
3.1 Proposed power system model 9
3.2 Interface of Homer Software 11
3.3 Proposed Site Location 11
3.4 Daily Load Profile 13
3.5 Solar radiation data in a year 13
3.6 Selected PV Panel 14
3.7 Research methodology of the proposed hybrid renewable energy 15
system
3.8 Wind Turbine Design 16
3.9 Monthly Average Wind Speed Data 17
3.10 Diesel Generator Design 18
3.11 Fuel Curve of selected Diesel Generator 19
3.12 Efficiency curve of selected Diesel Generator 20
3.13 Design Battery 19
3.14 Bi-Directional Converter Design 21
4.1 Diesel Generator with connected load 22
4.2 PV/Wind/Battery with connected load 22
4.3 PV/DG/Battery with connected load 23
4.4 WIND/DG/Battery with connected load 23
4.5 PV/WIND/DG/Battery with connected load 24
5.1 DG-based electricity production throughout the year 26
5.2 PV/Wind/Battery-based electricity production throughout the year 27
5.3 PV/Battery/DG-based electricity production throughout the year 28
5.4 Wind/Battery/DG-based electricity production throughout the year 29
5.5 PV/Wind/Battery/DG-based electricity production throughout the 30
year
5.6 Variation of Diesel Price 33
vii
List of Table
Chapter Table Name Page
1.1 Maximum electricity production chart 4
viii
List of Abbreviation
BD Discharge of battery
DF Factor of derating (%)
EE energy (kW/y)
F1 Coefficient of intercept
F2 Fuel curve slope
G Solar irradiations (kW/m2
GEC Charges of energy (kWh)
GS Standard solar irradiation (kW/m2)
MinNPC Minimum value of NPC
NBiomass, G Number of biomass generators
NBattery Number of batteries
NDiesel, G Number of diesel generators
Ninverter Number of inverters
NPV Number of photovoltaic cells
NPC Net present cost (USD)
PD Outcome of the diesel operated generator at that
time
Prated Rated capacity of PV module (W)
HOMER Hybrid optimization model for electric
renewables
LCOE Levelized cost of energy (USD/kWh)
LHV Lower heating value (MJ/kg)
MinLCOE Minimum value of LCOE
RD Rated diesel generator capacity
TC Temperature of the PV cell (◦C)
TS Standard PV cell temperature (◦C)
αP Coefficient of the solar power
ηPV Efficiency of the PV cell (%)
ix
CHAPTER-01
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
Population and economic growth have been driving up energy needs in Bangladesh over
the last decade. Hilly regions, like the rest of the country, rely heavily on power, which is
why grid expansion is so important [1, 2]. Economic growth, and particularly growth in
developing nations, is often credited to increased energy production and access. It may
also be utilized to increase national output [3]. Therefore, electricity is vital for enabling
long-term growth. Roughly 1.06 billion people, or roughly 14 percent of the global
population, do not have access to electricity. About 41 million people in Bangladesh have
no access to electrical power [4].
Figure 1 shows Bangladesh's electrification rate (in percentage) and suggests that more
and more individuals in the country are gaining access to electricity; however, this growth
is still behind the pace of population rise. The increased worldwide demand for power is
met mostly through the usage of traditional energy sources like natural gas, oil, and coal.
As a result of limited reserves and high use, however, they are decreasing sources.
Additionally, pollution from all these energy sources degrades the natural ecosystem.
Because of this, cutting CO2 emissions by 50–80% by 2050 is an absolute need [5].
Lessening our use of fossil fuels and increasing our use of renewable energy sources are
two ways to cut down on emissions [6-8]. Since traditional power generation accounts for
a large portion of both electricity consumption and pollution, it is crucial to identify
renewable energy sources. Renewable and optimum energy sources might be promoted to
meet the increasing load demand in Bangladesh and elsewhere [9,10].
The same is true with energy, which is in high demand worldwide to keep the global
economy and progress going [12,13]. Because of the electrical shortage, businesses all
around the world are struggling. Because of this, developing nations often experience grid
outages lasting longer than 8 hours [3]. Furthermore, emerging nations have issues with
power consumption for millions of people without electricity, as well as difficulty
preserving a clean environment with economically viable sources of energy [14,15]. The
1
GDP of both wealthy and developing nations suffers when there is an extended period of
electrical outage [16].
Although Bangladesh's per capita electricity consumption is still lower (560 kWh) as
compared to the per capita consumption of the globe (3127 kWh) [1], the power industry
has been greatly improved, covering energy demand via a 90% grid supply. The use of
renewable energy sources and the development of related technologies remain,
nevertheless, uncommon in Bangladesh. Existing infrastructure cannot keep up with the
rising nationwide demand for power. Due to their reliance on external variables and the
unpredictability of their availability, renewable energy sources that operate independently
from the grid cannot guarantee a constant supply of power [17, 18]. Accordingly, hybrid
energy systems are being looked at as potential alternatives to this situation. Batteries or
internal combustion engines powered by gasoline may be used in conjunction with solar
photovoltaics (PV) to create a workable and affordable system, according to the literature
[19, 20]. Though hybrid PV/wind/diesel/battery configurations have been used in other
countries, they are uncommon in studies of Bangladesh's off-grid settlements. Through a
system design approach that considers existing energy resources, this study lays forth a
plan for bringing electricity to rural areas of Bangladesh. Specifically, this work
demonstrates the rarity of past studies emphasizing hybrid energy systems that use
biomass. This research also discusses the appropriate size of hybrid energy systems to
provide uninterrupted power to the region under consideration, such as the island of
Kutubdia in Bangladesh. This research looks at the best possible practicality of five
different off-grid systems for the proposed location.
1.2 Objectives
The major goal of this paper is to optimize the sizing of a hybrid renewable energy system
to supply continuous energy to the considered area of Kutubdia Island in Bangladesh
through technical and economic analysis. The following actions were taken to accomplish
this goal
• The power system is played through in all possible configurations, taking into
account renewable energy sources and determining the best possible optimal
system.
2
• The proposed optimal system is compared with the current energy situation in
selected area. For the optimal system, sensitivity analysis and payback are also
considered in sensitivity analysis, the effectiveness of wind speed and diesel price
variation is discussed.
Figure 1.1: Rate of installed capacity of electricity produced from different sources of
energy [21]
The available energy sources are the only determinant in a country's strategy for the
generation of electricity. Multiple power stations in Bangladesh use a variety of energy
sources, including coal, gas, and nuclear power, to produce electricity. There will be
24,000 MW of electricity production by 2021's end, 40,000 MW by 2030's, and 60,000
MW by 2041's end [21]. Electricity consumption, on the other hand, is expected to rise
3
from 2020's predicted 14,000 MW to 2021's 19,000 MW, 2030's 33,000 MW, and 2041's
52,000 MW. It is anticipated that annual electricity output would rise from 510 kWh in
2020 to 700 kWh in 2021, 815 kWh in 2030, and 1475 kWh in 2041 [21].
4
Chapter 2
Literature Review
5
The annual cost of a hybrid micro grid for an island that uses solar panels, wind turbines,
tidal current, batteries, and diesel is estimated in [21], using an improved multi-objective
grey wolf optimization technique, in order to keep the system's annual cost as low as
possible and avoid the risk of a power distribution deficit. This research cannot fully
represent the right COE since it only considers the startup and running expenses of the
installed equipment. In [22], a Genetic Algorithm (GA) is used to optimize a hybrid
system composed of solar, wind, batteries, and diesel in order to supply the power
demands of a tiny hamlet in northern Nigeria at the lowest cost and even with the least
environmental effect. Reducing the NPC, COE, unmet load, and CO2 emissions of an off-
grid HRES using a GA and the HOMER Pro software is shown in [23]. In [24], a Firefly
algorithm is used to calculate the optimal size of a solar-wind-battery storage hybrid
energy system for delivering cheap, reliable power to remote Indian villages. This
approach uses just one day of summer and winter data, which is inadequate for simulating
the whole year.
In [25], the off-grid HRES that powers the Kutupalong camp in Ukhia, Cox's Bazar,
Bangladesh is designed with the use of the HOMER Pro software in order to reduce the
system's NPC, COE, and CO2 emissions. Their proposed system does not seem to include
any kind of sensitivity analysis. The proposed method would aid in improving energy
efficiency and encouraging the growth of renewable energy sources in Ukraine, as stated
in [26]. There is no visual indication of which permutation is the most efficient or eco-
friendly in this setup. Hybrid photovoltaic (PV), diesel, small hydro, and battery systems
were designed for use in off-grid areas of southern Cameroon (ref. [27]). The findings
demonstrate that the proposed method improves upon the status quo with respect to NPC
while simultaneously decreasing energy expenditures and carbon dioxide emissions. Their
proposed system shows no indication of sensitivity analysis. To ensure the government's
strategy is successful, the existing condition, future prospects, and up-to-date statistics on
renewable and sustainable energy sources in Bangladesh are presented in Ref. [28].
In [29], it was investigated whether the energy needs of autonomous desalination systems
(ADS) generating up to 50 m3 of water per day in a location with moderately high wind
and solar radiation profiles could be met by hybrid renewable energy systems (PV-wind-
generator). When compared with more traditional fossil fuels, these renewable energy
6
sources are prohibitively expensive. Construction strategies for renewable energy-based
hybrid power plants in the megawatt range are discussed in [30], with the emphasis being
placed on identifying the most cost-effective and technologically possible options.
Although a grid-connected system is proposed, a return-on-investment estimate is not
provided. Reducing building energy consumption and satisfying load demand at the lowest
possible cost are the goals of the demand-supply management (DSM) approach and
particle swarm optimization (PSO)-based technique combined in ref. [31]. In contrast,
with DSM, the share of renewable energy jumps from 15% to 63%. Despite the high cost
and huge distances necessary to deliver fuel, making it less economical and sustainable in
rural locations, Ref. [32] focused on HRESs that carry diesel as a backup. Objective of
[33] is to design and envision an ideal micro solar-diesel hybrid power producing plant for
use in a rural area of Bangladesh to consistently meet the country's electrical energy
demands. There is no mention of sensitivity analysis in the proposed framework. In the
proposed framework, sensitivity analysis is not addressed. PV, micro hydro, wind turbine,
and biomass generators compare the price of HRES to that of a stand-alone diesel
generator in [34]. The suggested system does not discuss sensitivity analysis. As stated in
ref. [35], HRES is now feasible because of the dramatic drop in the cost of wind turbines
and solar panels in recent years. The ideal system is determined by three primary factors:
the intensity of renewable resources; the ratio of thermal to electrical demand; and the cost
of diesel fuel. Environmental effect or sensitivity analyses are not mentioned in this
system. The unreliability of renewable energy sources makes the HRES scaling process
more challenging. As a result, it's important to strike a balance between cost and
reliability. This has led to the development of a number of models (algorithms) and
software tools for optimizing HRES designs, with more on the way [36-38]. Analytical
hierarchy method (AHP) [39] was used to rank the importance of criteria to be used to
create the best hybrid power systems.
In this work, several different scientific articles have been reviewed to analyses the
feasibility of the economic aspects of standalone off-grid systems for hybrid energy. In
different configurations of hybrid energy, PV, wind, hydro, and biomass are commonly
used sources of energy based on their availability in the specified regions. In the majority
7
of hybrid energy systems, diesel generators and batteries are used as backup sources of
energy and energy storage systems, respectively. Moreover, the converter is used for the
the conversion from DC to AC or vice versa.
battery
8
Chapter 3
Methodology
3.1 Our Proposed System Description
This research identifies the most effective hybrid energy system layout for meeting the
load requirements of a certain off-grid community. Figure 1 depicts the suggested model
for the electrical grid. The HOMER Pro program was used to run a simulation, and the
costs were determined by balancing the many aspects of the hybrid energy system against
the constraints of the system at the time, as well as the weather and energy demands of the
building under study. The NPC and COE were determined with the aid of this program.
This cost estimate formed the basis for the comparative study of the best system. Utilizing
the optimization and sensitivity analysis features of the HOMER Pro software, the
practicality and feasibility of various hybrid energy system designs, especially those used
in off-grid settings, may be evaluated.
9
3.2 HOMER
The workflow of the HOMER is shown in Figure 2. Hybrid renewable energy architecture
includes three main stages: before HOMER analysis, during HOMER optimization, and
after HOMER analysis.
The pre-HOMER assessment checks the design configuration and framework early on to
make sure it can support the infrastructure over the long run. It is difficult to develop and
execute a successful hybrid system to manage the required load requirements without
comprehensive documentation of the specified family, community, and energy needs. So,
the first step is to evaluate the demographics, energy sources, and load requirements of the
off-grid area of interest. With the help of this method, you'll be able to zero in on the
specific load requirement at your site and identify the energy sources that can meet it.
The pre-HOMER section assesses the total cost of ownership (TCO) of a hardware
system, including the purchase price, ongoing operating expenses, and eventual cost of
replacement.
After HOMER analysis is complete, a sensitivity assessment of the planned off-grid area
is required to validate the results. Many factors, including photovoltaics, batteries, fuel,
and temperatures, were subjected to a sensitivity analysis. These details might help you get
a good feel for what goes into choosing an off-grid community's energy infrastructure.
The simulation's result is duplicated and fine-tuned using the relevant sensitivity factors.
The effect on the natural world is also considered in this section. Investors will know how
long they may expect to reap the benefits of their effort.
10
Figure 3.2: Interface of Homer Software
11
3.4 Assumed Load
This study considered a city with 100 residents, 18 retail establishments, 10 food Service
establishments, and 3 lodging establishments. Table 3.1 displays the anticipated seasonal
load requirements during the summer and winter. The daily peak demand was predicted to
be 70.98 kW, while the primary load was expected tobe752 kWh/day.
Table 3.1: Estimated electricity demand for Kutubdia Island
Type Description No. Power Summer Winter
of in (W)
Load Use Hour Watt- Hours/ Watt-Hours/Day
s/ Hours/Da Day
Day y
CFL 2 15 6 180 8 240
Fan 1 80 14 1120 0 0
House TV 1 120 8 960 7 840
Fridge 1 240 24 6000 24 6000
Total (For 455 8260 7080
one house) 100 46,500 826000 708,000
Total
(Houses)
12
3.5 Daily Load Profile:
13
As shown in Figure 3.5, solar radiation is at its peak during the months of February
through May. An annual clearness index of 0.5312 is achieved, with daily radiation
averaging 4.81 kWh/m2/day.
PV power production is very susceptible to climate change. The PV panel's module comes
from Generic, which also makes the panel itself. There has a 1 kW rating (kW). It was
calculated by raising the temperature coefficient by 0.1% for every degree Celsius.
Increasing the efficiency of the PV panel might increase its annual output. The hourly base
output of the photovoltaic system may be calculated using equation (3.1) [25].
…………… (3.1)
Where YPV denotes the rated capacity of PV array, fPV is known as derating factor (80%),
IT is incident solar irradiation in kW/m2, IS is standard solar irradiation in kW/m2, αP is
coefficient of the solar power, TC is the temperature of the PV cell in °C, and TS is the
standard PV cell temperature. The temperature of the PV cell can be obtained using
Equation (3.2) [25].
…………………. (3.2)
14
Where Ta is defined as temperature (°C), ηPV is the efficiency of the PV cell, and NOCT is
nominal operating cell temperature.
Pre-
Homer
Analysis
Figure 3.7: Research methodology of the proposed hybrid renewable energy system
The wind data shown in Figure 5 was given by the NREL and was used in this study. The
module for the wind turbine was manufactured by Eocycle and is now under review
(Model: EO10). The turbine's hub height is 25 meters, and it has a design life of 20 years.
There was no way to harness the influence of nature. Turbines capture the wind's kinetic
energy and convert it to electricity. There are a number of factors to consider when
choosing a wind turbine, including hub height, cut-in wind speed, expected service life,
and total cost. Since available power is a function of wind speed at the generator's hub
height, the output of various types of wind generators varies widely. For a particular hub
height, the required
15
wind speed for energy production may be calculated using the power law equation. The
price is determined on the kind of land [25]. The turbine has a 25 m tall
……………… (3.3)
16
3.6.3 Modeling of Diesel Generator
Diesel (price) is needed for any power system proposal or modeling. The Bangladesh
Petroleum Corporation (BPC) reports that the unofficial diesel price in Bangladesh is now
USD 1 per liter (L) [40].
There has been a great deal of price fluctuation throughout the years with this. Since
diesel fuel price is closely linked to NPC and COE for the generation of electricity per
unit, the timing of any diesel-based micro grid project might be accelerated, postponed, or
even cancelled [1]. It is possible to figure out how much diesel fuel you use using this
equation: (3.5).
17
The fuel curve of selected Diesel Generator:
18
The efficiency curve of selected Diesel Generator:
19
3.6.4 Battery Modeling
The storage component of a hybrid energy system is major equipment that is utilized
to maintain a consistent voltage during periods of lower power generation. In most cases,
a Li-ion battery is used for power storage [1].
………………………. (3.7)
20
Figure 3.14: Bi-Directional Converter Design
Table 3.3 lists the many inputs considered while modelling a PV, Wind Turbine, DG,
Battery, and Bi-directional Converter.
21
Chapter 4
Design Analysis of Proposed System
22
4.3 Case III :( PV/DG/Battery)
In this case PV panel, Diesel Generator, and for storage Battery has been used. The
schematic diagram of this case is shown below.
23
4.5 Case V: (PV/WIND/DG/Battery)
In this case PV panel, Wind Turbine, Diesel Generator, and for storage Battery has been
used. The schematic diagram of this case is shown below.
24
Chapter 5
Results and Analysis
HOMER Pro is used to model various hybrid energy systems. For techno-economic
analyses and feasibility studies, NPC and COE are utilized in this study to determine
several optimal configurations.
WT Capacity (kW) - 8 - 5 5
DG Capacity (kW) 80 - 80 80 80
25
5.1.1. Result of Case I: (Only DG-Based)
This is the base case. In this case, NPC and COE are higher than in other cases that are
considered in this system. In Table 5.2 shows that, the annual operating cost is USD
1,02,743and the NPC is USD 1,078,186 for the only DG-based system. The COE is USD
0.38/kilowatt-h (kWh). Table 5.2 shows the details of the augmented electrical result.
Figure 4.1 shows the production of electricity throughout the year in this system.
Capacity Shortage 0 0
26
5.1.2. Result of Case II: PV/Wind/Battery
This is the worst case. The NPC and COE are the highest of all the combinations. From
Table 5.3 we see that NPC of this combination is USD 1,374,082 operating cost is USD
30,391 and the COE is USD 0.206/kWh, which is lower than case 1. The simple payback
of this system is 12 years. Table 5.3 shows the details of the augmented electrical result.
According to this table, the wind turbine generates 61.2% of the electricity for this
specific system. In this system, the excess electricity, unmet electric load, and capacity
shortage are 394,837 68.2, and 255 kWh/y, respectively. Figure 5.2 shows the production
of electricity throughout the year in this system. In the months of May to September, wind
speeds are higher than in any other month of the year.
27
Figure 5.2: PV/Wind/Battery-based electricity production throughout the year
28
5.1.4 Result of Case IV: Wind/Battery/DG
According to Table 4.5, the NPC, yearly operating cost and initial capital for this specific
system are USD 1,00,6857, USD 39,257 and USD 98,750 respectively. The COE is USD
0.156/kWh, which is less than in cases 1, 2 and 3. The simple payback of this hybrid
system is 3.3 years. Although simple payback is lower than other cases, it’s not the best
case. Because in HOMER optimization, results depend on the NPC and COE. Most of the
electricity, 2,60,361 kWh/y, is produced by wind turbines, which is 72.5% of total
electricity, according to Table 4.5. The production of excess electricity is 22 % of total
production. There is no unmet electric load and capacity shortage. In Figure 4.4, we
observe wind turbines producing maximum electricity throughout the year. DG’s
participation is quite low.
Table 5.5: Augmented Electrical result for Wind/Battery/DG
Electrical Elements kWh/y %
Wind Turbine 260,361 72.5
Production
DG 98,879 27.5
Total 359,240 100
Consumption AC load 274,480 100
Total 274,480
Excess Electricity 79,133 22.0
Quantity Unmet Electric load 0 0
Capacity Shortage 0 0
Electricity Production of Case IV:
29
Figure 5.4: Wind/Battery/DG-based electricity production throughout the year
PV 52,157 13.2
DG 81,260 20.6
Total 274,480
Capacity Shortage 0 0
30
Figure 5.5: PV/Wind/Battery/DG-based electricity production throughout the year
31
CO2 218,666 0 141,283 76,276 62,145
32
The variation of diesel fuel price is shown as below:
33
5.3.3. The Effects of Solar Radiation
The hybrid alternative using PV, wind, battery, and direct-drive generators is graphically
illustrated in Figure 4.10 by changing the solar irradiation. It is obvious that the NPC and
COE are influenced by changes in solar radiation. For instance, the NPC and COE are
USD 1078186 and USD 0.144 at 4.81 kWh/m2/day solar radiation, but they rise to USD
1089369 and USD 0.146 at 4.50 kWh/m2/day solar radiation. However, the NPC and
COE are USD 1181988 and USD 0.200, respectively, when the solar radiation reaches
5.00 kWh/m2/day. NPC is lower, even if COE is the same as when solar radiation is 4.5
kWh/m2/day.
The study subsequently investigated the optimal hybrid system with the present energy
system and compared the various scenarios characterized by the HOMER software tool
based on COE and NPC. Policymakers might choose a hybrid-based energy system with
the aid of this comparative study. In comparison to the price of the current energy system,
the COE of the ideal configuration that selected chose is USD 0.144/kWh dollars per
kWh. Mostly, diesel generators are used to produce electricity in the considered area.
However, only diesel-based systems are the costliest, as mentioned in Table 5.1. Now a
days, they are also using solar home systems. The cost of SHSs is approximately USD
0.72/kWh [44]. Therefore, compared to solar and diesel-powered systems, the suggested
system’s COE is more affordable.
34
Chapter: 06
Conclusion
6.1 Conclusion
This research investigates the viability of a hybrid system for future energy generation on
Bangladesh's Kutubdia Island. Five scenarios are investigated, and a viable configuration
substantially reduced NPC and emissions is proposed. The case at hand is PV/Wind/
Battery/DG. This system is made up of such a 35 kW PV panel, a 50-kW wind turbine, an
80 kW DG, and 70 Li-ion batteries, according to HOMER. The NPC is USD 1,078,186
with a 70.4% renewable rate. The proportion of renewable energy is higher than the
PV/wind/battery system. In the suggested system, DG generates 20.4% of the power, while
wind turbines generate 66.1%, PV panel generate 13.2%, respectively. Carbon dioxide
emissions are 62,145 kg/y, which is fewer than in all other scenarios except
PV/Wind/Battery. The payback period is 3.9 years in the proposed system. In sensitivity
analysis, it shows how the NPC and COE vary depending on diesel price and wind speed.
This study discusses the design and selection of the optimal system configuration for
achieving high efficiency and techno-economic feasibility utilizing locally accessible
renewable energy resources. The research takes into account a tiny community, thus more
research is necessary to determine the size of HRES in light of widespread energy
consumption. The outcomes displayed in the research region might not apply to all of
Bangladesh. In future research, we should analyze the embodied carbon emissions of wind
turbines.
35
REFERENCES
[2] M. E. Hoque, F. Rashid, and M. Aziz, “Gasification and power generation characteristics
of rice husk, sawdust, and coconut shell using a fixed-bed downdraft gasifier,”
Sustainability (Switzerland), vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 1–19, Feb. 2021, doi: 10.3390/su13042027.
[4] K. Mohn, “The Gravity of Status Quo: A Review of IEA’s World Energy Outlook,” 2020,
doi: 10.5547/2160-5890.9.1.kmoh.
[5] R. , R. J. , S. J. et al. Knutti, “A scientific critique of the two-degree climate change target.
,” Nature Geosci, vol. 9, pp. 13–18, 2016.
[7] G. Yang and X. Q. Zhai, “Optimal design and performance analysis of solar hybrid CCHP
system considering influence of building type and climate condition,” Energy, vol. 174,
pp. 647–663, May 2019, doi: 10.1016/J.ENERGY.2019.03.001.
[9] M. F. Ishraque, S. A. Shezan, J. N. Nur, and M. S. Islam, “Optimal Sizing and Assessment
of an Islanded Photovoltaic-Battery-Diesel Generator Microgrid Applicable to a Remote
36
School of Bangladesh,” Engineering Reports, vol. 3, no. 1, Jan. 2021, doi:
10.1002/eng2.12281.
[10] B. K. Bala and S. A. Siddique, “Optimal design of a PV-diesel hybrid system for
electrification of an isolated island—Sandwip in Bangladesh using genetic algorithm,”
Energy for Sustainable Development, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 137–142, Sep. 2009, doi:
10.1016/J.ESD.2009.07.002.
[12] R. Burgess, M. Greenstone, N. Ryan, and A. Sudarshan, “Demand for Electricity on the
Global Electrification Frontier *,” 2020.
[13] M. E. Hoque and F. Rashid, “Analysis of Energy Consumption and Efficiency to Reduce
Power Losses in Industrial Equipment Solar Magnetic System View project Electricity
from Different sources View project,” 2017. [Online]. Available:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322131690
[15] D. Kearney, “EIA’s Outlook Through 2035 From the Annual Energy Outlook 2010,”
2010. [Online]. Available: http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/analysis.htm
[17] C. Li, D. Zhou, H. Wang, Y. Lu, and D. Li, “Techno-economic performance study of
stand-alone wind/diesel/battery hybrid system with different battery technologies in the
cold region of China,” Energy, vol. 192, p. 116702, Feb. 2020, doi:
10.1016/J.ENERGY.2019.116702.
37
[18] Z. Huang, Y. Lu, M. Wei, and J. Liu, “Performance analysis of optimal designed hybrid
energy systems for grid-connected nearly/net zero energy buildings,” Energy, vol. 141, pp.
1795–1809, Dec. 2017, doi: 10.1016/J.ENERGY.2017.11.093.
[25] D. N. Luta and A. K. Raji, “Optimal sizing of hybrid fuel cell-supercapacitor storage
system for off-grid renewable applications,” Energy, vol. 166, pp. 530–540, Jan. 2019,
doi: 10.1016/J.ENERGY.2018.10.070.
38
[27] W. Zhu, J. Guo, G. Zhao, and B. Zeng, “Optimal sizing of an island hybrid microgrid
based on improved multi-objective grey wolf optimizer,” Processes, vol. 8, no. 12, pp. 1–
24, Dec. 2020, doi: 10.3390/pr8121581.
[28] N. Yimen et al., “Optimal sizing and techno-economic analysis of hybrid renewable
energy systems—a case study of a photovoltaic/wind/battery/diesel system in Fanisau,
Northern Nigeria,” Processes, vol. 8, no. 11, pp. 1–25, Nov. 2020, doi:
10.3390/pr8111381.
[30] S. Sanajaoba, “Optimal sizing of off-grid hybrid energy system based on minimum cost of
energy and reliability criteria using firefly algorithm,” Solar Energy, vol. 188, pp. 655–
666, Aug. 2019, doi: 10.1016/J.SOLENER.2019.06.049.
[31] T. Chowdhury et al., “Developing and evaluating a stand-alone hybrid energy system for
Rohingya refugee community in Bangladesh,” Energy, vol. 191, p. 116568, Jan. 2020, doi:
10.1016/J.ENERGY.2019.116568.
[33] E. Muh and F. Tabet, “Comparative analysis of hybrid renewable energy systems for off-
grid applications in Southern Cameroons,” Renew Energy, vol. 135, pp. 41–54, May 2019,
doi: 10.1016/J.RENENE.2018.11.105.
39
[36] N. K. R. H. R. P. Md. Nurunnabi, “Optimal sizing of grid-tied hybrid renewable energy
systems considering inverter to PV ratio—A case study,” Journal of Renewable and
Sustainable Energy, vol. 11, 2019.
[38] E. I. Come Zebra, H. J. van der Windt, G. Nhumaio, and A. P. C. Faaij, “A review of
hybrid renewable energy systems in mini-grids for off-grid electrification in developing
countries,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 144, p. 111036, Jul. 2021,
doi: 10.1016/J.RSER.2021.111036.
[39] S. Suzauddin Yusuf and N. Nath Mustafi, “Design and Simulation of an Optimal Mini-
Grid Solar-Diesel Hybrid Power Generation System in a Remote Bangladesh,” 2018.
[40] Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, and IEEE
Malaysia Section. Sarawak Subsection, 2019 International UNIMAS STEM 12th
Engineering Conference (EnCon) : proceedings.
40
[44] M. M. Gamil et al., “Optimal sizing of a real remote Japanese microgrid with sea water
electrolysis plant under time-based demand response programs,” Energies (Basel), vol. 13,
no. 14, Jul. 2020, doi: 10.3390/en13143666.
41