Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Exam Format
This exam is worth 100 points and accounts for 30% of your final grade.
The final exam will take place on Thursday December 16th at 4pm in Fulton 511. The final is 90
minutes (1.5 hours) in length. This is an individual closed-book, closed-notes exam.
The final is cumulative. All material in the assigned readings will be fair game, but most (not all)
questions will focus primarily on the material emphasized in lectures.
1
Technology & Strategy Topic Sheet for Final Exam
2
• Data – differentiation and switching costs
• Network effects
• Distribution channels
• Patents (Arrow’s disclosure paradox)
- Strategy Terminology
• Sustainable Competitive Advantage: Financial performance that consistently
outperforms their industry peers. The goal is easy to state, but hard to achieve.
• Economies of scale: when a firm can spread costs across increasing units of
production. Example: Netflix incurs a cost of $300 million for 25 million
subscribers while Blockbuster incurs the same cost for 1.3 million subscribers
• Scale Advantages: advantages related to size.
• Operational Effectiveness: performing the same tasks better than rivals perform them
same activities (and resources) done better (Fedex v. UPS) Strategic positioning:
where you perform same tasks in a different way or perform tasks differently, operational
effectiveness is performing same tasks but just better different activities (and resources)
(Netflix, Zara)
• Straddling: When a firm adopts more than one method of doing business (occupies
more than one position) yet fails to gain the full advantages of any of these efforts.
• Six ways in which switching costs allow companies to hold onto their customers
despite strong market competition: 1) learning costs, 2) information & data, 3)
financial commitment,4) contractual commitment, 5) search costs, 6) loyalty
programs. (should be able to come up with at least 4 of these)
- Porter’s Five Forces
• Price transparency – the degree to which complete information is available
• Information asymmetry – When one or more party has more or better information
than its counterparty
• -The rivalry among existing competitors
-The threat of potential new entrants
-The threat of substitute and complementary products
-The power of suppliers
-The power of buyers
Categorize all forces into high or low, or strong or weak
3. Fresh Direct
- Product-market fit – the degree to which a product or service satisfies the demands of the market
(Fresh Direct started in Manhattan, where there is high demand for grocery deliveries due to high
traffic and stuff)
- Inventory turns – Number of times inventory is sold or used during a given period, higher figure
means company is selling products more quickly (Fresh Direct had fresher food due to their high
3
inventory turns)
- Brand, data, switching costs – Fresh Direct co-brand their products with suppliers, share their data
with suppliers to establish and strengthen supplier brand
- Straddling - When a firm attempts to adopts more than one method of doing business, or occupies
more than one position, yet fails to gain the full advantages of any of these efforts (Traditional
grocers can’t copy Fresh Direct’s delivery business because it would leave them straddling)
4
driven decision making, and due to this they are able to ship new inventory every two
weeks for “Outbound Logistics” (way faster than rivals, due to vertical integration),
- Apply the value chain model to Zara’s case
• Look at Above
- How does marketing differ at Zara relative to that of other large fashion companies?
• They have lower marketing expenses as they have lower markdown prices, since they
mostly sell all of their inventory
- How are design decisions typically made at Zara?
• They use data that they pull from customers
- What are the differences between a push and a pull model?
• marketing involves pushing your brand in front of audiences (usually with paid
advertising or promotions). Pull marketing on the other hand means implementing a
strategy that naturally draws consumer interest in your brand or products. ZARA is pull
- Explain Zara’s Data-Driven Decision Making process.
• Using the data from POS and PDA, they were able to design clothes that customers
wanted (they aren't guessing like GAP), the data helps them design clothes that
customers actually want
- What are the benefits for Zara to have limited production runs?
• They are able to have low markdowns as they have lower stock and can sell all of it
- How does Zara incentivize employees to use in-store technology?
• The company ties compensation to sales (70%), so if employees use these systems they
get more money
- What are the limitations of Zara’s Spain-centric, just-in-time manufacturing model?
• ZARA will be heavily affected by any disruption to the Spain region, as they distribute
inventory every two weeks from here, such as natural disasters, terrorism, etc.
Additionally, ZARA will be negatively affected during periods when the Euro
strengthens relative to the U.S. Dollar, which would raise ZARA’s costs compared to
competitors. There are also rising transportation costs in the area which are a concern
for ZARA.
5
• There is a lot of scale here as well - more customers, more content (more money to create
exclusives)
- Marginal costs of digital products – pricing strategies – cost associated with producing one
additional product or service, Digital goods have no marginal cost, but only for content owners
- Bandwidth caps – a limit imposed by ISPs (like Cable or Telephone company) on the total amount
of traffic that a given customer/subscriber can consume (higher fees for faster, direct
communication)
- Atoms to bits – We are going from “physical” goods (made from atoms such as Newspapers or
CDs) to “digital” goods (made from bits such as LinkedIn for Newspaper job listing and
Spotify/Apple Music instead of CDs), and this is realigning nearly every media industry
- Brick and mortar store - Brick and mortar refers to a physical presence of an organization or
business in a building or other structure, Netflix doesn’t need it?
- Economies of scale - when a firm can spread costs across increasing units of production, Netflix
had a large userbase over which they could spread the costs of their distribution centers
- Initial public stock offering (IPO) - the process by which a private company can go public by sale
of its stocks to general public. It could be a new, young company or an old company which decides
to be listed on an exchange and hence goes public.
- Windowing - content is available to a given distribution channel for a specified period of
- time (window), Netflix doesn’t own most of its content, cost to license
Questions and Exercises:
- Describe basics of the two separate Netflix business models: DVD-by-mail and digital streaming
Mailed DVDs to people, use Brand, Scale, and Data to gain competitive advantage, and had a
strong economy of scale by spreading its distribution center costs over its large userbase
- What downsides might a firm experience from “going public” early?
Once public, a firm has to disclose its financial position, so if there is a huge growth trajectory,
other firms will try to copy/follow it (happened with Stage 1 DVD company Netflix)
- Understanding how Netflix sustained competitive advantage and won the DVD-by-mail business is a
useful example of effective tech-enabled strategy. Know the three critical (and mutually reinforcing)
resources that DVD-by-mail rivals failed to imitate: brand, scale, and a data asset
Brand – brand is built through customer experience, Netflix initially had brand through
delivering DVDs, now have the brand of large streaming company
Scale – Netflix has a strong economy of scale, Netflix had a large userbase over which they
could spread the costs of their distribution centers
Data/Switching Costs – collaborative filtering, Netflix used (technology that monitors trends
among customers and uses this to personalize a given customer’s experience) this to get data on
customers to create the best customer experience possible
- How did Netflix build brand strength? How is brand strength built in general?
Netflix had the best customer experience (ranked number one), which helped them build brand
strength. In general, brand strength is built through customer experience.
- How does the “long tail” concept relate to Netflix’s ability to offer the customer a huge selection of
movies (DVDs)?
Netflix offered a huge selection of unique DVD titles. 75% of DVDs shipped by Netflix were
back-catalog titles, whereas 70% of Blockbuster rentals came from new releases. A traditional
video store had only about 3,000 titles on its shelves, whereas Netflix offered about 125,000
titles And customers saw the advantage in having choice.
6
- What role did economies of scale play in Netflix’s strategies in the DVD-by-mail model? How did
these scale economies pose an entry barrier to potential competitors?
- How does streaming potentially strengthen the Netflix data asset (relative to data collection with the
DVD-by-mail business)?
More data can be gathered on the internet in relation to things like which titles to display on the
home screen of a user’s streaming account and related
- What are the various key issues and challenges facing the video streaming models?
There are legal issues based on content by country (French law requires a wait time of three
years after film release before it can be streamed online), Licensing issues limit available content
that can be provided to customers.
- What are some popular pricing models adopted by streaming service providers?
Single Monthly Subscription Fee (Netflix), pay-per-view, commercially supported (but free)
content, and subscription for additional premium offerings (Google, Amazon, Hulu)
6. Moore’s Law: Fast, Cheap Computing and What This Means for the Manager
- Define Moore’s Law. To what industry does it apply?
The phenomenon of “faster, cheaper” computing (Chip performance per dollar doubles every
eighteen months), it applies to the semiconductor industry
- Price Elasticity. Are tech products typically price elastic?
Price Elasticity - how quantity demand fluctuating with change in price
Price Inelastic - things that demand won’t change on price, such as getting heart surgery
Price Elastic - if price changes, it can open new markets (many/most digital goods are
elastic)
- Describe one main implication of Moore’s Law for managers (not just managers at computing
firms)
Moore’s Law makes possible the once impossible. And as a manager, you have to
predict the future. But managers are often blindsided by unanticipated rate and
disruptive capabilities of technology change.
- What are a few ways that Moore’s Law has impacted developing economies?
It opens up newer markets for cheap cell phones, allowing more people in developing
economies have cell phones and digital communication
- Moore's Law: chip performance per dollar doubles every eighteen months. Think twice as fast, or
storing twice as much info. (Applies to the semiconductor industry / transistors)
- Moore’s Law over the years: We can build a computer that does something useful; a large business
or university can have one; any business can have one; everyone has one; everyone can carry one
around with them; things can have their own computers.
- Similar improvements in cost per performance: Optical Fiber – new material that increased chip
performance way more than the “every 18 months it doubles” Law; Data storage – some are
experimenting by crafting computing components using biological material (think a DNA-based
storage device.
- Triple Threat to Moore's Law: size (limit to how small you can make chip), heat (if you cram too
many things in a small space you can't control the heat), power (you need a lot of power to cool
down the chips, and this power can be costly)
- Moore’s Law Terminology
7
Semiconductor - in a business context refers to ‘computer chips’ (e.g. the semiconductor
industry is the chip business)
microprocessor - the calculating brain of a computer. Intel dominates this market in PCs,
ARM (licensed) dominates smart phones
volatile memory - requires a charge to hold its value (e.g. the RAM in your PC, which loses
data when the power is cut)
non-volatile memory - retains value even when not charged (e.g. the flash memory in your
camera)
7. Disruptive Technologies
- Key Characteristics of Disruptive Technologies
• Come to market with a set of performance attributes not initially valued by existing customers
• Performance attributes that customers do value improve to the point where the new tech invades
the established market
- Examples: ARM, Blockchain – right now (not many people see it as a serious thing), Kodak –
(Kodak Film Cameras) company had tech for digital cameras, but at the time nobody valued (thus
didn’t want) digital cameras, Apple Music
- Bitcoin – solves the problem of double spending, an open-source decentralized payment system that
operates in a peer-to-peer environment, without bank or central authority. Cryptocurrencies - a
digital asset where a secure form of mathematics is used to handle transactions, control the creation
of additional units, and verify the transfer of assets, take advantage of blockchain technology, all
cryptocurrencies will involve blockchain, Blockchain – a distributed and decentralized ledger that
verifies transactions and ownership, making it difficult to tamper with or shut down, underlying
technology of Bitcoin, may or may not involve cryptocurrencies
Wallet – no one can transfer the asset (bitcoin) without a special password (private key),
which is often stored referred to as a wallet, Ethereum - , mine – miners donate their
computer power in exchange for the opportunity to earn additional tokens in
cryptocurrency, awarded to the quickest miner (“solving a puzzle”)
- Mitigating the risk of disruptive technologies
• Identify technologies - external and internal conversations
• Managing an Option Portfolio of Innovations of emerging technologies, investing in firms,
startups, etc so it has the “right”, not obligation, to make an investment, can invest more
resources in more promising technologies/firms
8. Amazon
Rent the Runway: had hypothesis was problem (people buy so much clothing but only wear half of it, so
there was a need for rentable clothing), their MVP was wear they went to a campus, asked students
whether they would rent dresses, and 37% people said yes, so it confirmed there was a need, they also
tested whether people would be comfortable renting dresses online (sent out a PDF via email), turns out
there was a need so they got user feedback and proceeded
13
- Internet backbone – high speed data lines provided by many firms all across the world that
interconnect and collectively form the core of the internet
- Last mile technologies – Technologies that connect end users to the Internet. The last-mile problem
refers to the fact that these connections are usually the slowest part of the network
- Bandwidth – Network transmission speeds, typically expressed in some form of bits per second
(bps)
- Net neutrality – principle that all Internet traffic should be treated equally, and ISPs should not
discriminate, slow down access, or charge differentially by user, content, site, platform, application,
type of attached equipment, or modes of communication
20. Google
- Understand the extent of Google’s rapid rise and its size and influence when compared with others in
the media industry. Recognize the shift away from traditional advertising media to Internet
advertising
o Online advertising represents the only advertising category that, over the last several years,
has been consistently trending with positive growth.
- How does search engine work? (How does Google index the Web and rank its organic search
results?)
o SEO, Three Steps, Crawling, Indexing, Displaying
- Spiders, Web crawlers, software robots
o Traverse available websites to perform a given task. Spiders discover documents for indexing
and retrieval
- SEO
o Search Engine Optimization process of improving a page’s organic search rankings
- Deep Web – Internet content that can’t be indexed by Google and other search engines.
- How Google’s search advertising revenue model work?
o
- PPC, CPC, CTR, quality score
o PPC – pay per click, advertisers don’t pay unless someone clicks on the ad
o CPC – a maximum cost per click an advertiser is willing to pay
o CTR – clickthrough rate, the number of clicks that your ad receives divided by the number of
times your ad is shown
o Quality Score – a broad measure of ad performance
- Geotargeting
o IP Address/GPS/WiFi/CellTower Triangulation used to find your location
- Cookies, retargeting/remarketing
o Track what you search and give you ads personalized on it
- Contextual advertising - Advertising based on a website’s content, lucrative, but has content agency
problem
- Content agency problem - A situation where ads appear alongside text the advertiser would like to
avoid, like an article where body parts were hidden in a suitcase while ads for suitcases were shown
- Negative keywords – words that when searched don’t want your search result to pop up (prevents
your ad from being triggered by a certain word or phrase)
- Recognize how technology is a catalyst, causing the businesses of many firms in a variety of
industries to converge and compete, and that as a result of this, Google is active on multiple
14
competitive fronts.
-
Dropbox
Freemium model – paying customers cover the costs of the free customer costs
Viral marketing - Leveraging consumers to promote a product or service
Questions and Exercises:
What are the four components we focus on when analyzing a new venture (e.g., Dropbox)?
Is it valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable?
Does Dropbox exhibit network effects?
Yes, as since they offered free trials and more users discovered how convenient the product
was, Dropbox gained its network externalities through word of mouth and referral programs as
the customer base rapidly increased after offering these free trials
What are the risks of relying on search advertising to reach customers in a competitive market?
Since there are much bigger companies that can (and will) pay a lot more for the keywords for
this market, and Dropbox might get pushed way down in the search results
What are the challenges for a startup like Dropbox to sell their products/services to
organizations/corporations?
Dropbox must accommodate the needs of larger corporations while still maintaining the
simplicity and accessibility of the platform. But to offer a more advanced version that would
greater meet the needs of larger corporations, they would be abandoning the simplicity of the
platform. (need two different versions)
How did Dropbox do viral marketing? Why viral marketing can be very effective in terms of Return on
Investment (ROI)?
Dropbox gave people free trials, through which people discovered how convenient the product
was and told their friends, who discovered the same thing, who told their friends, etc. and they
leveraged other people through free trials to promote their product. It is very effect of ROI
because it costs nothing as opposed to paying for ads
Why cloud computing can be an appealing option for startups and small firms?
Lowers development time (sophistication of these tools/services) and is cheaper and easily
scalable as your firm grows
Is the freemium model suitable for Dropbox? Why?
Yes, because even after free trials, Dropbox operated with "freemium" as it understood that
operating services with freemium would naturally drive the customers who are willing to spend
their money on the platform (by enough people knowing about it you know someone will want
to pay), surpassing the maintenance cost of "free" users. And eventually, the paying users would
cover the costs of the free users.
15