Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2023
CPJXXX10.1177/00099228231171784Clinical PediatricsChen et al
Article
Clinical Pediatrics
Caidi Chen1*, Fanli Liu1*, Jianjing Fang2*, Linyuan Sima1, Liyan Ni1,
Songjie Xiang1, and Siwen Xia, MD1
Abstract
Thyroglossal duct cysts (TGDCs) are congenital and developmental abnormalities in infants and young children.
This retrospective case series study examined the characteristics of 7 patients <3 years (mean age, 1.9 years)
with TGDC complicated with a parapharyngeal mass treated at one hospital between January 2019 and 2022. Four
patients had a painless mass around the neck, 2 had a painless mass associated with snoring, and 1 presented repeated
swelling and pain. B-ultrasound suggested 6 cases of TGDC and 1 possible lymphangioma. All patients were treated
with Sistrunk surgery to remove the TGDC. Six patients had no cyst recurrence during follow-up (6 months to 2
years). In conclusion, TGDC complicated with a parapharyngeal mass has complex and variable clinical manifestations.
Completely removing the cyst while sparing thyroid cartilage and surrounding vascular and neuroanatomical structures
is important to avoid complications. The patients are likely to be free from recurrence after surgery.
Keywords
infant, children, thyroglossal cyst, laryngoscopy, paracentesis, case series
more than 15 mm), and the fibrous cord extending to the this study. The continuous data were expressed as means
foramen cecum, is resected. Sistrunk’s procedure is still ± standard deviations (SD) or medians (ranges). The
considered the gold standard in treating TGDCs in categorical data were expressed as n (%).
infants and young children, but marsupialization and
simple cyst excision can also be performed.10,11
Results
The surgery is usually successful in older children
and adults if inflammation is controlled,12,13 but due to Clinical and Pathological Characteristics
the physiological and structural differences, the failure
rate of surgery in infants and children is significantly Seven patients (5 males and 2 females), aged 1.9 years
higher than in adults.14 Interestingly, the surgery’s suc- (range, 10 months to 2 years 7 months), were included in
cess rate and the disease’s recurrence are associated with this study (Table 1). Four patients had a painless mass
the anatomical structure and location of the cyst identi- around the neck, 2 had a painless mass around the neck
fied during the surgery.15,16 Clinical diagnosis, surgical associated with snoring, and 1 had repeated swelling and
treatment, and postoperative precautions need in-depth pain. All patients underwent B-ultrasound examination
exploration. before surgery; TGDC was confirmed in 6 patients,
TGDCs are uncommon in infants and young chil- while lymphangioma was suggested in 1 patient.
dren, and TGDCs with respiratory obstruction due to a Preoperative computed tomography (CT) examination
parapharyngeal neck mass are even rarer. Therefore, this was conducted on the patient with suspected lymphan-
study aimed to examine the clinical characteristics and gioma to distinguish the mass boundary; imaging sug-
prognosis of infants and children <3 years of age with gested a left anterior cervical intramuscular cystic
TGDC complicated with a parapharyngeal mass. lesion.
All included patients underwent surgery due to con-
servative treatment failure. Six of the 7 patients under-
Methods went surgery more than 3 months after diagnosis. One
patient was suffering from repeated neck infection and
Study Design and Patients underwent surgery 1 month after diagnosis once the
This retrospective case series study included infants and infection was under control.
children <3 years of age with TGDC complicated with Strikingly, all patients had simple TGDC without
parapharyngeal masses admitted to the Department of anterior cervical fistula. Preoperative electronic laryn-
Otolaryngology of our Hospital between January 2019 goscopy in 1 patient showed a right aryepiglottic fissure
and 2022. mucosa bulge with a smooth surface. In 3 patients, mag-
The inclusion criteria were (1) <3 years old, (2) netic resonance imaging (MRI) of the neck showed a
underwent classic Sistrunk surgery9,17 because conser- cystic mass in the neck with a clear boundary. Magnetic
vative treatment was ineffective, and (3) TGDC con- resonance imaging suggested that the airway was nar-
firmed by postoperative pathological examination. rowed due to airway compression by the mass in 1
Patients with a physical examination that showed a mid- patient.
line mass in the neck rather than a unilateral parapharyn- All patients underwent surgery because conservative
geal mass were excluded. treatment was ineffective. The TGDC mass in the rear of
The Ethics Committee of our Hospital approved the the tongue was removed using the traditional Sistrunk
study protocol. The requirement for individual consent surgery. The drainage was removed after about 3 days,
was waived by the committee because of the retrospec- and the sutures were removed 7 days after surgery.
tive nature of the study. The patients were followed up (6 months to 2 years)
after the surgery. The neck incision recovered well, the
scars hidden in the necklines were not detected easily,
Data Collection
and the family members were satisfied with the results.
The demographic and baseline clinical characteristics Only in 1 case (repeated infection of the neck mass
(including age, sex, symptoms, and imaging examina- before surgery) did a small cyst in the middle of the
tion results), treatment, and prognosis during follow-up hyoid bone recur 6 months after surgery, while no cysts
were collected from the medical records. were detected in the other 6 patients.
Case 1 (typical 1Y1M Female 6 months after the neck mass found √ √ √ √ √ July 15, 2021-July 20, 2021 11M No recurrence
case) with snoring
Case 2 2Y7M Male 1 month after the neck mass was / √ / √ √ December 15, 2021-December 6M No recurrence
found 19, 2021
Case 3 2Y6M Female 11 months after the neck mass was / √ / √ / September 27, 2021-September 9M No recurrence
found 30, 2021
Case 4 2Y1M Male 1 year after the neck mass was found / √ / / √ May 4, 2021-May 10, 2021 12M No recurrence
with snoring
Case 5 10M Male Half a month after neck swelling and / √ √ / √ January 3, 2021-January 7, 2021 18M Recurrence of small cyst
aggravation for 1 day in the median of hyoid
bone half a year after
surgery
Case 6 2Y5M Male 1 year after the neck mass was found / √ / / / June 2, 2020-June 8, 2020 2Y No recurrence
Case 7 2Y1M Male 2 years after the neck mass was found / √ √ / √ March 11, 2019-March 18, 2019 2Y No recurrence
3
4 Clinical Pediatrics 00(0)
Figure 1. Typical case presentation. (A) Laryngoscopy results demonstrate a right parapharyngeal mass protruding into the
larynx. (B) Ultrasound of the neck shows a subcutaneous cystic mass of about 35 × 20 mm2 on the right side of the neck
with a distinct boundary. (C) Neck MRI (T2) showing a lobulated cystic mass of about 32 × 32 × 23 mm3 in size in the right
parapharynx with a clear boundary. The airway is narrowed due to mass-induced compression of the trachea, and the parotid
and submandibular glands are enlarged. (D) Cyst mass after complete excision. (E) Postoperative pathology examination
(hematoxylin-eosin [HE], ×200) shows a cyst wall covered with squamous epithelium and no prominent atypia; differentiated
and mature thyroid cells beside the cyst wall. (F) Neck MRI shows postoperative results.
Abbreviation: MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.
June 2021 due to a right neck mass observed for 6 months, abnormalities were observed during inhalation.
with aggravation and dyspnea for 1 month. Six months Electronic fiber laryngoscopy detected a mucosal bulge
ago, the family members observed a mass (about the size with a smooth surface in the right parapharynx, com-
of a peanut) on the right side of the neck, accompanied by pressing the airway (Figure 1A).
snoring and stridor, but without fever and cough. The A neck ultrasound at the outpatient clinic showed a
diagnosis in the pediatric outpatient clinic was a right subcutaneous cystic mass of about 35 × 20 mm2 with
neck cyst by a combination of B-mode ultrasound, MRI, clear boundaries on the right side of the neck, compress-
and other auxiliary examinations. The right neck cyst was ing the back of the trachea (Figure 1B). The neck MRI
treated with puncture and fluid extraction, which relieved showed a lobulated cystic mass of about 32 × 32 × 23
the symptoms, but the mass in the back of the neck mm3 with a clear boundary in the front of the right
increased repeatedly. Thus, multiple punctures were per- carotid artery, compressing the glottis area, leading to
formed. During the last month before admission, the mass the narrowing of the airway and enlargement of the
had grown, and the child suffered from aggravated snor- parotid and submandibular glands (Figure 1C). The
ing, dyspnea, and frequent awakenings. admission diagnosis was “parapharyngeal mass: sus-
Physical examination revealed a movable cystic mass pected thyroglossal cyst, Laryngeal obstruction (grade
of about 35 × 20 × 20 mm3 in the right parapharynx, III).”
with clear boundaries. The mass moved with swallow- After excluding the surgery and anesthesia contrain-
ing. Three concave signs without tenderness and other dications, the resection of the parapharyngeal mass was
Chen et al 5
performed under general anesthesia. During surgery, obstruction. In the included patients, the masses were
blunt dissection was performed around the cyst. The located in the parapharyngeal space, compression of the
cyst adhered to the surrounding tissue, and its root was airway, leading to respiratory obstruction. Furthermore,
around the back of the hyoid bone, indicating a TGDC. patients under 3 years old have a small airway, the con-
Thus, about 1.0 cm of the hyoid bone and the root of the nective tissue in the neck is loose, and the airway is
cyst were removed (Figure 1D). After hemostasis, drain- more likely to develop edema in the presence of infec-
age was placed, and the incision was sutured layer by tion or oppression. Therefore, all 7 patients suffered
layer. Three days later, the patient was discharged from from respiratory obstruction.
the hospital after removing the drainage. The postopera- In addition to the clinical manifestations and physical
tive pathology examination confirmed the TGDC examination, TGDC in infants and young children can
(Figure 1E). Three months later, the clinical symptoms be diagnosed through auxiliary examinations. Neck
were relieved, and the neck MRI showed no residual ultrasound, CT, and MRI are commonly used for diag-
mass (Figure 1F). No recurrence was reported during the nosing TGDC in infants and young children and for
1-year follow-up. determining the location, size, shape, nature, blood sup-
ply, and the correlation between the mass and surround-
ing tissues.11,25 In patients undergoing electronic
Discussion fiberoptic laryngoscopy, round-like bulged unilateral
The present study showed that TGDC complicated with laryngopharyngeal mucosa can be identified as one of
parapharyngeal masses in infants and young children the warning signs. Still, TGDC complicated by parapha-
has complex and variable clinical manifestations. The ryngeal masses in infants and young children lacks char-
mass can be punctured and aspirated when parapharyn- acteristic manifestations, leading to confusion with
geal TGDC is considered after B-mode ultrasound, CT, liquid cystic tumors that can also occur in infants and
or MRI. Surgery might be an alternative after conserva- young children. Therefore, puncture and resection are
tive treatment failure. Thyroglossal duct cysts are recommended when a parapharyngeal TGDC is sus-
uncommon in infants and young children, and TGDCs pected after B-mode ultrasound, CT, or MRI.
with respiratory obstruction due to a parapharyngeal Sistrunk surgery in the external cervical approach is
neck mass are even rarer. Their main symptoms include one of the most used surgical approaches for TGDCs.26
dyspnea,18 laryngeal stridor,19,20 or asphyxia.6,21,22 Given the short neck of infants and young children and
Furthermore, the mass in the patients included in previ- the fact that the bone structure has not been developed
ous studies was in the midline neck,6,18,19,21,22 and unilat- fully and the body surface landmarks are lacking, the
eral neck mass is even rarer, leading to a high risk for cervical stripe is considered the marking line of the sur-
misdiagnosis. The patients reported here underwent sur- gical incision. Typically, the first cervical stripe is
gery after conservative treatment failure and were con- located at the level of the hyoid bone, the second cervi-
firmed with atypical TGDCs according to the cal stripe is between the thyroid cartilage and the cricoid
pathological examination. The result suggests that cartilage, and the third cervical stripe is at the level of
patients with such characteristics and conservative treat- the tracheal ring 3-4 above the sternum in infants and
ment failure should be considered for TGDC. young children. Surgery along the cervical stripe can
Thyroglossal duct cyst might exhibit no clinical avoid the intraoperative loss of direction to increase the
symptoms, and patients often seek medical attention due safety of neck surgery for infants and young children
to a neck mass.23 In this study, a physical examination with no severe surgical scar or incision infection and
revealed a smooth, movable cystic mass in the middle of reduce the impact on facial esthetics, thus making it
the neck that had mobility when swallowing. In some acceptable to the families of patients.
patients, a cord was described along the direction of the Furthermore, the development speed of each system
hyoid bone, as reported previously,24 but if the structures of infants and young children is different, with the ner-
of the hyoid bone and other neck bones are immature, vous system developing early.27 During surgery, the
the correlation between the hyoid bone and the mass diameter of the nerves of the infants is often found to be
cannot be determined by palpation. The cases included like that of adults, but the structures of the neck and
in this series confirmed that in infants and young chil- other tissues are not fully developed, especially the
dren with a unilateral parapharyngeal mass and symp- hyoid bone, which is an anatomical marker. The hyoid
toms of laryngeal obstruction, the possibility of a TGDC bone of the infants is slender and should be identified
should be considered to avoid misdiagnosis. The rela- carefully to locate the cyst accurately.28 Thus, the corre-
tively long time between diagnosis and surgical removal lation between the fistula and the hyoid bone should be
could also explain why the TGDCs caused airway judged cautiously. When the boundary between the
6 Clinical Pediatrics 00(0)
fistula and the hyoid bone is distinct, the hyoid bone can have not been fully ossified is important to completely
be preserved; otherwise, a part of the hyoid bone needs remove cysts and avoid complications.
to be removed.29 After the excision of the cyst, hyoid In conclusion, infants and young children <3 years
bone resection does not affect the probability of the of age with TGDC complicated with parapharyngeal
postoperative recurrence of TGDC.30 In contrast, pre- mass have complex and variable clinical manifestations.
serving the hyoid bone can reduce complications and Clearly establishing the diagnosis of pharyngeal mass
preserve the anatomical markers. Strikingly, when the due to TGDC is essential for proper management, and
fistula passes through the hyoid bone, the resection of imaging examinations can be helpful in diagnosis.
the bone should reach at least 1.0 cm, or else it can easily Inflammation control is the key to management.
rupture the cyst wall or the fistula and its branches, Children who fail conservative treatments should be
resulting in recurrence. In addition, the surrounding tis- treated with surgery as soon as possible. Completely
sues should be removed along the cyst wall during the removing the cyst while sparing thyroid cartilage and
surgery, except for patients with repeated infection surrounding vascular and neuroanatomical structures is
before surgery that may lead to severe adhesion. important to avoid complications. Infants and young
The complications of TGDC resection mainly include children <3 years of age are likely to be free from recur-
wound infection or hematoma, nerve paralysis, hypo- rence after surgery.
thyroidism, and TGDC recurrence.31 In our patients,
postoperative complications were fewer, which was in Author Contributions
line with previous reports wherein TGDC resection in CC and SX: Carried out the studies, participated in collecting
infants and young children ≤3 years old did not increase data, and drafted the manuscript. FL and JF: Performed the
the risk of complications.32 However, infants and young statistical analysis and participated in its design. LS, LN, and
children must be prepared for the perioperative period. SX: Participated in acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of
This study included all cases admitted to our Hospital data and draft the manuscript. All authors read and approved
between January 2019 and January 2022, but only 7 the final manuscript.
cases were operated on during this time, confirming that
few infants and young children manifested TGDC with Availability of Data and Materials
parapharyngeal masses. Thus, it is necessary to extend All data generated or analyzed during this study are included
the duration of follow-up and include additional cases to in this published article.
obtain reliable conclusions in future studies.
Atypical cases characterized by a unilateral parapha- Declaration of Conflicting Interests
ryngeal mass are rare with TGDC and even rarer with The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
respiratory obstruction. Patients with such characteris- respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
tics can easily be misdiagnosed as cystic hygroma or article.
branchial cleft cysts, which would mislead the treatment
plan. As the analysis of the cyst fluid can lead to a defin- Funding
itive diagnosis, and since puncture and fluid extraction
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial sup-
would relieve the symptoms, ultrasound-guided punc- port for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
ture extraction should be performed. Infants under 3 article: The study was supported by Fundamental Research
years of age have a risk of dyspnea or even asphyxia Project of Wenzhou City (Y20210015, Y20211064).
because of small immature airways. If dyspnea >II
degree occurs, it can be quickly relieved by timely punc- Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
ture and drainage, atomization, systemic hormone, and
The Ethics Committee approved the study protocol of the
other symptomatic treatment. Children who fail those
Second Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University.
conservative treatments should be treated with surgery All the included infants’ parents or legal guardians signed
as soon as possible. Preoperative inflammation control informed consent. All methods were performed in accordance
is key. Although the external cervical approach Sistrunk with the relevant guidelines and regulations.
surgery is the classic choice, neck localization of infants
under 3 years of age remains one of the challenges for
Consent for Publication
head and neck surgeons. In this study, it was found that
the intraoperative projection of the 3 cervical lines of Not applicable.
infants should be strictly followed. Carefully looking for
the hyoid bone while sparing thyroid cartilage and sur- ORCID iD
rounding vascular and neuroanatomical structures that Siwen Xia https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6179-7418
Chen et al 7