You are on page 1of 7

One Person Company (OPC): A Comparative

Study on South Asian Countries

Md. Mahadi Hasan


Assistant Professor
Department of Accounting & Information Systems
University of Dhaka
Email:mahadi.ais@du.ac.bd

Abstract
One Person Company (OPC) is a new concept in Bangladesh which is introduced through the amendment of the
Companies Act 1994 through an official gadget published on 26th of November 2020. One Person Company
(OPC) means a company which has only one natural person as shareholder*. Previously a single person was
not able to form a company in Bangladesh. This opened an entryway of opportunity for those who are not
interested in doing business with others or who are unable to form public or private limited companies because
of a lack of like-minded investors. One Person Company (OPC) is introduced by the government of Bangladesh
for creating an investor friendly environment to attract both national and international investment. This study is
conducted to show a comparative picture of the One Person Companies(OPC) act and rules among Bangladesh,
India and Pakistan. Data were collected from the secondary data sources. The study found several similarities
and dissimilarities in One Person Company (OPC) in compared countries. If proper actions are taken by the
government to make the provision clearer, and tax benefits are given in the initial stage after formation, then OPC
will get its momentum. The governance issue of OPC need to be addressed properly so that it cannot be used
as a tool for tax evasion and money laundering in Bangladesh.
Keyword: One Person Company (OPC), Single Member Company (SMC), South Asian Countries.
[*Sect-2(1) bb of the Companies Act 1994.]

28 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
interested in investing in incorporated institutions. For
1.0 Introduction
smaller businesses looking to break new ground as an
One Person Company (OPC) opened a new epoch alternative to sole proprietorship, the term OPC also
for the entrepreneur of Bangladesh to get benefit of seems to be the one of the best options. Additionally,
company without sharing the ownership to others. it helps entrepreneurs obtain exclusive ownership
One Person Company (OPC) is new in Bangladesh of their institution as a registered business. This is
but the concept is not new to the world. OPC exists important for the growth of present and potential
in several countries like the UK, USA, Singapore, entrepreneurs in Bangladesh.
France, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Saudi Arabia, China,
This study is a critical analysis of the present provisions
India and several other countries of the world. In
of OPC introduced through the 2nd amendment
Bangladesh before the amendment of 2020 for private
of the Companies Act of Bangladesh in 2020. A
limited company minimum 2 (two) persons and for
comparative analysis is done in South Asian countries
public limited company minimum 7 (seven) persons
focusing on Bangladesh, India and Pakistan. The study
were required. Now any natural person can form a
is based on secondary data and divided into four
One Person Company (OPC) after fulfilling certain
sections. The first section covers the salient feature
conditions in Bangladesh. The Person starting an OPC
of the One Person Company (OPC), rules and
is the sole owner of the company and will enjoy the
regulation of Bangladesh. The second part covers a
advantages of a registered company. One Person
comparative analysis of the OPC rules and regulations
Company (OPC) will provide entrepreneurs legal
of Bangladesh, India and Pakistan and in the final part,
protection along with a chance to get incorporated
some recommendations are provided based on the
as a legal entity to get several advantages which
findings and finally conclusion is drawn.
were previously not possible as a sole proprietorship
business entrepreneur. Unlimited liability was one of
the main concerns of entrepreneurs who wanted to 2.0 Literature Review
start a business alone. One Person Company makes The One Person Company (OPC) is not a new
it possible to put the legal and monetary liabilities only idea from the global context. Several studies were
to the company not to the individual starting OPC. conducted from different countries points of
In sole proprietorship legal liability of individual is view. Verma (2021) critically assesses the basic
unlimited where personal assets can be make liable for understanding of OPC along with his historical and
the business operation which was the big barrier for legal perspectives, looking at OPC advantages. The
the entrepreneur to start a business entity. OPC give author looked back on his development journey
relief on this issue allowing a single person to form a through multiple lenses and committed to addressing
registered company. the specific legal and regulatory requirements of OPC
Bangladesh is not doing satisfactorily in the Ease of that will affect the substantive implementation of OPC
Doing Business rank published by the World Bank rules in India. The study found that despite of having
for a long time. The recent score of Bangladesh flaws, OPC has made a remarkable contribution from
is 168 just immediate before the introduction of 2014 to 2021 in the Indian economy. The high tax rate
OPC in 2020 through the second amendment of compared to the sole proprietorship business is one
the Companies Act 2020. Our neighboring country of the major limitations. A different tax rate based on
India ranked 62 which is far more ahead of us. Even OPC size was suggested by the author in response.
Pakistan ranked 108 in 2019 ahead of Bangladesh in Government initiative for facilitating banks’ support is
many aspects. The government of Bangladesh is trying recommended for further expansion of OPC to full
to improve the business environment of Bangladesh fledge.
through many initiatives. One Person Company is Dang and Sharma (2015) studied the opportunities
one of them. The limited liability provision of OPC and challenges of One Person Company in India.
will give entrepreneurs the freedom to take extra The main advantages they found are greater
risks. In addition to legal protection and tax flexibility, opportunities for small entrepreneurs, low risk,
the One Person Company helps entrepreneurs helpful to young entrepreneurs, combines feature
obtain financial relief from banks who are far more of sole proprietorship and company, less formalities

29 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
for formation. The main challenges are one person the peculiarities and similarities between the two
cannot form more than one OPC, it cannot carry non- legal systems. Single member companies in Europe
banking financial activities, compliance cost is high in and China by analyzing and comparing several key
comparison to sole proprietorship, and exiting private provisions in each jurisdiction to uncover the strengths
limited company cannot be converted to OPC. and weaknesses of current jurisdictions and to inspire
Several studies were done showing the formation future legislators. Both legal systems of the EU and
procedure advantages and disadvantages. Dey (2018) China recognize the legal status of single member
shows a comparative study of sole proprietorship, a company by law. In both case company law has a
private company, the basic steps of the formation of major role in Single Member Company. In China,
OPC and its industry wise incorporation progress. one natural person is allowed to have only one single
Total eleven steps required to form One Person member company, but the case is different in Europe.
Company in India. Sector wise growth shows that In some European region, personal disclosure of
business service firms represent 61.36% of the OPC property is required while in China, it not required
and Community, Personal & Social Services represent to disclose in OPC. Piercing the corporate veil is not
10.98% of the incorporated firm. Manufacturing shown in Chinese company law yet where it is found
companies represents only 8.11% and the lowest one in many cases in European countries.
is Mining & Quarrying companies represent 0.31% of Tessema (2012) focuses on the meaning of single
the total incorporated OPC. member company and its details, developments,
OPC is also studied from different dimensions. Ali problems, legal remedies, and objectives. It also
(2015) studied to see whether the idea of Single covers the formation, management and general
Member Company (SMC), is a way to exploit and regulation of private companies in Germany, France
to averse the company liability by the Capitalist. The and the United Kingdom. The final part is devoted
study was conducted based on the Pakistan Company to Ethiopian company law and recommendations.
Ordinance 1984. The study argues that there is no Although there was no law in Germany specifically
provision in Pakistani law to effectively establish a authorizing the formation single member company but
mechanism of checks and balances to mitigate the risk a single shareholder acquiring all shares in a company
of Pakistani SMCs evading corporate liability. In the after incorporation has been legal in Germany since
same context, the study found shortcomings of the last century. On the other side, in 1985 single member
SMC Act related to the concept of corporate social, company was approved in France. The management
economic and environmental responsibility. of single member company can be done by single
shareholder or other in German, French and English
Studies were conducted to compare the different
Law. Ethiopia’s legal system is different from the one-
country’s legal framework on OPC. Badri et al. (2014)
man company law. Allowing a single member company
conducted a study comparing the Single Member
in Ethiopia will promote equality and facilitate the right
Company Act of England, Germany, France and Iran.
to engage in economic activities through creation of a
Chen (2008) tried to show a comparative view of
good environment for business.
China and Singapore One Person Company (OPC).
The authors found that special treatment given to As the concepts of OPC is very recent development
single member companies in China contrasts with the in Bangladesh very few studied found on it.
indifferent treatment given in Singapore. Singapore’s Shakibuzzaman (2021) assesses the prospects of One
indifference to formal OPC ensures that one man Person Company in Bangladesh. The most attractive
company is indeed an attractive and viable alternative feature of the OPC is the liability of the owner is
to the sole proprietorship. This is precisely the blemish limited up to his investment in the OPC. A separate
of China’s pragmatic approach, where the fear of legal entity can be formed under the umbrella of
the lack of an independent foundation puts an extra the legal system of Bangladesh having many facilities
burden on official one member firms and undermines like taking support from the Banks and financial
the effectiveness of China’s One Member firms and institutions. OPC will be the best option to the small
severely limit its viability. and medium entrepreneurs with small investments
in Bangladesh. Considering the above literature, a
Miao (2012) shows a comparative study of the
clear gap found in the area of OPC in Bangladesh.
legal framework of Single Member Company in the
Previously no study found that compare OPC in south
European Union and China. The study explores
Asian countries like Bangladesh, India and Pakistan.

30 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
This study focuses addressing several issues of OPC a manager, secretary and other employees for the
in Bangladesh showing a comparative picture of India company’s management
and Pakistan. This study will open a new arena for • The minimum paid up capital of an OPC will be Tk
future researchers to study One Person Company 25 lakh and maximum Tk 5 crore, and its annual
(OPC) from different dimensions.
turnover in the previous year must be minimum
Tk 1 crore and maximum Tk 50 crore. If these
3.0 Objectives of this Study amounts exceed the maximum limit, an OPC
The main focus of this study is to depict a comparative may be converted to a private or a public limited
view of the legal framework of One Person Company company complying with other requirements of
(OPC) from South Asian perspective. The other the Act.
specific objectives are- • The company needs to put OPC at the end of its
i) To see the salient feature of the One Person name to indicate it as One Person Company.
Company (OPC) rules of Bangladesh. • The director of the OPC must hold at least one
ii) To find out the lacking of the present legal director’s meeting in six months.
framework OPC of Bangladesh based on the • An OPC must keep proper accounting records as
comparison. per the provisions of the Companies Act 1994.
iii) To give some recommendations for further The existing provisions relating to auditors and
improvement of OPC in Bangladesh. audit reports will apply to an OPC with necessary
adaptations. Its financial statements (every
4.0 Methodology balance sheet and profit-loss account) and must
This study is descriptive in nature and based on be signed by the sole shareholder and submitted
secondary data. Data were collected from various to the Registrar within 180 days of the completion
secondary sources, Journals. The main sources were of the financial year.
the rules and acts of the three South Asian Countries • All shares of a One Person Company may be
related to OPC. Companies Act 1994 of Bangladesh transferred to another natural person only.
(with its 2nd Amendment of 2020) of Bangladesh, • OPC may borrow and make payment of loan
the Companies Act, 2013 of India and Single Member from bank or financial institution subject to
Companies Rules, 2003 Pakistan were the main the provisions of section 159 to 175 of the
sources of data for this study. Companies Act, 1994 with necessary adjustments
as required.
5.0 Salient Features of One Person • The One Person Company (OPC) may be winded
Company(OPC) in Bangladesh up voluntarily following the existing provisions
of winding up in the Companies Act, 1994 with
• Only one person can form a One Person
necessary adjustments as required.
Company (OPC) for any lawful purpose. A single
person can form only one OPC in Bangladesh.
• There will be only one member or shareholder 6.0 Comparison of OPC Legal
for One Person Company(OPC) Framework in South Asian
• The company need to mention a nominee as a Countries
legal requirement of formation. The nominee will The comparison of One Person Company related
become the company’s sole shareholder in case of rules regulation in south Asian Countries consisting of
the original shareholder’s death or incapacitation Bangladesh, India and Pakistan are summarized below-
or insanity. 6.1 Relevant Act/Rules: OPC was introduced in
• Registration procedure will be similar like a private Bangladesh through the Companies Act second
limited company with necessary adaptation. amendment 2020. Where in India, it was introduced
• An OPC will have only one person as its member, in 2013 through the Indian Company Act 2013. In
who will be its sole director. But he may appoint Pakistan, it was introduced in 2003 through the Single

31 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
Member Companies Rules 2003. The company will be for submission to the auditor. OPC is exempted from
named as One Person Company (OPC) in Bangladesh preparing cash flow statement in India. SMC must
and India but Single Member Company(SMC) in keep proper accounting records as per the law to
Pakistan. file the audited accounts with SEC of Pakistan if the
6.2 Formation: Any natural person can form OPC in paid-up capital is 7.5 million or more. The director(s)
Bangladesh. In India, to form OPC, the natural person shall ensure that proper books of account are kept
must be a resident of India. In Pakistan, natural person and prepared so that such profit and loss accounts
and body corporate can incorporate SMC. The or income and expenditure accounts, balance sheets,
pattern of name during the formation will be like XYZ and reports may be brought before the company in
OPC in Bangladesh, XYZ (OPC) Private Limited in general meeting. Authentication of books of accounts
India and XYZ (SMC-Private) Limited in Pakistan. No shall be done by the sole shareholder director for all
restriction is found in the law regarding the foreigner of the three countries compared.
to incorporate OPC in Bangladesh. But information 6.6 Nominee: Need to mention a single person name
procedure and NID number is required. That may as nominee in Bangladesh and India as per the law.
make it difficult to a foreigner to incorporate OPC One person can be nominee in more than one OPC
in Bangladesh. A foreigner can incorporate SMC in at a time. In Pakistan there is no provision in the
Pakistan if he/she is resident. In India, no foreigners SMC rules of 2003 regarding selecting a person as
are allowed to form OPC. OPC will be a limited nominee but there is a provision for nominee director
company in Bangladesh and Pakistan but in India, OPC and alternative nominee director. This provision is
may be limited by share, guarantee and unlimited exempted through the recent amendment in Pakistan.
company. In Bangladesh and Pakistan, OPC and SMC In formation process, legal heirs need to be mentioned
can be formed for any lawful purpose but in India, in Pakistan as per the SMC rules.
OPC not allowed to form for non-banking financial 6.7 Administration: Sole shareholder will be the
investment activities. director of the company in Bangladesh. In India,
6.3 Turnover Requirement: There is a turnover minimum 1 maximum 15 director can be appointed
requirement to form OPC in Bangladesh and India. by OPC. In Pakistan, as per section 174, the sole
Minimum 1 crore and maximum 50 crore turnover shareholder director may appoint additional director
is required in Bangladesh and in India. It is maximum as required. Minimum one but maximum limit not
2 crore per year. No such requirement is found in mentioned. In Pakistan, directors are classified as
Pakistan. member director and non-member director where
6.4 Capital Requirements: Al least Tk 25 lakh no such classification found for Bangladesh and India.
authorized and paid up capital required to form OPC The board cannot remove the member director or
in Bangladesh. Where in India authorized capital of 1 the non-member director but the single member can
lakh rupee is required to form OPC. No requirement remove any director, chief executive or secretary in
is set for paid up capital. In Pakistan, authorize share Pakistan.
capital of 1 lakh rupee is required. Minimum paid up 6.8 Conversion: If annual turnover exceeds Tk
capital as set by the company. No OPC/SMC can 50 crore, an OPC may be converted to a private
issue share to the general public in all three countries or a public limited company complying with other
compared. requirements of the Act in Bangladesh. In India,
6.5 Books of Accounts: An OPC must keep proper after two years of registration, conversion to Private
accounting records as per the provisions of the Limited Company possible. Conversion must be done
Companies Act, 1994 in Bangladesh. Its financial in case of increase in turnover over certain amount.
statements (every balance sheet and profit-loss In Pakistan, Single Member Company (SMC) may be
account) and must be signed by the sole shareholder converted to Private Limited Company by increasing
and submitted to the Registrar within 180 days member or by the death of the sole shareholder.
of completion of the financial year. In India, OPC Private company limited by share may be converted
financial statements need to be approved by the to Single Member Company (SMC) after complying
Board and needs to be signed by only one director the rules. No such provision is found in India and
Bangladesh.

32 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
6.9 Meetings and Proceedings: In Bangladesh, as per such provision is found for Bangladesh and India.
section 392F, the Director of OPC will call at least one 6.14 Contract with the Single Member: No such
board of directors meeting in every half year. In India, provisions is found in Bangladesh companies act.
director of OPC will call at least one board meeting In India, if OPC enters into a contract with its sole
in every half year, the difference between two board member (who is also a director), company must
meeting shall be not less than 90 days. In Pakistan, the incorporate the terms of the contract/offer in the
company need to hold meeting when required subject Memorandum, unless the contract is in writing or
to the provision of rule 5. No provision regarding the record in first board meeting after the contract. In
notice of the meetings is found in Bangladesh and case of contract in ordinary course of business above
India. In Pakistan, notice of the meeting need to be rules do not apply. In Pakistan if SMC enters into a
notified to the member and secretary and they need contract with its sole member (who is also a director),
to be present for fulfilling the requirement. For AGM, company must incorporate the terms of the contract/
auditor shall be given notice for not less than twenty- offer in the Memorandum, unless the contract is
one days. In Bangladesh, no provision is found in the in writing or record in first board meeting after the
law for quorum of OPC meeting. In India, no quorum contract. In case of contract in ordinary course of
for meeting is required if there is only one director. In business above rules do not apply.
Pakistan, single member present in person or through 6.15 Death of Single Member: In Bangladesh and
proxy shall be the quorum for the general meeting India, in case of death of the single member of the
provided that secretary shall not act as proxy of the OPC, nominee will be shareholder in run the OPC
single member. taking assets and liabilities. In Pakistan, in case of death
6.10 Company Secretary: In Bangladesh, single of single shareholder of Single Member Company
member may appoint company secretary but no time (SMC) , either be wound up or be converted into
limit is given in the law. In Pakistan, Single Member private company.
Company (SMC) shall appoint a company secretary 6.16 Transfer and Transmission of Share: In
within 15 days of incorporation. For India, no clear- Bangladesh, law allows OPC to transfer all share at
cut provision is found regarding this issue. once to a single person only. In Pakistan, share transfer
6.11 Annual General Meeting(AGM): No requirement is possible through passing ordinary resolution by the
of AGM found in Bangladesh for OPC. OPC are member. Relevant provision will have to be used to
exempted to hold AGM in India. AGM shall be held transfer the share in India. In Pakistan transmission
as per the provisions of section 158 and rule 5 in of shares to the legal heirs shall be recorded in the
Pakistan. No provision is found regarding the dividend register of members by the secretary. No such
declaration in Bangladesh and India. In SMC rules of provision is found in Bangladesh.
Pakistan, it is mentioned that the SMC may declare 6.17 Winding-Up: In Bangladesh, OPC may wind up
dividend and pay in accordance with the provision of voluntarily subject to the provision of the Companies
the sections. Act 1994. In India, if any OPC remains inactive for
6.12 Taxation: Tax rate for OPC in Bangladesh for more than one year from the date of incorporation,
2022-23 is 22.5%, where in India, no specific tax owner may apply for winding up of the company under
rate found for OPC. It is mentioned that domestic the normal procedure or Fast Track Exit scheme of the
Company in India whose turnover is less than 400 Ministry of Corporate Affairs of India. In other case,
crores will have a tax rate of 25%. In Pakistan, except the OPC may be wound up voluntarily or by the order
Banking and Public limited company tax rate is 29% for of the Tribunal. In Pakistan, SMC may be wound-up by
small company tax rate is 20%. No specific tax rate is the relevance provision of the Companies Ordinance
found for SMC. of 1984.
6.13 Disputes: In Pakistan in case disputes arise
between the company and its management or 7.0 Issues to be addressed in
between the directors inter se, dispute shall be Bangladesh
resolved through mediator before going for formal Several issues need to be addressed in Bangladesh for
dispute resolution such as arbitration or litigation. No further enhancement of OPC growth. The turnover

33 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023
requirement is very high in Bangladesh, whereas there Chen, J. (2008). Clash of Corporate Personality Theories: A
Comparative Study of One-Member Company in Singapore and
is no requirement in Pakistan. The high turnover
China. Hong Kong Law Journal, 38, pp.425-452
requirement may slow down the ability of potential
Dang, R., and Sharma., N. (2015). One Person Company:
entrepreneurs to start OPC in Bangladesh. Provision Concept, Opportunities & Challenges in India. International
for appointment of more directors shall be introduced Journal for Research in Management and Pharmacy
so that flexibly for the owner remains for appointing 4(3) pp.1-4

directors in case of necessary. No minimum paid up Dey, P.K., (2018). One-Person Company a New Business
Opportunity in New Companies Act: A Panorama, International
capital requirement may also act as an impediment
Journal of Advance Research and Development. 3(3).
for the flourishment of OPC in Bangladesh. Some pp. 10-14
issues need to be addressed clearly, such as contract Income Tax Department India (2023), Domestic Company for AY-
with the member and OPC, Meeting notices, quorum 2022-2023, Income Tax DepartmentGovernmentofIndia,https://
of meetings, disputes between the company and www.incometax.gov.in/iec/foportal/help/company/return-
applicable.
management. The tax rate of OPC is 22.5% in
Income Tax Pariptra 2020-2023. Income Tax rate for 2022-2023,
Bangladesh. It was 25% in previous assessment year.
National Board of Revenue. https://nbr.gov.bd/uploads/
The government of Bangladesh may give some tax paripatra/Paripatra_2022-2023_.pdf, pp.1-6
benefit for OPC for the initial years after registration. Md Shakibuzzaman, ‘Evaluating the Prospects of One Person Company
Government should also address the governance in the Rising Entrepreneurial Scenario of Bangladesh’ (Bangladesh
issue so that OPC cannot be used as a vehicle for tax Law Digest, September 16, 2021)
evasion and money laundering. Miao, B. (2012). A Comparative Study of Legal Framework for Single
Member Company in European Union and China. Journal of
Politics and Law. 5 (3), pp 1-14.
8.0 Conclusion PWC Tax Summary Pakistan (2023). Corporate - Taxes on
One Person Company is initiated in Bangladesh corporate income –PWC Worldwide Tax Summary. https://
through the 2nd amendment 2020 under the taxsummaries.pwc.com/pakistan/corporate/taxes-on-
corporate-income
Companies Act 1994. Through this, the government
of Bangladesh are trying to attract many investors to
RJSC of Bangladesh, (2022). Recent Registration Statistics of RJSC,
invest more and more where they were frightened
https://roc.gov.bd/site/page/2f14b592-33c7-4931-b276-
by the liability of sole proprietorship business. e16b0a9ded0d/-Tessema, A. (2012) Comparative Single-Member
OPC has to less compliance burden in comparison Companies of Germany, France and England: A Recommendation
to others companies. After introduction of OPC to Ethiopia (December 22, 2012). Available at SSRN:
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2193070 or http://dx.doi
2020, company registered as OPC in Bangladesh till org/10.2139/ssrn.2193070
December 2022 is very low in number. If tax rate is
Verma., S (2021). A Critique on the Concept of One Person
reduced to an optimum level with more clarification in Companies, and its Relevance in Indian Entrepreneurship,
law introduced, then OPC will be a good option for International Journal of Law Management and Humanities,
local and international investors in Bangladesh. 5(2), pp. 771 - 791.

Relevant Act and Rules:


References The Companies Act 1994 of Bangladesh.
Ali, R. (2015). Whether the idea of Single Member Company
The companies Act 2nd amendment 2020 of Bangladesh.
(SMC), is a device to exploit and to avoid the corporate
liability by the Capitalist? A critical Analysis of Section 160 The Companies Act. 2013 of India.
of (Pakistan) Companies Ordinance, 1984, IALS Student Law Single Member Companies Rules, 2003 of Pakistan.
Review, 3 (1), pp. 3-6
Amendments in the Single Member Companies Rules 2015 of Pakistan.
Badri, H., Torkmalak, H., & Badri, M. (2014).
Investigating the Formation of Single Member
Company at the Act of England, Germany,
France and Iran. Scientific Journal of Pure
and Applied Sciences, 3(6), pp. 363-369.

34 THE COST AND MANAGEMENT


ISSN 1817-5090, VOLUME-51, NUMBER-02, MARCH-APRIL 2023

You might also like