Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2478/s11533-006-0022-9
Research article
CEJM 4(3) 2006 531–546
Abstract: In this paper some decompositions of Cauchy polynomials, Ferrers-Jackson polynomials and
polynomials of the form x2n + y 2n , n ∈ N, are studied. These decompositions are used to generate the
identities for powers of Fibonacci and Lucas numbers as well as for powers of the so called conjugate
recurrence sequences. Also, some new identities for Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind are presented
here.
c Versita Warsaw and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg. All rights reserved.
∗
d.slota@polsl.pl
532 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
and
n/3
2n n − k 2k
qn (x, y) = x y (x + y) (x2 + x y + y 2 )n−3k . (2)
k=0
n−k 2k
These decompositions are differ from those already published – see especially [13]. Also,
presented here proof of decompositions (1) and (2) by induction is based on a simple
recurrence dependence between polynomials pn (x, y) and qn (x, y) seems to be new. In
this paper, decompositions (1) and (2) are applied to generating the identities for powers
of Fibonacci and Lucas numbers (some of them – the simplest ones – are identical with the
identities discussed in [1, 6, 7]; also in [4] some of these simplest identities are presented).
In Sections 4 and 5 the notion of pairs and triples of conjugate recurrence sequences is
introduced. The identities for the powers of elements of such sequences are also derived.
In the last section of the paper, the following decomposition of polynomials: x2n +y 2n ,
n ∈ N is discussed:
n
x2n + y 2n = ωr,n · (x y)r · (x2 + x y + y 2 )n−r . (3)
r=0
The combinatorial and analytical descriptions of coefficients ωr,n are provided, in partic-
ular the analytical description where Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind are used.
Formula (3) is applied to generate some identities for the powers of Fibonacci and Lucas
numbers. Also, some new combinatorial identities for the Chebyshev polynomials of the
first kind are presented.
Publications concerning the identities of the sums of the powers of elements of recur-
rence sequences, (especially second order), are fairly recent [1–3, 5–11, 14]. The results
presented in the publications generally indicate two directions: generating formulas with
a bounded number of elements (our paper falls into this category) and generating formulas
with an increasing number of elements [6–9]. Some papers are focused on formulas for gen-
erating functions of sequences of the powers of elements of recurrence sequences [3, 5, 14],
as well as generating the identities by means of such functions. Other papers [10, 11]
discuss generalized forms of certain known identities (especially for Fibonacci and Lucas
numbers).
and
qn+1 (x, y) = u qn (x, y) + t pn−1 (x, y), (5)
Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546 533
etc.
n/3
2n n − k 2k
qn (x, y) = x y (x + y) (x2 + x y + y 2 )n−3k
k=0
n−k 2k
2n n − k
n/3
= t2k un−3k
k=0
n−k 2k
:= Wn (t, u), n = 1, 2, . . . (7)
where t := x y (x + y) and u := x2 + x y + y 2 .
534 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
Proof. The proof of Lemma (2.2) is followed by induction on n and by applied Lemma (2.1).
For example, we have
(n−1)/3
2n + 1 n − k 2n n − k
Vn+1 = u Vn + t Wn = + t2k+1 un−3k +
n − k 2k + 1 n − k 2k
k=0
2n n − k 2k+1 n−3k
+ t u =
k=n/3
n−k 2k
(only if 3|n)
(n−1)/3
(n − k)!(2n + 3) 2k+1 n−3k
= t u + 3t2k+1 un−3k =
k=0
(2k + 1)!(n − 3k)! k=n/3
(only if 3|n)
(n−1)/3
2n + 3 n − k + 1 2k+1 n−3k
= t u +
n − k + 1 2k + 1
k=0
2n + 3 n − k + 1 2k+1 n−3k
+ t u =
k=n/3
n − k + 1 2k + 1
(only if 3|n)
n/3
2n + 3 n − k + 1 2k+1 n−3k
= t u .
k=0
n − k + 1 2k + 1
The first six polynomials Vn (t, u) and Wn (t, u) are presented below:
n Vn (t, u) Wn (t, u)
1 3t 2u
2 5tu 2 u2
3 7 t u2 2 u3 + 3 t2
4 3 t (3 u3 + t2 ) 2 u4 + 8 t2 u
5 11 t u (u3 + t2 ) 2 u5 + 15 t2 u2
6 13 t u2 (u3 + 2 t2 ) 2 u6 + 24 t2 u3 + 3 t4
and
qk (x, y) = Wn (t, u), k ∈ N, (9)
for the values x, y which are Fibonacci and Lucas numbers with appropriately selected
indices. For example, we obtain the following formulas:
11
3 Ln+2 − L11 11
n − Ln+4 = 33 Ln Ln+2 Ln+4 8 L2n+4 + 11 (−1)
n
×
3 2
× 8 L2n+4 + 11 (−1)n + 3 Ln Ln+2 Ln+4 ,
and
13
13 13
Fn+2m − F2m Fn+1 − F2m−1 Fn =
2 2
= 13 F2m−1 F2m Fn Fn+1 Fn+2m Fn+2m + F2m−1 F2m Fn Fn+1 ×
2 3 2
× Fn+2m + F2m−1 F2m Fn Fn+1 + 2 F2m−1 F2m Fn Fn+1 Fn+2m .
The above mentioned identities, are discussed for the following values of arguments
(three nontrivial examples are given below):
a) for x = F2m Ln+4m+1 and y = F2m+1 Ln (n, m ∈ N0 ):
and for x = −F2m−1 Ln and y = Ln+2m (or x = −F2m−1 Ln and y = −F2m Ln+1 ,
n, m ∈ N0 ):
or equivalently: ⎧
⎪
⎪ a2 + b + 2 c − d = 0
⎪
⎪
⎨
⎪ b2 = c2 ⇔ c = ±b
⎪
⎪
⎪
⎩ d = a2 + 2 b + 2 c.
Now, let us suppose that the elements of recurrence sequences {xn } and {yn } satisfy
the conditions (10)–(12) for c = b and d = a2 + 4 b. Then the following eight identities
could be derived (more precisely 3 × 8 = 24 new identities if we count the additional
identities for t and u):
a) for x = xn+2 and y = b xn :
2k+1 2k+1
yn+1 − xn+2 − (b xn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
2
where t = b xn+2 yn+1 xn and u = yn+1 − b xn xn+2 ;
b) for x = yn+2 and y = b yn :
2 2k+1 2k+1
(a + 4b) xn+1 − yn+2 − (b yn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = b (a2 + 4 b) yn xn+1 yn+2 and u = (a2 + 4 b)2 x2n+1 − b yn yn+2 ;
c) for x = (a2 + 4 b) xn and y = a yn :
(2 yn+1 )2k+1 − (a yn )2k+1 − ((a2 + 4 b) xn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = 2 a (a2 + 4 b) xn yn yn+1 and u = (2 yn+1 )2 − a (a2 + 4 b) xn yn ;
d) for x = a xn and y = yn :
(2 xn+1 )2k+1 − (a xn )2k+1 − yn2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = 2 a xn yn xn+1 and u = (2 xn+1 )2 − a xn yn ;
e) for x = zn+3 , y = −a b zn and z ∈ {x, y}:
((a2 + b) zn+1 )2k+1 − zn+3
2k+1
+ (a b zn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = −a b (a2 + b) zn zn+1 zn+3 and u = ((a2 + b) zn+1 )2 + a b zn zn+3 ;
f) for x = a zn+3 , y = b2 zn and z ∈ {x, y}:
((a2 + b) zn+2 )2k+1 − (a zn+3 )2k+1 − (b2 zn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = a b2 (a2 + b) zn zn+2 zn+3 and u = ((a2 + b) zn+2 )2 − a b2 zn zn+3 ;
g) for x = yn+1 and y = −a xn+1 :
(2 b xn )2k+1 − yn+1
2k+1
+ (a xn+1 )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = −2 a b xn xn+1 yn+1 and u = (2 b xn )2 + a xn+1 yn+1 ;
h) for x = (a2 + 4 b) xn+1 and y = −a yn+1 :
(2 b yn )2k+1 − ((a2 + 4 b) xn+1 )2k+1 + (a yn+1 )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
where t = −2 a b (a2 + 4 b) yn xn+1 yn+1 and u = (2 b yn )2 + a (a2 + 4 b) xn+1 yn+1 .
538 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
for every w ∈ {x, y, z} and n ∈ N and suppose that the following conjugate conditions
are satisfied
xn+2 + A xn = yn+1 (14)
yn+2 + A yn = zn+1 (15)
zn+2 + A zn = B xn+1 (16)
for every n ∈ N. Then the natural condition:
−a A9 + 3 A8 + 3 a A6 + 3 A5 + 6 a2 A4 + (a4 − 3 a) A3 + 3 A2 + a = 0.
Proof. Apply to equality (16) identities (15), (14) and (13) for w = x we obtain the
identity
which implies ⎧
⎪
⎪ −b A3 + 3 A + a2 + b = 0
⎪
⎪
⎨
⎪ B = (1 + a b) (1 + A3 )
⎪
⎪
⎪
⎩ (b2 − a) A3 + 3 A2 + a = 0.
Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546 539
Corollary 5.2. If elements of sequences {xn }, {yn } and {zn } satisfy conditions (13)–
(16) then the following identities hold true (only three identities – generalizations of the
identities from Section 3 are presented below):
a) for x = xn+2 and y = A xn :
2k+1 2k+1
yn+1 − xn+2 − (A xn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
2
where t = A xn+2 yn+1 xn and u = yn+1 − A xn xn+2 ;
b) for x = yn+2 and y = A yn :
2k+1 2k+1
zn+1 − yn+2 − (A yn )2k+1 = Vk (t, u),
2
where t = A yn xn+1 yn+2 and u = zn+1 − A yn yn+2 ;
c) for x = zn+2 and y = A zn :
The following identity relates to decompositions (6) and (7) and shall be used to generate
a set of the identities for the powers of Fibonacci and Lucas numbers.
1 1
ω0,n = 1, ω1,n = −n, ω2,n = n(n − 3), ω3,n = − n(n − 2)(n − 7),
2 6
1 1
ω4,n = n(n − 3)(n2 − 15n + 38), ω5,n = − n(n − 3)(n − 4)(n − 6)(n − 17).
24 5!
where Ωn (x) := 2Tn (x/2) is the so called: modified Chebyshev polynomial of the first
kind (see [16] where many interesting properties of these polynomials are discussed).
x8 + x4 y 4 + y 8 = (x2 + xy + y 2 )4 − 4xy(x2 + xy + y 2 )3 +
+ 2x2 y 2 (x2 + xy + y 2 )2 + 4x3 y 3 (x2 + xy + y 2 )
3
= 3(x2 + xy + y 2 )4 − 2 (x2 + kxy + y 2 ), (18)
k=0
10 5 5 10
x +x y +y = (x + xy + y ) − 5xy(x2 + xy + y 2 )4 +
2 2 5
Remark 6.4. The identities generated in Corollary 6.3 bring to mind easily verifiable
divisibility relations. Accordingly, for each n ∈ N, 3 | n, there is a polynomial pn ∈
Z[x, y], such as:
2
4n
pn (x, y) x2 + k x y + y 2 = 3 x 2 + x y + y 2 − x8n − (x y)4n − y 8n . (21)
k=0
Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546 541
Proof. We have
x2 + y 2 = 0 ⇐⇒ y = ±i x
and then we get
4n
3 x2 + x y + y 2 − x8n − (x y)4n − y 8n =
4n
= 3 ± i x2 − x8n − (±i x2 )4n − (±i x)8n = 0.
Now, we have
⎧
⎪
⎨ x3 − y 3 = 0,
x2 + x y + y 2 = 0 ⇐⇒ ⇐⇒ y = x exp ± i 23 π .
⎪
⎩ x − y = 0,
Hence, we obtain:
4n
3 x2 + x y + y 2 − x8n − (x y)4n − y 8n =
= −x8n 1 + exp ± i 83 n π + exp ± i 163
n π =
= −x8n 1+(−1)n exp ∓i n3π +(−1)n exp ±i n3π = −x8n 1+2 (−1)n cos n3π =
(but cos n3π = (−1)n−1 /2 whenever 3 | n)
= −x8n 1 + (−1)2n−1 = 0.
Moreover, we get
2 4n
2
3 x + xy + y −x 8n
− (x y) 4n
−y 8n =0
y=−x
and
∂ 2
2 4n 8n 4n
8n
3 x + xy + y − x − (x y) − y = 0.
∂x y=−x
2
542 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
5 5
2 L2n+2 + (−1)n − L10
n − Ln Ln+1 − L10
n+1 =
= 125 Ln Ln+1 L2n+2 F2n+1
2
2 L2n+2 + (−1)n ;
5 5
2 L2n+2 − (−1)n − 55 Fn10 + Fn Fn+1 + Fn+1
10
=
= 55 Fn Fn+1 Fn+2
2 2
F2n+1 2 L2n+2 − (−1)n ;
7 7
4 L2n+2 − Ln Ln+3 − L14
n − Ln Ln+3 − L14 2
n+3 = 280 Ln Ln+3 Ln+2 ×
2 2 3
2
× F2n+3 4 Ln+2 − Ln Ln+3 100 F2n+3 4 Ln+2 − Ln Ln+3 + Ln Ln+3 ;
2
7 7
4 Fn+2 − Fn14 − Fn Fn+3 − Fn+3
− Fn Fn+3 14
=
2 3
2 2 2
= 56 Fn Fn+3 Fn+2 F2n+3 4 Fn+2 − Fn Fn+3 4 F2n+3 4 Fn+2 − Fn Fn+3 + Fn Fn+3 .
Remark 6.5. The coefficients ωr,n from Lemma 6.1 for the values of r near to n are
related to Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind Tn (x) = cos(n arccos x), x ∈ [−1, 1]
(see [12, 15]), because the following lemma holds:
Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546 543
Corollary 6.7. By differentiating the identity (23) for x ∈ (−1, 1) we obtain the following
formulas:
(n−1)/2
n sin(n arccos x) kn− 2k n − k
Tn (x) = √ =n (−1) (2x)n−2k−1 , (24)
1 − x2 k=0
n−k k
etc.
1 1 2√ 2 m−1
k m− k 2m− k
ωm−1,m = T2m 2 = 3m sin 3 πm = 2m (−1) ; (29)
2 3 k=0
2m− k k
√ n/2−1
1 1 n2 π 3 π 1 n− k n− 2k
T = − cos n 3 + n sin n 3 = n (−1)k
;
4 n 2 3 9 k=0
n− k k 2
(30)
√
1 1 1 1 1 m2 2 3
ωm−2,m = T2m 2 − T2m 2 = − cos 3 πm − m sin 23 πm =
4 4 2 3 9
m−2
l 2m 2m − l m − l
= (−1) ; (31)
l=0
2m − l l 2
544 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
1 1 4√ 4
T2m 2 = 3m(1 − 2m2 ) sin 23 πm − m2 cos 23 πm =
24 27 9
m−2
k 2m 2m − k 2m − 2k
= (−1) ; (32)
k=0
2m − k k 3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
ωm−3,m = T2m 2 − 4 ωm−2,m = T − T2m 2 + T2m 2 =
8 24 8 24 2m 2 4 2
1√ 1
= 3m(2 − m2 ) sin 23 πm + m2 cos 23 πm =
27 9
m−3
l 2m 2m − l m − l
= (−1) . (33)
l=0
2m − l l 3
Moreover, from identities (24)-(26) it is possible to generate the following identities
between the derivatives of Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind.
Tn (x) T (x) T (x) Tn (x)
n−3
− 2 (3 n − 3) n n−2 + 4 (3 n2 − 3 n + 1) n n−1 − 8 n3 =
(2x) (2x) (2x) (2x)n
n/2
3
k k n−k
= −32 n (−1) (2x)−2k , (36)
k=1
n − k k
and the following general formula hold:
l (l−k) n/2
Tn (x) 2l−1 k+l k
l
n−k
k
(−2) pk,l (n) =2 n (−1) (2x)−2k , (37)
k=0
(2x) n−l+k
k=1
n − k k
where
p0,l (n) = 1, pl,l (n) = nl ,
pk+1,l+1 (n) = (n − l + k) pk,l (n) + pk+1,l (n), k = 0, 1, . . . , l − 1.
Hence, for x = 12 we get the following identities:
√ n/2
π 3 π k n−k
cos n − sin n = (−1) k
, (38)
3 3 3 k=1
n−k k
√ n/2 2
n π 3 π k k n−k
cos n − (3n − 2) sin n = (−1) , (39)
3 3 9 3 k=1
n−k k
√ n/2 3
n π 3 2 π k k n−k
cos n − (2n − 3n + 2) sin n = (−1) . (40)
3 3 9 3 k=1
n − k k
Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546 545
Remark 6.9. Because the derivatives of polynomials Tn (x) are recurrently related [12]:
References
[1] L. Carlitz and J.A.H. Hunter: “Sums of Powers of Fibonacci and Lucas Numbers”,
Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 7, (1969), pp. 467–473.
[2] A.F. Horadam: “Basic properties of a certain generalized sequence of numbers”,
Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 3, (1965), pp. 161–176.
[3] A.F. Horadam: “Generating functions for powers of a certain generalised sequence
of numbers”, Duke Math. J., Vol. 32, (1965), pp. 437–446.
[4] T. Koshy: Fibonacci and Lucas Numbers with Applications, Wiley, New York, 2001.
[5] T. Mansour: “A formula for the generating functions of powers of Horadam’s se-
quence”, Australas. J. Combin., Vol. 30, (2004), pp. 207–212.
[6] R.S. Melham: “Sums of Certain Products of Fibonacci and Lucas Numbers – Part I”,
Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 37, (1999), pp. 248–251.
[7] R.S. Melham: “Families of Identities Involving Sums of Powers of the Fibonacci and
Lucas Numbers”, Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 37, (1999), pp. 315–319.
[8] R.S. Melham: “Sums of Certain Products of Fibonacci and Lucas Numbers – Part II”,
Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 38, (2000), pp. 3–7.
[9] R.S. Melham: “Alternating Sums of Fourth Powers of Fibonacci and Lucas Num-
bers”, Fibonacci Quart., Vol. 38, (2000), pp. 254–259.
[10] J. Morgado: “Note on some results of A.F. Horadam and A.G. Shannon concern-
ing a Catalan’s identity on Fibonacci Numbers”, Portugal. Math., Vol. 44, (1987),
pp. 243–252.
546 Roman Witula, Damian Slota / Central European Journal of Mathematics 4(3) 2006 531–546
[11] J. Morgado: “Note on the Chebyshev polynomials and applications to the Fibonacci
numbers”, Portugal. Math., Vol. 52, (1995), pp. 363–378.
[12] S. Paszkowski: Numerical Applications of Chebyshev Polynomials and Series, PWN,
Warsaw, 1975 (in Polish).
[13] P. Ribenboim: Fermat’s Last Theorem For Amateurs, Springer, New York 1999.
[14] J. Riordan: “Generating functions for powers of Fibonacci numbers”, Duke Math. J.,
Vol. 29, (1962), pp. 5–12.
[15] T. Rivlin: Chebyshev Polynomials from Approximation Theory to Algebra and Num-
ber Theory, 2nd ed., Wiley, New York, 1990.
[16] R. Witula and D. Slota: “On Modified Chebyshev Polynomials”, J. Math. Anal.
Appl., (2006), in print.