Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Panchayati Raj
Te term Panchayati Raj in India signifies the 3. All planning and development activities should
sstem of rural local self-government. It has be entrusted to these bodies.
been established in all the states of India by 4. The panchayat samiti should be the executive
zÁis of the state legislatures to build democracy body while the zila parishad should be the
t grass root level'. It is entrusted with rural advisory, coordinating and supervisory body.
sdlbgment. It was constitutionalised through the 5. The district collector should be the chairman
Constitutional Amendment Act of 1992. of the zila parishad.
6. There should be a genuine transfer of power
NUTION OF PANCEHAYATI RAJ and responsibility to these democratice bodies.
7. Adequate resources should be transferred to
ant Rai Mehta these bodies to enable them to discharge their
Committee
ary 1957, the Government of India
functions and fulfil their responsibilities.
8. A system should be evolved to effect further
examine the working of the appointed
Community
a
devolution of authority in future.
opment
Sion Programme (1952) and the National
Service (1953) and to suggest measures for
These recommendations of the committee were
accepted by the National Development Council in
BdiMiwannt working.
Rai G
The chairman of this committee
Mebta, The committee submitted
January 1958. The council did not insist on a single
rigid pattern and left it to the states to evolve their
nent ofNove
thember 1957of and recommended the es-
But the
own patterns suitable to local conditions.
should be
wtheich schemecame to'democratic decentralisa- basic principles and broad fundamentals
sEsapbelciuisflhitcimemantTecommendat
ely ionsknownmade byPanchayati
be as
t of athree-tier panchayati raj
it are:
identical throughout the country.
Rajasthan was the tirst state to establish
chayati Raj. The scheme was inaugurated
Pan
by the
sVayarsuiscehhmaayd-atgramtSamiti
be at
panchayat
at the
at the block level and zila
he district level.
level,
village Rajasthan was followed by Andhra
also adopted the system in 1959,
Nagaur district.
prime minister on October 2, 1959, in Pradesh, which
Thereafter, most of
itIheectorgelaneicicailoyns. linked
These tiers should
through a device of in- the states adopted the system. created panchayati raj
Though most of the states
he vdiliargescy panchayat
with should be constituted institutions by mid 1960s, there
were differences
to the number
elsamiti
ected representatives, with regard
three
so on. Por exampl, Rajasthan adopted thetwo-tier panchayats, that is,
ticr system while Tamil Nadu adopted the
judicial panchayats to
eivil and criminal cases.
Nystem West Bengal, on the other hand, adopted the
tour ier Nystem Futher. in the Rajasthan Andhra Study Teams and Committees
Pradesh pattern, anchayat samiti was powertul as
the blxk waN the unit of planning and development. Since 1960, many study
while in Maharashtra Gujarat puttern, zila parishad working groups have beenteams, commit eees and
was powertul as the distriet was the unit of planning appomted
the various aspects of functioning
and development.Some states also established nyaya system. They are mentioned
below inPanchay at Ra
Table 38 |
Table 38.1 Study Teams and Committees on Panchayati Raj
Name ef the study Team /Commitee Chairman
1960 Committee on Rationalisation of Panchayat Statistics V.R. Rav
1961 Working Group on Panchayats and Cooperatives S.D. Mishra
1961 Study Team on Panchayati Raj Administration V. lswaran
1962 Study Team on Nyaya Panchayats
a
G.R. Rajgopal
1963 Study Tcam on the Position of Gram Sabha in Panchayati Raj Movement R.R. Diwakar
1963 Study Group on Budgeting and
Raj Institutions
Accounting Procedure of Panchayati M. Rama
Krishnayya
1963 Study Team on Panchayati Raj Finances K. Santhanam
1965 Committee on Panchayati Raj Elections K. Santhanam
9 1965 Study Team on the Audit and Accounts of Panchayati Raj R.K. Khanna
10.
Bodies
11
1966Committee on Panchayati Raj Training Centres G. Ramachandran
1969 Study Team on Involvement of Community V. Ramunathan
and Panchayati Raj Institutions in the Development Agency
Reform Measures Implementation of Basic Land
12. 1972 Working Group for Formulation of Fifth Five Year Plan on Community N, Ramakrishnayvd
Development and Panchayati Raj
13. 1976 Smt. Daya ('houbv
Commitee on Community Development and Panchayati Raj
Ashok Mehta Committee populationof
villages with a total dxt
In December 1977, the tr
Janata
u committee on panchayati rajGovernment appointed
20,000.
first
poim
institutions under the 2. A district should be the SupervisIOD
chairmanship of Ashok Mehta. It submitted its
in August 1978 and made 132 report tralisation under popular CNCCUiets
revive and strengthen the decliningrecommendations to state level. distr
I9) The dscai trsbunals shnid be established conatituled in 1988 by theGadgil. Thus howb
the chairmanship of V.N, question of cltetive
eiectisn u» the Parhayats Kaj ifitulkns, Was askcd us consider thecould be made
Panchayati Raj institutions
38.6 Indian Polity
Hanumantha Rao Committee Report on District their dissolution and othher matters
Planning (1984). Both the committees have sug their functioning.
gested that the basicdecentralised planning function related to
should be done at the district level. The Hanumantha Thungon Committee
Rao Committee advocated separate district planning
bodies under either the District Collector or a minis In 1988, a sub-committee of the
ter. In both the models, the Collector should play a mittee of Parliament was
constituted Consultative
Com-
significant role in the decentralised planning though manship of P.K. Thungon to examineunder the chair.
the political
and administrative structure in the district
the Committee stated that Panchayati Raj institutions for th.
would also be associated with this process (of decen purpose of district planning. This
tralised planning). The committee recommended that gested for the strengthening of the commi t ee sug-Ra
Panchayati
the Collector should be the coordinator, at the district System. It made the following recommendations
1. The Panchayati Raj bodies should be const.
level, of all developmental and planning activities.
Thus the, Hanumantha Rao Committee differed in tutionally recognized.
this respect from those of Balwantray Mehta Com 2. A three-tier system of Panchayati Raj wih
mittee, the Administrative Reforms Commission of panchayats at the village. block and distrit
levels.
India, the Ashok Mehta Committee and finally the
G.V.K. Rao Committee which recommended reduc 3. Zilla Parishad should be the pivot of the Par
tion in the developmental role of the District Collec chayatiRaj system. It should act as the plar
tor and which assigned a major role to the Panchayati ning and development agency in the district.
Raj in development administration. 4. The Panchayati Raj bodies should have afixed
tenure of five years.
LM Singhvi Committee 5. The maximum period of super session of 3
body should be six months.
In 1986, Rajiv Gandhigovernment appointed a com 6. A planning and co-ordination committet
mittee to prepare a concept paper on 'Revitalisation should be set-up at the state level under the
of Panchayati Raj Institutions for Democracy and chairmanship of the minister for plann1ng
Development' under the chairmanship of L M Sing The presidents of Zilla Parishads should be
hvi. It made the following recommendations. its members.
Ray
(i) The Panchayati Raj institutions should be 7. Adetailed list of subjects for Panchayati the
constitutionally recognised, protected and pre incorporatedin
and
should be prepared
served. For this purpose, a new chapter should Constitution. should
be added in the Constitution of India. This will 8. Reservation of seats in allthethree-tiers
There
should
make their identity and integrity reasonably be on the basis of population.
and substantially inviolate. It also suggested also be reservation for women. set-up
constitutional provisions to ensure regular, free should be
9. A statefinance commission down the criterd
and fair elections to the Panchayati Raj bodies. in each state. It would lay finances
of
(ii) Nyaya Panchayats should be established for a and guidelines for the devolution
cluster of villages. to the Panchayati Raj institutions. chiefex-
the
(iii) The villages should be reorganised to make 10. The district collector should be
Gram Panchayats more viable. It also empha
sised the importance of the Gram Sabha and Ccutive officer off the Zilla Parishad.
called it as the embodiment of direct democracy.
(iv) The Village Panchayats should have more Gadgil Committee Programmes
partyunder
financial resources.
The Committee on Policy and Thiscommittee
() The judicial tribunals should be established constituted in l988 by the Congress best
in each state to adjudicate controversies about
election to the Panchayati Raj institutions, the chairmanship of V.N. Gadgil. "how
question of etBècive"
was asked to consider the
Panchayati Raj institutions could be made
PanchayatiRaj S.7
la this context,
the committee made the following panchayati raj inatitutiona. In June 1990, a two day
NOmmcdations ; conference of the state chief mininters under the
L Aconstitutional status should be bestowed on chaimanship of VP Singh was held to diseusN the
the Panchayati Raj institutions, 0ssues relating to the strengthening of the panchayati
Athrve-tier system of Panchayati Raj wvith raj hodies. The conterence approved the proponals
panchayats at the village, blo¢k and district for the introduetion of a fresh constitutional amend
levels. ment bill, Consequently, a constitutional amendment
3. The term of Panchayati Raj institutions should bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha in September
he fixed at tive years. 1990. However, the tall of the government resulted
4 The menmbers of the Panchayats at allthe three in the lapse of the bill.
levels should be directly elected. Narasimha Rao Government The CongresN
$. Reservation for SCs, STN and women. Government under the prime ministership of P
6The Panchayati Raj bodies should have the VNarasimha Rao once again considercd the mat
responsibility of preparation and implementa ter of'the constitutionalisation of panchayati raj
tion of plans for socio-economic development. bodies. t drastically moditied the proposala in this
For this purpose, a list of subjects should be regard to delete the controversial aspectN and intro
specified in the constitution. duced a constitutional amendment bill in the Lok
7. The Panchayat Raj bodies should be empow Sabha in September, 1991, This bill tinally emerged
ered to levy, collect and appropriate taxes and As the 73rd ConstitutionalAmendment Act, 1992 and
duties. came into force on 24 April, 1993,
8. Establishment of a State Finance Commis
sion for the allocation of finances to the
Panchayats. 73RD AMENDMENT AcT OF 1992
9. Establishment of a State Election Commis
sion for the conduction of clections to the Significance of the Act
panchayats.
The above recommendations of the Gadgil Com This act has added a new Part-IX to the Constitution
mtiee became the basis for drafting an amendment of India. This part is entitled as "The Punchayats' and
Oll aimed at conferring the constitutional status and consists of provisions trom Articles 243 to 243 0.
In addition, the act has also added a new Eleventh
protection the Panchayati Raj institutions. Schedule to the Constitution. This nehedule vontains
29 tunctional items of the panchayats. It deals with
Const itutionalisation
Rajiv Gandhi Government The Rajiv Gandhi
Articlo 243-0.
The act has given u practical shape to Artiele
40 of the Constitution which Nays that, "The State
Government Biintroduced
Anendment the 64h Constitutional
l in the Lok Sabha in July 1989 o whall tako steps to organise village panchayats und
endowthem with sueh poworn and authority as may
constitutionalise
panchayati raj institutions and
tthehem more powerful
Lok and broad based. Although,
make be tecessury lo euable them to tmctin as units of
Nelf-govemment." This article loma a part of the
Directive Principles otf Stale Policy.
Was not Sabha passed the bill in August 1989, it
"The act gives a constitutional ntatus to the pan
Was approved by the Rajya Sabha. The bill
vehenmently
grhe ofederal opposed by the Opposition on the
und that system.
it sought to strengthen centralisation in
chayatiraj institutions It has brought them under the
purview of the justiiable part of the Constitution, In
other words, the stale goverments are under const
VP Slngh tutional obligation to adopt the new panchayati eaj
Government The National Front Gov- Nystem in acoordanwe with the provisons of the at.
rmment,so n
\989 under the Prime Ministership of VPSingh,
afler aSsuming office in November
Minounced that it would take steps lo slrengthenthe
Consequently, ucither the lormation of panchayata
nor the holding of elections at regular intervalx de.
pendon the willof the state governmentany more.
hatient Feate
anylaw made by the state legislature. However, no 1. The principles that should govern:
personshall be disqualified on the ground that he is (a) The distribution between the state and
less than 25 years of age if he has attained the age
the panchayats of the net proceeds of the
f 2vears. Further, allquestions of disqualifica taxes, duties, tolls and fees levied by the
rions shall be referred to such authority as the state state.
legislature determines. (b) The determination of taxes, duties, tolls
State Election Commission The superinten and fees that may be assigned to the
dence. direction and control of the preparation of panchayats.
electoral rolls and the conduct of all elections to the (c) The grants-in-aid to the panchayats from
the consolidated fund of the state.
panchavats shall be vested in the state election com
mission. It consists of a state election commissioner 2. The measures needed to improve the financial
to be appointed by the governor. His conditions of position of the panchayats.
service and tenure of office shall also be determined 3. Any other matter referred to it by the gover
nor in the interests of sound finance of the
by the governor. He shall not be removed from the
panchayats.
ofice except in the manner and on the grounds pre The state legislature may provide for the composi
scribed for the removal of a judge of the state high tion of the commission, the required qualifications
court. His conditions of service shall not be varied of its members and the manner of their selection.
to his disadvantage after his appointment. The governor shall place the recommendations of
The state legislature may make provision with the commission along with the action taken report
respect to all matters relating to elections to the before the state legislature.
panchayats. The Central Finance Commission shall also
Powers and Functions The state legislature may suggest the measures needed to augment the con
endow the Panchayats with such powers and author solidated fund of a state to supplement the resources
ty as may be necessary to enable them to function as of the panchayats in the states (on the basis of the
Institutions of self-government. Such a scheme may recommendations made by the finance commission
contain provisions for the devolution of powers and of the state).
responsibilities upon Panchayats at the appropriate Audit of Accounts The state legislature may
level with respect to (a) the preparation of plans for make provisions with respect to the maintenance
cCOnomic development and social justice; (b) the of accounts by the panchayats and the auditing of
Impiementation of schemes for economic develop such accounts.
ment and social ijustice as may be entrusted to them,
Application to Union Territories The presi
including those in relationto the 29
the Eleventh Schedule. matters listed in
dent of India may direct that the provisions of this
act shall apply to any union territory subject to such
Finances
a
The state legislature may (a) authorise exceptions and modifications as he may specify.
panchayat
duties, to
tolls and levy,
collect and appropriate taxes,
Exempted States and Areas The act does not
duties, tolls and fees; (b) assign to a panchayat taxes,
fees levied and collected by the state apply to the states of Jammu and Kashmir, Nagaland,
gover
he nment; (c) provide forconsolidated
panchayats from the
making grants-in-aid to
fund of the
Meghalaya and Mizoram and certain other areas.
These areas include, (a)the scheduled areas and the
state; and (d) provide for constitution of funds for tribal areas in the states'; (b)the hill area of Manipur
crediting al moneys of the panchayats. for which a district council exists; and (c) Darjeeling
district of West Bengal for which Darjeeling Gorkha
Finance
shall, Commission The governor of astate HillCouncil exists.
after every five years, constitute a finance However, the Parliament may extend the provi
commis ion to review the financial position of the sions of this Part to the scheduled areas and tribal
panachayats. Governor:
dations to the It shall make the following recommen- areas subject to such exceptions and modifications
as it may specify.
Indian Polity
38.10
Laws and Pan 13. Roads, culverts, bridges,
Continuance of Existing ferries,
chayats Allthe state laws
relating to panchayats
expiry of one
until the
other means of communication
14. Rural electrification,
including
waterways and
shallcontinue to be in force
year from the
commencement of this act. In other
the new panchayati
electricity
15. Non-conventional energy sources distribution
words, the states have to adoptwithin the maximum 16. Poverty alleviation programme
raj system based on this act 17. Education, including primary and second
1993, which was
period of one year from 24 April, However,
schools
the date of the commencement of this act. 18. Technical training and vOcational education
before the
allthe panchayats existing immediately expiry 19. Adult and non-formal education
commencement of act shall continue till the 20. Libraries
of their term, unless dissolved by the state legisla 21. Cultural activities
ture sooner.
22. Markets and fairs
ConsequentBy, majority of states passed the pan
chayati raj acts in 1993 and 1994 to adopt the new 23. Health and sanitation including hospitals, an:
system in accordance with the 73rd Constitutional mary health centres and dispensaries
Amendment Act of 1992. 24. Family welfare
25. Women and child development
Bar to Interference by Courts in Electoral 26. Social welfare, including welfare of the hand:
Matters The act bars the interference by courts in capped and mentally retarded
the electoral matters of panchayats. It declares that 27. Welfare of the weaker sections, and in particl
the validity of any law relating to the delimitation lar, of the scheduled castes and the scheduled
of constituencies or the allotment of seats to such tribes
constituencies cannot be questioned in any court. It 28. Public distribution system
further lays down that no election to any 29. Maintenance of community assets.
is to be questioned except by an electionpanchayat
petition
presented to such authority and in such manner as
provided by the state legislature. CoMPULSORY AND VOLUNTARY PPROVISIONS
compulso
Eleventh Schedule It contains the following the (ds:e
Now, we will identify separatelyvoluntary
29 functional items
placed within the purview of (obligatory or mandatory) and(features) oft t
panchayats: tionary or optional) provisions (1992) orthePart
1. Agriculture,
including
improvement, agricultural extension
2. Land Constitutional Amendment Act
implementation
forms, land consolidation and soil
of land re of the Constitution:
3. Minor irigation, water conservation
shed development management and water A. Compulsory Provisions Village
4. Animal Sabha in a
5. Fisherieshusbandry, dairying and 1. Organisation of Gram
6. Social
poultry group of villages. the
it
villae,
toprvataeuthorlaixes,
zing dutthemies, tollsto levy,and fees.
collect and The
are as follows:
state legislation on the Panchayats in the
1. A consonance with
Scheduled Areas shall be in religious prac
0F soçial and
1996 (ExTENSION Acr)
the customary law, management practices of
tices andtraditional
community resources.
he of Part
IX of the constitution relat- a habita
ordinarily consist ofhamlet
P1SainoncshayHoats wsuchever,
areas
o
are not applicable to the Fifth
the Parliament may extend
2. A village
tion or
a group
a
shall
group
of
of
hamlets
habitations or a
comprising a community
or
accordance with
m
he Tications asareas,it maysubject to such excep-
specify. Underthis and managing its atlairs in
traditions and customs.
P'arliament has enacted the *Provisions
Panchayati Raj 38.1|
6. Reservation of seats (both members and chair of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas)
persons) for SCs and STs in panchayats at all Act", 1996, popularly known as the PESA Actor the
the three levels. Extension Act.
7. Reservation of one-third seats (both members At present (2016), ten states have Fifth Sched
and chairpersons) for women in panchayats ule Areas. These are: Andhra Pradesh. Telangana,
at all the three levels.
Chhatisgarh,Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand.
8. Fixing tenure of five years for panchayats at all Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha and Ra
levels and holding fresh elections within six jasthan. All the ten states have enacted requisite
months in the event of supersession of any compliance legislations by amending the respective
panchayat. Panchayati Raj Acts.
9. Establishment of a State Election Commission
for conducting elections to the panchayats.
10. Constitution of a State Finance Commission Objectives of the Act
after every five years to review the financial The objectives of the PESA Act are as follows°:
position of the panchayats. 1. To extend the provisions of Part IX of the
Constitution relating to the panchayats to the
B. Voluntary Provisions scheduled areas with certain modifications
1. Giving representation to members of the Parlia 2. To provide self-rule for the bulk of the tribal
population
ment (both the Houses) and the state legislature 3. To have village governance with participa
(both the Houses) in the panchayats at different tory democracy and to make the gram sabha
levels faling within their constituencies. a nucleus of all activities
2. Providing reservation of seats (both members 4. Toevolve a suitable administrative framework
and chairpersons) for backward classes in consistent with traditional practices
panchayats at any level. 5. To safeguard and to preserve the traditions and
3. Granting powers and authority to the panchayats customs of tribal communities
to enable them to function as institutions of 6. To empower panchayats at the appropriate
self-government (in brief, making them au levels with specific powers conducive to tribal
tonomous bodies). requirements
4. Devolution of powers and responsibilities upon 7. To prevent panchayats at the higher level trom
panchayats to prepare plans for economic de assuming the powers and authority of pan
velopment and social justice; and to perform chayats at the lower level of the gram sabha
Some or all of the 29 functions listed in the
Eleventh Schedule of the Constitution. Features of the Act
5. Granting financial powers to the pachayats,
The features (or the provisions) of the PESA Act
tnat is, authorizing them to levy, collect and
appropriate taxes, duties, tolls and fees. are as tollows:
1. A state legislation on the Panchayats in the
Scheduled Areas shallbe in consonançe with
PESA ACT OF 1996 (ExrENSION Acr) the customary law, social and religious prac
tices and traditional management practices of
The
provisions
ing to the
of Part IX of the constitution relat- community resources.
Panchayats
Schedule areas.
are not applicable to the Fifth
However, the Parliament may extend
2. Avillage shall ordinarily consist of a habita
tion or a group of habitations or a hamlet or
these provisions to such areas, subject to such excep- a group of hamlets comprising a community
tions and and managing its affairs in accordance with
provision, modifications as it
the Parliament has
may specify. Under this
enacted the "Provisions traditions and customs.
Indian Polity
38.12
consist 11. The recommendations of the
village shall have a Gram Sabha the Panchayats at the Gram Sabha o
3. Everv whose names are
included in the
appropriate level
ing of persons
at the village be mandatory for grant of shall
electoralrolls for the Panchayat or mining lease for minorprospecting
minerals \icencethe
In
level. Scheduled Areas.
shall be competent to safe
4, Every Gram Sabha traditions and customs 12. The prior recommendation of the
guard and preserve thecultural identity, com or the Panchayats at the appropriateGram Sabha
of the people, their leervel
munityresources and the
customary mode of
be mandatory for grant of
concession forshali
exploitation of minor minerals by
13. While endowing Panchayats in the auction.
dispute resolution,
Areas with such powers and authoritySchedul ed
shall-
§ Every Gram Sabha and proj
(i) approve of the plans, programmes as may
ects for social and economic development be necessary to enable them to function a
before they are taken up for implementa institutions of self-government, a State Leg.
tion by the Panchayat at the village level; islature shall ensure that the Panchayats at
and the appropriate level and the Gram Sabha ar.
(ü) be responsible for the identification of endowed specifically with
beneficiaries under the poverty alleviation (i) the power to enforce prohibition or to regu
and other programmes. late or restrict the sale and consumption
6. Every Panchayat at the village level shall be of any intoxicant
required to obtain from the Gram Sabha a cer
tification of utilisation of funds for the above (ii) the ownership of minor forest produce
plans. programmes and projects. (iii) the power to prevent alienation of land in
The reservation of seats in the Scheduled Areas the Scheduled Areas and to take appro
in every Panchayat shall be in proportion to priate action to restore any unlawtully
the population of the communities for whom alienated land ofa Scheduled Tribe
reservation is sought to be given under Part IX markets
of the Constilution. However, the reservation (iv) the power to manage village over money
exercise control
for the Scheduled Tribes shall not be less than (V) the power to
one-half of the total number of seats. Further, lending to the Scheduled Tribes Institu-
control over
al! seats of Chairpersons of Panchayats at all (vi) the power to exercise all social sectors
in
ievels shall be reserved for the Scheduled tions and functionaries re- and
Tribes. local plans
8. The state government may nominate such
(vii) the power to control including tribal
sources for such plans
Scheduied Tribes which have no representation satteguards
in the Panchayat at the intermediate level or sub-plans
shall containhigherlevel
the Panchayat at the district level. But such 14. The State Legislations at the any
Bomination shall not exceed one-tenth of the to ensure that Panchayats of
and authority Grun
Lotal members to be elected in that Panchayat. do not assume the
powers
ofthe
9. The Gram Sabha or the Panchayats at the ap level or
propriate level shall be consulted before mak Panchayat at thelower fol
Sabha. endeavourto
ing the acquisition of land in the Scheduled shall Schedulelothe
Areas for development projects and before 15. The State Legislature Sixth adinistra-
resetting or rehabilitating persons affected by low the pattern of the the dsstrct
such projects in the Scheduled Arcas. How Constitution while designing
Panchayatsat
ever, the actual planning and implementation tive arrangements inthe Areas. Pan-
to
of the projects in the Scheduled Areas shall be
coordnaicd at the state level. levels in the Scheduled law (relatingwhichis
10 Planning and management of minor water bod l6. Any provision of any Areas) thisAt
shall cease to be in force at the expiry of one to a thin tax domain and partly due to
vear from the date on which this Act recejves Panchayats own reluctance in collecting
the assent of the President. However, all the revenue.
Panchayats existing immediately before such (i) Panchayats are heavily dependent on grants
from Union and State Governments.
date shall continue till the expiry of their
(iii) A major portion of the grants both from
term, unless dissolved by the State Legislature Union as well as the State Governments
sOoner.
is scheme specific. Panchayats have lim
ited discretion and flexibility in incurring
expenditure.
FINANCES OF PANCHAYATI RAJ (iv) In view of their own tight fiscal position,
State Governments are not keen to de
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission
volve funds to Panchayats.
of India (2005-2009) has summarized the sources (v) In most of the critical Eleventh Schedule
of revenue of the Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) matters like primary education, health
and their financial problems in the following wayv7a. care, water supply, sanitation and minor
1. A major portion of Part IX of the Constitu irrigation even now, it is the State Gov
tion deals with structural empowerment of
ernment which is directly responsible for
the PRIs but the real strength in terms of both implementation of these programmes and
autonomy and efficiency of these institutions is
dependent on their financial position (includ hence expenditure.
ing their capacity to generate own resources),. (vi) Overall, a situation has been created where
In general, Panchayats in our country receive Panchayats have responsibility but grossly
inadequate resources:
funds in the following ways:
i) Grants from the Union Government based 3. Though, in absolute terms, the quantum of
funds the Union/State Government transfers
on the recommendations of the Central
Finance Commission as per Article 280
to a Panchayat forms the major component of
its receipt, the PRI's own resource generation
of the Constitution.
is the soul behind its financial standing. It
(i) Devolution from the State Government
based on the recommendations of the is not only a question of resources; it is the
existence of a local taxation system which
State Finance Commission as per Article
243-I. ensures people's involvement in the affairs of
(ui) Loans / grants from the State Government. an elected body. It also makes the institution
accountable to its citizens.
(iv) Programme-specific allocation under Cen 4. In terms of own resource collection, the
Gram
trally Sponsored Schemes and Additional Panchayats are comparatively in a better posi
Central Assistance.
() Internal Resource Generation (tax and tion because they have a tax domain of their
non-tax). own, while the other two tiers are dependent
b. Across the country. States have not given ad only on tolls, fees and non-taX revenue for
generating internal resources.
cquate attention to fiscal empowerment of the
P'anchayats. The Panchayats own resources 5. State Panchayati Raj Acts have given most of
are meager. Kerala, Karnataka and Tamil the taxation powers to Village Panchayats.
Nadu are the states which are considered to The revenue domain of the intermediate and
progressive in PR*s empowerment but even District Panchayats (both tax as well as non
there, the Panchayats are heavily dependent on tax) has been kept much smaller and remains
government grants, One can draw the folloW confined to secondary areas like ferry services,
ing broad conclusions: markets, water and conservancy services, reg
(i) istration of vehicles, cess on stamp duty and a
Internal resource generation at the Pan-
chayat level is weak. This is partly due few others.
38.14 Indian Polity
6 Ashy of varous State Legisiations indicates 4. Overwhelming
that &aumber of taxES, duties. tolls and fees
funding:A reviewdependency
of r on
nme under the jurisdiction of the Village
Panctavsts These interalia inchhde octroi,
source funds shows themoney received:
government
dence of Panchayats on overw helming and own
groper house tax. profession tax, land tax/ When Panchayats do notgovernment depen-
K Nes tolls on vehicles, entertainment tax/
fees hese fees, tax on non-agriculture land, instead receive funds
from
raise
less likely to request a outside. res funding
.ources and
iee on egistration of cattle, sanitation'drain 5. Reluctance to use social aud1t people are
age consenancy AK. water rate tax, lighting
power devolved
fiscal powers: An
rae t . aducstion cess and tax on fairs and
the right to levy GP (Gram IMportantis
festivais.
markets,
tax on Panchayat
fairs and also for property. business
like services
street lighting or public providet
REASONS FOR IKEFFECTIVE few toilets, etc. Ver
PERFORMANCE Panchayats use their fiscal power to
Evet afer coaferring the
and collect taxes.
The argument pushedleyby
otection through the 73 constitutional status and Panchayat heads is that it is difficult to lerv
tax on your own
tbe performance of the Amendment Act (1992), you live in the constituency, especially when
Panchayati Raj Institutions
PRÌs) has not been satisfactory 6. community.
Status of the Gram
and Sabha: Empowering the
expected level. The various reasons not upto the
for this sub Gram Sabhas could have been a powertul
aptirnai periornance are as follows weapon for transparency, accountability
i. Lack of adequate for and
devolution: Many States
have not taken adequate
involvement of the
marginalized sectons.
steps to devolve 3Fs However, a numnber of the State Acts have not
(ie, fnctions, funds and spelt the powers of Gram Sabhas nor have any
the PRis to enable them tofunctionaries) to procedures been laid down for the functioning
discharge their of these bodies or penalties for the otficials
constitutionaliy stipulated
is imperative that the function. Further, it 7. Creation of Parallel Bodies: Often. Part
PRls have resources to
match the lel Bodies (PBs) are created for suppused)
While SFCsresponsibilities
(state finance
entrusted to them. speedy implementation and greater accouni
submitted their commissions) have ability. However, there is little evidence e
few States have recommendations, not many show that such PBs bave avoided the els
implemented
steps to ensure the fiscal these or taken including that of partisan politics, sharingof
2
Excessive control by viability of theIn PRIs. spoils, corruption and elite capture.mainstream
Miss
States, the Gram bureaucracy: some
in a postion of Panchayats have been placed
m
(in particular) often bypassing duality, and
programmes, create disçonnect,
Gram Panchayat subordination. Hence, the
new
and the
alienation between the existing the leg1tt-
extraordinary Sarpanches
amount of time
have to spend structures and functions. PBS usurp the PRIsb
Offices for funds and or visiting Block mate Space of PRIs and demoralizeendow menls
These interactions with the technical approva. virtue of their superior resourcenumber ofGrun
fice distort the role of Block staff of 8. Poor Infrastructure: Alarge not haveecn
representaives,
3. Tied
Sarpanches as elected Panchayats in the country do Percentottie
25
ofthe
aature of funds: This has two full time Secretary. Around basic
tions. The Gram do nÍt have monitor
activiies slated under aimplica Panchayats planning.
scheme are not always certain buildings. The database for of the
cascs.
e?
of the
district
ties being This resulis
appropriate
in
for all parts ing etc., are lacking in mostrepresentatives
knO»
relevant and periodic training, they are only around 20% Gram Panchayats reported so
ofgood, performtheir functions properly. be having computing facility. In some States.
able to
not.
Althoughall the District and Intermediate Village Panchayats do not have any computing
Panchayats are connected with computers, facility.
TamilNadu
1. Village Panchayats 12618
2. Panchayat Unions 385
3. District Panchayats 29
1. Gram Panchayats 513
Tripura
2. Panchayat Samitics 23
3. Zilla Panchayats 4
4. Autonomous District Councils
52000
Utar Pradesh 1. Gram Panchayats
2. Kshetra Panchayats 820
3. Zilla Panchayats 70
S4
Mile stones in the Evolution of Panchayati Raj
Awars SFirst Generation Panchayats
polity
Const ituent Assembly debates onthe role of Panchayati Raj in Indian
The January; Direcive Princ1ples of State Policy
Constitutionof India on 26
comes into force government'
Imention vil age panchayats as 'units of self (Art 40)
under Arunachal
Vet to hold them elections in
Pradeshpaving
the new
dispensation
way for panchayat
Panchayati Raj 38.19
removed by
election commissioner cannot be
appointed by him.
S AND REFERENCES the governor, though
present (2016), ten states of India have
Int subject of Local Government' is men 5. At Andhra Pradesh,
scheduled areas. These are:
ied in the State List under the Seventh Chhatisgarh, Gujarat,
schedule of the Constitution. Telangana, Jharkhand, Pradesh, Ma
bill was passed by the Lok Sabha on 22 Himachal Pradesh, Madhya
Rajasthan. Presently
Jecember, 1992, and by the Rajya Sabha on harashtra, Odisha and areas
there are a total of ten tribal
December, 1992. Later, it was approved by
e1? state assemblies and received the assent
(2016), four states of
(autonomous districts) in theTripura (1) and
(3),
i he president on 20 April, 1993. Assam (3), Meghalaya
eAct Mizoram (3).
defines all these terms in the following Panchayats in Scheduled Areas,
anner: 6. S.K. Singh, May 2001, P.26.
t Kurukshetra,
Panchayat means an institution (by what-
ever name called) of self-government for 7. This Act received the assent of
December, 1996.
thePresident
purDisptrgover
ose.ict nmeans
or by
public notification for this (2010-2015), Volume
P424-426. 2002, Institute
udge of a adistrict in astate.
October,
9. Panchayati Raj Update,New Delhi.
high court can Sciences,
otnl