Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unit 7
Unit 7
7.1 INTRODUCTION
Geographical Indication (GI) is a relatively new but important instrument in
intellectual property protection. The TRIPS Agreement defines geographical
indications as: Indications which identify a good as originating in the territory of a
Member of the WTO, or a region or locality in that territory, where a given quality,
reputation or other characteristic of the good is essentially attributable to its
geographical origin.
It is well known that the soil and climate of a particular region or territory, may impart
some valuable distinctive quality and character to a particular agricultural product
(e.g. basmati rice from the western Himalayan foot hills; mangoes from Malihabad,
UP). A territory can similarly be distinguished for its specialized skills and processes
which make some item produced there highly desirable. India abounds in goods which
are highly prized due to their origin in specific regions: tea from Darjeeling, sarees
from Banaras or Kanchipuram, silk from Mysore, chappals from Kolhapur, etc.
Internationally, there is no dearth of goods which are in great demand for their
specific origin e.g. champagne, the sparkling wine from the specific territory of that
name in France. GIs have great economic significance. For the producers from a
geographical territory which imparts a characteristic or quality in a product, which is
highly valued by the customers and is not found on any similar product from another
region or territory, the GI serves to identify the source of the product distinguishing
their product from those of producers in other regions. For the consumer, the GI is
assurance of the particular quality, feature or characteristic which the customer is
seeking. The protection of GI helps the development of ethical trade and commerce as
it prevents unscrupulous producers and dealers from forging or counterfeiting genuine
goods, which deceive the consumer and deprives the genuine producers and the
authentic geographical region of legitimate economic returns.
The TRIPS Agreement gives additional protection for GIs for wines and spirits,
because some brands, owing their appeal to their geographical origin, command huge
markets, e.g. Champagne, Scotch.
An important provision in the TRIPS Agreement is that a country is not obliged to
protect a GI of another country if the GI is not under active protection in its home
5
Protection of Other country. Thus if India expects protection to a GI from India, the said GI has first to be
Industrial Property
protected in India as intellectual property. A country which does not protect its GI has
still to protect the GIs of other countries, if they are protected in their home countries
and seek protection in India.
In view of these considerations the Government of India has enacted the Geographical
Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999, which is a fairly
comprehensive legislation. It has come into force with effect from September 15,
2003. In the following all discussion deals with the provisions of this Act, referred to
as the Act.
Objectives
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
• The geographical map of the country or region or locality in the country in which
the goods originate or are being manufactured;
7
Protection of Other • Every application under sub-section (1) shall be examined by the Registrar in such
Industrial Property
manner as may be prescribed.
• Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Registrar may refuse the application or
may accept it absolutely or subject to such amendments, modification, conditions
or limitations, if any, as he thinks fit.
• In the case of refusal or conditional acceptance of application, the Registrar shall
record in writing the grounds for such refusal or conditional acceptance and the
materials used by him in arriving at this decision.
Withdrawal of Acceptance
Where the application for registration has been accepted by the Registrar but before its
registration, the Registrar is satisfied that the acceptance has been in error, or in the
circumstances such that the geographical indication should not be registered or should
be registered under conditions different from the conditions or limitations mentioned
in the application, the Registrar may withdraw the acceptance, after hearing the
applicant, if he so desires.
Advertisement of Application
Once the application for registration has been accepted, the Registrar advertises the
application, as accepted, together with conditions of acceptance. After the
advertisement, the registration can be opposed.
Opposition
Any person who wants to oppose the application for registration may file a notice of
opposition within three months from the date of advertisement or re-advertisement of
an application for registration or within a further period not exceeding one month, in
writing to the Registrar, and on payment of prescribed fees.
The Registrar serves a copy of the received notice on the applicant. The applicant
must send a counter-statement of the grounds on which he relies in support of the
registration application within two months of the receipt of the notice of the
opposition. The Registrar then sends a copy of the counter-statement made by the
applicant to the opponent. After hearing the parties and considering the materials and
evidence on record, he decides the matter. If the applicant fails to file a counter-
statement within two months, the application shall be deemed to have been
abandoned. The Registrar is empowered to make correction of any error and
amendments in an application.
In case of opposition to the application, if the opponent or the applicant neither resides
nor carries on business in India, the Registrar may require a security to cover cost of
proceedings before him. In the absence of such security, the opposition, or the
application, as the case may be, may be treated as abandoned.
Registration
Once an application has been accepted, the Registrar, unless otherwise directed by the
Central Government, registers the geographical indication and the authorised users, if
any, mentioned in the application. The date of filing of the application for registration
is treated as the date of registration. The Registrar then issues a certificate in the
prescribed form sealed with the seal of the Geographical Indications Registry each to
the applicant and the registered user(s). If the registration of a geographical indication
is not completed within twelve months from the date of application due to applicant’s
default, the application will be treated as abandoned after giving notice to the
applicant to complete the proceedings within the time limit as specified in the said
notice. The Registrar has the power to amend the register or the certificate of
registration for correcting any clerical error or an obvious mistake.
8
Indian Law on
SAQ 2 Geographical
Depict the procedure of registration of geographical indication in India in a flow chart Spend " Indications
form. 5 min.
• In the case of agricultural goods if the person produces the same, including the
one who processes or packages such goods.
• In the case of natural goods, if the person exploits such goods.
• In the case of handicrafts or industrial goods, if the person makes, manufactures,
trades or deals in such production or exploitation or making or manufacturing of
the goods.
• Uses the GI on the goods or suggests that such goods originate in a geographical
area other than the true place of origin of such goods in a manner which misleads
the public; or
• Uses another GI to the goods in a manner which falsely represents to the public
that the goods originate in the territory, region or locality in respect of which such
registered GI relates.
10
Suit and Relief for Infringement Indian Law on
Geographical
A suit for infringement or passing off arising out of the use by the defendant of a Indications
registered GI is to be instituted in a District Court having jurisdiction to try the suit.
Section 67 of the Indian GI Act provides for relief in case of infringement. The court
can grant to the plaintiff relief in the form of injunction and, at the option of the
plaintiff, either damages or account of profits together with any order for destruction
or erasure of infringing labels and indications, if necessary.
However, the court shall not grant relief by way of damages on account of profits, if
the defendant satisfies the court that he was unaware and had no reasonable ground to
believe that the GI, complained of, was on the register in the name of plaintiff and that
when he became aware of the existence and nature of the plaintiff’s right in the
geographical indications, he forthwith ceased to use it.
Appeal
Appeals against an order or decision of the Registrar or the Rules framed under the
Act lie to the Intellectual Property Appellate Board, established under the Trademark
Act, 1999. The aggrieved person may prefer an appeal to the Appellate Board
normally within three months from the date on which the order or decision is
communicated. After this period, no appeal is admitted.
The Appellate Board can grant a certificate of validity of a registered GI, or an
authorized user. If in a subsequent legal proceeding the question of validity comes up,
the registered proprietor or the authorized user can recover the full cost and expenses
as between a legal practitioner and his client.
• The application for its registration has been filed, or it has been registered in good
faith under the law relating to trade marks; or
• The rights to such trademark have been acquired through use in good faith before
the commencement of the GI Act, or before the date of filing of the application for
registration of the GI under this Act; or
• The right of a person to use his name, or the name of the predecessor, in business
is protected, if it does not cause confusion or mislead the public; or
• No action can be taken in connection with the use or registration of a trademark
even if considered infringing of a GI after five years of its coming to the notice of
the registered proprietor or an authorised user.
• If any goods meant for sale or any purpose of trade or manufacture are enclosed
with any package or thing for which a GI has been applied;
• Using a GI in connection with goods in any manner likely to lead to the belief that
the GI designates or describes the said goods; or
13
Protection of Other Limitation Period for Initiating Prosecution
Industrial Property
The Act places a time limit of three years for initiating prosecution after the
commission of the offence charged or two years after the discovery thereof by the
prosecutor, whichever expiration first happens.
• The register and any document upon which any entry in the register is paste;
• Every notice of opposition to the registration of a GI, application for rectification,
counter-statement thereto, and any affidavit or document filed by the parties in
any proceedings before the Registrar;
• Indexes of (i) registered GIs, (ii) GIs in respect of which applications for
registration are pending, (iii) the names of the proprietors of registered GIs and
(iv) the names of authorized users; and
• Such other documents as the central government may specify by the notification
in the Official Gazette.
Power of the Registrar
In all proceedings under the GI Act before the Registration, the registrar has all the
powers of a civil court for the purposes of receiving evidence, administering oaths,
enforcing the attendance of witnesses, compelling the discovery and production of
documents and issuing commissions for examining the witnesses. The Registrar can
order costs he may consider reasonable; it will be executable as a decree of a civil
court. The Registrar may, on an application, review his own decision. If the Registrar
is of the opinion that an applicant has defaulted in pursuing his application, he may
require the applicant to remedy the defect within a given time, failing which the
application may be treated as abandoned.
7.12 SUMMARY
Let us now summarize the points covered in this unit.
15
Protection of Other • The term of registration in the first instance is for 10 years and can be renewed
Industrial Property
from time to time for further 10 years.
16
2. Indian Law on
Application filed by interested parties Geographical
Indications
Examination of applications
by the Registrar, issue of
objections and receipt of
inputs from the applicant
Acceptance by Registrar
Withdrawal
Y
of
acceptance?
Advertisement of
acceptance
Opposition
to Y
acceptance?
Applicant’s counter
statements within
N two months
Hearing of both
parties
Y Acceptance? N
Registration of GI
3. Yes.
4. i) False ii) False iii) True iv) False
Terminal Questions
1. Refer to Sec. 7.1.
2. Refer to Sec. 7.1.
3. Refer to Sec. 7.9.
4. Refer to Sec. 7.9.
5. Refer to Sec. 7.7.
17