You are on page 1of 25

APQP 3rd Edition and Control Plan 1st Edition:

What You Need to Know to Be Ready


Webinar Presenters

Dave Mimms, AIAG Jeremy Hazel, Plexus International


• Quality Professional • Experienced Trainer and
with 30+ years curriculum developer
automotive experience specializing in core tools
(Toyota, AIAG) implementation and
• AIAG Participant in utilization.
APQP and Control Plan • Jeremy specializes in small
revision workgroup team development and risk
• Dave supports various based-thinking
projects & workgroups implementation strategy
as AIAG quality staff

2
Poll Time!

Q1 Q2
What area are you currently in with What is your tier within the automotive
your organization? space
• Program management • OEM
• Supplier Quality • Tier 1
• Plant/ corporate quality • Tier 2
• Operations • Sub tier below 2
• Manufacturing
• Other

3
Why the Need for APQP and CP Update?
• It’s about time! (1st Edition 1994; 2nd 2008 – minor changes)
• Industry changes in program management cycles/methods
• Technology changes (product and processes)
• Supply Chain expansion (“New to Auto”, cross-sector suppliers)
• Opportunity to harmonize CSRs and suggest “best practices” based on
Lessons Learned from past programs
• Alignment to IATF 16949 (2015), leverage related AIAG publications
• Customer expectations evolving (consumer, regulatory, etc.)

4
Why Separate Control Plan manual?

Flexibility and Agility Continuous Improvement


• Anticipate more frequent updates • Ford, General Motors and Stellantis
than APQP as technologies evolve collaboration to list frequent weak
• Flexibility to revise/upgrade based points and how to address
on Lessons Learned, Best ✓Harmonized CSRs
Practices, and alignment to other ✓Clear Requirements related to top
standards and harmonized opportunities for improvement
expectations ✓Increased guidance on process to
develop and manage Control Plans

5
The core tools hierarchal structure
APQP

Alignment with the current model


FMEA
• The breakout of the control plan is
consistent with the way we have
Control Plan been teaching the core tools for
years
MSA • The measurement studies required
for PPAP are driven by the control
plan
SPC
• The control plan remains the
operational expression of the FMEA
PPAP
Changes to APQP

Program Management Sourcing Clarification/Detail


• Risk Assessment • Increase focus on • Change Management
and Mitigation Sourcing stage, just during APQP
• Gated Management as important as • Capacity Planning
expectation and “readiness” using OEE
guidance • Checklist to assess • Traceability
• KPIs related to APQP & mitigate risk
during Sourcing • Error-Proofing and
process Mistake-Proofing
• Gated Management
includes sub-tiers
7
At a Glance: APQP Sourcing (section 0.5)
0.5 Sourcing 0.5.1 High Risk Supplier Evaluation
• New AND Existing suppliers (sub- • Organization must have a method to
tier) require thorough vetting to identify “high risk” suppliers
ensure design and manufacturing • Criteria to define high risk include:
capability − New supplier to Organization
− New location or site
• Sourcing checklist should be
− New technology
completed to confirm supplier
suitability (based on CQI-19 Sub- − History of poor quality
Tier Supplier Management Process) − Supplied components have Safety or
Regulatory requirements
• Scope for Sourcing ends with − No certification to ISO 9001 or IATF
acceptable vetting results. All other 16949
APQP activities cascade to sub-tier.
At a Glance: APQP Gated Management (App B)
• New Gated Management Section
• Suggested documentation
checklists for each “gate” review
• Aligned to typical Program
milestones
• Supports expectation for “gate
review” in 1.14 Leadership Support
• Includes review of Supplier (sub-
tier) APQP activity, not just
Organization’s
Managerial vs technical aspects
Technical Managerial or Governance
• An increase in number of tasks • Increased number of gates
• Change in the graphic to extend • More up-front planning
product development • Higher focus on lessons learned
• More focus on risk-based thinking
The governance framework
Control Plan Manual Overview
Evolved from “how to fill in the form” in APQP/CP 2nd edition to:
• Chapter 0 Introduction
− Clarify linkage to APQP processes; emphasize “Living Document”
• Chapter 1 Requirements and Guidelines
− Clear requirements for key topics (common weak points, harmonized CSRs)
• Chapter 2 How to Develop Control Plan
− Expanded guidance with emphasis on process approach
• Chapter 3 Control Plan Stages
− Importance of each stage, harmonized CSRs for Safe Launch
• Chapter 4 Effective Use of Control Plans
− Maximize Control Plan effectiveness in context of holistic QMS

12
Control Plan Key Content/Changes
Characteristics Address Common Clarified
Management Weaknesses Expectations
• Special • Error-proofing • Directed Supply
Characteristics confirmation information
identification and • Volume-based gathering activity
classification sampling frequency • Safe Launch,
• Pass-Through (ensure containment) including “exit
Characteristics • Reaction Plan criteria”
identification and documentation
management (action & responsible)

13
At a Glance: Control Plan Chapter 1
Requirements and Guidelines for 12 topics based on past problems
Key examples:
• Special Characteristics
− Allow use of “correlation matrix” (correlate organization symbols to customer's)
− Customer may also designate "key" or "critical" characteristics for special handling
• Pass-Through Characteristics
− Organization must have a process to identify and ensure adequate control of PTC
throughout supply chain, and must communicate control methods to customer
− Recommended CQI-19 PTC Matrix to communicate control methods to customer
• Directed Supply
− Organization must get necessary information from Supplier to develop
Organization's control plan unless otherwise specified by mutually signed
agreement (MPA, etc.)

14
At a Glance: Control Plan Chapter 3
Control Plan Stages
• Addition of “Safe Launch” requirements
• Typical Application (figure 3.1)
• Pre-Launch: Customer may require during
Pilot Stage and continued into launch; how
to document
• Production: Start of Production WILL
include Safe Launch
• Must establish judgment criteria to exit
Safe Launch - typically 90 days no
problems to customer and no problems
Typical application of Safe Launch Control Plan identified by Safe Launch
additional/enhanced controls/containment
At a Glance: Control Plan Chapter 4
Considerations for using QMS elements to maximize effectiveness
Key concept, why it’s important, what to do, and how to do it for:
• Reverse PFMEA
• Using Software to Develop and Manage Control Plan
• Layered Process Audit as Control Plan Verification
• Control Plans in Highly Automated Processes
• Using Family/Foundation Control Plans and FMEAs
• Control of Storage and Handling Related Risks
• Abnormality Management related to Control Plans

16
Poll Time Part Deux!

Q3 Q4
Given what you saw in the presentation When it comes to utilization how will you
how ready do you feel you are for the new be using the new APQP and Control plan
version and the subsequent deadline to • We will be adopting it for our own
adopt it organization as an existing
• Very ready automotive supplier
• Somewhat ready • We will be driving through our
• We have a lot of work to do supply chain
• We will be implementing it for the
first time as an automotive supplier

17
Enabling Rapid Electrification of Industry

Framework Flexibility New Suppliers to Auto New Technology


• Quicker cycles of • Customers will still • Sector Specific
development expect APQP and guidance proposals
• Sequence and CP execution can be made
duration of actions (process agreed)
may be flexible
(consult customer)
Consistent Intention/Purpose
APQP manual: “The intent of APQP is to proactively assess and mitigate risk factors impacting product launch.”
CP manual: “The goal of a Control Plan is to facilitate communication with everyone involved to assure that all required
controls are completed on time and in full, every time.”
18
Fast Feedback Team – accelerated development
• Suppliers/OEMs Consulted • Key Contributions
Diverse demographics & opinions Suggestions, best practices, concerns
− Bosch ➢APQP
− Freudenberg-NOK ✓ Gated Management guidance
− Geely
− GKN ✓ Traceability expectations
− Honda ✓ Checklist expansion (best practices)
− Rivian
− Magna ➢Control Plan
− Nexteer ✓ Special Characteristics classifications
− NXP Semiconductors
− Paccar ✓ Pass-Through Characteristics assurance
− Shape Corporation ✓ Reaction Plan details
− Panasonic Battery Solutions ✓ Directed Supply relationships

19
Implementation Timing Targets

Ford General Motors Stellantis


• 6 months after • 6 months after • 6 months after
publication publication publication

All will ACCEPT immediately after publication


(Nothing new is contrary to current, positively enhanced new content is OK)

20
What Should You Do to Be Ready?

Learn the Content Gaps? More Training? Implement & Reflect


• Get the new • Assess gaps between • Pilot project with
documents as soon as current practices and limited scope
possible the new APQP and • Reflect from your
• Utilize AIAG eLearning Control Plan manual viewpoint and that of
and training resources • Knowledge and your customer
expertise gaps may • Document and
require additional Implement Lessons
training Learned

21
AIAG Training Resources Purchase Your Presale Publication
and Training Now!

• APQP and Control Plan transitioning


• Control Plan- Understanding and
Implementing
• APQP overview
• APQP Control Plan and PPAP-
Understanding and Implementing
• PPAP- How to review and improve the
effectiveness of PPAP

Join the ranks of AIAG and take advantage of member savings on critical resources like these!
Be sure to visit the membership area of our website today for additional information on AIAG member
benefits – including deep discounts on industry essentials, opportunities to volunteer, and more –
22
and fill out an application to get started.
Thank you
APQP 3rd Edition and Control Plan 1st Edition FAQ’s

When is the new APQP 3rd edition and Control Plan 1st edition officially being released?

• The anticipated release date for both publications is March 1, 2024.

How much are the new publications going to cost?

APQP / CP Publication Type Member Non-Member


Hardcopy $ 55 $ 165
Individual e-Document $ 55 $ 165
Corporate Subscription $ 1,600 $ 2,600
Hardcopy $ 99 $ 297
Kit (both
e-Document $ 99 $ 297
documents)
Corporate Subscription $ 2,880 $ 4,680

What languages are the new publications going to be offered in?

• The new publications will be offered in English, Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Portuguese, and
Spanish when the document launches.

When will training be available for the new processes?

• Training will be available at launch. Please review the training classes listed above.

When will the new APQP and Control Plan be required by the OEMs?

• At this time, General Motors implementation date is six months for the release date of the
documents
o Contact your customer representative with implementation questions

When will the new APQP and Control Plan be accepted by the OEMs?

• Ford, General Motors, and Stellantis have agreed they will accept use of the new APQP and
Control Plan immediately after publication, since nothing in the new documents conflict with the
APQP 3rd edition.

Is the Control Plan form or fields changing with this update?

• The Control Plan forms have been updated

Will the AIAG Core Tools Support Software, CTS, include the new Control Plan?

• Yes, the new forms for APQP and Control Plan are anticipated to be available at launch
Is AIAG planning to offer standardized software for creating the new Control Plans?

• Yes – AIAG’s Core Tools Support Software, CTS, creates and manages Control Plan, FMEA, and
PPAP documents quickly, accurately, and globally

Do the OEMs expect suppliers to update existing Control Plans to meet the new requirements?

• No, suppliers will not have to update existing Control Plans to meet the new requirements.

Are the Core Tools Self-Assessment and Quality Core Tools Knowledge Badge being updated to include
the new versions of APQP and Control Plan?

• Yes, the current Core Tools Self-Assessment and Quality Core Tools Knowledge Badge will be
updated to include the newest versions of APQP and Control Plan.

What are the major changes to APQP*?

• Removed Control Plan content into stand-alone document


• Added Sourcing section and Sourcing Checklist
• Added Change Management section and Change Management Checklist
• Added section for APQP Program Metrics, including Example in Appendix C.
• Added section for Risk Assessment Mitigation Plan
• Added "Part Traceability“ content
• New Gated Management Section
o Suggested documentation checklists for each “gate” review
o Aligned to typical Program milestones
o Supports expectation for “gate review” in 1.14 Leadership Support
o Includes review of Supplier (sub-tier) APQP activity, not just Organization’s

*Note, this list is not all-inclusive and should not be used for gap-analysis. If your customer requires you
to complete APQP and Control Plan documents, you are encouraged to read them in their entirety.

What are the major changes to Control Plan*?

• Clarify link to APQP processes, Living Document


• Clarify Requirements (topics from lessons learned and Customer Specific Requirements)
• Provides detailed guidance how to develop, not just form fields
• Addition of “Safe Launch” requirement to the control plan phases
• Includes effective use of Control Plan guidance based on practices of excellent organizations
• App A: CP Examples - Table for Process Dependent considerations; General to illustrate key
requirements/expectations
• App B: Forms/Checklists - Updated based on changes in Chapters 1-3

*Note, this list is not all-inclusive and should not be used for gap-analysis. If your customer requires you
to complete APQP and Control Plan documents, you are encouraged to read them in their entirety.

You might also like