Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Q.2 How did Miller justify his not asking Hans to share some of his good things during the winter?
Ans. The Millers youngest son, as soon as he heard that Hans is in trouble, offered to call
Hans to their house and to share with Hans half his porridge. This offer infuriated the Miller. He
claimed that if Hans went to his house and saw his warm fire and good supper and the great
cask of red wine, he would become jealous. It would certainly destroy Hans’ nature that the
Miller would never allow. He further claimed that Hans might ask him to lend some flour; but
the Miller would not give him because ‘flour’ is one thing and ‘friendship’ is another. We should
not mix up these different ideas together because these have different meaning and spelling.
Q.3 How did the Miller justify his rebuke to Hans for staying in bed a little later than usual after his
tiring expedition to the market?
Ans. The Miller came to collect money from Hans for the sack of flour that Hans sold for the
Miller in the market yesterday. Hans was so tired that he was still in the bed. The Miller harshly
criticized Hans for his laziness. The Miller said, “Idleness is a great sin.” He again reminded Hans
that he was going to give him his wheelbarrow so Hans should work hard. He argued that people
are generally not sincere, so they say charming things and try to please and to flatter, but a true
friend never minds giving pain in order to rectify the mistake of a friend. He claimed that as he
was his best friend, so he would always take care of Hans not to be involved in any destructive
activity.
Q.4 What was the supreme manifestation of the Miller’s selfishness which caused Hans to lose his
life?
Ans. One stormy night the Miller came to Hans house. He seemed worried because his son had fallen
down from a ladder and got hurt. The Miller wanted Hans to go and call in the doctor. The
doctor lived far away. The night was very dark, so Hans asked the Miller to give him the lantern
he was carrying, so that he could keep himself away from ditches. But the Miller refused to give
him the lantern because it was his new lantern and it would be a great loss to him if anything
had happened to the lantern. Hans was so devoted that he did not mind the refusal of the Miller
and went on bravely. He reached the doctor’s house and sent him to the Miller’s house. At last,
when he was trying to return to his house, he lost his way and drowned in a deep hole in the
moor because he could see nothing in the darkness.
THE DEVOTED FRIEND
MCQ’s
********************************