You are on page 1of 1

T

TERRITORIALIZATION / DETERRITORIALIZ- THOMPSON, EDWARD PALMER (1924–1993)


ATION / RETERRITORIALIZATION Coined Left-wing historian and political activist
by French poststructuralist thinkers Gilles who, alongside the critics Raymond
Deleuze and Félix Guattari, these terms Williams and Richard Hoggart, played
describe a concept of material change an important role in the foundation of
often used in postmodern and postcolonial ‘cultural studies’ as an academic discipline.
theory. In A Thousand Plateaus (first pub- Thompson’s The Making of the English
lished 1980), Deleuze and Guattari argue Working Class (first published 1963) was a
that the physical, biological and cultural pioneering work of social history which
world is made up of layered regulatory aimed to rescue the ordinary lives of work-
systems or ‘strata’. Preserving unity and ing people from ‘the enormous conde-
uniformity, these strata work within the scension of posterity’ (1968: 13), and to
fixed elements and limits that they also demonstrate that the development of class-
constitute and maintain. While experience consciousness is ‘an active process, which
presents constant variation, these differen- owes as much to agency as to conditioning’
ces are always cancelled out by the strata. (1968: 9).
Changes to individual elements cannot Thompson’s belief in the autonomy of
transform the whole system. However, the the individual was reflected in his politics.
variable potentials and qualities of matter Amongst the first ‘New Left’ intellectuals,
itself constantly overflow the strata, form- Thompson quit the Communist Party and
ing a body without organs that gives rise to established New Reasoner, a journal of
new systems and structures. And since they ‘socialist humanism’ that was later
do not depend upon but constitute the fixed subsumed into New Left Review. Soon
units they order, the strata also have a afterwards, its editorial agenda moved
virtual existence ‘alongside’ the actual towards continental theorists such as Louis
matter they affect. Deleuze and Guattari Althusser, prompting Thompson, in ‘The
therefore characterize stratified systems as Poverty of Theory’ (1978), to declare
‘territorialized’, embodied instances of an ‘unrelenting intellectual war’ (1978: 381)
abstract function. This abstract or virtual against Althusserian theory, which, he felt,
function differs from Plato’s unchanging, presented citizens as ‘utterly passive’
intangible Idea, however, as it is precisely (1978: 366) victims of ideology. [CRC]
because strata are ‘territorialized’ that they See also Chapters 3 and 5.
are also subject to processes of deterri-
torialization, where differences escape Further reading
from territorialized functions, and reterri- Thompson, Edward Palmer (1968) The
torialization, where new systems are Making of the English Working Class,
formed or, conversely, an old one is re- Harmondsworth: Penguin.
embodied in a different situation. Rather Thompson, Edward Palmer (1978) The
than a Platonic denial of change and differ- Poverty of Theory and Other Essays,
ence, Deleuze and Guattari offer a novel London: Merlin Press.
way of thinking its concrete reality. [DH]

260

You might also like