Niobium—Base Alloys
E.N. Sheftel & O. A. Bannykh
Int Mae ad Mert 12193-1994) 303-314
ne “Sse Hoorn Lane
Pineda Gro Sn Algh res
habeus
‘Baikov Institute of Metallurgy, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia
(Received 25 March 1994; accepted 16 May 1994)
[Abmiracts On the basis of the research carried out by the authors and the
‘aualysis of the published data, the eeeaie principles of the alloying end
designing of strdcture of niobium alloy, providing high strength and work
abiy ofthe alloys intended fortwo operating temperatures: from 1300 up (0
1400°C and from 600 to 800°C, have been considered. The developing
principles axe basod on the revesling of interdependence berween phase
Sagas,
characteristic Of slementa and phases forming nthe
proper alloys as well as their smuctures end’ mechanical properics: Main
'tention has been paid to the alloys of Nb-Mey-X (X=, N.C) systems with
Oxide, nie an carbide dispersoids
INTRODUCTION
‘Among the alloys based on refractory metals of
groups VA and VIA, niobium alloys are perhaps
the most varied. The niobium alloys used in
various fields of engineering may be conven-
tionally divided into two groups—structural and
precision. To the first group, high-temperature
heat-resistant alloys are attributed. To the second
group, alloys having special physical properties
are attributed. Among them are superconducting
alloys; alloys characterised by specified values of
linear thermal expansion coefficient, high elas-
ticity and proper biocompatibility (for medicinal
application as implants). The most numerous
‘group of alloys to which application of niobium is
oriented high temperature strength alloys.
More than 30 years ago, in the 1960s, the
attention of specialists engaged in material
sciences was drawn to refractory metals as struc-
tural materials to be used in aerospace engineer-
ing. Apart from the ability to operate under
high-temperature conditions, such materials
should meet the following requirements: high
workability and low density providing reduction
of the launch weight. Concerning the above
mentioned niobium with faq 2468°C, having
the lowest density (8-4 g.cm=*) among ail refrac-
tory metals and the highest low-temperature duc-
tility, the highest solubility of interstitial elements
303,
and, connected with it, the least sensibility of due-
tile properties to their content, it was considered
as the most perspective basis for structural alloys
to be used under high-temperature conditions.
‘At that period the principal problems for Nb-
alloys to be solved have been in searching for
‘ways to increase high-temperature strength at
satisfactory workability, as well as methods of
protection against oxidisation at operating tem-
peratures exceeding 1000°C. As a result, at the
‘end of the 1960s and beginning of the 1970s, a
great number of alloy compositions were deve-
loped which may be conventionally divided into
low-, medium and high-strength alloys that have
been used for a long time operating at
1000-1200°C arid a short time working at
1200-1700°C (Table 1).
In those years, developments failed 10 solve the
problem of simultaneously achieving high strength
and high workability to an alloy as well as provid-
ing safe long-term operation of designed protec-
tion costings. This became a cause of certain
stopping in carrying out researches in the field of
No-alloys that was aggravated by successes
achieved in those years in the ficld of designing
superalloys and advanced cooling structures
In the middle of the 1980s, refractory metal
alloys (especially niobium alloys) became an
object of research interest again in connection
with searching for materials characterised by high304
‘Table 1. High-emperatar niobium alloys and thelr
E.N. Sheftel, 0... Bannylth
Lowatrength| Bs: Vv.
ss 3y-128zr
C103xB-3 IORI 1Ti—-0722
NBUIKB-1} iZr~01C
of MPa Sige, MPa
1100 12006 1B00rC nove 120 1300°C
160-260 = = = - =
Mediumstrengih B66: SMo~5V— 122
FSas 27Te—10W- 0722
VN 46Mo~ M4Zr— 0126
SVMtz —— SW=2Mo~ 12r~(005+007)C
Dass 1ow=25z"
of, MPa Sees MPa
a0 1200. 1300 nore 1200 1300"
260-450 190-280 = 160-240 100-130 36-70
“High-sreagih Fa 15W=5Mo~ 12r—D1C
B50, ASW=SMo— STi Ize
VN 30Mo— 152: ~03C~003CeLa
Series VAM (22+ 28)W=2Ht=(0067+0:13)C.
We 3009:—_30uE-9W
MPa
n0¢e 1300 1300
350-450 140-300 100
"Annealed sate
operating properties, to be used in new genera-
‘tions of spacecraft, aircraft and powder engincer-
‘ng, as well as in connection with development of
new progressive technologies. In this search, a
problem appeared in design materials intended
fr filling two operating temperature ranges. The
first, temperature range extends from 600 to
900C where wrought Ti-alloys do not already
‘work whereas Ni-alloys do not meet the specific
strength requirements, The second one extends
from 1100 to 1500°C where wrought Ni-alloys
do not already work whereas alloys based on
intermetallics and heat-resistant ceramics, con-
sidered as perspective structural materials, do
‘not provide the required strength, ductility or
fracture toughness.
The present report, drawn up on the basis of
further research carried out by the authors and
‘the analysis of the published data, deals with the
scientific principles of alloying and control of the
structure of niobium alloys providing high
strength and workability of the alloys for operat-
ing temperature ranges from 1100 to 1400°C and
from 600 to 800°C.
To design Nb-alloys destined to operate at tem-
peratures where 0-1 Tuer < T<(0'3-+ 065) Tex all
the known methods of strengthening may be
applied, such asthe soli solution one, alloying by
substitutional and interstitial elements, precipita-
tion or dispersion strengthening, as well as crea-
tion of special structures. As a rule, the most
effective combination of strength and ductility is
achieved when joint application of several reason
ably chosen methods of strengthening is used.
‘SOLID SOLUTION STRENGTHENING
Proceeding from the known mechanisms of solid
‘olution strengthening, producing and some other
requirements to be met by the designed alloys, the
alloying elements should comply with one of the
following criteria: (1) presence of wide solubility
range even if at high temperatures; (2) an increase
of intra-atomic bonds that is suficiently reflected
in increased melting point (Tq) of the alloy—
strengthening in this case is Kept at T>0'5 Tue
where the unstrengthening processes are deter~
mined by diffusivity of the clements; (3) a great
difference of atomic sizes as compared to No—
this parameter determines the origin of consider
able elastic distortions in the crystal lattice causing‘Nioblum—base alloys 305
dislocation impeding the plastic flow provess—
such strengthening is kept at T05 122
Dior at%zefa.%4O 505 ee
‘s 7
Ne-ZeNtnunN) EB
Nb-ZiC(HEC) 3sNiobitum—base alloys 307
\
3
7
!
ar
sty
Teper of eng CC)
Fig. 2. Effect of quenching and folowing ageing tempera-
tures on hardness and variation of resistivity for two-phase
Nb-Iwt9cZr0, alloys with Oval’ ZrO,
Table 3, The size of ZrO, particles in Nb-13421-O alloyst
wth (6 + 06 }vol% 210, bersus he ageing conditions
‘Ageing Plate engih, Plate ichness Distance berveen
4) ‘a
conte ‘orice
oe a
350-8 «90 Sewerlatom =
$50 20 50 Sew stom i
layers
950 100 60 Sevtstatom 70-140
‘ayer
90 29150 = 200
i200 "S57 30-50 oot
Aker quenching om 1700°6
the increase of oxygen diffusivity in Nb at 1100°C.
This results in reducing the effect of precipitation
strengthening at this temperature.
‘An efficient suppression of oxide particle co-
agulation up to 1600°C has been obtained in
internal oxidized alloys with excess oxygen con-
tent (related to Me,,O,) in solid solution (Table 4).
The authors”! explain this fact by dramatic
decrease of equilibrium solubility of ZrO, in the
solid solution in presence of excess oxygen. In
order to provide sutficient ductility of alloys free
oxygen content should not exceed 0-2-0'3 at %.
‘The structure of these internal oxidized alloys
is characterized by presence of 1 vol.% of highly
dispersed (40-60 A) coherent to the matrix par-
ticles of fee. modification ZrO{HfO,) pre~