You are on page 1of 4

The Use of Technology in Suicide Prevention*

Mark E. Larsen, Nicholas Cummins, Tjeerd W. Boonstra, Bridianne O’Dea, Joe Tighe, Jennifer
Nicholas, Fiona Shand, Julien Epps, and Helen Christensen

strategies, such as installing safety barriers on the Golden


Abstract— Suicide is one of the leading causes of death


globally, and is notably a significant cause of death amongst Gate Bridge [3], however technological advancements offer
young people. A suicide outcome is a complex combination of new opportunities in suicide prevention, with the potential to
personal, social, and health factors, and therefore suicide reduce the number of deaths by suicide.
prevention is a challenge, requiring a systems approach
incorporating public health strategies, screening at-risk A recent search of the IEEE Xplore database for suicide-
individuals, targeted interventions, and follow-up for suicide related journal and magazine articles identified 26 potentially
survivors and those bereaved by suicide. Engineering practice relevant articles. Seven of these reported or mentioned cases
has been implicated in the hindrance of the adoption of suicide where an individual had died by suicide, four mentioned
prevention strategies, such as installing safety barriers at the suicide bombing, one described an image analysis technique
Golden Gate Bridge, however technological developments offer to detect completed suicides, and six articles discussed
new opportunities in suicide prevention, and the potential to suicide in relation to other mental health topics (linking
reduce the number of deaths by suicide. surveillance to suicide, assisted suicide, cyber-bullying, the
We present an overview of current technological history of electroconvulsive therapy, forecasting depression
developments which are facilitating research in the field of in bipolar disorder, and detecting symptoms of depression
suicide prevention, including multiple modes of screening such from medical records). Only two articles were closely related
as network analysis of mobile-phone collected connectivity to the prevention of suicide, both detecting depression or
data, automatic detection of suicidality from social media crisis from speech [4, 5]. Although there is a relative lack of
content, and crisis detection from acoustic variability in speech engineering research on suicide prevention, the IEEE EMBS
patterns. The current field of mhealth apps for suicide code of ethics calls for us to “engage in research aimed at
prevention is assessed, and an innovative app for an Indigenous
advancing the contribution of science and technology to
population is presented. From this overview, future challenges
improving healthcare provision” [6]. We therefore present an
– technical and ethical – are discussed.
overview of some of the current technological developments
I. INTRODUCTION which are occurring in the field of suicide prevention. Studies
involving human participants were approved by the
Suicide is a leading cause of death globally [1], and in institutional ethics committee.
Australia accounts for 2,500 deaths per year – approximately
the same number as breast cancer or skin cancer [2]. Notably, II. SCREENING FOR SUICIDALITY
it is the leading cause of death among Australians aged 15–
44. There is no single causative pathway to a suicide Detecting the presence of suicide ideation or behaviours
outcome, rather it is the result of a complex combination of is a challenge, even for physicians [7]. The potential to aid in
personal, social and health factors. Suicide prevention is the detection of a suicidal crisis or the onset of a pre-crisis
therefore a challenge, requiring a systems approach state is an important outcome, as it has been estimated that up
incorporating public health strategies, screening at-risk to 66% of people who die by suicide have contact with a
individuals, targeted interventions, and follow-up for suicide primary health service in the month prior to their death, but
survivors and those bereaved by suicide. There have been their suicidality is often undetected [8]. The increasing
instances where it has been suggested that engineering ubiquity of sensor-enabled smartphones and the use of online
practice has hindered the adoption of suicide prevention social media platforms offer the potential for passive,
background data collection, and automatic detection of
suicidality and its associated risk factors.
* Research supported by the NHMRC Centre of Research Excellence in
Suicide Prevention APP1042580, NHMRC John Cade Fellowship A. Detecting Social Withdrawal with Smartphones
APP1056964, NHMRC Project Grant APP1060477, AFFIRM, SMHR,
NSW Mental Health Commission, Department of Health and Ageing, Social withdrawal is a key warning sign for episodes of
Department of Health WA, Young and Well Cooperative Research Centre, depression and suicidal behaviour [9], and one which may be
Department of Broadband, Communication and the Digital Economy, ARC detectable by other members of an individual’s social
ICT Centre of Excellence program, and ARC Discovery Projects network. However, the emergence of this behaviour is not
DP110105240 and DP120100641.
M. E. Larsen, T. W. Boonstra, B. O’Dea, J. Tighe, J. Nicholas, F. Shand
always obvious. Passive monitoring using smartphones
and H. Christensen are with the Black Dog Institute, University of New provides a tool that can map social networks and detect such
South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2031, Australia. T. W. Boonstra is also with withdrawal.
MOVE Research Institute, VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Email: {mark.larsen, b.odea, j.tighe, j.nicholas, Several studies have used proximity or location-based
h.christensen}@blackdog.org.au, {t.boonstra, fionas}@unsw.edu.au. features as a proxy for social ties [10]. Whereas these
N. Cummins and J. Epps are with the School of Electrical Engineering previous studies have used specific study-provided handsets,
and Telecommunications, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW which limits the scalability of such a system, researchers at
2031, Australia and the ATP Research Laboratory, National ICT Australia
(NICTA). Email: n.p.cummins@unsw.edu.au, j.epps@unsw.edu.au.
the Black Dog Institute have developed a custom app for

978-1-4244-9270-1/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE 7316


Android and iPhones that participants installed on their own accurately and automatically detect social media posts that
handset. The app performed a periodic Bluetooth discovery are indicative of genuine risk is of great interest.
scan to detect other nearby users, and was tested in a pilot
study with staff and students within the organisation. Based Machine learning algorithms for the automatic detection
on the scanning data, patterns in the connectivity between of strongly concerning suicidal tweets have been developed
individual participants in close proximity can be observed [17]. In this study, 14,701 suicide-related tweets were
(Fig. 1). A social network can then be defined by combining acquired, 2,000 of which were selected for manual labelling
the scanning statistics of the participants. The weights of the as either “strongly concerning”, “possibly concerning”, or
network edges were determined from the number of times “safe to ignore”. A total of 14% were considered strongly
each pair of devices observed one another (Fig. 2a), which in concerning. These labelled tweets were then applied to a
turn define the network topology (Fig. 2b). Support Vector Machine, which demonstrated an accuracy of
80% when applied to a sample of unseen “strongly
Figure 1 – Connectivity between one participant and other nearby concerning” tweets – an accuracy equivalent to that of the
devices, over one week. The colour map represents the number of times inter-rater agreement among the human coders in the manual
the Bluetooth devices were in proximity during a one-hour window.
labelling process. This demonstrates the feasibility of
establishing automated detection systems for concerning
suicidal content posted on Twitter and has the potential to be
adapted for other social media sites.
C. Crisis Detection from Speech Patterns
Speech can be a key marker for suicide crisis detection.
The linguistic content of speech is used by clinicians to aid
crisis detection, however gaining reliable linguistic
information from a patient who is in crisis can be difficult.
The frankness and honesty of an individual’s response
depends on their desire and ability to communicate at a time
Figure 2 – (a) Connectivity matrix showing the strength of each when their outlook and motivation may be impaired [18, 19].
network edge, and (b) the resulting topography of the social network.
Paralinguistics are the vocal phenomena that occur
alongside the linguistic information, and these non-linguistic
(and hence language-independent) cues can be used as an
objective marker in crisis detection [20]. Paralinguistic
features include biological traits (such as ethnicity, sex, age
and height) and social signals (such as conversational sounds
and intimacy). Of particular interest for suicide crisis
detection is that paralinguistic analysis has been shown to be
useful in objectively monitoring emotional [21] and mental
states [20, 22].
Paralinguistic analysis may be particularly well suited to
implementation in mobile devices or call centres, in view of
Previous studies have established the connection between the fact that 80% of suicide attempts involve some form of
social connectivity and mental health, indicating that people prior warning, and people who call crisis centres are around
with depressive symptoms tend to group together [11] and 30 times more likely than average to attempt suicide [23].
that adolescent girls with depressive symptoms have fewer Speech production is the output of a complex cognitive
social connections [12]. Therefore, tracking how a social and muscular system, and slight physiological and cognitive
network changes over time and detecting changes in social changes, which can be expected due to the intense changes in
connectivity may provide important information about affective state during a crisis, can produce noticeable acoustic
emerging episodes of depression and suicidal behaviour. The changes. These changes alter speech production systems in
ability to map changes in social networks using participants’ such a way that is measurable using prosodic, articulatory,
own smartphones offers a non-intrusive, platform- and acoustic speech features. For example, reduced acoustic
independent, and scalable method to investigate the effect of variability has been found to be significantly linked to the
changes in social interactions on mental health. presence of depression (Fig. 3) [24].
B. Detecting Suicidality on Twitter A range of prosodic alterations have been linked with
In addition to the correlations with real-world social individuals in a suicidal crisis, including unusual and
networks, mental health is also associated with the patterns of unexpected vocal patterns and audible changes in acoustic
usage and behaviour within online social networks [13, 14]. properties [25]. Suicidality has also been linked with shifts in
Online social networking platforms, particularly social media spectral energy, either from lower to higher frequencies [4,
sites, have been used to detect the presence of a suicide crisis, 5], or the reverse [26]. Recently statistically significant
as evidenced by the recent attempts to deploy detection tools differences have been reported between voice quality features
for use in Twitter [15] and Facebook [16]. However, due to obtained from the speech of either suicidal adolescent voices
the large volume of content shared in these sites, the ability to or matched controls [27].

7317
Figure 3 – A comparison of spectrograms showing four repetitions of B. ibobbly
the phrase ‘PATAKA’ for an individual in a normal mood state (top)
and very severe depressed state (bottom). Low energy regions are Although there is a general lack of evidence-based,
darker, high energy regions are lighter. Notice the lack of sustained interactive apps currently publicly available, this situation is
energy in the 1kHz and 3kHz regions in the very severe example. changing. One example of an innovative suicide prevention
Figure reproduced from [24]. app is ibobbly, which was designed to reduce the suicide rate
amongst young Aboriginal Australians [29]. This is a
particularly high-risk group, in which the suicide rate is four
times higher than the non-Indigenous population, and one
which has a high rate of adoption of smartphones and social
media use [30].
The ibobbly app was designed with extensive
consultation with the local community, and in a culturally-
relevant manner. The app is based on proven Acceptance and
Commitment Therapy, but presented in a highly graphical
form (see Fig. 4) with artwork by local Aboriginal artists. It
also incorporates audio playback of the text components, to
aid accessibility in a population with various levels of
English literacy. Self-reported data were collected through
the app using custom measures and standard
Research into links between changes in suicide risk and psychometrically validated measures of depression, distress,
changes in paralinguistic cues is still in its infancy. Many suicidality, and impulsiveness. The ibobbly app has been
results have been found in small datasets recorded under non- piloted in a randomised controlled trial in eight communities
ideal conditions, raising issues relating to their validity and in the Kimberley region of Western Australia and the results
generalisability. However they show future speech research will be available shortly.
can potentially yield a simple, low cost, automated, and
Figure 4 – Screenshot from one of the ibobbly modules.
objective crisis detection aid.

III. INTERVENTIONS
Following the identification of a potentially suicidal
individual, effective interventions are required in order to
manage the crisis situation. The screening methods identified
above are still in development and have not yet been
incorporated into an intervention, however, they are all well-
suited to incorporation into mobile applications (apps). Apps
provide a flexible platform from which a variety of
intervention strategies can be employed – including public
health and mental health techniques.
IV. DISCUSSION
A. Review of Mobile Apps
The field of suicide prevention is a relatively new
Mobile apps are a popular way of accessing health application for the engineering community. Nevertheless,
information and resources, despite a lack of evidence for
advancements are being made in multiple modes of
publicly available apps across a spectrum of mental health
disorders [28]. As there is no clear link between research and screening individuals who may be at risk, and the detection
public implementation, we have conducted a review to assess of possible suicidal crisis – we have described detection
whether existing apps for suicide prevention are consistent through passive sensor data collection, analysis of social
with established evidence-based practice. media content, and paralinguistic processing of speech.
Mobile apps are being used as a convenient platform for the
The review identified 123 apps from the iTunes and
Google Play app stores which were related to suicide. Of delivery of suicide prevention programs, and will be
these 123 apps, 12 (9.8%) contained potentially harmful enhanced by the incorporation of these novel screening
content which may encourage self-harming or suicidal techniques, for example in the use of adaptive interventions
behaviours. Exhaustive testing of the apps was not part of the in response to these measures.
review process, however 31 (25.2%) of the apps exhibited Developing tools for suicide prevention remains a
obvious bugs or reliability issues, excluding those related to challenge. It is a difficult population to access, and one
general usability. Despite the potential for apps to provide an which requires a high degree of sensitivity. Best practice for
interactive experience for users and to harness data from responding to an automatic indicator of suicidality is not yet
various sensors, only 54 (43.9%) of the apps offered any clear [31], and the expectations of privacy and the
interactive features beyond the passive consumption of, or
implications of false positives must be addressed. Ensuring
navigation through, content. Mapping individual components
of these apps to the evidence base is currently underway. appropriate safeguards and community consultation are
crucial to facilitating this important research topic.
Expanding the scope and availability of suicide prevention
7318
programs and translation into wider practice requires [13] M. Burke, C. Marlow, and T. Lento, "Social Network Activity
and Social Well-Being," Chi2010: Proceedings of the 28th
community and clinical engagement, as well as Annual Chi Conference on Human Factors in Computing
technological innovation and advancements, and engineering Systems, Vols 1-4, pp. 1909-1912, 2010.
skills will be a key component in this interdisciplinary field. [14] M. Larsen, T. Boonstra, P. Batterham, B. O'Dea, C. Paris, and H.
Christensen, "We Feel: Mapping emotion on Twitter," IEEE J
Biomed Health Inform, In press 2015.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT [15] Samaritans. (2014). Samaritans Launches Twitter App To Help
Identify Vulnerable People. Available:
M.E.L., T.W.B. and H.C. thank the staff and students at
http://www.samaritans.org/news/samaritans-launches-twitter-
the Black Dog Institute who participated in the pilot of the app-help-identify-vulnerable-people
social connectivity project. N.C. and J.E. thank National ICT [16] Facebook. (2015). Facebook Safety. Available:
Australia who support their work. B.O. and H.C. https://www.facebook.com/fbsafety/posts/817724748265365
[17] B. O'Dea, S. Wan, P. J. Batterham, A. L. Calear, C. Paris, and H.
acknowledge the efforts of Dr. Cecile Paris, Dr. Stephen Christensen, "Detecting suicidality on Twitter," Internet
Wan, Dr. David Milne (CSIRO) as well as Dr. Philip J Interventions, vol. 2, pp. 183-188, 2015.
Batterham and Dr. Alison L Calear (National Institute for [18] H. Hendin, J. T. Maltsberger, A. Lipschitz, A. P. Haas, and J.
Kyle, "Recognizing and responding to a suicide crisis," Ann N Y
Mental Health Research) who significantly contributed to Acad Sci, vol. 932, pp. 169-86; discussion 186-7, Apr 2001.
the ‘Detecting Suicidality on Twitter’ project. J.T., F.S. and [19] R. W. Maris, "Suicide," Lancet, vol. 360, pp. 319-26, Jul 27
H.C. thank Alive and Kicking Goals Suicide Prevention 2002.
[20] N. Cummins, S. Scherer, J. Krajewski, S. Schnieder, J. Epps,
Program (WA), the Young and Well Cooperative Research and T. Quatieri, "A Review of Depression and Suicide Risk
Centre, HITnet Innovations, Thought Works, Muru Marri Assessment using Speech Analysis," Speech Communication (In
Indigenous Health Unit UNSW, Kimberley Aboriginal Press), 2015.
[21] V. Sethu, J. Epps, and E. Ambikairajah, "Speech based emotion
community members, Men’s Outreach Service (WA), recognition," in Speech and audio processing for coding
Aboriginal Artists – Martha Lee, Danica Manado and Esah enhancement and recognition, T. Ogunfunmi, R. Togneri, and
Coffin, Nyamba Buru Yawuru Aboriginal Corporation, M. Narasimhai, Eds., ed New York: Springer, 2014, pp. 197-
Rubibi (Broome, WA), Goolarri Media (WA), Dr Kathy 228.
[22] Z. N. Karam, E. M. Provost, S. Singh, J. Montgomery, C.
McKay, BackTrack (NSW) and Samsung for their help and Archer, G. Harrington, et al., "Ecologically Valid Long-Term
support in the ibobbly study. Mood Monitoring of Individuals with Bipolar Disorder Using
Speech," 2014 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,
Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP), 2014.
REFERENCES [23] Mental Health America. Suicide. Available:
[1] World Health Organization, "Disease and injury regional http://www.mentalhealthamerica.net/suicide
mortality estimates, 2000–2012," 2012. [24] N. Cummins, J. Epps, V. Sethu, M. Breakspear, and R. Goecke,
[2] Australian Bureau of Statistics, "3303.0 - Causes of Death, "Modeling spectral variability for the classification of depressed
Australia, 2013," 2015. speech," in 14th Annual Conference of the International Speech
[3] Suicide Prevention Australia, "Overcoming the stigma of Communication Association, INTERSPEECH 2013, August 25,
suicide," 2010. 2013 - August 29, 2013, Lyon, France, 2013, pp. 857-861.
[4] D. J. France, R. G. Shiavi, S. Silverman, M. Silverman, and D. [25] N. W. Hashim, M. Wilkes, R. Salomon, and J. Meggs, "Analysis
M. Wilkes, "Acoustical properties of speech as indicators of of Timing Pattern of Speech as Possible Indicator for Near-Term
depression and suicidal risk," IEEE Trans Biomed Eng, vol. 47, Suicidal Risk and Depression in Male Patients," in 2012
pp. 829-37, Jul 2000. International Conference on Conference on Signal Processing
[5] A. Ozdas, R. G. Shiavi, S. E. Silverman, M. K. Silverman, and Systems (ICSPS 2012), 2012, pp. 6-13.
D. M. Wilkes, "Investigation of vocal jitter and glottal flow [26] T. Yingthawornsuk, H. Kaymaz Keskinpala, D. M. Wilkes, R.
spectrum as possible cues for depression and near-term suicidal G. Shiavi, and R. M. Salomon, "Direct acoustic feature using
risk," IEEE Trans Biomed Eng, vol. 51, pp. 1530-40, Sep 2004. iterative EM algorithm and spectral energy for classifying
[6] IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society, "IEEE suicidal speech," in 8th Annual Conference of the International
EMBS Code of Ethics." Speech Communication Association, Interspeech 2007, August
[7] P. A. Nutting, L. M. Dickinson, L. V. Rubenstein, R. D. Keeley, 27, 2007 - August 31, 2007, Antwerp, Belgium, 2007, pp. 749-
J. L. Smith, and C. E. Elliott, "Improving detection of suicidal 752.
ideation among depressed patients in primary care," Ann Fam [27] S. Scherer, J. Pestian, and L.-P. Morency, "Investigating the
Med, vol. 3, pp. 529-36, Nov-Dec 2005. speech characteristics of suicidal adolescents," in 2013 38th
[8] J. J. Mann, A. Apter, J. Bertolote, A. Beautrais, D. Currier, A. IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal
Haas, et al., "Suicide prevention strategies: a systematic review," Processing, ICASSP 2013, May 26, 2013 - May 31, 2013,
JAMA, vol. 294, pp. 2064-74, Oct 26 2005. Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2013, pp. 709-713.
[9] K. A. Van Orden, T. K. Witte, K. C. Cukrowicz, S. R. [28] T. Donker, K. Petrie, J. Proudfoot, J. Clarke, M. R. Birch, and H.
Braithwaite, E. A. Selby, and T. E. Joiner, Jr., "The interpersonal Christensen, "Smartphones for smarter delivery of mental health
theory of suicide," Psychol Rev, vol. 117, pp. 575-600, Apr programs: a systematic review," J Med Internet Res, vol. 15, p.
2010. e247, 2013.
[10] N. Eagle, A. S. Pentland, and D. Lazer, "Inferring friendship [29] Black Dog Institute. (2015). Overview of the iBobbly trial.
network structure by using mobile phone data," Proc Natl Acad Available: http://digitaldog.org.au/programs/ibobbly-black-dog-
Sci U S A, vol. 106, pp. 15274-8, Sep 8 2009. institute/
[11] J. N. Rosenquist, J. H. Fowler, and N. A. Christakis, "Social [30] T. Callinan. (2014). Remote Indigenous Australians rely on
network determinants of depression," Mol Psychiatry, vol. 16, Facebook to stay in touch. Available:
pp. 273-81, Mar 2011. http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/08/26/remote-
[12] M. C. Pachucki, E. J. Ozer, A. Barrat, and C. Cattuto, "Mental indigenous-australians-rely-facebook-stay-touch
health and social networks in early adolescence: a dynamic study [31] N. Lee, "Trouble on the radar," Lancet, vol. 384, p. 1917, 2014.
of objectively-measured social interaction behaviors," Soc Sci
Med, vol. 125, pp. 40-50, Jan 2015.

7319

You might also like