Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sblimacija Leda Lukov - Lebedev
Sblimacija Leda Lukov - Lebedev
A. V. LUIKOV
Heat and Mass Transfer Institute, Byelorussian Academy of Sciences, Minsk. BSSR, USSR
and
D. P. LEBEDEV
Chemical Engineering Institute, Moscow, USSR
Abstract-The basic transfer equations for evaporation of a solid body into vacuum are considered.
Experimental results on ice sublimation with thermoradiative and conductive heat supply as well as on
sublimation in drying processes and continuous sublimation process from a permeable plate are presented.
These studies explain the peculiarities of the sublimation mechanism for different energy supplies and
under periodic and continuous conditions of the process. With ice sublimation from a porous permeable
plate near a surface, a stepwise change in temperature is observed at a distance of several lengths of the
mean free path of vapour molecules.
l-UC,
x = I-Ic**iic al (10)
1 1
Nu,Kn + 2
+ (2 - ” grad div G (12)
because to a first approximation it is possible P
to consider I z a. The total resistance (l/K++)
is thus equal to where D is the velocity, F is the external force,
1
p is the density, q is the dynamic viscosity
-=&+f.
K ++
(11) coefficient, z is the time, y is the relation of gas
heat capacity at a constant pressure to that at
a constant volume.
The diffusional resistance (l/Nu,Kn) is in-
If the continuity coefficient K, is equal to
versely proportional to the product of the
zero (K, = 0), then at y = 1 equation (13) is
Nusselt and Knudsen numbers (Nu,Kn).
reduced to Navier-Stokes’ classical equation.
Under ordinary conditions of liquid evapora-
The continuity coefficient K, is
tion at atmospheric pressure the Knudsen
number is small (Kn 4 1). The Nusselt number
is also small. Then the diffusional resistance K, = $Kn.M (13)
(l/Nu,Kn) is large, as compared to the kinetic
one (l/A), and the evaporation process is where M is the Mach number.
determined by the transfer process (see equation Thus, at a low velocity u (the Mach number
(I)). is small) the continuity coefficient K, is small,
However, with evaporation into a vacuum the however, in a deep vacuum (Kn 9 1) the con-
Knudsen number Kn sharply increases (Kn N l), tinuity coefficient may not be taken as equal to
therefore, for some evaporation regimes the zero. A. S. Predvoditelev’s theory is based on the
diffusional resistance becomes less than the assumption that transport velocities of mole-
kinetic one (NuJ’Cn 9 A). The evaporation cules vary at a distance of a mean free path of
process is then determined by the rate of phase molecules. Thus, when solving heat and mass
transition (j = IAiic, = IA&J. These rela- transfer problems involving sublimation it is
tions are valid in the molecular evaporation necessary to start with equation (12) but not
regime. In a transient molecular-viscous regime with the Navier-Stokes’s equation.
when the liquid vapour pressure P, is consider- The experiment shows that evaporation from
ably higher than the partial pressure P,, of the an ice surface occurs non-uniformly. Evapora-
air (an inert gas), i.e. P, B Pa, hydrodynamics tion takes place from certain surface sections
of heat and mass transfer between a body and a and is related to microdefects of an ice surface.
surrounding medium may be described by the If ice evaporation occurs from a porous body,
Navier-Stokes transfer equation with a correc- then pores and capillaries of a body tilled with
tion for the continuity coefftcient K, which was the ice are the sites of evaporation.
for the first time introduced by A. S. Predvo- In this case some averaged velocity of a
ditelev [2]. vapour (<) is observed.
1090 A. V. LUIKOV and D. P. LEBEDEV
H.M.
;I --growth ot’crys(als at a subtimabtc surface of ice made of water
bf.M.
FIG. 4. Ice surface in a sublimation process with thermoradiative heat supply. The side of the gauze mesh is 70pm.
The vacuum is 0.5 mm Hg. The temperature of the emitter is 200°C.
H.M.
FIG. 6. Propagation of the sublimation front (zone) in the film model.
A-vapour zone
B-ice zone of a fine-crystalline structure
H.M.
FIG. 7. Moisture sublimation into vacuum in a single glass macro~pillary (0 200 pm) withoul its pre-
liminary freezing. The vacuum is 0.5 mm Hg.
H.M.
FIG. 8. Ice-water sublimation into vacuum in the “film model” with a metal gauze for the case of conductive
heat and mass supply.
H.M.
STUDY OF THE ICE SUBLIMATION PROCESS 1091
mines the temperature drop at the ice-vapour (c) Existence of internal defects of an ice
interface which may be equal to several degrees. structure. These internal defects of a structure
The proof of this statement* is as follows: after appearing at a sublimation surface become
(1) measurement of values of temperature apparent as “centres” of the growth of crystals
jumps with ice sublimation from a permeable from the vapour phase.
plate in case of continuous conductive heat For example, different ions in water, of which
supply PI the ice polycrystal [14] is made, may be such
(2) re-emission effect with ice sublimation into “centres” of crystallization. If at the surface of
vacuum as established in [7] which shows that the ice, made of bidistilled water, there is
in vacuum when the length of the mean free practically no growth of crystals, then the
path considerably differs from the distance of an inclusion of different ions into the water (into
ice surface to an emitter screen the flow of a crystalline lattice of the ice) considerably
sublimable vapour molecules is reflected from changes the pattern of surface growth of crystals,
the emitter screen back to the sublimation Fig 2.
surface and intensifies the sublimation process Figure 2a shows a crystal growing at a
(3) pressence of small optical non-uniformity sublimable surface of ice made of conducting
near a sublimation surface [20] water. The growth and the shape of crystals at
(4) growth of crystals at a sublimation surface. the ice surface considerably change, depending
The growth of crystals at the surface of a on pH in a liquid bidistilled water sample. In
sublimable ice layer with thermoradiative heat Figs. 2b and c are given the crystals growing at a
supply is determined not only by a decrease sublimation surface at pH = 10. While increas-
near a sublimation surface but is a result of ing pH up to 12.5 the dendrite shape of crystals
simultaneous action of the following factors turns into a “petalled” one, Fig. 2e. The addition
[6, 7, 141:
(a) considerable increase in the concentration
of water vapour subliming from an ice surface
at the interface (ice-vapour in the sublimator
chamber);
(b) geometrical non-uniformities (“striped
structure”) of an ice surface, Fig. 4.
The geometrical non-uniformity of an ice
surface in a thermoradiative flow causes the 400 -
PH
* A temperature drop near a sublimation surface with FIG. 3. Dependence of maximum height of crystals growing
thermoradiative heat supply may be measured directly at a sublimable surface of ice and of sublimation rate
with considerable errors. AC/AT upon pH in a liquid water sample.
1092 A. V. LUIKOV and D. P. LEBEDEV
of Ca2+ ions into a bidistilled water sample crystal into two regions: first which is in contact
creates a new curious spherical shape of crystals, with the heating surface and second in which
Fig. 2d. The dependence of the sublimation there takes place volumetric sublimation.
intensity upon VG/Vr in a liquid water sample
and appropriate height I+ of the crystals growing
at a sublimable surface is shown in Fig. 3.
As is seen from Fig. 3, the growth of crystals 4-
moisture there occur both a decrease in the rate The ejection of a vapour and ice particles
of drying and increase in temperature of the through an ice interlayer into the vacuum may
material. lead to the destruction of the whole capillary-
porous skeleton. This fact should be borne in
Sublimation from a porous skeleton mind not only with sublimation drying when
In the film model [18], of the diaphragmatic using the traditional modes of energy supply
radiative flow q where the nickel imitates the (radiation, conduction) but also with drying by
edge of a capillary-porous body, there took means of high-frequency currents.
place plastic ice deformation of a glass-like
structure (region B) with the formation of a line- Continuous process of ice sublimation into vacuum
crystalline structure of the ice and its subsequent from a permeable plate
sublimation, Fig. 6. In the sublimation process In a steady-state regime with the continuous
two zones are formed: zone of a vapour A, supply of the constant-temperature water and
Fig. 6c and zone of a tine-crystalline structure. with a constant heat flux inside a metal-
The sublimation region may be referred to as a ceramic plate the temperature fields are estab-
region of the destructive ice of a line-crystalline lished which divide this plate into three phase
structure. regions [ll, 133:
It may be observed in Fig. 6 how elements of a 1. liquid-phase region, in which the entering
fine-crystalline structure of the ice are sublimed water supercools up to crystallization tempera-
(decrease in sizes) and are partially, under the ture;
action of a created pressure drop, entrained in 2. solid-phase region, in which there take
the form of separate fine crystals into the subli- place solidification (crystallization) of the water
mation chamber. and supercooling of crystals up to sublimation
In the case of a constant radiative heat flux temperature;
the thickness (depth) of the sublimation region 3. gaseous or vapour phase-region, in which
decreased with a decrease in vacuum as well as there occurs migration of sublimable molecules
the diameter of the pores of a skeleton. The into the ambient medium-the vacuum cham-
increase of a thermoradiative heat flux led to ber.
increase in the thickness (depth) of the sublima- Unlike the ice sublimation processes with the
tion region. Strictly speaking, it is impossible to thermoradiative and contact heat supply when
speak here about the concept on a sublimation the ice temperature (with a heat load up to
surface in a capillary-porous skeleton since a 1600 kcal/m’h and a pressure in the sublimator
sublimation process occurs in a surface layer of 0.5 mm Hg = 66.6 N/m’) was not more than
of the ice (sublimation zone) of a fine-crystalline - 18°C its temperature in a porous plate did
structure. not exceed -2, -4°C whereupon accordingly
The process of preliminary freezing of a the ice had smaller density and strength.
capillary-porous skeleton considerably influ- For the study of a mechanism of this complex
ences sublimation in vacuum. The presence of process of sublimation the model imitating this
unfrozen free moisture in a capillary-porous process was developed in [13]. The model
body in a sublimation process leads to the forma- consisted of a fine gauze fixed between flat
tion of local regions with an overestimated transparent optical glasses. The water and heat
vapour pressure [13]. In Fig. 7 is shown a were supplied to this gauze from below. During
process of formation of vapour bubbles; in experiments the upper part of the gauze was
Figs. 7a, b, their sublimation ; in Figs. 7c, d, the connected to a vacuum.
ejection of ice plugs and unfrozen moisture from The model developed made possible the
a glass macro-capillary (Fig. 7e). visualization of the process and high-speed
1094 A. V. LUIKOV and D. P. LEBEDEV
photography confirmed the hypothesis stated (b) coalescence of an ice line-crystalline struc-
in [ll, 131 and explained that continuous ture zone with a liquid region near the walls of a
migration of a substance into vacuum in the skeleton, Fig. 9b ;
presence of a fwecl solid phase ice occurs due to (c) ejection (breakthrough) of a liquid near
a periodic increase and decrease of sublimation the walls of a skeleton and its flow along a
and has a pulverizing character. When deepening surface (first stage of ejection), Fig. 9c. The most
or decreasing a sublimation surface in some possible regions of ejection are shown by the
places the thickness of the ice of a glass-like arrows in Fig. 9c.
structure may decrease so that there occurs The duration of the cycles diminishes with a
local ejection of moisture which after penetra- growth of a heat load and a decrease in the
tion into a sublimation zone almost instan- diameter of capillaries. The efficiency of micro-
taneously freezes, sometimes forming ice ejections with a decrease in a diameter of pores
columns. Then in these places there occurs ice and heat load also becomes smaller.
formation of a fine-crystalline structure and a It should be noted that the processes in all
glass-like structure, i.e. the process has a three phase regions are in a close dynamic
pulverizing character, Fig. 8. The analysis of interaction. If the moisture inflow from a liquid
the films obtained allows the separation of the region is disturbed or the vacuum in the sub-
mechanism of pulsations into the following hmator increases there occurs deepening of the
stages (Fig. 9): sublimation surface, unless the dynamic equili-
brium sets in with respect to the water supply
from a liquid region, its crystallization in a solid
phase region and sublimation in a vapour phase.
The external problem for the process under
(a)
consideration deals with the outflow of a water
vapour through pores of a permeable plate into
the vacuum accompanied by a stepwise change
of temperature in the vicinity of a surface at a
distance of an order of a mean free path.
(b) (d)
I I I 1
The value of the temperature jump depends 7. A. V. LUIKOV, B. M. SMOUKY, P. A. NO~IKOV and
on heat load and vacuum in the sublimator as E. A. VAGNER,On some peculiarities of a sublimation
mechanism and formation of ice crystals in vacuum,
well as type of flow of water vapour (viscous, Znzh. Fiz. Zh. 15, 782-787 (1968).
molecular-viscous, molecular). The mean free 8. D. P. LEBEDEV,Kinetics of ice sublimation under
path of a jet may be taken as a thickness of an vacuum at conductive heat supply with a movable
boundary; Heat transfer with ice sublimation at con-
active layer of vapour which is considerably ductive heat supply with a movable boundary, Thermo-
superheated with respect to a vapour tempera- aerodvnamics. Izd. ITMO AN BSSR. Minsk (1970).
ture at a prescribed vacuum in the sublimator. 9. D. P.‘LEBEDEV,Kinetics of an ice sublimation process
under vacuum with radiative heat supply, Heat and
So, for example, when decreasing a pressure in Mass Transfer, Vol. 10. Nauka i tekhnika, Minsk (1968).
viscous flow at a constant heat load 4 = 7.7 x 10. D. P. LEBEDEV, Kinetics of ice-water sublimation from
lo3 W/m2 the thickness of the vapour layer porous metal ceramics, Izv. vuzov SSSR, Energetika
No. 4,92-97 (1970).
increases up to 3 mm (Fig. lo), the value of a 11. D. P. LEBEDEV, A mechanism of heat and mass transfer
temperature jump, up to 58°C. For a constant coefficients in ice sublimation in porous metal ceramics,
vacuum the thickness of a vapour layer adjacent 12 Zzv. vuzov. SSSR, Energetika No. 8, 8489 (1970).
H. G. KESSLER.Kiiltetechnik. Heft 6. 201-209 (1963).
to a wall remains constant and equal to 1 mm, 13: D. P. LEBnDEv’andT. L. P&EL&N; Some pecuharities
which corresponds to a value of a temperature of hydrodynamics and heat transfer with ice-water
jump around 2°C. sublimation from porous metal into vacuum, Problems
on Heat and Mass Transfer Theory. Izd. AN BSSR,
REFERENCES Minsk (1970).
1. A. V. LUIKOV and L. L. VASILIEV,Heat and mass 14. A. V. LUIKOV, Heat and Mass Transfer in Capillary
transfer of capillary-porous bodies in a rarefied gas Porous Bodies. Pergamon Press, Oxford (1966).
flow, Proc. Symposium Thermodynamic Aspects of 15. Trans. Japan. Sot. Mech. Engrs 34 (263), 1232-1238
Freeze Drying: Transfer of Heat and Mass in Porous (1968).
Systems and in Systems of Particles at a Low Pressure, 16. W. H. LAM~CIV and J. R. MARSHALL,Freeze drying with
Geneva (1966). radiant energy, Chem. Engng Prog. 48(l) (1952).
2. A. S. PREDVODITELEV, On the molecular-kinetic basis of 17. A. A. GUKHMANand E. A. ERMAKOVA, On heat transfer
hydrodynamic equations. Izv. AN SSSR, otdel tekhn. peculiarities with ice sublimation in a vacuum Zh.
nauk. No. 4 (1948). Tekh. Fiz. 23, 285-291 (1953).
3. C. G. TRUESDELL, Rational. Mech. Anal. 1, 125 (1950). 18. D. P. LEBEDEV,The study of ice-water sublimation
4. A. V. LUIKOV, T. L. PERELMAN,S. S. ANISIMOVand mechanism with conductive heat supply and con-
D. P. LEBEDEV,Kinetics and hydrodynamics of evapor- tinuous mass supply for models of capillary-porous
ation and sublimation processes, 4th. Int. Heat Transfer bodies, Inzh. Fiz. Zh. 19, 218-223 (1970).
Conf., Versailles (Sept. 1970). 19. A. V. LUIKOV,Drying Theory. Energia, Moscow (1969).
5. D. P. LEBEDEV,Peculiarities of the mechanism of ice 20. V. A. SOLOVIEV, Study of the density of a vapour-gas
sublimation under vacuum, Heat and Mass Transfer, medium in a boundary layer of sublimable ice, Inzh.
Vol. 11. Izd. ITMO AN BSSR, Minsk (1969). Fiz. Zh. 15, 804809 (1968).
6. D. P. LEBEDEV,Crystal formation at the surface of a 21. A. V. Lur~ov, Analytical Heat Diffusion Theory.
sublimable layer with ice sublimation into vacuum, Academic Press, New York (1968).
Inzh. Fiz. Zh. 15, 794-804 (1968).
RCumLOn considere les equations fondementales de transfert pour l’tvaporation dun corps solide
dans le vide. On presente des resultats experimentaux sur la sublimation de glace aver apport de chaleur
par rayonnement et conduction aussi bien que ceux sur la sublimation dans des pro&lb de sechage et le
pro&de de sublimation continue a partir dune plaque permeable. Ces etudes expliquent les particular&s
du mecanisme de sublimation pour differents apports d’energie et sous des conditions p&iodiques et
continues du processus. Avec la sublimation de glace depuis une plaque poreuse permeable pres dune
surface, un changement echelon de temperature est observe a une distance de plusieurs longeurs de libre
parcours moyen des molecules de vapeur.
1096 A. V. LUIKOV and D. P. LEBEDEV