Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of Composite
Insertion Technique on
Cuspal Deflection Using an
Clinical Relevance
All insertion techniques using composite materials caused measurable cusp deflection
during polymerization, with little difference between different incremental techniques.
The silorane-based composite produced significantly less cuspal movement.
lm. The deflections in group B were 1) 38.82 6 recognized that the overall size and cavity config-
3.64 lm, 2) 50.39 6 9.17 lm, 3) 55.62 6 8.16 lm, uration influence the resulting shrinkage stress and
and 4) 49.61 6 8.01 lm. Cuspal flexure for the the degree of cuspal deflection.12-16 Many different
low-shrinkage composite was 11.14 6 1.67 lm incremental insertion techniques are recommend-
(group A: 4 mm depth) and 16.53 6 2.79 lm ed; however, the evidence used to define the most
(group B: 6 mm depth). appropriate technique is inconclusive, and many
Conclusions: All insertion techniques using questions remain. Research to measure the degree
conventional composite caused cuspal defor- of cuspal deflection with different materials and/or
mation. In general, deeper preparations techniques in vitro has inherent limitations. The
showed increased cuspal deflection—except use of extracted teeth can be problematic as a result
of their size, shape, and biological differences.16 In
posite and ivorine teeth, a pilot study using standard ane-based) composite (Filtek LS, 3M ESPE, St Paul,
microtensile testing was carried out. A group of MN, USA) inserted in bulk.
ivorine teeth were sectioned, air-abraded, and Bonding for all subgroups restored with Spectrum
bonded to both methacrylate and silorane-based TPH3 was carried out using Scotchbond Multi-
resin composite using identical bonding agents and Purpose Adhesive (3M ESPE), omitting the dentin
procedures as for the cuspal deflection study de- primer step. The low-shrinkage composite restora-
scribed below. Standard microtensile serial section- tions were bonded using the corresponding silorane
ing and bond strength testing (Bisco, Schaumburg, adhesive, following the manufacturer’s recommen-
IL, USA) were performed. Means were calculated dations. Restorations were inserted and photo-
and were considered adequate to ensure attachment polymerized using a Demetron LC halogen light
of restorations to the cavity walls. curing unit (Sybron Dental Specialist, Orange, CA,
Prepared teeth were divided into two main groups USA) with an intensity of 400 mW/cm2. All sub-
of 30 specimens each: group A (4 mm depth) and groups received the same total curing time of 80
group B (6 mm depth). Each group was further seconds, as defined in Table 1, and in all cases the
subdivided into five subgroups (n=6) according to light cure was directed from the occlusal surface.
the composite and the insertion technique used. Four Light source was held as close as possible to the
subgroups were all restored using a conventional occlusal surface, avoiding any contact with the tooth
hybrid composite, Spectrum TPH3 (Dentsply, Caulk, to eliminate any effect on the Linear Variable
Milford, DE,USA), and were categorized according to Differential Transformers (LDTVs).
their insertion technique, as follows: 1) bulk inser-
tion, 2) horizontal increments, 3) tangential incre- Cuspal Deflection Measurements
ments, and 4) a modified tangential technique Cuspal deflection was measured continuously
(Figure 1). The fifth subgroup of both groups was throughout the restorative placement procedure
restored using a proprietary low-shrinkage (silor- using two LVDTs (AX/1/S, Omega, Stamford, CT,
Cavity Depth Bulk Insertion Horizontal Increments Tangential Increments Modified Tangential Increments
Group A (4 mm) 80 seconds 1 mm þ 1.5 mm þ 1.5 mm Two equal increments 1 mm þ two equal increments
20 3 20 3 40 = 80 s 40 3 40 = 80 s 20 3 30 3 30 = 80 s
20 3 20 3 40 = 80 s 40 3 40 = 80 s 20 3 30 3 30 = 80 s
302 Operative Dentistry
a
Means followed by different on-line small capital letters are significantly
Figure 3. LVDTs connected to data acquisition system, in which the
different at p , 0.05.
entire setup was assembled on a stabilized table to minimize noise.
Jafarpour & Others: Composite Insertion Techniques and Cuspal Deflection 303
when smaller dimension cavities were utilized. Use this effect was due to light attenuation preventing
of an experimental silorane low-shrinkage composite the deepest layers of the restoration from full
in natural bicuspids resulted in a cuspal deflection of polymerization, which was carried out from the
6 lm using a slightly smaller preparation size and a occlusal surface. In essence it is possible that the
greater (8) number of increments than were used in polymerization light was curing the composite to full
the current study. 4 These comparisons provide some cure only for the first 4 mm of depth, thus negating
validation of the ivorine model used. any major differences between 4 mm and 6 mm
Ivorine teeth do not, however, replicate the depths. In contrast, the use of increments allowed
combined properties of dentin and enamel inherent full access of each increment to the light, and full
in natural tooth structure; therefore, the use of cure was effected, resulting in the development of