Desai 2

!
"
$ %
&
*
Conrad, Joseph, Heart of Darkness
2
3
' $ (
( & ) ( * " + ,-.- (
/01221 1- 3 1221 ( & 3 (4
3 5( 3 6 7
8 '19 516 5 6 : 8 '2-
';;/ <9 516 5 6 &
';;9 5 ' ';;-6 8 '5'6 5 6 & (
';;- 5 '2 ';;-6
1 ( 7 3 4 8 $ 3 4
= " 7 3 4 $
>
$ 5 ?
?6
<
#
# @
. & (
: 8 + '2- ';;/ 5';;/
6' A #
( #
1
Section 103 (1) of the 1996 Constitution
4
# #
1
,
,3 1221
( * & & 8
@ ( ( 3
B & $
+ A 5?+A ?6 (
C 5C 6 5 $ $
* & ( 6 3
<
> 5> 6 ( 3 +A & (
@
/ B >
C
# C % '
( D C A(
B C #
#
C > $ * $
* D 5?D ?6 #
* B 5B 6
% #
C
2
Section 125(1)(2) of the 1996 Constitution
3
Record, evidence of Fraser, p8 - 9
4
Record, evidence of Fraser, p11 - 14
5
9 C @ # #
$ D $ C 5C 6 $ E*
& ( '$
';;/ <' 4 1221
# # 5
# 6
C #
- > E
C > 3
(
; (
@ @
& $
'2 F
@ F
! " #$ " ! % & " ' &

(!$$!) #* ((' !( +' ((' !(
' ! $ ( !+ ,--. ! / ' $% ' 0 !& '
$ '! ! + 0 + !( !
' (! + '! / 0 $ && !( (! + ! + '%+ ' ) '
&% ' (! + '! ) & ! 1
# %& !( &% 2 '$$ + ! & )' ' !2' ' $
+' '& '! / & " 1
6
* + $" ' & 3! ' 0%$ ' ' & ! " !( *

" &! ! ! 0 '& '! ' $ '! ! '&&% &
+ '! ' , , # 1
*! + $ 2 !! ! ! '&&% &
( !' , , # #!2 4
* (' ' 0& ' &" !( #!2 1

# * !++ '! & ' &" !( &% (' ' 0&4
'' B '/ 1221 ( ( * " ,-,9 +

-01221 ( /01221 ( 3 #
E
F
$$ 0 '" !( +! ' &3# (' &/ ' ) &! 2

" ' */ #* * !( # $!) + '! " &! & ( !+ 56 0
7& / 5 7& ! * " &! ! '* '
# &1
' +' 3 +' & !( !2' !( &
" ( !+ ,--. ! ! * ( +'$* + +# !( &%
" &! 1
'' * " &! &&! ' )' !((' !( +' !(
& " 84
'1
4G
7 5?7 ?6
7
'<
, 3 1221
+A @
( ( 3
'. '< 3 1221

$ C F
($%'& 9 "" ' 9 "& " $ + / "'! &' 9 &

! %$8
E F
: & 2 &"'! &' + $%'& ' 0 ) ' ;

5 + & ! !$" '& 0'& ' &9 "&
" $ + &0 #!% !!"0 7 " ' % 0 ' $'0 ' 0 # 7!+
%' & 0 2! + $%'& +! ' ' 0& ! %& ' 0
' 0 2' '&8
', A $ C F
+' & & ' '" & + $%'& ! %& ' 0 0 2' '& <
! %& ' 0 !+ !" $ (!! $* ' $%'& / +'7 !& & !+
' $%'& !" 0 &" 77 ' 7 ! ! %& ' 0 !+ 2 !"
; (& !" 0 &" 77 ' &7 7 $4 ' ' $'0 ' 0 '&
! ( 7$'7 #* ; &'! $ 0 ' 0&# ! # 2 & '04
8
0 $'0 & ' ! &! 7 # ) ' ' $'0 ' 0 )

+ ' ! %& ' 0 ' 0 & + $ '&/ ) &7* $'7 0 # %'7 '& !+
!+2 $ 00 & !! "!$' ' ' +" ' & !%4
' )! 0$! 0!% ' 7 ! !& ) ' ) & ' '
) 0 ) 0 #!% ) 00 &$%' '&84
'/ (
@ 3 = :
5 + 5? + ?6 & 6 3
7 C 5C 6 $ 5?$ ?6
'9 B ,. =>>= ?
&%&" ' ) 7 !( ;#%00' 0: "$! < (( )! 7 )'
F
(' /) ' ' $% $ " ! ""' 0 @%'"+ / +' !9

&+' & (! #%00' 0 !((' & $'& ' 0 2' &/ ) &
&%$ !( !% ' &) " !( 0!2 + ' & $$ '! &48
'- $ C F
' 0$! 0 &7! & ' + $%'& &7 $A
%&& ' '& $ ! !+ ' &"'! * 0'&

2 ' " +' 2 # ) ' 0& ; 7!2 &"'! &' 9
' ' % & '! +" 2 ' " !2' &' $
+' '& &' # *( '& B ' ' / ) # ) ' 0 +
& &0 $ # *( '&/ '& 0$! ' 2 $ C ! #' 48
9
'; B ,D =>>=
F
" !2' ' $ $ 0'&$ '2 #%00' 0 +*& * & " /

)' &!% & $!& ! +' '& '! ! (' +' 0
' 2 & '0 '! & )' ! ' $% $$ 0 '! &
&!" '& ' ' (! + '! !$!0* " !0 ++ & )
%& ! +! ' ! & (( !+"% &48
12 E E
1'
@
+ + + ( 5 ++( 6 $
C
11 & (
: 8 + '2- ';;/ 5';;/
,
6 : 8
1< ';;/ :
/
:
1. ';;/
A '2.
5
Section 103 (1) of the 1996 Constitution
6
Section 2 of the 1996 Constitution
10
';;/ & (
)9 #
)-
;
#
1, A #
( # #
'2
#
1/ ';;/
';;/
''
#
'1
19 & (
7
Section 104 (1)(b)(I) read with schedule 4
8
Section 104 (1)(b) (ii) read with schedule 5 of the 1996 Constitution
9
Section 104(1)(b)(iii) of the 1996 Constitution
10
11
Section 143(2) of the 1996 Constitution
12
11
'<
'/ 4 ';;- & (

'.
A
@ '-
',
+ ';;9
1- A 8 9 & &
* E
& A
@
E
E
1; ';;- &
+ ++( $( 5
$ 6 $
A
';;- '' + 122' 3 * 3
53 6 ( & (
# $
<2 > B ';;- ,$ 122' 3 D 3 "53 "6

3 > # > 1-
13
The Constitution of the Western Cape, 1 of 1998
14
Ex parte speaker of the Western Cape Provincial Legislature: in re certification of the Constitution of the
Western Cape, 1997(4) SA 795 CC
15
Ex parte speaker of the Western Cape Provincial Legislature: in re certification of the amended text of the
Constitution of the Western Cape, 1997, 1998(1) SA 657 CC
12
4 1222 , $ 122' C 3 8
#
8 C # $ 122' $
( 3
H & 8
$
++( 3 3 "
$ ( 3 ++(
<' + $ 122'
+ ++(
$ 3 (
3 H
$ ( 3 (
& ( , $ 122'
# + ++(
( 3 5 ( 6
<1 $ 3 1221 ( 3 (
++( 3 3 8
<< ( &
'/
( 8
A &
( 5
6 $ 8 )
= ) I ) = ) = )
> ) 7 ) ( D * ) 7 ) 8
16
Public Service Act, Act 103 of 1994, and in particular Section 7
13
'9
8 =
) )
)
'-
<. $ ';;. ' + ';;/ $ E* F

& ( 3 C
' $ ';;/ C ,
# , 122' 7
<' 4 1221 B , 4 1221
D $ E*
E E
<,
1221
& (
</ A
=#
& $
<9 8 E* $
8 5?8 ?6
17
Public Service Act, Act 103 of 1994, Section 7 read with schedule 2
18
Public Service Act, Act 103 of 1994, Section 7(3)(b)
14
& )
+ &
( )
+ &
( & C 8 )
<-
0 & (
<; & (
'2 ';;- :
" &
(
( >
E #
.2 &
& (
15
B
$ E* 3 8 >
@ : 3 (
.' 3
A #
C
B $
$ * $ * #
#
@
.1
#
%
(
+ #
A
@
& (
16
.< @ B ( 8
3 8 3 > #
#
:
+
.. C
C $ J * A
E # +
@
C C @
., C @
C + 4 8
5 8 6 7 E #
./
.9 +A +A
D 4 C " 5C " 6
& (
17
E #
C
8
.- 8 @ (
( 3
# 7
(
7 @
3 3 D 5D 6 ( 3 53 6
A 7 % $ 3
3 " 3 4 4 C
5C 6 C I C ( 7 8 57
8 6 3K 5 3K 6
.; A 7
7 E #
$ 3 3 " &
5& 6 3 J 5J 6 5
7 6 3 C J " 5J "6 5
7 % 6) ( 5
7 6) 3 = 3 5=
3 6) 3 & 8 58 6 3 = 7 57 6
& @
E # 7 $ 57
8 * 5* 66
3 3 53 6 8
E #
$ 3 3 " A 8 5?8 ?6 $ 8
18
5?$ 8 ?6 & 8 5?8 ?6 $

E #
,2 $ 3 3 "
7 +A ( #
@
E #
,'
#
< 222 #
,1 >
& ( #
#
@ E
A
#
#
19
,<
+A
5
6
+A
#
,. A #
$
4 1221 $ E*
$ D
% @
,,
E #
20
,/
7 ',1 A 5
7
6
7 %
A
,9 @
$ 3 3 " 8
$
= I L
$ 3 3 "
7 A *
8 " = IL 7 8
';
#
,- # 0
@
= IL A
$3;; 222 22
= I L
$
3 *
4 54 6 # @
C
19
Exhibit “BBB"
21
# 4
#
$ 4
7 = I L
,; B 4
$
= IL
: $
A = I L
@
$
@ $ = IL :
@ 4
F G
/2 A E
D
/' ';,
F
'0 & !( " !( &&'! $ ' & +%& #

" !+! + ' ' 4
22
# ((' ' / ! !+' (( '2 %& !( &!% & +%&

# " !+! 4
%#$' +' '& '! +%& # 2 $!"+ 9! ' 4
2' & +%& # " !2' '+" ' $$*/ ( ' $*/ @%' #$*
)' !% #' &4
!"$ H& & +%& # &"! !/ "%#$'
+%& # !% 0 !" ' '" ' "!$' *9+ 7' 04
( %#$' +' '& '! +%& # !% #$ 4
0 &" * +%& # (!& #* " !2' ' 0 "%#$'
)' '+ $*/ &&'#$ % ' (! + '! 4
!! %+ 9 &!% + 0 + 9
2 $!"+ " ' &/ ! + I'+'& %+ "! ' $/
+%& # %$ '2 4
' %#$' +' '& '! +%& # # ! $* " & '2 !(
!% ( ' " !"$ / )' +"$!*+
" &! $ + 0 + " ' & # & ! #'$' */
!#C '2' */ ( ' &&/ ! &&
'+# $ & !( " & ! ' 2 # ! " & '! 48
/1 ( 8 ';;.
# E E
( 8 : ( 8
7 : ( 8 E C
A ( 8 ';;.
)
23
/< ( 8
( 8
$ E* A
( 8 0
=# ( 7 0
E
3 ( 8
<5165'6
/. ( > 3 ';;;
#
: 8
C :
/,
+ ';;/ ( A
';-1 : *
: ( 3 A 8 8
$
// # @
B ( $ E*
24
F
/9 & $
@ B
%
& $ 3>
( D
+A
'& !2 * !( !0
/- $ , 3 1221 +A
( D & 8
$
@ & $ &8'22
+A # .
$ $ E* C
+A
@
( 3 +A &
( > +A %
/; 8 @
@ 8 3 8=: A =8
5? 8 3?6 :<; ,,1 <2 $ @
B 98 122'
3
26
( D
" #'$' ' & !( !0 ,>>
92 B ,3 1221 +A #
A '- 3 1221 >
F
$'+' * && ! % ! !08

@%'"+ +! & ' ! & ! &+' *
'! ( @% * &'0 $&/ #% ' '2 )'
0 !( &" %+& &' 4 @%'"+ ) & !
! ) '& !2 (! ' '& '((' %$
! $ $* +' !) @%'"+ +'0 2
# %& 4 !) 2 / @%'"+ '& &'0 !
!" ' + % $$* ! % !+ ' $$*4 '& " #$
!( +! ' ! ' 0 % '! ( !+ 0 =. !% & *
&' / )' !% # ' 0 # +! $*
!" 4 $&! # %& ! +! ' ! + ' 0
) +' !" ! & %& ! ) &!+ ! '&
*' 0 2 & !""' 0 2' ' ! + ' 048 =>
9' %
1'
# & $
A
11
F
20
Page 3, para 3 of the report.
21
Exhibit D
22
Exhibit D, p9
27
!0 & # &'0 ! 0'2 *!% * & !(

& 2' & #%00' 0 2' '! &*& + &' 4 (
!+"$ ! !%0 &) " '& " (! + #*
" !( &&'! $&/ !0 # &'$* & %" (! =. !%
+! ' ! ' 0 (! )' $ && #%00' 0 2' &4 B (
"!) %"/ !0 & & ) !$ ( @% *
0 % !+ ' $$* & & ( ( @% * !
+' ) * #%00' 0 2' &! !
&' 4
1<
91 H & $
@
>
'222 @ A
A
& $ & $ <,
A & $ $ *!%
+! %$ &'0 $ )' " ! & &%&"
( @% * &' 4
9< A & $
@
1.
@
' C 2 $'&
>1 5 6
@
23
Exhibit D, p13
24
Exhibit D, p 31
28
>.
! " ! & ! C 7 *!%
$'& ! &!% 2!' 4
1 C &" '(' ( @% *
>'
>' @ # =
@ 5
37"6
) *!% & $! 7 8 ! *!% & /
! " ! C 7 ! % ' ! $'& 4
9. #
+A 4 ?
5? ?6 7 & $
7
& $
1,
& $ #
1/
9, $
& $
:>
& $ %
A
25
Record, p 31(3)
26
Record, p 31(30)
29
& $
B
& $
=
:>
& $
& $ A
5
6 & $
& $
9/ A C & $
A
M
& $
99 H E # 7
@
19
8
1-
7
1;
+A 7
<2
7
27
Record: p 2607(8)
28
Record: p 2635(5); 2643(23)
29
Record: p 2643(30)
30
Record: p 2644(10)
30
<'
# +
7
<1
& $ 7
# @ : 3
<<
! $%&'! & (' ' 0&
9- & $ &8'22
5 6
@
& $
+
& $
& $
+A @
& $
9;
& $
& $ )
"
)
31
Record: p 2644(21)
32
Record: p 2688(25)
33
ecord: p 2699(19)
R
31
-2 A & $ @
@
5
6
" ! % + " ! && (! !0
-' $ > & (

*
& $ $ > 3
: B 5B 6 12 3 1221
<.
-1 B 1; + 1222 8 3
$ E*
<,
@
@ &
5. $ 8 6 53 '
6 D A
& $ &8'22
( $ E* :
1 :',. ,/' 12
& $ &8'22% :-- -/' -/
:1.< .1< 2/
@ $ E
34
Exhibit E
35
Exhibit E, annexure U
32
* C @ + @
A 3 '19
';;1 A 8 3
-< $ $ 1222 C
$ 7 : 3 (
C D : # 5D : # 6
" D : # C 4 122'
D : # #
"
+A E
</
-. B '/ > 122'

C D : # : $
5?$ ?6 4 + ( 8 5?8 ?6 (
5?( ?6 C #
( %
( @
<9
-, 8 @ 8 5? ?6
$ 7 :
< 122' # # =
$ E*
(
36
Record, exhibit E, page 34
37
Record, exhibit E, page 34
33
( A 1 1222
53A886
<-
M F
A ( A 1
1222 $ E* #
(
A B
7
<;
.2
$ E
.'
* 8 E$ : 3
-/ # D : #
@ C 8
.1
$ 8 D : # $
C #
.<
38
Exhibit E, annexure V
39
40
41
42
Exhibit E: affidavit of Van Aarde, para 4
43
34
-9 #
..
C @
7 #
.,
@ @ B 1' 3 122' $ $
3 C
./
$ 3
$ 3
A
N
D
D 3
-- $ A
.9
: N F & C A
C '< 4 122' "
' $' 0
N
.-
$ 4 122' 3
.;
8 3
$ 3 C
3 $ E* 4 122'
$ : -
122' 3
44
45
46
Exhibit E, annexure X
47
Exhibit E, annexure W
48
Exhibit E, annexure W, para 6.2
35
N
3 $
-; B 1' 122' C
$ E* %
8 (8 B .
8 122' 3 D " D 5?D ?6 8 3
# @ $ E*
3 $ 5?$ ?6 8 3
& $ &8'22
,2
@ @ 3 D 8
& $ :19 /;, 22
:9 222 22 +
8 3
:<; ,,1 <2 # @
', 8 122'
$ & F * C (% & (!
'& & 2' 2 # "" !2 (! " *+ #* %+
&!% 0 + $ !%I "$ & " ! 48
;2 C , 8 122' $
8 3 @
# & $
:<; ,,1 <2 '/ B 122'
D : # "
= $ ;'' (
C : 4,'
49
Exhibit E, annexure Y
50
Exhibit E, annexure Z
51
Exhibit E, page 40
36
' ' 0&
;' @ $ ;''
A D : #
$ E* &
$
,1
@ $ ;''
& $
C 98 122' >
@ & $
,<
;1 @ @
& $ '2 . ' &
( $
@ @
;< & $
@ + @ @
( C @ ( C
* ( ( C
: 5J8 <96 # * ;
H = A
F
" ! & '+ 2 $% !( J> >>> " & 9

%""$' & & 2' &+ *# " ! % )' !% ' 2' ' 0
!+" '2 & ' & & ) $* $'2 * '& !(
'' $ '+"! ' 2' '! !( !+" '2
52
Exhibit E, page 40
53
Exhibit E, p 40
37
& '& ' '+"!&&'#$ ! '+" ' #$ 4 !) 2 /

'& $ 0 '! I $% & (' $'& '! !( " '
@%! '! (! & % ' * & 2' &4 ' @%! '! & (!
& % ' * & 2' & +%& # ( ! ((' !(
!2' ' $ ! (! (% '! 3
(' $'& '! 84
!% #'$' * 3 &"! &'#'$' *
;.
A
E
A
;, A C $ E*
& $ @
A
..5'65 6 ( > 3 ';;;
7
<-5'65 6 ( > 3 ';;;
+%& !+"$*/ &%
!+"$' #* " + / ' 0 '*! ! & ' % '! $
' & ' % '! / )' " !2'&'! & !( 48
38
;/ B ..
.,5 6
.. A -'516
..
;9
& $ $ &
7 8 A
& $ E$ F
B 8
.. ., ( > 3
!++ '!
;- A .
8 3 8 7 : << ' '
E$ B 8
@
;'' ( C :
0
& $
;; ( &
% #
#
39
F / F
F
'22 A
@ E
5A 6
' ' 0&
'2' +
40
% !!+ ! $!! /
!2' ' $ 0'&$ %
41
/
F
'21
A =#
3
<
=# 7
. @
C B
#
3
1 =# A E
'2< & & $
9 -
( &! & 2' 0 && ! % !!+ %& ! ) ' '

) & "%
'2. C
C 3 "
C M ( 3 & $
# "
42
,.
'2, C
B
,,
+ 122' A #
C
#
,/
$ E* & $
C
,9
A # C
3 8 5?8 ?6
,-
C
@ & $
A
,;
'2/ 3 ( J 5?J ?6 3
/2
122' 7
J
(
J
# 7
H C
/'
J B
54
Record, p 125(14)
55
Record, p 125(18)
56
Record, p 126(6)
57
Record, p 125(30)
58
Record, p 128(8)
59
Record, p128(25)
60
Record, p 305(10)
61
Record, p 309(27)
43
/1
J
/<
( *
'29 B 7 $ E* % B
> ';;- 8 1222
3 (
/.
D B
/,
C
B + 122' B
//
/9
'2- B C
3 ( 5( 6
/-
B %
C %
(
/;
B
92
7
9'
'2; 3 8 5?8 ?6
91
&
62
Record, p 310(11)
63
Record, p 310(15)
64
Record, p 399(18)
65
Record, p 403(10)
66
Record, p 405(3)
67
Record, p 405(16)
68
Record, p 407(23)
69
Record, p 408(3)
70
Record, p 408(30)
71
Record, p 409(6).
72
Record: p 791(21)
44
C B
9<
7
9.
A
''2 3
9,
122'
C C 3 " B
7
9/
0 *+ ' 0 ) & 7' 0 "$ # ) '((

"!$' ' $ " ' & :& !$ ! & #'$'&
!2 + !( & " 48KK A
( D A
3 # F %& ' ) & : ! + $ '+ &4
& & + * !( ! 2 & '! & !%0
)' + +# & !( +* " * ! / $+!& 2 # '+
' "" ' " &&/ +* !$$ 0% &/ '&
'& ) ! # + +' / '$ '
! && ' !+ ) +%& &7 ! "$ &
2 !% !!+& $ " ! & 7 (! #%00' 0
2' &48KD 7 # C %
#
3 % @
73
Record: p 792(6)
74
Record: p 792(10)
75
Record: p 2061(10)
76
Record: p 2062(23)
77
Record: p 2063(1)
45
9;
3 #
C
-2
3 8 (
3
#
-'
@ & $ @
''' C
-1
>
-<
+A %
(
-.
C
''1 C
-,
B
$
-/
8
-9 --
O
78
Record: p 2063(19)
79
Record: p 2064(8)
80
Record: p 2064(23)
81
Record: p 2068(20)
82
Record: p 2892(11)
83
Record: p 2892(20)
84
Record: p 2894(12)
85
Record: p 2905(17)
86
Record: p 2907(12)
87
Record: p 2907(17)
88
Record: p 2923(25)
46
''< C
-;
B (
(
( 7 #
;2
;'
# .
''. C
( 3 3 " C B
;1
# 'O 1
;<
@ C
J
;.
'', B C M
/O
1O
89
Record: p 2923(30)
90
Record: p 2926(27)
91
Record: p 2927(12)
92
Record: p 2928(18)
93
Record: p 2928(20)
94
Record: p 2930(4)
47
! $%&'! & (' ' 0&
''/
C (
( & *
''9 & $
#
( + * A
@ F
@
& $
+A
5 6 5
6
" )
A
A
+A
48
(
5 6
( )
& $
@
56
C
"
5 6 +
49
@
E
( * C & 8 )
5 6 C C B
+A A +A
* $
+A #
)
5 6 +
C & $ +
#
P
@
7
# 3
1221
# )
5 6
)
50
5 6
8 0B 122'
$
* &
C
* &
''- A
& $ @
# #
#
! % + $ ' 0 ! & #$'& + !( % !!+
''; D : # $ 7 :
;,
3 7 11
> 122' C C 3 $8 5?$
8 ?6 5 $ 8 6
95
Exhibit H
51
;/
$ 5?$ ?6 8 8
&
*
'12 B 1, 122' D : # C
7 & 3 4 7 5?
7 ?6 ;9 @
B 1 3 122'
C D : # 7 8 3
@ 1222 7
$ E* 8
8 C
;-
8 3@ 7
'1' B '/ 122' @
3 3 D 5? D ?6
$ & 3 ( & 5?& ?6 $ $
& $ B 8 D : # A
- 122'
$ 5B 8 6 D
$ *
'11 B 1- 122' C @ D : # #
3
7 D & C
D : # @
$ E*
96
Exhibit H, para 19
97
Exhibit H, p 7, para 21
98
Exhibit H, para 22
52
'1< B <' 122' D : #

C M @ & $ $
& , 8 122' A
C
<' 122' &
$ $ 8 7 F
= !!& * & ' &%" 2 + $ 2 0 ' 0

!! 0 7!+ # 2 & '0 7 0 0 ' ) 7 &;
& 7 2 ' 0 ' 2!! 7 % " '! ' '
! + (0 $ )! 4 ' '&
!! & 7$'7 &! ; ( &'$' ' #' ' 2!$0
) ) 7 0 (' $'& !" '! $
# &7'7# +! ) &4 0 )' 0 ) !" '
# & %% 2 ' $'0 ' 0 2 ! " &&' 0 '&/ !! & 7
&! ; ( &'$' ' 4
? !!& !! 0 7!+ & $ !%'& *
+ % !' ' ' ' 2 # 2' & $ )
% !"&'0 2 ' & $$' 03 ! %& 2 ;
!+0 )' 0 ) ' ' 0 ' ' 2 ' $!7 $
;;
2 & 7 3' & !% ! & % 4
'1. B ,8 122' D : # E 3 :( 5?( ?6

# 7 @
@ 5 :<; 222 226
'22
B , 8 122' ( E
' & !% ' 0& 7&' &
99
Exhibit H, annexure L
100
53
$ D : #
@ ( @
'2'
D : #M
'1, & &

@ D8
'1/ A
B
'21
A
@ & $ &8'22
:, ''; 22
E
'2<
' ' 0
'19 A B
101
102
Exhibit E, p 40, Record
103
Record, p 308(9)
54
'2.
104
Exhibit E, p 40, Record
55
E
E E
56
'1- & (
%
B
$ E* $ 8
B
$ E*
#
F F F E
'1; C
<4 1222 C
$
', 1222 '8 1222 '2, D8
8 5
. 8 12226
C 3 . 8 1222'2/ B '< 8 1222 D
8 8 C C $8
'<2 A 8 8
. 8 1222 . $ 1222 A
3 4 5?4 ?6 $
105
Electronic Diary, Dr Barnard.
106
Electronic diary, Dr Barnard, 4 September 2000
57
$ * 3 8
& 5?& ?6 8 3 B 1222
'<' +
19 + 1222 8 8
L < (( ! &&'& ' "&* !$!0' $ " !('$' 0 !(
( ' $ %&$'+ $ + &8/
# % ( * C
F
" & & ! &'& $* ( * !

)' ! 4 ! ! & &
& ' $$'0 0 * )' "!$' ' $
$ ) (! + #! */ ( '$& !
% & ) * $ ) (! + ! $ ' $*
)' ' !% ( ' !% " &8
'<1 A F
+'0 (! # !( 2 $% ! ! 2 * !
"" !" ' (! %+ :& )'$$' 0 && ! & '
" !('$' 0 ' !0 '! '@% & ' $* )'
'2 & ' 2!$2 ' ' !0 '! !( &%&" &
& (! ' ' & !( % # 2'!$ ' &
" 84
'29
'<< B 19 + 1222 8 3 33 " 5?3 "?6 C
3 " 8 8
107
Electronic diary, Dr Barnard, 27 November 2000
58
8 5?8 88?6 @ 03 122'

( 8 8
'<. $ 8 1222 3 122'
B 1. 4 122' 8 $ 8
# & (! " + !( !++% ' * ( *L
'& %&&'! ! %+ 8
$ 8
0
$ 5
# % 6
8 8
C 4 $ 8 F
'2-
A 5J36 5
# % 6
B , 3 122' 8
58(AH6 & ( * F
'2;
$ 5 #
% 6
'<,
58(AH6 ( *
108
Exhibit “F”, page 27 to 40
109
Annexure “F”, page 41 to 50
59
& # &&' 0 ' (! + '! '

' & !( &!% '&'! + 7' 0 $ ' 0 ! '+" !2 & 2' 84
' !+"$' )'
+' '+%+ ' (! + '! & % '* & & 8 0%' $' & <
&"! &'#$ (! " ! ' 0& &' '2 ' (! + '! @% '
#*/ ! 2 $ ! !2' ' $ !2 + % % &48 A
E
:';, 22
B # :,2 222 22
:/22 222 22 A
3
8 A
#
( $ * 0
8(AH F
0' $ ' 0 (! + '! ' )'$$

'+ !%&$* " !2' &%((' ' / $' #$ / $ 2
$*& ' (! + '! !( '0 & @% $' * ! !"
+ 0 + !( & " !2' ' $ ! $
!2 + & ' &%""! !( &!% / 7 !)$ 0 9 '2
& 0' '&'! + 7' 01
% ' )'$$ &'0 '+"$ + (( '2 + &% & !

" ! & &' '2 ' (! + '! ' !+"$' )'
0%' $' & " & '# #* $ !2 + 48
60
'</ A
@ #
F
A )
)
$ )
B
'<9 F''2
Premier Director General
Deputy DG
IASU head
Data/information collector Analyst

X4 X2
Administrative Support
X2
110
Exhibit “F”, page 50
61
'<- $
3 8
E F
8 E F 3 )
8 E F 8 $ 8 )
8 E F E )
8 E F E )
8 E F 8
'<; 5
6 E / 9 - 3
122' 8 8
E
<' 3 ' 122' 8
''' ''1
E E <F
8 $ 8
<' 3 ' 122' 4 5 E
6 F
0 '& '! $ 2 $!"+ & !) !+"$ &% *

!++ ' (! + '! % ' # & (( &
(!$$!)&L
, !+"! 1
= & &1
, +' '& '2 ' 4
111
Exhibit “K”, page 15 to 28
112
Exhibit “K”, page 17 to 21
62
!( " + &%""! & '& !++ '! 4

'$& ' '& ! ' '! ! "" ! #' )'
"' + $ !++ '! &/ +"! * " ' * )'$$ #
+"$!* ! ! # &'& % '$ + '& (! + $$*
'(' ! ! )'& 4 !++! '! (! ( *
! ' ! ' 0 0* & $ *# ' '('
'& 2 '$ #$ 8
'.2 B 1/ > 122' C F ! + $

"" !2 $ (! '+"$ + '! !( & ( * & 0* (!
& " 8/ $ 8
'.'
$ * C E
E $ * A
E
<2 4 122' & F
% &' I" '& )'$$ & &&' * 2 ! # # !%0 ' 8 A
# E #
:' .22 222 22
C 1< > 122'
(
63
'! $ (! '! !( &% % '
'.1
C $ *
95<65 65 6 ( 8 ';;.
>
''<
C A
F
' 7$ #$*7$'7 ! $ 2 ' ' ) & !+ '

!! 7!+& '0 ' !!0+ 7 2 ' & ' &)
) !+ !"&'0 2 & 0' & &" 7 ' $'0 ' 0
2 & + $/ # ) 7/ ' 0 / + 2!! $ 00' 0&
7!+ ) 7! 7 # &$%' +' 0 2 0 + 7$'784,,.
'.< C #
'',
& ( 7
113
Record, evidence of Dr Barnard, page 2867
114
115
64
+A C +A
''/
'.. H E # C
& (
''9
+A 7 #
+A
F
7 2 !00 2 %' $'7 ' $ 2 7 '' &

# $ 0 '7 ) & !+ ! & 7!$$ 0 & 2 ' $"
! & 2' %$$ $ ' ' $'0 ' 0 2 ' " !2' &' 7! 0 &!
%$$ !!7 + 7! ) 7 ) %$$ %$$ &'! $
" ! %7 +! & 7$ + 748,,D
'., C E #
C "
E +A
C
8
+A 7 F
116
117
118
65
B!!7 + ' ' # &! !+ ' &) 7 $; "

7 2 %' $'7 ' ' $'0 ' 0 !!7 #* ' '
2 ' " !2' &' #*0 2! 0 +! & )! 84,,-
'./ 8
'12
@ +A C
+A
7 C
'1'
+A
'.9 C C
3 8
C
+A
(! + $ " ! % (! !" '! !( &% % '
'.- 8 8
C
(
* $ 122'
7
1;
119
120
Record, evidence of Mr Smit, page 825 – 826; Record, evidence of Dr Barnard, page2997
121
Record, evidence of Dr Barnard, page2998
66
B 122' 8
$
* E
'.;
* A
(% '! & !( + +# & !( &% % '
',2 1; B 122' >(

8 5 6 C
# $ $ E* 5
B 6
',' +
@ 5
C 6
F
67
'9) 7$* #' & '! &
8 E F
o 1< 4 122' )
o / 122' )
o 12 122'
o <8 122' & )
o 1. 8 122' '' 8
& )
o - B 122'
H8 )
o 11 B 122' #
+ +! ) ' ! %+ '!
: 5 @ 6 #
F
H 8 (8
1; 4 122'
C B 8 3 ")
5 6)
8B8 +1 C
8 .4 122' @
)
68
/ 4 122' 5
6 8 C B F
'11
8 * C
',1
& +A B 3 * C
5?C ?6 D 8 8 1- 4 A
C
@ +A 8 (8
( @ 8
8 $ $ + 3 5?+ 3 ?6 (
$ A
( %
F
* ' %7 '& ! ! / F * $ 2
!! %'0 '& ' &9 "& 0 ' 0 ' # &'0 '& !+
; ' $$'0 &' ' &8 ' !""!&'&' ' # &
' $$'0 &' 0 + &7 " !" '0 ' / '
!2' &' & ' $'0 ' 0&2 +!N & ; # 2' '
& $ 0 ' 0 & ' $$'0 &' "!0' 0& # &7!% +!
)! 7 2 0 !!7 ' 2!! 0 & $
"$ &' 0 2 ; 3 $'& #* ' &9 "
!2' &' $ +' '& &' & ) #! 0 ' 2!! & $
+! ' 4 ' ' ' 0 & $ ' # !!
0 +! '0 )! 48
122
Exhibit “F” : pages 81-86
69
',< A 1; B 122' 8
! & 2 & 0' ' (! + '! & !( #' /

0'2 (( ! &"! &'#'$' * !( ' ! $ '
&" !( ' (! + '! + 0 + / & 0' !9
! ' '! &%""! 48 '1<
',.
@
$ $ E* 5
B 6
',, + 3
(
( @ C B
F
1/ 4 122' 1; 4 122'
C B = >
:1 ;-/ 22 '1.
1< B 1. B 122'
C B
123
Exhibit “F” : pages 104 - 110
124
Exhibit “M”, page 91 - 96
70
(
'1,
4
',/ + + 3
(
5' 6'1/
A <4 122' 5- 6'19
E
0 5 8 8
3 "6
',9 + 3 @
@ C
B E
) & ' 2 &! 7 2 2!7 $'2 &

7 7 ' !7%+ &!% 7*7 &!% 7!++
$ ) !" ' ' & %7 %% / ' ' !% / ' ) 2 '
125
Exhibit, “M”, page 97 -100
126
Exhibit, “U”. Record, evidence of Dr N Marais, page 680
127
Exhibit, “U”. Record, evidence of Dr N Marais, page 680
71
!7%+ / 2 7' &$'7 $2! & %$$ ' 7 #'

2!! 0 $O )! 48,=D
',- B
B 7
'' 8
H8 E
&
',; + 3 #
8 ''
A
'1;
+ 3
B 7 ' 7 ' ' # ! $' 0 2 ' !7%+ ) & !+

'0&' & ; % ' 7 ' $$'0 &' # $ ' 7 #' 2!!
0 ' 4 7 ' 7 ' # ! $' 0 ) & !+ ' 7 #'
# ) 0 & &' !! ' '&'7!:& ) !!7 2' '
!2' &' + 0 # & $ ' ' 02 ' 2!! 2 $
+!! $'7 !!7 2!! & $$ + 7 !! ! !+ '
48,?>
'/2 & @ #
F
128
Record, evidence of Dr N Marais, page 681
129
Record, evidence of Dr Marais, page 682
130
72
F!! &' L B+ '& !!7 &! ; " &!! ) ! !+ $ &/

7! $ & !" ; 0 $ # &'& &!% ) ' 2 2 '&/
2 7 '& B8
'&L 7 $ % !"' ' !! 4 7 ' ' !7%+
0 &' &; !7%+ 2 ) & $'7 ) ' / 48
F!! &' L $%& +& + '& ' ; !7%+ 2 ) & $'7
) ' P8
'&L ' ) & ' B8
F!! &' L ' "!$' ' ' !( "!$' '7%&+ & 2 ) 0 %$$
! $ 7 '& 2 ' 0 # % ! !+ %$$ / &! %$$ &!%
2 ) / &* %$$ ' $ & ' 4 +%& +P8
'&L 7 &!% 0$! %$$ 2 &!% 7 '& C 48
'/' + 3 #
7 # F
'&L 7 ' 7 %$$ ) & ! ; 0 !! + !0 ' ;

2 7 ( & !+ & $( " &' & " !# 2 && $ ) '
(% 7&' 2 &!% ) &4 ' !!( 7 &!% # &$'& '
2!! $'0 ' 0& 0 ) & + '& !!7 0 &O
' $'0 ' 0& !7%+ &!% 2!! # ' +! & )! 2' ' 7 #' 4
) &0 " !! ' +!! $'7 ' 2 ; 0$'7& #%$$ ' /
$ !!7 0 " !! ' +!! $'7 ' 2 ; ) 7$'7& " ! %7
) & 7 2 # $ 0 &!% ' '('& ! %$$ 0
# ' 04 ' &!% + )!! ; '"' & ' $'0 ' 0&(% 7&'
0 ) & ' + 2 ' !! 2 ' $'0 ' 0 !+ '
2 & # ' ' # &$%' +' 0&9 $ 2 &' 2
2 !! 48
73
#& L ' ' $'7 ) 7 ) 0 ! '& ' '

* " 7 '& ' 2 # + ' 7 #' 2!! $'0 ' 0&/ '& ' 0P8
'&L ' ) & +* ' %74 7 +! ) & !"
%' )*& 7 ' ' $ " '! ' 7 7 &$ 0& !" '
0 $ ' ) & ' 7! 7 ) &4 '& 2' +* +! '$'7 !+
7!++ $ ) !" ) %$$ 0$'7& 7# $& 48,?,
$ '! & '" !( + +# & !( &% % ' )' + +# & !(

" !2' ' $ 0!2 + / / ! 0 ' &
'/1 7
$ >
8 (8 A
3 $ 3
'/< C
+A A
+A
+A
+A 3
C +A B &
131
74
'/. A +A
+A
C #
+A %
3
+A
&
* +A
& *
+
! $%&'! & (' ' 0&
'/, ' 8 1222

( E
E
$ 8
( ( )
5 $ 6
$ 8
3E
$ *
8 8 3 "
+ 3 (
8 8 $ 3 " + 3
+A8 +A 8 88 A
75
'//
C
E F
5 # 3 "6
C 3 " 8
& )
C % 1222 122'
C 8 8
$
)
C 5
6
)
C
C A
P C B P
)
C
3E )
76
#
#
C
)
'/9
5 ) 8 3)
) @ & $ 6
(
(
#
C
'/-
8 8
(
F
A 8 3 5
77
6 D
( % E
& $ )
8 8 3
)
A
@ @ )
C
)
= >CA)
( H 8
(
)
C +A B
C
)
78
D $
8
3 0 122'
'/; #
+A
'92 A
@ F
122'
# )
+
3 8 88 122'
@ #
79
@ # 8
8 5
@
6
E@
@
'9' P
@
E
3E C
8 3 )
& $
( *
'91
@
80
* P P @
#
A
@
#
'9< A
&
*
+A &
#
( *
@ *
# 7 #
#
&! & %'
'9. B ', 3 122' C 3 8 8

5 C '. 3 122'6
81
&
3 A=
+A )
* C C
$ 8 )
D : #
$ 8 )
3 4 C $
8 )
$ 8 88 E
$
8 )
3 " 8 88
8 $
8 )
3 3 4 8 (8 7
$ 8 )
8
$ 8
82
1- > 1221
D 8
$ 8
1- > 1221
'9,
3E> ( *
C B 8 8 3 "
$ 8 5
6 A
+ 3
(
! !( %' +
'9/ ? ? B $ E*
'<1 '<< '<.
B 4 C C
E C
7
F
132
Record, evidence of Mr Oliver, page 426 - 428
133
Record, evidence of Mr Joshua, page 319
134
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, page 135
83
' ) & ' ! '0 !+ ' "!& 2 ' / 2!7 4

' "% ) & !+ ) 7 + ) 0 ! + '& ' ' '
" !2' &' / ; %' &/ ' ' ' 7!++'&&' / ; %' &0 '+
" !C 7/ + ' $ 7 !% 4
& 0 ) 7 + ' " !C 7 !+ $" !+ '
2 '$'0 ' &&' % &' / & + + ' 2 '$'0 '
!$&" $ & 2 ' 0 ! ( 7 */ /
2!! ! & 2' ' ' '&'N$ (&7!" 2 7% '0
+ & ! '0 0 4 7 ! 2 $$'0 $) 2 '
7% '0 + & 0 7 / &!++'0 2 +* 2!! + $'0
7!$$ 0 & #* & & ) ' ' %7 0 $ )! /
! 0 + ' $+ $4
&; + & ; &" &' $ " !C 7 $!! &/ " !# C* 7% '0

+ & ' ' 7 * !+ ' " !C 7 2 ' 0 ! (
7 *4 ' '& !!7 0 %' '& (0 $O 2!! ' & ' !++'&&'
!!7 ; ) 7& % ' ! &! 7 ' 0 0 0 &' '&
!+ + * ; " + & %7 %% & $/ '
2 ' "!& / 7$ #$*7$'7 0 2
&!% )! ' # & # &7'7# 7 ' ' "!&
0 2%$ &!% )! 84
'99 C E
F
' ( ' B 2' ' ' " !C 7 !+ + ' '

' ) 7/ % +* + & !
0 Q '('& '& !" 0 ! 2 %$$ # &!
# &! 7% '0 ' / '& &!4 & ' ' )!! '&/ 9
84
% 8/ '& ' &!4 7 7!+ %' ' !+0 )' 0/ 7 7

' + & 0! / 7 )!% 0 0 2' ' # $ 0 2 '
" !2' &' ' # & # &7'7# + & 7 * !+ ' !
B8,?J
'9- & @ C
#
@ @
'</
A C
# $
+"$!*+ ! & ! $% # (! & #$'& + !(

' (! + '! & '
'9; C
( 8 8
F
'<9
B ' 8 1222
D 8 $
8 4
8
.8 1222 .$ 1222
F
135
136
137
Annexure “M” page 10 to 14
85
'& ! +"$!* & $$ # ' $*

&"! &'#$ (! &&'& ' 0 +"$!* ' L9
7' 0 '+" && &&+ !( " *&' $ '&7 !

"%#$' " '2 " !" * )' ) 2 !( ! 1
2 $% ' 0 " + :& !+"$' )'

+' '+%+ ' (! + '! & % ' *& 1
2 $% ' 0 "! & '2 #* " + !

"!$' ' 0 + & ! ' '(* & ! ( $$& !( #!
' (! + '! " ! && &48
'-2 A
8 :';, 22
5 # 6
'<-
'-' '8 1222
8 $ 8
4
D 8
'-1 8 8 #
4
'<;
C , B 1222 #
$ $ '< '. >
138
Annexure “M” page 42 to 46
139
Exhibit “M”, page 9
86
C ( . ( 1 8 E ' A
:';, 22
'-< 8
1- > 122' # 5 $
8 6 . $ 1222 . 3 122''.2
# <3 122' .
3 122' <' 3 122' 8 #
1- > 122' 5 $
'.'
8 6 . $ 1222 . 122' <
122' # $ 8 .
122' <' 3 122''.1 +
+"$!*+ ! & ! $% (! "% "!& & !( ' (! + '!

& '
'.<
'-.
B 57 6 8 8 3 " .3
122' '. 3 122' '- 122'
<' $ 122'
F
140
Exhibit “M”, page 15 and 16
141
142
143
87
)! 0 #! 7& ( ' ) 7 + & !!( (% 7&'

& !" &'! $'& ' 0&# & %% F '$'0 ' 7% ' '
& $ ) &/ !+ !" ' 2 $% ' 0 2 2 '$'0 ' &' $'0 ' 0
' ' & + $' 0 2 (!7%& ! & % ' 0 $ )
0 + &7 "&2 '$'0 ' +% '&'" $ "!$'&'N ' 0 &
(% 7&' ' 84,..
'-, B 9 4 122'
5 B 7 F 8 8 6 +
'.,
3 :'-2 22 5 # 6
<' $ 122' F
)! 0 #! 7& ( ' &

!!((% 7&' & $ ) & !+ ' 2 $% ' 0 2
2 '$'0 ' &' $'0 ' 0/ ! )'77 $' 0&) 7 # $ ' $'&
(!7%& ! & % ' 0 $ )
0 + &7 "&2 '$'0 ' +% '&'" $ "!$'&'N ' 0 &
(% 7&' ' 4 ' & $ ' '
"$'0 32 )!! $'7 0 " & + '
(! + $'& 48
'-/ 7
C ', 3 122'
+
144
145
Exhibit “M”, page 86 -90
88
% +"$!*+ ! ! $% " + !(
!++% ' * ( *
'./
'-9 B 1< 3 122'
4 57 $ 8 6
$ :';2 22 5 # 6
)! 0 #! 7& ( ' ) 7 + & !!( (% 7&'

& !" &'! $'& ' 0&# & %% F '$'0 ' 7% ' '
& $ ) &/ !+ !" 7!R ' ' 0 2 ' ' & 2 '
" '2 & 7! /! )'77 $' 0&) 7 # $ ' $'& (!7%&
! & % ' 0 $ ) 0 + &7 "2 '$'0 '
+% '&'" $ "!$'&'N ' 0 & (% 7&' ' 84
+' '& '2 ' ' 0&
'--
@ C
@
A
C E
146
Annexure “M”, page 69 to 73
89
''516 ( 8 ';;. 8 ''5165 6
A ( 8 : A 1'
A % B
$ E*
''516 ( 8 ';;.
A "
@
A 8<
:
C
# 7
90
'-;
@
8
B
$ E* #
';2 & C %
8
8 $ #
';'
0 F
$ '4 122' $
8 $
'4 122' 122'
5: ; /,' .26 3 122' 5: 1< -,,6
C ' 4 122' $
8
7 3 122' 5: 1' 1'2 126 4 122' 5:
91
1. 9.2 ',6
3 " '; 122'

7 <' 3 122'
8 ' 3 122' 7
'' 4 122'
8 ' 4 122' 7
.4 122'
D : # '2 > 122' 7

', 4 122'
+ 3 1/ 4 122' 7
19 4 122'
!++ '!
';1 (
8 ''516 (
8 ';;.
92
+% '! !( ! )! 7 & % ' 0 " '! " +# =>>>

! =>>,
';< $
:';, 22 5
6F
=>>> +' *
8 1222 <' 122 22 11 2<, 22
B 1222 <, '22 22 <1 <92 22
+ 1222 <9 /<, 22 1/ ;'2 22
$ 1222 '9 ;.2 22 '2 91, 22
4 122' </ ./, 22 - ,-2 22
> 122' <- 112 22 '. 2.2 22
3 122' <' 122 22 '1 -92 22
==K KS>4>> =,K J?>4>>
';. A
1222 ' 8 1222 8 >
' 8 1222
> 122'
$ *
$ 8 @
" C '.
3 122'
93
$ *
'.9
B
+% '! !( ! )! 7 & % ' 0 " '! =>>, !

+# =>>,
';, A 3 4= 5?= ?6 19
122' 8 ) D 8 3 " + 3
$ *
5C 6 A
@
A @
4 122'
'.-
';/
122' $ 122' F
=>>, * +' ' T $ '&

122' '1 -92 22 ', .2, 22 - <-, 22 2 22
3 122' 2 22 </ //2 22 << ',2 22 2 22
4 122' <' 122 22 <, 1;, 22 <' 122 22 . <12 22
4 122' <' 122 22 << 9<, 22 <' 122 22 2 22
122' <' 122 22 <9 -<2 22 <' 9-, 22 2 22
8 122' 1- -/2 22 H H 2 22
B 122' <' 122 22 <- 21, 22 <, --2 22 ' -22 22
147
Record, evidence of Mr Joshua, page 318 - 319
148
Annexure “M’, page 85
94
+ 122' 2 22 2 22 2 22 2 22
$ 122' 2 22 2 22 2 22 2 22
,SS J?>4>> ,-S -J>4>> ,K, S>>4>> S ,=>4>>
';9 @
A #
@
@ #
B B B
@ B
' ' 0&
';-
#
A
+
95
!++ '!
';; $ E*
96
F
F
97
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NIA AND THE WESTERN CAPE

GOVERNMENT
122 +A & *
P
P
A & $ &8'22F
) )
) E +A
# # #
+A A #
F U V
12' A 8
<- ';;. 5 A 8 6 + 8
A <; ';;. 5 8 A 6
' 4 ';;, A 8
+A 8 88
8 A
+ A
8 ) + A E
98
) E
+ A E
121 +A 8 88 + A
8 5 +A8 6 C
8 8 5 CB88 6 C 8 8
* C ( C 4
8 @ ' 4 ';-2 ( 3 ( & C
C 5 196 $ *
+ A 8 <' 4
';;1 $ *
$ '4 ';;, +A8
+A 8 88 +
'.;
8 A +A F
! 0 / ! $ 2 $% $*& !+ & '

' $$'0 /' ! !<
' '(* * ! "! ' $ !
& % ' * !( "%#$' ! ' & " !"$ 1
'' %""$* ' $$'0 0 ' 0 * &%
! 1
# ! (%$('$ '! $ !% 9' $$'0
&"! &'#'$' ' & (! '& "% "!& ! ! %
!9! ' !% 9' $$'0 ! 0 /
149
Section 2 of Act 39 of 1994
99
! $ / 2 $% / $*& ' " ' (! + '!

0 ' 0 !% ' $$'0 ' ! !9
' ' '(* * ! "! ' $ !
& % ' * !( "%#$' ! ' & " !"$ 1
'' ' (! + &' !( * &% 1
''' &%""$* ) && * ' $$'0 $ ' 0
! * &% ! !% ( ' !$'
2' (! "% "!& !( ' 2 & '0 ' 0 *
!(( ! $$ 0 !(( 1
!0 " + $' $$'0 @% & !(
* ' & " + !( / / )' !%
$ * ! 2 $% &+' &% ' $$'0
* ! ' $$'0 '&"!& $ !( 0 *
) ' ! &'% & " + $ ' $$'0 / !
" + ! ! 48
12< 8 88 + 8 A
',2
F
! 0 / ! $ / 2 $% $*& (! '0
' $$'0 / I $% ' 0 (! '0 +'$' * ' $$'0 /
' ! !L
' ' '(* * ! "! ' $ !
& % ' * !( "%#$' ! ' & " !"$ 1
'' &%""$* ' $$'0 $ ' 0 ! * &%
! 1
# !' & ' % L
150
Section 2 (2) of Act 39 of 1994
100
' !% 9 ' $$'0 + &% & )' '

2' 1
'' ! ' ! &%$ '! )' 0 */ !% 9
' $$'0 + & !% &' "%#$' 1
!0 " + $' $$'0 @% & !(
* ' & " + !( / / )' !%
$ * ! 2 $% &+' &% ' $$'0
* ! ' $$'0 '&"!& $ !( 2'
) ' ! &'% & " + $ ' $$'0 / !
" + ! ! 48
','
12. + 8 A
# @ 8
8
:
:
5 + $ >
8 (86 :
8
:
12, 8 <5<6 8 A
8
8 .5165 6
151
Section 3 of Act 39 of 1994
101
+ A 8
12/ 8 A + A E
5 +A B 6
E
+ A 8 +A B
',1
8 @
8 E
+ A 8
E A
',<
@ 5
3 6 +A B
129 A E
+A B ( A E
(A B & (
+A B
152
Section 4(2)(e) of Act 39 of 1994
153
Section 5 if Act 39 of 1994
102
12- A
#
',.
';;/
9
F
! + $ !9 " '!
12; $ 1222 1221 $ * +A 3 8 &

8 # @ 3 3 5?3 ?6
3 + A 3
8
1'2 $
1222 E #
+A & * C
# '; 4 1222 C
',,
+A B A
&
& '1 4 1222
#
154
Schedule 4 and Schedule 5 of Act 108 of 1996
155
Letter Dr Barnard to the chairperson NICOC dated 19 June 2000, without a file reference
103
& 7
+A # ) *
) #
@ =
)
E 1-
4 1222 3 & 5 3
8 C 1- 4 12226 3
',/
3 8 8 ( @ E
1'' +A .4 1222
E ( D
',9
33 F
A &"! & ! ! &"! L $$'0 '

0 ! 2'!$ ' &"! 0 * ' &
" / ,- 5% =>>>4
' + ' '" !( *!% $ ! #!2 !"' /
,- 5% =>>>/ 2 ! &%$ )'
' & "
" & '2 ' *!% " !2' / !!7# 7&/ '
! ! "$* ! *!% @% ' &4
=4 + & #* &&' 0 '&&% !(
2 '$ #'$' * !( ' $$'0 ! *!% !%0
156
Letter 28 June 2000 Minister Wiley to Minister Tshwete, reference DCS13/4/1/4/2
157
Letter of 4 July 2000, office of the Co-ordinator for intelligence, reference NICOC/B1/DGW Cape/2
104
& " 4 )'& ! &% *!% + '

'" !( ! ' $$'0 ! + & " ' ' 0 !
2'!$ )' ' " !2' '& ! 2 '$ #$ !
*!% !%0 & " 4 + %
'+" &&'! *!% " !2' ' $ 0!2 +
+' '& '! 2 '2 0!! & 2' ( !+
)!%$ "" ' ( # 7 '( '& '& !
& 4
?4 $&! *!% "! 2 '2 ( !+
! '&&% !( I' 2'!$ ' & "
&"! ' %& */ ) ' '& && &&+ ! !
# &'& !( ' $$'0 # & / ) '
( &' ! # & 48
1'1 @
1'< $ 1222 +A
8 1222 +A
(
+A
+A E
E
H
+A % E
105
&
',-
'8 1222 >
1'. 8 +A 3 C
* 5?* ?6 5$ $ * +A
6 #
8 ( 8 ) $
A ( A E
5 (A B 6 7 $ E* +A
( 0 $ E*
',;
+A
1', B '. 8 1222'/2 &

( * + $ *
A 3 ( 3
& (
( $ E* @
158
Record, evidence of Mr B P Gilder, page 1176 and 1184 - 1185
159
Record, evidence of Mr B P Gilder, page 1184 - 1185
160
Letter dated 14 September 2000 from Mr Vusi Mavimbela of NIA, to the Premier, Mr G N Morkel,
reference NIA/A1/12/3/11/2, Exhibit “F”, page 1
106
1'/ B ', 8 1222 ( C

'/'
$ E* 19
8 1222 +A &
1'9 B 12 8 1222
'/1
C C
1/ 8 1222 C
( D 7 3 # 8 (8) 3 * 7 Q
'/<
8 +$> C ( E +A B
(
E
( *
$ * F
2! $'2 / + C% 7 ' 7 %
$L & % ' 0& ' & / 2 )!! $'7 2'
' & ' %&'! $ 7!R ' ' 0/ & $/ & ' 0 $ 0 2
' ' 7 % 90 $/ + & !+ ' !2' &' $
0 ' 0L &9 " 2 )!! '0 !" ' !2' ' $
$$'0 !9! ' ' 0 !++' 1 2 $'2
& $ !!7 !" & ' 7!++% '7 &' 7 $ 2 '
' " !2' &' $ " + 2
+ &7 "&2 '$'0 ' L8
161
Letter dated 15 September 2000Office of the Premier to Director General, Exhibit “F”, page 3
162
Electronic diary, Dr Barnard, 20 September 2000 and exhibit “F” page 5A
163
Letter 26 September 2000 (reference DG3/2/4/3), Exhibit “F”, page 5A – 5B (the letter was dated by
Advocate Oliver and signed by Dr. Barnard) Record of evidence, Advocate Oliver, page
107
'$ $ &7 7 $' 0 %&& ' !2' &' $ +' '& &' L
&9 " ' " + 2 '
$$ 0 &' 0 + &7 " )! 2 ' %' 2! ' 0
& $ &"! '0 0 (' $'& )! 48
1'- B 1/ 8 1222
C ( 3 C
8 4 &!! $'7 '+84'/.
1';
( 7 +A
F
7 7 $' 0 ' ' ! 7!+& 7 $$ $'7 !" "!$' ' 7 2$ 7

+ %& $( !( ' '& & "$ &2' ' ' % ' ' '&' ' (
! + !( ' ' 7 % 9 $ ! & % %
5!& % 2 $'2 + &! '0 2 &! 7
! & % 4 ! * )*$ & !! 0 7!+ )! & $
$$ &7 7 $' 0 ' ' ! 7!+& 2' 2 $'2 "$ &2'
) ' ! '0 7!R ' ' 0' ' 2 # & $ ! 4
' +! &7 '( $'7 < ! 7 % ' !!( 2
/ ' !!( 2 ' ' &9 " ' ' '&
2 )!! $'7 2' $$'0 &' ' & < ! +
! 7 0 !" # "!$' ' 7 ('0%% !(
" !2' &' $ +" '0 7!2 ' $$'0 &' 0
164
Letter 26 September 2000 (without filing reference) addressed by Dr Barnard to Premier Morkel, exhibit
“F” page 4.
108
2 '0 $' 2 ' %' 9 ( '7 &

$$'0 &' 0 + &7 " ! 2 0 ' 4 ' &! '0
0 ' & 77' 0 !( $ (!! + $%'& ' 0 #*2!! # $
!! ) 0 )! ' ' 0 2 $ 2 #*2!! # $ +'&
) $+& ' ' 7 % 9 $ 2 ' !2' &' ' $$
0 2 $$ / 2!! ' $' 0 "$ &2' / %' %7$'7
2 ' 0 $'0 )! 4
7+ ; 2 & !% ' 0 !! +' & & #!0 ! +
0 $ 0 ) & 7 ' ' &# $ 0 '7 '&
2!! '0 ! +' 0& 2 ' !2' &' &9 "
0 0 )! !+ & + ) 7' 0 !" ' $'0 ' 0&0 #' + '
# ) 7& $$'0 ' 2$! ' 2 ' $'0 ' 0 2 %'
' !! ' + 0 '08
112 ( C C
( 3 5> 6 3 *
# 19 8 1222
3 #
( 3 E +A (
$ +A %
E * 7
> ( 3
>
'/,
& ( +A
11' 19 8 1222 C
( *
165
Record, evidence of Mr B P Gilder, p1186
109
+A
@
1/
8 1222 3
C
'//
'/9 '/-
111 A B 8 @
+A @
'/;
A C
E
+A & (
11< B ' 8 1222

+A8 +A
8 88 D 8 8 $
8 C
166
167
Record, evidence of P Smit, page 745 - 746
168
Record, evidence of G Oliver, page 401 - 402
169
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, page 141 - 143
110
11. +A ( *
@
( +A
8 1222 4 1221
8 3
& 5 8 (86
D 5 8 88
# 6 '92 B '< B 1222
C & 8
'9'
8 B 1; + 1222 5
6
C
& 8 3 '91
& $ &8 '22%
:',. ,/' 12
& $ :-- -/' -/ 5 :1, ;-< 22 6
11, 8 @ 8 3
$ 9 -+
122' 8 3 (
* )
& $ &8 '22
170
Communication Dr Barnard and legal advisors SASS
171
Electronic diary, Dr Barnard, 13 October 2000
172
xhibit “E”, annexure”U”
E
111
'9<
# :1-
.,' 2< &8 '22 & $ :<;
'9.
,,1 <2 : ( 8 8 (
-+ 122'
22 ,- ( %
( D C B
# @
3 + D
8 3 8
# 8
'9,
8
'9/
( 8 H A
> +A
& D C
+A %
(
'99
A
+A ( D
@
173
Annexure “L” being the offices of the Premier, the Director General, and a secure room “as also the
Premier’s office at Leeuwenhof”.
174
Exhibit “J”, annexure”M”
175
Record, Evidence of R P Strydom, page 61 - 65
176
Record, Evidence of R P Strydom, page 66
177
Record, evidence of A Fraser, page 4
112
11/ B <' 3 122' $ * C

'9-
+A & !( " '2 !+" ' & ! ! &
! &%$ &
5 6
:
+A @ $ E*
<2 4 122' * " '2 !+" */
! ! / ! &%$ ! ! " '2 & 2' " !2' *!%
' & ' % '! '& %&' 0 ! %& &' # 0' ' 0 !( =>>> % '$
!)8
"
+A
A
119
8 3
5
6 +A80+A 08 88
178
Exhibit “A”, NIA/A1/W1/13/7
113
11- E
8 1222 $ 122' F
: ( (A B )
3 $ * 3
A 3 8 )
+A )
>
& ( 8 8 + 3
# +A 08 88 )
C +A B
& 5
6 $ * C
C
11; +A 3A88
& (
E F
1<2
& $
( *
114
>
+A
+ *
& (
&
1<' C
# & $
7 #
B 0+ 122' F
) & '+ !( 0 2 ' & "!$' ' $

! & '! ' 7 ' $* 2 *7 & &
) ) # ' 0 !#& 2 ) % ' 0
'+ 4 & & " !"$ 7 ) ) *!% )
!' 04 !) *!% 7 !) + * 2 # " !' 4
! : ' 7' ) & ' $* $ !%0 2 ! " !!( !(/ !(
# ' 0 !#& 2 ! ) *) '& %&&'! & '
2 '!%& "$ & ) & !$ ) & !%$ +
# %& *!% 7 !) '& ) & "$ ) *!% !%$ ! #
!2 4B !%0 ' ) & #' ! #% ' $*
' ) & #% ' ) & : ! # %& ' 2' ! + !(
' & '& %& ) ) & 2 * $'# +"
! !2 !) !2 + ) ' " 2 '$
115
) ' $* '& %&&'! & ! ) ! 2

' " '2 B8,K-
1<1 C
'-2
7
'-'
1<<
B + 122' 5
$( ++( 6 +
8 E
C #
( D C
F
!% &%&"' '! ) & ) ) &% 2 '$$ #* 0 ' & !(

'! $ !2 + 4 ! ) * )!%$ *!% !
'! $ !2 + ! !+ !
&) "' 048
179
180
181
116
'-1
1<. C
$ * +
A 8 1222
'-<
1/ 8 1222
& L $$ ' 7 (' & ! $& )' $' '&!

"!$' ' $ $ 2 $ & ! ! $& )' ( / +
+ '! ! *!% $' ) $ &%&"' '! ) )
# ' 0 "$ % &% 2 '$$ ) ) &&%
) & % $$* ! 0!' 0 ! 7 "$ 48
#& L & @% & ' ) ' ' 0 & !%$

'& $!& " !"$ ! # ' 0 #%00 ' && P8
& L E &84
#& L " 0 " (!$$!)& # !& )!

#%$$ ' +&/ ( & ! ( * ! &
% & ' 4 '& : 0!' 0 ! # !9!" '! % '$
% 7' 0 '& 0'2 4 & ' &' P
& L % & $'7 84
#& L 8 & % 7' 0 2 (! !+' 0 ' ) ' ' 0

! *! (! +P8
& L !%$ : $$ & ) 4 + * # 48,D.
182
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, page 131 to 132
183
Letter 26 September 2000, exhibit “F”, page 5A to 5B and letter 26 September addressed by Dr Barnard
to Premier Morkel, exhibit “F” p4
184
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, p141 to 143
117
1<, C + 1222 5
>CA
& H8 6'-, F
7 *!% # 7 ! "!' + $' '& )

!% & $2 & & '!%& & 2 '! & #!% "!$' ' $
'+" ' $' * !( '! $ $$'0 0 *84
1</ & C F
'& "!' + $' & ) $$ ' $$'0

" ! % & ) ' ) '2 ( !+ !++% ' * ) & '
+ * ' & & ! %" ! & *!% 7 !) !
' ! &'! & @% & &!+ && ' $ & %(( )
! $ )' ) C%& 2 0! ' 48,DS
1<9 7 #
7 # (
'& '& $ '! & '" !( '& %& # %& !( + *

' & & ) 0! $ & & ) 0! !$ & !%$ 84
185
Memorandum 27 November 2000 L Steyn (F P Smit to Minister Bester) entitled “FBI: Offer to assist
SAPS in psychological profiling of fanatical muslem elements”
186
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, p174
118
& ? ?
'-9
1<- & /4 122' 8

'--
C B 5
C 6
'-;
) & ) !$ '&&% !( +% % $ &%&"' '! & :2 (

!4 &&%+ ' 7 " !( '& !++'&&'! :&
'2' ' & # %& '! $ !2 +
&%&" " ' $$'0 0 ' &4
" &%&" '! $ !2 + ) & &"*' 0 !
' 8,->
2! $'2
1<; B
@
187
Record, evidence of Mr Bester, p174 to 175
188
Exhibit “F”, p81 - 86
189
190
119
( * +A
7 F
5 / +* % & ' 0 ' ' ' $$* ) & ) )

! #!% / # %& !( # 79' / +" & ! 7
' ! :& !+"% / ! &! & $'7 & % ' * !(
' (! + '! ' !2' 4 &!+ & 0 $&! ) &
" & '& %&&'! ) )' ' ! $
!( '! $ $$'0 0 * ) ) &
&" '(' $$* @% & ! 0'2 ) ' &&% !%
#%'$ ' 0 ) & ! # ' 0 #%00 2 "" 1
) ' : 0 &% ! (' + '! ( !+ '+4
# + ! ' 7 (! &!+ !( "!$' ' ' &
$&! (! & '! + 0 + 48,-,
1.2 7 # C
( 3 C +A A #
19 8 1222 +A E
( F
&" '(' $$* ) &&% < *

"" ! %& (! !9!" '! / ) ' ) & 0 %"! /
+ 7' 0 ' (! + '! 2 '$ #$ ! +) * '/
&7 + (! &&% *
)!%$ !9!" )' + #% )
&&% ! !( " !"$ ' #%'$ ' 0 )
# ' 0 #%00 )' !% '& 7 !)$ 0 84
191
Record, evidence of Adv G Oliver, p400 to 4001
120
' + L E &/ #% *!% & * @% & ) & (! ) '

&&% 48
$'2 L E &/ @% & ) ' &&% 8,-=
1.' & @
# F
*% & ' 0 $&! ) & ' ) & ! ! $* !

$ ' 0 ! #% $&! ! " !"$ ) ! + * #%0
!2' 4 ) ' 2!$2 ' & &' '2 ' 2 & '0 '! &
!% $!&& !( + ' ' & ( !+ !&"' $& !&
' 0& ) &%&" '+' $ &* ' ' 2!$2 + /
!& 7' & !( ' 0&84,-?
+'
1.1 E + A
8 8 1222
8 8
C +A
7 C
& (
@ 7 +A
8 B & ( *
192
Record, evidence of G Oliver, p401 - 402
193
Record, evidence of G Oliver, p402 - 403
121
7
$
* +A 7
122' C @ 8 5
6 +A
>
+A B
C
1.< 8 C @
> +A
';.
8
';,
& @ +A #
+A
+A
';/
+A 7
C +A
# 3
( +A
7
+A +A
194
Record, evidence of Mr Smit, p745 - 756
195
Record, evidence of Mr Smit, p766
196
Record, evidence of Mr Smit, p825
122
@
';9
1.. C $ * ( F
& .$ ';;/ $ 122' 7
$ *
'> ';;1 <2 + ';;/ $ *
+A8 ' 4 ';-2 <' 4 ';;1 $
&
(
+A
1., C +A
& $
* @ A
+A
';-
@ ( @ A
B 122'
+A & *
197
Record, evidence of Mr Smit, p424 - 429
198
Record, evidence of Dr Barnard, p2870 - 2871
123
+A
';;
+A %
1./ A +A C ';;9
& * + H
+
# F
7 2!! & ' + ' 0 0 %$ '0 ' +

0 &!('& '7 7&' & &!% 7! # !! %' 2! 4
F ) N ' ( ' ' / &; 0 ' 0&' & $$' 0 !
# 2 ; "!$' ' 7 " *2 $ ' ' 2 &! 7' 0
+ 0 ) & !+ C%'& ) %$$ ' ( &' ) (% 7&'
+! %' ! ( / ' !(( &' ) (% 7&' 7! %' ! ( 2
+ $%'& ' 0 ' ; " !2' &' ) ' ! %$$ "!$' ' 7
# ) & ' / ) & ! 0 + 7 !+ '
) ' 02 ' 48=>>
1.9 #
F
7 ' +* !!(0 %' '& 0'& 0 !!

%' ' 0& ) & 2 $ 77 &' & ' < 2 ' # 0' 2 ;-K (
!! "!$' ' 7 0 &" 77 ) ' ' 7 #' &7 +
199
Record, evidence of Dr Barnard, p2884
200
124
"$ &0 2' 4 7 2 0 !! !" +*

" &!! $'7 7 / ' 7 !" +* 7 !!
' 0 # 7 '&4 F 7 0 !! ' +* !!(0 %' '&
0'& ' 2 !% ) & < 7 0 # %'7 ' )!!
2 !% ) &/ ' ! '0 2 !% ) & ' )
' ' & $ 0 ' 0! " *"!$' ' 7 #
& & ' ' " !2' &' / ' ) 7 &! &!% )!% ! &!!&
) ; + & ' 0 0 &!% )!% O ' 4 2!$0$'7 ! &;
$ " !& & ' 0 0 0 &' / ) !! 7 !!7 0'&
0 %'0 ' + 2 ' ) 0 )' 0 ' ' 2 # / !+
( &' ) + N$& + &! ' $'0 ' 0& 7 ' '
' " !2' &' ! 0 " & 7! )! 48=>,
1.- C
8 3
121
1.;
( C +A
7 #
# 19 8 1222 F
201
202
125
7 2' " ' / ' ; 0 &" 7 ) +* 7!$$ 0 # '

0! 2 ) / + ' !!( 2 / +* 7!$$ 0 / F%&'
2%+# $ / % & ) 7 &' ) ' '&/ ' '
)!! '0 ' 2 & +' ! 7 $0 2 L
! C%$$ + $%'& ' 0 ' ' ' 0 #!% !( ' P8
:& ; 2!% '0 / ! & 7 %00 '
0 %' '& 2 +* 7!$$ 0 '$ ! / ! C%$$
+ $%'& ' 0' ' ' " !2' &' !( ' P8 ( !" "!$' ' ' !(
+" P8 7 2' !+ 0 &O & ' 0 !!
' $'0 ' 0 2 +" 7 ! & ' 2' C%$$* 2 *
2 ' !" '0 + ' 0 4 & ' 0 !! 0 &! '
+' '& &' $$ & 7 7 C%$$ ' 2 ' 2
! & 7 *48
* ' 0 $ ' ' ' )!! '0 ' 2 '

+' / & / '& ' ! +' 0 0 0 L '
2' ' "$ & ' 48 ! 7 0 &O/ 7 2' ' !!7
! 0 + '7& 2 + ' / 0 ' 2' ! & !" &7 '(
' &! '&48 ! & ' !" &7 '( 7 7 *4 &; + &;
%'& 7!!" +! C* ; &7 '( $'7 # ' ( 7 * $$ &4 '
2' ! & !" &7 '(4 ' !!' 0 7!+ ' 48=>?
1,2 C #
#
7
+A
>
+A
203
126
12.
1,' & @ 1/ 8 1222
C # 3 8
19 8 1222
B @
12,
@ > A * %
19
8 1222
1,1 C 8
+A A
@
+A F
7 0 ) & & ' &! '&/ & ' ( ' '&/ )

% ' +' < 2 &7!! ) % ' +'
204
205
127
0 %'0 '& %$$ ' ' ' 2 # 2 %$$ 7 (

0 ' / '& ' ; (!% 48=>S
1,< A * +A #
C #
* +A
129
7 # @
1,. +A
C
C # F
7 ' ! 0 + 7 0 $ !+ 7 ' &7 '( $'7

! +' 0 ' 0 7 * ' 48=>D
'$
1,, * +A
+A &
206
207
208
128
( * 1222 7 4
1222 $ $ * +A
B ( $ $ *
8 88 =# A $ A
+A
+A % ( $
1,/ * # +A &
( $ ( 3 >
+A % & (
E E
E
( A E
(A B
1,9 * #
+A $ A
* ) + A
$ A * @
A A +A %
* 5 6
*
* )
*
129
12;
* &
#
+A *
1'2
1,- * # # +A
A 3 ( '19
';;1
7 4
< $ ';;; 3
$ * +A 1222 +A
>
+A
( $
( 3 ( 3 >
( ( $ *
8 1222 ( 3 C
C 19 8 1222 $
* +A 3 > >
( 3 3
209
Record, evidence of Mr B P Gilder, p1177 to 1178
210
130
>
+ $ * A
1''
& ( +A
1,; $ 19 8 1222 C
( *
+A
* 3
7 +A %
+A
# C +A
7
@ @
7
3 3 8
@
1'1
& * 7
# > . @
+A
+A
211
212
Record, evidence of Mr B P Gilder, p1188 - 1189
131
1/2 A 1222 +A
# &
( *
+A
1'<
B
+A 1222
122' ( *
*
1'.
A # +A
& *
H 8
>CA 8
A H
& H 8
8 88 >CA
H8
+A (
A
A
>CA A
+A ( * E
* *
213
214
132
*
'2 B 122' * > +A
C C ( A
>CA
1',
1/' & +A &

* *
8 122' C 3 8 C
3 8 +A
1'/
@ * @ 3
C C
'2 B 122'
C
8 1222
+A (
* C
( * +A
+A (
+A
>CA 1'9 C *
(
* #
A
215
216
217
133
( *
@ * +A C
*
1'-
1/1 ( 3 D $
5?$ ?6 B 0+ 122'
$ +A
1';
A 5
#6 +A
+A # (
* + 122' 8 +A
# 8
'' +A
# 3
* +A
112
1/< * (
@
218
219
220
134
C
B 122'
1/. & @ +A
& *
#
11'
( 7
+A
& *
1/, +A 8(AH
& ( * 122'
( 3 > 8
111
(
@ +A
11<
# C B 122'
1// *
+A #
7
221
222
223
Record evidence of Mr Bester, p123
135
C F ) $'& ! # @%' ! & / !%

&%&"' '! ) & ) ) # ' 0 &% 2 '$$ #* 0 ' & !(
11.
'! $ !2 + 84 *
C (
+A &
@ 8 1222 +A
@
& C
C B 122' +A
& ( *
11,
# *
+A
11/
1/9 *
( 1222
+A (
H
+A & (
8 1222 >
* 5 E 6
+A +A
224
225
Record, Gilder, p1236
226
136
# &
( 122'
* 2 *
0!! $ '! & '"84 * F
&( & $$ ' '& 2 * 0!! $ '! & '"4 ! :

7 !) ) & !%$ & * '&/ ' " &! / #% '
"" & !+ 0!! $ '! & '" && 2 *
&!! ( 0 ) ' $ ! (! + '! !(
!++'&&'! / " $* $ &/ ' & & ) )
"" ! '++ ' $* ! ! & % ' * "" '& $/ $ &
' ' ' $! / $ %& ! '& !2 * !( !0/
! %+ & # ' 0 7 !% 4 2 !) !+"$
" !" & % '* "" '& $ !( !2' ' $ +' '& '! /
)' (%$$ !9!" '! !( $$ " + & !(
!2' !% !) & % '* 2'&! &4 % &
2 ' (! + $$* ' +* '& %&&'! & )' & /
+ & @%' ( @% $* )' #! "!$' ' $
+' '& '2 $ &' !2' 84 ==K
1/- & C
C
11-
227
Record, Gilder, p1241-1242
228
Record Gilder, p1242
137
1/; $
11;
+A
192 * #
& ( +A
(
1<2
+A A
A
1<'
+A
+A %
3A88
+A E
C
+A #
229
230
231
138
19' A
& * +A
8 1222 $ 122'
( *
+A
191 A ( * @
+A 8 1222 1/
1<1
8 1222
8 A >
C
( *
( * +A E
"
( +A
232
Exhibit “F”, page 4
139
19<
( #
E +A 8 <5<6
+ 8 A <; ';;.
$ 8
+A
+A
19. > A 3 ( '19

';;9 " 7
"
$ *
@
+ +A
C *
8 1222
+A
19, +A
#
P 3 A 8
( 8 E
140
19/ @ @
C C 5
( 3 6 P 19
8 1222 P E
C @ +A
19 8 1222
*
@ C
+A
@ 5
6 +A
# E +A
A
C %
+A E
+ @
C
3 A $
*
@ 7
+A
E (
199 C
C >
141
5 6
+A
%
+A C
+A
$ ( * #
+A
19-
5 @
+A 6
E +A
3A88)
) )
) @ & $
)
) "
+A
+A
19; E +A
@
E
( % 8 A
: @ EB * ';;/
142
+A
# +A
(
+ @
8 3 5 6
+A
1-2 A #
A C
B #
143
E C
#E+A8 +A
#E
E@
#
%
#
#
&
&
E 5
# E @
6
144
1-' B
& $
7 #
1-1
1-< # @
145
146
1-.
B ( B $ *
';;.
A
B
>
1-, > ( 3 +A &

1<<
C
# C %
' ( D C
A( B
C # #
C
# #
C
1-/ >
B $ $ E* B $ E*
233
Record, evidence of Mr Fraser, page 14
147
1-9 D #
%
E #
(
#
1-- ( &
C B
B
C F
1-; + 8 ';;/
C
B ( $ E*
+
$
1;2 C 5<6
@
5$ A 6
E$ 8 8
$ A
3 1222
148
1;' 3 A 7 :
C
#
B $ E* 5 $*'010.6
1;1 ;/ 5 6
#
C #
F
8 > & ( P
1;E2;E';;-
$ ( A 8 8 (8
& '<E2,E';;-
3 3 N FC
& EJ * P 1' ';;-
D & EJ : $
'; > ';;- 8
$ 8 : '1 + ';;- P
&
P
149
: @ F D
P '/-0;/ P
1;< A
,516 ( A ';-1 3A88

8 ,516 ( A ';-1
: 0
0
# :,222
#
1;. A 3A88 E
1;,
@ '2 . 1 3A88
@ F
150
! (' ' $
!" &
E
1;/ A
$ E* % B
F
';;-
1;9 A C
# B
+
151
1;-
( & = B
B E$ 7 : 3 &
@
3A88
1;;
+
( & 7 8 =
$
<22 # B
( 8 ,516
( A ';-1 3A88
# F
4 $ 3 F '' $
';;;
$ 8& 8 # $* +A
+A ( E P.+ ';;;
C ( 3 F 8 F B
( P 7 P 1, B 1222
152
8 : & +A B & 8 +
8 : '/E,1E;; P
A C ( & 1' ';;- P
$ ';;-0;; F 8
P
A C ( 8 J
& '- ';;; P
<2'
@ @
B
<21 > ( &
& $ @
( & +A + A
';;90;- ';;90;-
1221 8
5J;0'0.6
<2< A '<5165 6 + ';;/

153
"
+ =
" A
3A88 ';;/
<2. > # C
% B
#
3 3
<2, A
( & B $ E*
<2/
(
F& F
. 9, : * :
( +
154
$
0
@
# B C C
B
(
#
<29 @
( & $ E*
95<65 6 (
8 ';;. @
0 <'
3 A 8 8 $
A
155
<2- + ( &
( &
<2; ( & : *
: ( +
<'2
7
> ( & %
<'' ( & +
<'1 3
A 8 8 $
<'<
156
157
<'. A
E B $ E
*
3 :
(
C $
= $
B $ $ E*
C $ E*
<',
E B $ E
* F
( ;
' 4 1222 @
B %
C
158
C
%
$ E* , 122'
#
1/ 4 122' $ E* 1- 4
122' A $ E*
C
$ B
$ E* C
' + 122'
C
@
B <9 'R
B
'2 <R
& ' ';;; =

$ E$ + @
= %
= $ F 7 : (
' + 122' 5 C
6 C
@ B
159
B $ E*
B 12 122' B
$ $ E* 5$$*6
8 3 8
0
5'1 3 122'6 B $$*
E$
C <2
';;; ', > ';;; @
'4 ';;- 7
<2
$ ';;; '4 1222 3 122' A
<2 ';;;
C '
4 ';;-
C ' > 122'

8 <95165 6 ( 8
F
8 <95165 6
8 E* ( 8
160
<95165 6 # 1' 4
';;;
C %
(
( 3 " C
(
8
A ( 3
C
(
<95165 6 C
E$ F 7 : 3
'/
<95165 6
C
<95165 6
( 3 %
( A
C
:/-' ;2; @ :.2 222 +
161
' ' 0&
<'/ B
$ E* @
$
<'9
( &
*
<'- (
@
# 7 $
@
C %
162
!++ '! &
<'; B % E
8 <-5165 6
( 8 ';;.
<12 ( &
$ E* <2 ';;; A
8 <-5165 6 ( 8
';;.
<1' ( &
7 ( &
& (
A 4 1221
& '/R '.R ';;;
& (
<11 ( & 8
<95165 6 ( 8 ';;. 8
<95165 6 #
@
C
163
<1< "
( & A
( & @
<1.
( &
@
B $ E*
F
<1,
@ '2 . '
& ( $ A
<1/
@ ( C
./< ,/1 J8
<9 ( C * (
<19 ( 5 <
(8 C 6 #
A
7
# #
164
B $ E* F
B $ E*
>
C B $ E*
@
:
/> 122'
!++ '! &
<1-
C
$ = J
165
( '2 . < &

( $
# #
<1; ( &
<<2 ( &
< : 122'
166
5W
167
<<' 7 * 8
+ 0$ ';;<
*
0 # 7
7 *
8
7 E
#
@
#
E (
*
#
* ';;<
7 $3',2
<<1 8 7 % 8
7 $ > ';;.
# #
* 7 *
@
+ ';;,
@ 7 @
168
* 8
7
<<< + @ 7
# H
# J )
# )
7
7
1<.
7 5
'' 4 ';;96 7
@
8
"
7 % %
1<,
<<. B '1 1222 > D "
(%0' '2 / )'( ($ & $'(
F
234
A copy of the judgment of the Cape High Court, delivered by His Lordship Mr Justice Farlam, under case
number 4840/96, was received in evidence as Exhibit “Z”.
235
A copy of this article was received in evidence as Exhibit “WW”
169
& 0 $'( !( ) + #%&' &&+ 56 0

7& '& )'( 5 "$ *& !% $'7 ) ' #!
0 + L & !""' 0/ & % ' */ +! & !""' 0/ ' && &
$' '0 '! < $! & !( $' '0 '! 4 '0% #* $ &&
!% # $ &/ % &) ' & !( 5 <
+ & 2 $ " !"$ $! 0 ) * ) !:2 #
% (! % !%0 ! ( $$ % 7& &" $$48
<<, 7
8 3 "
> D
7
0 $ A
3 " 7
( *
<</ $ 8 1222 # 7
7
$3' -
1</
E 19
8 1222 7& ( & )
# $ 8 $ 4
#
236
Cape Times headline dated 7/09/2000, Exhibit “WW”, p11.
170
1<9
$ 4
#
122' C 4 1221 7 %
!)
7& ' +'$$'! &8 F $$ 0 '! & !( (! '0
% * &+%00$' 0 A F 7& & # !%0 ' !
!% ( ' < %& !( < & !( +'$$'! & !( &481<-
7
3 3 " # 7 %
3 1221
<<9 #
' 2 & '0 "! %"! $$ 0 '! & ' + ' $ ' 0
! "!&&'#$ '" !( +! ' & #* " &! & ( !+ 56 0
7& 8/ 3 1221
8
#
7 #
B 1221 *
237
Cape Times, 27 September 2000, Exhibit “WW”, p12.
238
Cape Times, 9 January 2002, Exhibit “WW”, p13.
171
F 5W
! % ! * ' 0 ! =D !2 +# =>>,
<<- 7
( 1222
1<;
# 7
3 ( & (
3 " 3 > 8
19 + 1222 $
1.2
@
7 % 7 8
5? ?6 7 (
3 '9 22 1- + 1222 F
( ! !% $ " ! ! 2 & '! !( '& +! ' 0

& @% & 2'& )' '$& !( " 7' 0
0 + & (! 7& 4
7' 0 )'$$ # 2 '$ #$ ' & % '* % 0 !%
" 7' 0 !( !2' ' $ +' '& '!
#%'$ ' 0/ $ / " !) 4
&& '& !# ' #* '2' 0 %" $ / % ' 0 $ (
' ! ! 0 / $ ( 0 ' ' ! ! " 4 ! ' % !
% '$ !+ / % $ ( 0 ' 4 #!!+
239
Record of proceedings, page 325
240
Record, Exhibit “X”, page 18 and 19
172
#$! 7& ) * & % ' * & (( )'$$ !" ' !

' '(' '! / " ! & " '0 ' ! " 7' 0
0 0 4
!! & ! $ ( ) ' $ ! $'( &4
+' :& !((' &%' / (' & ($!! / !!+ ,DJ4
! ( '$' " 7' 0 0 + &/ "$ & !%$ *!%
2'& + !( !$! *" !( < * 7&8
<<; 7 # (
/22 D 3 C "
3 7 3 "%
3 "
! '! & (! +! ' $$'
<.2 $ 1- + 1222 3 "

# $ :1 ,
@ 7
@ $ 7 3 "
# 8
7
$ &
(
173
<.' D 3 " 3 @
1.'
7 3 "
$ 7
1.1
:1,2 222 22
<.1 7 @
3 "
@ :,22 222 221.<
@ H8S9, 222
<.< 7 %
E
#
<.. 7 4 122' 3 "

C : 8 3
$3'2, 222 22 3 "1..
241
Record, p349
242
Record, p350
243
Record, p351
244
Record, p352 to 353
174
#
:.22 222 22 H E # 7
$3'2, 222 22
1.,
3 " 1; + 1222
<., 8 @
3 "
$3'2, 222 22 :,22 222 22
@ D D
5 ( ( &
6 :,22
222 22 1./ 7
3 % 3 " % D
%
<./ B 3 " $
@ :122 222 22 :1,2 222 22
J
3 3 " 1.9 J
7
7
245
Record, p1061
246
Record, p355
247
Record, p357
175
3 "
4 C 8
* & = $ 7 @ J
@ 3 "
<.9 $ E # 7 8 7
3 "
1.- 1.;
7 @
:9 9-. 22 - 122' *
& = (
1,2
8 @
- 122' +
7
@ 3 "
1,'
7 3 "
@ $ @
248
Record p1008
249
Exhibit, “EE1”
250
Exhibit, “EE2”
251
Record, p1013
176
<.- B @ 7
1,1
# :1-, 222 22
1,<
7
<.; " 8 (8
3 4 7 5?4 7 ?6
$
* > 8 5?* ?6
<,2 $ '. $ 1222

8 8 E E $ & F
! ) !+ ' + * !
'& ! (' +& $!# $ ' & 0 ! 0'2
! '! !( XKJ >>>4>> & "!$' ' $ ! '! !
+! ' $$' 4 # !% !( '&
/ $ * / " !) 4 3 !4 .>J==S
K-J, ! ?,=,>- 8
<,' '9 4 122' $

! ) !+ ' + * ! 8/ F
)!%$ ( ! '(' $ ' 0 !

! '! ( !+ $!# $ ' ,. +# =>>>4
252
Record, p1020
253
Record, p359
177
)!%$ "" ! # &!+ ! (%&'! ' 0

! )! # 7 !% & !( +! ' $$' '&
! (' +& ' +& !( !% ! '0' $ @% & XKJ
>>>4>> & !%$ # " ' ' ! !% !( F!
% '! % / $ * / " !) <
!% %+# L .>J ===S K==D/ ! L ?,=,>-8
$ &
1,.
8
<,1 7 # *
3 C
7 #
S9, 222 22 # 5
:9,2 222 226
$3'2,
1,,
222 22 5 6
<,< &
8 5?8 ?6 7 %
8 (8 '/
> 122' $ & (
F
254
Exhibit “X”, page 17
255
Record, p866
178
' &
+ !( ( +'$* 7& ! &/ + 2 * " !%
!& *!% ! '! 4
E!% & ( ' (%$$*
$ % 8=JS
<,. 7
8
8 7 8 '< 4
1221 8
1,9
'/ > 122'
<,, 7 @ $
:. 222 222 22 122.
7 @ $
1,-
$ A
3 3 "
% *
<,/ 7 122'
3 7
256
Exhibit “X”, page 22
257
Exhibit “AA”
258
Record, page 365
179
D 7
1,;
3 +
3 3 " 3 8 5 6
* 3 7 7 3 7G : B
3 #
$ 7
3 1221 7
% ' 0 !( ! 7 $ ' '0 '! 8
<,9 $ B + 122'
++( $
3 %
$ &
* + 3 3 8
;.<'02' *+3 $ 7$ D "
;,-,02'
<,- 3 I >
A 3 ( J " 5J " 6
7 % #
C 19 + 122' "
259
Record, p858
180
I > A
1/2
:1'; '-1 22
<,; 7 # 3
7 3 J "
" 8 3 7
7 3
</2 I
> A 19 + 122' 3
" 8 (8 5 6
4 7 C 8 7
3
@
:'22
222 22 ,+ 122') :1. 9-; .' '< + 122' :.-
222 22 <2 4 1221 :./ <;1 ,;
3 J "
4 1221
</' 7 :'22 222 22

3 3 : 5?: ?6) :., 222 22
260
Exhibit “X”, p2 to 15 and Exhibit “BB”
181
8 ) $3'2
222 22 3 )1/'
# :., 222 22 :.- 222 22
8 8 "
</1 & @
7 :'22 222 22
: <2
4 1221 :.- 222 22
1/1
8 #
</< &
I > A
B 5$ $ * (
6 3 " C 3 ( H
" 8 J 8
<' B 122' '2 22
11 22 7 %
1/<
A C
7 % B
7 %
261
Record, p370
262
Record, p921
263
Record, p371
182
%
7 #
7 C
$ E # 7 8 C
7
C
8
C
</. 7
8 @ 3
1/.
$ (! ! 7 $:& !++! '! '00!2 $
</, </, 8 @ ( '' + 122'

3 @ D
&
<// 1- + 122' 8
: ( 5?8 ?6 " 8 (8 4
7 %
# $
122' 3 1221 :- 222 22
264
Record, p945
183
:- ,22 22 #
:/2 ,92 22 :'1
222 22 #
7 #
% 3 *
$ 5 $ 6 3
</9 7
# :., 222 22 8
1/,
8 $ E # 7
1//
8 8 '2 $ 122'
$
:,, /,, 22 7 #
8
7
:., 222 22 3
1/9
8 7
8
8
3 % 8 @
# :;1 222 22
:;. 222 22 7 E # F
265
Record, p966 to 967
266
Exhibit “DD13”
267
Record, p977
184
! &L ! *!% " ' .J >>>P
7& L E &/ #% '& $ / ! &/ ) &

"" !I'+ $*4 0! $ $ / ( ! & #*
! 7 $:& !% / :2 (! 0! '& +
!)/ ) ! $ ! %& ) &7 (! -=
>>>4>> ! -. >>>4>>4 + &% ) (!% '& $
'& '& $ :+ ( ' 0 !4
! &L & 4 ! < #* '& !% / '&

' $ P
7& L ' $ / I $* * &4
! &L &7 (! -. >>>4
7& L 5 / -> < ' ->&: C 48=SD
</- + 7 8 3 5
@ 6 @ 8 :;1
222 22 :;. 222 22 7 8 % E # F
! &L "" ! *!% .J >>> )

"" % $ :& I +! *P %& &
% & ( !+ *!%/ ' ) & ' ->:&/ &! '( *!% 0 2 .J
>>> % $ )!%$ 2 0'2 .J +! 4
7& L I $*4
! &L )! ) "" ! $$ P
7& L $$ ) )'$$ (' !% 4
268
Record, evidence of Mr Harksen, page 968
185
! &L & BB
7& L $$ ! : 7 !) '+ % $
" ' 4 ! $* 7 !) ) 0! $ ( !+
!% ( !+ ! 7 $/ *!% 2 + '! + /
! '& $ ) & ('0% + '! ' 7 !%
-> >>>/ -. ! ) 2 '& !+ &/ '&
&! ) * + '! " ' $( '& % $
" ' ! $(4
! &L ' "" P $ #*

' $ P
7& L ) & B !%$ # 5 % */ # % */ '

!%$ # < ) $ # & ! 7 $1& #' *
% $ :& !%& / ) $&! '& %&& ' < !
$$* + +# 4
! &L % ) & : ' # (! +!2 ' ! !%&

$) &" ' P
7& L !/ ) & $ * +!2 ' 4 ) & $ *

+!2 ' ! !%& / ! &4
! &L % & + !( ( *!% )'$$ & F

' + " ' JJ SJJ ! ,> !( +# / *!% &
PB
! &L !/ ) $$ !#! *:& &%00 & ' 0 B *

)!%$ *!% " * ! -. >>>P * )!%$ # -.
>>> " ' P
7& L $$ :+ ! 2' &) '&

$ !( !% !( ! 7 $4
@% & -= ) 2 +! * ' 2!$2 :+
186
! 2' ) &%#"! '& 0 $ +

)'$$ 0'2 2' I $* ) * &7 (! '& +! *4
! &L !/ ' $ P
7& L E &4
! &L ! *!% ' 7 ' :& 0!! ' ' $

& !%$ 0'2 2' P
7& L E &/ ' 7 '& '& 2 * 0!! ' 4
! &L 7& (! &%00 & '! 4
7& L * "$ &% 48=S-
</; A 7
8 )
8 > 1221)
8 > 1221
@
8 8
# :., 222 22 > 03 1221
3 %
7 :., 222 22
3 A
$ 122' 3
8 5 6 > 1221
269
Record, evidence of Mr Harksen, p976 - 977
187
%" '! #* 7!)' T !( % 0 $!) $'( ! "! &

(
<92 7 3 "
B 122' E
3 " 7 #
4 3 "
E :12 222 22
# 7 3 "
192
#
@
<9' $ E # 1/ 4 122' 4
19'
7 3 " F
& 7&
7 *!% (! 0 ' 0 ! &%#9$ % 0 $!) % ' 0
" '! !( $ '! & !( !% !+ 4
!%0 ' "" !" ' & !%$ ! # !
0 + & ) '2 9
,4 " '! !( &%#9$ )!%$ # ( !+ =? 5%$*
=>>, (! "" !I'+ $* ? +! &L
=4 +! $* $& $$ # => >>>4>> " +! 1
?4 )'$$ # &"! &'#$ (! $ ' '* ! &%+
$ " ! 0 &1
270
Record, p870-871
271
Exhibit “Y” and Record p869-870
188
.4 )'$$ # &"! &'#$ (! * + 0 %& 7' 0 ' !

! &' '! " !" * ! & '& (%$$*
' &% 1
J4 E!% 2 2'& !) & ! & !
&%#9$ 4
7 *!% (! *!% !9!" '! &&'& *!%
2 0'2 ! +* )'( ' 0' 0 '& & '! 4
<91 A 7 7 8 E #
3 " @ 7
7 :/2 222 22
3 " @
7
$$ 0 '! & !( (' & '2 #* ! 7 $ 7!)' T
<9< 7
3 3 " 0 $
F
7 3 " H8
# 122' 3
& (
3 " @
H8
7 H8S12 222 22
189
3 "
H8 7
191
@ 3 "
7
7 H8
J 3
J 3
H8S1 ,22 22 8 122'
$ 8
& 8
7
7
3 3 "
)
*
$ 3 5
3 "6 E
)
E H . $ 122'
3
D A
3
272
Record p378
190
7 %
19<
7 + 3
3 " 7 %
B 3
; > 1221 3 # % :
%
3 7 3 F
)! (%$ 2 ' 0 ' &%" # ; ' 0 !%& : +! 0

$!2 $* ( ' &4 )'$$ # # 7 0 ' 48=K.
3 7
F : F
<9. 7
@
273
Record p2141
274
Exhibit “QQ”
191
<9, A @ 7
3 3 "
3 3 "
$ # $
) 3
) )
7 3 D
) 3 ")
& $ $
5?& $$ ?6) 3 8 >
7
#
A
<9/ 3 " 7
> 1-
+ 1222 3 1221 7
3 3 "
#
7
<99 7 % $ H8
S9, 222 22 0 $3 '2, 222 22
3
3 " 7
$3 '2, 222 22 3 "
192
$ :9,2 222 22
$3;;
222 22 $ 122' 3 "
3 3 " #
8 7 %
<9- J 7 @
@ :,22 222 22 '/ > 122'
$ @
:1-, 222 22 5 6
J
@ :,22 222 22
7
% @
7 %
@ :1-, 222 22
@ :,22 222 22
7 % @
@ 8 7 % E
* & =
3 " @
193
<9; & 7 %
3 % 7 7
8
A 7 #
8 3
7
8 8
7 = 7
7 3 7
3 8
@
<-2 & 7 3 %
#
7
%
<-' 7
I > 7 J "
7
19,
3 0 8 J "
275
Record p2271
194
7 E
3 %
7 7
8
19/
<-1 7 C D $
$ E #
D
7 % D
C
7 %
D 7
<-< 3 3 " 7
7
(
3 > (
B 3 3 "
7
7 % A
276
Record p2270 and p2294
195
F L9 56
70 !%
<-. 3 ';-.
7 : (
7 " ';;-
( & (
'' + 122' $ B ';;-
3 " 3 >
3 "
199
$ A 3 %
F ) ) !" +) ' + ! (% '&' 0
(! (! ' '& " !2' 48
' ' $ ' 0 )' 56 0 7& V !+'& & !( ! '!
<-, 3 @ #
7
1- + 1222 7
277
Record: p 1821(14)
196
7 % #
19-
7
#
$! !( '+ ' :& &% #$ * ! & &
19;
! : #! ! ' * !) 7 F 444
+* )'( & )&" " & ! + ' +! ' 0 $$& +
) :& "" ' 0 * ! ' '0 / '( :2 0!
1-2
<-/ & 7
3 L
444 #% 7 $ ) (! '0 * & )' $$

$$ 0 '! & + 0 ' & '+ !" " !"$ '
" + !( 5%& ' !%$ & '$$ ! 0 '+ !% !(
!% */ &! ! & *& ! *!% & $(/ ;" "& '& 0%* & 0!
&!+ &! !( & ! * '( ( '0 * & '& & '$$ 4:8=D,
278
Record: p 1909(27)
279
Record: p 1826(12)
280
Record: p 1909(8)
281
Record: p 1912(27)
197
<-9 3 7
1-1
* # 7
1-<
7
7 * #
1-.
7 B
7
<-- 3 "" 3 "

1-,
7 8
1-/
3 " 7
<-; $ 7
3 " '22
282
Record: p 1913(5)
283
Record: p 1913(18)
284
Record: p 1916(6)
285
Record: p 1917(20)
286
Record: p 1918(16)
198
1-9
3
1--
'22 :' ,22 222 22 3
1-;
#
'22 ,22
1;2
'22 A
7
3 " 3
7 $ 5 $
1;'
6
<;2 :
7 %
& 7
1;1
$ 3 " 3
7
3 " 7& & !(( ! 0'2
287
Record: pp 1817(28); 1923(20)
288
Record: p 1925(10)
289
Record: p 1923(28)
290
Record: p 1924(9)
291
Exhibit “X” 18
292
Record: p 1925(25) and p1926(4).
199
1;<
" * ! '! 4
3 3 " 7
5 6
1;.
7 7
@ 8
8 +
7
<;' 3 @ 3 "
7
1;,
# :,22 222 22
<;1 3 % E #
7
7 7 $
$ 0' '+
1;/
+! * & E #
293
Record: p 1926(10)
294
Record: p 1926(18)
295
Record: 1927(3)
296
record: p 1927(10)
200
7
:,22 222 22 F )!%$ : 2
7 !) ) ! !48=-K &
)!%$ : 2 9 ! $* ) ' 0 +! * )!%$ 7 !)
) ! !481;- 7
1;;
F &
<22
)!%$ 2 " '4 & @
@ $ 3 F 444 '(
+! * )!%$ :2 ' ) ! ! )' ' 48 7
<2'
3
:,22 222 22 1- +
1222 7
<21
7 # F
( !% & )!%$ 2 ! 0'2 ' # 74 !%$ : # $$!) !

<2<
7 " +! * ( !+ 7& " &! $$*8 )!%$ #
" " ! " ( !+ 7& ( )!%$
297
Record: p 1932(25)
298
Record: p 1932(30)
299
Record: p 1933(10).
300
Record: p 1933(12)
301
Record: p 1934(3)
302
Record: p 1977(18)
303
Record: p 1977(18)
201
' ! % %& ! #%&' && " !"$ )!%$ + 7 ! '! !

48<2.
<;< 3 7 #
<2,
@ 8
7 %
<2/
<;. # 3 #
<;, 3
<29
:,22 222 22 7
5 6 $
7 3 7
<2- <2;
@
304
Record: p 1977(23)
305
Record: p 1977(29)
306
Record: p 1978(5)
307
Record: P 1935(5)
308
Record: p 1935(19)
202
7
# # 7 % 3 1221 &
7
#
3 " 7
<'2
7 3
<''
7 8
7 7
<;/ 8 @ 1- + 1222
$
7 * 3
# F
) & ' (! + #* M 7& ) &

0!' 0 ! + 7 ! '#% '! / ' 7/ !( XKJ >>>48<'1/
309
Record: p1935(17)
310
Record p1936(20); 1937(16)
311
Record p1939(29)
312
Record: p 1951(10)
203
' : 7 !) + !( !+" */ $$ 7 ) '

) & !+' 0 ( !+ !% &' !% * '( ' ) &
7& :& !+" *! !/ ) & : &% 48?,?
444 ' )!%$ :2 !+ 2' !+" * &&%+

7& ) & ! )' 48?,.
<;9 3 # H8 S9, 222 22

:,22 222 22
<',
7 H8
<'/
S9, 222 22 122'
7& 2' '& ! '! & '
' '! $ !++% ' * ) & 0!' 0 ! 0 %& ! '! !(
<'9
XKJ >>>/>>4 7 7
<'-
313
Record: p 1951(14)
314
Record: p 1951(18)
315
Record: p 1951(30)
316
Record: p 1953(1)
317
Record: p 1954(6)
318
Record: p 1954(29)
204
<;- B 3 %
3
7 7
#
'" !( %+ !( -- >>>/>>L
<;; 3 " $
$3;; 222 22 $ 3 @
3 "%
$3;; 222 22
>
%
3 % $3;; 222 22
.22 3 $3;; 222 22

3 " "!&&'#$* # )
+! & !( 5%$* %0%& 8 122' <'; B
319
Record: p 1973(12)
205
3 "
$ 3
3 " 7
3 "
<12
7
7
<1'
3 " @
<11
3 @
<1<
3 "
.2' A 3 "% @ 3
8 @
3 " <1. 7 8
= 3 C8 C
<1,
5? ?6 3 = 3 @
320
Record p1973(28)
321
Record 1974(11)
322
Record 1973(20)
323
Record p1981(3)
324
Record: p 1987(30)
325
Record: p 1986(3)
206
8 $
<1/
C8
.21 C 3 = 3 = 3 @
3
<19
3
= 3
3 # @
3
$
.2< = 3
> = @
# A
$ )
) #
@ $ 3
8 )
326
Record: p 1986(7)
327
Record 1989
207
# + (
8 7
$ @
.2. = 3 #
# #
#
.2, 3 @
7
= 3
F
# %& ' ) & (' & '+ ) : '2 ! '!

' (! '0 % *' & 84?=D
.2/ 7
328
Record: p 1986(19)
208
<1; <<2
7 = 3
# 3
= 3
<<'
@
.29 3 #
&
= 3
#
<<1
7 =
<<<
3
8 @ = 3
C8 B
$3;; 222 22 E
7 P $
329
Record: 1989(25)
330
Record: p 1989(20)
331
Record: p 1991(3)
332
Record: p 1993(27)
333
Record: p 1993(30)
209
7 %
.2-
$3;; 222 22 3 @ 3 "
<<.
'1 1221 3 "
*
7 % A F
'& -- >>> ) & '2 ( !+ ) $$ 7 !) $! $

(' ' (% '&' 0 2 $ 7& :& !+ 4
%& !( '& 0 $ + :& #%&' && $' 0& )'
!2 + & &7 ! + ' ! *+!%& &'
( & # 7$ & ( !+ 48
.2; E
3 3 "
7
.'2 3 3 " @
3 7 ',1
A 3
334
Record: p 1981(14) & (22)
210
3 " @ 5 3
6 7
! 7 $ ' '0 '! 8
.''
7
.'1 3 7
3
7
:'22 222 22
: ) $3/ 222 22 5 :1. 9-; .'6 8 )
:.- 222 22 8
I > A 7
:./ <;10,;
$ (! ! 7 $:& !++! '! '00!2 $
.'< 3 ( '' + 122'

@ ( D
3 &
211
# ( 3
7
<<,
3 E
7
:/ 222 22 3
.'. 7
<</
8 5 6
1- + 122' 4 7 %
5 7 6 8
( 8 3 #
@ $
7
$ 4 7 %
C 8
7
7 % 7
7 3 % F
!++'&&'! L * ' *!% ) !+ 7& P
335
Record p1885(22)
336
Exhibit “X”, p16
212
2 ' + L %& '& 2 * '+"! " &! / ) &

2 */ 2 * '+"! " &! '+ / ! + 7&
) & ! !% / + 4
!++'&&'! L * )!%$ *!% 2 ! &' ' ! !% P
2 ' + L %& + / 2 * ' 0 ) &/ * & '

+%& 0 '& ! 7& / ! 7 $ '& %&&'! & )'
7& B
B !++'&&'! L + !+' 0 ! @% & '! !( ! !% / ) *

)!%$ ' 2 # ! !% P
B F ' + L !/ !/ (! +*& $( 2 : + 7&

) !) $$* & */ '& +* / 7& 4
B 2 ' + L ) !& 7 '& & */ '& '&

! 0 488??K
.', $ % 7
.'/ 3 8
7 7
<<-
8 3
7 7
337
Record p3184
338
Record p1885
213
$
8 3 3
<<;
& 5 :1;, 222 226
E
<.2
.'9 A '2 $ 122' $ @

:,, /,, 22
:'1 222 22) :.,2 22)
:'2- 22 $ 122' 3 1221
<.'
:.< 2;9 22
3 3J 3 '' $ 122'
:'1 222 22
:- 222 22 +
#5 6
.'- 7 :., 222 22

3 8
3 7
339
Record: p 2036(19)
340
Record p1887
341
Exhibit “DD” 2 & 13
214
8 5 6
8 8 "
:.; -1, 22 8 J A 9/ 5( 6
D 58 J 6
.'; 7 % 3 8
8 @ #
:;1 222 22 3
8 >
1221 7 8 8
@ 7 5
3 12216 3
8 3
<.1
8 F
! &L ' $ $&! ' ' ! ! &'! '

) & '& / "!&&'#'$' * !( *!% + 7' 0 ! '#% '!
!) & ! 7 $:& $ !( " !" * ' '00!2 $ 4
$* $ ( %) !(4 ' !+ %"P 5= 6
% $ L E &/ ' < ) & '& %&&'! / <# %&
' 7 $ :& !%& ) & & '$$ # ' 0 #%'$ +!2 ' !
"$ ' !) / ! " * ) &
& ! 0 & ' / *!% 7 !)/ )'$$ $"48?.?
342
Record p1891 to 1892
343
Record p3325
215
.12 8 3
F
!++'&&'! L !) ) &' / $! ! 0'( P
% $ L ) & 0'( / * &4
#& L % *!% % & ' 0 ( !+ '+ ) &

) & & ! 0 / ) & $ 7 !( (% &/ ) & & ! 0 /
!%$ : " * / '& '0 P
% $ L :& ! 4 ' 7 ) !2 '& !

'& !%& 4
B44
% $ L ! + / *!% 7 !) "" $* '

' ) & !! ( (! ) / !! ( (! ) !%$ ((! /# %&
'& !% & !+' 0 %" B
!++'&&'! L / &! !%$ : ((! 'P
% $ L :& ! / * &48?..
.1' 8 3 8
8 % D '1 > 1221 B '<
> 1221 3 $
3 %
344
Record p3332-3333
216
<.,
8 B
8
8 J
<./
#
3
$ 3 :.- 222 22 5 :.< 2;9 226)

:/22 22 5 :.,2 226)
:'/ 1,2 22 5 :'1 222 226 5
6
:; ,22 22
# 4 4 1221
:'9 222 22 8
3
# 3
.11 8 @
$
$ 122' F
#& L ( *!%: # ' (! + $

$ *# " ' ) & : !% & ' 0/ )!%$ *!% & '$$ 2
0'2 ! 7 $ +! *P
345
Record p3282-3283
346
Exhibit “HHH”
217
% $ L ) & ! &&' * $$*48?.K
.1< + # 7 %
7
8 '< > 1221

# 8 9
3 1221 7
:., 222 22 8 5 8
6 1- 3 1221 D '- 4 1221
E # 7 8 3
# :;1 222 22
@ ) # :., 222 22
8 8 3
4 1221 8
8 J
.1. 8 J $
$ ( 5( 6
8 % A 8
3
$ ';;1 $ 3 %
<.-
347
Record p3334
348
Record p3205 - 3207
218
& " +! * 2 $!"+ %& L
.1, 3 8
& $$ 3 7
7 #
$ & (
7
7
<.;
7 P5 3 6
P
3 A 0</,;0122' 12
$ 122'<,2 3
3 7 3 " 1'
<,'
$ 122'
.1/ 3
7
3
349
Record 2001(26)
350
Exhibit “HH”
351
Exhibit “FF”
219
.19 3
<,1
$
<,<
444 )!%$ 2 # ! '! & #%&' && &&! ' &

!( 7& 8
$&!/ * &! !( ! *+!%& ! ! )!%$ ) !

! '#% ! %& ' & (!% ' 0" ' '"$ &48?J.
.1- 8 @ & $$ 3
*
8
3 8
8 D
* 4 1221
<,,
3 8 P 3 % P 7
3 #
352
Record: p 2001(8)
353
Record: p 2001(12)
354
Record: p 2001(20)
355
Record p1092-1094
220
<,/
3
)
8 " )
3 :'2
<,9
.1; & E #
3 % F
' : + ) ' + ( !+/ & $! 0 & ' ) & #*

$ 0 $+ &48?JD
.<2 7 3
:'2
<,;
8 " 3 F
)!%$ : & * ' ) & )' T $ / ' !%$ :2 #

*) 48?S>
356
Record: p 2002(17)
357
Record p1095
358
Record: p 2005(10)
359
Record: p 2005(12)
360
Record: p 2005(15)
221
.<' & 3 % F
!%$ :2 & ' / * &48?S,/
.<1 # #
3 F
#& L '( *!% ' & * ' / ) * ) & ( !

)' T $ P :& ) :+ &7' 04
! 7 $L )!%$ : 7 !)4
#& L E!% : &) P
! 7 $L !%$ < !/ ) $$ ' !%$ # < !/ $ +

! &) 4
#& L E!% : &) P
! 7 $L !4 ! : !$$ / &! B
!++'&&'! L ! 7 $) ' *!% & * P
! 7 $L & ' $ + ! < :+ ! 0!' 0 ! &" %$

</1
!) ! ) !%0 '+
361
Record: p 2005(26)
362
Record p2005-2006
222
.<< 3 @ 8 "
*
7
$ 8 "
8G 122'
3 " 8 + 122'
3 $3/ 222 22
8 "
.<. 3 % F
!++'&&'! L % ' *!% ' 7 7& )!%$ # ' 0

+! *P
! 7 $L !/ ! 7& / !4 !4 !4
!++'&&'! L 6 P
! 7 $L !/ ! 6 / !4 ! $!!7/ $ + $$ *!%4
!%0 +* ( ' / % $ / ) & 2 *
' & ! &&'& %& !%0 2' '+ ' <
# %& '& & '! ' )' T $ / !%0 " "&
B
#& L ! :& # & ' )' T $ / &! ,>

+'$$'! ) & "!&&'#$* 0!' 0 ! !+ ( !+ '+ ( !+
)' T $ P
! 7 $L ! ( !+ '+ #% " "& '& ( ' &)

'& # & / *!% 7 !) ) + 4 % ' 7 )
+%& 2 0! !%0 +* +' '+ / # %&
223
% $ ' & * )!%$ &&'& / )!%$

" "& ' & %+ $ &' ' &&'& ' 0 '&48?S?
.<, A
:'22 22 3
& $$
2 $% '! !( ! 7 $:& 2'
.</ 3
A
F
3 7 19 8 1222
( *
7
* 7
@
B 3 7
@ $
7
& 5 #
363
Record p2006-2007
224
6
7
$
7
$ #
# 7
3
3 7
$
7 8 1222
3 1221 #
#
7 8 5 7 6)
7 ) 7
D
) 7
$
5
6
8 $ 7 %
D
7 A 7
3 $ 3
225
3 $3 ;; 222 22
7 5 6
3 "
#
7 $3;; 222 22
7 3 % @
= 3
=
3 C8
= 3 3
3 %
@ 3 "
$3;; 222 22 7
7 3
8
@ #
$
B
3
$3;; 222 22 @
7
226
C #
8
7
8 :
& 3 #
@
#
3 8
7
8
8 3
8 > 1221
$
3 1221 3
8
227
3 # #
# :9,2 222 22
7 # #
3
7 7 $
# 3
7 # 7
8
7 %
D 7
8 3 7
7 % 3 " 5? " ?6
8 #
$ 7
3
3
$
" 7 % 3
#
" (
"
8
&
228
3
7 7
3 %
7 %
3
@ @
> 3
(
#
&
3 7
7 %
F ML
70 !%
.<9 3 " ';-2

7 3
';-, ';-9 7 3
7 J +( ';;, ++(
229
';;/ ';;- 7
3 ( &
B ';;- 3 > $
* & (
7
, $ 122' $ *
* +
</.
++(
.<- ( 7 3 "
> D " '1 1222
</,
A E #
3 " 7 )
:< /
) # 8 *
A
@
7 3 "
)
7 ) *
<//
# *
A
7 3 " @
364
Record, evidence of Mr Markovitz, page 2347
365
A copy of this article was handed in to the Commission as exhibit “WW “, pages 7, 8 & 9
366
Record, page 2429
230
7 % )
$ ( ( * *
>
</9
D $
7 (
</-
(
' ' $ ' 0 !+'& & !( ! '! &
.<; 3 " # + 1222 $

</;
,$
<92
1222 7
$ 7
7
7
J
3 "%
@ 7 %
# > D
367
Record, page 2356
368
Record page 2424 - 2429
369
Record, page 2430
370
Record, page 2437
231
%
<9'
@ C 8 +
7
..2 3 "
7 ( 3
( * 1- + 1222 A
7 7
<91
0 ) ! $'7 + 2 * +% A 7
'22 4
8 5 6
$
<9<
3 " F
! &L !)/ ' @% & '! !( !(( #* '+ ! #%'$

,>> !%& & ! "$ & 7& # #% !) ' 5!
$!2! +" !+ %"P
371
Record page 2349
372
Record, p2351
373
Record, p2452 - 2453
232
7!)' TL ' !+ %"/ #% ' ' : !+ %" < ! * &/

!/ ' :& @%' ! / ' ' !+ %" % ' 0 +* '& %&&'! '
+* !((' :& ) ( $ + *#
+' & !%$ ) ! & */ ' ! ! 7
" ' %$ + & 0 (% B
! &L *!% ' ! % '+4 :+ ! 0!' 0 ! 0!

!2 ' 0 ' / @% & '! !( ,>> !%& & 5! $!2!
+ %" *!% ' ' ' ! ! 7 $ '& + ) &
" " !" ! % ( !+ !2 & &/ ! '! (! " *P
7!)' TL #&!$% $*/ ' 4
! &L ' *!% & */ '& '& *!% &! !( " & !$!0*L
' 7) 2 ( ' 84
7!)' TL !%$ ' $*/ !%$ ' $* 2 & '

4 : + +# % $ $ 0% 0 + * 2
+"$!* / #% ' 7 &!+ #! * ) ! '& !(( ' 0 KJ >>>
!$$ & ! !# ' ( !+ !+" * !2 & &/ )!%$ # ( '
!( "!$' ' $" *48?K.
! &L !)/ & *&/ '( 2 ! &%++ '& ' / *!%

' ' *!% ) +! * (! *!% " * ( !+ '+P
7!)' TL E &4 F * $* ! ' ! 2 & '!

' ' ' !+ ) & ' &!$2 ' '& !% */
!) )!%$ " * < # #$ ! 0 (! ! '! !
!+ ' ! !% *4 ) &"!7 ' / #% ) &
2 % $$* ! 2 B8?KJ
374
Record, evidence of Mr L Markovitz, p2356 - 2357
375
Record, evidence of Mr L Markovitz, page 2351
233
..' 1- + 1221
7 8
S9, 222 22 $ F
7!)' TL ) ) & !(( )' =J>

>>>4>>/ ) ! J>> >>>4>>/ ) ' ! KJ> >>>4>>
) ' 7 9 9 00 ) + (' & / !) '
+ / ) ' ) & *! )! $ ) 0!
('0% %" ! XKJ >>>4>>/ '& ! $ ' +* +' & !)
<9/
+ (' & / T
..1 *
3 "
..< 3 " 1- + 1221

7 *
<99
S9, 222 22 $ '. $
1222 7 @ $ M
376
Record, evidence of Mr L Markovitz, page 2352
377
Record, page 2349
234
7 * $
'9 4 122' $
S9, 222 22
$ = > C8
3 " 7
S9, 222 22 $ A
$3 '2, 222 22
$3 '22 222 22 $3 ;; 222 22 7
% ! ) 7!)' T V 7&
... A 7 J 3 "
@
$ @ :,22 222 22
C
$
@
J $3 '22 222 22
S9, 222 22 J 3 "
1< > 122' 3 "
7
$3'22 222 22
7
7
235
.., A 3 "
7
J 5
7 6 ( * C 1<
> 122' 7 7
J ) # 7
<9-
J
../ 3 " @
:,22 222 22
..9 3 " ( 3
7
* #
122' A
7 $ 3
..- & 7
H 8 ( * C
122' 3
S12 222 22 7
@ 5
378
Record, page 2362 - 2363
236
7 6 H 8
<9;
# 7
'" !( %+ !( -- >>>4>>
..; 3 " $3;; 222 22

$3' 222 22 *
7
#
<-2
7 % 3 "
+
* $
+ #
3 "
+ 3 "
<-'
; 4 122' 122' 7
3
3
379
380
Record, page 2403
381
Record, p2403, (6–15)
237
7
8
A E # 3 "
7 ) && #* 7& 8
+ 7 ! '! 8 <-1 7
.,2 3 "
# 7
8
7 3 " C
# 3 "
7
<-<
8
7
8
3 "
7
8
7 3 "
:2 0! &!+ +! *8?D. 7
382
Record, p2510
383
Record p2484 - 2485
384
Record p2568-2569
238
<-,
&
3 "
<-/
$3;; 222 22
3 " 8
7
7
3 " %
<-9
8 % E
7 #
.,' 8
3 "
$
<--
+
1221 $
7 7
$ 7
@ 3
385
Record p2590
386
Reocrd p2578
387
Record p2592
388
Record, page 2531 to 2533
239
&
$
C8 = 3 $ 3 #
<-;
8 A
> 1221 #
:'.2 222 22
= 3 7
= 3
<;2
= 3
.,1 3 "
7 3
3 1221 7 7
@ 8 ','
A 7
(
B = @ 7
@ 7 3 A
3 7
J " 7 %
.,< @
7 5
6
389
390
Record, page 2538
240
7 %
$ +
7 %
$
7
.,. &
4 1221
7
.,, A # $3 ;; 222 22
7 7 #
$3 ;; 222 22 122'
7 A 7
S9, 222 22 # * ) 7
<;'
C 1221
7
7 # 1- 3 1221 7
A 7 %
7
<;1
391
392
Record, page 2460
241
%" '! #* 7!)' T !( $'( ! % 0 $!)
.,/ 7
3 " 122'
B 122' 7 % 4
7 5 6 :12 222 22
7
+
7 # :12 222 22
7 @
<;<
@ 7 @ +
@
#
3 " @
47 C
@
+ 122'
3 "
7 122'
@
:/2 222 22
.,9 A B 122' 7 %
* E*
@ 7 %
393
Record, p2389
242
7
<;.
.,- + 7
@
7
<;,
7 7 3
7 D 7 > 1221
* 7
& $$ 3 $ 122'
3 "
3 "
A
! 7 $8 ' '0 '!
.,; $ B 122'
7 D
( 8 7
3 * 7
8 #
7 C
I* 7 7
394
Record, p2399
395
Record, p2399
243
3 7 <'
B 122'
" 8 J 8
7 7 %
: :'22 222 22
<;/
#
@
#
1221
A
7
+ 122'
2 $% '! !( 2' !( 7!)' T
./2 3 " 3
A F
A 3 " 7
7 ( % #
396
Record, page 2384
244
$ 7 %
> D 3 "
7
$ 3 " > D
3 "%
@
P
#
7
7
E
B 7 * 5
6 :1,2 222 22 3 "
:,22 222 22 :9,2 222 22

3 "
E
7
3 " $
8 3 "
B 3 "%
245
* P
7 P
8 *
A
3 "
7 %
8
3 " 7 %
7 %
5 7 % # 6 7 %
E
>
P
7
E 7 :/2 222 22
7
@ +
7 %
>
>
7 %
246
3 "
7 %
3 "
@
3 " #
7
%
@ 7
# 3 "
*
7
# 7
3 # 3 "
3 "
$3;; 222 22 $
%
$3;; 222 22
7 3 "
7
B 3 "
8
7 > 8
3 "
247
# 7 8
3 "
3 "%
A
# 7 )
)
7 3 $
) 3 = 3
)
$
#
7 #
#
3 "
3 "
>
7 # 3 "%
7
248
./' 3 "
7
$3;; 222 22
./1
3
3 " 5 6 7
@
@
&
./< #
3 3 "
7
7
& (
* 7
@
#
./. 3
3 " $
+ =
3
249
7 $
7 + (
% # 3 @
J " 7
$ 3
+ A 7
+
@ A 3 # 7
+
@ 7
+
./, 3 3 "
+ > D '1 122' &
% A
+ :'22 222 22
7
7
.// 7 3 UD 5D 6
( > :'22
222 22 % ';;.
@ 7 %
D
./9
250
./- 7
3 3 "
3 ( ""
@ #
./; 7 3 3 "
.92 7
3
3 "
L -- >>>4>>
.9' @ $3;; 222 22 #

3 3 " A
$3;; 222 22 3 "
122' 3 "
251
7 $
7 J $3;; 222 22
$3'2, 222 22 $3'22 222 22
7 3 3 " #
3 3 "
3 " 4 122'
* 7 3 "
3 "
7 7
#
7 8 3 "
.91
$3;; 222 22 @
F
3 " 7
7
7 )
252
# 3 " 7
( C
8 )
# 7
+ A
3 "
@ 3 " &
7
3 " A
#
3 "
3 "
7 7
7 #
A 3 "
7 7
7
7 3 " >
7
7
253
7 7 3 "
7
7 J
7
7 7
3 "
$3;; 222 22
7
3 "
3
7 A
$3;; 222 22 5 6
F
3 7
8
)
3 = 3 : 3 C8
@ 8 )
254
= 3 3 @
= 3 $
1221 8
3
= 3 % 8
= 3 #
+ (
8 = 3 >
= 3 )
= 3 @
$ M
3 3 " 8
$ %
= 3 7
$3;;
255
222 22
= 3
+ #
$ %
# = 3
3 "
7
@ 7 %
7
3 @
3 7
J "
3 " A 7
3 "
7 @ @
5 6
3 "
.9< A 7
7
256
L 8
.9. 3 E 3 D
B 0+ 122'
7
P 8
3 P 7 %
L :
F
.9, B '' $ 122' 7

$ 3 % 8 +
4 4 1221 5 # #
:- ,22 22 6
.9/ 3 8 >
1221 8
:.; -1, 22
8 J 3 8
4 1221
8 J
257
.99 7
7
.9-
3
L E M
.9; 3 " E 4
7 B 122'
+ 122'
3 " % <'
B 122'
.-2 3 "
:/2 222 22 7
.-' 7
3 " A 3 "
#
7 %
258
L E
M E
E
.-1
3 3 " 7
7 % # +
7 %
.-< $ 7 3 "
= 7
3 "
A 5( 6 D
B+ =+ B 3 "
7
3 C =#
B 8 7 D 3 $
=# B B+ =+ B
259
3 "
7 7
B+ =+ B
260
'2 (% ' 0 !( "!$' ' $" ' &
3 : 3 4 >
A$ 8
&
A A$ 8
7
* ! T
H $ 3 5 H$3 6
# 3 : "
0 $
H$3
# H$3
261
$ A3 $ 8
$ 3 %
%
3 B :
( %
$ 5 $ 6 3" (
+=7 &H
( 8
262
3 D 4 4 $ % :
D M &
$ *
@
V
263
APPENDIX 1
COMPOSITION OF WESTERN CAPE GOVERNMENT
PREMIER
,, E ,--D J =>>,
*+ 3
,, E ,--D< ,. E =>>>
7 D 7 F (4 3
( I F 4&7 3
> I F D7 >
7 F C 7
A I F 74 C
D * I* F ( 3 J "
8 8 F 4 4
ID F ( 3
= I8 F +44 J
3 ( & I3 F 3 D
8 I= F 3 &
,. E =>>> < =D 5 E =>>>
7 ID 7 F C 7
264
= I F 74 C
I& F ( 3
7 F +44 J
8 8 I: F 3*= &
> I$ ( F D$ 3 "
3 ( F >4
D * F ( H
= F 7 Q
F 7* :
= I F *
8 8 I( : F >4 5 6
=D 5 E =>>> < ,- =>>>
7 ID 7 F C 7
8 F 74 C
8 8 I( : F (4 3
8 I: F ( 3
7 F +44 J
> C ( I F D$ 3 "
D * I$ ( F ( H
= F 7 Q
( 3 I& F 7* :
= I F *
,- =>>> < ,D 5 =>>,
7 ID 7 F C 7
8 F 74 C
8 I: F ( 3
265
7 F +44 J
> C I F D$ 3 "
D * I$ ( F ( H
= F 7 Q
( 3 I& F 7* :
= I F *
8 8 I( : F $3 3
,D 5 E =>>, < J =>>,
7 ID 7 F C 7
8 F 74 C
8 I: F ( 3
7 F +44 J
> C ( I F D$ 3 "
D * I$ ( F ( H
= F 7 Q
( 3 I& F 7* :
= I F *
8 8 I( : F $3 3
I F = Q
266
((=+$AW 1
>B: 7= B33A88AB+
& $ & * 3 B :
A+ =8 A* B:
$ 3" (
8= := :L B 7= B33A88AB+
$ A 3
5( $ 48 F3 E4 12216
>B: $ D$ C
+4 8 3 3 3
>B: 3 ( C
3 C>: X& '1 1221Y
>B: ( &
=(3 (8 3 C 7
>B: +A
A 7 D 8 +A
D4C " 3 $ & 3 &447
267
>B: $ 3 *3 I 3 $D 3 "
( C 7 8 ( 3K 3 44C
>B: 3 4 7
( 3 & J 3 3 D
>B: 3 = 7
8 *
>B: 3 J
3 >48
>B: 3 ( J "
( 7 8
>B: 5= > I3 D 6
3 C J "
: +8 :A( AB+ 8=: A =8

268
G?
' 4 ( >
1 4
< J : ( 8
. 3 : D B
, 7 4 C
/ C UD : #
9 : $
- ( J
; 3 4
'2 4G 7
'' * # B
'1 C (
'< = 4 3
'. 7 8
', & 8
'/ & &
'9 $ + 3
'- > ( 8
'; : 3
12 = Z 3 7
1' * 7
11 C ( *
1< D
1. J
1, C J "
1/ * + 3
19 ( J "
1- $ D 3 "
1; $ 4 ( $ 8
<2 $ D $ C
<' J 7 3
<1 * = $
<< A 8
<. 8 DK 7 C
<, A : $
</ & 8
269
G.
E G
=> * =>>= < ,D !# =>>=
D $ * +A $ *
I ( &
C D +A & ( * '-0<021
8 3
C
$ & $ &8E'22
= 3 B % F $ F >
> C 3 7C P
* 3 7 C
7 : 3 C UD : #
4 : 3 : $
J [ %P 3 $
D C $*% P* B
3 C %
+ 1 4G 7 P $
( 6
B F C(
( D @ >
F C(
Z C P F C(
: : 8
8 = + C
270
= * B
H ' $ + 3
$ + 3 <4 122'
& > ( 8
W C ( 5 6
L' D D 3 " 3 47
L1 > # 4 7 3 3 " '0-0122'
L< D 4 7 3 3 " 120''0122'
L. $ :. 1;' 9, P H 1'0'102'
Q > 4 .-.20
B 7=: =W7ACA 8
' & $ &8E'22 \'222 ,1.E,E'2'
D & 8 ( 7 8
CC D I J " 3
838 7 J "
$$ C P 7 P $$'< P
== ==' P @ $D 3 " *
==1 P A *
>> D
** $ $
77 $
271
44 D 7 8
JJ @
DD : 3
33 P 0 '-< P P J
++ $ 3 J "
BB 8 P 0J "
(( : 3 J "
ZZ =# P3 # % :
:: 'E,
88 J
+B$ D
HH D 8 5& $ 6 3 3
> =P
&& 'E'< #
WW D 3 3 %
LL
QQ C P 3
C P( J "
CCC > : P= IL
D 3 3 " 4 8 5A 6
272
$$$ 3 3 "% B I+
=== : + 1 4
>>> $ D$C
*** & 8 %
777 > # 8 8
444 8 J A
JJJ B $
DDD > # = $
333 B $ P $ 7 ';;/
+++ > A
'I1 +++' P( +++1 P 8 I(
BBB $ 3 C
((( (((' > $ = @

(((1 > $ = @ P8

Desai 2

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Desai 2

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

!

! " #$ " ! % & " ' &

* + $" ' & 3! ' 0%$ ' ' & ! " !( *

* (' ' 0& ' &" !( #!2 1

'' B '/ 1221 ( ( * " ,-,9 +

$$ 0 '" !( +! ' &3# (' &/ ' ) &! 2

'. '< 3 1221

($%'& 9 "" ' 9 "& " $ + / "'! &' 9 &

: & 2 &"'! &' + $%'& ' 0 ) ' ;

0 $'0 & ' ! &! 7 # ) ' ' $'0 ' 0 )

(' /) ' ' $% $ " ! ""' 0 @%'"+ / +' !9

' 0$! 0 &7! & ' + $%'& &7 $A

%&& ' '& $ ! !+ ' &"'! * 0'&

" !2' ' $ $ 0'&$ '2 #%00' 0 +*& * & " /

'/ 4 ';;- & (

<2 > B ';;- ,$ 122' 3 D 3 "53 "6

<. $ ';;. ' + ';;/ $ E* F

5?$ 8 ?6 & 8 5?8 ?6 $

'0 & !( " !( &&'! $ ' & +%& #

# ((' ' / ! !+' (( '2 %& !( &!% & +%&

" #'$' ' & !( !0 ,>>

$'+' * && ! % ! !08

!0 & # &'0 ! 0'2 *!% * & !(

! $%&'! & (' ' 0&

" ! % + " ! && (! !0

-' $ > & (

-. B '/ > 122'

' ' 0&

" ! & '+ 2 $% !( J> >>> " & 9

& '& ' '+"!&&'#$ ! '+" ' #$ 4 !) 2 /

!% #'$' * 3 &"! &'#'$' *

' ' 0&

'2< & & $

( &! & 2' 0 && ! % !!+ %& ! ) ' '

0 *+ ' 0 ) & 7' 0 "$ # ) '((

! $%&'! & (' ' 0&

! % + $ ' 0 ! & #$'& + !( % !!+

'1' B '/ 122' @

'1< B <' 122' D : #

= !!& * & ' &%" 2 + $ 2 0 ' 0

'1. B ,8 122' D : # E 3 :( 5?( ?6

' & !% ' 0& 7&' &

'1, & &

" & & ! &'& $* ( * !

8 5?8 88?6 @ 03 122'

'<. $ 8 1222 3 122'

& # &&' 0 ' (! + '! '

0' $ ' 0 (! + '! ' )'$$

% ' )'$$ &'0 '+"$ + (( '2 + &% & !

Premier Director General

Data/information collector Analyst

0 '& '! $ 2 $!"+ & !) !+"$ &% *

!( " + &%""! & '& !++ '! 4

'.2 B 1/ > 122' C F ! + $

'! $ (! '! !( &% % '

' 7$ #$*7$'7 ! $ 2 ' ' ) & !+ '

7 2 !00 2 %' $'7 ' $ 2 7 '' &

B!!7 + ' ' # &! !+ ' &) 7 $; "

(! + $ " ! % (! !" '! !( &% % '

(% '! & !( + +# & !( &% % '

',2 1; B 122' >(

'9) 7$* #' & '! &

! & 2 & 0' ' (! + '! & !( #' /

" !2' ' $ $ 0'&$ '2 #%00' 0 +& & " /

!0 & # &'0 ! 0'2 !% & !(

' + L E &/ #% !% & @% & ) & (! ) '

% & ' 0 $&! ) & ' ) & ! ! $ !