You are on page 1of 6

Received: 29 March 2019 Accepted: 31 March 2019

DOI: 10.1002/pa.1948

PRACTITIONER PAPER

Analyzing the progress and prospects of financial inclusion in


India

Rajesh Barik | Pritee Sharma

Discipline of Economics, School of Humanities


and Social Science, Indian Institute of Taking data from Financial Access Survey, Global Findex and Reserve Bank of India
Technology Indore, Simrol, India
bulletin, this paper tries to analyze the progress occurred and the future prospect
Correspondence of financial inclusion in India. Our analysis depicts that India has witnessed a quick
Rajesh Barik, Discipline of Economics, School
progress in financial inclusion. Though there is long way to go to achieve the dream
of Humanities and Social Science, Indian
Institute of Technology Indore, Simrol 453552, of universal financial inclusion, there is no doubt that tremendous progress has been
India.
achieved in the recent time. Specifically, after the implementation Pradhan Mantri Jan
Email: rajeshbarik195@gmail.com
Dhan Yojana in August 2014, much improvement has happened in opening of bank
deposit accounts. Similarly, the post‐dimerization period has seen a rapid growth of
digital finance in India. Despite high growth of digital transaction, digital payment
among the women, rural people, elderly people, and less educated people is much less
than other groups of people. The provision of good digital infrastructure to the
remote area, opening of more financial literacy centers and extension of credit to
the marginalized people can help to fulfill the true essence of financial inclusion in
India.

1 | I N T RO D U CT I O N financial inclusion in India. After independence, to fulfill the goal of


financial inclusion, GOI nationalized 14 banks in 1969 and again, six
The successes of financial inclusion necessitate inclusion of financially more banks were nationalized in 1980. Similarly, the establishment
excluded and unbanked people under the purview of formal banking of regional rural banks had played greater role to extend the banking
system. The easy access of formal banking to the unbanked/under services to the rural unbanked areas. Likewise, the recent introduction
banked people has become an indispensable part of development for of PMJDY has helped the poor and marginalized people to open their
every country. The provision of secure, adequate and affordable credit bank account with zero or minimum balance. Same like GOI, the
to the unbanked/under banked people is the basic precondition for Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had also undertaken so many initiatives
economic growth, alleviating poverty and reducing income inequal- to extend the banking outreach to the unbanked rural masses. The
ities. There is much empirical evidence that depicts financial inclusion implementation of social banking policy, introduction of Know your
has very significant effect on many economic variables such as pov- Customer norms, opening of financial literacy centers, implementation
erty, inequality, human development and economic growth (see Laha, of no‐frill account and opening of Business Correspondents (BCs) are
2015; Lenka & Sharma, 2017; Park & Mercado, 2017; Zhang & Posso, some of eye‐catching programs initiated by the central bank of India
2017). Realizing the importance of financial inclusion on other eco- to expand the banking outreach.
nomic indicators, every developing and underdeveloped countries in Gwalani and Parkhi (2014) argued that many efforts have been
the world is trying to obtain universal financial inclusion. In this regard, undertaken to fulfill the dream of universal financial inclusion but
the Government of India (GOI) has taken some major initiatives such India being a diversified country needs more innovative models to
as the nationalization of banks, opening cooperative banks, establish- speed up financial inclusion drive, which will alternatively spur eco-
ing regional rural banks and implementing bank licensing policy and nomic growth. Poonam and Chaudhry (2016) found that 2001 to
very recently the introduction of Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana 2014, most of the Indian states have improved the condition of
(PMJDY) are some of the key schemes, which have helped to increase financial inclusion in their respective states. But despite all this

J Public Affairs. 2019;e1948. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/pa © 2019 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 1 of 6
https://doi.org/10.1002/pa.1948
2 of 6 BARIK AND SHARMA

improvement in financial inclusion, still these efforts have failed to India. No‐frill account scheme allows the customers to open their bank
attract the rural poor to obtain the basic banking services. Despite vast accounts with minimum balance or no balance. Similarly, other major
expansion of bank branches, a large number of people are remaining schemes such as Know your Customer, Electronic Benefit Transfer,
excluded from formal financial system (Mahadeva, 2008). While asking Uniq Identification Authority of India, Direct Benefit Transfer, PMJDY
the question who are excluded from the formal financial system?, one and Mudra banks have been introduced in India for the promotion of
obvious answer comes that the underprivileged and marginalized peo- financial inclusion in India.
ples (such as farmers, unorganized workers, women, artisan, self‐ Apart from these major schemes, the central bank of India has also
employed, and pensioners) are excluded from banking system (Dev, introduced several financial products and services for promoting
2006). financial inclusion in India. Some of the financial services has
Based on this above arguments, this paper analyzes the undergone extremely benefited to the unbanked people in India. For example,
progress and future path of financial inclusion in India. This paper is through the use of Kisan Credit Card, the bank is providing small
organized as follows. Section 2 of the paper discusses the recent ini- credits or loans to the poor farmers to cover their cost of cultivation,
tiatives and status of financial inclusion in India. The subsections of harvest and farm maintenance. Similarly, the introduction of BCs has
Section 2 discuss the recent development of digital finance and finan- helped the banks to provide the basic banking services to the poor
cial inclusion between different groups of people in India. Section 3 of people at a low and an affordable cost (Figure 1).
this paper discusses the future path of financial inclusion in India. As a consequence of these initiatives, India has seen massive boost
Lastly, Section 4 of this paper provides concluding remarks. of financial inclusion in recent times. It can be recalled that the com-
mercial banks started to implement financial inclusion as a part of their
business policy after they were instructed to adopt a 3‐years Financial
2 | RECENT INITIATIVES AND STATUS OF Inclusion Policy approved by the board in 2010. Furthermore, financial
FINANCIAL INCLUSION inclusion received a boost through the implementation of PMJDY in
2014. PMJDY added 336.6 million new bank accounts expanding
In the recent years, GOI and RBI have undertaken several initiatives to the base of such accounts to 536 million by the end of March 2018.
expand the financial outreach to the unbanked people of India. Both The opening of new bank accounts has increased the deposit rate,
the institutions have endeavored to introduce so many schemes to which is a good indicator for economic growth and poverty reduction.
meet the goal of universal financial inclusion. For example, RBI intro- Given the praiseworthy penetration of banking services and the
duced no‐frill account in the year of 2005 for providing basic banking sustained financial inclusion policies, it is observed that 80% of adults
services to the unbanked people and to increase financial inclusion in have bank accounts in their name. These bank accounts will help the

FIGURE 1 Recent development in financial inclusion (FI) Sources: Author's PreparationNote: KYC_ Know Your Customer, EBT_ Electronic
Benefit Transfer, UIDAI_ Uniq Identification Authority of India, DBT_ Direct Benefit Transfer, PMJDY_ Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana, ATM_
Automated Teller Machine, USSD_ Unstructured Supplementary Service Data, UPI_ Unified Payments Interface, AEPS_ Aadhaar Enabled Payment
System
BARIK AND SHARMA 3 of 6

unbanked poor people to save money in their accounts, access micro beneficiary's bank account without any official linkages, which ulti-
credits and to obtain government subsidies through Direct Benefit mately brings good governance in the country.
Transfer scheme (Figure 2). Additionally, most of the banks in India have opened their own
mobile apps to provide banking services to their customer. On the
other hand, banks are trying to build up their customer's confidence
2.1 | Banking through digital technologies that e‐banking is as convenient and reliable as banking in person. Sim-
ilarly, academic research has shown that mobile banking and internet
Since last 10 years, India has witnessed massive progress in digital banking increase the banking habits of the people, speed up financial
banking. The inventions of new innovative technologies have drasti- transaction and provide better financial services with a greater accu-
cally changed the traditional banking systems in India. The traditional racy, reliability and security (see Alam, Patwary, & Rahim, 2013; Liao
cash‐driven Indian economy has been changed to cashless economy & Cheung, 2002). Therefore, the use of mobile banking and internet
through the rapid adoption of e‐banking and e‐commerce. The high banking is gaining much popularity among the Indian masses in general
penetration of mobile phone and internet has helped to expand the and young people in particular. Despite the huge usage of
banking outreach and serve to the unbanked people in India. The mobile/internet banking, there are some other technological innova-
frequent use of mobile/internet banking has enabled to provide the tions (such as installment of micro ATM, use of debit/credit card, e‐
banking services without the presence of physical bank branches. This wallet, etc.) that have helped to boost digital finance in India
branchless banking service has allowed people to obtain banking ser- (Figure 3).
vices anywhere and anytime in an easy and affordable cost. Further- Moreover, the post‐demonetization period has witnessed a sharp
more, this e‐banking system has benefited a lot to the disadvantaged rise in digital transactions. When the governments of India withdraw
section of people in India. Through the Jan‐Aadhra‐Mobile (JAM) ini- currency notes of ₹ 1000 and ₹ 500 in November 8, 2016, suddenly,
tiative, people are allowed to link their Jan dhan bank account with cash crunch happened in India and people started adopting various
their mobile number and Aadhar card, so that they can directly receive noncash channels for their transaction. In this regard, fintech services
government subsidies in their bank account. This JAM programs have played a major role to provide various technical support for
mainly benefit in two ways. First, it reduces corruption by avoiding financial transaction to happen. Now, various noncash channels like
ghost beneficiaries and second, it transfers money directly to the Paytm, debit/credit card and PhonePe are available even if in the

FIGURE 2 Trend of bank branches,


outstanding deposit/credit in India
Sources: Sources: Financial Access Survey,
IMF, 2017

FIGURE 3 Development of digital


technologies in India
Sources: Sources: Financial Access Survey,
IMF, 2017
4 of 6 BARIK AND SHARMA

small Indian cities. Today, there are several digital channels exist in banking structure (see Table 1 below). Population group‐wise analysis
India, which help the consumers to make digital payment just at the of financial inclusion depicts that among every population group, own-
click of the button. It is true that the dream of digital India has to go ership of bank account has speedily increased from previous time
a long way because still cash transaction has occupied large number periods. Though there are financial inclusion gaps existing among the
of financial transaction in Indian market. But there is no doubt that different population groups, there is no doubt that a significant
the volume of digital transaction has increased over times and will amount of progress has been undertaken than the earlier period. The
increase more in near future. According to the NASSCOM and KPMG recent government scheme like PMJDY has facilitated the poor and
joint report (2016), the transaction value for the Indian fintech indus- marginalized people to open a bank account with zero or minimum
try is expected to touch USD 73 billion by 2020 from its present balance. As a consequence of this, enormous progress has happened
investment USD 33 billion (Figure 4). in India. This progress has assisted to fill‐up the financial inclusion gaps
between the different populations groups (i.e., between male and
female, poor and rich and young and adult).
2.2 | Financial inclusions between different groups Though much progress has happened in financial inclusion in India,
of people the worrying factor is that more than half of the accounts are rarely
used by the bank customers. The mere opening of bank account is
It is argued that most of the underprivileged and marginalized peoples not the only aim of financial inclusion rather the utilization of these
are excluded from banking system. Basically, financially excluded accounts through saving and accessing credit is also essential for ful-
groups are farmers, unorganized workers, women, artisan, self‐ filling the true essence of financial inclusion. While observing the
employed and pensioners (Dev, 2006). Looking from this perspective, saving and credit accounts from the Global Findex dataset, it can be
the active participation of marginalized people in the financial inclu- understood that only 20% of Indian adults are able to have saving
sion drive is necessary for their empowerment because it provides a account in their names. Furthermore, this number declines further in
kind social protection to them. Connecting all the weaker sections of case of poor individuals, female population, rural people, young adults
people with the formal financial system has many positive outcomes and primary or less studied population groups (see Table 1). Similarly,
for their life. Provision of microcredit through the formal financial with regard to the access of credit from the formal financial institu-
institutions will help the poor to increase their banking habits, tions, the situation is worse. Only 7% of Indian adults are able to
augment saving, smoot consumption and enhance their capability by access credit from the formal financial system. While considering poor
investing on their non‐income generating activities such as health, people, women, young adults and primary or less educated population,
education, sanitation and other basic entitlements. Research finding the number further decreases to 6%, 5%, 5% and 6%, respectively (see
describes that the expansion of financial inclusion can raise the finan- Table 1).
cial condition and can improve the standard of living of the poor and
disadvantaged groups of people (Srijanani, 2012). Similarly, Sen
(2001) argues that the availability and easy access to finance have very 3 | FUTURE PATH OF FINANCIAL
significant effect on other economic entitlement. INCLUSION
Hence, analysis of the availability and usability of financial services
among the different groups of people is necessary to measure the Analysis of various dataset depicts that much progress has been
degree of financial inclusion in India. While looking the current dataset occurred with regard to financial inclusion in India. But there is long
from Global Findex, it is clear that the basic requirement of financial way to go to achieve the goal of universal financial inclusion. While
inclusion (i.e., owning a bank account) has been fulfilled in a greater India has made significant growth in accelerating financial inclusion,
extent. Ownership of bank account among the adults has increased challenges continue to remain on both the access and usage fronts.
over time and has brought 80% of Indian adults under the formal Fulfilling the true essence of financial inclusion requires regular use

FIGURE 4 Volume of electronic payment in


the post‐demonetization period
Sources: RBI Monthly BulletinNote: Volume in
million; NEFT, national electronic funds
transfer; IMPS, immediate payment service;
UPI, unified payments interface; POS, point of
sale
BARIK AND SHARMA 5 of 6

TABLE 1 Financial inclusions between different groups of people

Deposit account Saving account Credit account

Variable name 2011 2014 2017 2011 2014 2017 2011 2014 2017

Adult (% age 15+) 35 53 80 12 14 20 8 6 7


Income, poorest 40% (% ages 15+) 27 44 77 10 7 12 7 5 6
Income, richest 60% (% ages 15+) 41 59 82 12 19 25 8 7 7
Female (% age 15+) 26 43 77 7 10 17 7 5 5
Male (% age 15+) 44 63 83 16 18 22 9 8 8
Rural (% age 15+) 33 52 79 11 13 18 8 7 7
Young adults (% ages 15–24) 27 43 71 8 10 13 4 4 5
Older adults (% ages 25+) 38 57 83 13 16 22 9 7 7
Labor force (% age 15+) 44 64 84 16 19 23 9 8 7
Primary education or less (% ages 15+) 31 43 75 10 11 15 8 6 6
Secondary education or more (% ages 15+) 59 64 85 21 19 25 7 7 7

Sources: The Global Findex Database, 2017.

of one's bank account. Statistical data show that large number of bank electronic and print media and also giving instruction how to use these
accounts opened through PMJDY remains inactive or have non‐active technologies for your financial transactions can also be one possible
users. There are much gaps exist between the deposit accounts, saving way to promote financial inclusion in India. Second, regular provision
accounts and credit accounts. Though much progress has occurred in of electricity and internet facility to the remote areas can help the
account opening, but with regard to usage of such accounts, insignifi- people to make their financial transaction through digital technology.
cant improvement has undertaken. There are few possible demand Third, reducing the minimum saving criteria, annual charges of
side and supply side factors are responsible for this inactiveness of debit/credit card and documentation criteria by different banks can
bank accounts. The possible reasons are lack of financial literacy, low promote saving accounts and digital payment. Fourth, extension of
income, high‐transaction cost, unavailability of bank branches, lack of formal credit to the poor and marginalized people at an easy and
identity prof, or documentation problem and so forth. However, some affordable cost can fulfill the true essence of financial inclusion in
of basic problems (such as high transaction cost and unavailability of India. Fifth, providing formal employment can help to usage of bank
bank branches) can be eliminated through the use of digital banking. account more frequently, because the employees receive their salary
But the use of digital banking has confronted numerous constraints via their bank accounts.
among the different population groups. The usage of digital transac-
tion among poorest 40%, rural people, female individuals, less edu-
cated peoples and older people are much less than other population 4 | C O NC L U D I N G R E M A RK S
groups. Though the accessibility of mobile/internet banking has
increased in India, women more than 45‐years age groups, the elderly Previous literature demonstrations, the beginning of 21st century has
people, people living in remote villages and primary or less educated witnessed a rapid growth in acceleration of financial inclusion in India.
people are still less likely to use a smartphone. Furthermore, Moreover, with the passage of time, the definition of financial inclu-
consumers from remote villages also face infrastructural barriers like sion has been changed. Financial inclusion is no more about opening
irregularities in electricity supply and poor internet connectivity. of a bank account rather utilizing these accounts for saving and credit
Sometimes the consumer's incapability to use digital technology also purpose has become the main goal of financial inclusion. Analyzing
stands as a barrier in the usage of digital banking. Even if one con- various national and international dataset on the accessibility and
sumer own smartphone with internet connectivity, lack of knowledge usability of financial services depicts that India has progressed a lot
to use it, difficulty in downloading apps, lack of understanding the in case of opening bank account than its previous time period. The
instructions, fear of insecurity and less reliability on technology also recent introduction of PMJDY has facilitated the poor and marginal-
cause for lesser use of digital technology in financial transaction. ized people to open a bank account with zero or minimum balance.
Hence, as a remedy of these hurdles, some necessary steps should As a consequence of this, 80% of Indian adults have owned bank
be taken to mitigate all these problems and to fulfill the goal of univer- account in their names. Though there is much variances of financial
sal financial inclusion. The first remedy can be the extension of finan- inclusion between different papulation groups, there is no doubt that
cial literacy program to each and every part of the country. The best PMJDY has enabled to fill‐up the financial inclusion gaps between
possible way to do is by opening more financial literacy centers and different groups in a large extent.
also by introducing financial literacy in the school and college text With context to the utilization of digital payment, India has imple-
books. Advertising different financial products and services through mented several new technologies for the easy and comfortable
6 of 6 BARIK AND SHARMA

transaction of customers. However, the post‐demonetization period NASSCOM & KPMG (2016). Fintech in India—A global growth story. Joint
has seen rapid growth of the use of digital payment in India. Despite publication by KPMG in India and NASSCOM 10,000 startups,1–59.

of this high growth in digital transaction, challenges and hurdles con- Park, C.‐Y., & Mercado, R. (2017). Financial inclusion, poverty, and income
inequality. The Singapore Economic Review, 63(01), 185–206.
tinue to remain in both accessibility and usability fronts. Though the
Poonam, & Chaudhry, A. (2016). Financial inclusion in India: A state level
overall accessibility and usability of digital payment has increased in
study. SSRG International Journal of Economics and Management Studies,
India, digital payment among the women, rural people, elderly people 3(3), 01–04.
and less educated peoples is much less than other groups of people.
Sen, A. (2001). Development as freedom. Oxford: OUP Oxford.
Lack of digital infrastructure facility, less financial literacy, low income
Srijanani, D. (2012). Financial inclusion: Taking banking services to the
and absence of formal employment opportunities are some of the common man. International Journal of Management & Business Studies,
major factors that restrict the rural consumers to use digital technol- 2(3), 54–58.
ogy for their financial transactions. Zhang, Q., & Posso, A. (2017). Thinking inside the box: A closer look
at financial inclusion and household income. The Journal of Develop-
ment Studies, 0(0), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220388.2017.
ORCID 1380798

Rajesh Barik https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8658-0207


AUTHOR BIOGRAPHIES
RE FE R ENC E S Rajesh Barik currently doing PhD at the discipline of Economics,

Alam, M. Z., Patwary, M. M., & Rahim, M. A. (2013). Mobile money system:
Indian Institute of Technology Indore. His area of interest in
The Bangladesh experience. International Journal of Scientific and research is financial inclusion, financial literacy, digital finance,
Research Publications, 3(10), 1–5. financial regulation, Poverty reduction, human development, gen-
Dev, S. M. (2006). Financial inclusion: Issues and challenges. Economic and der development, gender discrimination, social exclusion, Social
Political Weekly, 41(41), 4310–4313. Policy etc.
Gwalani, H., & Parkhi, S. (2014). Financial inclusion—Building a success
model in the Indian context. Procedia ‐ Social and Behavioral Sciences,
Dr. Pritee Sharma is an Associate Professor at the discipline of
133, 372–378. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.04.203
Economics, Indian Institute of Technology Indore. She has
Laha, A. (2015). Association between financial inclusion and human
obtained her PhD degree from Indian Institute of Technology
development in South Asia: A cross‐country analysis with special
reference to India. Journal of Economic Policy and Research, 10(2), Bombay. Her research experience is largely related to the analyti-
69–91. cal problem of allocation and access of natural resources particu-
Lenka, S. K., & Sharma, R. (2017). Does financial inclusion spur economic larly land and water. She also works in the area of financial
growth in India? The Journal of Developing Areas, 51(3), 215–228. inclusion and rural poverty in India.
https://doi.org/10.1353/jda.2017.0069
Liao, Z., & Cheung, M. T. (2002). Internet‐based e‐banking and consumer
attitudes: An empirical study. Information & Management, 39(4),
283–295. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378‐7206(01)00097‐0
How to cite this article: Barik R, Sharma P. Analyzing the
progress and prospects of financial inclusion in India. J Public
Mahadeva, M. (2008). Financial growth in India: Whither financial inclu-
sion? Margin: The Journal of Applied Economic Research, 2(2), Affairs. 2019;e1948. https://doi.org/10.1002/pa.1948
177–197. https://doi.org/10.1177/097380100800200202

You might also like