Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
S C I E N C E @DIRECT"
Article
Abstract: The direct conversion of methane using a dielectric barrier discharge has been experimentally
studied. Experiments with different values of flow rates and discharge voltages have been performed
to investigate the effects on the conversion and reaction products both qualitatively and quantitatively.
Experimental results indicate that the maximum conversion of methane has been 80% at an input flow rate
of 5 ml/min and a discharge voltage of 4 kV. Experimental results also show that the optimum condition has
occurred at a high discharge voltage and higher input flow rate. In terms of product distribution, a higher
flow rate or shorter residence time can increase the selectivity for higher hydrocarbons. No hydrocarbon
product was detected using the thermal method, except hydrogen and carbon. Increasing selectivity for
ethane was found when Pt and Ru catalysts presented in the plasma reaction. Hydrogenation of acetylene
in the catalyst surface could have been the reason for this phenomenon as the selectivity for acetylene in
the products was decreasing.
Key words: plasma; dielectric barrier discharge; thermal process; methane conversion; catalyst
charges, gliding arc or dielectric barrier discharges was used in this experiment. In order to maintain
(DBD) at atmospheric pressure and ambient temper- a similar configuration for every experiment, for ex-
ature. Some researchers have tried to add auxiliary ample. the gap distance, the reactor capacitance was
gases in the process, such as hydrogen [3]. air [3-51. checked and measured before the experiments. The
oxygen [4-71 and noble gas j5.81. Among them. niix- reactor capacitance was in the range of 8.2-8.8 p F in
ing gas between methane and C 0 2 was found to be air-filled gap conditions. The same reactor size and
the most promising technique to produce more valu- configuration were used for the thermal (non-plasma)
able products, such as synthesis gas [9.10]. Some process.
others used different types of plasma discharges that
could possibly produce different product distribution 2.2. Power supply and heater
[lO,ll].
The maximum voltage and frequency of the AC
In the present research, a comprehensive study
power supply (Auto electric, model A1831) were
on the performance of plasma and thermal treatment
10 kV and 20 kHz. To measure voltage and
for methane conversion has been undertaken. Plasma
current waveforms, a digital oscilloscope (Agilent,
process was done on a dielectric barrier discharge
model 54641A), a voltage divider (Tektronix, model
(DBD). A series of metal catalysts (Ni. Ru. Pt). sup-
P6015A), and a current probe (Fluke, model i400 s)
ported by Al203. had been prepared to investigate
were used. The external input power was measured
the effect of the products distributions.
by a digital power meter (Metex, model M-3860 M)
inserted at the AC power input line. The amount
2. Experimental setup of actual power supplied were calculated by following
equation:
Figure 1 shows a schematic diagram of the exper-
imental setup. Methane, as the source gas. was in-
Actual power = / ( V ( t ) x I ( t ) ) d t x frequency
troduced into a cylindrical reactor under atmospheric
pressure. Gases were analyzed by gas chromatogra-
The typical waveform of voltage and current, used
phy. Details of each part of the system have been in this experiment, is shown in Figure 2. For the ther-
described in the next sections.
mal process, a tubular furnace equipped with a tem-
perature controller (Daepoong Industry, Korea) was
Plasma reactor used.
6000 , 200
4000
mad[ MFC
-
100
s,
-
2
2000
0 O
z
E
Heater
u
>
3 E
0
-2000
Thermal process -100
-4000
The reactor was a cylindrical pyrex tube (ID of 7.5 2.3. Materials preparation
mm) with two parallel-straight wires (0.2 mm diame-
ter, stainless steel) as an inner metal electrode and an All experiments were carried out using pure
outer electrode of silver film coated around t,he tube. methane (CH4) with purity higher than 99.99%. Flow
The effective gas volume and length of the reactor rate of the source gas was controlled by a cali-
were 8.8 ml and 200 mm, respectively. A high voltage brated mass flow controller (Milipore, model FC-
and frequency alternating current (AC) power supply 28OSAV). Analysis of the gas sample was carried out
Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry Vol. 15 No. 2 2006 89
c
from 5 ml/min to 40 ml/min and the voltage was set ;. 0.08 1
at 3, 3.2, and 4 kV. Figure 3 shows the effects of input E
methane flow rate and voltage on the plasma process. @ 0.06 -
0
- 40
5
experimentally done by Le et al. [15] and numeri-
cally simulated by Rhallabi and Chaterine [16]. Coke
.-
0
will be formed a t the plasma regions where the tem-
.?
c 30
-0
W
perature is relatively high, for example, at the sur-
v, 20 face of the electrode. At the surface of the electrode,
methane will be converted into C and 4 H or H2.
10
Table 1. Methane conversion and product distribution comparison between plasma and thermal processes
shows the products comparison between plasma and the most driving factor in dissociating methane mole-
thermal process. Most of products of thermal process cules into H2 and C.
were dominated by H2 and C. Solid carbon was not
measured, but much of it was found in the output CH4 f C+2H2 (13)
line of the reactor. At a flow rate of 20 ml/min, the The production of higher hydrocarbon was rela-
conversion of methane was begun at temperature of tively small and difficult t o detect on using our analy-
700 "C. To achieve similar conversion as in the plasma sis instrument. Methane can be converted directly
experiment, it required the temperature to be more into higher hydrocarbons, such as C2 hydrocarbons,
than 900 "C. In the thermal process, supplied heat is and hydrogen via thermal coupling reactions:
All these reactions are highly endothermic, and 3.2. Catalyst effect
high temperature operation is required to obtain fa-
vorable thermodynamics. In order to avoid the de- In order to improve the selectivity of products,
composition of products, very short time reaction, 0.5 grams of three different catalysts have been put
should be performed [lS] and consequently, this makes a t the end of plasma zone of the reactor. The pur-
a difficulty to achieve high conversion of methane. pose of this is t o prevent the production of higher
By comparing the experiment results, it can hydrocarbons from decomposition reactions. Table 2
be seen that the plasma process has an advantage shows the CH4 conversion and product distribution
on higher hydrocarbons production. The existence with different material packs. The experiment was
of electrons and methyl radicals, produced during conducted at a methane flow rate of 20 ml/min. It
plasma process, could be the primary role in initiat- shows that the conversion of CH4 to other hydrocar-
ing the decomposition of methane and recombination bons was enhanced with the use of catalyst. Although
reactions of higher hydrocarbons. the difference was relatively small, the existence of
Table 2. Effects of different material packs loading on methane conversion and products distribution
~~
ethane (C2H6) over Ptly-Al203 catalyst was 1.35 on the surface of catalyst, can initiate the series of hy-
times as high as that over non-catalyst treatment. On drogenation reactions:
the other hand, no acetylene (C2H2) was detected by C2H2(surf) + H(su,f) C2H3(surf) (18)
our analysis instrument. According to this result, the GH~(surf)+ H(surf) CaHli(surf) (19)
existence of Pt catalyst in the plasma reaction would
convert the produced acetylene into ethane by the hy-
Ca&(surf) + H(surf) + C2H5(surf) (20)
drogenation reaction on the surface of catalyst. C2HB(surf) + H(surf) ----f CZHG(surf) (21)
Low activation energy (-0 kJ/mol) of acetylene In our previous experiment, under the non-
adsorption on Pt will make acetylene attach easily to catalytic reaction, the above reactions rarely oc-
the surface of the catalyst 1191. curred. This was shown by small yields of C2H4 and
92 Antonius Indarto et al./ Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry Vol. 15 No. 2 2006