Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1–8
a
Health and Safety DiÕision, SHINE Group, Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam 603 102 (TN), India
b
Tamilnad Hospitals, Cheran Nagar, Perumbakkam, Chennai 603 102 (TN), India
Received 26 August 1998; revised 27 October 1998; accepted 11 November 1998
Abstract
The presence of dicentric chromosome ŽDC. and micronuclei ŽMN. frequency in the peripheral blood lymphocytes of 25
cancer patients prior to chemo and radiotherapy and 21 healthy volunteers were studied. The overall DC and MN showed
significantly higher frequency compared to those obtained in normal healthy volunteers Ž p - 0.0001.. However, among 25
patients only 15 showed a higher frequency of DC aberration, nine patients showed the presence of minutes ŽM. and seven
patients showed chromatid breaks ŽChB.. The reasons for the higher frequency of aberration observed in these cancer
patients are discussed in this paper. q 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
0027-5107r99r$ - see front matter q 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 2 7 - 5 1 0 7 Ž 9 8 . 0 0 2 3 8 - 3
2 P. Venkatachalam et al.r Mutation Research 425 (1999) 1–8
eral blood lymphocytes of cancer patients prompted average of 51.36 years. In this study among seven
us to carry out a systematic study to measure the male patients two were smokers and among 18 fe-
frequency of chromosomal aberrations such as DC male patients one had the habit of chewing tobacco.
and micronuclei ŽMN. in peripheral blood of cancer With respect to the nature of cancer, 48% had cancer
patients prior to the initiation of chemo or radiother- of cervix, 8% had cancer of breast and oesophagus
apy. and the remaining 34% had cancer of thyroid, rec-
tum, bladder. All the 21 of normal healthy volunteers
were males and non-smokers. Their ages are given in
2. Materials and methods Table 3.
The blood samples were obtained from a total Blood samples of cancer patients were collected
number of 46 persons. Among these, 25 were cancer from Tamilnad Hospitals, Chennai, Tamilnadu, India
patients unexposed to any chemo or radiotherapy and and Government Arignar Anna Cancer Hospital,
the remaining 21 were from normal healthy volun- Kancheepuram, Tamilnadu, India. About 3 ml blood
teers. Details such as age, gender and type of the from each patient was collected in a sterile hep-
cancer of the 25 patients are given in Table 1. Age of arinised vial. The blood samples were then trans-
the cancer patients varied between 22 and 75 with an ported to the laboratory in an ice bath. These sam-
ples were brought back to room temperature prior to
setting up of the culture.
Table 1
Type of cancer, age and gender of patients
2.3. Culture for DC chromosome aberration
S. no. Code. Age Smokerr Gender Type of
no. Žyears. non-smoker cancer
The method for DC chromosome aberration assay
1 TNH-1 63 NS F Thyroid
is described elsewhere w9x. Briefly, the method is
2 TNH-2 46 NS F Breast
3 TNH-4 52 NS F Neck given below. To 0.5 ml of the blood sample, 5 ml
4 TNH-5 52 NS M Pyriformfossa RPMI-1640 ŽSigma. culture medium supplemented
5 TNH-6 68 NS M Lung with 7.5% NaHCO 3 , 20% fetal calf serum, 200 mM
6 TNH-7 22 NS M NHL L-glutamine, penicillin 100 unitsrml and strepto-
7 TNH-9 55 NS F Breast
mycin 100 mgrml, was added. A total of 200 ml of
8 TNH-10 55 NS F Cervix
9 TNH-13 47 NS F Cervix phytohaemagglutinin-M ŽPHA-M, Gibco, BRL. was
10 TNH-15 49 S M Oesophagus added to the culture to initiate cell division. At 46 h,
11 TNH-16 55 NS F Oesophagus the cells were blocked at metaphase by adding col-
12 TNH-17 57 NS M Rectum cemid to a final concentration 0.1 mgrml. The cul-
13 TNH-18 56 NS F Endometrium
ture was incubated for another 2 h. The cells were
14 TNH-19 35 NS F Cervix
15 TNH-20 45 NS F Cervix harvested by centrifuging the sample at 400 = g and
16 TNH-21 50 NS F Cervix the cell pellet obtained was given hypotonic treat-
17 TNH-22 54 S M Bladder ment with 0.45% KCl for 20 min at 378C. The cells
18 KAN-1 52 NS F Cervix were washed with a mixture of methanol and acetic
19 KAN-2 41 NS F Cervix
acid Ž3:1, Carnoy’s fixative. for three times. After
20 KAN-3 55 NS F Cervix
21 KAN-5 50 NS F Cervix the first wash, the cells were suspended in a mixture
22 KAN-6 50 NS F Cervix of methanol and acetic acid Ž1:1. for 10 min and
23 KAN-7 50 NS F Cervix centrifuged. After a final wash with Carnoy’s fixa-
24 KAN-8 75 T F Check tive, cell pellet was suspended in a known volume of
25 KAN-9 50 NS F Cervix
fixative Ž0.5 ml.. The cells were then cast by allow-
TNH, Tamilnad Hospital; KAN, Kancheepuram; F, female; M, ing three drops of the cell suspension to fall on a
male; S, smoker; NS, non-smoker; T, tobacco chewing. pre-cooled slide from a height of 10 cm. The slide
P. Venkatachalam et al.r Mutation Research 425 (1999) 1–8 3
was air dried and stained with 10% Giemsa solution from a height of 1 cm, air dried and stained with
ŽpH 6.8., mounted with DPX and scored for DC Giemsa. Cells with two daughter nuclei, surrounded
using light microscope ŽNikon Optiphot-2, Japan. by cytoplasm were scored for the presence of MN
under 10 = 100x oil immersion. according to the modified criteria of Countryman
and Heddle w11x.
2.4. Culture for MN
2.5. Statistical analysis
The method for cytokinesis-blocked MN assay The DC, excess acentrics ŽAC., ChB, minutes
has been described by Fenech and Morely w10x. The ŽM. and MN frequency obtained in cancer patients
procedure is given briefly below. The culture was set were compared with those obtained from normal
up the same way mentioned for DC aberration till healthy volunteers using Welch approximation un-
the addition of PHA-M. Cytochalasin-B ŽSigma. at a paired ‘t’-test.
final concentration of 3 mgr5 ml culture was added
at 44 h. The cells were incubated for another 28 h at
3. Results
378C. The cells were then harvested, given hypotonic
treatment and washed with Carnoy’s fixative as men- The aberrations such as DC, AC, ChB, M and
tioned for DC aberration. Three drops of cell suspen- MN scored in cancer patients and healthy volunteers
sion were allowed to fall on to a clear cooled slide are given in Tables 2 and 3, respectively. Table 4
Table 2
Frequency of various chromosomal aberration and MN observed in peripheral blood of cancer patients
Code CS DC AC M ChB DCr CB MN MNr
no. cell cells cell
TNH-1 136 1 1 1 – 0.0074 1000 39 0.039
TNH-2 106 0 1 – 1 ND 1000 45 0.045
TNH-4 196 0 2 1 – ND 1000 33 0.033
TNH-5 141 3 4 – 3 0.0213 1000 19 0.019
TNH-6 161 0 3 – 2 ND 1000 15 0.015
TNH-7 190 17 16 3 3 0.0895 1000 20 0.020
TNH-9 250 3 2 – 3 0.0120 1000 36 0.036
TNH-10 125 0 – 2 – ND 1000 28 0.028
TNH-13 100 0 – 2 4 ND 500 17 0.034
TNH-15 200 1 2 1 2 0.0050 1000 29 0.029
TNH-16 100 3 2 – 1 0.0300 1000 26 0.026
TNH-17 100 0 – – 2 ND 1000 18 0.018
TNH-18 100 1 1 – 1 0.0100 1000 10 0.010
TNH-19 126 0 – 2 2 ND CF – –
TNH-20 106 0 – – 2 ND 1000 15 0.015
TNH-21 150 1 – 1 1 0.0067 CF – –
TNH-22 100 2 – – – 0.0200 200 16 0.080
KAN-1 200 0 – 1 2 ND 1000 17 0.017
KAN-2 125 2 2 – – 0.0160 1000 18 0.018
KAN-3 150 4 – 2 3 0.0267 1000 21 0.021
KAN-5 150 5 2 – – 0.0333 1000 15 0.015
KAN-6 150 0 1 1 2 ND 1000 9 0.009
KAN-7 100 1 – – 1 0.0100 1000 39 0.039
KAN-8 100 5 2 – 5 0.0500 1000 123 0.123
KAN-9 100 1 3 – 2 0.0100 1000 12 0.012
Total 3462 50 44 17 42 21,700 620
CS, Metaphase cells scored; DC, dicentric chromosome; AC, excess acentrics; M, minutes; ChB, chromatid breaks; MN, micronuclei; ND,
not detected; CF, culture failed; CB cells, cytokinesis blocked binucleated cells.
4 P. Venkatachalam et al.r Mutation Research 425 (1999) 1–8
Table 3
Frequency of various chromosomal aberration and MN observed in peripheral blood of male healthy volunteers
S. Age CS DC AC M ChB DCr CB MN MNr
no. cell cells cell
1 46 239 – 1 – – ND 1000 11 0.011
2 28 727 1 – 2 – 0.0014 1000 13 0.013
3 38 200 1 – 1 – 0.005 1000 3 0.003
4 45 372 1 3 – – 0.0027 1000 21 0.021
5 35 171 – 1 – – ND 1000 15 0.015
6 43 295 1 1 1 – 0.0034 1000 10 0.010
7 32 203 1 – – – 0.0049 1000 20 0.020
8 39 239 – 5 – 4 ND 1000 19 0.019
9 37 200 – – – – ND 1000 8 0.008
10 29 192 – 1 1 – ND 1000 10 0.010
11 34 101 – 1 – 1 ND 1000 5 0.005
12 31 628 1 – 1 – 0.0016 1000 3 0.003
13 30 406 – 2 – – ND 1000 9 0.009
14 29 250 – 1 1 1 ND 1000 9 0.009
15 28 250 – – 1 – ND 1000 17 0.017
16 29 250 – – 1 1 ND 1000 14 0.014
17 33 250 – 2 – 2 ND 1000 22 0.022
18 35 250 1 1 – – 0.004 1000 14 0.014
19 37 250 – – 1 – ND 1000 7 0.007
20 29 250 – – – 1 ND 1000 12 0.012
21 28 400 – 1 – 3 ND 1000 13 0.013
Total 6123 7 20 10 13 21,000 255
CS, Metaphase cells scored; DC, dicentric chromosome; AC, excess acentrics; M, minutes; ChB, chromatid breaks; MN, micronuclei; ND,
not detected; CB cells, cytokinesis blocked binucleated cells.
compares the average frequencies of these aberra- cer Ž0.0113 " 0.0026. alone showed a significant
tions observed in cancer patients to those obtained in increase compared to that of healthy volunteers Ž p -
healthy volunteers. The increase in the aberration 0.005, Table 5.. The DC frequency Ž0.0174 "
frequencies in cancer patients compared to healthy 0.0031. observed in patients with cancer other than
volunteers were highly significant except for M, the cervix, also showed a significant increase com-
where it was only significantly higher. Among these pared to that of healthy volunteers Ž p - 0.0001.. In
aberrations DC frequency was nearly 13 times higher one patient ŽTNH-7. remarkably high DC frequency
compared to healthy volunteers as other aberrations was observed Ž0.089rcell.. In this patient among 17
were only 2 to 5 times higher in cancer patients. The DC, a single cell alone had 10 DC Žone pentacentric,
average DC frequency in patients with cervical can- one tricentric, four DC, Fig. 1.. The average DC
frequency Ž0.0101 " 0.0017. after excluding the re-
sult obtained from this sample, was significantly
Table 4
Comparison of various chromosomal aberrations and MN ob-
served between healthy individuals and cancer patients Table 5
Type of Healthy Cancer p-value Frequency of DC in healthy individuals compared to that of
aberration individuals patients cervical cancer and patients other than cervical cancer
Fig. 1. Multiple chromosome aberration observed in a lymphocyte of a non-hodgkins lymphoma patient prior to therapy.
higher compared to that of healthy volunteers Ž p - frequency of MN in cancer patients was significantly
0.0001.. higher than that of age-matched controls Ž p -
The MN frequency observed in cancer patients 0.0001..
was also compared to that of age-matched healthy
individuals. The MN frequency in age-matched con-
4. Discussion
trol was obtained using the equation Y s 0.00029 X
q 0.00171, where Y is the frequency of MN and X Cytogenetic methods have been used extensively
is the age of the donor. This equation was generated for monitoring base-line chromosome aberration fre-
from the results obtained in this laboratory w12x. The quency in population unexposed w13,14x, and ex-
6 P. Venkatachalam et al.r Mutation Research 425 (1999) 1–8
posed to low level radiation w15,16x. This technique not due to the uniform increase in aberration fre-
has also been used to monitor population exposed to quency among metaphase cells scored. Since the
industrial chemicals w17,18x and chemotherapeutic increase in DC was due to the presence of single
agents w5,19,20x. rogue cell, it was not included in the study as it was
With respect to the increase in DC, MN and felt that this may not result in corresponding increase
translocation frequency in the peripheral blood lym- in MN. TNH-21 was not included as the culture for
phocytes of cancer patients compared to those of MN had failed. The correlation study carried out in
healthy volunteers, it was suspected that these pa- the remaining 13 patients showed a ‘r ’ value of 0.55
tients had undergone radiotherapy or chemotherapy ŽFig. 2.. It is not known whether a better correlation
in the past. The medical records of these patients, would have be seen if the number of metaphases and
however, had indicated that they were not given any binucleated cells scored were large as the total num-
of these treatments prior to the collection of blood ber of DC observed in cancer patients was nearly 12
samples. If the patients had undergone radiotherapy, times higher than that of observed in normal sub-
the frequency of DC would have been much higher jects, whereas in the case of MN it was only 2.5
than that observed in the present study. It has been times higher in cancer patients compared to that of
reported that chemotherapeutic agents like bleomycin observed in normal subjects. With respect to MN
w19x, cyclophosphamide w17x and chemicals like ethy- frequency in cancer patients the comparison was
lene oxide w21x induce chromosome aberrations. made to that obtained in age matched healthy indi-
However, these patients were not treated any of these viduals as it is known that MN frequency increases
drugs, as evidenced from medical records. Perhaps with age. However, Fenech et al. w23x and Gatenberg
increase in chromosomal aberrations in blood lym-
phocytes of cancer patients could have been due to
the exposure of certain mutagenic agents capable of
inducing dicentric aberrations. Similar to our results,
Antoine et al. w6x have shown significantly higher
frequencies of DC in peripheral blood lymphocytes
of patients with cervical cancer. Honeycomb w5x has
shown AC and ChB in patients with CML. Aronson
et al. w4x also have observed AC and ChB in the
blood of children with leukaemia. At the same time
Diener et al. w7x, Kleinerman et al. w8x, and Catena et
al. w22x did not observe any increase in the frequency
of DC in blood lymphocytes of Morbus Hodgkin
lymphoma, cervical cancer and adenocarcinoma, re-
spectively.
In the present study, it has been observed that
even though the overall DC frequency observed in
cancer patients was higher compared to that of nor-
mal individuals, only 15 out of 25 cancer patients
had shown a higher frequency of DC. To confirm the
results further, the frequency of MN was measured.
A correlation between DC and MN was carried out
in patients who had detectable DC frequency. This
was studied only in 13 out of 15 patients who had
detectable DC frequency. The two patients who were
not included for the study were TNH-7 and TNH-21.
In the case of TNH-7 the number of DC was more Fig. 2. Correlation between DC and MN observed in cancer
because of the presence of single rogue cell and was patients Ž r s 0.55..
P. Venkatachalam et al.r Mutation Research 425 (1999) 1–8 7
w7x A. Diener, G. Stephen, Th. Vogl, J. Lissner, The induction of w18x G. De Jong, N.J. van Sittert, A.T. Natarajan, Cytogenetic
chromosome aberrations during the course of radiation ther- monitoring of industrial populations potentially exposed to
apy for Morbus hodgkin, Radiat. Res. 114 Ž1988. 528–536. genotoxic chemicals and of control populations, Mutat. Res.
w8x R.A. Kleinerman, L.G. Littelfield, R.E. Tarone, S.G. 204 Ž1988. 451–464.
Machado, M. Blettner, L.J. Peters, J.D. Boice, Chromosome w19x G. Obe, W. Matthiessen, D. Gobel, Chromosomal aberration
aberrations in peripheral lymphocytes and radiation dose to in the peripheral lymphocytes of cancer patients treated with
active bone marrow in patients treated for cancer of the high-energy electrons and bleomycin, Mutat. Res. 81 Ž1981.
cervix, Radiat. Res. 119 Ž1989. 176–190. 133–141.
w9x IAEA Report, Biological dosimetry, Chromosome aberration w20x F. Sarto, R. Tomanin, L. Giacomelli, A. Canova, F. Rai-
analysis for dose assessment, In: Technical Report Series No. mondi, C. Ghiotto, M.V. Fiorentino, Evaluation of chromo-
260, IAEA, Vienna, 1986, pp. 1–69. somal aberration in lymphocytes and micronuclei in lympho-
w10x M.A. Fenech, A.A. Morely, Measurement of micronuclei in cytes, oral mucosa and hair root cells of patients under
lymphocytes, Mutat. Res. 147 Ž1985. 29–36. antiblastic therapy, Mutat. Res. 228 Ž1990. 157–169.
w11x P.I. Countryman, J.A. Heddle, The production of MN from w21x S.M. Galloway, P.K. Berry, W.W. Nichols, S.R. Wolman,
chromosome aberrations in irradiated culture of human lym- K.A. Soper, P.D. Stolley, P. Archer, Chromosome aberra-
phocytes, Mutat. Res. 41 Ž1976. 321–332. tions in individuals occupationally exposed to ethylene oxide
w12x S.F.D. Paul, Comparison of dose–response curves obtained and in a large control population, Mutat. Res. 170 Ž1986.
for micronucleus and dicentric frequency in biological 55–74.
dosimetry, PhD thesis, Submitted to University of Madras, w22x C. Catena, D. Conti, P. Parasacchi, P. Marenco, B. Bortolato,
Chennai, 1996. M. Boutturi, M. Leoni, M. Portaluri, E. Righ, Micronuclei in
w13x M.A. Bender, A.A. Awa, A.L. Brooks, H.J. Evans, P.G. cytokinesis blocked lymphocytes may predict patient re-
Groer, L.G. Littlefield, C. Pereira, R.J. Preston, B.W. Wa- sponse to radiotherapy, Int. J. Radiat. Biol. 70 Ž1996. 301–
cholz, Current status of cytogenetic procedures to detect and 308.
quantify previous exposures to radiation, Mutat. Res. 196 w23x M. Fenech, J. Denham, W. Francis, A. Morely, Micronuclei
Ž1988. 103–159. in cytokinesis blocked lymphocytes of cancer patients fol-
w14x D. Anderson, P.C. Jenkinson, R.S. Dewdney, J. Francis, P. lowing fractionated partial-body radiotherapy, Int. J. Radiat.
Godbert, K.R. Butterworth, Chromosome aberrations, mito- Biol. 57 Ž1990. 373–383.
gen-induced blastogenesis and proliferative rate index in w24x H.W. Gantenberg, K. Wuttke, C. Streffer, W.U. Muller,
peripheral lymphocytes from 106 control individuals of the Micronuclei in human lymphocytes irradiated in vitro or in
UK population, Mutat. Res. 204 Ž1988. 407–420. vivo, Radiat. Res. 128 Ž1991. 276–281.
w15x D.C. Lloyd, R.J. Purrott, E.J. Reeder, The incidence of w25x M.R. Thompson, R. McInnes, H. Willard, Genetics in
unstable chromosome aberrations in peripheral blood lym- Medicine, N.B., Philadelphia, USA, 1991.
phocytes from unirradiated and occupationally exposed peo- w26x P. Venole, B. Tedeschi, D. Caporossi, B. Nicoletti, A study
ple, Mutat. Res. 72 Ž1980. 523–532. on lymphocytes of neuroblastoma patients, Cancer Genet.
w16x P. Bigatti, L. Lamberti, G. Ardito, F. Armellino, Cytogenetic Cytogenet. 36 Ž1988. 13–23.
monitoring of hospital workers exposed to low-level ionising w27x P. Venole, B. Tedeschi, B. Nicoletti, Fragile site induction by
radiation, Mutat. Res. 204 Ž1988. 343–347. aphidicolin may be increased neuroblastoma patients, Cancer
w17x M. Sorsa, L. Pyy, S. Salomaa, L. Nylund, J.W. Yager, Genet. Cytogenet. 36 Ž1988. 13–23.
Biological and environmental and occupational exposure to w28x V.J. Neel, A.A. Awa, The saga of Rogue lymphocytes,
cyclophosphamide in industry and hospitals, Mutat. Res. 204 RERF Update 5 Ž1993. 7–9.
Ž1988. 465–479.