UNIVERSITY OF THE EAST 1"Sem 2023-2024 LIST OF CASES Civil law Review 1 Dean V.M. Paguirigan COURSE OBJECTIVE: Civil Law Review 1 includes three major subjects: Persons and Family Relations, Property, and Wills and Succession. This course outline contains the pertinent cases which willilustrate the application of the law to reablfe situations or legal problems. At the end of the semester, each student is expected to have a working knowledge of the provisions of the Code and to be able to answer hypothetical cases presented by synthesizing the provisions of the law with the doctrines enunciated in the cases included in ths syllabus. CASE TITLE CITATION Tanada vs. Tuvera 136 SCRA 27 Tanada vs. Tuvera 146 SCRA 445 Garcillano v. House of Rep. G.R. No. 170338 December 23, 2008 Philsa vs. CA, 356 SCRA 174 Unciano Paramedical vs. CA 221 SCRA 285 Cuivs. Arellano University 2'SCRA 205 People vs. Jabinal 55 SCRA 607 Van Dom vs. Remillo 139 SCRA 139 Ando v. Dept. of Foreign Affairs G.R. No. 195432 August 27, 2014 Republic v. Kikuchi G.R. No. 243646 June 22, 2022 ‘Aanar vs. Garcia 7 SCRA 9S Bellis vs. Bellis 20SCRA 358 Uorente vs. CA 345 SCRA 592 Candelaria v. Dalaygon G.R. No. 139868 June 8, 2006 HUMAN RELATIONS Diaz vs. Encanto G.R. No. 171303 January 20, 2016 Allbenson vs. CA 217 SCRA 16 Globe Mackay vs. CA 176 SCRA 778 Barons Mktg. vs. CA 286 SCRA 96 California Clothing v. Quinones G.R. No. 175822 October 23, 2013 Rellosa vs. Pellosis ‘August 9, 2001 NPC vs. Philipp Brothers November 20, 2001 Carpio v. Valmonte Sept. 9, 2004‘Ardiente vs. Pastorfide G.R. No. 161921 (Art. 20) Garcia vs. Salvador(Art. 20) Meralco vs. CA, Custodio vs. CA Gashem vs. CA Frenzel vs. Catito Carbonell v, Metrobank G.R. No. 178467 Rico v. Union Bank G.R. No. 210928 Reyes vs. Lim NDC vs. Madrigal Wan Hai Padilla vs. CA Daluraya v. Oliva G.R. 210148 Fegarido v. Alcantara G.R. No. 240066 (See Rule 111, Rules on Criminal Procedure) PREJUDICIAL QUESTION Donato vs, Luna ‘Quiambao vs. Osorio ‘Ape vs. Fernandez Beltran vs. People Spouses Pahang v. Metrobank (See Rule 111, Rules on Criminal Procedure) CIVIL PERSONALITY Geluz vs. CA CITIZENSHIP Republic v. Chule Lim Maquiling v. Comelec G.R. NO. 195649 (See Article IV, Sections 1 to 5, 1987 Constitution) MARRIAGE Calimag v. Macapaz G.R. No. 191936 July 17, 2013 March 20, 2007 187 SCA 243 253 SCRA 483 219 SCRA 115 July 11, 2003 ‘Api 26, 2017 February 14, 2022 August 11, 2003 September 30, 2003 4129 SCRA S58 Dee. 8, 2014 June 13, 2022 160 SCRA 441 158 SCRA 674 242 SCRA 509 June 20, 2000 July 12, 2004 2SCRA 801 Jan, 13, 2004 July 2, 2013 June 1, 2016Balogbog v. CA 269 SCRA 259 Avenido v. Avenico G.R. NO. 173540 January 22, 2014 Republic vs. CA 236 SCRA 257 Silverio vs. Republic Oct. 19, 2007 Republic vs. Cagandahan Sept. 12, 2008 Republic v. Albios G.R, No. 198780 October 16, 2013 Sevilla v. Cardenas July 31, 2006 ‘Abbas v. Abbas G.R. No. 183896 January 30, 2013 Cariaga v. Republic G.R. No. 248643 December 07, 2021 Mallion v. Alcantara ‘October 31, 2006 Republic v. Dayot March 28, 2008 Navarro vs. Domagtoy 259 SCRA 129 Beso vs, Daguman 323 SCRA 566 Republic v. Manalo April 24, 2018 Morisono v, Morisono G.R. No. 226013, July 2, 2018 Juego-Sakai v. Republic G.R. No, 224015 July 23, 2018 Abel v. Rule G.R. No. 234457 May 12, 2021 Borja-Manzano vs. Sanchez(Art. 34) Mar. 8, 2001 VOID MARRIAGES Quiazon v. Belen G.R. No. 189121 July 31, 2013 Castillo v. Castillo G.R. No. 189607 April 18, 2016 Suntay vs. Cojuangco-Suntay 300 SCRA 760 Terre vs. Terre 211 SCRAS Iwasawa v. Custodio September 11, 2013 Fujiki v. Marinay June 30, 2013 Republic v. Olaybar Feb. 10, 2014 ‘See: Rules on Declaration of Absolute Nullity of Void Marriages and Annulment of Voidable Marriages effective March 15, 2003 PSYCHOLOGICAL INCAPACITY/ ARTICLE 40-41 Santos vs. CA 240 SCRA 23, Ching Ming Tsoi vs. CA 266 SCRA 324 Antonio v. Reyes March 10, 2006 Tan-Andal v. Andal G.R. No. 196359 May 11, 2021 Egmalis-Ke-eg v. Republic G.R. No. 249178 July 13, 2022 Pugoy-Solidum v. Republic G.R. No. 213954 April 20, 2022 Domingo vs. CA, 226 SCRA 573ee Bobis vs. Bobis(Art. 40) 336 SCRA 747 SSC vs. Azote G.R. No. 209741 April 15, 2015 Mercado vs. Tan 337 SCRA 122 Pulido v. People of the Phils. G.R, No. 220149 July 27, 2021 Morigo v. People Feb. 6, 2004 Carino vs. Carino 351 SCRA 131 Calisterio vs. Calisterio(Art. 41) 330 SCRA 201 Republic v. Cantor G.R. No. 184621 December 10, 2013 Republic v Granada - G.R. No. 187512 June 13, 2012 Republic vs. Alegro Dec. 9, 2005 Santos v. Santos G.R. No. 187061 October 08, 2014 Republic v. Catubag G.R. No. 210580 April 18, 2018 Tadeo-Matias v. Republic G.R. No. 230751 April 25, 2018 VOIDABLE MARRIAGES. ‘Anaya vs. Paraloan 36 SCRA 97 Aquino vs. Delizo 109 Phil. 21 Republic v. Villacorta G.R. No. 249953 June 23, 2021 Jimenez vs. Republic 409 Phil. 273 LEGAL SEPARATION Ocampo vs. Florenciano 107 Phil. 35 Bugayong vs. Gines 100 SCRA 616 Laperal vs. Republic 6 SCRA 357 ‘Ong v. Ong Oct. 23, 2006 ‘See: Rule on Legal Separation effective March 15, 2003; Republic Act No. 9262 or VAWC Law RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND & WIFE: Arroyo vs. Arroyo 42 Phil. 54 Pelayo vs. Lauron 12 Phil. 453 llusorio vs. lusorio. 332 SCRA 169 Goitia vs. Campos Rueda 35 Phil 252 PROPERTY RELATIONSQuiao v. Quiso G.R. No. 176556(102) Wong vs. CA Valdez vs. RTC Estonina vs. CA Ayala Investment vs. CA, Guiang vs. CA PNB vs. Reyes, Jr. G.R, No. 212483 Ferrer v. Ferrer Alinas v. Alinas Docena vs. Lapesura Manalo vs. Camaisa Carlos vs. Abelardo Relucio vs. Lopez Homeowners Savings Bank v. Dailo In Re Separation of Prop. Of Muller Salas v. Aguila (Art. 147) Ventura v. Abuda (Art. 148) Barrido vs. Nonato G.R. No, 176492(147) Malilin vs. Castillo(Art. 148) Fehr v. Fehr Saguid v. Rey Atienza v. De Castro ‘THE FAMILY AS AN INSTITUTION Hontiveros vs. RTC Br. 25, lloilo Guerrero vs. RTC of Ilocos Hiyas Savings Bank v. Moreno Favis v. Favis G.R. No. 18592 Moreno v. Khan G.R. No, 217744 FAMILY HOME Modequillo vs. Breva Manacop vs. CA Manacop vs. CA De Mesa v. Acero G.R. No. 185064 Patricio v. Dario Ill PATERNITY AND FILIATION July 4, 2012 200 SCRA 792 260 SCRA 221 266 SCRA 627 286 SCRA 272 291 SCRA 372 October 5, 2016 November 9, 2006 April 14, 2008 March 28, 2001 January 21, 2002 April 9, 2002 January 16, 2002 March 11, 2005 August 29, 2006 Sept. 23, 2013 (GR 202370) Oct. 23, 2013 (GR 202932) October 20, 2014 333 SCRA 628 October 23, 2003 June 10, 2003 Nov. 29, 2006 309 SCRA 340 229 SCRA 274 ‘August 31, 2006 January 15, 2014 July 30, 2018 185 SCRA 766 215 SCRA 773 277 SCRA 57 January 16, 2012, Nov. 20, 2006Wy Andel vs. Macaraig 89 Phil. 165 Babiera vs. Catotal 333 SCRA 487 Benitez Badua vs. CA 229 SCRA 468 Aguilar vs. Siasat G.R. No, 200169 (172) Sanvary 28, 2015 ‘Arado v. Alcoran G.R. No, 163362 July 08, 2015 ‘Ara. Pizarro G.R. No. 187273 February 19, 2017 Salas v. Matusalem G.R. 180284 Sept. 11, 2013 Jao vs. CA 152 SCRA 359 liano vs. CA 230 SCRA 242 Tayag vs. CA 209 SCRA 665 Fernandez vs. CA 230 SCRA 130 Cabatania v. Regodos Oct. 21, 2004 Sayson vs. CA 205 SCRA 321 Liao vs. Liyao 378 SCRA 563 De Jesus vs. Estate of Dizon 366 SCRA 499 Concepcion v. Almonte ‘August 31, 2005 Agustin v. Prollamante June 15, 2005, in Re Change of Name of Julian Lin Mar. 30, 2005 Briones v. Miguel cx. 18, 2008 Feb. 18, 2014 Grande v. Antonio Republic v. Capote February 2, 2007 De Santos vs. Angeles 251 SCRA 200 ADOPTION: Republic Act No. 11642, otherwise known as the DOMESTIC ‘ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION AND ALTERNATIVE CHILD CARE ACT signed into law on ‘January 6, 2022 repealed RA 8552 and 9623 - and it took effect on January 28, 2022 ‘SUPPORT Lacson v. Lacson August 28, 2006 Lim-Lua v. Lua G.R. No, 175279-80 June 5, 2013 Del Socorro vs. Van Wilsem G.R, No. 193707 December 10, 2014 PARENTAL AUTHORITY Caram, vs. Atty Segui G.R. No. 193652 August 5, 2014 David vs. CA 250 SCRA 82 Libi vs. AC 214 SCRA 16 Espiritu vs. CA 242 SCRA 362 Santos vs, CA 242 SCRA 407Perez vs. CA (Custody) Vancil vs. Belmes(G.R. 132223) Masbate v. Relucio G.R. No. 235498 ‘St. Mary's Academy vs. Carpitanos CASES IN PROPERTY Leung vs. Strong Machinery DBP vs. CA Republic vs. Guzman Heirs of Delfin v. NHA G.R. No. 193618 Malabanan v. Republic G.R. No. 17987 Republic vs. Guzman Republic v. Gielezyk G.R. No. 179990 Republic v. Pasig Rizal, In.; G.R. No. 213207 Leong ws. See G.R. No. 194077 (428) Mendoza vs. Salinas (433) Villasi v. Garcia G.R. No. 190106 Geminiano vs. CA Aquino vs. Aguilar G.R. No. 182754 (448) Tecnogas vs. CA Pleasantville vs. CA Delos Santos v. Absjon G.R. No. 215820 Ochoa v. Almazan(448) Leviste Mgt. v. Legaspi Towers G.R. No. 199353 Nazareno vs. CA (acer) Navarro vs. IAC (acer) Robles vs. CA De Aviles vs. CA (quieting) Calaito v. Obado G.R. No. 181596 Catedrilla v. Lauron G.R, NO. 179011 (487) Del Campo vs. CA Extraordinary Devt. V. Bico G.R. No. 191090 Magsano et. Al. vs. PSLBI G.R. No. 215038 Quinios v. Nicolas G.R. 210252 (494) Seraspi vs. CA Verdad v. CA Tabuso vs. CA(G.R. No. 108558) Gabriel v, Crisologo G.R. No. 204626 Cequena vs. Bolante Subic Bay Resorts v. Femandez G.R. No. 193426 255 SCRA 661 358 SCRA 707 July 30, 2018 376 SCRA 473 37 Phil. 644 253 SCRA 414 326 SCRA 574 November 28, 2016 September 3, 2013, 326 SCRA S74 October 23, 2013 15 February 2022; December 03, 2014 February 6, 2007 January 15, 2014 (accessory) 259 SCRA 344 June 29, 2015 February 10, 1997 253 SCRA 10 March 20, 2017 Sept. 13, 2007 April 4, 2018 257 SCRA 589 February 12, 1997 328 SCRA 97, 264 SCRA 473 January 30, 2017 April 15, 2013 351 SCRA 1 October 13, 2014 (493) October 17, 2016 (493) June 25, 2014 331 SCRA 293 256 SCRA 593 June 21, 2001 June 9, 2014 330SCRA 216 September 29, 2014 (559)EASEMENTS, Pilar Devt. Corp. v. Dumadag G.R. No. 194336 Reyes v. Spouses Ramos G.R. No. 194488(448) De Guzman vs. Filinvest G.R. No. 191710 Williams vs, Zerda G.R. No. 207146 Villanueva vs. CA Quimen vs. CA Spouses Sta. Maria vs. CA Cristobal vs. CA Camarines Norte Elec. vs. CA Costabella vs. CA Eneamacion vs. CA Dionisio vs. Ortiz Calimoso v. Roullo G.R, No. 198594 Sps. Garcia vs. Santos and Tan G.R. No, 228334 Sps. Ermino v. Golden Village G.R. No. 180808 Cruz v. Pandacan Hiker’s Club ox ne 1 Perez v. Madrona G.R. No. 184478 DONATIONS Cabatingan vs. Cabatingan Carinan v. Cueto G.R. No. 198636 Heirs of Mariano v. City of Naga G.R. No. 197743 Gonzales vs. CA(donation) Republic vs. Silim (Acceptance) Republic v. Llamas G.R. No. 194190 Roman Catholic vs. CA Prov. of Cam. Sur v. Bodega Glassware G.R. No. 194199 Republic vs. Guzman Gestopa vs. CA Noceda vs. CA Imperial vs. CA Eduarte v. CA City of Angeles vs. CA CASES IN SUCCESSION Heirs of Gonzales v. Sps. Basas G.R. No. 206847 Salitico v. Heirs of Felix G.R. No. 240199 March 11, 2013, February 11, 2015 January 14, 2015 March 15, 2017 330 SCRA 278 257 SCRA 163, 285 SCRA 351 291 SCRA 122 345 SCRA 85 193 SCRA 332 195 SCRA 74 204 SCRA 745 January 25, 2016 (Easement) June 17, 2019 ‘August 15, 2018 January 11, 2016(Nuisance) March 21, 2012 June 5, 2002 08 October 2014 (748) March 12, 2018 June 18, 2001 April 2, 2001 January 25, 2017 198 SCRA 300 March 22, 2017 326 SCRA 90 342 SCRA 105 313 SCRA 504 316 SCRA 393 253 SCRA 391 261 SCRA9 June 15, 2022 April 10, 2019Treyes vs. Larlar G.R. No. 232579 DKC Holdings vs. CA Genato v. Bayhon G.R. No. 172035 Coronel vs. Court of Appeals Dela Merced v. Dela Merced G.R. No. 126707 Aruego vs. CA Lorenzo vs. Posadas Castaneda vs. Alemany In Re Will of Riosa Enriquez vs. Abadia Miciano vs. Brimo Bells vs. Bellis Baltazar vs. Laxa G.R. No. 174489 Bugnao vs. Ubag Bagtas vs.Paguio Neyra vs. Neyra Acop vs. Piraso Mitra v. Sablan G.R, No. 213994 Valmonte v. Ortega G.R. No. 157451 In Re Lopez G.R. No. 189984 Jaboneta vs. Gustilo Avera vs. Garcia Ieasiano vs. Ieasiano Cagro vs. Cagro Caneda vs. CA Cruz vs. Villasor Guia v. Cosico G.R. No. 246997 Azuela v. Castillo Roxas de Jesus vs. De Jesus Labrador vs. CA Ajero ws. CA Kalaw vs. Relova Perez vs. Tolete Aznar vs. Garcia Testate Estate of Maloto Molo vs. Molo Tolentino vs. Francisco ‘Mercado vs. Santos Nuguid vs. Nuguid Morales v. Olondriz G.R. 198994 Caniza vs. CA Pecson vs. Coronel Acain vs. IAC September 8, 2020 329 SCRA 66 ‘August 24, 2009 263 SCRA 15 February 25, 1999 254 SCRA 711 64 Phil. 353 3 Phil. 426 39 Phil 23 95 SCRA 627 50 Phil. 867 20 SCRA 358 April 11, 2012 14 Phil 163 22 Phil. 227 76 Phil. 333 52 Phil. 660 April 18, 2018 December 16, 2005 November 12, 2012 5 Phil. 541 42 Phil. 145 11 SCRA 423 92 Phil. 1033 222SCRA 781 54 SCRA 31 May 5, 2021 April 12, 2006 134 SCRA 245 184 SCRA 170 236 SCRA 488 132 SCRA 237 232 SCRA 722 7 SCRA 95 158 SCRA 451 90 Phil. 37, 57 Phil. 749 66 Phil, 215 17 SCRA 449 February 3, 2016 268 SCRA 641 45 Phil, 216 155 SCRA 101Neri vs, Akutin Viado Non vs. Court of Appeals Perez vs. Garchitorena Rabadilla vs. CA Morente vs. dela Santa Rosales vs. Rosales Parulan v. Garcia Francisco vs. Alfonso G.R. No. 138774 Nieva vs. Alcala Solivio vs. CA ‘Sumaya vs. IAC ‘Mendoza v. Policarpio G.R. NO. 176422 De Papa vs. Camacho Ching v. Rodriguez G.R. No. 192828 Pecson vs. Mediavillo Dorotheo vs. CA Heirs of Uriarte vs. CA ‘Ang vs. Pacunio G.R. No. 208928 (970) Tirol v. Nolasco G.R. No. 230103 (972) Bagunu vs. Piedad Pascual vs. Bautista Manuel vs. Ferrer Aquino v. Aquino G.R. No. 208912 Verdad vs. CA Cacho vs. Udan Coja vs. Aquillo Abellana de Bacayo vs. Borromeo Bicomong vs. Almanza City of Manila vs. Archbishop Torres vs. Lopez Nepomuceno vs. IAC Ralla vs. Untalan Balanay vs. Martinez Plan vs. JAC ‘Aznar Brothers Realty vs. CA 74 Phil, 185 325 SCRA 652 54 Phil 431 334 SCRA 522 9 Phil. 387 148 SCRA 69 June 9, 2014 March 8, 2001 41 Phil. 915 182 SCRA 119 201 SCRA 178 March 20, 2013 144 SCRA 281 November 28, 2011 28 Phil. 81 320 SCRA 12 284 SCRA S11 July 8, 2015 August 27, 2020 347 SCRA 571 207 SCRA 561 247 SCRA 476 December 7, 2021 256 SCRA 593 13 SCRA 693 Dec. 10, 2007 14 SCRA 986 80 SCRA 421 36 Phil. 815 49 Phil. 504 139 SCRA 206 172 SCRA 858 64 SCRA 452 135 SCRA 270 327 SCRA 359 10