Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TRANSFER BLUEPRINT
A National Guideline for Technology
Transfer Offices in Saudi Arabia
1.3 Who are the relevant stakeholders within the technology transfer ecosystem? 07
2.3.2 What are some key organizational design considerations for a TTO? 16
What are the core technology transfer processes and procedures followed by
2.3.6 18
TTOs?
Glossary 23
The purpose of this blueprint is to provide TTOs, and IP, and details their importance in
guidance on the best practices for technology the innovation journey. Moreover, this
transfer. It is not intended to be a section provides context by giving examples
comprehensive or definitive answer to all of TTO success stories.
questions related to technology transfer
• The second section discusses key
activities. Rather, it is a starting point for KSA
considerations for setting up a TTO. It details
universities and research centers wishing to
how TTOs can achieve financial sustainability
establish Technology Transfer Offices (TTOs) and
and forge sustainable long-term partnerships.
for TTOs looking to improve their knowledge of
best practices. • The third section provides key considerations
for operating an effective TTO. It provides
Even though this blueprint is a collection of best
best practices related to TTOs’ operating
practices on how to conduct technology transfer,
models, including roles, governance model
KSA universities, TTOs, and research centers
considerations, organizational structure,
should use it as a guide, and make sure it is
policies, processes and procedure, and tools
tailored to their specific context, actual
and technologies.
challenges, research capabilities and pipeline,
and overall aspirations for research and The blueprint is intended for a broad audience,
innovation. including TTOs, researchers, entrepreneurs, and
policymakers. We hope it will be a useful
The blueprint is divided into three sections:
resource for anyone involved in the technology
• The first section defines technology transfer, transfer process.
Disclaimer
The information contained in this blueprint is not intended to be legal professional
advice. It is important to consult with an attorney and an IP licensing professional
before entering into any technology transfer agreement.
1.3 Who are the relevant stakeholders within the technology transfer
ecosystem?
TTOs interact with various stakeholders in different cutting edge basic research), supporting TTOs’
ways. efforts to commercialize the technology (e.g.,
providing incentives to inventors), and creating a
On one hand, TTOs help their customers, private
culture of innovation and entrepreneurship (e.g.,
sector companies, by connecting them with
providing opportunities for students to start their
universities to address the companies’ most pressing
own companies and encourage entrepreneurship).
needs through collaborative research agreements.
They provide these companies with knowledge about • Industry/Private sector/nonprofit sector helps the
the latest inventions and IPs generated by universities transfer of technology by sponsoring opportunities
and research institutions. for researcher and students to collaborate, by
investing in technology development projects (e.g.,
On the other hand, multiple key players contribute to
technology hackathons and accelerators).
the success of technology transfer and
commercialization. Key players include: • Venture capital and private equity supports
technology transfer by financing the companies
• Government supports technology transfer by
that will undertake the commercialization of
creating a favorable regulatory environment
technologies (e.g., early-stage investment), and
including maintaining and promoting the
provide growing companies the follow-on
protection and use of intellectual property) and
investment they need to be successful (e.g., later-
encouraging the commercialization of early-stage
stage investment in spinouts).
technologies (e.g., through tax or other financial
incentives to promote new technology The above parties all play a key role in supporting
adaptation). technology transfer. By working together, these
stakeholders can ensure that new technologies are
• University, as the primary funder of TTOs
developed, commercialized, and used to benefit
encourage and incentivize the adoption of
society.
research innovations and resources (e.g., funding
KPIs, or key performance indicators, are metrics used resources needed to be successful.
to measure the performance of a TTO and track its
Without clear and well-defined KPIs, it is difficult for a
progress. They:
TTO to know if they are being effective. These KPIs can
• Set the TTO’s direction: defining specific KPIs helps be divided into three main categories:
to focus the TTO's efforts and avoid wasting time
• Input KPIs,
and resources on activities not aligned with its
goals. • Output KPIs,
• Define the TTO’s purpose: the KPIs that a TTO • Impact KPIs.
chooses will reflect its priorities and mission. For
Input metrics often measure the activities undertaken
example, a TTO that is focused on commercializing
by the TTO and the University to measure the
university research will likely track KPIs such as the
progress of technology transfer while outputs
number and revenue generated from licensing
measure the result of the application of TTO expertise
agreements, and the number of startups and
to those activities. Finally impact metrics are often
spinoffs created.
derived from the output metrics but are beyond the
• Measure the impact created by the TTO: by direct action of the TTO and as such they are more
tracking its KPIs over time, the TTO can measure reflective of the innovation ecosystem’s overall health
impact. This can inform necessary adjustments to and success.
the TTO's strategy and ensure its positive impact
On the other hand, input KPIs primarily measure the
on the university and on society.
TTO's ability to support research and innovation at the
• Communicate the value of the TTO to university. These KPIs are also essential to the long-
stakeholders: by tracking and reporting on its KPIs, term health of the university because they indirectly
the TTO can demonstrate its value to stakeholders. measure its ability to produce research.
This can help build support and secure the
A TTO is financially sustainable when it can discretion to technology transfer activities, leaving the
demonstrate continued viability through the TTO heavily dependent on the university and making
continued contributions of the University. In order to funding unpredictable.
demonstrate viability, the TTO will have to show that it
Universities must be educated on the importance of
has the capacity to generate impacts and income from
technology transfer and the crucial role they play in it.
its outputs to offset the investment made by the
University. It is a crucial element that enables To achieve financial sustainability, TTOs need to
universities to create impact and benefit for society by understand their two main potential sources of
supporting the TTO. Without a strong value income: university funding, and revenue generated
proposition accepted by the university the TTOs would from technology transfer activities.
not be able to support the commercialization of
Universities receive research funding from the
research, build relationships with industry, or promote
government. They allocate a portion of this funding to
technology transfer over the long term.
their TTOs. While this is the main source of funding for
Financially sustainable TTOs are better positioned to TTOs, it is also one of their biggest challenges since it
attract and retain top talent, respond to challenges, makes them dependent on the university research
and create positive societal impact. budget.
Achieving financial sustainability can be a long and Additionally, TTOs leverage their own capabilities to
difficult process due to: generate extra revenue. This revenue can come from
different activities, such as
• The time needed to commercialize research: it can
take many years to commercialize research, and • Licensing: revenue is generated when TTOs license
TTOs need a steady stream of income to cover their intellectual property to industry partners. The
their operating costs during this time. amount of revenue that a TTO receives from a
licensing agreement depends on its terms.
• The uncertainty of the commercialization process:
Common types of licensing agreements include
there is no guarantee that any research
revenue-sharing agreements, dividends from
commercialization will be successful, and TTOs
equity ownership, and the sale of spinout shares.
need to be prepared for the possibility of losing
Licensing agreements can also include material
money on some projects.
transfer agreements (MTA). TTOs receive revenue
• The lack of awareness of technology transfer: from patented material or software rights
many researchers and industry partners are not transferred to industry partners.
aware of the benefits of technology transfer, and
• Consulting services: revenue can be generated by
TTOs need to educate these stakeholders about
providing a variety of services, such as identifying
the process to build relationships and generate
potential markets for a technology, developing
revenue.
business plans, providing IP advice, and negotiating
Government funding is typically directed to the licensing agreements. Consulting services can be a
university in the form of research funding. The good way for TTOs to generate revenue and build
university then allocates a specific amount at its own relationships with industry partners.
TTO staff, whether they be one person or • Marketing: promoting the technologies,
multiple teams, play a variety of roles to enable expertise, and resources of the university to
the commercialization of university research potential industry partners, investors, and
output. The primary roles, observed in most startups. This includes developing marketing
international TTOs, include: strategies, creating marketing materials, and
organizing networking events. The TTO must
• Policy and Practice Development: managing also market its own success internally and
the process of developing guidance for the externally to achieve sustainability.
university and its constituent elements on
how to establish, improve, and accelerate • Licensing: pricing, negotiating, and concluding
knowledge transfer activities. commercial right agreements with industry
partners and startups.
• Engagement and Education: engaging actively
in the realm of technology transfer, where • Compliance: monitoring compliance with
TTO staff frequently participate in lab financial and non-financial aspects of licenses
meetings, visit professors' offices, and attend once they are concluded to ensure that the
classrooms across campus. These university recovers that which it is entitles to
engagements involve discussing the receive whether it be royalties or information
advantages of contemplating the initiation of on the development of new jobs and
a company, forming partnerships with products.
industries, or simply aiding a professor in
realizing their role as an inventor. • Spinouts: supporting and encouraging the
establishment of startup companies created
• Invention Disclosure Assessment: specifically to license university IP (often
representing the expansive opening of the called a spinoff) and to participate in the
innovation funnel, this phase demands adept management and growth of those companies
professionals who possess expertise in both through incubation, investment and often the
science and business. Their task is to ascertain provision of space.
which disclosures have the potential for
protection and, more significantly, which ones • Consulting: establishing a first form of
necessitate protection. engagement that a company will have with a
university before engaging in more
• Intellectual Property (IP) Management: substantial collaborative research projects.
making the decision to file, where to file, The TTO can support researcher who are
when to file, reviewing the filing to date and willing and able to develop future
managing the costs associated with the opportunities for their research through
outcomes are all aspects of creating consulting activities.
something that can be marketed to
businesses or form the basis of a startup.
What are the governance model options followed by • Enabling quicker and more agile responses to
TTOs? business needs, more effectively meeting industry
TTOs can adopt various governance models depending demands.
on several factors such as their maturity level and • Providing legal protection to the university through
resource availability. Governance model options a "legal firewall" by signing separate agreements
include: andshieldingthe institutionfrom potential liabilities.
• Remainembeddedwithintheuniversity. • Facilitating successful commercialization due to
• Existas an independentwhollyownedsubsidiary. attraction and appropriate remuneration of top
technologytransfertalentand capabilities.
• Form a nonprofit company owned by a consortium
ofuniversities. • Clearly segregating responsibilities between
researchandcommercialization.
A. Embeddedwithintheuniversity
The governancemodelalsoofferssome challengessuch
TTOs following this model are considered a department as:
within the university. This model offers several
advantagessuchas: • Potential misalignment between the TTO and other
partsoftheuniversity.
• Providing accesstouniversity resources.
• Challenges communicating and coordinating with
• Fostering a culture of innovation and knowledge other universitydepartments.
transferwithinthe institution.
C. Nonprofit company owned by a consortium of
• Ensuring close proximity to ongoing research and universities
emerging technologies and enhancing the ability to
identifypromising innovations. TTOs following this model are nonprofit organizations
operating under the ownership of several universities.
• Being a part of the university community, Representatives from these universities usually sit on
positioningthe TTO as an innovationvehicle. the board of these TTOs. This model offers several
This modelmightalso presentsome challenges,such as: advantagessuch as:
• Slower decision-making processes due to reliance • Ensuring faster capability building due to
on numerous stakeholders, potentially impeding collaborationamong partneruniversities,
the technologytransfertimeline. • Increasing exposure to new research since each
• Potential conflicts of interest between the TTO and universitymayhave uniquefocusareas.
research departments because the former • Realizing better cost efficiencies due to shared
emphasizes commercialization while the latter functions.
prioritizes research outputs.
• Having a greater breadth of resources than an
• Remuneration on a university scale rather than an individualuniversity could justify.
industryone.
However, the model is less prevalent than the first two
B. Independentwhollyownedsubsidiary optionsdue tocertain challenges,such as:
TTOs following this model operate outside the • Higher risk of conflicts between partner universities,
university but remain under its ownership. These TTOs requiring careful management of differing interests
have dedicated people across all their functions. This andpriorities.
modeloffersseveraladvantagessuch as:
• Slower decision-making processes due to cultural
• Fostering stronger business-to-business differencesbetween collaborating institutions.
relationships with private companies, as an
independent entity solely focused on bridging • Weakattachmentperceptionto the university.
academiaand industry.
2.3.3 What are some key organizational design considerations for a TTO?
TTOs commonly adopt a functional handles annually and assuming that it needs
organizational structure, which organizes one IP manager for every 40 patents. This
operations around well-defined roles. Employees number considers all other functions and
are grouped together based on their skills and roles performed by the TTO, such as licensing,
expertise such as finance, marketing, or IP. This marketing, and back-office support.
structure ensures clear delineation of
• Roles and responsibilities: a dedicated team
responsibilities.
with well-defined roles and responsibilities
These functions are divided into "front-office" promotes efficiency, avoids confusion,
functions such as licensing, intellectual property optimizes resource allocation, expedites
management, marketing, and spinouts, and decision-making, and enables effective
"back-office" functions such as human resources, communication. It is essential for TTO
finance, and information technology. This helps employees to clearly understand their roles to
TTOs manage activities in a well-organized ensure efficient navigation of complex
manner, ensuring visibility and accountability. technology transfer processes.
There are several important elements to • Leadership: strong leadership is essential for
consider for the successful TTO, including: TTOs to guide strategy, decision-making,
resource allocation, external advocacy, and
• Size: TTO size (number of employees)
relationships with the university leadership
depends on several factors such as the
and administration. TTOs should seek the
volume of patents handled, the research
support of university leadership and ensure a
output of the university, and the topics of
shared understanding of the pivotal role of
interest in research. A TTO can be sized by
technology transfer within the university's
estimating the number of IP patents it
agenda.
2.3.6 What are the core technology transfer processes and procedures followed by TTOs?
Technology transfer is a long and difficult process with a low chance of success. TTOs need to effectively
manage this process to maximize the chances of developing innovative technologies.
TTOs usually follow similar processes and procedures in their technology transfer journey.
Commercialization
Agreement Negotiations
Execution &
Monitoring
2.3.3 What are some key organizational design considerations for a TTO?
As seen in figure 1, these can include:
The process typically begins with the inventor
1) Invention disclosure: providing submitting an invention disclosure form to the
information about an invention to a TTO. TTO, which should include the following:
The disclosure should include a detailed
• The name of the inventor(s) and their relative
description of the invention, as well as any
contributions
relevant information about the invention's
potential commercial applications. Its • The title of the invention
importance lies in:
• A detailed description of the invention
a) Assessing potential: disclosure allows the
(including the critical solution it provides)
TTO to evaluate the invention's worth and
decide on further action. • Any relevant information about the
b) IP protection: disclosure enables the TTO invention's potential commercial applications
to file a patent, safeguarding the • The inventor's contact information
invention's related intellectual property.
c) New technologies marketing: disclosure It is particularly important to make a full
helps the TTO present the invention to disclosure of the invention and to define it in a
potential partners for commercialization. way that clearly creates borders of protection for
the resulting patent. An incomplete disclosure
can cause problems in the patent filing activity.
Inventors should disclose their inventions to a
Moreover, a disclosure outside of the TTO and
TTO as early as possible. By disclosing, inventors
university at this stage will, in most countries,
can protect their inventions and increase the
invalidate any patent application, so the
chances of commercialization. The disclosure
disclosure should be kept internal to the
process should be detailed, confidential, and
university and be on a need-to-know basis.
timely.
TTOs leverage certain technologies and tools to several commercial software offerings to do
support their technology transfer activities. this, of which the most popular are Inteum
Selecting software depends on the TTO’s needs and Wellspring.
and the size of their operations. Adequate
• Patent search databases: TTOs can benefit
training should be provided to all relevant
from accessing patent databases such as
members to maximize the benefits. Some useful
USPTO patent search or Patentscope to
technologies and tools used by international
conduct prior art searches and assess the
leading TTOs include:
novelty and patentability of inventions.
• Data management software: TTOs deal with
• Knowledge management systems: TTOs can
data related to intellectual property, licensing
employ knowledge management systems
agreements, and research projects.
such as Sharepoint to organize and share
Implementing a robust data management
internal expertise and best practices related
software facilitates organized and efficient
to technology transfer.
handling of this information. There are