Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Sensors International
journal homepage: www.keaipublishing.com/en/journals/sensors-international

Significance of Quality 4.0 towards comprehensive enhancement in

manufacturing sector
Mohd Javaid a, *, Abid Haleem a, Ravi Pratap Singh b, Rajiv Suman c
a
Department of Mechanical Engineering Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India
b
Department of Industrial and Production Engineering Dr B R Ambedkar National Institute of Technology, Jalandhar, Punjab, India
c
Department of Industrial & Production Engineering, G.B. Pant University of Agriculture & Technology, Pantnagar, Uttarakhand, India

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Quality 4.0 corresponds to the growing digitisation of industry, which uses advanced technologies to enhance the
Quality 4.0 quality of manufacturing and services. This fourth quality revolution is envisaged to digitise the entire quality
Industry 4.0 systems and subsequently improve the existing quality approaches. Innovative industries adopt cloud-based
Quality revolution
quality 4.0 innovations in the controlled production process. It is used to resolve quality problems satisfacto-
Quality control
Sensors
rily when they emerge and carry out real-time quality analyses to improve competitiveness and use them. Various
Technologies ongoing challenges are take-over by Quality 4.0 technologies, such as automated root cause analysis, machine-to-
machine connectivity to parameter auto adjustment, simulation of real-time processes and more. Quality 4.0 is a
modern form of quality management. Digital technologies paired with more sophisticated methods and smarter
processes will allow high-performance teams to provide consumers with high-performance and quality goods
reliably. Sensors play an essential role in improving the quality of manufacturing and services. These can improve
protection, increased internal productivity and sustainable operations. This paper provides how quality 4.0 will
have a significant impact in the field of manufacturing. Various Key Aspects and enablers of Quality 4.0 for
Manufacturing are discussed, finally, Identified and discussed eighteen significant applications of Quality 4.0 in
the field of manufacturing. Quality 4.0 not only concerns the things happening inside a factory; it also includes the
complete supply chain from Research and Development (R&D), manufacturing, development, distribution, sales,
and service after-sales.

1. Introduction communication and maintaining the quality of the manufacturing sys-

We are at the centre of the fourth industrial revolution, which refers
to as Industry 4.0. Data analytics, cooperation, scalability, and
networking technological advances accelerate creativity and change the
paradigm in the fabrication of products and services. During
manufacturing, quality must be maintained by which Quality 4.0 tech-
nologies are available to fulfil major challenges regarding quality. This
quality revolution evolved technology like artificial intelligence, ma-
chine learning, large media, cloud computing, augmented and virtual
reality, new materials, the Internet of Things, and more for better
tem. Quality 4.0 is a practical approach with a spectrum of strategic and
cultural activities and technology problems. Predictive quality analysis is
a method used by producers in predicting quality of already in the
manufacturing process goods, parts, and materials [1–3].
Traditionally, quality control is called a quality service feature. Given
that consistency is a part of the production, allocations for quality control
systems are in the hand of more or better manufacturing equipment.
Quality 4.0 focuses on the necessary details, reducing the cost of poor
quality and tracking quality results. Many organisations have started
growing their data collection resolution using sensors and analytics.

* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: mjavaid@jmi.ac.in, mohdjavaid0786@gmail.com (M. Javaid), ahaleem@jmi.ac.in (A. Haleem), -singhrp@nitj.ac.in (R. Pratap Singh), -raje.
suman@gmail.com (R. Suman).

Production and hosting by Elsevier

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sintl.2021.100109
Received 13 May 2021; Received in revised form 12 June 2021; Accepted 14 June 2021
Available online 24 June 2021
2666-3511/© 2021 The Authors. Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
M. Javaid et al.
Sensors are also an essential component of Quality 4.0 which can help
maintain the manufacturing quality. These businesses inspect the quality
and procedures of their suppliers to avoid problems of quality down-
stream rather than checking the components as the main task of quality.
In close cooperation with suppliers’ producers, they understand their
suppliers' internal processes and improve component efficiency to fulfil
their suppliers' quality requirements [4,5].
Regulation of quality is an important aspect of the automobile in-
dustry. Maintaining output efficiency is the primary priority of all
manufacturing plants. Each plant unit should carry out the quality con-
trols, and quality levels must be established using Quality 4.0 technolo-
gies. Big data analysis is an effective means of finding any irregularities
and ensuring quality maintenance during the whole production process.
Quality 4.0 is one of the variables that can do business. These technol-
ogies accelerated changes would inevitably lead to a shift in the way
multiple businesses operate daily. This will entail a culture transition that
will impact staff and leadership and feed into such factors as product
creativity, production productivity, success in the supply chain,
enforcement, and, of course, quality. Quality 4.0 comes in here, which is
a central principle is to harmonise quality control with industry 4.0's new
capabilities and supports companies to achieve organisational excellence
[6,7].
Quality management systems and practitioners must be an integrated
component of the environment to succeed and add to the organisation's
ultimate advantages. Quality 4.0 provides Quality professionals with vast
volumes of data in real-time and concurrently from many sources, and
this information can be used to allow quick, tactical decision-making.
Quality 4.0 integrates data and technologies as well as uses them to
promote creativity and enhance overall quality. In order to ensure
confidentiality of data while preserving Patient Health Information and
Intellectually Property business, vast volumes of data are being handled
under Quality 4.0. Smart products can receive and transmit data between
machines and people in the medical device industry, and, therefore,
incoming data must not be hazardous to the equipment and the user
[8–10].
Quality 4.0 provides appropriate information that is continuously
conveyed via the system. Thus, to ensure data protection and identity
disclosure, a delicate balancing of digital confidence is required. Artifi-
cial intelligence and machine learning on validation are used to reflect
positive effects on production operations. This technological innovation
achieves expected results and shows that our validation processes and
technology always lead to better quality. Furthermore, AI and machine
learning algorithms can learn and remember something originating from
the algorithm, enhancing quality 4.0 [11,12]. This paper aims to discuss
the major benefits, drivers, and applications of Quality 4.0 in
manufacturing.
1.1. Need for the study
Quality 4.0 offers a range of methods and strategies to simplify reg-
ulatory practices. There is a need to study various capabilities of Quality
4.0 technologies in manufacturing, which positively impact the Industry
to enhance quality. To take full advantage of Quality 4.0, Industries aim
to automate digital processes and harmonise and link those automated
processes to other systems and operations. Improving the system mini-
mises the time needed for high-value employees and management to
implement and concentrate on improvement and creativity. High-level
management support in a company will promote activities and conduct
that contribute to the organisation's quality results. They must also use an
organisational approach focused on continuous growth, with modern
technologies enable organisations to compete for quality and maintain
their competitive edge. Several new skills for quality practitioners are
vital for new revolutions, and preparation will play an important role
because different skills at multiple levels will be appropriate [13,14].
Organisations may exchange effective regulatory techniques through
departments and workplaces using this quality revolution. Important
2
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
data analytics will warn companies, allowing for proactive actions, to
possible violations of enforcement. Compliance-based activities and data
processing can be automated by integrating business information man-
agement and operational technology. Quality 4.0 enables companies to
evaluate their enforcement policies and recognise growth opportunities
[15,16].
1.2. Research objectives
Quality 4.0 involves aligning administration and processes with in-
novations to achieve quality. It aims to maintain conventional best
practices and to simplify these processes through analytics and digital
networking. Current development processes are improved by leveraging
new connectivity, data and computational capabilities to maintain
quality. Intelligent computers are used to collect data remotely in real-
time. Companies must use data for decision-making purposes and find
ways to integrate data from different processes for precision and clarity.
Companies interact with operational technologies to enable data, pro-
cesses, and individuals to work together [17,18]. Managers can aim at
using quality management software to harness the disruptive forces of
networking, data and analysis. The major research objectives of this
paper are as under:
RO1: To identify Quality 4.0 and its significant benefits;
RO2: to provide key aspects of Quality 4.0 for manufacturing
development;
RO3: to identify major elements associated with Quality 4.0 in the
manufacturing domain;
RO4: to identify significant enablers of Quality 4.0 for enhancing
manufacturing scenario;
RO5: to identify and discuss Quality 4.0 applications to enhance
quality in manufacturing.
1.3. Research methodology
Identified and studied, published research articles on Quality 4.0 and
its associated technologies. The overview of these articles regarding
quality is discussed in this paper to improve the focus of our work. The
paper summarises current thoughts regarding this topic and aims to
provide a critical assessment available from studies. The critical infor-
mation regarding Quality 4.0 in manufacturing is provided for a better
understanding. Figures and tables provide clarity of research objectives.
This article primarily focuses on the applications of Quality 4.0 in the
field of manufacturing. This paper will help researchers to find new
research areas to carry out various studies to improve quality.
2. Quality 4.0
Quality 4.0 integrates emerging technology with conventional quality
approaches, which allow organisational efficiency, and creativity to
achieve new optimums. Artificial intelligence, mobile devices and
transactions provide emerging ways of collaboration. Smart sensor net-
works, big data, cloud computing and applications like argument reality
(AR) and virtual reality (VR) are among the new developments for
quality. Quality teams have to play an active leading role in these efforts.
Quality 4.0 is driven by technologies that provide real change in quality,
leadership, and quality process culture. Quality 4.0 encapsulates several
innovations to develop the capabilities of manufacturing. Social
networking platforms can be used to exchange lessons and perspectives
through and among organisations. Artificial intelligence and machine-
learning applications can be used to build new abilities, while systems
used to enhance the ability to work with people are AR and VR. Intelli-
gent technologies and wearables devices can help assess employees while
learning management, AR and VR systems can enhance training provi-
sion [19–21].
Quality 4.0 describes the path to emerging technology that suppliers
can take. This involves deep learning, statistical analysis, IoT, big data
M. Javaid et al.
and cloud analytics and conventional quality control frameworks, which
are used to enhance market efficiency and continue to improve it.
Smarter practices and processes can help to increase consistency in
different ways through digital technology. In order to anticipate quality
problems and maintenance requirements, businesses should, for
instance, track and gather data in real-time and use analysis. Digital in-
struments can help people do their jobs efficiently, more accessible, and
lower costs [22,22].
Quality 4.0 certainly requires quality control digitisation. This digi-
talisation of quality infrastructure, processes and individuals is more
important to take into account. Quality 4.0 can replace traditional ap-
proaches of quality and the best mechanism to improve current pro-
cesses. Manufacturers should use the Quality 4.0 system to assess their
current status and determine what adjustments are needed to progress
into the future regarding quality. It allows top management to fulfil
various challenges. Companies pursuing Quality 4.0 should build their
analytical strategy. In Industry 4.0, connectivity is transformed by a set of
inexpensive embedded sensors which supply connected individuals,
goods, and edge devices and processes with nearly real-time feedback.
Smart sensors and smart wearable devices detecting people and their
surroundings may be used by related individuals [23,24].
Connected products may provide reviews on their lifecycle success.
This efficiently attaches critical equipment to wired edge computers.
Edge sensors also analyse the system and make predictive/prescriptive
decisions. This Quality 4.0 connectivity aspect enables the decision-
making process to be reduced globally by delivering open data and
sound analysis. Connectivity, data and analysis have been profoundly
transformed and expanded as an influential source of creativity and
quality assurance. Digital transformation in the manufacturing, pro-
cessing and production markets around the world is fundamentally
transforming now. Besides, Quality 4.0 will also develop the function of
the current inspection. Since automatic equipment installed into the
machinery and production lines quantify the conducted activities. It will
play an essential role in decision-making on measurement systems,
reviewing data gathered and taking suitable preventive action to enhance
current processes. Quality 4.0 incorporates modern innovations with
conventional quality approaches to achieve new optimal efficiency,
market excellence and creativity [25–27].
Industries realise that quality 4.0 will generate considerable value, a
comprehensive plan and an implementation programme. The results
demonstrate the need for businesses to step up their Quality 4.0 imple-
mentation. A multi-faceted solution that tackles various strategic, cul-
tural and technical problems is vital to achieving. At all levels of the
supply chain, survey participants understand the significance of quality
4.0. However, they view production and R&D as fields where increased
efficiency can be helpful. The exposure of the value produced on the shop
floor represents the perceived significance for development. Participants
are now aware of the advantages of implementing quality 4.0 in science
and technology to enhance the design and quality of new goods. Intel-
ligent technologies are being used in production systems and processes
by which tremendous capacity can be developed [28–30].
3. Benefits of Quality 4.0
When quality is gaining relevance for the business agenda, new ap-
proaches are now available to solve the complexities of quality control.
Quality 4.0 is among the many developments that give rise to future in-
dustries, which digitally enhanced plant structures and processes to in-
crease productivity and flexibility in the factory and throughout the supply
chain. Digital technologies can help to improve quality in various ways.
Online platforms can allow people to do their jobs quicker, smarter, and at
a reduced cost. Wired communications are suitable for high-performance,
time-sensitive automation activities. Factors such as environment are
typically tracked, and one can identify their significant effect on quality
fluctuations. The immediate quest for greater process visibility represents
IoT's immense capacity for proactive quality control [31,32].
3
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
Various quality problems originate, and manufacturers may also build
and incorporate a quality management model to improve product prop-
erties. The machine's operations are automatically adapted to uninten-
tional variations, such as environmental factors, to obtain high and stable
product attributes by capitalising on continuous sensors inputs. Small
and multinational businesses will also rapidly scale their production and
supply chain operations through the digitalisation and integration of
design and manufacture processes using Quality 4.0. Further, they
needed a scalable framework that could expand during the quality
compliance phase for their staff and products. Modern medical device
manufacturers rely on dispersed teams and supply chains to accelerate
product production and launch, including design collaborators, consul-
tants, and tiered suppliers. As a result, companies adopted emerging
technologies to enhance product capabilities and regulatory enforcement
goals regarding quality [33,34].
Emerging technologies like IoT and robots will lead to improved re-
sults for patients worldwide, leading to improved quality health care in
the medical field. Quality 4.0's progress has helped drive technology and
strategies to improve conformity. In today's world, it is crucial to align
the dynamic production of products and quality processes. IoT de-
ployments also tend to be disproportionately complex, costly and data
acquisition inherent in most industrial environments. In reality, anything
amounts to selecting the best technologies for the exemplary business
scenario. With the introduction of modern IoT applications, it became
more peripheral for automation [35,36].
4. Key Aspects of Quality 4.0 for manufacturing development
Fig. 1 explores the various qualitative aspects of the implementation
of Quality 4.0 culture throughout the manufacturing environment. The
major traits are the database of cloud-related facts, optimisation of the
process, system automation, technically advanced supports such as;
artificial intelligence, sensors technology and virtual reality features, etc.
These features further develop the manufacturing domain faster and
processively and satisfy end customers [37,38]. In addition, the concepts
like 3D/4D printing, the internet of things, virtual learning & training
events also support the successful implementation of overall quality
culture in manufacturing sites.
Quality 4.0 manage and improve new quality and existing Quality
Service environment. Digital data, analytics, convergence and scalability
are the pioneers of this fourth technological revolution, which informs
Quality 4.0 strategies. This discovers innovative ways to link humans,
devices and data. These technologies bring in analytics, material sciences
and transformational communication skills. These innovations enable a
quality transition of society, leadership, teamwork and expectations for
the manufacturing industry. Quality 4.0 can support the amount of data,
customers, devices and apps globally. Processes need to be harmonised,
streamlined and optimised, to allow high-quality workers to move from
Fig. 1. Key aspects of quality 4.0 for manufacturing development.
M. Javaid et al.
quality clearly to innovation and improvement [39,40]. Companies can
evaluate the existing processes and procedures for enforcement to find
areas to be improved in the quality aspect. A quality culture around the
organisation can appear elusive, and Quality 4.0 can make it easier to
gain increased communication, exposure, insights and teamwork. Per-
formance teams need to re-align their priorities to link to corporate
buy-in and incubator ownership strategic objectives. Wearable,
augmented reality, and robotics can enhance teaching and information
sharing through computer training, artificial intelligence, and machine
applications. Using Quality 4.0 technology is crucial to efficiency because
it allows leadership, teamwork and enforcement [41,42].
Quality 4.0 has become necessary for the survival of manufacturing.
From product creation to front-office business transactions and all in
between, any process must be distinguished by consistency. In this
modern era of accelerated change, Quality 4.0 tends to be the concept of
consistency as a method of containing rather than a tool of prevention.
Quality 4.0 is fascinating, and at least some of the innovations will be
used in quality manufacturing in upcoming years. This quality revolution
relies on a collective quality strategy to ensure quality is a top priority in
manufacturing. Furthermore, it aims to increase consumer and supplier
chain accountability for quality across the business [43,44].
5. Major elements associated with Quality 4.0 in manufacturing
domain
The most important elements associated with the execution of Quality
4.0 philosophy throughout manufacturing are; integration of systems,
computer-aided design & manufacturing, the utility of manufacturing
robots, computer vision, data requisition setups, etc. Fig. 2 exemplifies
the numerous aspects accompanying the implementation of the Quality
4.0 ethos in the manufacturing culture. These aspects also offer steeper
progress in the overall manufacturing sphere in a quick & productive way
[45,46]. Furthermore, the notions like man-machine interface, smart
machinery for production, optimised solutions, overall digitalisation,
pr
ecised measurements practices, etc., also rope the efficacious enact-
ment of quality 4.0 principles in manufacturing domains.
Quality 4.0 aims to guarantee the excellent quality of industries. It
impacts all divisions within the company and spreads to and from the
supply chain. Quality 4.0, a response to the current scenario in the
manufacturing industry, is driven by innovations that offer a new
perception of quality. In production-level processes, efficiency is
improved by new technologies. Cloud computing, big data, augmented
reality, blockchain, AI, machine learning, cyber-physical networks, the
Internet of Things, and more are the most important technologies to
enhance quality 4.0. The outcome is a new, holistic quality control
approach that enables the manufacturing sectors.
Fig. 2. Aspects of quality 4.0 in manufacturing environment.
4
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
A Quality 4.0 approach confirms the fundamental source of quality,
and by using this method, the consistency of new goods and procedures is
assured, and even quality problems can be seen to alleviate the root
cause. Therefore, quality must be at the forefront of product design
through development and beyond, particularly in advanced technology.
Quality 4.0 offers a formal approach in and phase of the production
process for the infusion of quality. In addition, it leads to a pragmatic
approach to product risk reduction [47–49].
Adopters will enhance their strategic advantage by optimising data
for risk control, quality assurance, and compliance. Companies must
follow an organised quality control strategy in order to meet the criteria
of Quality 4.0. The quality management system is supplemented by
cloud-based systems that allow industries to access required data
whenever it is necessary. Cloud-based applications evolve smoothly with
organisation and empower to add new processes, personnel and locations
to the system. Furthermore, the manufacturer can view data from any
platform and worldwide from cloud systems. An automated corrections
mechanism will handle corrections and controls throughout the company
to reduce risk and minimise confirmed root causes. In the packaging
sector, there are many typical applications for these technologies. For
example, manual checks are required for most orders and shipments in
completion centres and warehouses [50–52].
6. Quality 4.0 to enhance business
Data were often the main catalyst for change in the efficiency sphere
to improve quality. However, the data gathering, interpretation, and
decision-making phase are delayed for most businesses. Quality 4.0
technological advancements include advanced analytics, manufacturing,
and engineering, enabling organisations, such as internal engineering,
manufacturing efficiency, provisioning performance and customer sup-
port, to gain real-time control of essential quality measurements in a
business organisation. In addition, the fast, reliable gathering of data
from multiple sources is used to allow informed, agile decision-making,
an integral element of Quality 4.0 [53,54].
Current quality measurements on various ongoing factors and provide
insight about what has happened. In the existing descriptive/diagnostic/
predictive paradigm, the Quality 4.0 innovations include Big Data,
computer training and artificial intelligence. Machine learning and in-
sights into artificial intelligence allow prescriptive analysis to forecast
failure and notify the measures needed to improve the results. Quality 4.0
provides better relation between Information technologies (IT) and
operating technologies (OT). In context, IT applies to tools such as
company quality control schemes, business resource planning, and
product lifecycles management. OT is the equipment used in production,
laboratory and service settings. Relatively inexpensive sensors can link
people, goods, edge equipment, carrying out local analysis without
exceeding central OT systems and processes. Networking will allow input
to be collected in real-time to enhance the business process [55–57].
Quality 4.0 is often referred to as an automation revolution that in-
cludes improved productivity, better performance, and details. The
transition in Quality 4.0 is not limited only to factories, but it also
positively impacts the social and economic climate. This makes processes
contribute to industrialisation; to produce optimum performance, they
require profound testing and quality assurance. Therefore, the only way
to achieve the greatest advantages in Quality 4.0 is to use quality per-
formance solutions, including enhanced efficiency, increasing income
and decreased risk [58,59].
Manufacturers will leverage the strength of big data to conduct
quality controls to ensure their goods are produced with the highest
quality. The producers can considerably minimise the number of tests
necessary to ensure desired consistency by using data intelligence and
computational services. The data from production processes and the
available test data and outcomes can be evaluated, specifically the
automatic AI-driven testing. Machine learning allows manufacturers to
M. Javaid et al.
continuously forecast the finished products' consistency until the final
testing [60,61].
The development of a quality product essentially relies on a thorough
comprehension of quality from the consumer's perspective. Therefore,
the producer has to weigh up trade-offs and make the necessary sacrifices
in a sustainable setting to fulfil as many meanings as possible. Linking
particular process variables to these attributes can commence once these
desired quality attributes are fully established. Quality 4.0 allows greater
connections with sensors that connect humans, goods, and processes and
providing feedback: allowing systems and people to work together with
new technologies. In recent years, tech developments like social
networking and blockchain have changed cooperation, and companies
should seek to use the transformational capabilities of communication,
data and analytics [62–64].
Quality 4.0 are also inconsistent with procedures, best practices, skills
and lessons learned in the organisation without worldwide scope. In
addition to data, cloud computing is especially essential for scalability.
Businesses find quality technologies for entire centralised processes.
Integration of processes and systems will allow quality employees to
move their attention from quality-based output to creativity. Quality 4.0
offers many automated enforcement opportunities. Today, infrastructure
vendors offer highly configurable, integrated and wired systems and also
provide validation tools. Companies can analyse their internal enforce-
ment processes and policies in order to find means of making progress.
Quality 4.0 offers a community of excellence through increased
communication, visibility, insights, and cooperation. Thus, to tackle this
problem, quality equipment should re-align its goals to correlate directly
to strategic priorities. Quality leaders across the company, including the
executive level, should promote and lead quality to foster ownership and
incentive ownership [65–67].
7. Quality 4.0 for environment
In manufacturing environments, Quality 4.0 has a major role in
assisting atmospheric sensors in monitoring temperature, moisture, and
air quality. Plant operators can track and manage optimum conditions
from their control centre remotely for different factory-wide operations.
The preservation of an optimal differential air pressure avoids dust
intrusion during manufacturing and thereby ensures the consistency of
the substance in the industries. Glueing and painting can be enhanced
with the desired humidity level in automobile manufacturing. Likewise,
reliable temperature control in the food industry guarantees quality
protection in the packaging and storage facilities. IoT collects and doc-
umenting accurate information about current environmental situations
and how they are used by individuals, such as equipment, machinery,
and cars [68–70].
Quality 4.0 technologies help producers eliminate various manual
testing procedures and respond quickly to problems that could disrupt
the production line. These also tend to be highly complex, costly and
daunting, with data collection being an underlying obstacle in most
manufacturing environments. Cleaning, formatting, and reviewing large
volumes of data gathered during the process starts with predictive ana-
lytics. The data is then supplied with statistical algorithms and machine
learning to gain helpful insights. These insights enable producers to
discover helpful links between essential variables, identify data patterns,
spot inconsistencies, and forecast future results and trends. It will fix the
root causes of challenges before quality problems arise. Predictive quality
analytics can help producers detect adverse incidents and root causes that
can lower production quality, impacting goods, materials, and compo-
nents [71–73].
Manual quality inspections are expensive and sluggish in a high-
volume, automated process. However, because of the raised quality
criteria, the so-called sampling inspection, i.e., assessing the quality of a
whole production batch, is no longer a flexible solution that evaluates a
limited part of the production. Computer vision and profound learning
enter into the latest quality assurance system. These technologies allow
5
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
inspection automation reliable, precise inspection results for any product
on the line in any environmental conditions. Machine vision can be used
to provide accurate results. However, vision machine cameras are not
sufficient for production quality control. Unable to identify these product
faults equally. It can be an extremely complicated challenge to detect a
defect based on a picture. The Computer Vision Quality Management can
be used for teaching to routinely identify multiple forms of defects based
on images [74–77].
Deep learning means feeding and teaching thousands of photos and
the Machine Vision Quality Control system to understand what is good
and what is not good and consistently improve these outcomes. A step-
by-step series of instructions explaining how to execute a routine oper-
ation is written using a standard operating procedure (SOP). An SOP may
be used as a guide to healthy working practices to guide manual and
automatic activities. Staff should complete them, in the same manner
each time to ensure reliable operations. Wireless systems are a devel-
opment for range, strength and ease of integration in the controlled
environment. For instance, industrial applications can demand that
thousands of sensors send millions of messages a day. By digitising the
supply, the emerging technology has created the integral digitalisation of
all the processes in the manufacturing environment. Emerging in-
novations such as the Internet of Things, big data architecture, and AI-
based techniques such as Deep Machine Learning have encouraged dig-
ital business transition. Any part of the manufacturing chain is subject to
technical innovation, one of which is quality management. The conse-
quences for every Industry of this aspect of the value chain are essential
for the final results [78–80].
8. Significant Enablers of Quality 4.0 for enhancing
manufacturing scenario
Fig. 3 is exploring the plentiful enablers that support the quality 4.0
realisation in the manufacturing scenario significantly. The related key
enablers of Quality 4.0 for the manufacturing environment areas are; the
concept of blockchain, condition monitoring, cybersecurity facts,
attempting industrial robotics at the ground, product control and solution
enablers, practices like IoT and IIoT, etc. Furthermore, the enablers and
philosophies like energy efficiency, big data flow, optimised solutions,
pr
ecised measurements practices, overall digitalisation, etc., also chains
the efficacious representation of quality 4.0 moralities in manufacturing
spheres [81,82]. These enablers of the quality 4.0 concept propose
enhancing the manufacturing domain in a conceptualised, smooth,
effective, and automated manner.
Quality 4.0 automates error reduction, saves time, cost and energy.
For preventive maintenance plans, possible faults and system history,
Fig. 3. Enablers of quality 4.0 for broad domain of manufacturing.
M. Javaid et al.
maintenance teams save time and remove the conjecturing by using these
technologies. These digital technologies introduce innovation to
specialist workers, especially those responsible for quality. In order to
achieve greater flexibility and convergence, regular processes and sys-
tems have to be reconciled again and again. However, there are limita-
tions in considering quality criteria, particularly with the versatility of
self-organisation. This means that in the future, a fault detection and
root cause investigation would undoubtedly be made considerably more
difficult for each commodity produced to have its way in the
manufacturing process. Quality 4.0 technologies can easily fulfil this
challenge. In particular, the current conditions of quality 4.0 are pushing
more on creativity in the business model. The cornerstone of a sustain-
able business model today and in the future is near-real-time data to
create innovative offerings with a consistent consumer value profile.
Many organisations have vast quantities of data gathered and processed
[83–85].
In a smart plant, the new focus needs to be given to analysing
knowledge from core business processes such as construction,
manufacturing, sales and quality control. Only with the ongoing assess-
ment and all the processes would it be possible to intervene quickly,
customise functions and schedule early results to improve quality control
using Quality 4.0 technologies. Agility is important to start-up firms that
can return to competitive markets even in generally difficult circum-
stances. Preventive quality control has a specific role in producing
product quality requirements with the help of quality 4.0 technologies.
Real-time recording, by modern sensor and measurement technology, is
feasible in automation in production processes. Digital quality testing
offers an insight into the requirements of consumers. Besides, potential
product characteristics and the use of special parts in systems can be
checked in advance, which in turn offers design and production process
knowledge [86–88].
The stated objective of Quality 4.0 is the full networking of all supply
chains. Through robust coordination with those involved in the process,
the flow of information is ensured in the best possible way to produce,
guarantee efficiency, logistics and manage performance. The outcome
should be promising synergies. Emerging technology is a constantly
changing part of the transformation, and facts are being developed early.
It takes a team-based approach to create an improvement in development
processes. This digital revolution can be accomplished by incorporating
quality inspection that makes it more efficient. Good process discipline
must be employed in the quality assurance process. New innovations
have sparked a revival of the interest in output quality using Quality 4.0
technologies [89–91].
9. Quality 4.0 applications to enhance quality in manufacturing
The quality 4.0 approach provides an outstanding opportunity for the
manufacturing and business strategy to enhanced quality. This quality
revolution provides several producers and technical goals for better
quality and efficiency of products and the entire system. A successful
Quality 4.0 approach allows companies to resolve long-term barriers.
Quality 4.0 was used by those who have solved some obstacles with
enhanced data integrity and fresh and high-truth data-driven perspec-
tives. The aim to develop a Quality 4.0 approach serves as a technology
benchmark guide that acknowledges both the basic values of technology
and the application of technology to quality. Technologies of quality 4.0
are built on a firm base of conventional consistency. Most significant,
producers now using quality 4.0 technology are gaining real value,
higher quality, expense, performance, market share and brand awareness
[92–94]. The innovations allow new approaches and answers to prob-
lems in the consistency of conventional enterprise and value chain.
Quality 4.0 during the Fourth Industrial Revolution is the state of pro-
duction for quality practitioners. It uses real-time data, which provides
interconnected devices that push performance management programs for
quality practitioners. Significant applications of Quality 4.0 to enhance
quality in manufacturing are discussed in Table 1.
6
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
The latest technological developments and advances in today's world
are artificial intelligence, machine learning, robotics, deep learning,
mobile machines and self-driving vehicles. Data are the digital currencies
in the era of automation. Data allows companies to gain insight into
customer's requirements and desires, while quality assurance method-
ology encourages companies to obtain more loyalty and deliver a great
experience. The transformation led to a focus on software tests' signifi-
cance for the delivery of high-quality products. Quality 4.0 is distin-
guished from past technology developments in the quality aspect as
cyber-physical devices power it. Cyber-physical networks provide bene-
fits by linking and exchanging information between suppliers and ma-
chines [169–172]. These modifications turn the output from a
hierarchical structure. How quality practitioners address quality issues
will change this new agile world. Due to its departure from quality
monitoring and assurance, IoT is changing quality management as the
focus of the quality profession. Quality is the product's goodness and
customer service. Experts use several mechanisms to regulate quality
using quality 4.0 technologies. This provides methods of quality control
such as root cause analysis and statistical control of procedures. Quality
management programmes are also focusing on quality monitoring and
maintenance. In reality, this involves preserving a certain degree of
goodness and faults and concentrating on additional operation
[173–176]. Sensors and other digital technologies also play an important
role in maintaining quality in manufacturing [177–179].
9.1. Major discussion on the study
Most quality leaders have focused on the implementation of Quality
4.0. It is successfully implemented in business departments, R&D and
marketing, when quality professionals oversee systems, ensure compli-
ance, and adapt to regular Quality incidents. Quality leaders need to
collaborate and provide a digital revolution of quality in order to reach
quality 4.0 fully. The interconnection of the quality system with the In-
dustry would ensure the quality of technology in the company. An
increasingly digital and connected world in which machines and com-
puters can optimise processes through automation and self-optimisation.
The advantages also apply to forecasting, supply chain management, and
even product creation beyond the physical manufacturing of products. A
combination of production, data and communication technologies and
the integration potential throughout the entire manufacturing supply
chain can be used to structure a smart plant. Quality 4.0 technology
enables data collection, which is essential to the intelligent factory.
Where intelligent sensors, motors and robots in the manufacturing and
assembly lines are used.
Sensors enhance awareness of taking place on multiple levels by
monitoring special processes throughout the factory. Innovations evolve
in Quality 4.0 converges to make the intelligent farm. It implements
factory knowledge that provides a complex manufacturing environment
and the expected outcomes, cost reduction, efficiency and reliability
improvement. In the future, production has to be highly customised so
that factories can work while remaining stable and reduce downtime for
retooling and resetting machinery. Automation functions that are
repeatable, mundane, unsafe, or at present affected by labour shortages
will get more difficult.
Quality control is notable in the modern manufacturing concept
because of the integration of manufacturing processes and the centralised
supply chain management, with improved efficiency. This increases the
efficiency of the internal processes and ensures economic competition
and profitability. The smart factory is founded upon the exact principle
that machines and robotics in these modern factories are monitored by
both humans and artificial intelligence software, thereby ensuring that
the variables that make up the manufacturing process are more effec-
tively controlled. Big data and artificial intelligence are the technologies
behind the modern paradigm of quality control. They thus collect, pro-
cess, and analyse a great quantity of information. The setting-up of a
quality scheme in Quality 4.0 assures protection and very large cost
M. Javaid et al.
Table 1
Quality 4.0 Applications to enhance quality in manufacturing.
S Applications Description
No
1 Automates inspection These emerging quality innovations
processes are driving to enhance the quality in
manufacturing fields. The
technology used in this revolution
automates routine and inspection
processes. Quality 4.0 practitioners
concentrate on mitigation by
evaluating results with the help of
sensors and IoT platform. In the
automotive sector, Quality 4.0
drives a revolution to maintain the
quality of products. The data quality
and integrated data exchange
networks would significantly impact
quality control, ranging from rising
speed and reducing quality costs to
changing driving skills. Quality
practitioners must learn and support
this growth and integrate it into
their workflows to remain
competitive.
2 Reduces cost of quality The majority of operations depend
on quality management, which
leads to higher quality overall costs.
Quality 4.0 reduces the cost of
quality of products during
manufacturing. The inadequate data
makes the qualified professionals do
research and provide a complete
image of their production to
maintain quality. This allows them
to change their methods more
quickly and relies on the precision of
the data in quality analyses. Quality
experts are currently required to
conduct further audits,
examinations, evaluations, and
other operations. This control is
incorporated into the system by new
quality 4.0 technology, making
certain operations less repetitive.
3 Quality control Quality 4.0 is the adaptation of the
emerging technology of
manufacturing for quality control,
resulting in improved operating
productivity, enhanced business
results and business models. Its
many advantages include managing
the operation in real-time, data
collection, and predictive
maintenance backed by analysis.
Digital technology can make a
difference in inconsistency, such as
that systems can be monitoring and
data from real-time sensors can be
extracted. The vast data from
various sensors can be evaluated to
forecast the organisation's quality
concerns and repair requirements to
minimise errors.
4 Research and For quality 4.0 progress,
development organisations should follow a multi-
faceted approach and problems
directly. Quality 4.0, starting from
research and development to
customer support, sale service,
would play an enormous part in the
entire value chain of an
organisation. Besides, in the R&D
process, the time and cost of product
creation can be minimised by
Quality 4.0 software. For after-sales
services, mobile digital solutions
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
Table 1 (continued )
S Applications Description References
References No
such as field service apps may be
[95–99] used by field engineers to improve
preventative efficiency and improve
customer experience. Quality 4.0 is
a priority on the management
agenda and an important part of the
organisational strategy. Quality 4.0
demands a creativity and learning
style in leadership.
5 Increase in organisation Quality 4.0 aligns best business [111–114]
effectiveness practices with the digital world
effectively. Companies that invest in
quality 4.0 would considerably
increase organisational and service
effectiveness, customer loyalty, and
corporate culture. Quality 4.0 is
about people using the technologies
and their methods. It will perform a
global Quality 4.0 survey to
recognise the problems associated
with quality 4.0 tools. The
application of quality 4.0 establishes
[100–104] a self-assessment method to
improve manufacturing and service
quality in industries.
6 Increase performance of The move to real-time data access [115–118]
the product and digital and physical technology
convergence also made businesses
more sensitive, proactive, and
profitable. The several innovations
behind Quality 4.0 are among other
applications in the Cloud, Artificial
Intelligence, Machine Learning, and
other innovative technologies.
Quality 4.0 is the most important
tool for businesses to use modern
digital technologies to increase their
operating performance and quality
of products. This makes everything
easy and simpler; the best quality
4.0 innovations ease and accelerate
manufacturing quality from any
[104–106] platform without losing compliance
and safety.
7 Business culture and For business culture and [119–121]
partnership partnership, quality 4.0 is also very
relevant. New technologies allow
businesses to communicate with
their vendors and consumers at a
more direct and intimate level.
Modern companies need to
collaborate closely and interact
freely with their suppliers.
Companies may create deeper links
through technology, contributing to
higher service and reduced risk
through real-time coordination,
customer experience and simplified
reporting.
8 Streamlines all quality The various app will help companies [122–126]
process streamline and synthesise quality
[107–110] processes in order to improve
enforcement and performance.
Quality 4.0 will use emerging
technology and practices such as
blockchain to obtain insight into
factors such as consumer loyalty and
increased awareness of the flow of
components and goods across
supply chains. Apps are constantly a
part of daily life for people and
companies in an environment of
smartphones, laptops, and
wearables to take advantage of
trends. Quality 4.0 offers a
(continued on next page)
7
M. Javaid et al.
Table 1 (continued )
S Applications Description
No
significant opportunity for
advanced applications that use
mixed reality and virtual reality to
improve the system's quality.
9 Re-align quality Quality 4.0 is an incentive to re-
functions align quality functions with wider
organisational strategies using
technological innovations.
Departments will overcome long-
standing quality problems by
implementing an appropriate
Quality 4.0 policy. In various
organisations, these arise in cross-
functional ownership, inadequate
coordination and conventional
fractured quality processes. This
quality revolution is transforming
dramatically in technology,
processing and production. The
concept Quality 4.0 covers all the
fast-moving innovations,
procedures, and activities
transforming manufacturing into a
better environment. It seeks to
identify those specific technologies,
procedures, and practices that allow
producers to create, manage and
maintain quality standards across
their supply chains.
10 Reshape production Quality 4.0 is the reshaping of
procedures device architectures, operating
features, production procedures,
policy for the supply chain,
customer support and quality
services compatible with regulatory
agencies. Intelligent and linked
systems are increasingly used as
marketers pursue the benefit of
marketing inventive goods and take
over traditional rivals. In addition,
digital innovation movements have
continued to identify plans for
quality 4.0 to eliminate dependency
on various quality control
frameworks and processes.
11 Productions of new The use of Quality 4.0 technologies
products will help provide high-quality and
secure equipment in all phases of
the new product production and
new introduction processes.
However, producers will be able to
find quality 4.0 for prototypes and
quality systems. It focused on a
modern, higher quality level guided
by leadership and accepted by all
sectors for the product development
chain. In addition, businesses can
achieve strategic benefits by
providing more product and quality
knowledge. This, in turn, would lead
to improved data-driven decisions
for quality, infrastructure, logistics
and supply chains departments and
cross-functional visibility for new
products. The transformation
technologies of quality 4.0 add
sophistication to the product,
making it more difficult to fulfil
stringent specifications for medical
devices.
12 Control operations Faster and smarter managing
processes and compliance with
regulatory authorities is needed
from manufacturers. Quality 4.0
allows enterprise structure to
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
Table 1 (continued )
References S Applications Description References
No
control operations within the
organisation and to develop
processes continuously. It combines
cooperation and continuity
[127–130] mechanisms across the supply
chain. The company automates
systems that conform to Quality 4.0
to keep producers of the fast-moving
Quality Transition. Quality 4.0
becomes a unitary strategy in this
respect to building a quality culture
that underlines continuous learning.
This helps quality and regulatory
departments target unparalleled
areas, improving the standard of our
products' quality and standard. As a
result, the goods, processes and
systems can develop and stay
important on the market today in
controlled manners.
13 Continuously Quality 4.0 can continuously [146–148]
monitoring monitor and regulate several
systems and process parameters
affecting product quality, depending
on effective quality management.
Thus, wired communications are
suitable for high-performance and
time-sensitive automation activities.
However, quality 4.0 adds
[131–134] considerable product uncertainty
and related costs, in addition to
costly human interference, thus
making it impossible to track the
root cause of quality problems.
14 Automatically alerts A variety of essential granular data [149–152]
during the wanted points can be found along the
condition production line via wireless IoT
networks. All sensors' data for real-
time surveillance, operative
observations and process
automation is consolidated through
a remote IoT network. This can
easily handle any unwanted
conditions between operational
equipment and systems by which
[135–139] alerts can be activated
automatically. This allows
producers to manage processes and
product results in efficient ways.
Beyond reactive, end-of-life quality
inspection, IoT data allows
constructive quality assurance to
detect and avoid peak output and
duplication defects much earlier in
the phase and repeat.
15 Operating Quality technologies collect and [153–155]
measurements transmit essential measurements,
such as pressures, friction,
temperatures, moisture and voltage,
of several machinery and appliance
in the whole sector. These massive
data flows from power analytic
methods to proactively predict an
imminent problem and plan
demand-based inspections and
repairs. The operators will quickly
identify underserved machinery,
detect imminent problems and
bottlenecks. The mobilise
instruments and components by
[140–145] providing a full, real-time image of
the cross-site properties. IoT
technology for proper management
allows organisations to connect all
manufacturing devices. Quality 4.0
(continued on next page)
8
M. Javaid et al.
Table 1 (continued )
S Applications Description
No
technologies alerts are released on
possible damage and catastrophe
leakage.
16 Detect defects Quality 4.0 technologies can also
detect defects, contributing to
cleaner emissions, before the
product is placed on the target
market. The quality management of
the automotive industry is all about
the right work tools. These
technologies will rely a little on the
actual product made, but there are
some key tools that any car facility
may use to boost its quality
management plan. These advanced
technologies include an analysis of
failure mode, process management
and an analysis of the measuring
method. An analysis of failure mode
enables the manufacturing process
to be analysed and future failure
points to be predicted. Once these
failure points have been identified,
It can be implemented to eliminate
them during development.
17 Proper operations of Quality 4.0 in manufacturing
finished goods processes relies on the inspection
and proper operation of finished
goods. Similarly, monitoring safety
procedures in connection with
regulatory compliance is equally
important to avoiding work harm.
Quality control is not only related to
components or equipment but also
suppliers and other individuals. By
deploying this quality revolution,
defects and accidents can be
reported during the manufacturing
process by performing proper
operations of finished goods.
Machine learning provides
computational solutions to process
improvement, anomalies analysis,
product consistency, and security
protocol issues that conventional
approaches cannot solve.
18 Quality Assurance Quality 4.0 technologies have great
capability to maintain quality in all
stages. Companies obtain quality
assurance in real-time by Quality
4.0. There is continuity in the
process as detailed documentation is
accessible at each point. Quality
assurance must be done in real-time
so that the procedures are not
necessary. Processes for quality
management offer a focused forum
for handling quality-related
practises such as analytics,
cooperation and enforcement.
Quality 4.0 is an ideal way to
enhance organisational procedures,
productivity and efficacy.
savings by evaluating today's most dynamic scenario. Errors that
contribute to a lower product output repeatedly arise during the manual
assembly and automatic manufacturing phases. Manual visual checks are
expensive, and mistakes are hardly reported properly.
With rising safety standards, environmental regulations and customer
demands for customisation, quality control is growing in importance.
New technologies enable a considerable increase in product quality,
sometimes with the use of surprisingly few resources. Quality 4.0 is the
digitisation of quality, regulatory and control processes in simple and
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
comprehensible language. The concept is not unique for technology
References alone but also means technology cooperation, society, leadership and
skills. Companies continue to search for ways to integrate data from
different processes to ensure consistency and accountability. Companies
establish a research strategy after or in combination with the data
strategy positively with the help of Quality 4.0 technologies.
[156–158] Quality 4.0 is a new way for quality practitioners to handle quality
and learn how they use and achieve excellence through quality using
today's digital resources. Quality professionals will lift their position from
the enforcer to the navigator to lead companies effectively through dig-
ital interruption and excellence. The need for perfect systems remains the
same, as more practice is automated. Current processes are fragmented,
and it is important for qualitative and company activities that the next
employee generation is trained to introduce new processes and strate-
gies. Quality practitioners need to transition from roles as data analysts to
roles for data wranglers through emerging technology, the awareness of
these technological advances.
With more knowledge, there is equipment produce at higher rates
than ever before. Innovation in these fields is catalysed by falling costs of
supporting technology such as sensors and actuators. The improved ar-
chitecture of the network expands the connectivity to become more
widespread and stable. This approach encourages manufacturers to use
intelligent technologies like the Internet of Things and robots to help
them hold the technology curve ahead. These approaches are paired with
[159–163] conventional quality processes to promote technical evolution and make
quality a core factor. It aims to streamline manufacturer’ regulations.
Quality 4.0 brings to the processed output a different level of techno-
logical resources. It ensures that all manufacturing practices and product
quality levels will be improved by quality 4.0. Industries embraced
Quality 4.0 in order to produce efficient results. However, several de-
partments with consistency can take part in technology-related business
strategy. Quality 4.0 is an ideal way to re-align the organisational
approach. Many companies have strategic goals related to big data,
which has cases for improving quality use.
The quality 4.0 approach helps businesses to tackle long-standing
challenges. Various sectors face constant quality problems in the
absence of quality choices guided by evidence and society of low quality.
For decades, many industries have faced the same ongoing qualitative
problems linked to weak culture, lack of data-driven quality judgments,
and inadequate cross-functional access to quality. By embracing Quality
4.0, organisations conquer several challenges with new data-driven
[164–168] truthfulness insight and increased openness. Quality leads to happier
clients, leading to market separation, and more retention and higher
earnings. It also contributes to the reduction of waste by quality
processes.
Quality 4.0 provides a whole management structure based on rising
customer loyalty and reducing costs continuously. It uses scientific
techniques for consistency measurement, related costs and improve-
ments. The standard of production is compliant with standards at its most
fundamental level. Quality design and conformity with requirements
provide the basic framework for the management of quality product
manufacturing activities. Customers' demands have grown over time,
production quality, anywhere the goods are made, packaged and mar-
keted, has become necessary. Quality 4.0 involves the architecture and
engineering of quality, quality monitoring and quality management.
Quality 4.0 introduces quality into the design of goods and processes
and anticipates future quality concerns before product development and
distribution. The main role of quality monitoring includes applying
prescribed procedures and products, maintaining operator and equip-
ment. Quality 4.0 includes all quality assurance practises, planning, co-
ordination, course and regulation. This provides technological assistance
for output quality traditionally; manufacturers have recognised the need
to incorporate quality across the complete business. The easiest way to
achieve quality is to minimise complications and errors, easily taken over
by quality 4.0 technologies. The operators can immediately be enforced
in manufacturing quality systems. Quality 4.0 technologies ensure that
9
M. Javaid et al.
the research procedures and products are carried out and that the results
conform with the requirements. Any difference in the results should be
assessed in the standard manufacturing framework.
The information about product quality is accessible most quickly,
providing clarity and reporting to the materials involved and avoiding
them being manufactured. Digital technologies provide awareness of
production patterns and quality management challenges in real-time. It
enables producers to take rapid action on problems and fully monitor
quality in all production processes. As a result, production efficiency is
constantly improved in the manufacturing sector using Quality 4.0. In the
whole purchasing, ownership and service interactions of a commodity,
value, satisfaction and desire are determined by several factors. There-
fore, the production standard must be responsive to current and changing
consumer and business requirements; it considers various factors that
contribute to customer satisfaction. Quality 4.0 must therefore take into
account technical progress and how it can affect and serve the end con-
sumers and the manufacturer itself.
Proper reporting is vital to ensure conformity such that accurate
monitoring of documents is critical, irrespective of the sector. All regu-
latory documentation specifications can be met effectively by a quality
control system by implementing this quality revolution. In addition, an
electronic record processing framework provides the whole document
lifecycle with traceability and monitoring. Furthermore, company laws
govern access to records and automate inspection and acceptance cycles
for electronic systems. Data and analytics are one of the significant
drivers of Quality 4.0. The authenticity and availability of reporting data
are used for internal and external investigations so to show the follow-up
of all good manufacturing standards.
10. Future of Quality 4.0
In the future, Quality 4.0 will progress towards improving employees'
baseline skills and better the skills scale-up. Technology such as social
media, machine learning, Artificial Intelligence, mashup software,
wearables, and Virtual reality should be exploited to facilitate training
and capacity building. In Smart factories, Cyber-Physical Systems will
allow contact between people and machines across major networks,
usually via the Internet of Things. They will be responsible for physical
structures, virtual representations and decentralised decision-making.
Many companies for satisfying quality 4.0, need a platform upgrade
within their supply chain and quality control activities to turn an en-
terprise into a smart factory. Investment in technologies will include
upgrading current equipment, sensor deployment, Artificial Intelligence,
Machine Learning, and company-level systems for solution growth.
In the future, Quality 4.0 will greatly expand the internal and external
IoT data and then turn them into valuable information. A cultural shift
will be required for Quality 4.0 initiatives to be successful, demanding
additional investments in people and change management. It will be
essential that employees throughout the organisation, including the
Quality team, participate in change and train them in the new paradigm
of Quality 4.0. The new business philosophy and culture vision must be
demonstrated and executed on a single basis by corporate leadership. The
participation of quality 4.0 will provides more advantages in the future.
This revolution will embrace the future of quality to achieve perfection. It
will enhance quality standards to support their organisations by using
quality standards and allowing the critical correlation between quality
excellence and their capacity to succeed in disruption.
11. Conclusion
Quality 4.0 is important for the management of all manufacturing
industries. It is essential to characterise the end-products, volatile con-
sumer demand, high materials and manufacturing costs to achieve effi-
ciency and reduce the rejection rate. By increasingly approaching the
manufacturing stage of the Internet of Things, quality control is seen as a
transformational field. The ability to continuously monitored and
10
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
regulate several systems and process parameters affecting product qual-
ity depends on effective quality management using Quality 4.0 technol-
ogies. Technologies used in this revolution are crucial to promote a
culture in which all workers have responsibility for quality and trans-
parency. Thus, to understand the effect of diverse cultures and types of
management on the effective adoption of Quality 4.0, analysis is needed
with various organisations of different dimensions and designs. With the
recent development of cost-efficient sensors, enhanced data acquisition
systems, and fast communication systems in cyber–Physical Systems,
quality control systems have become quite effective. Big data would
allow for a comprehensive and integrated view of consumer demands to
enhanced the quality of the entire manufacturing system. The striking
aspects of quality 4.0 are to maintain the quality of the product life cycle.
The level of service can also be successfully tracked using artificial in-
telligence by gathering and testing the product consumption. In the
future, transparent and visible support for top-level management facili-
tates optimistic consumer perceptions towards Quality 4.0.
Declaration of competing interest
None.
References
[1] A. Zonnenshain, R.S. Kenett, Quality 4.0—the challenging future of quality
engineering, Qual. Eng. 32 (4) (2020) 614–626.
[2] Q. Aini, B.S. Riza, N.P.L. Santoso, A. Faturahman, U. Rahardja, Digitalization of
smart student assessment quality in era 4.0, Int. J. 9 (1.2) (2020).
[3] S.V. Novikov, A.A. Sazonov, Production's digital transformation analysis using
Industry 4.0 technologies, Amazon. Invest. 9 (27) (2020) 234–243.
[4] T. Jordan, Connected, intelligent, automated: the definitive guide to digital
transformation and quality 4.0, Qual. Prog. 53 (8) (2020) 62-62.
[5] G. Narayanamurthy, G. Tortorella, Impact of COVID-19 outbreak on employee
performance–Moderating role of industry 4.0 base technologies, Int. J. Prod. Econ.
234 (2021) 108075.
[6] T. Salimova, N. Vatolkina, V. Makolov, N. Anikina, The perspective of quality
management system development in the era of industry 4.0, Perspective 12 (3s)
(2020) 2334–2356.
[7] A.G. Frank, G.H. Mendes, N.F. Ayala, A. Ghezzi, Servitization and Industry 4.0
convergence in the digital transformation of product firms: a business model
innovation perspective, Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 141 (2019) 341–351.
[8] A.V. Carvalho, D.V. Enrique, A. Chouchene, F. Charrua-Santos, Quality 4.0: an
overview, Procedia Computer Science 181 (2021) 341–346.
[9] S. Arsovski, Social oriented quality: from quality 4.0 towards quailty 5.0, in: 13th
International Quality Conference 13, 2019, p. 397.
[10] A. Chiarini, Industry 4.0, quality management and TQM world. A systematic
literature review and a proposed agenda for further research, The TQM Journal
(2020).
[11] L. Fonseca, A. Amaral, J. Oliveira, Quality 4.0: the EFQM 2020 model and industry
4.0 relationships and implications, Sustainability 13 (6) (2021) 3107.
[12] M. Sony, J. Antony, J.A. Douglas, Motivations, barriers and readiness factors for
Quality 4.0 implementation: an exploratory study, The TQM Journal (2021).
[13] M. Javaid, A. Haleem, R. Vaishya, S. Bahl, R. Suman, A. Vaish, Industry 4.0
technologies and their applications in fighting COVID-19 pandemic, Diabetes &
Metabolic Syndrome: Clin. Res. Rev. 14 (4) (2020) 419–422.
[14] J. Nenad
al, The new EFQM model: what is really new and could Be considered as a
suitable tool with respect to quality 4.0 concept? Quality Innovation Prosperity 24
(1) (2020) 17–28.
[15] A. Çalık, A novel Pythagorean fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS methodology for green
supplier selection in the Industry 4.0 era, Soft Computing 25 (3) (2021)
2253–2265.
[16] D. Yurin, A. Deniskina, B. Boytsov, M. Karpovich, Quality 4.0. Time of
revolutionary changes in the QMS, in: E3S Web of Conferences, 244, EDP
Sciences, 2021, p. 11010.
[17] R. Kubat, Quality 4.0: the internet of things is only half the solution, Quality 57 (4)
(2018) 42–45.
[18] S. Finn, The missing link in quality 4.0: building the business case for executive
buy-in and company engagement, Quality 58 (13) (2019) 37–39.
[19] E. Bryndin, Directions of development of industry 4.0, digital technology and
social economy, American Journal of Information Science and Technology 2 (1)
(2018) 9–17.
[20] Y. Quan, S. Park, Review on the application of industry 4.0 digital twin technology
to the quality management, Journal of the Korean Society for Quality
Management 45 (4) (2017) 601–610.
[21] M. Gadre, A. Deoskar, Industry 4.0–digital transformation, challenges and
benefits, International Journal of Future Generation Communication and
Networking 13 (2) (2020) 139–149.
M. Javaid et al.
 Turk, Construction 4.0-digital transformation of one of the oldest
[22] R. Klinc, Z.
industries, Economic and Business Review for Central and South-Eastern Europe
21 (3) (2019) 393–496.
[23] M. Wang, C.C. Wang, S. Sepasgozar, S. Zlatanova, A systematic review of digital
technology adoption in off-site construction: current status and future direction
towards industry 4.0, Buildings 10 (11) (2020) 204.
[24] Hancke, E., Vannucci, M., Colla, V., Cateni, S., Sellami, R., Dupont, S., .. & Arteaga,
A. Quality 4.0-Transparent Product Quality Supervision in the Age of Industry 4.0.
Impact And Opportunities Of Artificial Intelligence Techniques In the Steel Industry:
Ongoing Applications, Perspectives And Future Trends, 54.
[25] A. Pagoropoulos, D.C. Pigosso, T.C. McAloone, The emergent role of digital
technologies in the Circular Economy: a review, Procedia CIRP 64 (2017) 19–24.
[26] G. Bressanelli, F. Adrodegari, M. Perona, N. Saccani, Exploring how usage-focused
business models enable circular economy through digital technologies,
Sustainability 10 (3) (2018) 639.
[27] R. Milward, G.H. Popescu, K.F. Michalikova, Z. Musova, V. Machova, Sensing,
smart, and sustainable technologies in Industry 4.0: cyber-physical networks,
machine data capturing systems, and digitized mass production, Econ. Manag.
Financ. Mark. 14 (3) (2019) 37–43.
[28] G. Tortorella, R. Miorando, R. Caiado, D. Nascimento, A. Portioli Staudacher, The
mediating effect of employees' involvement on the relationship between Industry
4.0 and operational performance improvement, Total Qual. Manag. Bus. Excel. 32
(1–2) (2021) 119–133.
[29] M. Javaid, A. Haleem, Industry 4.0 applications in medical field: a brief review,
Current Medicine Research and Practice 9 (3) (2019) 102–109.
[30] L.M. Fonseca, Industry 4.0 and the digital society: concepts, dimensions and
envisioned benefits, Proceedings of the international conference on business
excellence 12 (1) (2018) 386–397 (Sciendo).
[31] M. Shayganmehr, A. Kumar, J.A. Garza-Reyes, M.A. Moktadir, Industry 4.0
enablers for a cleaner production and circular economy within the context of
business ethics: a study in a developing country, J. Clean. Prod. 281 (2021)
125280.
[32] N. Vel
asquez, E. Estevez, P. Pesado, Methodological Framework Based on Digital
Technologies for the Implementation of Industry 4.0 in SMEs. 2019 Sixth
International Conference on eDemocracy & eGovernment (ICEDEG), 2019, April,
pp. 371–374 (IEEE).
[33] H. Oliff, Y. Liu, Towards industry 4.0 utilizing data-mining techniques: a case
study on quality improvement, Procedia CIRP 63 (2017) 167–172.
[34] T. Kliestik, E. Nica, H. Musa, M. Poliak, E.A. Mihai, Networked, smart, and
responsive devices in industry 4.0 manufacturing systems, Econ. Manag. Financ.
Mark. 15 (3) (2020) 23–29.
[35] Z. Z
avadsk
a, J. Z

avadský, Quality managers and their future technological
expectations related to Industry 4.0, Total Qual. Manag. Bus. Excel. 31 (7–8)
(2020) 717–741.
[36] M. Massaro, S. Secinaro, F. Dal Mas, V. Brescia, D. Calandra, Industry 4.0 and
circular economy: an exploratory analysis of academic and practitioners'
perspectives, Bus. Strat. Environ. 30 (2) (2021) 1213–1231.
[37] D. Prestiadi, W. Zulkarnain, R.B. Sumarsono, Visionary leadership in total quality
management: efforts to improve the quality of education in the industrial
revolution 4.0, in: The 4th International Conference on Education and
Management (COEMA 2019), Atlantis Press, 2019, December, pp. 202–206.
[38] A. De Carolis, M. Macchi, E. Negri, S. Terzi, A maturity model for assessing the
digital readiness of manufacturing companies, in: IFIP International Conference on
Advances in Production Management Systems, Springer, Cham, 2017, September,
pp. 13–20.
[39] A. Haleem, M. Javaid, Additive manufacturing applications in industry 4.0: a
review, Journal of Industrial Integration and Management 4 (4) (2019) 1930001.
[40] G. Rathee, M. Balasaraswathi, K.P. Chandran, S.D. Gupta, C.S. Boopathi, A secure
IoT sensors communication in industry 4.0 using blockchain technology, Journal
of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 12 (1) (2021) 533–545.
[41] F.L. da Silva, G.D.C. Barriga, July). “Industry 4.0” digital strategy, and the
challenges for adoption the technologies led by cyber-physical systems, in:
International Joint Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations
Management, Springer, Cham, 2019, pp. 463–472.
[42] G.L. Tortorella, F.S. Fogliatto, K.F. Esp^
osto, A.M.C. Vergara, R. Vassolo,
D.T. Mendoza, G. Narayanamurthy, Effects of contingencies on healthcare 4.0
technologies adoption and barriers in emerging economies, Technol. Forecast.
Soc. Change 156 (2020) 120048.
[43] H. Gupta, A. Kumar, P. Wasan, Industry 4.0, Cleaner Production and Circular
Economy: an integrative framework for evaluating ethical and sustainable
business performance of manufacturing organizations, J. Clean. Prod. 295 (2021)
126253.
[44] D. Plumpton, Cyber-physical systems, internet of things, and big data in industry
4.0: digital ManufacturingTechnologies, business process optimization, and
sustainable organizational performance, Econ. Manag. Financ. Mark. 14 (3)
(2019) 23–29.
[45] L.S. Dalenogare, G.B. Benitez, N.F. Ayala, A.G. Frank, The expected contribution of
Industry 4.0 technologies for industrial performance, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 204
(2018) 383–394.
[46] R. Drozd, R. Wolniak, Metrisable Assessment of the Course of Stream-Systemic
Processes in Vector Form in Industry 4.0, Quality & Quantity, 2021, pp. 1–16.
[47] H. Ahuett-Garza, T. Kurfess, A brief discussion on the trends of habilitating
technologies for Industry 4.0 and Smart manufacturing, Manufacturing Letters 15
(2018) 60–63.
11
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
[48] J. Ratnasingam, Y.Y. Lee, A.A.A. Azim, R. Halis, L.C. Liat, A. Khoo,
M.N.Z.M. Amin, Assessing the awareness and readiness of the Malaysian furniture
industry for Industry 4.0, Bioresources 15 (3) (2020) 4866–4885.
[49] M. Ammar, A. Haleem, M. Javaid, R. Walia, S. Bahl, Improving material quality
management and manufacturing organizations system through Industry 4.0
technologies, Mater. Today: Proceedings (2021).
[50] M. van Geest, B. Tekinerdogan, C. Catal, Design of a reference architecture for
developing smart warehouses in industry 4.0, Comput. Ind. 124 (2021) 103343.
[51] F. von Briel, P. Davidsson, J. Recker, Digital technologies as external enablers of
new venture creation in the IT hardware sector, Enterpren. Theor. Pract. 42 (1)
(2018) 47–69.
[52] S. Johnson, Quality 4.0: a trend within a trend, Quality 58 (2) (2019) 21–23.
[53] N. Yadav, R. Shankar, S.P. Singh, Critical Success Factors for Lean Six Sigma in
Quality 4.0. International Journal of Quality and Service Sciences, 2021.
[54] M. Glogovac, J. Ruso, M. Maricic, ISO 9004 Maturity Model for Quality in Industry
4.0. Total Quality Management & Business Excellence, 2020, pp. 1–19.
[55] Y. Li, J. Dai, L. Cui, The impact of digital technologies on economic and
environmental performance in the context of industry 4.0: a moderated mediation
model, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 229 (2020) 107777.
[56] A.D. Neal, R.G. Sharpe, K. van Lopik, J. Tribe, P. Goodall, H. Lugo, A.A. West, The
potential of industry 4.0 Cyber Physical System to improve quality assurance: an
automotive case study for wash monitoring of returnable transit items, CIRP
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology 32 (2021) 461–475.
[57] J. Ramezani, J. Jassbi, Quality 4.0 in action: smart hybrid fault diagnosis system in
plaster production, Processes 8 (6) (2020) 634.
[58] A.V. Gurjanov, D.A. Zakoldaev, A.V. Shukalov, I.O. Zharinov, Organization of
project works in Industry 4.0 digital item designing companies, J. Phys. Conf.
1015 (5) (2018, May) 52034 (IOP Publishing).
[59] X.F. Shao, W. Liu, Y. Li, H.R. Chaudhry, X.G. Yue, Multistage implementation
framework for smart supply chain management under industry 4.0, Technol.
Forecast. Soc. Change 162 (2021) 120354.
[60] A. Rainnie, M. Dean, Industry 4.0 and the future of quality work in the global
digital economy, Lab. Ind.: a journal of the social and economic relations of work
30 (1) (2020) 16–33.
[61] M. Nú~ nez-Merino, J.M. Maqueira-Marín, J. Moyano-Fuentes, P.J. Martínez-
Jurado, Information and digital technologies of Industry 4.0 and Lean supply
chain management: a systematic literature review, Int. J. Prod. Res. 58 (16)
(2020) 5034–5061.
[62] E.O.B. Nara, M.B. da Costa, I.C. Baierle, J.L. Schaefer, G.B. Benitez, L.M.A.L. do
Santos, L.B. Benitez, Expected impact of industry 4.0 technologies on sustainable
development: a study in the context of Brazil's plastic industry, Sustainable
Production and Consumption 25 (2021) 102–122.
[63] S.M. Lee, D. Lee, Y.S. Kim, The quality management ecosystem for predictive
maintenance in the Industry 4.0 era, Int. J. Qual. Innovat. 5 (1) (2019) 1–11.
[64] S. Reedy, A pulse on quality 4.0 for medical device manufacturing, Quality 58 (13)
(2019) 34–36.
[65] C.G. Armani, K.F. de Oliveira, I.P. Munhoz, A.C.S. Akkari, Proposal and
application of a framework to measure the degree of maturity in Quality 4.0: a
multiple case study, in: Advances in Mathematics for Industry, 4.0, Academic
Press, 2021, pp. 131–163.
[66] Q. Iqbal, R. Nawaz, Rife information pollution (infollution) and virtual
organizations in industry 4.0: within reality causes and consequences, in: Research
Anthology on Digital Transformation, Organizational Change, and the Impact of
Remote Work, 2021, pp. 1578–1592 (IGI Global).
[67] A. Süt}oov
a, L.  s, F. K

 Soo oca, Learning needs determination for industry 4.0
maturity development in automotive organisations in Slovakia, Quality Innovation
Prosperity 24 (3) (2020) 122–139.
[68] N. Medi
c, Z. Anisi
c, B. Lali
c, U. Marjanovi
c, M. Brezocnik, Hybrid fuzzy multi-
attribute decision making model for evaluation of advanced digital technologies in
manufacturing: industry 4.0 perspective, Advances in Production Engineering &
Management 14 (4) (2019).
[69] G.H. Watson, Constant evolution towards quality 4.0, Qual. Prog. 53 (8) (2020)
32–37.
[70] K. Schwertner, P. Zlateva, D. Velev, June). Digital technologies of industry 4.0
inmanagement of natural disasters, in: Proceedings of the 2nd International
Conference on E-Commerce, E-Business and E-Government, 2018, pp. 95–99.
[71] G. Fedorko, V. Moln
ar, M. Vasil, R. Salai, Proposal of digital twin for testing and
measuring of transport belts for pipe conveyors within the concept Industry 4.0,
Measurement 174 (2021) 108978.
[72] C. Kirschner, C. Hell, T. Schüler, K.D. Starosta, March). Digital technologies
(industry 4.0) drive the disruptive innovations in crafts enterprises, in:
International Conference on Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Academic
Conferences International Limited, 2018, pp. 482–XIV.
[73] M. Fromhold-Eisebith, P. Marschall, R. Peters, P. Thomes, Torn between digitized
future and context dependent past–How implementing ‘Industry 4.0’production
technologies could transform the German textile industry, Technol. Forecast. Soc.
Change 166 (2021) 120620.
[74] F. Ludbrook, K.F. Michalikova, Z. Musova, P. Suler, Business models for
sustainable innovation in industry 4.0: smart manufacturing processes,
digitalization of production systems, and data-driven decision making, J. Self
Govern. Manag. Econ. 7 (3) (2019) 21–26.
[75] B.A. Kadir, O. Broberg, Human-centered design of work systems in the transition
to industry 4.0, Appl. Ergon. 92 (2021) 103334.
[76] R. Ashima, A. Haleem, S. Bahl, M. Javaid, S.K. Mahla, S. Singh, Automation and
manufacturing of smart materials in Additive Manufacturing technologies using
M. Javaid et al.
Internet of Things towards the adoption of Industry 4.0, Mater. Today:
Proceedings (2021).
[77] G. Dutta, R. Kumar, R. Sindhwani, R.K. Singh, Digital transformation priorities of
India's discrete manufacturing SMEs–a conceptual study in perspective of Industry
4.0, Compet. Rev.: An International Business Journal (2020).
[78] L. Wang, G. Wang, Big data in cyber-physical systems, digital manufacturing and
industry 4.0, International Journal of Engineering and Manufacturing (IJEM) 6 (4)
(2016) 1–8.
[79] M. Parkhomenko, J. Pustovit, D. Ivanenko, A. Denisov, M. Voinarivskyi, Digital
law and electronic ethics in the formation of society 4.0, J. Leg. Ethical Regul.
Issues (JLERI) 22 (2019) 1–6.
[80] C. Lee, C. Lim, From technological development to social advance: a review of
Industry 4.0 through machine learning, Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 167
(2021) 120653.
[81] A. Barari, M.D.S.G. Tsuzuki, Y. Cohen, M. Macchi, Intelligent manufacturing
systems towards industry 4.0 era, J. Intell. Manuf. (2021) 1–4.
[82] T. Paschou, F. Adrodegari, M. Rapaccini, N. Saccani, M. Perona, Towards Service
4.0: a new framework and research priorities, Procedia Cirp 73 (2018) 148–154.
[83] V. Alc
acer, V. Cruz-Machado, Scanning the industry 4.0: a literature review on
technologies for manufacturing systems, Engineering science and technology, an
international journal 22 (3) (2019) 899–919.
[84] D. Powell, D. Romero, P. Gaiardelli, C. Cimini, S. Cavalieri, Towards digital lean
cyber-physical production systems: industry 4.0 technologies as enablers of leaner
production, in: IFIP International Conference on Advances in Production
Management Systems, Springer, Cham, 2018, August, pp. 353–362.
[85] M. Sony, J. Antony, J.A. Douglas, Essential ingredients for the implementation of
Quality 4.0, The TQM Journal (2020).
[86] J. C
arcel-Carrasco, C. G

omez-G
omez, Qualitative analysis of the perception of
company managers in knowledge management in the maintenance activity in the
era of industry 4.0, Processes 9 (1) (2021) 121.
[87] K.T. Siphoro, E.M. Bakama, C.M. Mukwakungu, N. Sukdeo, November). Transition
to Quality 4.0 and lean4. 0 from traditional lean and quality systems: the case of a
packaging company in South Africa, in: 2020 IEEE International Conference on
Technology Management, Operations and Decisions (ICTMOD), IEEE, 2020,
pp. 1–5.
[88] S. Sajid, A. Haleem, S. Bahl, M. Javaid, T. Goyal, M. Mittal, Data science
applications for predictive maintenance and materials science in context to
Industry 4.0, Mater. Today: Proceedings (2021).
[89] M.B. Ahmed, F. Majeed, C. Sanin, E. Szczerbicki, Experience-based product
inspection planning for industry 4.0, Cybern. Syst. (2021) 1–13.
[90] M. Ardolino, M. Rapaccini, N. Saccani, P. Gaiardelli, G. Crespi, C. Ruggeri, The
role of digital technologies for the service transformation of industrial companies,
Int. J. Prod. Res. 56 (6) (2018) 2116–2132.
[91] J. Torous, K.J. Myrick, N. Rauseo-Ricupero, J. Firth, Digital mental health and
COVID-19: using technology today to accelerate the curve on access and quality
tomorrow, JMIR mental health 7 (3) (2020), e18848.
[92] F. Murmura, L. Bravi, G. Santos, Sustainable process and product innovation in the
eyewear sector: the role of industry 4.0 enabling technologies, Sustainability 13
(1) (2021) 365.
[93] D. Ivanov, A. Dolgui, B. Sokolov, The impact of digital technology and Industry 4.0
on the ripple effect and supply chain risk analytics, Int. J. Prod. Res. 57 (3) (2019)
829–846.
[94] K.I. Kurpayanidi, A.A. Ilyosov, Problems of the use of digital technologies in
industry in the context of increasing the export potential of the country, ISJ
Theoretical & Applied Science 10 (90) (2020) 113.
[95] S. Bag, S. Gupta, S. Kumar, Industry 4.0 adoption and 10R advance manufacturing
capabilities for sustainable development, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 231 (2021) 107844.
[96] H. Fatorachian, H. Kazemi, Impact of Industry 4.0 on supply chain performance,
Prod. Plann. Contr. 32 (1) (2021) 63–81.
[97] M. Savelyeva, N. Shumakova, April). Innovative approach to training industry 4.0
experts, J. Phys. Conf. 1515 (3) (2020) 32065 (IOP Publishing).
[98] A.B.L. de Sousa Jabbour, C.J.C. Jabbour, M. Godinho Filho, D. Roubaud, Industry
4.0 and the circular economy: a proposed research agenda and original roadmap
for sustainable operations, Ann. Oper. Res. 270 (1) (2018) 273–286.
[99] D. Sudrajat, M. Achdisty, N. Kurniasih, S. Mulyati, A. Purnomo, S. Sallu, The
implementation of innovation in educational technology to improve the quality of
website learning in industrial revolution era 4.0 using waterfall method, J. Phys.
Conf. 1364 (1) (2019, December) 12044 (IOP Publishing).
[100] A.G. Frank, L.S. Dalenogare, N.F. Ayala, Industry 4.0 technologies:
implementation patterns in manufacturing companies, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 210
(2019) 15–26.
[101] A. Haleem, R. Vaishya, M. Javaid, I.H. Khan, Artificial Intelligence (AI)
applications in orthopaedics: an innovative technology to embrace, Journal of
Clinical Orthopaedics & Trauma 11 (2020) S80–S81.
[102] D.A. Zakoldaev, A.V. Shukalov, I.O. Zharinov, D.E. Baronov, Components and
technologies of system projection of digital and smart factories of the industry 4.0,
in: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Vol. 537, No. 3, p.
32014), IOP Publishing, 2019.
[103] G.L. Tortorella, A.M.C. Vergara, J.A. Garza-Reyes, R. Sawhney, Organizational
learning paths based upon industry 4.0 adoption: an empirical study with
Brazilian manufacturers, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 219 (2020) 284–294.
[104] D.C. Fettermann, C.G.S. Cavalcante, T.D.D. Almeida, G.L. Tortorella, How does
Industry 4.0 contribute to operations management? Journal of Industrial and
Production Engineering 35 (4) (2018) 255–268.
12
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
[105] J. Villalba-Diez, D. Schmidt, R. Gevers, J. Ordieres-Mer
e, M. Buchwitz,
W. Wellbrock, Deep learning for industrial computer vision quality control in the
printing industry 4.0, Sensors 19 (18) (2019) 3987.

[106] J. Vrchota, P. Reho r, M. Maríkov
a, M. Pech, Critical success factors of the project
management in relation to industry 4.0 for sustainability of projects, Sustainability
13 (1) (2021) 281.
[107] A. Muscio, A. Ciffolilli, What drives the capacity to integrate Industry 4.0
technologies? Evidence from European R&D projects, Econ. Innovat. N. Technol.
29 (2) (2020) 169–183.
[108] D. Horv
ath, R.Z. Szab
o, Driving forces and barriers of Industry 4.0: do
multinational and small and medium-sized companies have equal opportunities?
Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 146 (2019) 119–132.
[109] E.G. Popkova, Y.V. Ragulina, A.V. Bogoviz, Fundamental differences of transition
to industry 4.0 from previous industrial revolutions, in: Industry 4.0: Industrial
Revolution of the 21st Century, Springer, Cham, 2019, pp. 21–29.
[110] P. K€obnick, C. Velu, D. McFarlane, Preparing for Industry 4.0: digital business
model innovation in the food and beverage industry, Int. J. Mechatron. Manuf.
Syst. 13 (1) (2020) 59–89.
[111] A. Saifudin, M. Aima, A. Sutawidjaya, S. Sugiyono, Hospital digitalization in the
era of industry 4.0 based on GHRM and service quality, International Journal of
Data and Network Science 5 (2) (2021) 107–114.
[112] A. Haleem, M. Javaid, I.H. Khan, Current status and applications of artificial
intelligence (AI) in medical field: an overview, Current Medicine Research and
Practice 9 (6) (2019) 231–237.
[113] A. Issa, B. Hatiboglu, A. Bildstein, T. Bauernhansl, Industrie 4.0 roadmap:
framework for digital transformation based on the concepts of capability maturity
and alignment, Procedia Cirp 72 (2018) 973–978.
[114] C. Tuffnell, P. Kral, P. Durana, T. Krulicky, Industry 4.0-based manufacturing
systems: smart production, sustainable supply chain networks, and real-time
process monitoring, J. Self Govern. Manag. Econ. 7 (2) (2019) 7–12.
[115] M. Cugno, R. Castagnoli, G. Büchi, Openness to Industry 4.0 and performance: the
impact of barriers and incentives, Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 168 (2021)
120756.
[116] A. Hidayatno, A.R. Destyanto, C.A. Hulu, Industry 4.0 technology implementation
impact to industrial sustainable energy in Indonesia: a model conceptualization,
Energy Procedia 156 (2019) 227–233.
[117] M. Kurnikova, E. Bolgova, S. Bolgov, V. Khaitbaev, I. Dodorina, Industry 4.0:
theoretical foundations and the strategic priorities of Russian regions, in: New Silk
Road: Business Cooperation and Prospective of Economic
Development”(NSRBCPED 2019), Atlantis Press, 2020, March, pp. 195–200.
[118] J.C. Hollowell, B. Kollar, J. Vrbka, E. Kovalova, Cognitive decision-making
algorithms for sustainable manufacturing processes in Industry 4.0: networked,
smart, and responsive devices, Econ. Manag. Financ. Mark. 14 (4) (2019) 9–15.
[119] V.L. da Silva, J.L. Kovaleski, R.N. Pagani, Technology transfer in the supply chain
oriented to industry 4.0: a literature review, Technol. Anal. Strat. Manag. 31 (5)
(2019) 546–562.
[120] M.C. Duman, B. Akdemir, A study to determine the effects of industry 4.0
technology components on organizational performance, Technol. Forecast. Soc.
Change 167 (2021) 120615.
[121] G.L. Tortorella, E. Silva, D. Vargas, An empirical analysis of total quality
management and total productive maintenance in industry 4.0, in: Proceedings of
the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations
Management (IEOM), 2018, October, pp. 742–753.
[122] M. Javaid, A. Haleem, Impact of industry 4.0 to create advancements in
orthopaedics, Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics and Trauma 11 (2020) S491–S499.
[123] O.B. Digilina, I.B. Teslenko, N.V. Abdullaev, Industry 4.0: contents, problems and
perspectives, in: Perspectives on the Use of New Information and Communication
Technology (ICT) in the Modern Economy, Springer, Cham, 2017, December,
pp. 32–38.
[124] J. Posada, C. Toro, I. Barandiaran, D. Oyarzun, D. Stricker, R. De Amicis,
I. Vallarino, Visual computing as a key enabling technology for industrie 4.0 and
industrial internet, IEEE computer graphics and applications 35 (2) (2015) 26–40.
[125] C. Liebrecht, M. Kandler, M. Lang, S. Schaumann, N. Stricker, T. Wuest, G. Lanza,
Decision support for the implementation of industry 4.0 methods: toolbox,
assessment and implementation sequences for industry 4.0, J. Manuf. Syst. 58
(2021) 412–430.
[126] M. Ghobakhloo, Industry 4.0, digitization, and opportunities for sustainability,
J. Clean. Prod. 252 (2020) 119869.
[127] A.A. Ismail, R. Hassan, Technical competencies in digital technology towards
industrial revolution 4.0, Journal of Technical Education and Training 11 (3)
(2019).
[128] F. Tao, Q. Qi, L. Wang, A.Y.C. Nee, Digital twins and cyber–physical systems
toward smart manufacturing and industry 4.0: correlation and comparison,
Engineering 5 (4) (2019) 653–661.
[129] S. Aheleroff, X. Xu, R.Y. Zhong, Y. Lu, Digital twin as a service (DTaaS) in industry
4.0: an architecture reference model, Adv. Eng. Inf. 47 (2021) 101225.
[130] E. Francalanza, J. Borg, P. Vella, P. Farrugia, C. Constantinescu, February). An
‘Industry 4.0’digital model fostering integrated product development, in: 2018
IEEE 9th International Conference on Mechanical and Intelligent Manufacturing
Technologies (ICMIMT), IEEE, 2018, pp. 95–99.
[131] M.C. Annosi, F. Brunetta, A. Monti, F. Nati, Is the trend your friend? An analysis of
technology 4.0 investment decisions in agricultural SMEs, Comput. Ind. 109
(2019) 59–71.
M. Javaid et al.
[132] P. Saxena, M. Papanikolaou, E. Pagone, K. Salonitis, M.R. Jolly, Digital
manufacturing for foundries 4.0, in: Light Metals 2020, Springer, Cham, 2020,
pp. 1019–1025.
[133] C. Riley, J. Vrbka, Z. Rowland, Internet of things-enabled sustainability, big data-
driven decision-making processes, and digitized mass production in industry 4.0-
based manufacturing systems, J. Self Govern. Manag. Econ. 9 (2021) 1.
[134] M. Gray-Hawkins, L. Michalkova, P. Suler, N.A. Zhuravleva, Real-time process
monitoring in Industry 4.0 manufacturing systems: sensing, smart, and sustainable
technologies, Econ. Manag. Financ. Mark. 14 (4) (2019) 30–36.
[135] E. Nica, Cyber-physical production networks and advanced digitalization in
Industry 4.0 manufacturing systems: sustainable supply chain management,
organizational resilience, and data-driven innovation, J. Self Govern. Manag.
Econ. 7 (3) (2019) 27–33.
[136] G.K. Br, S.K. Majumdar, S. Menon, Manoeuvre of electronic entrepreneurial
ecosystem to contemporary indicator of techno business leadership in industry
4.0: digital entrepreneurship, Global J. Enterprise Inf. Syst. 10 (3) (2018) 25–33.
[137] W.P. Neumann, S. Winkelhaus, E.H. Grosse, C.H. Glock, Industry 4.0 and the
human factor–A systems framework and analysis methodology for successful
development, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 233 (2021) 107992.
[138] B. Ill
es, P. Tam

as, P. Dobos, R. Skapinyecz, New challenges for quality assurance of
manufacturing processes in industry 4.0, in: Solid State Phenomena, 261, Trans
Tech Publications Ltd, 2017, pp. 481–486.
[139] S. Duran, G. Sengil, Integrated technologies, advances and benefits in Industry 4.0,
International Journal of Business Ecosystem & Strategy (2687-2293) 1 (2) (2019)
31–38.
[140] J. Stentoft, K. Adsbøll Wickstrøm, K. Philipsen, A. Haug, Drivers and barriers for
Industry 4.0 readiness and practice: empirical evidence from small and medium-
sized manufacturers, Prod. Plann. Contr. (2020) 1–18.
[141] R. Stark, T. Damerau, K. Lindow, Industrie 4.0—digital redesign of product
creation and production in berlin as an industrial location, in: The Internet of
Things, Springer Vieweg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2018, pp. 171–186.
[142] D. Balderas, A. Ortiz, E. M
endez, P. Ponce, A. Molina, Empowering Digital Twin
for Industry 4.0 using metaheuristic optimization algorithms: case study PCB
drilling optimization, Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 113 (5) (2021) 1295–1306.
[143] T. Tirto, Y. Ossik, V. Omelyanenko, June). ICT support for Industry 4.0 innovation
networks: education and technology transfer issues. Design, Simulation,
Manufacturing: the Innovation Exchange, Springer, Cham, 2019, pp. 359–369.
[144] A.C. Pereira, F. Romero, A review of the meanings and the implications of the
Industry 4.0 concept, Procedia Manufacturing 13 (2017) 1206–1214.
[145] M. Rüßmann, M. Lorenz, P. Gerbert, M. Waldner, J. Justus, P. Engel, M. Harnisch,
Industry 4.0: the future of productivity and growth in manufacturing industries,
Boston Consulting Group 9 (1) (2015) 54–89.
[146] B. Bigliardi, E. Bottani, G. Casella, Enabling technologies, application areas and
impact of industry 4.0: a bibliographic analysis, Procedia manufacturing 42
(2020) 322–326.
[147] R. Marciniak, P. Moricz, M. Baksa, Towards business services 4.0-digital
transformation of business services at a global technology company, in:
International Workshop on Global Sourcing of Information Technology and
Business Processes, Springer, Cham, 2019, December, pp. 124–144.
[148] I. Wrobel, M. Sidzina, Design study for automatic production line of a sub-
assemblies of new generation car body structures compliant with the “industry
4.0” concept, Sensors 21 (7) (2021) 2434.
[149] A. Raj, G. Dwivedi, A. Sharma, A.B.L. de Sousa Jabbour, S. Rajak, Barriers to the
adoption of industry 4.0 technologies in the manufacturing sector: an inter-
country comparative perspective, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 224 (2020) 107546.
[150] S. El Hamdi, A. Abouabdellah, M. Oudani, June). Industry 4.0: fundamentals and
main challenges, in: 2019 International Colloquium on Logistics and Supply Chain
Management (LOGISTIQUA), IEEE, 2019, pp. 1–5.
[151] R. Tasmin, N.S. Rahman, I. Jaafar, N.A. Abd Hamid, Y. Ngadiman, The readiness of
automotive manufacturing company on industrial 4.0 towards quality
performance, International Journal of Integrated Engineering 12 (7) (2020)
160–172.
[152] R. Sahal, S.H. Alsamhi, J.G. Breslin, K.N. Brown, M.I. Ali, Digital twins
collaboration for automatic erratic operational data detection in industry 4.0,
Appl. Sci. 11 (7) (2021) 3186.
[153] J.M. Müller, D. Kiel, K.I. Voigt, What drives the implementation of Industry 4.0?
The role of opportunities and challenges in the context of sustainability,
Sustainability 10 (1) (2018) 247.
[154] E.V. Karanina, D.A. Loginov, A.N. Timin, Overcoming the threats and risks of the
strategy of education quality management in a region in Industry 4.0, Int. J. Econ.
Pol. Emerg. Econ. 13 (6) (2020) 632–647.
13
Sensors International 2 (2021) 100109
[155] G.L. Tortorella, D. Fettermann, Implementation of Industry 4.0 and lean
production in Brazilian manufacturing companies, Int. J. Prod. Res. 56 (8) (2018)
2975–2987.
[156] Q. Qi, F. Tao, Digital twin and big data towards smart manufacturing and industry
4.0: 360 degree comparison, Ieee Access 6 (2018) 3585–3593.
[157] B. Chen, J. Wan, L. Shu, P. Li, M. Mukherjee, B. Yin, Smart factory of industry 4.0:
key technologies, application case, and challenges, Ieee Access 6 (2017)
6505–6519.
[158] J.K. Gerrikagoitia, G. Unamuno, E. Urkia, A. Serna, Digital manufacturing
platforms in the industry 4.0 from private and public perspectives, Appl. Sci. 9
(14) (2019) 2934.
[159] A. Ancarani, C. Di Mauro, F. Mascali, Backshoring strategy and the adoption of
industry 4.0: evidence from europe, J. World Bus. 54 (4) (2019) 360–371.
[160] R.G.G. Caiado, L.F. Scavarda, L.O. Gavi~ao, P. Ivson, D.L. de Mattos Nascimento,
J.A. Garza-Reyes, A fuzzy rule-based industry 4.0 maturity model for operations
and supply chain management, Int. J. Prod. Econ. 231 (2021) 107883.
[161] W.S. Alaloul, M.S. Liew, N.A.W.A. Zawawi, I.B. Kennedy, Industrial Revolution 4.0
in the construction industry: challenges and opportunities for stakeholders, Ain
shams engineering journal 11 (1) (2020) 225–230.
[162] B. Dachs, S. Kinkel, A. J€ager, Bringing it all back home? Backshoring of
manufacturing activities and the adoption of Industry 4.0 technologies, J. World
Bus. 54 (6) (2019) 101017.
[163] G. Dalmarco, F.R. Ramalho, A.C. Barros, A.L. Soares, Providing industry 4.0
technologies: the case of a production technology cluster, J. High Technol. Manag.
Res. 30 (2) (2019) 100355.
[164] A. Mitra, On the capabilities of cellular automata-based MapReduce model in
industry 4.0, Journal of Industrial Information Integration 21 (2021) 100195.
[165] D. Kiel, J.M. Müller, C. Arnold, K.I. Voigt, Sustainable industrial value creation:
benefits and challenges of industry 4.0, in: Digital Disruptive Innovation, 2020,
pp. 231–270.
[166] D. Li, Å. Fast-Berglund, D. Paulin, Current and future Industry 4.0 capabilities for
information and knowledge sharing, Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 105 (9) (2019)
3951–3963.
[167] E.G. Margherita, A.M. Braccini, Industry 4.0 technologies in flexible
manufacturing for sustainable organizational value: reflections from a multiple
case study of Italian manufacturers, Inf. Syst. Front (2020) 1–22.
[168] P.F. Siltori, R. Anholon, I.S. Rampasso, O.L. Quelhas, L.A. Santa-Eulalia, W. Leal
Filho, Industry 4.0 and corporate sustainability: an exploratory analysis of possible
impacts in the Brazilian context, Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 167 (2021)
120741.
[169] M.L. Nunes, A.C. Pereira, A.C. Alves, Smart products development approaches for
Industry 4.0, Procedia manufacturing 13 (2017) 1215–1222.
[170] M.D. Nardo, D. Forino, T. Murino, The evolution of man–machine interaction: the
role of human in Industry 4.0 paradigm, Production & Manufacturing Research 8
(1) (2020) 20–34.
[171] R. Pozzi, T. Rossi, R. Secchi, Industry 4.0 technologies: critical success factors for
implementation and improvements in manufacturing companies, Prod. Plann.
Contr. (2021) 1–21.
[172] N. Durakbasa, G. Bas, J. Bauer, Implementing education vision in the context of
industry 4.0, in: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Vol.
448, No. 1, p. 12045), IOP Publishing, 2018, November.
[173] A.G. Khanzode, P.R. Sarma, S.K. Mangla, H. Yuan, Modeling the industry 4.0
adoption for sustainable production in micro, small & medium enterprises,
J. Clean. Prod. 279 (2021) 123489.
[174] C. Lukita, S. Suwandi, E.P. Harahap, U. Rahardja, C. Nas, Curriculum 4.0: adoption
of industry era 4.0 as assessment of higher education quality, IJCCS (Indonesian
Journal of Computing and Cybernetics Systems) 14 (3) (2020) 297–308.
[175] A. Hariharasudan, S. Kot, A scoping review on digital English and education 4.0
for industry 4.0, Soc. Sci. 7 (11) (2018) 227.
[176] Y. Lu, Industry 4.0: a survey on technologies, applications and open research
issues, Journal of industrial information integration 6 (2017) 1–10.
[177] P. Chandra, Miniaturized label-free smartphone assisted electrochemical sensing
approach for personalised COVID-19 diagnosis, Sensors International 1 (2020)
100019.
[178] A. Haleem, M. Javaid, R.P. Singh, R. Suman, S. Rab, Biosensors applications in
medical field: a brief review, Sensors International (2021 May 13) 100100.
[179] B. Purohit, P.R. Vernekar, N.P. Shetti, P. Chandra, Biosensor nanoengineering:
design, operation, and implementation for biomolecular analysis, Sensors
International (2020 Sep 9) 100040.