Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Winning in a Downturn
Managing Working Capital
The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is a global manage-
ment consulting firm and the world’s leading advisor on
business strategy. We partner with clients in all sectors
and regions to identify their highest-value opportunities,
address their most critical challenges, and transform their
businesses. Our customized approach combines deep in
sight into the dynamics of companies and markets with
close collaboration at all levels of the client organization.
This ensures that our clients achieve sustainable compet
itive advantage, build more capable organizations, and
secure lasting results. Founded in 1963, BCG is a private
company with 66 offices in 38 countries. For more infor-
mation, please visit www.bcg.com.
Winning in a Downturn
Managing Working Capital
W
orking capital is downturn, all businesses can benefit Strategies to manage working capital
an important from a renewed focus on working are particularly effective in invento-
source of cash capital. Those with short-term liquid- ry-intensive industries such as manu-
throughout the ity problems can reduce inventories facturing, consumer goods, and re-
business cycle, and optimize receivables and pay- tail, where most companies can
but it is especially critical during a ables to free up cash quickly; busi- reduce working capital by up to 25
downturn. nesses with strong balance sheets percent in the first year alone. By
but decreasing demand for their contrast, companies that do not take
In periods of economic expansion, products can reduce inventories to extra measures in a downturn typi-
managers often focus so intently on offset falling sales so that working- cally see their working capital in-
revenue and earnings growth that capital ratios don’t worsen; and com- crease, sharply limiting their options.
they ignore other, less obvious meth- panies whose performance remains
ods of value creation, such as work- strong can use working-capital strate- Accounts receivable and accounts
ing-capital management—the proc- gies to solidify their financial posi- payable can often yield quick wins,
ess of optimizing net current assets tion and attack competitors weak- with almost all of the potential sav-
relative to business volume. But com- ened by the crisis. During a ings achievable in the first 6 to 12
panies that manage their working downturn, effective working-capital months. One global consumer-pack-
capital effectively can generate cash, management can spell the difference aged-goods company was able to
streamline their operations, and im- between bankruptcy and solvency or generate €253 million in cash the
prove their cost position. When the between acquiring and being ac- first year by optimizing its receiv-
economy is expanding, the impact of quired—but too often, companies ables and payables management.
reduced working capital can be the fail to take action. Simply boosting efforts to collect re-
critical difference between success ceivables—by proactively reminding
and failure in a takeover bid, or be- Getting Cash Quickly customers of upcoming payment
tween funding a strategic project deadlines, for instance—can deliver
with cash on hand and funding it A comprehensive approach to work- results within weeks. Since accounts-
through a debt offering. ing-capital management can reduce receivable and accounts-payable
funds tied up in inventory, receiv- practices can vary widely, companies
The payoff for effective working-capi- ables, and payables by 20 to 40 per- should review them by industry and
tal management can be even greater cent, releasing cash that can country to ensure that their terms
during an economic contraction, strengthen a company’s competitive are not needlessly generous, leaving
when reduced access to external position during tough economic money on the table. And they should
funding and sharp decreases in sales times. For an industrial goods com- renegotiate payment terms, dis-
can greatly limit available cash. Al- pany with revenues of €10 billion, for counts, and penalties accordingly.
though companies with liquidity is- example, that can translate into Other methods to control receivables
sues face particular challenges in a €300 million to €800 million in cash. and payables are effective but may
Winning in a Downturn 1
take longer to implement. For exam- them to specific customer segments, ronment, the focus of inventory
ple, renegotiating contract terms for example) can deliver benefits management shifts from guarantee-
with suppliers and customers often fairly quickly. ing supply to reducing inventory
frees up large amounts of cash, but stockpiles, which requires a funda-
restrictions imposed by existing con- An added benefit: unlike cost-cutting mentally different mindset and ap-
tracts may delay the benefits for up and other belt-tightening measures proach.
to one year. that can hurt morale and future
The first step is to stop the growth of
Whereas cutting inventory through- Working-capital inventory. Excess inventory results
out the system can take time, more when sales slow relative to the mate-
management
modest measures can generate up to rials already on hand, and it worsens
two-thirds of the total potential sav- often strengthens when inputs continue to enter the
ings in the first year. Smaller and operations for pipeline at the pre-slowdown pace.
more frequent orders, for example, By acting quickly to curb the inflow
can lead to major reductions in over- the upturn. of new inventory, companies can
all inventory levels in a matter of avoid a crisis and adopt a more in-
months. And during a downturn, growth, working-capital management cremental approach to inventory
suppliers are less likely to adhere to often strengthens operations for the management.
strict policies concerning minimum upturn.
orders. Companies that consolidate First, cancel, freeze, or postpone sup-
suppliers at the same time can sim- The Downturn Difference plier orders as soon as sales begin to
plify the purchasing process and slow. Then resize future deliveries in
bundle their orders for increased vol- Although working-capital manage- keeping with current sales volume.
ume—and sometimes for larger dis- ment is always important, a compa- Before ordering any new inventory,
counts. Using strategies such as ny’s strategy must fundamentally take a systemwide view of demand
these, one industrial-equipment sup- change when demand drops. Falling and inventory levels across the or-
plier reduced its inventory by 10 per- sales and tight credit markets pre- ganization in order to rebalance raw
cent in less than three months and sent a different set of challenges materials and work-in-process (WIP)
by 30 percent within a year. than growing sales and supply short- in all locations. And double-check
ages. As a result, when an economic underlying demand assumptions be-
Even better, these programs cost very expansion evolves into a contraction, fore setting new order levels. A glob-
little to implement. Managing receiv- businesses must reevaluate and ad- al machinery manufacturer was able
ables and payables more carefully just their approach to each of their to sharply reduce its raw-materials
often requires nothing more than working-capital categories: inventory, inventory by renegotiating its supply
simply complying with previously es- accounts receivable, and accounts contracts based on a review of cur-
tablished guidelines. For instance, in payable. rent sales volume and committed
good economic times, many compa- customer orders, which showed a
nies fail to hold customers to the Inventory: Focus on Reducing softening of demand.
terms of their contracts. By enforcing Stock. When sales are increasing
contract terms, assigning clearly de- during robust economic times, the Reducing levels of buffer stock, too,
fined monitoring roles to employees, supply of key inputs may tighten, can release significant amounts of
and creating a process for automati- limiting a company’s growth. With cash. At many companies, managers
cally addressing problems early, com- the risk and potential damage of responsible for buffer stocks are com-
panies can get results with virtually stockouts heightened, inventory pensated at least partially on the ba-
no capital investment. The fear of management tends to focus on guar- sis of their ability to meet demand,
losing customers may make compa- anteeing a constant supply of inputs. so they build up large piles of inven-
nies reluctant to take such measures In a recession, however, declining de- tory. By identifying the ideal in-stock
in a downturn, but doing so in a dif- mand can lead to excess inventory in rate given different demand patterns
ferentiated manner (by applying all phases of production. In this envi- and service levels, companies can de-
Winning in a Downturn 3
cies can improve collection and re- restricting credit. To offset the im- down the retailer’s overall costs
duce costly defaults. pact of such actions, consider consol- while strengthening relationships
idating orders with a smaller num- with its most important suppliers.
Accounts Payable: An Ongoing ber of preferred suppliers to
Source of Financing. When the maintain higher volumes, or use the While the greatest risk in a working-
economy is strong, managing ac- threat of terminating a supplier to capital program is not doing enough,
counts payable tends to be a relative- negotiate better terms. companies must also avoid acting
ly straightforward process. Compa- too drastically. Dramatic action may
nies typically negotiate the best Companies can release cash in the short term, but
agreements possible with their sup- the dangers posed to a company’s
manage their cash
pliers and then pay in accordance longer-term competitive position
with the contract. During a down- for the short term may far exceed the benefits. Be sure
turn, however, payables can repre- and their business to evaluate the tradeoffs. For in-
sent a low-cost source of funding. stance, a financially stable company
“Leaning on the trade” by delaying for the long term. must seriously consider the benefits
payments is a tactic that can provide of tightening terms for financially
a bridge loan when cash is tight. To A Two-Way Street weakened suppliers. Although the
conserve cash, never pay suppliers gain in bargaining power may deliv-
early. And renegotiate for extended As they plan their cash-generating er a quick win, the resulting damage
payment terms or major discounts maneuvers, companies must take to the relationship could cause sup-
for prompt payment whenever pos- into account the actions that their ply disruptions when strong demand
sible, depending on your company’s customers and suppliers may take to returns. By weighing such decisions
position. protect their own interests—such as carefully, companies can manage
negotiating for better terms, delaying their cash for the short term and
Companies must also turn their at- payments, canceling orders, and re- their business for the long term.
tention to supplier viability and the jecting deliveries. Companies that
risk that delivery of key inputs will be don’t anticipate and plan for such Planning the Approach
interrupted. Since declining sales vol- moves will be at a disadvantage and
umes can hurt suppliers, it is impor- may find their cash position deterio- Without an effective plan of attack, a
tant to segment them and evaluate rating. To be prepared, determine working-capital management pro-
their relative strength. Look at each your responses in advance. gram will fall far short of its full po-
vendor’s overall financial stability tential impact. There are three phas-
and importance to production. If a For example, when a customer re- es to planning a program.
supplier that provides critical materi- quests better payment terms, have
als or services is in financial difficulty, answers and arguments in hand to Assessing Liquidity and Demand.
consider purchasing larger volumes more effectively manage negotia- First, assess the company’s current
or arranging shorter payment terms. tions and maintain or improve your cash position and determine which
This support may ensure continued company’s payment position. In way demand for its products is mov-
deliveries and lead to stronger, more some instances, it may be advanta- ing. Then plot its position on a plan-
advantageous relationships. For non- geous to proactively negotiate a re- ning matrix to determine its options.
strategic suppliers with liquidity vised payment schedule, perhaps of- (See Exhibit 1.)
problems, it may make sense to nego- fering to take back inventory that
tiate vigorously for large discounts. can be resold. A major European re- Companies faced with falling de-
tailer approached strategic suppliers mand and a lack of liquidity are in
Faced with declining sales, suppliers that faced potential liquidity prob- the most challenging spot. They
may have to act defensively to pro- lems and offered to reduce average must aggressively manage their cash,
tect their margins, eliminating favor- payment terms from 60 to 15 days in using every possible lever to main-
able payment terms, increasing pric- exchange for price reductions of 1 to tain or strengthen their position, de-
es, cutting back on deliveries, or 3 percent. This strategy brought spite the potentially damaging long-
Winning in a Downturn 5
Exhibit 2. ...and Evaluate Potential Actions on the Basis of Escalation Level and Time Frame
◊ Reduce payment terms for ◊ Organize sales campaigns for ◊ Systematically develop supplier
noncore customers excess stock capabilities and advanced logistics
Moderate ◊ Prolong payment terms for ◊ Renegotiate lead times and lot ◊ Implement make-or-buy decisions
escalation noncore suppliers sizes with key suppliers ◊ Establish back-to-back agreements
◊ Enforce strict penalties for late
payments
◊ Avoid early deliveries
€50 million €125 million €230 million
ment to include employees deep The Goal: An Integrated cash visibility, and active cash man-
within the company. Ambitious plans Cash-Management System agement. (See Exhibit 3.)
that aim to generate significant cash
very quickly require the coordinated While working-capital management Cash Governance and Organiza-
effort and discipline of large groups is an effective tool for cash genera- tion. Establish a “corporate cash
from all levels of the organization. tion, particularly in times of econom- DNA” by deeply embedding cash
ic contraction, it is only one part of a management into the organization
Although frontline employees will do comprehensive, integrated approach so that cash flow becomes a key
much of the work involved in reduc- to cash management. The goal of an management metric. This effort
ing working capital, senior manage- integrated approach is not to gener- should not be limited to the finance
ment must demonstrate ongoing ate cash in the short term—although or treasury department. Instead, es-
support and commitment in order to that may be one element of the pro- tablish cash governance with dedicat-
instill a sense of urgency. Manage- gram—but to achieve greater insight ed responsibilities at all levels of the
ment must also develop the tools into available cash through cash organization and with clear guide-
and systems that will guarantee suc- planning and forecasting, and to link lines for cash management process-
cess, such as tracking tools to moni- both of these to the operating levers es. And disseminate cash-relevant
tor progress toward targets and regu- that affect cash flows. It allows com- knowledge to all employees through
lar reviews to evaluate performance panies to manage cash effectively training and workshops and by tying
and identify any needed corrective and react quickly to changes in busi- compensation to cash flow targets.
measures. Where appropriate, adjust ness performance. Integrated cash The goal is to make cash manage-
employee incentives to encourage management has three key elements: ment a fundamental part of every-
cash management. cash governance and organization, day operations rather than some-
I
just one such lever. Others include tion themselves more strongly for
optimizing fixed assets, cutting costs, n an economic downturn, effec- the future.
and increasing sales, each of which tive working-capital manage-
has the potential to bridge the gap ment—as part of a broader ap-
between the desired level of cash proach to cash management—can
and the projected actual cash in- do much to offset the negative pres-
flows. Consider these actions in all sures on revenues and margins. Most
phases of the business cycle—not companies can generate cash quickly
Winning in a Downturn 7
About the Authors Acknowledgments For Further Contact
Patrick Buchmann is a principal The authors would like to thank This report is a joint publication of
in the Hamburg office of The Gary Callahan, Martha Craumer, Kim BCG’s Corporate Development and
Boston Consulting Group. You Friedman, and Gina Goldstein for Operations practices. If you would
may contact him by e-mail at their contributions to the editing, like to discuss this report, please con-
buchmann.patrick@bcg.com. design, and production of this report. tact one of the authors.
To receive future publications in electronic form about this topic or others, please visit our subscription Web site at
www.bcg.com/subscribe.