Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CDMO Report
CDMO Report
Development and
Manufacturing
Organizations (CDMOs)
are leading innovation
for pharmaceutical
partners
11
2 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
How pharmaceutical CDMOs use their
technological know-how to enter the center
stage of manufacturing
Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are flexible
third-party manufacturing partners for pharmaceutical
companies — but can they also become leaders of innovation?
The pharmaceutical CDMO industry is consolidating, EY, 2017 EYGM Limited., EYG no. 04551-172GBL
1
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 3
Section 1 continued...
Small
Biologics Novel modalities
molecules
Manu- Chemical Microbial Mammalian Chemical Enzymatical Microbial Mammalian Cell
facturing synthesis fermentation cell culture synthesis production fermentation cell culture manipulation
categories
Products Small Peptides mAbs Antisense mRNA Plasmids Viral vector CAR-T, stem
(selected molecules oligos, RNAi cells
examples)
Typical lot ~t ~g-kg ~g-kg ~kg ~g (COVID-19: ~g (to kg) Viral titer, # of Cell #,# of
size kg) doses1 doses
Typical facility • Often • Medium to • Medium to • Medium • Large-scale • Currently still • Large-scale • Medium-
scale large scale Large- Large- scale production in medium production scale
chemical Scale Scale currently, in progress scale, in progress production
API plants production production but (COVID-19) providers are (large in progress
upscaling working on investments (large
• Up to • Up to • Up to
possible commoditizing in recent investments
several several several
kg scale years) in recent
100k L 10k L 10k L
years)
capacity capacity capacity
Industrial mfg.
maturity
Still the most Important for Segment Growing Jump in Relevant as used Major Current
important biotechnology with large importance maturity due as precursor for component of volumes
segment production growth in rising with to COVID-19 e.g., mRNA and ex- and in-vivo rel. low due
in terms of intermediates past decades, number of vaccines gene therapies gene therapies to mainly
volume and further advanced autologous
value growth products in nature of
expected pipeline products
1. Amount depends e.g., for viral vectors on target tissue and type of virus
Source: EY-Parthenon analysis High Low
Figure 1: Schematic segmentation of modalities and underlying manufacturing categories
4 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
The CDMO value chain is moving towards
a “one-stop-shop” service portfolio
We also observed another major trend: partnering pharma and manufacturing process2. A more recent example for a
or biotech companies increasingly expect CDMOs to expand further expansion of the value chain is the combination of
from having specialty knowledge towards providing expertise the existing integrated manufacturing services for clinical
along the entire manufacturing processes up to and including stage products with clinical trial services. These were
commercial launch. This trend is strengthened by the fact previously a separate domain for classical clinical research
that the customer base for CDMOs experiences a shift from organizations (CROs3). Thus, CDMOs enlarge their service
primarily “big pharma” companies towards including more offerings and are now delivering to patients, not only their
and more smaller biotech companies. The latter naturally pharma partners. In summary, via the further integration up-
have a sole focus on developing their drug pipeline without and downstream of core capabilities along the value chain,
having vast experience in manufacturing, let alone a CDMOs are striving to meet changing customers’ needs.
manufacturing site. They require an early integration of their
operations with partnering CDMOs in the drug developmental
Weathering the Storm Together — Part 1 and 2, published 10/27/2021 on the Medicine Maker; Roundtable: How CDMOs Handled the Pandemic (ampproject.org) and How
2
have Pharma CDMOs Responded to the COVID-19 Pandemic? (themedicinemaker.com); accessed 11/16/2021
In this case not to confuse with contract research organizations, often also abbreviated as CRO.
3
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 5
Section 1 continued...
Target Patient
Drug development Extraction Solids Primary packaging
identification recruiting
(e.g., blister, strip,
bottle, pre-filled
syringe) Drug
Lead discovery Analytics Synthesis Semi-solid
application
Service offering focus
Small scale
Large scale (phase III to commercial)
6 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
Players at scale, extenders and complementors as emerging
CDMO business models
To summarize the observed M&A movements, we would like finish capabilities. Lastly, complementors are quite careful
to point out to three major CDMO strategies in classifying expanders that are typically small and highly specialized,
three types of players (Figure 3): Players at scale, extenders, and that invest in complementing areas. An example for
and complementors. Players at scale have the purchasing this model would be the case of an antibody drug conjugate
power to move into new areas quickly and decisively, specialist that acquires a specialist of relevant conjugation
broadly extending their business model that is typically technologies.
already vastly integrated. Extenders are investing in selected
In the following sections, we are going to explore how the
segments along adjacent growth trajectories, for example,
M&A landscape has moved the market in the recent years.
to extend their manufacturing service capabilities by fill and
Customer types (early/late stage) Customer types (early/late stage) Customer types (early/late stage)
Figure 3: Schematic illustrative overview of typical types of CDMO movements observed on the market
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 7
2
8 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
The majority of transactions have targets in
North America
North America is the center of gravity for CDMO transactions
63 68
39 44
30 42.32
(based on 27
transactions with �
disclosed transaction
value)
2%
22.11
(based on 28 22%
transactions with �
disclosed 76%
transaction value)
3.3 7.4
1% 7.6
6% (based on 12 (based on 14
transactions with � (based on 21 transactions
transactions with �
disclosed transaction with d
� isclosed transaction
disclosed transaction
value) value)
value)
2%
93% 12% 16% 6%
6% 24%
82%
82% 70%
1. In 2017, 4 megadeals (>US$1b) make up for ~US$18.8b of the reported transaction values
Number of CDMO transactions APAC
2. In 2021, 4 megadeals (>US$1b) make up for ~US$37.9b of the reported transaction values
Cumulative deal value, US$b EMEA
Americas
Source: EY-Parthenon analysis, S&P Capital IQ, secondary research
Figure 4: Overview of CDMO-related M&A volume and value per year between 2017 and 2021. Regions: Americas, North, Middle and South America; APAC,
Asia Pacific region; EMEA, Europe, Middle East, and Africa
Of note: not all transactions publicly reveal financial conditions. Information was available for 102 of the 244 M&A transactions investigated herein.
4
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 9
Section 2 continued...
US$49b
10 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
Table 1: Top target countries for CDMO M&A transactions based on number of deals and transaction volume in deals
between 2017 and 2021, sorted by the region of the headquarters of the target company.
1 US 97 1 US 66.28
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 11
Section 2 continued...
Figure 5: CDMO investment flows (deal values in US$b) of investigated M&A deals between 2017 and 2021. Arrows originate in the region of the acquirer; arrowheads
point towards the region of the target
12 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
The CDMO landscape is further consolidating
The 10 companies with the highest numbers of deals within one quarter (27%) of M&A deal activities between 2017 and
our timeframe contain several major CDMO players (Table 2021 originated from these 10 players, indicating that the
2). The 10 most active companies conducted an average of market consolidation we observed already in our previous
7 transactions between 2017 and 2021 per player. About report continued.
Table 2: List of top 10 companies active in M&As, ranked by numbers of deals (2017 to 2021)
Charles River
Public Company $2.9b3 9 $1,818m
Labora-tories International, Inc.
WuXi Apptech
Public Company $3.3b 7 $425m
Biopharmaceuticals, Ltd.
1. S&P Capital IQ
2. Annual reports
3. Based on 2020 revenue
4. Based on transaction values that are publicly available, not exhaustive
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 13
33
14 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
How a drive towards technology leadership is
shaping the CDMO market
Capability expansions in biologics and novel modalities seem to be major drivers
behind M&A activities and internal investment decisions in the CDMO sector
Capacity, Capacity,
Capability &
Capacity & Capability &
Capability & 7% 0%
Geographic Capability Geographic Capacity &
Geographic
extension extension extension Capability
extension
14% 14% extension
Capability extension
28%
Novel modalities
Capacity &
Geographic extension
Geographic extension 5%
0% Capacity extension
Capability &
13%
Geographic extension
13%
Capacity &
Capacity, Capability
Capability &
Geographic
3% extension
extension 21%
Capability extension
45%
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 15
Section 3 continued...
16 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
Drug product capabilities were the major area of interest along
the value chain for M&A deals involving small molecule
CDMO services
Lastly, we also investigated the steps along the value chain a larger number of transactions, involving companies that
that the companies in the analyzed M&A deals were focusing include drug product manufacturing. For biologics and novel
on (Figure 7). Investments were mainly equally distributed modalities, transactions involving research and development
between the value chain steps of development services, drug capabilities were the most prominent. This may also reflect
substance manufacturing and drug product manufacturing, the larger need for developmental services in new and faster
while packaging and product business were represented less. growing markets, in which technology has not yet
Deals including small molecule capabilities stood out with reached maturity.
17 17
6 9
4
R&D Drug Drug Packaging Raw Other R&D Drug Drug Packaging Raw Other
substance product materials products substance product materials products
Novel modalities
59
49
42
8 12 9
Figure 7: Value chain focus based on number of deals within the CDMO M&A transactions, 2017 to 20215
Investments including multiple modalities and value chain steps counted multiple times.
5
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 17
Section 3 continued...
Source: Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc. Thermo Fisher Scientific Completes Acquisition of PPD, Inc.
18 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 19
4
20 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
Main drivers of M&A transactions are
CDMOs, but investment companies
are gaining interest
Investment companies are only slowly entering the M&A space that is
still dominated by CDMOs
244 Total
number of deals 23%
27% 52%
72%
25%
2%
6
The S&P Capital IQ classification of was used to label investment firms.
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 21
Section 4 continued...
Companies owned by
investment firms were
acquired mostly by
privately held companies
and only to a minor extent
by public players or other
investment firms
A target-buyer’s matrix compares results in this study on our 2017 report vs. 18% observed herein) as well as
to previous findings in the CDMO landscape (Figure 9). investment firms acquiring private companies (4% vs. 21%).
Companies owned by investment firms were acquired mostly At the same time, the number of deals involving public
by privately held companies and only to a minor extent by companies, either as buyer or as target, was reduced. Hence,
public players or other investment firms. Comparing our while M&A deals within the private sector remained high,
findings to the 2017 report, a remarkable increase could be an emerging role of investment firms in the M&A landscape
seen for private strategic companies acquiring a portfolio indicates a growing interest in this part of the life science
company from investment firms (6% of the deals based business.
Type of buyer
Increase
compared to 2017 report Private strategic Public strategic Investment firm
Figure 9: Ownership change matrix based on M&A deals between 2017 and 2021. Matrix is color-coded with darker blue indicating a higher portion of total number of
transactions than light blue colors. Segments that saw a pronounced increase vs. our EY-Parthenon analysis in the 2017 report are indicated by arrow signs.
22 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 23
5
24 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
How the CDMO market is poised
for growth
Are continuous outsourcing trends, ever more complex manufacturing
networks and new technologies marking the CDMO sector for success?
To summarize, this report analyzed the M&A landscape in More broadly, we also expect CDMOs to foster their new
the CDMO industry between 2017 and 2021, and compared role as technology innovators. Major players increasingly
insights with results from our previous report covering the incorporate smaller startups and technology leaders. Looking
time frame from 2012 to 2016. The updated EY-Parthenon across modalities, we also anticipate that product companies
analysis this time also includes the assumed strategic will continue to move towards the CDMO service market,
rationales behind the investigated deals. Our results reveal while CDMOs will increasingly move towards extended
an ongoing consolidation trend within the CDMO market product offerings, especially in the novel modalities space.
and unraveled the companies’ special investment focus on In addition, integration of clinical trial services could be a
technology and capabilities. new trend area for CDMOs to enter high value, low volume
segments, for example, in case of personalized medicine.
Integration of the company network is happening along three
However, a respective business model would be quite
main axes: Extension of the capabilities along value chains
different from a more traditional “volume first”
within a modality, extension to new modalities and, in select
business model.
cases, an extension from a focus of product offerings towards
offering additional service categories (such as clinical trial Distilling the essence of the market movers of the past five
services). Especially the rise of new technologies offers years, CDMOs are expected to become additional strong
potential to revolutionize therapies and supply chains. We contributors to innovation in the pharmaceutical industry.
expect these trends to persist throughout the next years. Overall, we anticipate that CDMOs will remain important
partners for pharmaceutical companies and are expected to
Compared to our initial CDMO M&A EY-Parthenon analysis in
gain further relevance through their increasing technological
2017, investment firms appear to gain appetite to become
expertise and know-how along the value chain.
more active players in the field, and we expect this trend
to continue. CDMOs present an interesting option to enter
life sciences and pharmaceutical markets by investing in
continuous service revenues, while still benefitting from high
growth rates in novel therapy areas.
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 25
6
26 | How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners
Appendix: Methodology
The sources used for the transaction EY-Parthenon analysis For the EY-Parthenon analysis of internal investments,
were S&P Capital IQ, company websites and press releases. 15 global CDMOs were selected based on ranking their
For the EY-Parthenon analysis of M&A transactions, respective revenues in 2020 as obtained from either annual
transaction data was accessed from S&P Capital IQ on reports or D&B Hoovers. The following 15 companies were
January 10th, 2022. M&A transactions were considered in analyzed for internal investments: Thermo Fisher Scientific
this study if a CDMO participated as buyer, seller or target Inc, Lonza Group Ltd, Catalent, Inc., Delpharm, Samsung
(or any combination thereof) in the transaction; CDMOs Biologics Co., Ltd., Recipharm AB, Vetter Pharma-Fertigung
were classified by our analyst team as such if the companies GmbH & Co. KG, WuXi AppTec Co., Ltd., FUJIFILM Holdings
publicly offer CDMO services (CDMO services include the Corporation, Aenova Holding, Boehringer Ingelheim
research, development, manufacturing of pharmaceuticals, Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Curia, Inc., Fareva, Divis Labs,
including API manufacturing); only transactions in which Jubilant Pharmova Limited. Internal investments per
more than 50% of the target companies were acquired were company were obtained by gathering S&P Capital IQ entries,
included (according to S&P Capital IQ data). The time frame press releases, news articles, and annual report extracts, and
for the inclusion of deals was a completion date within extracting the type of investment, modality affected, and
01.01.2017 to 31.12.2021. EVs were calculated by dividing transaction value of the investment.
total transaction values by respective shares acquired in
the transaction. Ratios of EV/target revenue were based on
values reported for the last twelve months from transaction
date, transaction year, or latest available values. Transactions
involving multiple modalities were counted for each modality,
respectively.
How Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) are leading innovation for pharmaceutical partners | 27
EY | Building a better working world
Contact
EY exists to build a better working world, helping to create long-term value for
Dr. Isabelle Heiber clients, people and society and build trust in the capital markets.
Partner/Principal
Strategy and Transactions, EY-Parthenon GmbH Enabled by data and technology, diverse EY teams in over 150 countries
isabelle.heiber@parthenon.ey.com provide trust through assurance and help clients grow, transform and operate.
+49 89 14331 27062
Working across assurance, consulting, law, strategy, tax and transactions, EY
Dr. Elias Eckert teams ask better questions to find new answers for the complex issues facing
our world today.
Manager
Strategy and Transactions, EY Parthenon GmbH
EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the
elias.eckert@parthenon.ey.com member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate
+49 89 14331 12539 legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee,
does not provide services to clients. Information about how EY collects and
uses personal data and a description of the rights individuals have under data
protection legislation are available via ey.com/privacy. EY member firms do not
Authors practice law where prohibited by local laws. For more information about our
organization, please visit ey.com.
Josselin Meylan
About EY-Parthenon
Engagement Manager, Strategy and Transactions,
EY-Parthenon teams work with clients to navigate complexity by helping them to
EY-Parthenon
reimagine their eco-systems, reshape their portfolios and reinvent themselves
for a better future. With global connectivity and scale, EY-Parthenon teams
Nadja Bekele focus on Strategy Realized — helping CEOs design and deliver strategies to
Senior Consultant, Strategy Life Sciences, better manage challenges while maximizing opportunities as they look to
EY-Parthenon GmbH transform their businesses. From idea to implementation, EY-Parthenon teams
help organizations to build a better working world by fostering long-term value.
Phillip Robbers EY-Parthenon is a brand under which a number of EY member firms across the
Consultant, Strategy Life Sciences, globe provide strategy consulting services. For more information, please visit
EY-Parthenon GmbH ey.com/parthenon.
ey.com