You are on page 1of 6

2014 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics

October 5-8, 2014, San Diego, CA, USA

Detection Methods for a Low-Cost Accelerometer-


Based Approach for Driver Drowsiness Detection
Samuel Lawoyin Xin Liu Ding-Yu Fei Ou Bai
Department of Biomedical School of Transportation Department of Biomedical Department of Biomedical
Engineering Science and Engineering Engineering Engineering
Virginia Commonwealth Harbin Institute of Virginia Commonwealth Virginia Commonwealth
University Technology University University
Richmond, USA. Harbin, China Richmond, USA. Richmond, USA.
e-mail: lawoyins@vcu.edu e-mail: xinliu@hit.edu.cn e-mail: fei@vcu.edu e-mail: obai@vcu.edu

Abstract—Thousands of accidents and fatalities occur each for monitoring drowsiness that is practical for daily commuter
year due to drowsy and fatigued drivers who choose to operate use.
motor vehicles despite their reduced level of alertness. Actively
monitoring Steering Wheel Movements (SWM) has been an Researchers have proposed many methods for the
important and well documented method for the detection of detection of drowsy and fatigued driving. One proposed
drowsy driving. Despite the efficacy of the SWM method, it has method is by monitoring Steering Wheel Movements (SWM).
yet to be widely deployed widely on motor vehicles as a practical Research has determined that SWM is both an effective and
means for individual early detection due to the cost prohibitive unobtrusive method for the detection of driver drowsiness
nature of current methods as well as complexity of installation [7,8]. Researchers have consistently reported a correlation
and implementation. Due to these limitations, potentially between a driver’s frequency of steering adjustments and their
lifesaving methods based on SWM monitoring have not been level of drowsiness [9, 10]. Not only does the regularity of
widely implemented. This paper assesses the efficacy of a SWM input decrease in drowsy drivers, but when SWM inputs
proposed low-cost accelerometer-based method of SWM do occur they are large and sudden [8,11]. Researchers also
monitoring by extracting various SWM parameters and using the observed that SWM inputs in fatigued drivers have fewer
extracted data to train machine learning algorithms. micro-corrections and more macro-corrections, with sleeping
Experimental results suggest that the use of adequately trained drivers making no corrections [12,13,14]. It has been
Support Vector Machines with Accelerometer-based SWM can demonstrated that the majority of sampled drivers show an
be a valuable tool in the detection of drowsy driving and the
increasing trend towards faster and larger steering corrections
reduction in death and injuries.
as they become drowsy [8].
Keywords—drowsiness; drowsy driving; accidents; road Electroencephalography (EEG) involves recording signals
safety; highway safety from the human scalp and translating them into states of
cognition. Being able to detect signals directly from the brain
I. INTRODUCTION is the most important physiological indicator of the central
nervous system activation and alertness [15]. Having prior
It has been estimated by the National Highway Traffic knowledge of the characteristics of EEG signals and what they
Safety Administration (NHTSA) that drowsy and fatigued represent in terms of drowsiness, it is possible to monitor a
drivers are responsible for about 1,200 deaths and 76,000 driver and interpret the EEG data into a conclusive state of
injuries each year [1]. Sleep deprived drivers who choose to alertness. The human brain gives off a series of EEG
operate motor vehicles contribute to drowsy driving [2]. Other frequencies including theta waves, and alpha waves [16].
drivers were initially alert but due to prolonged driving, their Theta waves indicate slow sleep. Alpha wave activity (8-13
awareness deteriorated with time [3]. Research has shown that Hz) actually increases during periods of drowsiness while
prolonging wakefulness is just as dangerous to driver safety as theta waves (4-8 Hz) increase as during sleepy episodes.
alcohol intoxication [4]. Fourteen point five percent 14.5% of
respondents polled in Ontario Canada admitted to having Another indicator of drowsiness that has been used by
fallen asleep or nodded off while driving [5]. researchers are eyelid closures. Eyelid closures are a physical
change that can be used as an indicator of the onset of
Clinicians have used several methods such as the drowsiness. Not only is eyelid closure seen as an important
Maintenance of Wakefulness Test (MWT) for detecting indicator of drowsiness, but the duration of the closure
unintentional sleep onset and drowsiness [6]. The MWT and suggests the degree of fatigue. Closures lasting for more than
other similar tests are valid predictors of unintentional sleep half a second are especially strong indicators of sleepiness
onset, however they cannot be ported onto the roads and [17]. The percent of eyelid closure (PERCLOS) over a time
highways where the fatalities are occurring. Consequently, it interval has also been used as a method to detect drowsiness
is necessary to have a cost-effective and unobtrusive method [18].

1636 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore.


978-1-4799-3840-7/14/$31.00
Authorized licensed use limited to: ©2014 IEEE
CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November Restrictions apply.
The method proposed in this paper utilized an
accelerometer attached to the surface of a steering wheel. The
accelerometer was used as a 360° rotation sensor which B. Physiological Data Recording
monitored the angle of rotation of the steering wheel as a During the driving tasks, the participants EEG signals were
means to implement the SWM based algorithms for drowsy recorded from the Oz and the Fz channels of the International
driver detection. 4 participants were recruited and asked to 10 20 EEG mapping, where Oz and Fz are commonly used for
perform simulated driving tasks. SWM data were retrieved drowsiness and fatigue studies [19]. Electrodes were
from the accelerometer along with other traditional measures referenced to linked earlobes. The participants Horizontal
of drowsiness including EOG and EEG for a prolonged period EOG (HEOG) were recorded to track their horizontal eye
of time and then the results were compared to assess the speed and movements as they scanned the centerline and the
efficacy of the accelerometer-based SWM method for the solid lane markings they were required to remain within.. The
detection of drowsy driving. biosensors used for EEG and EOG monitoring were AgCl
electrodes. The EEG electrodes were held in their proper
The necessity for a practical and inexpensive means of locations with an electrode cap. A high definition camera was
drowsy driving monitoring is very high especially in light of used to monitor the driver’s eyes for eye closure events which
the consistently high annual figures on drowsy driving were used in supplement to validate EOG data for PERCLOS
fatalities. Despite these numbers, the fatalities continue to analysis.
occur year after year in part because there is no cost effective
and easy method to implement this drowsy driving
C. Accelerometer-based SWM monitoring
technology. The proposed method provides a simple and cost-
effective means to deploy the well-documented method of For SWM monitoring, the angle of rotation of the steering
drowsy driving detection based on SWM. Additionally, it can wheel was measured using an MPU-6050 digital
be implemented on new vehicles or retrofitted on older accelerometer (InvenSense, San Jose, California) as a 360°
vehicles which continue to be manufactured with no drowsy rotation sensor. Right turns from neutral gave positive values
driving detection mechanisms. while left turns from neutral gave negative values. A neutral
steering wheel gave a 0° reading.

II. MATERIAL AND METHOD The full method for accelerometer-based SWM detection
is described in a previous article [20]. The most important
A. Driving Tasks equation however relates the static acceleration due to gravity
measured across the accelerometer’s x-axis ( ) with that
Four participants were recruited to perform driving tasks in
measured across the y-axis ( ) according to:
a vehicle simulator setting. A steering wheel and automatic
transmission pedals were provided to the participants. The
participants were instructed to maintain a straight course of
travel in the center of the road without exiting the road as (1)
indicated by white markings on either side of the road. It was
impossible for participants to maintain a straight course on the
road center without making road exit events unless constant where was the SWM angle being estimated.
routine SWM inputs were made to maintain the course.
Participants were asked to perform 45 minutes of driving 4 The significance of the accelerometer-based method was
times for a total driving period of 180 minutes. its ability to non-intrusively monitor driver drowsiness in a
cost-effective and easy to implement manner. The two
unanswered questions remaining from the prior study were
how effective the method would be in the presence of low
frequency noise which would defeat a low pass filter, and how
effective the method would be when it is actively used for
drowsiness detection. This current paper addresses the second
question by investigating the efficacy of the method for
accurate drowsiness detection when fused with physiological
training data and when used independently.
The accelerometer-based method for SWM detection as
described in the prior study does not by itself interpret
drowsiness data. The current study demonstrates an
assessment of how the data from the accelerometer-based
approach can be correlated to individual levels of driver
drowsiness.

Fig. 1. Driving tasks required lane maintenance

1637 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


Authorized licensed use limited to: CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November
D. Training Support Vector Machine (SVM) models e) PERCLOS 80: PERCLOS indicates the number of
All physiological data, SWM data, and other metrics times per period of time that the eyes are closed. PERCLOS
measured over the total driving period of 180 minutes were values are especially high right before accidents occur [24]. In
collected once per minute yielding 180 data points for each of this case, the period of time measured was one minute. P80
was used which indicates that the eyes had to be closed at least
the 9 measures. The first 15 minutes of the first 2 driving tasks
80% to be included in the analysis.
were considered periods of alert driving, while the last 15
minutes of the final 2 driving tasks were considered to be
periods of increased drowsiness. 2) Training SVM models using only accelerometer-based
SWM predictors: After the data was classified using the 9
1) Training SVM models using all 9 measured predictors: measured predictors, a model based solely upon
All recorded features were initially used to train the SVM accelerometer-based SWM measurements was generated and
model to determine how much accuracy could be achieved then the accuracy of the model was assessed. The four
through the fusion of 9 physical, behavioral, and physiological measures of drowsiness based solely upon SWM measures
measures of drowsiness. Machine learning was performed to were:
generate a model for detecting drowsy driving. The training
predictors included accelerometer-based SWM data: the SWM a) The number of sudden SWM turns exceeding 8.3°s-1:
average amplitude of turns, SWM zero crossings, SWM During driving tasks, drowsy participants make large and
number of sudden turns, and the standard deviation of SWM. sudden rotations of the steering wheel with increasing
Non-SWM based predictors were the theta power of EEG at frequency. The threshold used to qualify large and sudden
Fz, the alpha power at Oz, the number of eye blinks per turns were those above 8.3°s-1.The number of turns which
were found in excess of 8.3°s-1 were recorded each minute.
minute, the average horizontal eye speed via HEOG, and the
perclos80 value per minute. In detail, the physiological b) The number of SWM zero crossings: As drivers
predictors of drowsiness used were: become more drowsy, their driving patterns become more
erratic as they meander within their lane and also become
a) Theta power at Fz: The theta power collected at more prone to exiting their lane. The number of SWM zero
location Fz of the International 10 20 system was used as one crossings is a way of measuring how much corrective steering
of the predictors of drowsiness. Increased theta power is being required by the drowsy driver as they attempt to
suggests that the driver is approaching a sleepy or drowsy remain in the driving lane as opposed to normal and less
episode. drastic lane maintenance SWM inputs characteristic of alert
drivers. Higher crossings of the 0° mark indicate reactive
b) Alpha power at Oz: Alpha power was collected from inputs.
the occipital region at location Oz of the International 10 20
system. An increased alpha power in EEG indicates that the c) The standard deviation of steering wheel movements:
driver is at the initial periods of reduced alertness. Increased As drivers become drowsy, their driving patterns eventually
alpha activities have been shown by researchers to indicate show signs of meandering from the lane center. This can be
increased sleepiness [21]. Alpha rhythms are known to be observed in the increased standard deviation of the SWM
increased during the transition from alertness to drowsiness recordings.
and are attenuated during alert periods [22]. Increased alpha d) The average amplitude of SWM turns: Although the
activities are a sign that mental relaxation has begun to settle total number of SWM turn inputs decrease during periods of
in, and hypovigillance could occur at this stage. A driver who drowsiness, the average amplitude of turns that do occur
continues in this relaxed stage could eventually fall into a fully increase as the SWM inputs become less frequent, but larger
drowsy state. in amplitude.
c) The number of eyeblinks per minute: Another
predictor of drowsiness used was the number of eyeblinks D. Classification of participant data into drowsiness states
observed per minute. There is a positive relationship between
drowsiness and eye blinks [23,24]. Eye blinks increase as After training the SVM models using participant data, the
drivers become more drowsy. Eyeblink frequency is newly generated models were then used to classify participant
especially high right before driving accidents occur [24]. drowsy driver.
Eyeblinking could also be considered as a behavioral predictor
of drowsiness. 1) Assessing the SVM classification of drowsiness via 9
measures: Using the models created earlier for each
d) The average horizontal eye speed via HEOG: As participant using the 9 physical, behavioral, and physiological
drivers become more drowsy, it is expected that their eye
measures of drowsiness, we tested the accuracy of the model
speed of scanning the road will change with time [25]. The
for use in determining a drivers state of drowsiness. C-support
average eye speed per minute was used as a predictor of
vector classifications [26] were the models of SVM used. The
drowsiness.
SVM kernel functions used was the Radial Basis Function

1638 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


Authorized licensed use limited to: CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November
(RBF). For validation of the method, 10 fold cross validation Participant 4
was used. Accuracy = 71.67%
Sensitivity = 63.33%
2) Assessing the SVM classification of drowsiness using Specificity = 80.00%
only accelerometer-based SWM measures: In order for the
True positive True negative False positive False negative
accelerometer-based drowsiness detection method to be as
19 24 6 11
simple and non-invasive as possible, it was necessary for the
system to eventually be completely independent from
physiological measures which can be complicated and
intrusive. The SVM models generated were using to test the B. SVM Classification of drowsiness using only
accuracy of the system. accelerometer-based SWM predictors
The 4 SWM based predictor variables were used to train the The Validation of drowsiness detection using only
SVM used for classification. C-support vector classification accelerometer based SWM predictors were performed to
was the model of SVM used. Radial Basis Function (RBF) determine the models accuracy when run independent of
kernels were used for classification. clinical measures as is the case in normal commutes.

III. RESULTS

A. SVM Classification of drowsiness using 9 training


predictors
Using a combination of physiological, behavioral, and
physical classifiers, the model was fed with validation data for
detecting drowsy driving. We used c-SVC models to train the
SVM models used for classifying drowsiness based on 9
predictors.
Using 10 fold cross validation and a Radial Basis
Function, the accuracy of classified data was found to have an
accuracy as high as 100.00%. Table I shows the properties of
the classifications.

Fig. 1. Drowsy SWM (above) is more sudden and of higher amplitudes than
alert SWM (below)

TABLE I. SVM OUTCOMES USING ALL 9 PREDICTORS


Using only the 4 SWM vectors namely: (1) the number of
10 Fold Cross Validation, Radial Basis Function, c-SVC sudden SWM turns exceeding 8.3°s-1, (2) the number of SWM
Participant 1 zero crossings, (3) the standard deviation of steering wheel
Accuracy = 100.00% movements, and (4) the average amplitude of turns, the trained
Sensitivity = 100.00% SVM achieved an accuracy as high as 100.00% drowsiness
Specificity = 100.00% detection when subjected to a 10 fold cross-validation as
shown in Table II.
True positive True negative False positive False negative
Results showed a generally good record of true negative
30 30 0 0 and true positive detections.
Participant 2
Accuracy = 80.00%
Sensitivity = 76.67%
Specificity = 83.33%
TABLE II. SVM VALIDATION USING ONLY 4 SWM PREDICTORS
True positive True negative False positive False negative
23 25 5 7 10 Fold Cross Validation, Radial Basis Function, c-SVC
Participant 3 Participant 1
Accuracy = 100.00% Accuracy = 76.67%
Sensitivity = 100.00% Sensitivity = 80.00%
Specificity = 100.00% Specificity = 73.33%
True positive True negative False positive False negative True positive True negative False positive False negative

30 30 0 0 24 22 8 6

1639 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


Authorized licensed use limited to: CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November
Participant 2 classifier was able to more accurately (71.67%) detect
Accuracy = 68.33% drowsiness in the same subject before drowsy symptoms had
Sensitivity = 63.33% begun to surface in steering behaviors.
Specificity = 73.33% In situations, such as was observed in the case of participant
True positive True negative False positive False negative
4, where a drivers steering behaviors are very similar in their
alert and drowsy states, the classifier will face increased
19 22 8 11
challenges while attempting to sort the behaviors across a fine
Participant 3 line between the 2 categories. This can be helped by training
Accuracy = 100.00% the classifier with a much larger number of data rows,
Sensitivity = 100.00% including those taken when the subject was fully drowsy and
Specificity = 100.00% not just marginally so. Certain individuals driving patterns
True positive True negative False positive False negative might also call for fine tuning of the kernel used and also the
30 30 0 0 type of SVM used.
Participant 4
This paper demonstrated that there is a cost-effective,
Accuracy = 43.33% efficacious, and accurate way to implement wide-scale drowsy
Sensitivity = 40.00% driving detection. The method is non-intrusive and does not
Specificity = 46.67% require any complex installations or modifications.
Effective detection of drowsy driving by accelerometer-
True positive True negative False positive False negative based SWM monitoring could be used to prevent the
12 14 16 18 thousands of accidents, injuries and fatalities that continue to
occur annually.
 In comparison to another known drowsiness detection
studies using SWM and machine learning, Eskandarian and
IV. CONCLUSION Sayed achieved an accuracy of 90% while training drowsy
SWM data using Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) [27]. The
This paper examined the efficacy of accelerometer-based
training data was based upon the simple concept that in an
SWM monitoring as a method for drowsy driving detection.
alert state, drivers make small amplitude movements of the
The machine learning outcomes observed by feeding the
steering wheel, while in a drowsy state, steering wheel
training data of 4 drivers into a support Vector Machine
movements become less precise and larger in amplitude [28].
suggested potential of the method for the prediction of drowsy
In the future, a larger number of participants will be
driving solely by SWM data.
recruited to improve upon the results of this preliminary study.
The combination of SWM training data with physiological
and behavioral data showed promising results, however the
ability to train Support Vector machines for the detection of REFERENCES
driver drowsiness using only the proposed accelerometer- [1] P. Rau. NHTSA’s drowsy driver research program. Washington DC:
based method is the most promising outcome due to its National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 1996.
practicality, ease of execution, and cost-effective nature. In [2] J. Connor, R. Norton, S. Ameratunga, E. Robinson, I. Civil, R. Dunn, J.
Bailey and R. Jackson. Driver sleepiness and risk of serious injury to car
addition, the classification accuracy of the method was occupants: Population based case control study. Bmj 324(7346), pp.
generally high. 1125. 2002.
The use of only 60 data points for each of the 4 participants [3] P. Hamblin. Lorry driver's time habits in work and their involvement in
traffic accidents. Ergonomics 30(9), pp. 1323-1333. 1987.
yielded very promising results considering the scarcity of [4] A. W. MacLean, D. R. Davies and K. Thiele. The hazards and
training data. The future use of a larger training set from prevention of driving while sleepy. Sleep Medicine Reviews 7(6), pp.
participants is expected to yield stronger SVM models for 507-521. 2003.
drowsiness classification which will make accelerometer- [5] W. Vanlaar, H. Simpson, D. Mayhew and R. Robertson. Fatigued and
Drowsy Driving: Attitudes, Concerns and Practices of Ontario Drivers
based SWM monitoring of drowsiness detection a much more 2007.
effective and accurate tool for use in the detection of drowsy [6] J. Virkkala, J. Hasan, A. Värri, S. Himanen and M. Härmä. The use of
driving. two-channel electro-oculography in automatic detection of unintentional
sleep onset. J. Neurosci. Methods 163(1), pp. 137-144. 2007.
The highest classification accuracy using only [7] R. Sayed and A. Eskandarian. Unobtrusive drowsiness detection by
accelerometer-based SWM was 100.00% while the lowest neural network learning of driver steering. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Pt. D:
classification accuracy was 43.33%. This could be due to the J. Automobile Eng. 215(9), pp. 969-975. 2001.
[8] P. Thiffault and J. Bergeron. Monotony of road environment and driver
scarcity of training data. Also, each participant’s reaction to fatigue: A simulator study. Accident Analysis & Prevention 35(3), pp.
prolonged driving was unique. Participant 4 had not become 381-391. 2003.
sufficiently drowsy within 180 minutes of driving for the signs [9] J. Fukuda, E. Akutsu and K. Aoki. An estimation of driver's drowsiness
level using interval of steering adjustment for lane keeping. JSAE Rev.
to show up in their driving behaviors. Using 9 predictive 16(2), pp. 197-199. 1995.
values with physiological signals including EEG data, the

1640 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


Authorized licensed use limited to: CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November
[10] M. Elling and P. Sherman. Evaluation of steering wheel measures for
drowsy drivers. Proceedings of the 27th ISATA, Aachen, Germany pp.
207-214. 1994.
[11] G. Borghini, L. Astolfi, G. Vecchiato, D. Mattia and F. Babiloni.
Measuring neurophysiological signals in aircraft pilots and car drivers
for the assessment of mental workload, fatigue and drowsiness.
Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 2012.
[12] K. Yabuta, H. Iizuka, T. Yanagishima, Y. Kataoka and T. Seno. The
development of drowsiness warning devices. Presented at Proceedings
10 Th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety
Vehicles, Washington. 1985.
[13] A. Eskandarian and A. Mortazavi. Evaluation of a smart algorithm for
commercial vehicle driver drowsiness detection. Presented at Intelligent
Vehicles Symposium, 2007 IEEE. 2007, .
[14] D. Chaput, C. Petit, S. Planque and C. Tarrière. Un système embarqué
de détection de l'hypovigilance. Journées d’études: Le Maintien De La
Vigilance Dans Les Transports.Lyon, France, INRETS, Lyon, France
1990.
[15] A. Eskandarian, R. Sayed, P. Delaigue, A. Mortazavi and J. Blum.
Advanced Driver Fatigue Research 2007.
[16] T. Åkerstedt and M. Gillberg. Subjective and objective sleepiness in the
active individual. Int. J. Neurosci. 52(1-2), pp. 29-37. 1990.
[17] K. Ogawa and M. Shimotani. A drowsiness detection system. Mitsubishi
Electric Advance pp. 13-16. 1997.
[18] W. Wierwille. Historical perspective on slow eyelid closure: Whence
PERCLOS. Presented at Ocular Measures of Driver Alertness, Technical
Conference Proceedings. 1999, .
[19] R. N. Khushaba, S. Kodagoda, S. Lal and G. Dissanayake. Driver
drowsiness classification using fuzzy wavelet-packet-based feature-
extraction algorithm. Biomedical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on
58(1), pp. 121-131. 2011.
[20] S. A. Lawoyin, D.Y. Fei, and O. Bai. Accelerometer-based steering
wheel movement monitoring for drowsy driving detection. Proceedings
of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of
Automobile Engineering, in press.
[21] L. Torsvall and T. åAkerstedt. Sleepiness on the job: Continuously
measured EEG changes in train drivers. Electroencephalogr. Clin.
Neurophysiol. 66(6), pp. 502-511. 1987.
[22] S. K. Lal and A. Craig. Electroencephalography activity associated with
driver fatigue: Implications for a fatigue countermeasure device. Journal
of Psychophysiology 15(3), pp. 183. 2001.
[23] A. Picot, A. Caplier and S. Charbonnier. Comparison between EOG and
high frame rate camera for drowsiness detection. Presented at
Applications of Computer Vision (WACV), 2009 Workshop on. 2009, .
[24] C. Papadelis, Z. Chen, C. Kourtidou-Papadeli, P. D. Bamidis, I.
Chouvarda, E. Bekiaris and N. Maglaveras. Monitoring sleepiness with
on-board electrophysiological recordings for preventing sleep-deprived
traffic accidents. Clinical Neurophysiology 118(9), pp. 1906-1922. 2007.
[25] D. Shin, H. Sakai and Y. Uchiyama. Slow eye movement detection can
prevent sleepǦrelated accidents effectively in a simulated driving task. J.
Sleep Res. 20(3), pp. 416-424. 2011.
[26] C. Chang and C. Lin. LIBSVM: A library for support vector machines.
ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology (TIST) 2(3),
pp. 27. 2011.
[27] L. Barr, S. Popkin and H. Howarth. A review and evaluation of
emerging driver fatigue detection measures and technologies. National
Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge.US Department of
Transportation, Washington.Disponível Em<
Http://www.Ecse.Rpi.Edu/~ qji/Fatigue/fatigue_report_dot.Pdf 2005.
[28] A. Eskandarian and R. Sayed. “Driving Simulator Experiment:
Detecting Driver Fatigue by Monitoring Eye and Steering Activity,”
PowerPoint presentation, NDIA 3rd Annual Intelligent Vehicle Systems
Symposium, Traverse City, MI, 2005

1641 15,2023 at 16:52:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


Authorized licensed use limited to: CINVESTAV. Downloaded on November

You might also like