Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GABAB Receptor Agonists and Antagonists Pharmacological Properties and Therapeutic Possibilities
GABAB Receptor Agonists and Antagonists Pharmacological Properties and Therapeutic Possibilities
SJ Enna
To cite this article: SJ Enna (1997) GABAB receptor agonists and antagonists: pharmacological
properties and therapeutic possibilities, Expert Opinion on Investigational Drugs, 6:10, 1319-1325,
DOI: 10.1517/13543784.6.10.1319
1319
1997 © Ashley Publications Ltd. ISSN 1354-3784
1320 GABAB receptor agonists and antagonists - Enna
Figure 1: Selected GABAB agonists. advances have led to a better definition of the GABAB
receptor and have helped define the therapeutic po-
tential of compounds that interact with this site. Now
that the receptor has been cloned, the tempo of
discovery may increase further, resulting in new in-
sights about the biological and pharmacological diver-
O
O sity of GABA receptors in general, and GABAB
H2N P CH
H2N P H 3 receptors in particular.
OH
OH
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)
Central & Peripheral Nervous Systems - Editorial 1321
induced late-phase pain response, administration of a furan-2-yl-GABA derivatives, all of which have rela-
GABAB receptor antagonist alone does not enhance tively low affinities for the receptor and are ineffective
pain, suggesting that endogenous GABA systems are following systemic administration [29-32]. Structure-ac-
not active under these conditions. The effect of GABAB tivity studies with phosphinic GABAB receptor agonists
agonists on substance P release and neurokinin recep- revealed that ethylphosphinic acid, and higher homo-
tor expression in the spinal cord is similar to that logues, are receptor antagonists (Figure 2; [16]). While
observed with morphine [28]. the initial members of this group, such as CGP 36742,
CGP 35348 and CGP 46381, displayed relatively low
affinities (µM) for the GABAB receptor (Figure 2,
3. GABAB receptor antagonists
Table 1), many were useful since they are active
Once GABAB receptors were identified, efforts were following systemic administration [17]. A dramatic in-
immediately undertaken to design antagonists for this crease in receptor affinity for phosphinic acid antago-
site. Initial attempts yielded phosphonic and sulfonic nists was noted when certain benzyl substituents were
acid analogues of baclofen as well as 3-benzo[b] placed on the nitrogen. Thus, compounds such as CGP
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)
1322 GABAB receptor agonists and antagonists - Enna
O O O
O COOH
H2N P O H2N P H2N P
HO O HO N
HO H
Cl Cl Cl
O OH O OH O
H H H
N P O N P N P
Cl Cl Cl
HO HO HO
O
125
COOH I COOH
N3 OH
OH O OH O
H H H H
N P N N P N 125
I
HO HO
O OH O
52432, CGP 54062, and CGP 54626 display IC50 values blocks the inhibitory response to baclofen in isolated
in the low nM range as inhibitors of GABAB receptor guinea-pig trachea and the antitussive effect of
binding (Figure 2, Table 1). Moreover, addition of a baclofen in both guinea-pigs and cats [33]. In addition,
substituted phenylpropionylamino (CGP 64213) or SCH 50911, CGP 46381, CGP 35348 and CGP 36742 all
benzoylamino (CGP 71872) moiety on the phosphinic block absence seizures in a variety of animal models,
acid side-chain yielded antagonists with high affinities and CGP 36742 significantly improves cognitive per-
(~ 1 nM) for the receptor and which can be labelled formance in rodents and primates [36-38,40].
with 125I (Figure 2, Table 1). In addition, CGP 71872
is used as a photoaffinity label for the GABAB site [14].
Using a different synthetic approach it was discovered 4. Therapeutic applications
that 2,5 disubstituted-1,4-morpholines, such as SCH
50911, as well as thiomorpholines, have GABAB recep- Baclofen has been employed for decades as a muscle
tor antagonist properties (Figure 2) [33]. While mem- relaxant to treat spasticity and skeletal muscle rigidity,
bers of this series are orally active, their affinities for with sedation being the major side-effect associated
the GABAB receptor are relatively low in comparison with its use. Although baclofen displays significant
with some of the phosphinic acid derivatives (Table analgesic activity in laboratory animals, it has not been
1). Because of their structure, these compounds are found to be clinically useful in this regard. While the
particularly useful pharmacophores for modelling the reasons for this difference between species are un-
GABAB receptor [34]. known, it is possible that tolerance develops rapidly
to the analgesic effect or that the analgesic dose in
The GABAB receptor antagonists are active in a variety humans is far above that necessary for profound
of biochemical and behavioural tests. Thus, both CGP sedation and skeletal muscle relaxation. If, as seems
55845 and CGP 52432 enhance the evoked release of likely, there are pharmacologically and functionally
neurotransmitter from rat spinal cord tissue and block distinct GABAB receptors, it may be possible to de-
baclofen-induced inhibition of this response, indicat- velop a receptor agonist with greater selectivity for
ing that this transmitter release is regulated by presy- sites mediating analgesic responses, as compared to
naptic GABAB receptors [35]. Moreover, SCH 50911 those responsible for sedation and muscle relaxation
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)
Central & Peripheral Nervous Systems - Editorial 1323
[20,41,42]. Such an agent may be particularly useful for little evidence yet to suggest that these sites are of
treating types of back pain that would benefit from a physiological consequence.
combined muscle relaxant/analgesic.
The development of GABAB receptor antagonists, and
As there are GABAB receptors on peripheral neurones the cloning of this receptor, may herald the arrival of
there is speculation that antagonists may be of benefit a new class of drugs. While the therapeutic possibilities
in treating a variety of conditions, including asthma, are numerous given their mechanism of action, clinical
bowel and bladder dysfunction [21]. However, until data are necessary to provide an appropriate perspec-
GABAB agonists selective for peripheral receptors are tive for their use.
identified, it may be difficult to demonstrate the supe-
riority of this approach over current therapies.
There is a great deal of interest in identifying therapeu-
Bibliography
tic uses for GABAB receptor antagonists, given their Papers of special note have been highlighted as:
novel mechanism of action. Data suggest they may be • of interest
of value for treating a variety of neurological and •• of considerable interest
psychiatric conditions, including absence epilepsy and 1. ENNA SJ: Gamma-aminobutyric acid A receptor subunits
cognitive impairments. Based on their neurochemical • in the mediation of selective drug action. Curr. Opin.
Neurol. Neurosurg. (1993) 6:597-601.
effects, it is possible they may be of value in treating
Overview of GABA A receptors.
anxiety and depression, and in protecting the brain
from neuronal damage associated with ischaemia [21]. 2. KROGSGAARD-LARSEN P, FROLUND B, BJARKE E: GABAA
receptor agonists, partial agonists, and antagonists. In:
The GABA Receptors (2nd Edition). Enna SJ, Bowery NG
(Eds.), Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey (1997):37-81.
5. Future prospects 3. MÖHLER H, BENKE D, BENSEN J et al.: Diversity in
structure, pharmacology, and regulation of GABAA re-
The discovery of GABAB receptors has opened new ceptors. In: The GABA Receptors (2nd Edition). Enna SJ,
possibilities for the development of chemically and Bowery NG (Eds.), Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey
(1997):11-36.
mechanistically novel therapeutic agents for the treat-
ment of conditions ranging from asthma to memory 4. CURTIS DR, GAME CJA, JOHNSTON GAR, MCCULLOCH RM:
impairment. While significant progress has been made Central effects of β-(p-chlorophenyl)-γ-aminobutyric
acid. Brain Res. (1974) 70:493-499.
regarding the chemistry and biology of this system,
much work remains to exploit these findings. In 5. DAVIES J, WATKINS JC: The action of β-phenyl-GABA
particular, it is crucial to determine whether there are derivatives on neurones of the cat cerebral cortex. Brain
Res. (1974) 70:501-505.
pharmacologically distinct GABAB receptors. Although
biochemical studies with GABAB agonists and antago- 6. BOWERY NG, HUDSON AL: γ-Aminobutyric acid reduces
the evoked release of 3H-noradrenaline from sympa-
nists suggest the existence of such sites, and experi-
thetic nerve terminals. Br. J. Pharmacol. (1979) 66:108P.
ence with other neurotransmitter receptors predicts the
presence of multiple subtypes, it will be difficult to 7. BOWERY NG, DOBLE A, HILL DR et al.: Bicuculline-insen-
sitive GABA receptors on peripheral autonomic nerve
assess fully the therapeutic benefit of GABAB receptor terminals. Eur. J. Pharmacol. (1981) 71:53-70.
agonists and antagonists until there are definitive data,
8. HILL DR, BOWERY NG, HUDSON AL: Inhibition of GABAB
in this regard. With the recent cloning of a GABAB
receptor binding by guanyl nucleotides. J. Neurochem.
receptor [14], it should be possible to address this issue (1984) 42:652-657.
directly. Indeed, it is notable that what appears to be
9. HILL DR: GABAB receptor modulation of adenylate cy-
a second GABAB receptor has been cloned which clase activity in rat brain slices. Br. J. Pharmacol. (1985)
shares virtually no sequence homology and which 84:249-257.
displays a somewhat different localisation in brain and
10. KARBON EW, DUMAN RS, ENNA SJ: GABAB receptors and
immunoreactivity than the receptor cloned earlier [43; norepinephrine stimulated cAMP production in rat
Kenya Kuriyama, Personal communication]. brain cortex. Brain Res. (1984) 306:327-332.
While it seems likely that GABAB antagonists, like 11. KARBON EW, ENNA SJ: Characterization of the relation-
GABAA agonists, will yield clinical benefits by their ship between gamma-aminobutyric acid B agonists and
transmitter-coupled cyclic nucleotide-generating sys-
direct action in the central nervous system, it is ques- tems in rat brain. Mol. Pharmacol. (1985) 27:53-59.
tionable whether either type of agent will be of value
12. GÄHWILER BH, BROWN DA: GABAB receptor-activated
in treating dysfunctions of peripheral organs. Thus,
K+ current in voltage-clamped CA3 pyramidal cells in
while pharmacologically responsive GABAB receptors hippocampal slices. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA (1985)
are located in peripheral organs and tissue, there is 82:1558-1562.
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)
1324 GABAB receptor agonists and antagonists - Enna
13. DOLPHIN AC, HUSTON E, SCOTT RH: GABAB-mediated GABA receptor agonists THIP and baclofen. Neurophar-
inhibition of calcium currents: a possible role in presy- macology (1985) 24:211-216.
naptic inhibition. In: GABAB Receptors in Mammalian
Function. Bowery NG, Bittiger H, Olpe HR (Eds.), Wiley, 27. SMITH GD, HARRISON SM, BIRCH PJ et al.: Increased
Chichester (1990):259-271. sensitivity to the antinociceptive activity of (+/-)-
baclofen in an animal model of chronic neuropathic,
14. KAUPMANN K, HUGGEL K, HEID J et al.: Expression but not chronic inflammatory, hyperalgesia. Neurophar-
• cloning of GABAB receptors uncovers similarity to macology (1994) 33:1103-1108.
metabotropic glutamate receptors. Nature (1 997)
386:239-246. 28. MCCARSON KE, KRAUSE JE: The formalin-induced ex-
Description of the cloning of GABAB receptors. pression of tachykinin peptide and neurokinin recep-
tor mRNAs in rat sensory ganglia and spinal cord is
15. FROESTL W, MICKEL SJ, HALL RG et al.: Phosphinic acid modulated by opiate preadministration. Neuroscience
• analogues of GABA. 1. New potent and selective GABAB (1995) 64:729-739.
agonists. J. Med. Chem. (1995) 38:3297-3312.
Comprehensive description of the chemistry of GABAB receptor 29. KERR DIB, ONG J, PRAGER RH, GYNTHER, BD, CURTIS DR:
agonists. Phaclofen: a peripheral and central baclofen antago-
nist. Brain Res. (1987) 405:150-154.
16. FROESTL W, MICKEL SJ, VON SPRECHEN G et al.:
• Phosphinic acid analogues of GABA. 2. Selective, orally 30. KERR DIB, ONG J, JOHNSTON GAR, ABBENANTE J,
active GABAB antagonists. J. Med. Chem. (1995) 38:3313- PRAGER RH: Antagonism of GABAB receptors by
3331. saclofen and related sulfonic analogues of baclofen and
Comprehensive description of the chemistry of GABAB receptor GABA. Neurosci. Lett. (1989) 107:239-244.
antagonists.
31. KERR DIB, ONG J, JOHNSTON GAR, ABBENANTE J,
17. FROESTL W, MICKEL SJ: Chemistry of GABAB modulators. PRAGER RH: 2-Hydroxy-saclofen: an improved antago-
In: The GABA Receptors (2nd Edition). Enna SJ, Bowery NG nist at central and peripheral GABAB receptors. Neuro-
(Eds.), Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey (1997):271-296. sci. Lett. (1988) 92:9296.
18. NAKAYASU H, NISHIKAWA M, MIZUTEMI H et al.: Immu- 32. BERTHELOT P, VACCHER C, MUSADAD A et al.: Synthesis
noaffinity purification and characterization of γ-ami- and pharmacological evaluation of γ-aminobutyric acid
nobutyric acid (GABA)B receptor from bovine cerebral analogues. New ligands for GABAB sites. J. Med. Chem.
cortex. J. Biol. Chem. (1993) 268:8658-8664. (1987) 30:743-746.
19. FROESTL W, MICKEL SJ, BITTIGER H: Potent GABAB 33. BOLSER DC, BLYTHIN DJ, CHAPMAN R et al.: The pharma-
agonists and antagonists. Curr. Opin. Ther. Patents (1993) cology of SCH-50911: a novel, orally-active GABA-B
3:561-567. receptor antagonist. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. (1995)
20. GEMIGNANI A, PAUDICE P, BONANNO G, RAITERI M: 274:1393-1348.
Phar macological discriminati on be twee n γ-ami-
34. FRYDENVANG K, ENNA SJ, KROGSGAARD-LARSEN P: (-)
nobutyric acid type B receptors regulating cholecystok-
(R)-5,5-Dimethylmorpholinyl-2-acetic acid ethyl ester
inin and somatostatin release from rat neocortex
hydrochloride. Acta Cryst. (1997). (In Press).
synaptosomes. Mol. Pharmacol. (1994) 46:558-562.
35. TEOH H, MALCANGIO M, BOWERY NG: GABA, glutamate
21. MALCANGIO M, BOWERY NG: Possible therapeutic ap-
• and substance P-like immunoreactivity release: effects
plication of GABAB receptor agonists and antagonists.
Clin. Neuropharmacol. (1995) 18:285-305. of novel GABAB antagonists. Br. J. Pharmacol. (1996)
Review of therapeutic possibilities for GABAB agonists and antago- 118:1153-1160.
nists. 36. HOSFORD DA, WANG Y, LIU CC, SNEAD OC: Charac-
22. CHAPMAN RW, DANKO G, DEL PRADO M et al.: Further terization of the antiabsence effects of SCH 50911, a
evidence for prejunctional GABA-B inhibition of cholin- GABA-B receptor antagonist, in the lethargic mouse,
ergic and peptidergic bronchoconstriction in guinea gamma-hydroxybutyrate, and pentylenetetrazole mod-
pigs: studies with new agonists and antagonists. Phar- els. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. (1995) 274:1399-1403.
macology (1993) 46:315-323.
37. BERNASCONI R, LAUBER J, MARESCAUX C et al.: Experi-
23. CHAPMAN RW, RIZZO CA, EGAN RW et al.: Antiallergy and mental absence seizures: potential role of gamma-hy-
antitussive activities of GABAB agonists. Pharmacol. droxybutyric acid and GABA-B receptors. J. Neural Trans.
Comm. (1992) 2:117-119. (1992) 35:155-177.
24. MCCARSON KE, ENNA SJ: Relationship between GABAB 38. MARESCAUX C, LIU Z, BERNASCONI R, VERGNES M: GABAB
receptor activation and neurokinin receptor expres- receptors are involved in the occurrence of absence
sion in spinal cord. Pharmacol. Rev. Comm. (1996) 8:191- seizures. Pharmacol. Comm. (1992) 2:57-62.
194.
39. BITTIGER H, FROESTL W, MICKEL SJ, OLPE HR: GABAB
25. MALCANGIO M, BOWER NG: Gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor antagonists: from synthesis to therapeutic
B, but not gamma-aminobutyric acid A, receptor activa- applications. Trends Pharmacol. Sci. (1993) 14:391-394.
tion inhibits electrically evoked substance P-like im-
munoreactivity release from the rat spinal cord in vitro. 40. MONDADORI C, PREISWERK G, JACKEL J: Treatment with
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. (1993) 266:1490-1496. • GABAB receptor blocker improves the cognitive per-
formance of mice, rats and rhesus monkeys. Pharmacol.
26. VAUGHT JL, PELLEY K, COSTA LG, SETTER P, ENNA SJ: A Comm. (1992) 2:93-97.
comparison of the antinociceptive responses to the Description of cognitive effects of GABAB antagonists.
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)
Central & Peripheral Nervous Systems - Editorial 1325
SJ Enna
Department of Pharmacology, Toxicology and Therapeutics, Univer-
sity of Kansas, Medical School, 3901 Rainbow Boulevard, Kansas
City, Kansas 66160, USA
(Tel: +1 913 588 7500; Fax: +1 913 588 7501;
Email: senna@kumc.edu)
© Ashley Publications Ltd. All rights reserved. Exp. Opin. Invest. Drugs (1997) 6(10)