Republic of the Philippines

Kolehiyo ng Lungsod ng Lipa

Marawoy, Lipa City
College of Teacher Education

PROPOSAL DEFENSE GRADING SHEET – Group ___

Members: _______________, ________________, _______________
____________________,__________________,_________________
CRITERIA WEIGHT RATING WEIGHTED
AVERAGE
1 CONTENT 50%
The thesis shows clarity, organization,
consistency of thought and ideas from the
first chapter to the last and possesses
adequate and substantial information to
explain the problem.
Descriptive Rating 30% Nominal Rating
No revision on content 92-100
Minor revision (correction on content from Chapters 1-3) 83-91
Major revision (correction on content from Chapters 1-3) 75-82
Total revision (failure) below 75

2 ORAL PRESENTATION

The students show effective presentation skills,

answer questions, and defend their points
effectively. Please indicate the individual rating
opposite the name of each group member.

Descriptive Rating Nominal Rating

Excellent 98-100
Superior 95-97
Very Good 92-94
Above Average 89-91
Good 86-88
Average 83-85
Satisfactory 80-82
Fair 77-79
Passing 75-76
Failure below 75
3 QUALITY OF WRITTEN REPORT 20%
The components of the report are well-knit
and technical style is adequate.
Note: Rating for this criterion is the same as the rating used for oral presentation.
OVERALL RATING 100%
Weighted Average = Rating X Weight
Overall Rating is the summation of all weighted average.

___________________________
Evaluator’s Signature