Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions: (Judaism, Christianity and Islam)
A Comparative Study
Supervised by :
Master of Arts
(Islamic Studies)
July 2020
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
2
Abstract
Almost all God’s creatures are in pairs, both concrete and abstract, animates and
inanimate. Homosapiens are males and females. There is at least a divine purpose
behind every creation and numerous benefits accompanying divine legislations. Men
and women were created with the same soul but the different in their anatomy and
physical structure. This difference does not in any way make one inferior or superior to
the other. It is a mere suggestion of different roles and responsibilities of each at home
and in the society at large. However, failure to sincerely recognize and appreciate this
simple fact has created a lot of gender challenges to the world over decades. Women
are being treated differently across cultures and religions. The Western world therefore
perceives most of the cultural and religious approach towards women as a form of
cruelty and injustice. As a result, they embark on campaign for emancipation of women,
gender equality (in spite that, male and female compete separately at Olympic and
other sport events), woman rights, liberalism etc. Hence, this work attempts to examine
the rights of women in the three Abrahamic religions with emphasis on marriage,
polygyny, divorce inheritance and their similarities and differences. It uses the religions’
Sacred Books as the main source of information as well as literatures of both classical
and contemporary scholars.This thesis would therefore be a source of enlightenment
especially to female.
CHAPTER ONE
CHAPTER TWO
2.0 Literature Review Women’s Position and Rights in the ancient civilization (From
Religious Perspectives)
CHAPTER THREE:
3.0. Position and Status of Women according to the Three Abrahamic Religions
4.6.1. Divorce
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
6
5.0. Inheritance
6.2. Conclusion
6.3. Recommendations
CHAPTER ONE
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
8
Undoubtedly, women constitute an integral part of the society and their impacts
are greater than their population. Throughout the human history, the evidence shows
that they contributed immensely in various sectors according to their positions for the
well-being of humanity. In contemporary time, the western secularized views of
feminism, modernism, gender equality and liberalism deprive them of their dignity and
metamorphosed them as ‘cheap commodities and objects of advertisement’. There are
also issues, which undermine the rights of women such as maltreatment of women by
the usage of religions, neglect of girl child, selective abortion, empowerment of women,
socio-political freedom, professional freedom and so on. The present study investigates
the positions of women and their rights according to the three Abrahamic religions in
contemporary context.
The main objective of this study is to examine the position of women and their
rights, specially, the study aimed:
i. To discuss the position and rights of women in accordance with the three
Abrahamic religions
iii. To evaluate the basic rights of women in various sectors and sphere i.e.
inheritance, husband and wife’s relations, education, social-political
freedom, economics, and professional occupations in contemporary context
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
9
iv. To examine the similarities and differences among the three religions i.e.
Christianity, Judaism and Islam
This research poses the following questions to meet the objectives of the study.
i. What are the concepts of women’s position and rights according to the
three Abrahamic religions?
ii. What are the concepts of marriage and divorce ,their importance,
principles, conditions and effects in accordance with three religions?
iii. What are the basic rights of women in various sectors and sphere as
inheritance, husband and wife relations, education, socio-political freedom,
economics and professional occupations?
iv. What are the similarities and differences among the three religions i.e.
Christianity, Judaism and Islam ?
This research employs a qualitative approach to collect the materials and analyze
them. Library research will also be conducted from virtual library, books and articles will
be downloaded. Other literature of both classical and contemporary scholars will be
reviewed in this context. Also, audio-visual recorded lectures of seasoned comparative
preachers on this topic will be analyzed. Lastly, a comprehensive comparative study of
the literature will be done, highlighting women’s rights in the three religions i.e.
Christianity, Judaism and Islam.
From the foregoing, it is evident that there have been a lot of attentions on women’s
right feminism. Yet, much has not really been done comparatively on it. Hence, this
study will fill some of the gaps and also serve as enlightenment to women of the three
religions.
CHAPTER TWO
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
10
This chapter discusses and examines the literature review related to the study on
the positions and rights of women described in three religions i.e. Christianity, Judaism
and Islam. There is an exhaustive list of previous studies which discuss the issues
pertinent to the issues for this research. Historical backgrounds of the three religions
about women’s rights will be provided and some extensive researches have been done
in many aspects of women’s study. This chapter elaborates on women’s rights in the
Ancient civilizations from religious perspectives. In addition, this review also addresses
some differences about women’s positions and rights among the three Abrahamic
religions with focus on women’s position and rights according to the ancient
civilizations, women’s marriage, divorce, gender equality, and other aspects of life
discussed according to three religions.
The 9th edition of the Oxford Advance learner’s Dictionary defines religion as one of
the system of faith that are based on the belief in the existence of a particular god or
gods ,or in the teaching of a spiritual leader ;the Jewish religion, Christianity, Islam and
other word religions.
Fortunately, the three religions mentioned are the center of this study and also
monotheistic. They believe in the same Supreme Being; God, Allah and Eloah. Though,
they worship Him in different manners as dictated in by their respective Holy Scriptures
cum doctrines.
Menachem Posner (2020) defined Judaism as the whole set of beliefs and practices
of the Jewish people as given by God, recorded in the Pentateuch and other sacred
writings of Judaism (Menachem, P. 2020). According to history.com, it is the oldest of
the three monotheistic religions dating back to 4,000 years, Christianity 2020 years and
Islam 1442 years (www.history.com 2020).
It is the belief of Jewish people that God is the sole Creator and administrator of the
universe who has no children, rivals or helpers. He is omniscient. That God gave human
beings free will so that He can reward or punish each individual in this life or after death
accordingly. From the belief of Jewish people is long awaited Messiah from the
descendant of King David who will orchestrate the era of eternal peace and Godly
awareness. This messiah will lead the Jewish people back to the promise land and will
reconstruct the Holy Temple in Jerusalem and there shall be no death again
(Menanchem, P. 2020). However, there are some Jews who do not belief in the coming
of Messiah (www.history.com 2020).
2.1.2 Founder of Judaism as Jews, and their belief Judaism. Also Jacob was identified as
Israel and his children Israelites (www.history.com and Menachem P. 2020).
Through Isaac, the Jewish people are descendants of Abraham whom God had made
covenant of becoming a great nation. Despite this, for hundreds of years, the Jewish
people (Israelite) suffered a great deal as slaves in Egypt under Pharaoh. After their
divine emancipation through Moses, they wondered for four decades in the wilderness
before entering their promised land where they built a Holy Temple in Jerusalem which
was annihilated around 587 BC. The Babylonians and pushed the Jewish people into
exile. It was rebuilt and further destroyed by the Roman invaders in 70AD (Menachem,
P. 2020)
According to history.com, the Jewish sacred book Tanakh which is also known as
“Hebrew Bible” is the same as the Old Testament, the Torah. It formed the basis for
other manuscripts which interpreted and documented oral laws. And Mishnah was
compiled around 200A.D. to explain the previously orally communicated Jewish code of
Law. Also, Gemara is an explanation of Mishnah* both are contained in Talmud with
outlines of the importance of the 613 commandments of Jewish law and rabbis
interpretation. Both the first and second version of the Talmud were completed in the
third and fifth A.D. respectively (www.history.com).
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
12
Jewish place of worship is called synagogue and most regular prayer is referred to as
Shema from the Torah. Their numerous holidays and festivals include. RoshHashanah
(the New year), Yom Kippur (day of atonement), Sukkot, Purim, Pesack (Passover) and
Shavuot. According to Menachem, P. 2020, Judaism is the natural religion of the Jews
though, some of them converted to other religions and there are some individual who
converted to Judaism via recognized rabbinical court (Menachem, P. 2020).
In human history, Jewish people have suffered series of persecution for one reason
or the other December 30, 1016 Granada Massacre is one experience. 1942 Jewish
expulsion from Spain is another and the holocaust in which over 6 million Jews were
killed is the greatest of their suffering and ordeal. (History.com 2020).
According to Don Vaugham 2020, BBC.co.uk 2009 and History.com 2019, the
Christian creed is built on the birth, life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Thus,
Christianity is a little over 2,000 years old and has more than 2 billion adherents
throughout the world. As one of the Abrahamic religions, Christians believe in the
existence of the Almighty God who shares divinity with the son and Holy Spirit, the
doctrine of Trinity (history.com 2019).
The symbol of Christianity is cross and its most significant holidays are Christmas – a
celebration of Jesus birth and Easter which commemorates his resurrection. As a result,
the Christians ardently believe in his second coming after he had ascended to heaven.
The Holy Scripture of Christianity is the Holy Bible. It comprises of the biographies of
Jesus Christ, some major Prophets, disciples, their teachings and instructions on how a
Christian should live his or her live. The Old Testament part of the Bible is followed by
Christians and Jews alike while only the Christians hold on to the New Testament
(history.com 2019). The first four books of the new Testament which contains the
biography of Jesus were composed around 40 years after the ascension of Jesus
between 70-100 A.D. and the remaining parts called ‘epistles’ were written by early
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
13
Christian leaders, ‘Acts’ of the Apostles describes the Ministry, the death of Jesus,
Revelation, prophesies, and the incidents of the end time. (history.com)
Since Jesus Christ is the center of Christianity, it is pertinent to give a summary of his
biography here.
Jesus was miraculously born to Mary, a Jewish virgin lady in Bethlehem of today’s
Palestine between 2B.C. and 7B.C. and the main source of his biography is the New
Testament. Despite that, little is known in the New Testament of Jesus’ Childhood.
(www.bbc.co.uk, 2014). But much of it is recorded in the Apocryphal Gospels of Pseudo-
Matthew and St. Thomas, Arabic and Armenian infancy Gospels. (Danielle, Peters M.
2020)
The intention of King Herod to destroy Jesus orchestrated the flight of Mary, Jesus
and Joseph, the carpenter to Egypt and their return after Herod’s death, thus Jesus grew
up in Nazareth (Matthew 2:1-23). The book of Matthew 3 gave the account of Jesus’
baptism in the hand of John the Baptist at Jordan when Jesus Christ was about 30 years
of age and his mission lasted for 3 years which was full of teachings, miracles and
healings as recorded in Matthew 14 and some other places in the New Testament. His
mission was supported by his twelve disciples. (www.bbc.co.uk 2014, the basics of
Christian history, history.com)
Afterwards, according to Matthew 27 and 28; Mark 16 Jesus was crucified for heresy,
buried and resurrected on Sunday, the third day after his crucifixion. For some days,
Jesus appeared to many of his disciple and was seen alive by many of his followers
before ‘he was received up into heaven and sat on the right hand of God’ (Mark 16:19)
(www.bbc.co.uk 2014).
If not for the missionary work of Saul who later became Paul after his dramatic
conversion to Christianity on his was to Damascus and his literary prowess to have
written 13 out of the 27 books of the New Testament, Christianity would not have
spread throughout the Roman Empire, Europe and to Africa (history.com, 2017,
www.bbc.co.uk 2008). Because, Jesus himself did not intend to form a new religion let
alone of spreading it but to reform Judaism. (history.com 2019) As such, Paul’s
theological concept of freedom from the Jewish law as signaled the resurrection of Jesus
and equal access to the Christian faith greatly assisted the development and spread of
Christianity (bbc.co.uk 2008).
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
14
2.2.3. Persecution
Christianity and Christians suffered greatly in the royal hands of some Roman
emperors such as Nero who blamed and killed many Christian for the fire outbreak in
64A.D., Christianity was illegal under Domitan (81-96A.D.) the persecution was severe
during the reign of Diocletian and Galerius (284-305A.D.) (History.com 2019,
www.bbc.co.uk 2008).
Afterwards, the Christians had a sign of relief when Constantine became victorious
over his foes and he attributed it to the Christian God, thus, he announced his
conversion to Christianity which became the official religion in Rome. He gave
Christianity a new look. He recorded some level of Success in his attempt to unify
Christianity, as well as in the formulation and codification of the (Christian) faith which
resulted into the Nicene creed. (www.bbc.co.uk 2008, history.com 2019).
The fall of Roman Empire in 476 A.D. disintegrated the unity Christianity and
punctured the centralized authority held by Pope; paved way for sects and
denominations which was much aided by Martin Luther activities is 1571. Presently,
there are three branches of Christianity;
The Eastern Orthodox governed by a Holy synod but without centralized authority
similar to the popes
The Protestants, created by Martin Luther. It has many denominations with different
doctrines and interpretation of the Bible. (history.com 2019, www.bbc.co.uk 2008).
The Catholic Church headed by the Popes
However, despite the disparity of doctrines among the sects and denominations of
Christianity, the life, teachings, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ formed the
bedrock of their faith. (history.com editors 2019).
Islam means peace and total submission to the will of God. It is a monotheistic
religion. Its origin is traced to 7th Century (610CE) in Makkah, Saudi Arabia with
Muhammad son of Abdullah as the messenger of God – Allah. During one of
Muhammad’s visitation to the cave of Hira where he used to meditate about God, angel
Jibreel appeared and revealed the Quran to him as message from God from then till the
rest of his life, he continued to receive the revelation. Thus, the Muslims believe that
the Qur’an is the exact word of God. ( American humanist.org2020, history.com 2019).
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
15
The ZaKaah: Alms-giving or Charity which is incumbent upon every Muslim whose
wealth has reached nisab (the minimum amount taxable). It is either one fortieth of
one’s annual net profit or 10% or 20% of Agricultural produce.
The Hajj: Holy Pilgrimage to Makkah. This is obligatory once in a life time of an able
Muslim.
The Sawm Ramadan: Fasting from dawn to dust for 29 or 30days in the month of
Ramadan, the 9th month of Islamic calendar (Hadith 3 or an-Nawawi,
Americanhumanist.org 2020).
Subsequently, when the intensity of the persecution reached its peak, Muhammad
and many of his followers flee to Yathrib which later became Madinah. This Hijrah
(religious migration) became a turning point in the history Islam as well as a point of
reference as it marked the beginning of the Islamic calendar. (American-human.m.org
2020, history.com 2019).
Eventually, Madinah became the capital of Islam during Muhammad’s life time.
Afterwards, there was series of battles (Badr, Uhud, and Khandaq) between the Muslim
in Madinah and the idolaters of Makkah. Then, the Makkans violated the treaty of
Hudaybiyyah of 628CE/6A.H. And the Prophet Muhammad in a more or less warless
circumstance conquered Makkah in 630 CE which made a larger percent of its
inhabitants willingly embraced Islam. (Americanhumanist.org, 2020) Ever since, Islam
continues to grow geometrically with a noticeable expansion during the reign of the
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
16
second caliph, Umar bin Khattab. Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam died in 632CE and
was succeeded by four rightly guided Caliphs whose reign lasted circa 632-661CE.
(Zidan, A. 1998)
Furthermore, Muslims lives are regulated by divine law called ‘Shar’ah’. It is all
encompassing as it covers all aspects of life both material and spiritual. Its main sources
are the Qur’an and Hadith of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) (History.com).
And the Islamic festivals are ‘Idul-fitr celebrated on the 1st of Shawwal, the 10th
month of the Muslim Calendar to mark the completion of Ramadan fast and ‘Idul-Adha
celebrated on 10thDhul-Hijjah, the 12th Month of the Muslim Calendar to commemorate
the submission of Prophet Ibrahim to sacrifice his son, Ismail (history.com, 2019).
Adoro, A.L. 2019 explains that in the ancient civilization of Rome ,Persia ,Greece,
Arab etc. women suffered permanent humiliation, damage due to deplorable living
condition and treatment by society. They were not next to but equal to animals and
slaves .They were considered as filth and property to be bought, sold and inherited.
(Adoro, A.L. 2019)
The Greek women of 400 B.C, experience d various hardship difficulties and
demeaning treatment in the spheres of marriage, inheritance and social life based on
the structure of the society. (webpage.pace.edu)
As important as marriage is in the life of the human beings, the Greek women were
denied of freedom of choice of partner. They were betrothed to men by their male
relatives. There consents were irrelevant and therefore not sought. In other words, they
did not marry; but were given in marriage. (Sealer, p.25 cited in webpage.pace.edu)
This arranged marriage did affect the Greek women emotionally and psychologically.
Furthermore, for a young lady to get married she must have an inherited property as
her dowry and marriage prerequisite, otherwise, she is banned from marriage
(webpage.pace.edu)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
17
Also, the marriage age was both early and late respectively. Early for females and
late for males. While the average death age for the latter is forty-five, it was the norm
for fourteen year old girls to marry men in their thirties .This resulted into numerous
children been orphaned at a tender age and high rate of young and fertile widows as
well as increase in infant mortality. (webpage.pace.edu)
Socially, the ancient Athenian Greek women were considered like adolescents that
should be monitored. Hence, their movements were restricted, spending most of their
time at home engaging in domestic shores, bearing children and nurturing them as their
primary duties. (webpagepace.edu)
In addition, Greek women generally experienced less status, rank and privilege
compared to other ancient civilizations even between husband and wives.
(www.historymusaim.ca)
The news at the birth of a girl child is presented and received with a big disgraced
and embarrassment for the mother who “turns her head away (from the husband) in
shame” (Demand cited in webpage.pace.edu) and the oikos .When asked how many
child they have Athenian men do not usually count the girls among their children
(webpage.pace.edu)
GreekBoston.com (2020) states that the inability of the ancient Athenian women to
own and control their own property disqualified them from becoming full citizens.
Whereas freed slaves had the rights of full citizens. Also, formal education was gender
based and it was for male only. (www.greekbostom.com )
However, Mark, C. (2016), asserts that The Greek girls children were educated in the
same way as the boys but with the addition and more emphasis on gymnastics, dancing
and music. Although the major aim of girls education was to prepare them for their role
of nurturing their children managing their homes but not to stimulate intellectual
progress directly. (www.ancient.eu )
In the primeval Rome, wives were mere property of their husbands and husbands
had all legal rights as regard children. Women were considered second to men and
could not officially hold political power and the few who did hold political power did
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
18
that through their husbands and or sons. Some emperors and senators’ wives had
noticeable influence on the government. They could not vie for political office but did
campaign for their spouses or relatives (historyextra.com).Though they had legal right
to own business and property. (www.ducksters.com)
The father is saddled with the responsibility of chosen husband for her daughter, a
choice she must not object except on account of bad character of the proposed
husband. She is just like a property to the husband, her absolute loyalty remains with
her father whose name she could continue to bear even after marriage .Her status
before her husband is lesser than those of her children. ( www.crystalinks.com )
A form of marriage in the ancient Rome is called Manus which means ‘hand’ in
Latin .This implies that a woman is considered as a mere property whose ownership is
transferred from the hand of her father to the hand of her husband. Girls were married
out in their early teens and even before that. This account for high rate of maternal
mortality as a result of multiple births before the age of twenty (a girl of 13 year could
give birth 5 to 6 times before attaining 20 years) marriage then was not love based . It
was based on political affiliation and economic reasons with the sole purpose of bearing
children who would worship the family gods. Gregory, S.A says:
The desire to use children as political pawns led to Children being engaged
at very young ages , sometime even as babies.To curb this , a law was
He added that one common kind of marriage then which also depicts the
demeaning status of women in the Ancient Roman custom was coemptio. Here, the
bride’s groom gave money the bride’s father to indicate he has bought her as a mere
property. ( Gregory S.A 2018).
Meanwhile, wealthy Roman women often used to contract the service of a slave or
freed women to breast feed their babies on account that they might be too weak to
start breast feeding immediately after delivery of their babies and that they might
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
19
acquire the mother tongue from the Greek wet-nurse just like the Arabs before Islam .(
www.historyaxtra.com )
Despite that marriage was a bond and unifying factor among families in the ancient
Rome, divorce was rampant and easily initiated without any legal procedures. The
marriage contract could be severed at will either by the husband or the wife or even
initiated by wife’s father whom by the law still remains her guardian and this
facilitate the reclaiming of the dowry paid to the husband . However, if the wife were to
be accused of infidelity, the husband would keep the dowry.
Also, due to motherly affection for the children some women were disrespected in
divorce since the custody of the children legally belongs to the husband. Though,
sometimes, at the benevolence of the husband, the children could remain with their
mother after divorce. A popular instance of this was when Sacribonial emperor
Augustus’s wife was abandoned in favor of the emperor’s third wife she was allowed
the custody of her new born Julia who she was later equally to her exile in the island of
Ventotene when she grew up. (www.historyexra.com )
The Roman girls children both in the upper caste and the bourgeoisie were not
denied the basic skills of literacy and numeracy. Yet some families engaged private
grammar or Greek tutors in order to adequately prepare their girls, for their future roles
of home makers and good wives. However very few writing by woman has survived,
even the memoir of Hero’s mother Agrippina the Younger did not survive
(historyextra.com, 2016). ’ …The principal goal of girl’s education [in ancient Rome]
was the ability to spine thread and weave cloth. (Gregory, S.A. 2018)
However, in the early 1400, the bishop and the religious authorities of the Christian
world got together in a beautiful place called London to debate whether women were
human or not and the concluded that they were not human.
In the year 1746 , in France a very enlighten group of the Christian clergymen converged
in Paris to debate if women were devils or human ,after a ten days intense debate ,the
conclusion was they are human but their souls are lesser than the soul of men .
700 years after the birth of Jesus (PBUH) Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) had a different
conclusion that women are not just equal to men but can sometimes even better than
men. It is quite surprising, hypocritical and ironical that after Muhammad has given
value to women, removed misconception about them, that we say Islam denigrate
women. The West are children of the same bishops from France and UK who said the
sort of things .And today they are campaigning for women libration which has done over
14 centuries ago. (Yaseen media, 2015)
Candace, West and Don, H.Z 1987 define sex as what ascribe as biology; anatomy,
hormones and physiology. Gender, was an achieved status: that which is constructed
through psychological, cultural, and means. (Candace, W. and Don, H.Z 1987)
Prior to 1979, the definition of human right conspicuously over looked violations in
the home but mainly focused on the violations of rights in larger society and this has
benefited men mostly. Fortunately, the year 1979 witnessed draft of convention on the
elimination of all forms of Discrimination against woman (CEDAN) and its adoption by
United Nations. And here a violation at home was a major agenda. Achievement of
gender equally was also among the mission statements at the Beijing Declaration and
platform for action which ensured from the first world conference of the United Nations
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
21
For the sake of gender equality , through the charter of the United Nation and the
universal Declaration of Human rights as adopted by the General Assembly in 1945 and
1948. The United Nation gradually extended human rights law to cover certain
standards for women, children, person, with disabilities who now have rights which
shield them from common age long discrimination in several societies ( www.un.org )
Ochuoga, D.O. (1997) concludes that religions have several illogical presumptions
about the rights of women in the society and before God. Therefore, it is a barrier to
gender equality. His conclusion is not supported by any scriptural and logical evidence
as he wrongly asserted that the three religions are male dominated. Whereas both
gender are mostly mentioned side by side in the Qur’an with the same expectations and
rewards except where specified Q.2:228; Q.33:35 are few examples.
Ochuoga, D.O 1997 alluded that women are both socially and conjugally inferior
to men based on his understanding and interpretation of Gen.1,2 and meanwhile there
is no single unequivocal statement that depict this .However ,The word `man` in the
Gen .1:26-27 refers to human being .It is repeated as male and female in the last clause
just for clarification .
Robuj Welzlea cited in Adoro, A.L 2019 asserted that: ‘Certainly, male and female
are two distinct sexes, a complete and convincing difference .If we claim to equalize
their rights, we cannot do so as far as their nature is concerned.’ A Russian scholar,
Antoni Nemela cited in Adoro 2019 said: ‘The fact is ,there is no equality between male
and female as proved by scientific studies carried out on the biological nature of men
and women .Their distinct biological nature does not permit equal responsibilities for
them .’ The controversy over the gender of Caster Simenya and her eventual
disqualification to participate in a tournament as well as separate competition for male
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
22
and female of the same age bracket in all sporting activities attest to the fact that male
and female are not equal.(TVC news at 10, 07-03-2021)
Also, nature demands that for orderliness, there must be a leader and this does not
in any way makes the led or one sex inferior, Gen.2:16.Therefore both men and women
have equal right in marriage with men having privilege of leadership. This is also
expressed in the Qur’an 4:34 ‘Men are the protectors and maintenance of women
because Allah has made one of them to excel the other, and because they spend (to
support them) from their wealth.’
At this junction, it is opined that gender equity should be the point of advocacy and
not equality because equity which emphasizes fairness, justice, giving each its due right
is argue to be the appropriate concept to apply. (Adeyeye, B.A (2018)
However, the Qur’an, Old and New Testaments Bible attest to the spiritual equality
of male and female in the verses inter alia ;Joel2:28,Gen.1:27,Q.33:35
The liberal society approves the abortion of female fetuses. Fred Arnod, Suniata
kishor, & Poy, T. k 2002 estimate that just in a decade (1990s) more than 100,000
female fetuses were aborted in India alone. A vehemently condemned act in the Qur’an
81:8. Yet, ‘AbdurRahman I.D. explains that abortion may be an option if child-bearing
would endanger the mother’s life during pre-natal or at delivery point. He justifies his
opinion with these Qur’anic verses: ‘Do not throw yourself into destruction with your
own hands.’ (Q.2:195) ‘Do not destroy yourselves; undoubtedly Allah is merciful to you’
(Q.4:29)
While abortion is generally described as an evil act in 2nd king 8:12, Exodus 21:22-25
sees it as finable offence which is antithetical to God’s will and commandment in Gen.
9:6-7. Even , if almost all the Biblical verses against abortion are not direct injunctions
but inferential and deduced ,the book of Romans 2:14-15 states that your instinct is
enough, you need no one to tell you of your crime as your conscience pricks you.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
23
According to the Jewish scholar, Rachel Mikva, 2019 , ’The majority of foundational
Jewish text assert that a fetus does not have the status of personhood until birth’ Again
he says : ’ In contemporary Jewish debate there are stringent opinions adopting the
attitude that abortion is homicide –thus permissible only to save the mother’s life…’
He finally submitted that there are divergent opinions as regard abortion but only by
critical study of Jewish texts like Talmud, Mishna and Halakha - The Jewish Law that
one would be able to explore these diverse views.(Rachel Mikva,2019)
Rabbi Ramond A. Zwerin, and Rabbi Richard J. Shapiro, 2017 quoted from Mishna
Thus:
the fetus within her and removes it limb by limb because her life
takes precedence over its life .once the greater part if it emerges
it may not be touched, for we not set aside one life for another
It is now understood that basically, in Judaism abortion is only allowed only if the
pregnancy poses a danger to the mother’s life at prenatal stage, before the emergence
of the baby’s head from birth canal, otherwise, another rule is applied.
Firstly, he failed to buttress his claim with textual or scriptural evidence. Secondly,
chastity bashfulness are not used both in the Bible and the Qur’an for female
pejoratively but honorifically. The Bible describes Mary, the mother of Jesus (PBUH) as
‘virgin Mary’, this exemplifies chastity .The Q.19:16-29 discusses her bashfulness and
chastity.
In order to prohibit any political leaders from repeating the sorts of abuse which
happened in the World War II, governments of several countries across the world first
agreed on international human rights. This was written in the universal Declaration of
human rights at Paris on December 10 in 1948 and it birthed the international
covenants called protocols. (NCA-10015,2015)
The concept of human rights is based on the belief that all people
are of equal value and Dignity just because they are human beings.
whom they want , and believing in what they want .Human rights
are meant for everyone equally , no matter what their race , religion ,
Furthermore, James Nickel sees Human rights as norms which aimed to shield all
human being from serious from political , legal and social abuses .(Nickel, J . 2019). He
identifies that humans rights is universal .To enjoy these rights, one does not need to
belong to particular class, nationally or religious affiliation. And these rights can be lose
either temporarily or permanently through ill-behavior (Nickel, J. 2019)
According to UN, human rights are those rights which are intrinsic to all
homosapiens, irrespective of religion, ethnicity, nationality, race, sex, language color or
any other status. These rights also include but not limited to the right to life and
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
25
liberty , freedom from slavery and torture , freedom of opinion and expression , the
right to work and education .(www.un.org )
However, the second optional protocol of the international convention on civil and
political rights which was adopted in 1989 advocates,
In a bid to recognize women and promote their course, 1975 was declared by the
General Assembly as the international women’s year and also organized the first world
conference on women in Mexico. One of the results of the conference was the
declaration of the years 1976-1985 as the UN Decade for women. ( www.un.org )
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
26
CHAPTER THREE
This chapter discusses the position of women as; teachers, mothers, wives and
daughters in the Judeo-Christianity and Islam
Even though, women and men responsibilities differ, they are of equal importance.
Www.jewfaq.org 2020 explains that God is neither male nor female and the masculine
form of address is just for convenience.
3.1.2. As Teachers
Mothers are also teachers who pass on both spiritual and moral teachings to the on-
coming generations ,thus preserving the Jewish values ‘reject not the teachings of your
mother’ (Prov. 1:8 RSV) was king Solomon’s advice to his son. Rashi cited in Isaiah, R.
2016 commented that the mother’s teaching is the oral tradition which complement the
written Torah and it is the medium requirement to enter Israel (Isaiah R. 2016) Yvette
Alt Miller writes ‘Throughout history it’s Jewish mother who’ve [sic] instilled Jewish
knowledge and love of being Jewish in the children and our tradition recognizes this
profound truth’ (Miller, Y.A. 2019)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
27
The Jews recognize the valorous of women which make her as an ideal mother in her
relationship with those around her as portrayed by king Solomon in Proverbs 31:10-31.
For this, Jews at Shabbat table, recite a poem Eishet chayil( ‘A woman of Valor’) every
Friday night in honour of women. ‘ Her children rise up and call her blessed ;her
husband also, and he praises her: “Many women have done excellently, but you
surpassed them all.”’( prov. 31 :28-29) (Miller,Y.A. 2019).
As mother, Jewish women earn the same respect and honour the father has from
their children as enshrined in Exodus 20:12 Leviticus 19:13. Samuel Lane writes: ‘Jewish
mother, like all mothers, are flesh-and –blood contradictory figures in our lives and
cannot be reduced to a monolithic representation, we owe them the fullness of their
complicated histories, for they have made possible our own’ ( Samuel Lane in Joyce
Antler 2019) .
Isaiah Rothstein writes that Rabbi Yisroel Meir Lau opined that Noah was given the
honour to save humanity and animal before the flood because he had a mother unlike
Adam and Eve. Hence, mothers are very important in shaping human life and they are
daily honoured for that. (Isaiah, R 2016) According to him mothers are the heroines and
pillars behind the Jewish values and practices (Ezekiel 19:1-10)
It is understood from rabbinic text that a man without a wife lacks substance and he
only becomes a phenomenon with the presence of a woman called wife in his life. Judith
R. Bashing cited in a commentary of Genesis Rabbah 17:2 on Genesis 2:18 ‘it is not good
for a man to be alone’ in this regard:
It was taught: He who has no wife dwells without good, without help,
without joy, without blessing, and without atonement. Without good:
‘It is not good for a man to be alone’ (Gen.2:18). Without help: ‘I will
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
28
make a fitting helper for him’ (Gen.2:18). Without joy: ‘And you shall
feast there, in the presence of the Lord God, and dance with your
out life too, for it is said, ‘Enjoy your life with a woman you
love’ (Ecclesiastes 9:9). R. Hiyyah b. Gomdi said: He is also incomplete, for
it is written, ‘And He blessed them and call them household’ (Deuteronomy
14:26). Without blessing: ‘You shall further
give the first of the yield of your baking to the priest, that a blessing
may rest upon your house’ (Ezekiel 44:30). Without atonement: ‘Aaron
shall then offer his bull of sin offering to make atonement for himself
and his household’ (Leviticus 16:11). R. Simon said in the name Of
Joshua b. Levi: Without peace too, for it is said : ‘Peace to you and
your household’(1Samuel 25:6). R.Joshua of Siknin said in the name of
R. Levi withhumanity’ (Gen.5:2)
[thus, only together are thy full human ]…(Genesis Rabbah 17:2 cited
in Baskin J.R. 2004).
As a wife, a woman is a helper to her spouse via her performance of domestic chores
which in turn enables her husband to be comfortable, perform well in his study and
useful in the society.(Gen.2:18) As inferred from song of Rabbah 7.11, women are
considered second citizens, next to men whose instructions she must always obey and
follow. ‘Your desire shall be to your husband, he shall rule over you’ (Gen.3:16). Baskin J.
R. 2004 explains:
In this passage, the male Knesset Israel, the community of Israel, is constructed
as the female beloved ; in the relationship between God, who is characterized as
masculine and the male community of Israel characterized as feminine, there is
no place for women. …Total devotion to the divine could have the effect of
displacing a wife in her husband’s affections…then at the same level, the human
connection must always be secondary, just as women were subordinate and
disadvantaged in other aspects of daily and marital life. (Baskin J. 2004, p.5)
The Rabbinic scholars also consider a wife as a liberator who freed her husband
from sins of conversation with all women and debauchery through bearing of children
and providing legal sexual outlet (B. Yevamot 63a, B. Nedarim. 20b cited in Baskin J.
2004).
They advised that women should be adequately catered for by their husbands being
their helpers and partners and should only be engaged in superficial matters. Baskin J.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
29
writes: ‘ While wives who fulfilled their marital obligations must be indulged within their
domestic boundaries, no man should assume his spouse as an intellectual with whom he
can communicate in any substantive way’ (Baskin, J. 2004)
He concludes that the collision between norms and experienced reality makes the
position of women as wives in Judaism a complicated issue. Where the sages
compassionately extol and appreciate those women who succumbed to male
dominance and facilitate the social-cultural and religious endeavors of their husbands,
the account of wives who defied the norms by attaining autonomy was equally given
‘still , we must not forget the penalties for bad wives those whose privilege crimes
appear to have been efforts at self-expression and autonomy in a Rabbinically defined
worldview in which woman could not be permitted to have independent roles’ (Baskin,
J. 2004, p.13)
Nevertheless, below are some Talmudic quotes which praise the virtues of women;
There was a noticeable change in the status of a daughter in Jewish law between the
patriarchal and Talmudic eras. While the daughter had no special preference in the
patriarchal era where she was just like any other of her father’s household about whose
treatment no one can query her father (Jephthah’s daughter, Judges 10: 34-39). Upon
attaining her majority, at the age of twelve years and six months, she gain her freedom
from absolute parental controls and secure some legal rights during the Talmudic era.
(Louis G. and Amram D.W 2020 )
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
30
The Biblical account in Exodus 21:7; Gen.31:15 also affirm the unquestionable
paternal authority to sell his daughter as a maidservant and betroth her to whoever he
wishes (Gen.29:15-35) or give her out for whatever reasons (Gen.18:18; Judges 18:24)
because she is considered as his property. Being her father’s property, he demands
damages for any injury done to her (Ex. 21:31), defamation of his daughter’s personality
(Deut. 22:29 ; Ex. 22:17). This paternal authority continues to exist over a daughter
even while in a marriage. Instances of this are witnessed between Laban, Jacob and
both did recognized this fact (Gen. 31:31, 43), and between Samson and his father in-
law (Judges 15:1-3), and between Saul and David (1 Samuel 25:44). In the latter two
instances, the daughters were even taken away by their father from their respective
husbands and betrothed to other men without their husbands’ consents. ‘But Saul had
given Michal his daughter, David’s wife, to Phalti, the son of Laish, which was of Gallim’
(1Samuel 25:44). (Louis G. and Amram D.W. 2020)
However, the abolition of the jubilee law since 6 BC in the Talmudic and post-
Talmudic eras put an end to the absolute paternal authority to sell his daughter into
maidenship in order to save her from continual slavery. (Kid. 69a; Maimonides,
“Yad”,’Abadin, I. 10 cited in Louis .G etal). Also, ‘all of the father’s rights over his
daughter’s person and property which survived in Jewish law from patriarchal time
ceased when she became bogeret. These rights are thus summed up in the Mishnah
(Ket. If.4; ib. Gem. 46b)’ (Louis, G. and Amram, D.W. 2021)
Initially, the father has the right to the custody of his daughter, but in case the court
decides based on the child’s interest and if the mother is found worthy of keeping the
child, the father is obliged to support his daughter while she is a minor till the age of six
(Ket. 49a cited in Louis G. etal, 2021), despite that she is in the custody of her divorced
mother. (Louis G. etal 2021). ‘ If the daughter, after attaining her majority, remain with
her father, and she is supported by him, he continues to be entitled to her earnings and
to that whichever finds…After the death of her father, his son and heir must support
the daughters out of the patrimonial estate until their marriage. (Ket. 52b; B.B. 1116b
cited in Louis, G. etal 2021).
Women have been unkindly treated in most of the ancient (Rome, Athens, India,
Arabia etc.) civilizations before the advent of Islam. The inhumane treatment of
womenfolk in the pre-Islamic era among the Arab is a mirror to the happenings in other
nations of that time. Whence, they were denied the right to; education, inheritance,
divorce, consensual marriage, dignity, gender justice, equity, property, security etc.
( Badawi, J.M. 1979,Hussain, N. 2020)
However, the Shari’ah of Islam emancipates women from absolute degradation and
highly revered them as indispensable companions of men in every stage of their lives.
Men have women as; Mothers, wives, and daughters. At each of the stages, Islam
enjoins men to show honour, respect, compassion and benevolence to women. Moon
Shaking 1976 writes: ‘The rights conferred on women by Muhammad [PBUH] represent
a vast enhancement of the status in which they were held in pre-Islamic Arab world’.
Thus, here are some of the Quranic verses and the Prophet’s Hadiths on kind treatment
of women in various stages of life:
‘And your Lord has decreed that you worship none but Him.
And that you be dutiful to your parents. If one of them or
both them attain old age in your life, do not say to them
a word of disrespect, nor shout at them but address them
in terms of honour...’ (Q.17:23-24)
‘And We have enjoined on man to be dutiful and good to his
parents. His mother bore him in weakness and hardship
upon weakness and hardship…but behave with them in
this world kindly…’ (Q.31:14-15)
‘And do good to your parents…’(Q.4:36) ‘…Be good and
dutiful to your parents…’ (Q.6:151 ;Q.29:8;Q.46:15).
Obviously, from the above verses, benevolence to parent is commanded along side
the worship of God with distinguished attention for mothers for her suffering in
pregnancy, delivery, nursing and rearing of her child (Yusuf Qardawi 2022). Also, the
Muhammad (PBUH) is reported to have said the following as regard treatment of
mothers:
Even if one’s mother is an unbeliever, Islam enjoins one to treat her with honour and
respect through good relationship. Asmã’ a daughter of Abubakr enquired from the
Prophet (PBUH) as regard her relationship with her unbeliever mother who had come to
visit her in Madinah . He (PBUH) said, ‘Yes be on good term with your mother’ (Al-Lu’lu’
wal Marjan 587).
The mother’s right to the custody of her child is weightier than the fathers. Abdullah
Ibn Amr Ibn Al-As narrated that a woman asked, “O Messenger of Allah, this son of mine
had my womb as container, my breast for drinking, my lap to contain him. His father
had taken him from me”. “The Prophet (PBUH) said, “You have more right if you do not
marry” (Musnad Ahmad Ibn Hanbal cited in Yusuf Q.)
The foundation of marriage in Islam is actually peace, love and harmony ‘And among
His signs is this, that He created for you wives from among yourselves, that you may find
repose in them, and He has put between you affection and mercy…’(Q.30:21). Hence, a
Muslim woman is not forced, her consent is very important. She receives mahr
(mandatory nuptial gift) footballer husband as a symbol of love and she is considered a
pure, an independent partner in her matrimonial (Q.2:228). Also, she must be
adequately catered for according to her husband’s financial status and standard of living
in their society by providing her with food clothes, shelter, medical care etc. (Q.65:7).
She should be treated kindly with honour. ‘And live with them honourably… (Q.4:19).
Yusuf Qardawi explains that this encapsulate all sorts of good treatments as regards
sponsor relationship which include :good manners, a flexible character, Sweet words, a
smiling face, a pleasing playfulness and amusing facial expression. In line with the
Hadith of the Prophet (PBUH) reported by Aisha may Allah be pleased with her that the
prophet peace be upon him said: “The best of you is the best to his family and I am the
best to my family” (Ibn Hibban charity vol.9 Hadith 4177 cited in Yusuf Qardawi, Badawi
J. N. Www.iium.edu.my ).
In spite of the presence of both couples in marriage the husband is saddled with the
responsibility of leadership ‘ …men are the maintainer and protector of
women…’(Q.4:34) and this does not make him a dictator as they both counsel and
mutually agree on important family matters ‘… if they both decide on weaning by
mutual consent, and after due consultation there is no shame on them…’(Q.2:233)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
33
However, the following Hadiths give insight into how treasurable a wife is in Islam:
Before as well as at the dawn of Islam in Arabian Peninsula, female infanticide was
prevalent. It has since then been forbidden by Islam and considered it a crime. (Quran
81: 8 - 9.) Women were generally maltreated, denied of inheritance from both father
and husband, abused, considered as weak and inferior to men and valueless. This made
them vehemently detested the birth of a baby girl friend and felt ashamed when the
news of a daughter is brought to them. ‘And when the news of (the birth of) a female
(child) is brought to any of them his face becomes dark and he is filled with him with
grief.’ (Q.16:58)
To avoid the shame of giving birth to a daughter, some of them resorted to burying
the child alive while some conceded to bringing her up with contempt. ‘He hides himself
from the people because of the evil of what whereof he has been informed. Shall he
keep her with dishonour or bury her in the earth? Certainly, evil is their decision.’
(Q.16:59)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
34
It is obvious from the above verse that Islam condemned such barbaric culture and
perpetrators shall be questioned on the Day of Judgment (Q.81:8-9).However , the
Qur’an 42:49-50 considers both male and female child equal gift which He bestows
either or both upon whom he wishes while in His wisdom renders some childless. Yusuf
Al-Qardawi recounts the Quranic story of Maryam mother of Jesus as one of such
daughters who are more remarkable and immortal in memories than several males
children. Of course, how many of her male contemporaries are still mentioned today?
(Yusuf Qardawi)
The following Hadiths of the Prophet (PBUH) belouds the status of daughters in Islãm
encourage parents and guardians to take good care of their daughters as they can
facilitate their admittance into paradise:
‘Aishah (RA) narrated: A lady along with her two daughters came
to me asking (for some alms) but she found nothing with me except
one date which I gave her and she divided it between her two
daughters and did not eat anything herself, and then she got up and
went away. Then the Prophet [PBUH] came in and I informed him
about the story. He said, “whoever is out to trial by these daughters
and he treats them generously (with benevolence) then, the daughters
will act as shield for him from Hell-fire” (Al-Lu’lu’ wal Marjan 1688).
Abu Hurayrah narrated that the Prophet (PBUH) said: “Whoever have
three daughters and show patience in their keeping, their pleasure and
displeasure, Allãh admits him into paradise for his mercy over them.
A man asked ,’And what about two daughters, O Messenger of Allãh?
He said ‘And two daughters as well.” Another asked, ‘O Messenger of
Allãh what about one daughter?” He said, ‘And one daughter as well”.
(Al-Zahaby, 4/176 cited in Yusuf Al-Qardawi )
Ibn Abbas narrated that the Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said: “Whoever
has a daughter born to him and does not bury her alive or humiliate her or
prefer his son over her, Allah will admit him to paradise because of her”.
(Musnad Ahmad Ibn Hanbal 1957)
It is not only fatherly care for daughters that admit one to paradise as the ultimate
reward but also brotherly. ‘Whoever has two sisters and his kind to them while they are
with him, will enter paradise because of them’ (Musnad Ahmad Ibn Hanbal 2105)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
35
In the same vein, Islam consider both male and female children as part of the
adornment of this life (Q.18:46) and prescribes the same spiritual and moral education
for them. The father has no right to sell his daughter or marry her to who she does not
please with or by any means make property of another man as in the ancient
civilizations. ( Yusuf Al-Qardawi, Al-Lu’lu’ wal Marjan 895).
CHAPTER FOUR
Marriage in Islam, is an act of worship (Ibadah) and its legality and ancientness are
expressed and affirmed in the following verses of the Qur’an and Hadiths of Prophet
Muhammad (PBUH)
‘And if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly with the
orphan –girls then Marry (other) women of your choice …’(Q. 4:3)
person (Adam) and From him ,He created his wife (Hawwa [Eve]) ,
and from them both He created many Men and women ;…’(Q.4:1)
‘And marry those among you who are single (i.e a man or woman
who has no spouse) and (also marry ) the salihun (pious fit and capable
one of your (male) slaves and maid servants (female slave s). if they be
poor, Allah will enrich them out of His bounty Allah is All –sufficient
for His creature’s needs All knowing {about the state of the people’
(Q.24:32)
The Qur’an 4:1; Q.25:54; Q30:21, Q.13:38, Q.4:1 clearly depict that marriage
institution in Islamic perspective is as old as the creation of human being. As its legality
are implied in those verses. Its choice of partner and means of procreation are more
prominent in Q.4:3 and Q.25:74
and women! Who so ever can bear the burden of marriage let him
marries, he secures half of his religion , let him fear Allah in the other
The Shari’ah of Islam covers all aspects of life in details .It believes that all parts of
human anatomy have their different roles and needs which must be fulfilled
legitimately without denial , suppression or transgression .Hence ,it is antithetical to the
western view of sex .(e.g. boyfriend and girlfriend relationship ,dating, casual lovers
etc.). Also it does not see abandonment of sex in marriage ) and celibacy as means of
nurturing the soul or attaining spiritual uplift nor-does it ( Islam)considers it (sex) as
inherently evil but rather sex is an highly recommended act of worship (Rizvi,S.M.1990)
Celibacy contradicts Gods wisdom of creating sexual desire in human nature which
can only be legally satisfied through marriage. Hence marriage positively affects spiritual
growth whereas monasticism truncates and punctures it. (Mansoureh Zarean and
khadijeh Barzegar 2016)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
38
A group of three men came to the houses of the wives of the Prophet
asking how the Prophet worshipped (Allah), and when they were
informed about that they considered their worship in sufficient and
said: “where are we from the Prophet as his past sins have been forgiven”.
’Then one of them said, “I will offer the prayer throughout the night forever”,
The other one said, “I will fast throughout the year and I will not break my
fast “. The third said, “I will keep away from the women, and will not marry
forever.” Allah’s Apostle [PBUH] Came to them and said,” Are you the same
people who said so-and –so? By Allah, I am more submissive to Allah and more
afraid of him than you; yet, I fast and break my fast I do sleep and also marry. So,
he who does not follow my tradition in religion is not from me (not one of my
followers).” (Sahih Bukhari, vol.7, Book.62, Hadith1)
Ibn Mas’ud narrated: We used to fight in the Battles in the company of the Prophet
(PBUH) and we had no wives with us. So, we said, “O Allah’s Apostles! Shall we get
castrated? “The Prophet forbade us to do so. (Sahih Bukhari vol.7)
Abdur Rahman I. Doi comments that these verses of the glorious Qur’an vividly
indicate that unlike other religions like Christianity, Buddhism, Jainism etc. which
consider celibacy as a great virtue, Islam, considers marriage a virtuous and an approved
institution.
Generally, Islam encourages male and female who are fit for marriage to satisfy
their sexual urges through legal matrimony and not outside wedlock. Women are great
stake holders in marriage .They have equal marital right with men only that the
husbands have privilege of leadership which must be exercise with love. And Allah has
made for you your mates of your own nature, and made for you , out of them , sons and
daughters and grandchildren and provided for you sustenance of the beat . (16:72)
‘And women shall have rights similar to the rights against them,
according to what is equitable; but men have a degree (of advantage)
over them (Q.2:228) Yusuf Ali ‘they are a garment to you and you are a
garment to them’ (Q2:187).
Bilikisu Yusuf identifies the following among others as the rights of women in an Islamic
marriage;
Right to humane treatment: Islam enjoins men to treat their wives kindly and
mercifully ‘’…And you should not treat them with harshness…’’ Q. 4:19. The
Prophet (SAW)said :The best of you are those who are best to their women ‘’
sunnah of Trimidh: 1162
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
39
Retainment of maiden name: it is only for the past fourteen centuries, it is only
Islam that unequivocally and legally permits women to retain their fathers name
after marriage. Example of this can be seen in the wives of the Prophet (PBUH),
Khadeejah bint Khuwaylid Zainab bint Jesh, Hafsah bint Umar etc. His daughters
Fatimah bint Muhammad , Ruqayah bint Muhammad and many female
companions
For a marriage to be considered legally valid in Islam, there are few important
conditions to be fulfilled which are; Sighah, the Ijabul and Qubul: This means proposal
and acceptance .it implies mutual consent of the prospective couple and freedom of
choice , Mahr, Waliyy, and Shahidayn. (Zarean, M and Berzegar, K. 2016).
Islam prohibits some classes of people from marrying one another for reason
ranging from marriage affinity to consanguinity, fosterage, morality, religious
differences, disorganization of family set up, evil effect of contamination of faith to,
shame and indecency, promiscuity, lack of self-control and obedience to Allah. Such
categories of people are enumerated in the Qur’an 4:22-24; Q. 2:221.
‘Therefore, a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold
fast to his wife and they shall become one flesh’ (Deut. 2:24) Wives
submit to your own husbands, as a to the Lord. For husband is the
head of the wife even as Christ is the head of the church …
(Ephesians 5:22- 24) ‘Let marriage be held in honor among all, and
let the marriage bed be undefiled, for God will judge sexually
immoral and adulterous’ (Hebrews13:4)
It is of the Christian’s belief that marriage is a handsome sign of God’s love and
getting married is a social display of love and eternal covenant between the couple .
(mark 10:9) marriage is a kind of life style established by God for the continuous
existence of Humanity. Hence, he created man male and a female to multiply as one of
the purpose of their creation ‘so, God created man in his own image, in the image of
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
40
God, He created him; male and female He created them’ ‘God blessed them and said to
them, ’Be truthful and increase in number (Gen.1.26-27)
All marriages experience difficulties but Christian believe that it is meant for life.
Despite that some marriages failed and couple separated, some Christians like Roman
Catholic hold the view that marriage vows are not breakable and in the sight of God, the
couple is still together. ‘’ I hate divorce ‘’says the Lord, God of Israel …’Malachi 2:16
(christianity.org.uk )
Marriage is one of the seven sacraments in the Roman catholic and it is built upon
these verses ,among others Gen.2;24,mark 10;2-12,matt.19;1-9;Eph.5:22-33 ;1 Cor.
7:10-16 and John 2:1-11 (Felix, J.S.J,2006. catholicresource.org)
These cited verses emphasize marriage in its monogamous form ‘becoming one flesh
and discourage divorce in it’s entirely “what God has joined together let no one
separate”
However , marriage is so special in the Bible that a newly married man is exempted
from going to war ,rather ,he should stay at home and make his wife happy (Dent.24:5)
And the sanctity of marital relationship is compare to that of the Christ and the church
(Ephesians 5:22-23)
Also, in Christianity, marriage is the only legitimate means of satisfying sexual urge
mutually between the spouse without force or deprivation (1 cor.7:2-5) marriage for a
man is considered a means for quick acceptance for his prayer. (1 Peter 3:7)
The bible emphasizes marriage to virgins and not a divorcee or widow except if she is
a widow of a priest. (Ezekiel 44:22) then what is the fate of other widows? However, the
wives are to submit to their husband as they (women) were created as befitting helpers
for men and not their equals. (Colossians 3:18-19; Gen.2:18)
Unlike in the Islam where mutual consent of the prospective couple is an essential
factor in validating the marriage and a rapist is punished for his crime, in Christianity a
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
41
rapist benefits from his crime by marrying his victim without her wish and paying her
father one hundred shekels of silver for defining his virgin daughter who he shall not
divorce (Dent.22:19)
Virtually, all the verses on marriage speak against divorce or remarriage of a divorced
woman stipulating that such a woman is eternally bond to her divorced (first) husband
hence she cannot marry another man and if she does, it is considered adultery and vice
versa (Matt.19:9; Romans 7:2-3, mark 10:11, 1 cor.7:10-11) ‘they shall not marry a
widow or a divorced woman,…’ (Ezekiel 44:22)
Marriage with non-Christians is not allowed because the Bible depicts Christian as
purity and lights, and others as impurity and darkness which have nothing in common
with the believers (2 Cor.6:14-18). However, if a Christian is already married with an
unbeliever separation is preferred to its continuity (1 Cor.7:15-16). Therefore, difference
in religion is a great impediment to marriage in Christianity.
Sacred order only constitutes impediments to marriage in the Catholic and Orthodox
Church. The catholic holds that the church leaders must be celibates but there is
relaxation to the rule hold. Martin Luther, the founder of the Protestants, got married
and preached against celibacy (Zarean, K. and Bargarbaze, M. 2016) He considered it “A
good wife is a gift from god”
In Judaism , a husband is responsible for the provision of shelter, clothing , food and
sexual relations (Exod.21:10).Marital relation are the woman’s right .A man cannot
sexually force his wife nor abuse her in any way as it was permitted in Christian
countries for a long time . She retains ownership of her property brought in to the
marriage but the husband can manage and enjoy the profits of the property.
(www.jewishvirtuallierary.org )
It is prohibited for a man to remarry his divorce wife after she has married another
man and become divorced again or widowed (Deut .24:1-4).A priest is prohibited from
marrying a divorcee or widow. Equally, prohibited is marriage with a mamzer because
they have been banned from entrance in to the presence of the lord Deut.23). It is also
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
43
prohibited to contract a marriage with a divorcee or widow within the first 90 days of
her divorce or being widowed. (www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org )
Therefore, the roles of women in the trio-religion are similar at home, although
monasticism is still part of Christian ideologies.
According to the Torah and Talmud, a man was permitted to marry more than
one wife, but a woman could not marry more than one man .Although polygamy
was permitted, it was never common. The Talmud never mentions any rabbi with
more than one wife. Around 1000 C.E, Ashkenazic Jew banned polygamy
because of the pressure from the predominant Christian culture… however, the
modern state of Israel allows only one wife … (www.jewishvirtuallierary.org )
Radford, F.M 2000, Asserts that in the Jewish tradition, the number of the wives a
man could have limited only by his ability to fulfill his marital and sexual duties to each
of them …it was not until somewhere between 960 and 1028 that a definitive Jewish
order against polygamy was entered. (Radford, F.M 2000)
The Bible (Pentateuch) being the primary source of the Jewish law did not prohibit
polygamy. It even preaches equity among the among the spouses and children of a
polygamous home (Dent.21:15-17) most of the key figures in the Bible had two or more
wives such as Abraham, Jacob, David Solomon, .Also, the judges, the rich and nobles
were recorded to be polygamous ‘And so Jurubbal, the son of Josh, went and live in his
own house .And he had seventy sons who went forth from his own thigh. For he had
many wives.’ (Judges 8:29-30;1 chronicles 2;26)
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
47
acceded that there is no clear-cut evidence from the teachings of the Apostles against
polygamy and it is morally accepted in non-Christian societies as in Africa, India and
China The report reads: In Africa we read of a chief having “there hundred wives” and
both in Africa and in Polynesia the wives are often numbered by tens or by scores’
(WMC, 1910, P.65). The report clearly states that polygamy is a clear defiance to the law
of God. Yet such a custom cannot be overlooked and accommodate while determining
the foundation of the Christian church. Polygamy is therefore a disqualification and
hindrance to baptism and adoption into the church’s fold.
However, various reports and resolution on polygamy have been made in difference
years throughout the worlds by Christian missionaries at different conferences such as
the Anglican by, 1900, Moravian- General Synod of Moravian church, 1879 and India
1906.
Due to some similarities among the reports and resolutions, one of them is presented
here:
China Resolution of Synod of Chao-Hwei-Chow
1. By the law of God marriage in accordance with the truth is that of one man
and one woman, each fulfilling a part in a life-long union, and they may not
be separated. Therefore, if a man who has a wife marries another or a
woman who has a husband is married to another man, in both cases this is a
breach of law of God.
2. If anyone who is a member of the church while his wife survives, again
marries another, he must certainty be expelled from the fellowship of the
church
3. If anyone, before he heard the Gospel, had taken a secondary wife, then
according to the spirit of the Gospel it is right to have some consideration of
is previous ignorance, and therefore, whether the church will receive him to
Baptism or not a matter for minute enquiry and decision according to the
true circumstances of the case, giving him to understand that the church can
by no means look upon it as a light matter.
4. If the secondary wife has no children and is willing to leave how and be
married to another Christian this may be done but it is necessary first to
consult the local session who shall enquire minutely, and decide the matter,
so that no further wrong may be done to the woman concerned.
5. If this secondary wife has children, or if she is unwilling to be married to
another, then they cannot be separated.
6. If for such reasons they cannot be separated them both parties must be
informed that the taking of the secondary wife was truly sinful and cannot be
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
50
sanctioned by the church but as the matter is ready thus involved, so that the
man concerned is a sincere believer in the Lord and there is no other
obstacle, then the church may receive him to Baptism, but he can never hold
office in the church.
7. In as much as the consequences of these matters are extremely serious, and
are of great difficulty, therefore local sessions must not decide by
themselves. They first petition the presbytery, and await the presbytery’s
minute enquiry and decision, and after sanction has been given such persons
may be admitted to Baptism.
8. Before the rite of baptism is admitted, the clergyman shall first read aloud
the above seven rules, that all the members of the congregation may hear
for their instruction, and thereafter Baptism shall be administered in the
usual form Translated from Chinese original (MWC, 1910, p.325)
From the foregoing, it is clear that there is no single direct in junction from the Bible
against polygamy. All the hue and cry about it in the Christian church is a mere clash of
cultures and ethnocentrism. The Biblical laws and injunction remain the same across
cultures though, their application may differ. Both the Orients and the Occidents have
different norms and cultures and they are not to be compared with each other but
rather the validity of any norm or cultural item such as polygamy should be evaluated
under the lens of the Bible with objectivity and without prejudice. (Bouit, J.J. 1981)
Happenstall notes:
We must refuse to regard as essential what is not firmly rooted in the scriptures.
The absolute truth of Christianity came not from Augustine or Calvin or from
Thomas Aquinas or Martin Luther, or from the Adventist Church. But from The
Holy Bible. The doctrine sacred scripture, miraculously inspired and authoritative
is indispensable to the Christian faith and to the church itself. (Happenstall, E.
1979 p.14)
The words of E. Kolz as cited in Bouit 1981 ‘they (German East Africa) hall refused
baptism to polygamists, not on the grand of biblical principle but because they wanted
to uphold what they considered the united counsel of 1913’ corroborated Happenstall’s
view. Also, W.T. Bartlett in Bouit 1981 announced:
Everybody understand that we are out to fight polygamy…..it is the
great evil in which Satan has power. Everybody must understand
that our mission village stands absolutely four square against
polygamy….we feel that it is absolutely vital to the existence of the
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
51
to wife Judith the daughter of Beeri the Hittite, and Bashemath the daughter of Elon the
Hittite. Which were a grief of mind unto Isaac and Rebecca’ (Gen. 26:34 – 35)
OBJECTION 2: That Deut. 17:16-17 and 1 king 11: 1 -8 are against polygamy.
REFUTATION 2: Both Deut.17:16-17 and 1 king 11:1-8 are not specifically against
polygamy but sound a note of warning on the abuse of power, excessiveness
edaciousness and materialism. They also encourage steadfastness and sincerity in the
worship of the only one God by shunning foreign wives. A portion of the verses reads:
‘for it come to pass, when Solomon was old, that his wives turned
away his heart after other gods and heart was not perfect with the
Lord his God, as was the heart of David his father’ (1 king 11:4)
Neither shall he multiply wives to himself, that his heart turn not away
neither shall he greatly multiply to himself silver and Gold.(Deut. 17:17)
OBJECTION 3: That Abraham never intended to be a polygamist if not for the barrenness
of his first wife Sarah (Gen. 16:2-10)
REFUTATION 3: Yes in almost all human culture, barrenness of the first wife is one of the
genuine causes of polygamous marriage. Yet, he was never blamed or cursed by God for
being a polygamist. Rather he was blessed and remains among His favorites. He is even
in paradise (Luke 16:22-25)
OBJECTION 4: That polygamy of the kings characterized by corruption and temptations
therefore is condemned by God.
REFUTATION 4: Nevertheless, there is no simple statement condemning polygamous
marriage from the Bible instead, it addresses the likely evil of marriage to alien wives
and abuse of polygamy.
OBJECTION 5: That these verses 1Ttim. 3:2 and Titus 1:6 are against polygamy
REFUTATION 5: The verses specifically refer to church leader and not church members
let alone general public it is also an indication that some faithful then were polygamous.
1 Timothy 3:2 read thus: A Bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife,
vigilant, sober, of good behavior given to hospitality, apt to teach’
OBJECTION 6: That polygamy is like adultery and other immoralities mention in Heb.
13:4; 1 cor. 5:11 and Gal. 5:19-21
REFUTATION 6: Those passages did not mention polygamy at all. The Bible contains
punish for adultery but did not for polygamy. Also polygamy is a legal marriage
recognized by the Bible as practiced by most of the prophets while adultery is not.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
53
Hence after a Keen scrutiny of the Biblical verses, it is ascertained that there is no single
unequivocal text which forbids or commands either polygamy or monogamy (Bouit, J.J,
1981 p.81; Zakir Naik)
The Christian believe that marriage is an eternal bond between a man and a woman
to become one indivisible flesh. (Matt:19:5).Therefore, polygamy is not
permitted .Though, there is no unequivocal statement or Biblical verse to support this
age-long doctrine which has practically increased the number of unmarried young ladies
,widows and divorcees in environments where monogamy is strictly adhere to and
polygamy castigated.
If the Israelites were to be monogamous, Pharaoh would not have been scared by
their growing population having being in Egypt for 430 years (Exod.12:12:40).
Monogamy as advocated by Christians is antithetical to God’s plan for man to be fruitful
and multiply on earth (Gen.1:28).it is also contrary to the Bible’s teachings and
permittance of polygamy. (Exod.21:10). In reference to David, God told him: ‘I gave you
your master’s wives ‘(2 Samuel 12:8). God, the Almighty never condemn any case of
polygamy in the Bible other than that of David as regard Uriah’s wife due to the
circumstance around it (2 Samuel 12:8-12).If polygamy is a sin as presented by most
churches, Abraham will not be in paradise (Luke16:19-31).
David, a chosen prophet of God had 8 wives whose names are scattered in 1 st
Samuel and 2nd and first chronicles. Abraham, father of faith and all nations married
keturah as his third wife (Gen.25:1).Among other godly people who practiced polygamy
in the Bible are: Abidjan 2 chronicles 13:21, Ahab 1 king 20:1-3 etc. Even Paul in
1Timothy 3:2 acknowledged polygamy, he did not condemn it.
In lieu of this, the Christians have no substantial scriptural evidence for their
doctrine of monogamy as polygamy is Biblical, monogamy is Western ideology and not
Christian. If polygamy is not prohibited in the Old Testament, it is not a sin the New
Testament. (Matt.5:17)
system having resulted into lewdness and concubinage. (Philip, B. and Jones, J. 2005) In
Islam, polygamy is a legal act yet, it is not mandatory upon every individual male. Allah
says in the Quran 4:3
…then marry (other) woman of your choice two or three or four but
if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly (with them), then
only one or (captives and the slaves) that your right hand possess.
That is nearer to prevent you from doing injustice (Q.4:3)
The fact that this verse says man should marry two or three or four or one if he
cannot do justice among more than one wife is not an encouragement that every man
should have minimum of two wives. Rather, it is a mere permissibility for those who can
meet the conditions of Islamic polygyny which include ability to equitably provide
shelter, food, cloth and other sustenance to the wives as indicated in the following
Hadiths (Philip, B and Jones, J. 2005)
The prophet (P.B.U.H) said ‘whoever has two wives and unduly to one of them will be
raised paralyzed on the Day of judgment.’ He also said as regard maintenance of woman
in a Hadith reported by Mu’awiyah al-Qushayri ‘that you feed her when you get food to
eat, clothe her when you get clothing for yourself…’ (Sunan Abu Dawud)
4.5.2. Circumstances which might Necessitate Polygyneous Marriage
Barrenness: One of the reason or importance of marriage is to safe human race
from extinction through procreation. Thus, in the absence of a child in a long
time marriage, a man may opt for another wife while the first wife subsists and
this is better than sending her away. Children partly account for the joy of a
marriage. The Prophet (S.A.W) is reported to have said: ‘Marry the loving and
fertile woman, for indeed I will be proud of your great numbers’ (Abu Dawud
2050) .In addition, the major reason for the polygamous lives of Abraham and
Jacob was bareness of their first wives respectively. The Bible says: (Gen 16:2-9)
‘Now Sarai, Abram’s wife had borne him no children. But she had an Egyptian
maidservant named Hagari, so she said to Abraham, “The Lord has kept me from having
children. Go sleep with my maidservant; perhaps I can build a family through her.”
Abram agreed to what Sara said….’ (Gen 16:2-10) medically, due to abortion,
complications during labour or caesarean section…
Cultural Practices: in most African societies, a monogamous man could not stand
edge to edge with a polygamist express his views in the presence of polygamous
men who enjoy high social esteem. For the singular reason of fitting into the
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
55
It should be noted from the 1st paragraph of the above excerpt that aside the scarce
birth of boys most of those that were born did not survive infancy. In this situation,
polygyny is far better that hypocritical monogamy which breeds illegal secret marriages
and brings down the status of woman by turning them into exploitable species in the
hands of ungodly men. Philip, B and Jones j write:
…It becomes obvious that there are not enough men for each woman
to have one. Thus many women are obliged to become mistresses,
girlfriends and playmates to fulfill their natural physical needs,
leaving their psychological needs distorted in such demeaning
relationship. Muslim can choose to join the West in its death throes,
falsely called “progress” and “sophistication”, or choose to retain Islamic
values. It is a fact that the average married Western citizens continue to
seek personal sexual freedom outside the framework of marriage. Serial
or progressive monogamy in which a person marries a number of times is
so widespread today that it has arrived as alternative marriage structure
in American society (Philip, B, and Jones J. 2005)
Virility of the husband: Obviously, no woman would want to share a husband
with other woman. Since the communal wellbeing overrides individual’s right in
Islamic law, polygamy as a form of marriage is legalized and has the potential to
solve the menace of the ever increasing population of female and scarcity of
male and as well protect the natural right and dignity of woman.
Aside the upsurge in the population of female, virility of a husband may necessitate a
polygamous lifestyle (Philip, B and Jones, 2005). Scientific studies have shown that men
mostly are more easily (even by mere glance at a female picture) and frequently sexually
aroused than woman. They think more about sex than woman. Sexual desire in woman
is usually stimulated by environment, exposure cultural orientation. Sexual desire in
woman is emotionally driven. However, men sex drives are stronger than woman. Philip,
B. and Jones, J. hold that this suites their natural role of motherhood and would surely
enable them build a family, the essential unit of every society. Roy Baumeister cited in
Richard Sine 2020 states that men have more varied fantasies and frequent sexual
aroused and that men seek more sex than woman throughout marriage relationship,
look for more sex partner and usually, show interest in casual sex than woman. They
often seek sex even at wrong places (Richard sine, R. 2020)
Sometimes, to some men, emotion or passion is out of sex. They satisfy their sexual
urges from anywhere it is obtainable irrespective of the personality they want to
cohabitate with, this is one of the reason they go after prostitutes which is a matter of
men seeking sex with woman and not vice versa, so also rape. Male priests are more
often involved in sex scandal than nuns. Richard Sine affirms that:
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
57
fear that you not be able to deal justly (with then). Then only one or (the
captives and the slaves) that your right hands possess. That is nearer to
prevent you from doing injustice’ (Q. 4:3)
“you will never be able to do perfect justice between wives even if it is
your ardent desire, so do not incline too much to one of them (by giving
her more of your time and provision) so as to leave other hanging (i.e.
neither divorce nor married). And if you do justice, and do all that is right
and fear Allah by keeping away from all that is wrong, then Allah is
over Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful” (Q 4:12a).
It is deduced from the above verse that financial capacity is a requisite for practicing
polygamy. An intending polygamous man must be financial buoyant in order to
adequately cater for the needs of his family.
Another important condition of polygamy is justice. A polygamist must be able to
maintain equity and justice among his wives. A man who lacks this quality is encouraged
to stick to only one wife. Each of the wives in a polygamous must be related to with
justice and equity, none of the wives is superior or inferior to the other. They all have
equal conjugal and social rights unlike the Western polygamy which is devoid of
responsibility as described by Annie Besant, her words:
There is pretended monogamy in the west, but there is really polygamy
without responsibility. The ‘mistress’ is cut off-when the man is weary of
her and sinks gradually to ‘the woman of the street’ for the first lover
has no responsibility for her future and she is a hundred times worse off
than the sheltered wise and mother in the polygamous home when we
see the thousands of miserable women, who crowd the street of Western
towns during the night, we must surely feel that it does not lie in Western
mouths to reproach for its polygamy with respect, than to be reduced to
the cast-out on the streets perhaps with an illegitimate child outside the
pale of law-unsheltered and uncared for , to become a victim of any
passer-by, night after night rendered incapable of mother-hood,
despised by all. (Doi, I.A. nd, p.72)
However, majority of the scholars agree that the Justice stated in the Quran 4:3 is
concern with concrete and material things like feeding, shelter, clothing, gifts etc. A
polygamist must demonstrate equity among his wives in this regard. Whereas the
justice described in the Quran 4:129 that man can never do justice among his wives is
addressing the issue of love, emotion, feelings which is firstly a matter of the heart
which man has no control over but Allah . Abdullah Bin Amr bin al-As reported that the
Apostle of Allah (S.A.W) said:
Verily, the hearts of the children of Adam, all of them, are
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
59
infinite wisdom knows why He permitted polygyny. But humanly, male fatality is far
higher than female , male are more exposed to hazardous works or activities( compare
to female) such as wars and invasions either internal or external(e.g. America against
Iraq, and Afghanistan , ISIS in Syria etc.) and the casualties are usually male leaving
behind humongous number or widows and unmarried young ladies . ( Ibrahim, A. 2020)
As a result, there is higher female population than male, in USA alone, there are 6.54
millions female more than male. In UK, there are 3.86 millions female more than male
(Erin, D. 2020). And Germany has 1.092 millions female more than male (Evgeniya, K.
2019)
However, if every man should practice monogamy, what would be the faith of the
remaining unmarried young ladies and widows? Definitely, polygamy as prescribed in
the in the Islamic Shari’ah is the panacea.
Yes, Islam never mandates polygyny on every individual but allows it with logical
regulations as stipulated in the Qur’an, Suratun-Nisaa verses 3 and 129.
In summary, the Bible speaks in favour of polygamy while most Christians defiantly
antagonize it. The Jews are confused about it whereas, their scriptures uphold it. It is
only Muslims that comply to their Shari’ah rulings on polygamy though some of them do
abuse it.
4.6.1 Divorce
Divorce as a verb according to Cambridge dictionary is to put an end to a marriage
contract through an official or legal process. This is the cessation of marital union,
separation between husband and wife. Different culture religions have handled it
differently in human history with women at the receiving end. From the outset of a
consensual sincere marital relation, no couple would have dreamt, or wished for a
divorce.
While divorce was very loose in the early Greek society, the primitive Romans made
it impossible to achieve after the rites of marriage had been concluded. Due to the
absence of divorce in the religions law, spousal killing could occur to get rid of one’s wife
or husband. Though, the laws of the Twelve Tables (451-450BC) made a provision for
divorce with the power vested in the husband (Doi, I. A. nd p .78).
Divorce among the Arab of Pre-Islamic era was determined by the nature of
marriage practiced in a particular region; patrilineal or matrilineal marriage. If it is
matrilineal marriage, a woman can divorce her husband at will by just changing the
direction of her tent, east to west or north to south and vice versa. While in patrilineal a
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
61
woman had no right to divorce at all she was considered part of the husband’s property.
(Smith, W.R. 1907)
Gone are the days when family ties were held in high esteem and divorce was very
rare and stigmatized. Today, it has become the trend with alarming rate, formally and
informally, both in regular marriage and legal partnership. The religious courts of the
supreme court in Indonesia granted 344,232 divorces in 2014 alone, 347,256 in 2015
and 365,633 in 2016 with an annual increase of about 3% (Gabriella, D.B.2017) from 2.2
Million marriages that were conducted in EU in 2016 there were about 1 Million
divorces (eu.europa.edu 2017).Vanguard news reported that between January and
March 2017, 24 divorces case were filed in a single court in Abuja, Nigeria.
(vangardngr.com April 2017). Divorce Magazine reported the provisional number of
marriages, divorces and annulment rate in the United States for the period between
2000 and 2017 where it represented the number of marriage for 2016 to be 2,245,404
implying 7.0 per 1000 of the total population (www.divorcermag.com, 2019)
Furthermore, it presented the percentage of new marriage that end up in divorce in
2012 only from Sweden 54.9%, Belarus 52.9%, England 51.2%, Luxembourg 47.4%,
Estonia 46.7, Australia 46% and united States 45.8. The divorce rate in Montana as at
2014 was 12.2 divorces for every 1,000 and Idaho had 14.4 divorces cases per 1,000
women (www.divorcemag.com2019)
However, Divorce is capable of having devastating emotional, social and psychology
effects on the couple, children and the society at large. There are ranges of factors that
can lead to divorce and the list is endless. They include; child marriage, Domestic
Violence, Women Independence, Liberal divorce Law, Risk taking behaviors, arranged
marriages, Financial problem, Infidelity, conflict and arguing, incompatibility etc.
4.6.2. Causes of Divorce
The following are some of the factors that can lead to dissolution of marital union.
1. Gender Role and Female Employment: Increase in married women employment and
shift in gender role from imbalance to gender equality. Some women pursuit their
career religiously at the detriment of their role at home. This drastically affects
marriages and the eventual dissolution of some. Harkonem states: ‘indeed, the
trends in female employment and in divorce rates have closely followed one another
and a positive relationship between the two is also visible across countries’.
(Harkonem J, 2014). The higher the earning of career women the higher the
tendency of losing their marriage because she is already engrossed in her job and
can sacrifice anything to sustain and keep her career growing. This eventually
resulted into more female filing for divorce than male. Despite its adverse effects on
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
62
their children especially those women who are more economically stable than their
husband. Lowenstein (2005). It was noted that some unemployed women remained
in their marriage despite its bitterness, economic statuses. Lowenstein (2005) and
the idea of “common purse” or joint account still prevent some marriages from
dissolution.
2. Low Intelligence: Education and Social skills: it was discovered that couples with low
education, intelligence and or social exposure have higher rate of divorce compare
to those highly educated, intelligent and exposed. This implies that people with
advanced education are meticulous in selecting spouses and this make their
marriage work (Lowenstein, 2005)
3. Alcoholism and Drug Abuse: Both drunkenness and substance abuse have been
identified as some key factors contributing to increase rates of divorce in America. A
drunken person is proven to misbehave and quarrel with people around him or her.
It can degenerate to incessant domestic violence which is another cause of divorce
(Lowenstein, 2005)
4. Sexual Incompatibility: Richard Sine (2020) affirms that men’s sexual drives are
usually stronger than women. They have frequent sexual arousal and fantasies than
women. That men do want sex more than women at every points or stages of
marital relationship whereas women sex drive are somewhat weaker and vulnerable
to influence. Though, it is not always as just explained there are certain instances
when a wife would have higher sexual drives than her husband or would have a
different perspective or attitude to sex due to previous sexual life style
(Cohabitation, Legal relationship). This will surely affect her current marriage and
stands at higher risk of divorce. If on the other hand the wife is the spouse with
lower sex drive, divorce is among the lines of options available aside polygamy if
allowed or adultery which is a vice and ridiculous.
5. Diverse Interests and Status: Difference of opinions, is often the source of argument
in every gathering and interaction so, if there is serious differences in the lifestyle of
a couple; they are at the risk of divorce. Whereas, a marriage in which the couple
have more similarities ranging from religion, work, educational level, ethnicity, goals
and social life style tends to last longer than a union where these are lacking
(Lowenstein, 2005)
6. Child Marriage: Among other names which are synonymous to child marriage are
‘underage marriage’, ‘Adolescent marriage’, ‘and teenage marriage’. This is a
marriage between individuals who are not medically, psychologically and physically
prepared to marry. This stage of life features emotional instability, nasty and hasty
decisions which may lead to marriage without consideration of its responsibilities,
just to fulfill sexual needs. Thus, this unpreparedness to tackle marital challenges
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
63
and emotional immaturity often lead to marriage dissolution. It was also observed
that some of these child or too early marriages came about as a result of premarital
pregnancy and shortly after the baby is born, some of the marriages collapse
(Gabriella, D.B, 2007 p.9). Also, Lowenstein (2005) noted that the risk of divorce is
higher for a woman who married before the age of 18 than one who married after
the age of 20.
7. Liberal Divorce Laws: Since 1965 to 2016 the rate of divorce has tremendously
increased in EU member states. Many studies attribute this increase to the change in
divorce law from mutual consent to permittance of unilateral divorce 1970 – 1985.
Previously, divorce was prohibited in many western countries and was recently
legalized in Spain 1981, Malta 2011, Ireland 1997 and Italy 1974. Adultery, insanity
with tiring process before 1970 when California opened the floodgate of the
liberalization of divorce in which anyone of the spouse can sue for divorce without a
reason (Harkonen, J.2014, p.8). Ever since with the ease procedure of obtaining
divorce, the national divorce rate in Scotland, England, Italy and Wales has doubled
(ec.europa.eu; Lowenstein, 2005)
4.6.3. Consequences of Divorce
The aftermath of divorce can either be positive or negative. Majority of the
researches conducted usually emphasis the negative results of divorce. Some of the
benefits of divorce include: avoidance of spousal murder, an instance of this is murder
of Mr. Haliru Bilyaminu Bello by his wife Maryam Sanda on November 18, 2017 at
Maitama, Abuja, Nigeria and the consequent death sentence of the wife on January 27,
2020 at Federal Capital High Court (FCT). If divorce had taken place prior that fateful day
the death could have been averted. Premium Times writes:
In his testimony at the beginning of the trial, Ibrahim Muhammed,
a friend of the deceased’s and a key witness, said he was at the
Maitama residence of the couple on the night of November 18,
2017 for over eight hours before the tragedy struck. He recalled
how an argument had degenerated into fisticuffs…. Mr. Muhammed
said Ms Sanda issued many threats to her husband, including to chop
off his genitals if he declined to grant her divorce (www.premiumtimesng.com )
It can reduce rate of female suicide, rate of domestic violence. It is also a sigh of relief to
some separated couple.
Effects on Children’s Academics: The immediate economic standard of the couple
after divorce and the circumstances around it is capable to hampering the academic
performance of the children (Harkonen J. 2014) Separation between parents affects
children in many aspects of life in relation to the age of the child or children at some
divorce. Patrick and Aaron 2012 present the opposing findings of an American Study and
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
64
Norwegian research on the negative effects of divorce on children. While the Americans
found out that the children who are in grades six or ten when their parent divorce were
more likely to get lower grades than those who experienced it at earlier stage, the
Norwegian came out with direct opposite of it. That children in the early classes from
kindergarten to grade 5 get lower score. (Patrick, F.F. and Aaron. 2012). Also, poor
academic performance set in for elementary school children immediately their parent
involve in divorce and remains throughout the elementary school. B y the age of 13,
there is a significant difference between the reading abilities of the divorce parent and
children of unbroken home and High school students of divorce homes have about 11
percent GPAS lower compared to their counterparts in stable homes. It was noted that
the negative effects of divorce on children and teenagers is a long term one. (Patrick,
F .F and Aaron 2012, p.28)
Absenteeism do hamper learning progress and divorce often lead to frequent
students absence from school therefore negatively affects the students academic
performance. Among the evil consequence of divorce on children education is
expulsion, suspension or dropout. Patrick and Aaron 2012 write:
4.6.3. 1. Effects of Divorce on Children’s Behaviour: Every child and even adolescent
has the tendency of misbehaving and exhibiting some anti-social behavior. But with the
presence of and keen supervision by both parents without pampering from either side
those juvenile delinquencies would be curbed and corrected. Meanwhile, separation
between parents would pave way for that ill-behaviour to explode thus creating public
nuisance and disturbance. Various studies have shown divorce as the major factor
responsible for juvenile crimes and antisocial behaviours. Patrick and Aaron 2012
report:
welfare benefits are divorced women (Patrick , F.F. and Aaron C. 2012)
Divorce is capable of pushing one into life of poverty. Divorce mostly has negative
repercussion, on women who largely depended on their husband before dissolution
while the man may add more to his savings. Divorce often lead to poverty (Harkonen, J.
2014) Divorce usually weaken relationship among parents, children, grandchildren and
grandparent just as the children of divorce parents too are susceptible to divorce
because they may inculcate some interpersonal skills which are not healthy for conjugal
stability and might likely perceive dissolution as a panacea to marital challenges
(Harkonen, J. 2014; Patrick, F.F and Aaron, C, 2012)
By and large, as marriage is natural, so also divorce is part of human nature. It is
inevitable in a society. Sometimes, it could be the best step to take in life and another
time, it could be the worse option as it might be necessary at certain circumstance not
that important. A couple or an individual should keenly weigh the pros and cons before
taking the bold stem.
Nevertheless, when one’s spouse becomes ‘bitter half’ and not ‘better half’, the best
alternative is to walk out of such marriage legally and avoid ‘spousal murder’ either of
the spouses could be the victim. Simply prolonged quarrel and incessant domestic
violence might eventually lead to death. The Biblical verse Exodus 14:14: “The Lord will
fight for you, and you have only to be silent” does not work here but Leviticus 10:10:
“Ability to decide for yourself”
4.7. Divorce in Judaism
Initially, in Jewish law the husband could divorce his wife without her consent but
later on the wife’s consent became necessary with the husband solely possessing the
power of get (divorve certificate). (Matt 5:31-32 (Radford, F.M. 2000)
Get is the Hebrew word for divorce document. It is an important aspect of the
Jewish divorce process without it marriage cannot be dissolve and a divorced wife
cannot remarry another man. Rabbis in Israel will never officiate at a wedding of any
divorced person without a get. The presentation of a get is an injunction from
Deuteronomy 24:1 Isaiah 50: 1, Jeremiah 3:8. ( www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org ).
However, in a situation whereby a Jewish man denies his divorced wife a get, hence
preventing her from remarrying another man in the future. This kind of woman is known
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
67
as agunah – “a chained woman’ and any child born in the state is considered
illegitimate.
Also, legally divorced couple are not permitted to marry each other again and cannot
marry a Kohen ( www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org ).
her again, he is required to perform fresh nikah with new mahr. (Furqan, A. 2003, Doi, A
(nd) and Booley, A. 2014)
Talaq Hasan(An Approved Talaq)
‘Hasan’ means ‘good’ or ‘approved’. It is also an approved form of Talaq but its
approval is lesser in degree compare to Ahsan. It comprises of three pronouncements of
talaq during three consecutive period of purity (tuhur). Its consecution does not really
mean there is no interruption. In fact, there might be interval of months or years among
the three months (period of purity). Each of these pronouncements should be made
when no sexual intercourse has taken place after cleanliness from menstrual cycle. After
each of the first two pronouncements, the husband may reverse is declaration, verbally
or via sexual intercourse before the expiration of ‘Iddah. But when he pronounces the
third Talaq, he can never revoke it and they cannot marry each other again except after
or with Tahaleel (Furqan A. 2003; Doi, I.A, nd) Allah, the almighty says:
The divorce is only permissible twice, after that, either you retain her
on reasonable terms or release her with kindness. And it is not lawful
for you (men) to take back (from your wives) any of your Mahr (bridal
money given by the husband to his wife at the time of marriage) which
you have given them, except when both parties fear that they would be
unable to keep the limits ordained by Allah (e.g. to deal with each other
on a fair basis). Then if you feat that they would not be able to keep the
limits ordained by Allah, then there is no sin on either of them if she
gives back (the Mahr or a part of it) for her Khul (divorce). Those are the
limits ordained by Allah, so do not transgress them. And whoever
transgresses the limits ordained by Allah, then such are the Zalimun
(wrong-doers etc) (Q. 2:229 Mohsin Khan).
Furthermore, the word Tuhur is emphasized in the above explanations due to its
importance in relation to divorce. The tradition of the Prophet (PBUH) contains:
Abdullah (b. Umar) reported that he divorced a wife of his with the
pronouncement of one divorce during the period of menstruation.
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) commanded him
to take her back and keep her until she was purified and then she
entered the period of menses in his (house) for the second time.
And he should wait until she was purified of her menses. And then
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
70
Talaq-ul-Bidi’ah
Ordinarily, as discussed above, a marriage becomes irreversibly dissolved after the
third pronouncement of ‘talaq’ at different occasions and time from the first and second
ones. But after the demise of the Prophet (PBUH) another form of divorced emerged
and precisely enjoyed prevalence during the Ummayad dynasty (Furqan, A. 2003) as the
name implied Talaqul-Bidi’ah- Divorce of Innovation. It is the act of making divorce
irreversibly in one sitting by pronouncing it verbally and physically to the wife or through
a phone conversation or in written form which may include genuine email or text
messages that ‘I divorce you’. I divorce you or in one sentence ‘I divorce you three
times’.
Doi clearly writes:
This form of divorce [triple talaq] leaves no room
for conciliation and no chance for reconsideration.
This is usually done by ignorant Muslims to satisfy
their selfish motives. When these ignorant people
pronounce divorce thrice at the same sitting,
they commit a heinous sin against the precepts
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
72
Islam gives woman the right of Faskh to dissolve their marriage if it is not working
out as against the men’s right of talaq. Yet, faskh should be the last option after all
means to conciliation have failed (Doi, I.A.) Allah says In the Qur’an:
And if a woman fears cruelty or dissertations on her husband’s part
there is no sin on them both if they making peace is better. And human
inner-selves are swayed by greed. But if you do good and keep away from
evil, verily, Allah is Ever well- Acquainted with what you do.(Q.4:128)
said, ”I suckled you both.” So, I went to the prophet (to ask him about it). He said (that
you were foster brother and sister)? Leave (divorce) her’. (Sahih Bukhari, vol.3 Book 48,
Number 828) The Q2:228-232; Q.4:35 contain injunctions on divorce.
Radford, F.M. writes that Shari’ah permits a husband to divorce his wife unilaterally
but gives the wife some rights to seek divorce through the Judicial system-Khul’, faskh.
(Radford, F.M. 2000)
Basically all major world religions encourage marriage and discourage divorce. The
Christian church see marriage as the union between Christ and the church which is
inseparable (Ephesians 5:25:33; Matt 19:6) and a convent before God (Matt 5:33).
Divorce is among the most repeated phenomena in the Christian Bible. Divorce as an
aspect of adultery which is one of the prohibited actions in the Ten Commandments.
However marriage is the God’s plan for man. The Bible says: ‘That is why a man leaves
his father and mother united to his wife and they become one flash’ (Gen:2:24).
A lot of things happen in marriage such as incest between father and daughter
bisexuality of a spouse, infidelity, pedophilia, prolonged quarrel, domestic violence,
abusive characters, denials, unfulfilled marital life, drug addiction etc. In case a marriage
is embattled with one or some those listed behaviors and all efforts to reform the
spouse prove abortive should the affected partner continue with such a union or seek a
divorce? Here is the church view on divorce and remarriage;
The Anglican Church does not really preach divorce but allows it as the final solution
to unrepairable collapsed marriage and allows the divorcee to remarry in the church.
Unlike the Anglican, in the Roman Catholic Church, marriage is one of the sacraments
and cannot be dissolved except via annulment or death of a spouse. Even if a couple
obtains civil divorce, they remain husband and wife before God and cannot remarry in a
Catholic Church. (Doi, I.A. nd) There argument is built on this and similar verses: I tell
you that anyone who divorce his wife, except for marital unfaithfulness and marries
another woman commits adultery (Matt. 19:9)
Annulment is the invalidation of marriage contract if it lacks any or all of the
following conditions;
The couple must freely marry without force or reservation
They must honor and love each other for life
They must accept children lovingly from God
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
76
In this situation, either or both of the spouses may request the marriage to be
declared null and void and secure a decree of nullity in order to be freed for
remarriage in the church. (www.bbc.co.uk2020 ).
The implication of this is that the Roman Catholic does not preach divorce, neither
does it directly allows it.
However despite that the Bible does not encourage divorce, it is permitted on certain
circumstances which are sexual immorality, infidelity, Hardness of human hearts and
disbelief or difference in religion as contained in the principal passage on divorce as
follows:
The Pharisees also came unto him tempting him, and saying unto him, is
it not lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cost? And he answered
and said unto them, have ye not read that he who made them at the beginning
made them male and female, and said, for this cause shall a man leave father
and mother, and shall cleave to his wife. And they twin shall be one flesh?
Therefore, they are no more twins but one flesh what therefore God had
joined together, let no man put asunder. They say unto him why did Moses
then command to give a writing of document to put her away? He said unto
them, Moses because of the hardness of hearts suffered you to put away
your views but from the beginning it was not so. And I saw unto you,
whosoever shall put away his wife except it be for fornication and shall
many another committed adultery: whose marrieth her which is put away
doth commit adultery (Matt 19:3-9 NIV)
Two reasons for divorce mentioned here are hardness of heart and adultery. Paul
Cater (2018) explains that adultery in this passage is a representation of the Greek word
‘Pornea’ is represented in ESV as ‘sexual immorality’ and in NIV as ‘marital
unfaithfulness’ The word Pornea encapsulate all the obnoxious obscenities listed in
Leviticus 18:20-24;20:10-21 below
Moreover thou shalt not lie carnally with thy neighbor’s wife to defile thyself
with her… thou shall not with mankind as with womankind: it is abomination.
Neither shalt thou lie with any beast to defile thyself therewith: neither shall
any woman stand before a beast to lie down thereto: it is confusion. Defile not
ye yourself in any of these thing: for in all these the nation are defiled which I
cast out before you (Leviticus 18:20-24 KJV)
Going by the meaning of pornea, incest, adultery, bestiality, homosexuality as
enumerated in these verses are enough reasons for divorce, each of them even attract
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
77
isolation and death penalty (Paul, C. 2018) .Another reason that can necessitate divorce
is found in 1Cor. 7:12-16.
But the rest speak I, not the Lord; If any brother hath a wife that believeth
not and she be pleased to dwell with him, let him not put her away.
And the woman which hath an husband that believeth not, and if he be
pleased to dwell with her, let her not leave him for the unbelieving
husband is sanctified by the wife, and then unbelieving wife is sanctified
by the husband; else were your children unclean; but now are they holy.
But if the unbelieving depart, let him depart. A brother or sister is not under
bondage in such cases; but Goal hath called as to peace. For what knowest thou,
O wife, whether thou shall save thy husband? Or how knowest thou, O man,
whether thou shall save thy wife? (1.Corithian, 7:12-16 KJV)
This passage emphasizes difference in religion as a genuine reason for divorce.
Hence, from the above verse, Paul Carter (2018) identifies the following five
instances as genuine reasons for a Christian to initiate divorce:
1. When her husband has committed adultery with his neighbor’s wife
2. When a spouse practices homosexuality
3. When a spouse practices bestiality
4. When a spouse commit incest
5. When there is a difference in religion and the spouse does not want to
continue, abusive marriage and physical assault, He opines that the wife
should report to those in authority-police and their church leaders or pastors
because he has become a wrongdoer, an oppressor and a sinner for beating
his wife and it is the God’s established authority that can avenge her case
(Romans 13:1-4)
The church should discipline him and if he the church excommunicates him by not
attesting to his faith. Also being an abusive man disqualifies him from serving in
the church. The Bible says:
‘ Now the overseer must be above reproach, the husband of one wife, temperate,
self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, not given to drunkenness,
not violent but gentle, not quarrelsome, not a lover of money. He must manage his
own family well…’ (1 Timothy 3:2-4 NIV).
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
78
Since such a husband has disobeyed God and those in authority the church therefore
consider the woman as being married to an unbeliever who hates his wife on account of
her faith so, the rule of 1 Corinthians 7:15 applies ‘But if the unbelieving depart, let him
depart. A brother or sister is not under bondage in such cases…’ (KJV) (Paul C. 2018)
Furthermore, a Biblically permitted divorce paves way for the victim of such divorce
to remarry. And that is the implication of a certificate of divorce which in Greco Roman
will contain the clause ‘you are free to marry any man you wish’ (Paul. C.2018). Jesus
(P.B.U.H) says. It has been said, ‘Any who divorce his wife must give her a certificate of
divorce’ (Matt. 5:31 NIV)
Also among the implications of 1 Corinthians 7:15 cited above is the legality of
remarriage ‘A brother or sister is not under bondage in such cases….’ But to a Christian
‘…She is free to marry anyone she wishes, but must belong to the Lord’ (1 Corinthian
7:39 NIV) (Paul, C. 2018)
4.9.2. Biblical Measures to Avoid Divorce
Certainly, the most heinous marital crime is adultery which is punishable by the law
and also makes ground for divorce if discovered and if not discovered, God, The
Almighty promises to deal with the perpetrator of sexual immorality in all categories
from adultery to homosexuality, bestiality, incest etc. because marriage is an institution
honored by God. ‘Marriage should be honored by all, and marriage bed kept pure for
God will judge the adulterer and all sexually immoral’ (Hebrews 13:4 NIV)
So, the Bible gives the following measures to regulate, avoid and debar people from
divorce,
MUTUAL LOVE AND RESPECT: the Bible encourages Love between the husband and wife
mutual respect for the sustainability of the marriage for this reason, a man will leave his
father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one
flesh….However, each of you must love his wife as he loves himself, and the wife must
respect her husband (Ephesians 5:31-33 NIV)
To avoid disunity and divorce a man must love his wife dearly and she should
reciprocate with same love and maximum respect. An arrogant and non-submissive wife
will dissolve marriage with her own hand (1 Peter 3:1 NIV)
Good Conducts: The Bible advices woman to imbibe the trait of other past pure woman
who won over their husbands with unfading, inner beauty and absolute submission to
their husbands, thus, they saved their marriage from divorce
Your beauty should not come from outward adornment such as braided
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
79
hair and wearing of gold jewelry and fine clothes. Instead it should be
that of your inner-self, the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit,
which is of great worth in God’s sight. For this is the way the holy women
of the past who put their hope in God used to make themselves beautiful.
They were submissive to their own husbands. (1Peter 3:2-5 NIV)
Husbands’ too are to be considerate, sympathetic, humble and compassionate to
their wives and avoid insulting manners to protect their marriages. (1 Peter 3:P7-10)
This will accelerate the acceptance of prayer.
YOU CANNOT MARRY HER AGAIN: Another means the Bible uses to prevent divorce is
the threat that one cannot remarry a wife one has divorced and has remarried
another man who also divorced her or dies.
If a man marries a woman who becomes displeasing to him because he
finds somethings indecent about her, and he writes her a certificate of
divorce, gives it to her and sends her from his house, and if after she
leaves his house she becomes the wife of another man, and her second
husband ohskikes her and write her a certificate of divorce, gives it to her
and sends her from his house or if he dies, then, her first husband who
divorced her, is not allowed to marry her again after she has been defiled.
Then would be detestable in the eyes of the Lord (Deuteronomy 24:1-4;
Jeremiah 3:1 NIV)
Patience, tolerance and forgiveness are deduced from the passage as some of the
traits that keep marriage going.
DIVORCE IS ADULTERY: Adultery is a grievous crime socially and spiritually and the
Bible in order to deter people from it, prescribes death penalty for it, likened it to
adultery in more than 70 percent of the places where the Bible discusses divorce.
Below are few examples.
He answered, “Anyone who divorces his wife and marries another woman
commits adultery against her. And if she divorces her husband and marries
another man, she commits adultery” (Mark 10:11-12 NIV)
For example by Law, a married woman is bound to her husband as long as he
lives, but if her husband dies, she is released from the Law of marriage so
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
80
them, is she marries another man while her husband is still alive, she is
called an adulteress But if her husband dies, she is released from that
law and is not an adulteress, even though she marries another man
(Romans 7:2:3 NIV)
I tell you that anyone who divorce his wife, except, for marital unfaithfulness,
and marries another woman commits adultery (Math. 19:9 NIV)
Basically, the Bible detests and prohibits divorce but only allows it on the ground of
genuine cases of adultery, serious physical assault, sexual immorality, difference in
faith, after death of a spouse as discussed above, legitimate divorce paves way for
legitimate remarriage. To make a remarriage possible issuance of certificate of divorce
is emphasized above all, what God joins together let no man put asunder (Matt.19:6)
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0. Inheritance.
The inheritance rights of widows and women generally are not conspicuously
described in the Bible. The only direct reference to it is the book of Numbers 27:8-11
which also formed the basis of the Jewish inheritance law in the Baba Bathra, Talmud
and Mishnah.
Under the Jewish law of marriage, the wife is entitled to receive ketubah (marriage
contract) amount from the husband’s estate. (Radford, F.M.2000). She does not really
inherit her husband’s property, she only receives support if does not remarry. Daughters
too were not given any share of the inheritance except in the absence of any eligible
male heir and when she eventually inherit via this channel, she must marry within her
father’s tribe.(Numbers 36:7-8). Aside the unfair treatment of women in the Jewish
system of inheritance, the double portion share of the first son is an iniquity.
(Deut.12:21)
Below is the details of inheritance in Judaism as given by Joseph Jacobs and Julius, H.G:
Each of the sons of the deceased receives an equal share of the estate of his
father or of his mother, except the first-born of the father, who receives a
double share (see primogeniture). A son born after the death of his father
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
82
The husband inherit from his wife , but the wife does not inherit from her
husband .Provision is ,however, made for her support as long as she remains
unmarried (see husband and wife; ketubah).The husband’s right of inheritance
extends only to property that actually belonged to his wife at the time of her
death (see dowry),but not to property that would have fallen to her had she
lived ,as for instance, an expected inheritance from a relative who however,
survive her or a debt which was not secured by a pledge or by a mortgage
(B.B.125b; Nahalot, i. 11, and “Maggid Mishneh,” ad loc.; Shulhan ‘Aruk, Eben
ha-‘Ezer,90,1). As in the case of her sons who died before her death ,the
husband who dies before his wife is not regarded as her heir to the extent of
transmitting her estate to his relatives(B.B.114b;see Rash Bam and Tos.ad loc.;
Nahalot, I .12).A man does not inherit from his betrothed (“arush”;Yeb.29b).
Later authorities made a provision against his inheriting his wife’s property in
case she died childless soon after marriage (see dowry). The husband does not
inherit from his wife if his marriage with her was illegal and carried the
punishment of excision (“karet”), but if the punishment involved was only
stripes, as in the case of a priest marrying a divorced woman, he does not lose
his right of inheritance to her estate (Tosef., Yeb. ii . 3).The husband is also the
heir of his apostate wife (Eben ha-‘Ezer, 90 3, gloss; Hoshen Mishpat, 283,gloss).
(Joseph, Jacobs and Julius, H.G, 2011 )
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
83
However, Job is recorded to have given his daughters inheritance equal to their
brothers (Job.42:15)
Unlike Jewish law, Islam makes provision for both spouses with certain portion of
each other’s estate, then, shares the reminder among the deceased spouse’s relatives.
In spite that Islam is often attacked for giving female half of a male share, there are
situations in which a female heir takes equal or more than a male heir .like the case of a
wife who left a daughter, her husband and her brother.(Radford, F.M.2000)
A regard double share for male child, Mary F.R.(2000) explains : ’One theory provides
that this is not gender discrimination parse , but rather a tangible recognition of the
more substantial male responsibility of supporting his own wife and children.’ She
affirms that : ‘…The Islamic approach of guaranteeing intestates share to certain named
female heirs results often in these women having greater rights than they would have
under Jewish law’ (Mary F.Radford,2000)
Most of the antagonist of Islam as regard women’s issues generally and the
inheritance in particular do base their points of argument on surface level. They either
ignorantly discuss an aspect where a male share of inheritance doubles that of a female
(implying oppression and injustice) are or deliberately silent and ignore other varying
numerous aspects where female’s shares of inheritance are more than male and where
the shares are equal. ‘God is no oppression of His servants ‘(Q.22:10).However, Islamic
law of inheritance does not really base on gender but on other factors (Da’wah institute
of Nigeria)
The Level of Kinship to the Deceased: The closer a person’s relationship to the
deceased, the more such individual will inherit irrespective of gender. For
instance, a daughter of a deceased woman gets half of the inheritance whereas;
the deceased husband takes one fourth. Simply because the daughter is a blood
relation while the husband is related through marriage.
Generation of the heir: Grandchildren always get more share than the grand
parents because grand children have more financial responsibility while
grandparent are often under the care of others .It is a genderless system .The
daughter of the deceased inherits more than the deceased parents.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
84
Financial Responsibility: This is the only aspect where gender affects the share of
heirs. Nevertheless, this difference is not either an injustice to male heirs nor
female but rather recognizes the huge financial responsibilities on male heirs.
This (such as payment of dowry ,school fees, medical fees accommodation,
feeding , clothing ,financial support of in laws and extended family etc. Q.4:34).
This third factor affect the share of the children of the deceased who are equal in
the above two categories. This is where the rule in suratun-Nisai, Q.4:11 comes
to play and it is restricted here,, not generally applied as propagated by most
feminist and orientalists.(www.dar-alifta.)
Furthermore,
…when the issue of financial burden does not exist , as in the case of
inheritance for uterine brothers and sisters, we find that the law give-Giver
makes the share of inheritance of the male equal to that of the female. God
(swt) says, ‘And if a man or woman leaves neither ascendants nor
descendants but has a brother or sisters, then for each one of them is a sixth.
But if they are more than two, they share a third (…).’(An-Nisa’,4;12)
(www.dar-alifta.org)
Dar-alifta identifies four concise and revealing facts about Islamic law of inheritance;
There are just four cases where male share double that of the female, numerous cases
where both male and female have equal share ,over ten cases where a female receives
more than a male heir and there are cases where a female inherits while a man does
not (www.dar-al-ifta.org)
These principles of inheritance are based on the Qur’an 4:7-14. Also, it should be
noted that before the advent of Islam women were totally denied of inheriting both
their father and husband. They were actually part of items to be inherited.
However, highlighted below are some of the rights of wife which make up the duties
of the husband according to Islamic faith;
The husband can inherit his wife if she dies first based on Islamic law.
The wife is an educator of their children.
Www.familylike.com (2020) pointed out the following roles of husband and wife in a
marriage according to scriptural understanding;
As it can be seen from the above, the duties and rights of husband and wife in the
three Abrahamic religious; Judaism, Christianity and Islamic are overlapping and are
therefore similar except that the wife has the right to inherit her husband in Islam which
is not obtainable in Judeo-Christianity.
In Islam women are highly revered that they are never left alone to cater for
themselves except on special situations. They are either catered for little or much by
their fathers or husband or other male relatives depending on the circumstance (Q.65:7;
4:34).
Nevertheless, Islam empowers women with several economic rights like; right to
private ownership of property( after marriage), inherit their husbands, fathers and
relatives, engage in any lawful economic activity to increase their wealth and keep the
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
88
profit to themselves, and receive mandatory nuptial gift-mahr from their husbands as
condition for marriage validation,. The Qur’an 62: 9-11; 4:2,4,7-11 among others form
the basis for these rights.( Doi, I.A. nd, Islahi, A.A. 2020). And the Q.33:35 is not gender
bias as regard economic pursuits and financial independence because Zakat is not
obligatory upon a Muslim who is financially dependent ‘… the man and woman who give
Sadaqat (i.e. Zakat, and alms, etc.)…’ (Q.33:35 Muhsin Khan)
Narrated Amr bin Al-Harith: Zainab, the wife of Abdullah said,… Zainab
used to provide for ‘Abdullah and those orphans who were under her
protection. So, she said… I went to the Prophet and I saw there an Ansar
woman who was standing at the door (of the Prophet with a similar
problem as mine. Bilal passed by us and we asked him, ask the Prophet
the orphans under my protection’. So Bilal went inside and ask the Prophet
regarding our problem… The Prophet said “Yes” (It is sufficient for her) and
she will receive a double rewards (for that): One for helping relations, and
the other for giving Zakat (Bukhari 24:1466 more example in Bukhar 11:938,
Samia Ahmed 2013 identify; Khadeejah bint Khuwaylid, the first wife of Prophet
Muhammad (PBUH), Shaffa’ bint Abdullah whom Umar bin Khattab appointed as market
supervisor and Arwa bint Ahmad, the governor of Yemen during the Fatimid era
between the late fifth and early sixth centuries exemplary as regard women
involvement in economic activities. (Samia A. 2013)
Two books of the Pentateuch, Numbers 26-27; 36:1-12 and Leviticus 25 talks about
land as factor of production and its ownership does not exclude woman.
(www.theologyofwork.org). The economic right Jewish women is also secured through
the ketubah.
The Jewish women are economically empowered through their dowry (ies) which is
secured by the Ketubah and serves as jointure in case of divorce or after the death of
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
89
the husband (Lewis N. Dembitz, 2011). Aside being the homemakers, the Jewish women
were at time the breadwinners of their families as induced or dictated by societal
worldview and were at a time, excluded from participation in economic activities. Rickle
Burman 1982 gives account of the two scenarios as follows;
However, scholars are advocating for a change of the Talmudic anti-woman laws.
Jacoba Kuikman writes:
In the classical Tradition, a law can be modified depending on the
censuses of the Jewish community. Therefore, the many Laws and
customs in the Talmud deny women independent legal status and
equal participation in ritual, prayer, and study as well as those that
discriminate against woman in marriage and divorce should in theory,
be open to change. (Jacoba k.2016)
He concludes based on Talmud that women are not just different from men but as
well inferior to them and their assigned role is at home, whoever defies this among
them will end up in tragedy like Bruriah (and Dinah Gen.34:1) while those who abide
and are supportive to their husband will succeed like Rachel, the wife of Akiba (Jacoba,
k. 2016).
He further agrees that generally, according to Jewish tradition, motherhood is the
essence of womanhood. Thus, men and woman are different but have complementary
roles. While woman will perfectly function at home, men will do well in the social and
political domain. Yet, there are certain women like Deborah, the wife of Lapidoth whom
circumstance made to function in the public arena, Prophetess and judge as evident in
Judge Chapter 4. He writes: ‘in the Middle Ages, the greatest women were considered
those who exercised influence in the public domain did so “in response to the need of
the nation” and largely against their own will (Kaufman: 73)’ (Jacoba, K. 2016)
In the contrary, Susan Grossman vehemently affirms that despite all proscriptive
statements against woman involvement in polities and leadership mantles, there are
evidences which show that woman did occupy leadership roles, spiritually, socially and
politically in Jewish history: she opines that the actions of both Sarah and Rebecca to
influence the birthrights of Isaac and Jacob respectively as recorded in Genesis 21:9-12
and 27:5-13 are political. As well as the involvement of Miriam in the liberation of the
Israelites from Pharaoh by making arrangements for the survival of her brother (Exod.
2:4-9) . She also led other women (Exod. 15:20-21). (Grossman, S.2013)
Susan Grossman emphasized that Deborah was the only Hebrew woman recorded in
Hebrew scripture to have fulfilled the trio aspects of religious, military and political
Leadership because she led general Barak on military campaign to Kedesh against the
army or Sisera. (Exodus. 4:4-10). Athaliah was also an Israelite female monarch, she
reigned for six years (2Kings 11:3-20) (Grossman, S.2013).
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
91
In conclusion, it is crystal clear from the above that home management is the
essential, primary and honoured role of Jewish women thus; they are prohibited from
the public or political affairs or administration as argued by Jacoba 2016.
Notwithstanding, there were exceptional women like Leah, Rebecca, Deborah, Huldah,
Rachel, Athaliah etc. who interfered into social and political affairs and assumed
leadership roles as affirmed by Grossman Sussan 2013.
However, the contemporary realities show the political rights of Jewish women and
the same can be said of Christian women. Grossman Sussan writes:
By the beginning of the 21st century, despite traditional prohibitions from
women filling roles of public authority, even the most traditional elementary
Jewish community had accepted the authority of woman leader in business,
politics and communal organizations (Grossman, S.2013)
That is, in principle they are denied political participation but in practice, they are
politically active.
The Believers, men and women, are protectors one of another; they
enjoin what is just, and forbid what is evil they observe regular prayers,
practice regular charity, and obey Allah and His messenger. On them will
Allah pour His Mercy: For Allah is exalted in power, Wise.
Haifaa A. Jawad 1998 writes:
For women, especially during the Prophet’s time, were very active
sociallyand politically. They were allowed and even encouraged to
participate in the process of building up the Madinan city and they
proved to be up to the task. (Jawad, A.H 1998)
Meanwhile, Imran, Y. et al 2014, affirmed that women have been denied political
participation as far back as 350 BC and Islam is actually the first to permit participation
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
92
of women in politics contrary to the Western view of Islam concerning Islamic politics
which they build on women denial of political right in the Arab gulf and some Muslim
States. They wrote:
They also noted that on the day of conquest of Makkah, Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.)
first took Bai’ah from the women, then men of Makkah and this indicates equal political
rights of both gender. They also align with some other writers on the leadership of
Aishah during the battle of camel as evidence for participation of Muslim woman in
politics. (Imran Yousuf,S. Sivarajan and Bilal Ahmad Shah (2014) Political Rights of
women As per Islam ‘A study of its concept”. Indian Streams Research Journal Vol. 4 (8).
Retrieved from http://ssrn.com/abstract=2499114 on October 2020.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
93
Since Shura is a key element in governance, the above indicates that Islam grants
women certain political rights (MWL 1995).
Iran did exemplify the political rights of woman as granted by Islam and Iranian
women have significant impacts on elections in Iran prior to 1999 till date (Sanam, V.
2015)
Hence, Islam allows women to participate in the social and political life in as much as
it does not affect their primary roles as wives and mothers (Imran Y. et al 2014).
-------------------------------------------------------------
*Mishna is the first post-Biblical compilation, compiled at the beginning of the 3 rd post-
Christian century by Rabbi Judah
CHAPTER SIX
There are wide range of similarities among the three religions as well as numbers of
differences as regard treatment and status of women. The following are some of the
acute discordances:
In the Judeo-Christianity, where a man can make and fulfill a vow, a woman is
considered the property of either her father or her husband based on the circumstance.
Hence, her pledge is not valid without the approval of her owner (Num.30:2-15). This is
not the case in Islam. Every individual, sane, matured Muslim can make and fulfill a
pledge independently. In fact, inability to fulfill a pledge attracts a prescribed penalty.
(Q.5:89, Q.60:2) (Sherif, A. 2013)
However, the opposite is the case in Islam, she lives her normal life amidst people
touches and plays with her husband but disallowed from coitus. She is also exempted
from salat (prayer), fasting and circumambulation of the Ka’bah. (Q.2:222, Sahih Bukhar
Vol.1, book 6, number 293,294,318,327 and 329.)
right. (Encyclopaedia Judaica P.424).Meanwhile, Islam considers both the married man
and woman culpable for adultery (Qur’an 24:2).
Finally, the story of creation in the book of Genesis 2:4-3:24, the blame of
disobedience is majorly put on Eve and she is eternally cursed for that, the curse which
still manifest on her daughters. Whereas, the Qur’an 7:19-23; 2:32-38 put blame both
Adam and Eve. They both sought God’s forgiveness and they were forgiven, hence no
issue of ‘generational curse or original sin or gender inferiority’. (Sherif, A. 2013)
Conclusion
This thesis traced the historical background, growth, creeds and books of the three
Abrahamic religions; Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Judaism Is the whole set of beliefs and practices of the Jewish people as given by
God, recorded in the Pentateuch and other sacred writings of Judaism. It is the oldest of
the three monotheistic religions dating back to 4,000 years, Christianity 2020 years and
Islam 1442 years. Its origin is traced back to Abraham and its holy Book is the Tanakh-
The Old Testament which forms the basis for Mishna, Gemara etc.
The creed of Christianity is built on the birth, life, death, resurrection and second
coming of Jesus Christ. As one of the Abrahamic religions, Christians believe in the
existence of the Almighty God who shares divinity with the son and Holy Spirit, the
doctrine of Trinity. The symbol of Christianity is ‘cross’ and its most important holidays
are Esther and Christmas.
Islam means peace and total submission to the will of God. It is a monotheistic
religion. Its origin is traced to 7th Century (610CE) in Makkah, Saudi Arabia with
Muhammad son of Abdullah as the messenger of God – Allah. Islam is built on ‘five
pillars’. Its dive Book is the Qur’an. While the annual Islamic festivals are ‘Idul-Fitr and
‘Idul-Adha, the Muslims lives are regulated by Shari’ah.
The positions of women in the ancient civilizations like Rome, Greece, Athens etc.
was also examined and we found that women were considered men’s property and
highly inferior to men thus the birth of a female child was detested. They were forcefully
betrothed at early teen to cement friendship and political relationships. Divorce was
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
96
rampant without any legal procedure. Nevertheless, both male and female children
were given basic education.
It was also concluded that the advocacy should be for gender equity instead of
gender equality. Generally, abortion is strongly prohibited in the three Abrahamic
religions except if the mother’s life is at risk.
Islam encourages male and female who are fit for marriage to satisfy their sexual
urges via legal matrimony and not outside wedlock. Women are great stake holders in
marriage .They have equal marital right with men only that the husbands have privilege
of leadership which must be exercise with love. Islam sees marriage as a virtue and an
act of worship just as refraining from it is considered unholy and unnatural in Judaism.
Although, the three religions agree that marriage (between men & women) is the only
legal sexual outlet, the Christians Bible belouds celibacy and prefers it to marriage which
it regards as alternative for those who cannot control themselves. (1st Corinthians 7:9).
Equally, the three religions vehemently dislike inter religious marriage.
However, the polygamous nature of the Africans posed a big challenge to the early
Christian missionaries as it is against the monogamous marriage of the church as
adopted from the Western culture. Some factors that can necessitate polygyny were
identified. Hence, it becomes a better alternative to divorce.
The duties and rights of husband and wife in the three Abrahamic religious; Judaism,
Christianity and Islam are overlapping and are therefore similar except that the wife has
the right to inherit her husband in Islam which is not obtainable in Judeo-Christianity.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
97
Recommendations
Male and female are not in all ramifications equal and each should be given his
or her due rights.
The position of religion especially regarding women should be taken from the
respective religion’s Holy Scripture and not from its adherents as they may not
act in accordance with their religion’s dictates.
The commonalities among Judaism, Christianity and Islam be used to promote
peace and the few differences should not cause acrimony
Adherents of each of the trio religions should respect views, cultures and
doctrines of one another and not jettison it in order to promote global peace.
Compatibility and sincerity of intending couples should be ensured before
solemnization so as to reduce the rate of divorce
That female education should be prioritized because they are the first teachers
to their children.
The society should not ridicule decently dressed females and put a check on
obscenity.
Bibliography
2020
Adeyeye, .B.A (2018) Assessment of Gender equity in Human capacity Training among
Aig-Imoukheiede, F. (1982) Pidgin Stew and Suffer Hand: The Pidgin(and Other Poems .
Ibadan:Heinnem
Albert, k. Ancient ( nd) Roman Woman: Costumes of all nations Retrieved from
A new look at Christianity in Africa (1972) Geneva: World Student Christian Federation
Arnord , F., Kishor , S. & Roy, T. (2002). Sex-Selective Abortions in India. Population
http://www.Jason.our/stable/3092788
30th May,2021
Baskin, J.R. (2004) European Judaism : A Journal for the New Europe 37 (2)88-102
www.Jstor/stable/41443729.
28,2020
Booley, A. (2014) Divorce and the law of khul’ A Type of No Fault Divorce found within
Bouit, J.J (1981) A Christian Consideration for Polygamy. A Project Report Presented in
Cartwright, M.(2014). The Role of women in the Roman World . Ancient History
23, 2020,
Christianity.org.uk
Crossway Bibles (2001) Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Retrieved from
www.openbible.info on 11/01/2020
Colonso, J.W. (1865) Three Weeks in Natal. Macmillan and co. Retrieved from
https://babelhathitruston.org
17, 2020.
Da’wa Institute of Nigeria (2017)a woman’s inheritance and gender equity in Islamic law
Islamic
22, 2020
May 7, 2020
Furqan , A.(2014) Understanding the Islamic law of inheritance retrieved from 1413960,
114,
bitstreme on 15/7/2020
Gebriella, D.B., Irwan .M.H., Ida ,R.N, Reni, K., Krim, M., Fatimah, A., Lina, R.S., Nyoman,
N. and
June 28,2020
Gregory, S.A. (2018) The Role of Women in Ancient Rome –Piecing Together A Historical
May, 2021
www.myjewishlearning.com.cdn.amproject.org
Islahi, A.A. (2020) Economic Empowerment of Women in Islam, doi.org
Jacob, K. (2016) Woman in Judas in woman in Religious leadership. Boisi Center for
Religion
and American Public Life.
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
102
22-05-2020
Joyce, A. (2019) Where Did the Stereotype of the Jewish Mother Actually Come from?
Rerieved
com/history/issues/issue-17/neglected-history-of-women-in-early-church.html
15/01/2020
www.jewishencyclopedia.com on 03/05/2021
Mark, C. (2014) The Role of women in the Roman world retrieved: https://
www.ancient.eu
Marry F. Radford, (2000) The inheritance Rights of women under Jewish and Islamic law,
Menachem, P. (2020)www.history.com
Miller, Y.A. (2019) 5 Ways Judaism Honours Mother. Retrieved from www.aish.com on
20th
March 2021
Patrick, F.F. and Aaron, C. (2012) The Effects of Divorce on Children. Retrieved from
Marriage
Paul, C. (2018 ) What the Bible Teaches about Divorce and Remarriage. Retrieved from
Ponguo, R. (2013) Why is Infant Mortality Higher in Boys than Girls? A New Hypothesis
Rachel, M. (2019). There is more than One Religious Views on Abortion-here is what
Jewish
Rizvi, S.M.(2014) Marriage and Morals. Retrieved from Ijtihadnet.com on April 28 2020
Romit, I.( 2013) Review The Status of Women in Jewish Tradition retrieved from
www.researchgate.net
Sanam, V. (2015): Islam, Woman and Politics. Chatham house. The Royal institute of
https://submission.org/Women_Islam_JudeoChristianity.htmld.
Smith, W.R. (1907) Kinship and Marriage in Early Arabia . Retrieved from archaive.org on
June
14, 2020
Sahih Muslim, kitabun-Nikkah, 1409, Trimidh 840, Abu Dawud 1841 cited in Mahmud, M
p.134
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
105
2006
Sine, R. (2020) Sex Drive : How Do Men and Women Compare? Retrieved from
www.ancient-origins.net/history-ancient-traditions/greek-women-0013292 on
24/3/2020
www.thetimesofisrael.comRetrieved on 17/5/2020
www.documantanddesigns.com
www.encient.eu
www.un.org
The Rights of Women in the Three Abrahamic Religions
106
www.bbc.co.uk
05-2020
www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org
www.timesofisrael.com
www.theologyofwork.org
Men divorce rate and marital status from 2000 to 2017 Ref.
on 08-02-2022
Zidan, A. (1998)The Rightly Guided Caliphs pp.95-159. Islamic Inc. Cairo, Egypt.
https://www.youtube.com/user/TheMercufulservant