Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: María E. Pistán, Daniel Cook, Susana A. Gutiérrez, Leonhard Schnittger,
Dale R. Gardner, Luciana A. Cholich & Ana M. Gonzalez (31 Jan 2024): Identification and
distribution of a fungal endosymbiotic Alternaria species (Alternaria section Undifilum sp.) in
Astragalus garbancillo tissues, Mycologia, DOI: 10.1080/00275514.2023.2299191
A. mollisimus and A. lentiginosus (Noor et al. 2018), and template. GoTaq DNA polymerase was used as
in the seeds of Ipomoea carnea (Neyaz et al. 2022; Pistán recommended by the manufacturer (Promega,
et al. 2022). Importantly, vertical transmission of the Madison, Wisconsin). Amplified PCR products
fungal endophyte of locoweeds was demonstrated were directly sequenced with the forward and
(Ralphs et al. 2011) and the presence of mycelia in the reverse amplification primers, respectively. DNA
seed coat was identified by light microscopy (Oldrup sequencing was performed at Eton Biosciences
et al. 2010). (San Diego, California).
To date, there have been no microscopic studies
among the SW-containing legumes that have investi
gated all the different organs of the same plant simulta Light microscopy (LM).—To determine the presence of
neously. The objective of this study was to identify the mycelium on the surfaces of fruits, seed coats, and
fungus from the seeds of A. garbancillo by polymerase embryos, the corresponding materials were soaked in
chain reaction (PCR) and to demonstrate the presence sterile water for 30 min, then dissected to expose the
of the endosymbiont in different aerial organs of the different parts of the fruit and seed coat, and stained by
plant using light and scanning electron microscopy. immersion in trypan blue for 3 min at 100 C (modified
from Oldrup et al. 2010).
For the localization of endophytic hyphae, histologi
MATERIALS AND METHODS cal sections obtained from seeds, stem, and leaves were
fixed in FAA (formalin, 70% alcohol, and acetic acid,
Plant material.—Samples of Astragalus garbancillo
(n = 30) were collected from El Infiernillo (San 90:5:5). The material was dehydrated through
Miguel de Tucumán Province, Argentina). a histological dehydrating series and subsequently
Voucher herbarium specimens were deposited in embedded in paraffin (Gonzalez and Cristóbal 1997;
the herbarium CTES of the Institute of Botany, Johansen 1940). Serial transverse (TS) and longitudinal
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences of Northeast (LS) sections 10–12 µm thick were cut with a rotary
(UNNE-CONICET) in Corrientes, Argentina, microtome and stained with astra blue and safranin
under number Pistán ME 02. (Luque et al. 1996). Safranin stains lignin and nuclei
red, and astra blue stains cellulose blue. Finally, the
sections were mounted in synthetic Canada balsam.
Identification and determination of SW Observations and photographs were made using
concentration in different tissues of A. garbancillo.— a Leica DM LB2 light microscope, equipped with
Seeds (n = 15), fruit walls (10 g), and portions of stems a Leica ICC50 HD digital camera (Leica Microsystems,
with leaves (20 g) were dried at 37 C to a constant weight Germany).
and finely ground using a FW100 mill (BioSmartest,
China). SW concentrations were measured using high-
performance liquid chromatography and mass spectro Scanning electron microscopy (SEM).—For conven
metry (HPLC-MS) according to previously described tional observation, portions of FAA-fixed fruits,
methods (Gardner et al. 2001). leaves, stems, and seeds were dehydrated in an
ascending series of acetone, then dried to the cri
tical point with CO 2, and finally metallized with
Identification of the fungal endosymbiont in seeds gold-palladium (Bozzola 2014).
of A. garbancillo.—DNA was extracted from seeds Additionally, paraffin-embedded and cut materials
using the DNeasy Plant Mini kit (Qiagen, Valencia, were observed by SEM using the Gaudet and Kokko
California) as described by the manufacturer. The (1984) technique with modifications as described
PCR primers ITS 5 and OR1a were used to amplify below. To this aim, the material was dehydrated and
a region of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) embedded in paraffin and then cut into 50-µm-thick
(Cook et al. 2009b). Thermal cycling conditions serial sections as previously described (see Light
for amplification of the ITS region from fungal Microscopy (LM)). Sections were affixed to a glass
isolates as well as plant samples were set as fol slide with Haupt’s adhesive (Bissing 1974) and dried
lows: an initial denaturation step at 94 C for for 48 h. The slides used for SEM observation were
3 min, followed by 40 cycles at 94 C for 33s, 57 previously cut into 4-cm-long sections, so that they
C for 50s, and 72 C for 30s, with a final extension would fit into the critical point drying chamber. The
step at 72 C for 5 min. To each reaction 50 ng of slide-mounted sections were deparaffinized with xylol,
total DNA isolated from the seeds were added as dehydrated in an ascending series of acetone, and dried
MYCOLOGIA 3
to the critical point with CO2. The pieces of glass slides both amplified ITS sequences were highly similar (>99%
with several sections were attached with double- identity, E value of 0.0) to the ITS sequences character
adhesive tapes to aluminum stubs and sputter-coated ized from isolates of A. bornmuelleri, A. cinerea, A. fulva,
with gold-palladium and examined with a scanning and A. oxytropis, previously described as Undifilum spe
electron microscope. cies. These results suggest that A. garbancillo is infected
The materials were observed and documented by by a fungal symbiont belonging to Alternaria section
photomicrographs using a scanning electron micro Undifilum, potentially representing an undescribed
scope (JEOL 5800 LV) at the Electronic Microscopy species.
Service of Corrientes (UNNE), Argentina.
Anatomy of A. garbancillo.—Examination of the
RESULTS sampled plants from the field revealed the absence
of visible hyphae on the different surfaces (leaves,
Identification and determination of SW
stems, fruits, and seeds) (FIG. 1). However, the
concentration in different tissues.—Swainsonine was
leaflets and fruits are covered with nonglandular
detected in all the tissues at concentrations of 0.08% of
trichomes (FIG. 1b–c).
dry weight (DW) in the seeds (100 mg DW), 0.02% of
DW in fruit walls, and 0.02% of DW in leaves and stems
Vegetative organs
of A. garbancillo.
Longitudinal sections of petioles and stems revealed
endophytic hyphae growing intracellularly inside par
Identification of the fungal endosymbiont in seeds enchyma cells of the pith and cortex. The hyphae have
of A. garbancillo.—Two unique DNA sequences were hyaline walls and cytoplasm that is stained with safranin.
amplified, sequenced, and subsequently deposited in The fungi did not maintain a uniform direction or precise
GenBank under accession numbers OR072798 and orientation; some hyphae were aligned parallel to the
OR072803. The percent identity between the two longitudinal axes of the plant stem (FIG. 2a–e), whereas
sequences was 99.61%. Using the ITS sequence others such as branched hyphae crossed transversely.
OR072798 (510 nucleotides [nt]) as a query, a BLASTn Necrosis or degradation of plant cells was not observed.
search showed as a best hit the sequence OR072803 No hyphae were found inside leaflets (FIG. 2f).
(99.61% identity, E value of 0.0), followed by several
additional sequences (99.41% identity, E value of 0.0) Fruit and seed
representing isolates of Alternaria section Undifilum The fruit wall is divided into exocarp, mesocarp, and
spp. Among these were sequences representing isolates endocarp (FIG. 3a). The exocarp or outer skin was com
of Alternaria section Undifilum spp. from the South posed of a layer of thin-walled cells covered by thickened
American species A. pehuenches (MN317300) and cuticle, the mesocarp consists of several layers of parench
A. illini (MN322830) (Martinez et al. 2019b). Using the yma cells, and the endocarp is made up of 4–6 layers of
ITS sequence OR072803 yielded similar results. Notably, sclerenchyma cells, which are arranged in several planes. In
Figure 1. a. General appearance of the plant. b. Surface view of leaf. c. Fruit and seeds. Bars: a = 20 cm; b–c = 1 mm.
4 PISTÁN ET AL.: ALTERNARIA IN ASTRAGALUS GARBANCILLO TISSUES
Figure 2. a–f. Light microscope photographs stained with astra blue–safranin (a–c) and scanning electron microscope photographs
(d–f) from stem and leaf of A. garbancillo showing mycelia of fungal endosymbiont (arrows). a–e. Longitudinal sections of petiole (a–b)
and stem (c–e). f. Transversal section of leaflet without hyphae. Bars: a–e = 25 µm; f = 100 µm.
fully ripe fruits, the outer layers dry out and the mesocarp concentration in seeds (0.08% DW) and fruit walls
is compressed. Hyphae were observed on the external (0.02% DW), besides other plant organs, and observed
surface of the fruit (FIG. 3a, b). In addition, the presence that the SW content in seeds was about 4 times higher
of septate hyphae with a sinuous course in the mesocarp is than in any other studied tissue. The different SW con
very abundant (FIG. 3b–e). centrations among species and within different organs
Seeds have a three-layered seed coat. The outer coat is of a species is consistent with observations in popula
referred to as exotesta and is composed of a layer of tions of A. pehuenches, A. illinii, and A. chamissonis,
thick-walled, palisade-like macrosclereids, common to where it has been reported to range from under 0.001%
all legumes (FIG. 3f). Adjacent to the exotestal cells is to over 0.08% DW (Martinez et al. 2018, 2019b).
the mesotesta, which is followed by the endotesta; both The association of the SW-producing endosymbiotic
these inner cellular layers are formed by thin-walled fungus Alternaria section Undifilum spp. with several
parenchyma cells. In these latter two layers, hyphae Astragalus species has been demonstrated by in vitro
were frequently present (FIG. 3f–h). Hyphal growth culture (Martinez et al. 2019b; Noor et al. 2020).
was also visible on the inner side of the fruit and seed. However, it has been reported that from the species
Within the seed, hyphae were abundant in the endo A. mollisimus var. thompsonii and A. amphioxys, detec
sperm (FIG. 3i) but not in the embryo tissues. tion of the fungus Undifilum spp. was faster and less
laborious by PCR than by culturing (Ralphs et al. 2008).
Additionally, Martinez et al. (2019b) reported that when
DISCUSSION
SW concentrations were lower than 0.01% DW, the
The presence of the SW-producing fungus is endophyte could not be in vitro cultured but was con
a prerequisite for the presence of SW in plants (Braun sistently detected in Astragalus samples by PCR.
et al. 2003; Pistán et al. 2022; Ralphs et al. 2011). Interestingly, these observations may suggest a higher
However, it has been observed that the SW concentra sensitivity of endophyte detection by PCR detection
tion varies widely between plant species and within the than by in vitro culturing. In the present study, PCR
same plant (leaves, scape(s), and flowers/pods) (Cook amplification followed by sequencing allowed us to
et al. 2009b). The SW concentration has been estimated determine that the fungal symbiont belongs to
in leaves and stems (0.03% DW) of A. garbancillo, but Alternaria section Undifilum.
not in seeds (Marin et al. 2020; Micheloud et al. 2017). The use of different microscopic techniques has
In contrast, in this study, we determined the SW demonstrated the presence of the SW-containing fungal
MYCOLOGIA 5
Figure 3. Fruit and seed of A. garbancillo showing mycelia (arrows). a, d–h. Light microscope photographs; stained with astra blue–
safranin (a, d, f, g) and with trypan blue (e, h). b–c. Scanning electron microscope photographs. a–e. Fruit. a. Cross-section of pericarp,
hyphae over exocarp (ec) and in mesocarp (mc); endocarp (nc) formed by sclerified cells. b. Mycelia over exocarp. c–d. Detail of
mesocarp with hyphae. e. Inner face of fruit with mycelia. f–i. Seed. f. Transversal section of seed coat composed by exotesta (et)
formed by macrosclereids, mesotesta (mt) and endotesta (nt), and hyphae. g. Detail of f showed one hypha in mesotesta. h. Inner face
of seed coat with mycelia. i. Detail of endosperm with hyphae. Bars: a, c, e, f = 50 µm; b, d, g–i = 10 µm.
endosymbiont of the order Chaetothyriales in Ipomoea No alteration of morphology or changes at the cellular
carnea (Cook et al. 2013; Neyaz et al. 2022; Pistán et al. level were observed in these regions and organs.
2022). However, only a few species of locoweeds from Oldrup et al. (2010) showed by LM that the endo
the genus Astragalus and Oxytropis have been studied phyte of A. lentiginosus is present inside the seed,
microscopically for the SW-producing endophytes. attached to or within the seed coat, but not to the seed
Reyna et al. (2012) and Noor et al. (2018) mention the embryo. Our analysis of A. garbancillo seeds is consis
location of hyphae of the fungus Alternaria section tent with the results reported by Oldrup et al. (2010),
Undifilum spp. in leaves, stems, and petioles of since we observed the fungus to be located in the meso
Oxytropis sericea, A. lentiginosus, and A. mollissimus testa and endotesta layers of the seed coat, but not inside
using different imaging methods. Applying SEM, trans the embryo. Importantly, our study also showed that the
mission electron microscopy (TEM), and laser scanning fungus grows inside the endosperm. Interestingly, this
confocal microscopy, these authors identified the exact can be seen also in FIG. 2 of Oldrup et al. (2010), but it
location of the fungal endosymbionts at the level of the seems to have escaped the notice of the authors because
vascular bundle in the leaves and the pith tissue of it is not further mentioned. The endosperm, an embryo-
petioles and stems. In the present study, the location nourishing tissue, either is consumed during the devel
of endophytes in the pith and cortex of petioles and opment of the embryo or remains in the mature seed to
stems in A. garbancillo was found to be similar to that be used in the germination process, during which the
reported by Reyna et al. (2012) and Noor et al. (2018). embryo develops into a seedling (Baroux and
6 PISTÁN ET AL.: ALTERNARIA IN ASTRAGALUS GARBANCILLO TISSUES
Elbein AD. 1989. The effects of plant indolizidine alkaloids (Fabaceae) poisoning in cattle in Argentina. Toxicon.
and related compounds on glycoprotein processing. In: 157:84–86. doi:10.1016/j.toxicon.2018.11.303.
James LF, editor. Swainsonine and related Glycosidase Martinez A, Robles C, Roper J, Gardner DR, Neyaz MS,
inhibitors. Ames (IA): Iowa State University Press. Joelson NZ, Cook D. 2019b. Detection of swainsonine
p. 155–187. producing endophytes in Patagonian Astragalus species.
Furlan FH, Lucioli J, Veronezi LO, Medeiros AL, Barros SS, Toxicon. 171:1–6. doi:10.1016/j.toxicon.2019.09.020.
Traverso SD, Gava A. 2009. Spontaneous Lysosomal sto Micheloud JF, Marin R, Martinez A, Gardner DR, Gimeno EJ.
rage disease caused by Sida carpinifolia (Malvaceae) poi 2017. Poisoning by Astragalus garbancillo var. garbancillo
soning in Cattle. Vet Pathol. 46:343–347. doi:10.1354/vp. in sheep in Northwestern Argentina. Int J Poisonous Plant
46-2-343. Res. 4:72–78.
Gardner DR, Molyneux RJ, Ralphs MH. 2001. Analysis of Molyneux RJ, Gomez-Sosa E. 1991. Presencia del alcaloide
swainsonine: extraction methods, detection, and mea indolizidínico Swainsonine en Astragalus pehuenches
surement in populations of locoweeds (Oxytropis spp.). (Leguminosae). Bol Soc Argent Bot. 27:59–64.
J Agric Food Chem. 49:4573–4580. doi:10.1021/ Neyaz M, Gardner DR, Creamer R, Cook D. 2022. Localization
jf010596p. of the Swainsonine-producing Chaetothyriales symbiont in
Gaudet DA, Kokko EG. 1984. Application of scanning the seed and shoot apical meristem in its host Ipomoea
electron microscopy to paraffin-embedded plant tissues carnea. Microorganisms. 10(3):545. doi:10.3390/
to study invasive process of plant-pathogenic fungi. microorganisms10030545.
Phytopathology. 74:1078–1080. doi:10.1094/Phyto-74- Noor A, Nava A, Cooke P, Cook D, Creamer R. 2018.
1078. Evidence for nonpathogenic relationships of Alternaria
Gonzalez AM, Cristóbal CL. 1997. Anatomía y ontogenia de section Undifilum endophytes within three host locoweed
semillas de Helicteres lhostzkyana (Sterculiaceae). plant species. Botany. 96(3):187–200. doi:10.1139/cjb-
Bonplandia. 9:287–294. doi:10.30972/bon.93-41497. 2017-0117.
Guan H, Liu X, Mur LA, Fu Y, Wei Y, Wang J, He W. 2021. Noor AI, Neyaz M, Cook D, Creamer R. 2020. Molecular
Rethinking of the roles of endophyte symbiosis and myco characterization of a fungal ketide synthase gene among
toxin in Oxytropis plants. J Fungi. 7(5):400. doi:10.3390/ swainsonine-producing Alternaria species in the USA.
jof7050400.
Curr Microbiol. 77:2554–2563. doi:10.1007/s00284-020-
Hardoim PR, van Overbeek LS, Berg G, Pirttilä AM,
02111-2.
Compant S, Campisano A. 2015. The hidden world
Nzabanita C, Liu H, Min S, Ting-yan M, Li YZ. 2018.
within plants: ecological and evolutionary considera
Locoweed endophytes: a review. J Plant Physiol Pathol.
tions for defining functioning of microbial endophytes.
65(2). doi:10.4172/2329-955X.1000192.
Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 79:293–320. doi:10.1128/
Oldrup E, McLain-Romero J, Padilla A, Moya A, Gardner DR,
MMBR.00050-14.
Creamer R. 2010. Localization of endophytic Undifilum
Huxtable CR, Dorling PR. 1982. Animal model of human
fungi in locoweed seed and influence of environmental
disease. Mannosidosis. Swainsonine-induced mannosidosis.
parameters on a locoweed in vitro culture system. Botany.
Am J Pathol. 107(1):124.
Johansen DA. 1940. Plant microtechnique. New York: 88:512–21. doi:10.1139/B10-026.
McGraw-Hill Book Co. Pfister JA, Stegelmeier BL, Cheney CD, Gardner DR. 2007.
Luque R, Sousa HC, Kraus JE. 1996. Métodos de coloração de Effect of previous locoweed (Astragalus and Oxytropis spe
Roeser (1972) -modifcado- e Kropp (1972) visando cies) intoxication on conditioned taste aversions in horses
a substituição do azul de astra por azul de alcião 8 GS ou and sheep. J Anim Sci. 85:1836–1841. doi:10.2527/jas.2007-
8GX. Acta Bot Bras. 10:199–212. doi:10.1590/S0102- 0046.
33061996000200001. Pistán ME, Gutiérrez SA, Schnittger L, Gardner DR,
Lu H, Wang SS, Zhou QW, Zhao YN, Zhao BY. 2013. Damage Cholich LA, Gonzalez AM. 2022. Localization of the fungal
and control of major poisonous plants in the western grass symbiont (Chaetothyriales) in Ipomoea carnea. Botany. 100
lands of China-a review. Rang J. 34(4):329–339. doi:10. (9):729–736. doi:10.1139/cjb-2022-0033.
1071/RJ12057. Ralphs MH, Cook D, Gardner DR, Grum DS. 2011.
Malm D, Nilssen O. 2008. Alpha-mannosidosis. Orph J Rare Transmission of the locoweed endophyte to the next gen
Dis. 3(1):21. doi:10.1186/1750-1172-3-21. eration of plants. Fungal Ecol. 4(4):251–255. doi:10.1016/j.
Marin RE, Gardner DR, Armién AG, Fortunato RH, Uzal FA. funeco.2011.03.001.
2022. Intoxication of llamas by Astragalus punae in Ralphs MH, Creamer R, Baucom D, Gardner DR, Welsh SL,
Argentina. J Vet Diagn Invest. 34(4):674–678. doi:10. Graham JD, Stegelmeier BL. 2008. Relationship between
1177/10406387221094272. the endophyte Embellisia spp. and the toxic alkaloid swain
Marin RE, Micheloud JF, Vignale ND, Gimeno EJ, O’Toole D, sonine in major locoweed species (Astragalus and
Gardner DR, Uzal FA. 2020. Intoxication by Astragalus Oxytropis). J Chem Ecol. 34:32–38. doi:10.1007/s10886-
garbancillo var. garbancillo in llamas. J Vet Diagn Invest. 007-9399-6.
32(3):467–470. doi:10.1177/1040638720914338. Reyna R, Cooke P, Grum D, Cook D, Creamer R. 2012.
Martinez A, Gardner DR, Cook D, Gimeno EJ, Robles CA. Detection and localization of the endophyte Undifilum
2018. Potencial toxigénico de Astragalus pehuenches oxytropis in locoweed tissues. Botany. 90(12):1229–1236.
Niederl en Argentina. RIA. 44(3):378–383. doi:10.1139/b2012-092.
Martinez A, Lauroua C, Borrelli LB, Gardner DR, Robles CA. Rios JL, Waterman PG. 1997. A review of the pharmacology and
2019a. Spontaneous outbreak of Astragalus pehuenches toxicology of Astragalus. Phytother Res. 11(6):411–18. doi:10.
8 PISTÁN ET AL.: ALTERNARIA IN ASTRAGALUS GARBANCILLO TISSUES
1002/(SICI)1099-1573(199709)11:6<411::AIDPTR132>3.0. Verma VC, Singh SK, Kharwar RN. 2012. Histological investi
CO;2-6. gation of fungal endophytes in healthy tissues of Azadirachta
Stegelmeier B, James LF, Panter KE, Ralphs MH, Gardner DR. indica A. Juss. Agric Nat Resour. 46(2):229–237.
1999. The pathogenesis and toxicokinetics of locoweed Yan L, Zhu J, Zhao X, Shi J, Jiang C, Shao D. 2019. Beneficial
(Astragalus and Oxytropis spp.) poisoning in livestock. effects of endophytic fungi colonization on plants. Appl
J Nat Toxins. 8:35–45. Microbiol Biotechnol. 103(8):3327–3340. doi:10.1007/
Takeda S, Tanaka H, Shimada A, Morita T, Ishihara A, s00253-019-09713-2.
Adilbish A, Gungaa O. 2014. Cerebellar ataxia suspected Yu Y, Zhao Q, Wang J, Wang J, Wang Y, Song Y, Geng G,
to be caused by Oxytropis glabra poisoning in Western Li Q. 2010. Swainsonine producing fungal endophyte from
Mongolian goats. J Vet Med Sci. 14:23. doi:10.1292/jvms. major locoweed species in China. Toxicon. 56:330–338.
14-0023. doi:10.1016/j.toxicon.2010.03.020.