MA11Lk CI LAND CI IIDAk(A 1kUL CkIML)

A|| pra|ses to A||ah the a|m|ghty and bounteous |ord here we are go|ng to def|ne the matter
of |and of f|dak |n order to takeaway some m|sunderstand|ngs from the m|nds of hanaf|'s
they peop|e c|a|m that sh|a use to make b|ame upon abubakar that he hurted the Daughter of
kasu|a||ah(pbuh) we wou|d ||ke to te|| them that sh|a has not made that trad|t|on |t |s
wr|tten |n your own authent|c books ||ke sah| bokhar|

Ayesha reported
After the death of kasu|a||ah(saww) nazrat Iat|ma(sa) went to abubakar a|ong w|th Abbas
|bneabdu|mut||b(ra) and asked about her r|ght the |and of f|dakbut abubakar rep||ed!f|dak
|s not the |and of yours |t |s actua||y the |and of maha[areen and ansar because I have heard
from kasu|a||ah(saww) that we rophets(asws) donot nom|nate |nher|tents because our
|nher|tence turns |nto sadqaWhen Iat|ma(sa) heard these words of abubakar she went back
to her house and never ta|ked w|th abubakar t||| her death
keference Sah| 8okhar| vo|#3 para no#24 k|tabu|fara|z page#717 had|th
no#1234(urdu ed|t|on trans|ated by a||ama waheed uzaman)

D|scuss|on about the fo||ow|ng narrat|on
Look at these words and read them carefu||y f|rst th|ng wh|ch shows the cr|me of abubakar |s
that Iat|ma(sa) d|d not ta|k to h|m t||| her death and rema|ned angry w|th h|mSecond th|ng
the ca||ph of mus||ms c|a|med that rophet(saww) sa|d we prophets do not |eave |nher|tents
for our |nher|tencebut |f |t was true that rophet(saw) had sa|d someth|ng ||ke abubakar
c|a|med then why Iat|ma(sa) c|a|med for such th|ng?was'nt that say|ng of the ho|y
rophet(saww) |n the know|edge of Iat|ma(sa) what |s the status of Iat|ma(sa) |n know|edge
accord|ng to sunn| books

IbneAbbas(ra) reported
rophet(saw) sa|d "there are four |ad|es who are super|or than the |ad|es of ent|re un|verse
1Aas|ya b|ntemoza'am the w|fe of f|r'on 2Maryum b|nte|mran the mother of
Iesus(pbuh) 3khad|[a b|ntekhuwa||d the umu| mom|neen 4Iat|ma b|nte
Muhammad(pbuh) |ady of heaventhus Iat|ma(sa) |s super|or than a|| these |ad|es |n
know|edge
keference1afseereDureMansoor vo|#2 page#68 by a||ama [a|a| udd|n
sayyut|(urdu ed|t|on pub||shed |n |ahore ak|stan)
Noe dec|de yourse|f a |ady who |s super|or than a |ady ||ke maryum who has a|so been
revea|ed by God what wou|d be h|s status had'nt she even known about usoo|s and furuhs of
re||g|on a greatest |ady |n the un|verse |s c|a|m|ng f|dak |s m|ne but abubakar |s say|ng no
kasu|a||ah(saww) sa|d aga|nst |t to whom you w||| ||sten?If you are st||| go|ng to accept ca||ph
as a true than you w||| have to deny uran8ecause quran te||s the true way to us |et us go to
the ho|y verse of uran

"nouseho|ds are pr|or than maha[areen and ansar |n the book of God"
(Ch a| Lhzaab verse no#6)
Now th|s verse te||s us the true face of mus||ms f|rst ca||ph who was c|a|m|ng that I have
heard from kasu|a||ah(saww) that we rophets do not |eave |nher|tents beh|nd us our
|nher|tence |s sadqa for maha[areen and ansar but uran |s say|ng someth|ng tota||y
oppos|tte to the c|a|m of ca||ph of mus||m now th|s verse te||s that ca||ph of mus||ms made a
||e towards rophet(saww) two cr|mes have done by ca||ph he had taken f|dak from
Iat|ma(sa) and made ||e towards rophet(saww)

Now |et us def|ne you from hanaf| authent|c book that one who makes ||e towards
rophet(saw) what wou|d be h|s pun|shment

Ab| saeed khudr|(ra) reported
rophet(saw) sa|d Cne who makes ||e towards me so he shou|d see h|s p|ace |n he||
Another narrat|on of Ab|saeed(ra) w|th same words next to th|s narrat|on

keference MasnadeAbuhan|ffa(founder of f|qahehanaf|yya) chapter no#1S page#4041
had|ths #23 pub||shed by shabb|r brothers urdu bazar |ahore trans|ated |n urdu by rof
Mo|ana Dost Muhammad Shak|r

As we have proved that abubakar made a ||e towards kasu|a||ah(saww) and we a|so proved
that one who makes ||e towards kasu|a||ah(saww) he |s |n he|| now you shou|d dec|de
yourse|f by tak|ng yourse|f out of sh|at and hanaf|yyat for a moment and th|nk accord|ng to
these narrat|ons and quran|c verse deos abubakar deserve to be ca|| a mus||m?

Iuture Cr|mes(rophet(s) awared abubakar about h|s future cr|mes)
Abu nazr reported
rophet(saw) sa|d I sha|| take the responsb|||ty of the martyres of ohad abubakar sa|d!a
kasu|a||ah! Are'nt we the|r brothers?d|d'nt we accept |s|am as they accepted?d|d'nt we
fought |n batt|es as they fought?rophet(saww) rep||ed yesbut I do not know what wou|d
you do after meabubakar started cry|ng and sa|d we sha|| ||ve a||ve whatmore!

keference Muwatta Imam Ma||k |bneanas baabu|[|had had|th no#38(urdu ed|t|on
pub||shed |n |ahore a|so |n karach|)

So th|s |s the status of abubakar a cr|m|na| a ||ar the one who has no va|ue near
kasu|a||ah(saw) even kasu|a||ah(saww) |gnored h|m from sh|faat because of h|s future cr|mes
as we proved from authent|c ah|esunnat books

Last Words
We d|d never want to hurt anybody |n re||g|ona| d|scuss|ons but |nfact the ev||s of today who
are mak|ng propogandas aga|nst sh|at |t |s actua||y for the|r treatment

Author Syed Iawad kaza Naqv|