Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: A 50 kbps/ISM band (902 − 926 MHz) low power transceiver for short-range wireless sensor networks (WSN) has
Voltage controlled oscillator been designed in 0.18 𝜇m 1-poly-6 metal CMOS technology and occupy 950 𝜇m × 800 𝜇m. The proposed WSN
Differential encoding modulator
transceiver designed based on an improved version of the Amplitude-Shift Keying communication scheme has a
900 MHz ISM band
better continuous RF modulated carrier waveform as well as does not require complex modulator/demodulator
Push-pull power amplifier
Wireless sensor network
circuits. In addition, to reduce power dissipation and increase power efficiency many circuit techniques have
been adopted. The power dissipation and the power efficiency of the proposed WSN transceivers are 1.58 mW
and 21%, respectively.
1. Introduction
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vlsi.2019.11.010
Received 19 June 2019; Received in revised form 4 September 2019; Accepted 18 November 2019
Available online XXX
0167-9260/© 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article as: F.R. Shahroury, Design of a low-power CMOS transceiver for semi-passive wireless sensor network application,
Integration, the VLSI Journal, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vlsi.2019.11.010
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 3. Waveform of the proposed simplified ASK, ASK, and OOK binary modulated bit stream.
allows prolonging the limited lifetime of WSN while achieving high- Keying (ASK) [16,17,19,21,24–26] modulator/demodulator circuitries
efficiency because they provide the largest percentage from the har- are less complex compared to PSK/FSK, their modulated output wave-
vested energy to sensor devices in the sensor node [12–15]. forms are not continuous. Thus, ASK and OOK are not well-suited for
The low power transceiver architectures and circuit techniques have the semi-passive transceiver. In an attempt to achieve continuity in the
been an active research topic [16–26]. It is to be noted that the modu- output waveform, ASK with a limited modulation index is utilized [22].
lation scheme did not get as much attention from the researchers as the However, the main drawback of this attempt is that the amount of har-
architecture of the transceiver circuitries. Further, it is worth mention- vested energy is highly dependent on the sent data. Especially, if the
ing that the modulation scheme is a crucial element in transceivers that data contains a long series of zero patterns. Another attempt is asym-
are based on energy harvesting from the RF signal. To maximize the metric communication link transceiver [23], with the aim of achiev-
harvested energy, the modulation scheme should support the continu- ing a fair trade-off between maximizing the required harvested energy
ous waveform. In addition, the modulator and demodulator circuitries and simplifying the demodulator circuitries. In Ref. [23], a continuous
for this modulation scheme should be simple and consume low power. modulated output waveform (FSK) is utilized in the downlink while a
As noted earlier, in principle all the transceiver circuitries and simple demodulator scheme is employed in the uplink (OOK). Though,
design techniques depend on the modulation scheme. As an exam- this attempt results in the necessity to equip the transceiver with two
ple, Phase-Shift Keying (PSK) [18] and Frequency-Shift Keying [20] antennas; one for uplink and another for downlink, which affects the
have continuous modulated output waveform, which increases the har- complexity, cost, and size of the transceiver.
vesting energy. However, FSK/PSK data extraction circuitries consume In this work, a symmetric high-efficiency semi-passive transceiver
large power, due to the complexity of their modulator/demodulator suitable for WSNs is proposed. The proposed WSN transceiver designed
circuitries. Although both On-Off Keying (OOK) and Amplitude-Shift based on a communication scheme has continuous modulated output
2
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
waveform as well as does not require complex modulator/demodulator power − 6 dBm. The phase noise of the proposed WSN transceiver is
circuitries. The architecture of the semi-passive wireless sensor node better than −117 dBc/Hz at 1 MHz offset frequency and the received
is depicted in Fig. 2 with the designed work is marked. The WSN energy-per-bit is 9 nJ/Bit, while the total power dissipation is 1.58 mW.
transceiver covers ISM band (902 − 926 MHz) channels with output This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 presents the principle
of the modulation scheme used in this work, Section 3 discusses the cir-
cuit implementation of all building blocks, Section 4 shows simulation
results, and Section 5 concludes this paper.
2. Modulation scheme
3
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
4
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
differential encoding, each digital data bit (Bcurrent (K)) is differentially of digital data is depicted mathematically using
encoded with a previous encoded bit (Bencoded (K − 1)) before modula-
tion. This requires an initial bit with an arbitrary value. The encoding Bencoded (K ) = Bencoded (K − 1) ⊕ Bcurrent (K ), (1)
Fig. 9. LNA circuit. Fig. 11. Block diagram of the differential decoder.
5
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
6
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
7
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
130 nm CMOS
and push-pull power amplifier circuits. To overcome the drawback of
Fabrication
904.5 MHz
the voltage headroom, the bulk terminal of each cross-coupled inverter
−16 dBm
−20 dBm
52 pJ/Bit
402 MHz
228 𝜇 W
transistor connects to the output of another cross-coupled inverter. This
OOK
20.7
[26]
N/S
reducing the threshold voltage of the cross-coupled inverter transistors
67
as well as increasing voltage swing of the push-pull power amplifier.
180 nm CMOS
Fabrication
457.5 MHz
−22 dBm
−10 dBm
915 MHz
12.4 𝜇 W
7 pJ/Bit
OOK
61.5
30.7
[25]
the original encoded digital data. The differential encoder decodes the
−103 dBc/Hz
90 nm CMOS
Fabrication
−12.5 dBm
−17.1 dBm
extracted digital data as depicted earlier in Eq. (2). The detailed design
FSK/OOK
96 pJ/Bit
860 𝜇 W
3.2.1. LNA
The LNA is used to maximize the sensitivity of the receiver, which,
413 ~ 419 MHz
413 ~ 419 MHz
9.2 ~ 42 nJ/Bit
2.84 ~ 5.7 mW
180 nm CMOS
along with the output power of the transmitter, dictates the maximum
Fabrication
range at which nodes can communicate. Aiming at low power and small
−4 dBm
79 dBm
chip size, a self-biased CMOS inverter that does not require additional
122.8
OOK
21.5
[24]
N/S
parasitic capacitance at the output node. The gain of the LNA (GLNA ) is
+1.43 dBm
Fabrication
36.6 nJ/Bit
OOK/BPSK
−62 dBm
19.2 mW
3.2 GHz
2.6 GHz
given as:
104.6
18.9
[18]
N/S
−126 dBc/Hz
106.4
20.2
[20]
FSK
(gmn + gmp)
GLNA = (gmn + gmp )Zout = . (6)
𝜔Cout
Where 𝜔 is the operating angular frequency.
−124 dBc/Hz
90 nm CMOS
OOK/2-tone
Fabrication
12.1 nJ/Bit
−83 dBm
915 MHz
915 MHz
−3 dBm
1.9 mW
6.3 ~ 11.6 mW
envelope (V env ) and it’s average (V ref ). The compare and toggle circuit
−114.3 dBc/Hz
180 nm CMOS
using V env and V ref as inputs. In the envelope, MN1-MN4 are diode-
OOK
18.2
[19]
received signal. V env follows the peak of the RF received signal when
902 MHz ~ 926 MHz
902 MHz ~ 926 MHz
−117 dBc/Hz
1.58 mW
−80 dBa
9 nJ/Bit
113.5
circuit. Hence C2 will discharge slower than C1 and V env will be faster
23.5
Sensitivities
Technology
Modulation
received signal, V ref will be higher than V env . Thus, the comparator
output will be high as well as D-FF will toggle its output digital bit.
Table 1
FoM RX
FoM TX
8
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
FF1 and D-FF2 are used to store a current (Breceived (k)) and a previous 5. Conclusion
(Breceived (k − 1)) encoded received bit, respectively. Exclusive-OR oper-
ation between Breceived (k) and Breceived (k − 1) is done by (G1). This work describes a low power, high-efficiency transceiver
appropriate for semi-passive WSNs. The proposed WSN transceiver
is designed, simulated, and verified using in 0.18 𝜇 m 1-poly-6
4. Simulation and results metal CMOS technology. It combines the major building blocks of a
transceiver such as the LNA, VCO, modulator and demodulator circuits,
In this section, the post-layout with the extracted parasitic RC netlist and power amplifier into one block to enhance the system integrity and
simulation results will be presented. The proposed WSN transceiver has minimize the power consumption. In addition, the proposed modula-
been designed, verified and simulated in CADENCE custom IC tools. tion scheme helps to simplify the modulator and demodulator circuits
Shown in Fig. 12 is a photograph layout of the proposed designed which are positively reected on the size and the power dissipation of
in 0.18 𝜇 m 1-poly-6 metal CMOS technology. The chip layout size is the WSN.
950 𝜇 m × 800 𝜇 m. The proposed WSN transceiver covers the (902 − 926 MHz) ISM
The timing diagram results of the proposed WSN transceiver illus- band with a 50 kbps data rate. The transmitter output power is −6 dBm.
trated in Fig. 13. In Fig. 13, the RF the transmitted a digital data is The phase noise of the implemented VCO is −117dBc/Hz at 1 MHz off-
modulated by an RF carrier of 915 MHz with an amplitude disturbance set. The total power consumption of the proposed WSN transceiver is
duration width of 30 ns, and a digital data rate of 50 kbps. As has been 1.58 mW. This low power has been achieved without sacrificing trans-
mentioned in subsection 3, PED should not delay the negative edge of mit output power, energy-per-bit, carrier tuning range performances,
the CLK. However, due to the disability of the PMOS device to instan- and phase noise. Future research on the design of PLL will be explored
taneously discharge internal capacitors (C1 &C2 ) of PED glitches appear to improve the PVT tolerance of VCO.
at the negative edges of CLK. As seen in Fig. 13, these glitches do not
affect transceiver operation because they are too short to be detected Acknowledgments
by the demodulator circuit.
The simulated the RF modulated carrier voltage is 155 mV rms result- The author would like to thank EUROPRACTICE for their kind sup-
ing in −6 dBm output power from 100 Ω antenna. The total power port by providing the Cadence Spectre Circuit Simulator and the tech-
dissipation of the proposed WSN transceiver is 1.58 mW from a 1.8 V nology files.
power supply. The calculated power efficiency (Epower ) of the proposed
WSN transceiver is 21%, where the power efficiency is given as: References
output power [1] F.R. Shahroury, A.A. Mohammad, Design of a passive CMOS implantable
Epower = × 100%. (7)
total power dissipation continuous monitoring biosensors transponder front-end, Microelectron. J. 90
(Aug. 2019) 141–153.
Fig. 14 and Fig. 15 show the VCO voltage swing and tuning range, [2] M. Sylvain, F. Lehoux, S. Morency, F. Faucher, E. Bharucha, D. Tremblay, F.
Raymond, S. Moineau, M. Allard, J. Corbeil, Y. Messaddeq, B. Gosselin, The
respectively. The VCO has a voltage swing of 0.5 V and a tuning range EcoChip: a wireless multi-sensor platform for comprehensive environmental
of 24 MHz (902 MHz to 926 MHz). The tuning range of VCO is limited monitoring, in: 2018 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems
by the fact that the large parasitic capacitors of the power amplifier (ISCAS), IEEE, May 2018.
[3] S. Kisseleff, I.F. Akyildiz, W.H. Gerstacker, Survey on advances in magnetic
transistors (M7 − M10) appear in parallel to the capacitor (C3) of the induction-based wireless underground sensor networks, IEEE Internet of Things
LC tank circuit. The phase noise performance of the VCO is shown in Journal 5 (6) (Dec. 2018) 4843–4856.
Fig. 16. The phase noise is −117 dBc/Hz at an offset of 1 MHz. [4] S. Ullo, M. Gallo, G. Palmieri, P. Amenta, M. Russo, G. Romano, M. Ferrucci, A.
Ferrara, M.D. Angelis, Application of wireless sensor networks to environmental
Table 1 shows the proposed WSN transceiver performance compar- monitoring for sustainable mobility, in: 2018 IEEE International Conference on
ison with state-of-the-art designs. The post-layout with the extracted Environmental Engineering (EE), IEEE, Mar. 2018.
parasitic RC netlist simulation results of the proposed WSN transceiver [5] V. Markevicius, D. Navikas, D. Andriukaitis, M. Cepenas, A. Valinevicius, M. Zilys,
R. Malekian, A. Janeliauskas, W. Walendziuk, A. Idzkowski, Two thermocouples
are listed in Table 1. The operation frequency of the proposed WSN
low power wireless sensors network, AEU - International Journal of Electronics
transceiver covers the ISM band (902 ~ 926 MHz) which is less than and Communications 84 (Feb. 2018) 242–250.
2.5% of the unity-gain frequency of 180 nm CMOS device. [6] H. Bhamra, J.-W. Tsai, Y.-W. Huang, Q. Yuan, J.V. Shah, P. Irazoqui, A subcubic
To compare the performance of the proposed WSN transceiver, two millimeter wireless implantable intraocular pressure monitor microsystem, IEEE
Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems 11 (6) (Dec 2017) 1204–1215.
figures of merit FoM RX and FoM TX previously presented in Ref. [32] [7] R.W.L. Coutinho, A. Boukerche, L.F.M. Vieira, A.A.F. Loureiro, Underwater
have been considered herein, which are given by: wireless sensor networks, ACM Comput. Surv. 51 (1) (Jan 2018) 1–36.
[8] I. Akyildiz, W. Su, Y. Sankarasubramaniam, E. Cayirci, A survey on sensor
networks, IEEE Commun. Mag. 40 (8) (Aug. 2002) 102–114.
FoMRX = −Sensitivity (dBm) − 10 × log(RXpower (W)), (8) [9] T.S. Panag, J. Dhillon, Dual head static clustering algorithm for wireless sensor
networks, AEU - International Journal of Electronics and Communications 88 (May
2018) 148–156.
FoMTX = Pout (dBm) − 10 × log(TXpower (W)). (9) [10] S.-M. Yu, P. Feng, N.-J. Wu, Passive and semi-passive wireless temperature and
humidity sensors based on EPC generation-2 UHF protocol, IEEE Sens. J. 15 (4)
(Apr. 2015) 2403–2411.
Based on Table 1, it is clear that the proposed WSN transceiver shows [11] R. Badia-Melis, J. Garcia-Hierro, L. Ruiz-Garcia, T. Jimnez-Ariza, J.I.R. Villalba, P.
its competitiveness for FoM RX and FoM TX . This has been achieved with- Barreiro, Assessing the dynamic behavior of WSN motes and RFID semi-passive
tags for temperature monitoring, Comput. Electron. Agric. 103 (Apr. 2014) 11–16.
out sacrificing energy-per-bit, carrier tuning range performances and [12] J. Pandey, B.P. Otis, A sub-100 W MICS/ISM band transmitter based on
phase noise, which demonstrates the effectiveness of the modulation injection-locking and frequency multiplication, IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 46 (5)
scheme in enhancing transceiver performance. It is important to men- (May 2011) 1049–1058.
[13] N.M. Pletcher, S. Gambini, J. Rabaey, A 52 W wake-up receiver with 72 dBm
tion that, the transceivers in Refs. [23,25,26] have achieved low energy-
sensitivity using an uncertain-IF architecture, IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 44 (1)
per-bit with a good FoM TX as a result of the asymmetric communication (Jan 2009) 269–280.
link architecture. In these architectures, the effort and the focus of the [14] I. Abdo, M. Odeh, F.R. Shahroury, A low-power and high-data rate passive RFID
transceiver using 28-nm CMOS technology, Microelectron. J. 46 (12) (Dec. 2015)
design are redirected from the transceiver circuitries side to the anten-
1426–1433.
nas side. In addition, the asymmetric communication link transceivers [15] B. Otis, Y. Chee, J. Rabaey, A 400W-RX, 1.6mW-TX superregenerative transceiver
require to equip the transceiver with two antennas; one for uplink and for wireless sensor networks, in: ISSCC. 2005 IEEE International Digest of
another for downlink, which affects the complexity, cost, and size of Technical Papers. Solid-State Circuits Conference, 2005, IEEE, Feb. 2005.
the transceiver.
9
F.R. Shahroury Integration, the VLSI Journal xxx (xxxx) xxx
[16] M. Vidojkovic, X. Huang, P. Harpe, S. Rampu, C. Zhou, L. Huang, J. van de [25] H. Bhamra, Y.-J. Kim, J. Joseph, J. Lynch, O.Z. Gall, H. Mei, C. Meng, J.-W. Tsai,
Molengraft, K. Imamura, B. Busze, F. Bouwens, M. Konijnenburg, J. Santana, A. P. Irazoqui, A 24 W, batteryless, crystal-free, multinode synchronized SoC bionode
Breeschoten, J. Huisken, K. Philips, G. Dolmans, H. de Groot, A 2.4 GHz ULP OOK for wireless prosthesis control, IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 50 (11) (Nov. 2015)
single-chip transceiver for healthcare applications, IEEE Transactions on 2714–2727.
Biomedical Circuits and Systems 5 (6) (Dec. 2011) 523–534. [26] L. Xia, J. Cheng, N.E. Glover, P. Chiang, 0.56 v, 20 dBm RF-powered, multi-node
[17] X. Huang, A. Ba, P. Harpe, G. Dolmans, H. de Groot, J.R. Long, A 915 MHz, wireless body area network system-on-a-chip with harvesting-efficiency tracking
ultra-low power 2-tone transceiver with enhanced interference resilience, IEEE J. loop, IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 49 (6) (Jun 2014) 1345–1355.
Solid State Circuits 47 (12) (Dec. 2012) 3197–3207. [27] I. Abdo, M. Odeh, F.R. Shahroury, A new modulation scheme for low power
[18] J.H. Jang, D.F. Berdy, J. Lee, D. Peroulis, B. Jung, A wireless sensor node for consumption and small size passive RFID tags, in: 2013 IEEE Conference on
condition monitoring powered by a vibration energy harvester, in: 2011 IEEE Wireless Sensor (ICWISE), IEEE, Dec. 2013.
Custom Integrated Circuits Conference (CICC), IEEE, Sep. 2011. [28] M. Odeh, I. Abdo, F.R. Shahroury, A low power and high efficiency CMOS
[19] D. Daly, A. Chandrakasan, An energy efficient OOsK transceiver for wireless sensor transmitter for wireless sensor network application, in: 2014 UKSim-AMSS 16th
networks, in: IEEE Radio Frequency Integrated Circuits (RFIC) Symposium, 2006, International Conference on Computer Modelling and Simulation, IEEE, Mar.
IEEE, June 2006. 2014.
[20] M. Flatscher, M. Dielacher, T. Herndl, T. Lentsch, R. Matischek, J. Prainsack, W. [29] B. Razavi, RF Microelectronics, second ed., Prentice Hall, 2011 (Prentice Hall
Pribyl, H. Theuss, W. Weber, A bulk acoustic wave (BAW) based transceiver for an Communications Engineering and Emerging Technologies Series from Ted
in-tire-pressure monitoring sensor node, IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 45 (1) (Jan Rappaport).
2010) 167–177. [30] Z. Li, W. Zhen-hua, L. Yong-ming, Z. Chun, W. Zhi-hua, C. Hong-yi, Clock
[21] H. Zong, J. Shen, S. Liu, M. Jiang, Q. Ban, L. Tang, F. Meng, X. Wang, An ultra low generator and OOK modulator for RFID application, J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci. 6 (10)
power ASK demodulator for passive UHF RFID tag, in: 2011 9th IEEE International (Oct. 2005) 1051–1054.
Conference on ASIC, IEEE, Oct. 2011. [31] Y.E. Papananos, Radio-Frequency Microelectronic Circuits for Telecommunication
[22] D.-M. Wang, J.-G. Hu, J. Wu, An HF passive RFID tag IC with low modulation Applications, Springer, 2013.
index ASK demodulator, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 66 (3) (Mar. 2019) 2164–2173. [32] T. Sano, M. Mizokami, H. Matsui, K. Ueda, K. Shibata, K. Toyota, T. Saitou, H.
[23] G. Papotto, F. Carrara, A. Finocchiaro, G. Palmisano, A 90-nm CMOS 5-Mbps Sato, K. Yahagi, Y. Hayashi, 13.4 a 6.3mw BLE transceiver embedded RX
crystal-less RF-powered transceiver for wireless sensor network nodes, IEEE J. image-rejection filter and TX harmonic-suppression filter reusing on-chip matching
Solid State Circuits 49 (2) (Feb. 2014) 335–346. network, in: 2015 IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference - (ISSCC)
[24] M.-C. Lee, A. Karimi-Bidhendi, O. Malekzadeh-Arasteh, P.T. Wang, A.H. Do, Z. Digest of Technical Papers, Feb. 2015.
Nenadic, P. Heydari, A CMOS MedRadio transceiver with supply-modulated power
saving technique for an implantable brainmachine interface system, IEEE J. Solid
State Circuits 54 (6) (Jun 2019) 1541–1552.
10