Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Auditing 3
AUDI7319
MODULE OUTLINE 2024
(First Edition: 2023)
This guide enjoys copyright under the Berne Convention. In terms of the Copyright Act, no 98 of
1978, no part of this manual may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any other information storage
and retrieval system without permission in writing from the proprietor.
Table of Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 3
Using this Module Outline .......................................................................................................... 5
This Module on Learn ................................................................................................................. 6
Icons Used in this Document and on Learn ................................................................................ 7
Module Resources ...................................................................................................................... 8
Module Purpose ......................................................................................................................... 9
Module Outcomes ...................................................................................................................... 9
Assessments ............................................................................................................................. 10
Module Pacer ........................................................................................................................... 15
Introduction
You were introduced to auditing in your second year of studies, and you are now in your third
and final year of your bachelor’s degree and well on your way to becoming a CA(SA).
As mentioned in Auditing 2A, auditing is a very important aspect of your studying career and
working career and is one of the four subjects that you will need to pass in CTA in order to
graduate and commence your articles. Hopefully by now you have a good idea of where you
want to do your articles, if not already signed with an audit firm. Students may decide to do TIPP
(trading inside of public practice) or TOPP (trading outside of public practice) for their articles.
The more common of the two being TIPP, entails three years of working at an audit firm and
conducting audits, hence the subject of auditing is crucial for your success in the audit firm of
your choice and during your articles.
The objective of an auditor, as you learnt in Auditing 2A is to obtain reasonable assurance about
whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due
to fraud or error. Reasonable assurance is gained by obtaining sufficient and appropriate audit
evidence to enable the auditor to express an opinion on the fair presentation of financial
statements.
In Auditing 2A you studied, amongst other topics, the need for an auditor, the regulation of the
auditor, the audit process, internal control concepts and business cycles. In Auditing 3 we will be
going into more detail regarding the audit process in order to start equipping you to become the
best article clerk and CA(SA) you can be.
In learning unit 1 we will be looking at planning an audit; why we plan an audit, what it entails
and the relevance and importance of planning an audit. You were introduced to planning an
audit in Auditing 2A and now we will be going into more detail with specific attention being
placed on the following International Standards on Auditing; ISA 300-Planning an Audit of
Financial Statements, ISA 315-Identifying and assessing the risks of material misstatement
through understanding the entity and its environment and ISA 320-Materiality in planning and
performing an audit.
In learning unit 2 you will learn about our responsibility relating to fraud and non-compliance
with laws and regulations in an audit. Is it our responsibility as auditors to identify fraud and non-
compliance with laws and regulations for our clients as part of our audit? (Start thinking about
this and researching it). In learning unit 2 we will also be covering communicating deficiencies in
internal control with those charged with governance and management. What is a deficiency in
internal controls? Which ones should we report and how do we report these? These topics are
not stand-alone topics and you will need to know how to integrate them into the audit process.
Remember that we conduct risk-based audits, which means that we identify, assess and respond
to the audit risks identified. In the planning stage of an audit (learning unit 1) you would have
learnt how to identify and assess these audit risks, now in learning unit 3 and 4 we will be looking
at some of these responses to the audit risks identified. How do we respond to an audit risk? –
By obtaining audit evidence! And how do we obtain audit evidence? – By performing audit
procedures! And so the puzzle pieces of auditing start fitting together.
In learning unit 3 we will focus on audit documentation and obtaining audit evidence and in
learning unit 4 we will learn one of the ways in which we can obtain this audit evidence – through
test of controls. This is where your knowledge of business cycles from Auditing 2A is crucial.
In learning unit 5 you will learn about the Companies Act and The King Code on corporate
governance and how it affects the auditor and their respective audits.
In learning unit 6 we will continue with obtaining audit evidence and you will learn about
substantive audit procedures. We will also go into detail on performing substantive procedures
in a computerized environment, in other words how do we perform a substantive procedure in
a computerised environment using computer assisted auditing techniques?
In learning unit 7 you will see how an audit comes to an end when you study the concluding
phase of an audit. This unit includes evaluating the audit evidence obtained and formulating the
all-important audit opinion. Start looking at listed company’s financial statements and study the
different audit opinions. What is the same in all the audit opinions you have read and what is
different?
Learning unit 8 focuses on using the work of others as part of our audit procedures and audit
evidence. Whose work can we use? When can we use it? What further procedures must we
perform on the work of others before we can rely on it?
By the end of Auditing 3 you would have been through the whole audit process; from planning
an audit to concluding the audit by issuing your opinion. You should have a thorough
understanding of how an audit is conducted. This knowledge is crucial for your CTA year and
your articles, therefore ensure you are not merely “parrot learning” but in fact understanding
what you are learning to enable yourself to transfer your knowledge to different scenarios.
Enjoy the journey of Auditing 3 and always keep your final destination in sight - CA(SA).
• This document does not reflect all the content on Learn, the links to difference resources,
nor the specific instructions for the group and individual activities.
• Your lecturer will decide when activities are available/open for submission and when these
submissions or contributions are due. Ensure that you take note of announcements made
during lectures and/or posted within Learn in this regard.
Kindly note:
• Unless you are completing this as a distance module, Learn does not replace your
contact time with your lecturers and/or tutors.
• AUDI7319 is a Learn module, and as such, you are required to engage extensively with
the content on the Learn platform. Effective use of this tool will provide you with
opportunities to discuss, debate, and consolidate your understanding of the content
presented in this module.
• You are expected to work through the learning units on Learn in your own time –
especially before class. Any contact sessions will therefore be used to raise and address
any questions or interesting points with your lecturer, and not to cover every aspect of
this module.
• Your lecturer will communicate submission dates for specific activities in class and/or
on Learn.
Icon Description
A list of what you should be able to do after working through the learning unit.
Sections where you get to grapple with the content/ theory. This is mainly
presented in the form of questions which focus your attention and are aimed at
helping you to understand the content better. You will be presented with online
resources to work through (in addition to the textbook or manual references) and
find some of the answers to the questions posed.
REMEMBER:
Module Resources
Prescribed Material (PM) SAICA Student Handbook 2023/2024 Volume 2, SAICA. Lexis
for this Module Nexis, Durban. (PM1)
9781776177530
and
and
Module Purpose
The purpose of this module is for students to gain an in-depth understanding of the audit
process together with relevant risk management principles, governance, and legislation to
complete an audit and form an audit opinion.
Module Outcomes
Apply the principles of pre-engagement activities, planning, gathering, and
MO1
evaluating audit evidence and reporting in a given scenario.
MO2 Formulate tests of controls and substantive procedures manually and digitally.
Assess the work of others in accordance with the requirements of the International
MO3
Standards on Auditing.
MO4 Evaluate and report on internal control risks in the business cycle.
Assess the results of audit evidence and the impact of unresolved uncorrected
MO7
misstatements and formulate an appropriate audit opinion and audit report.
Apply the principles of relevant legislation, including the Companies Act and the
MO8
King IV code of corporate governance to a given scenario.
Assessments
Integrated Curriculum Engagement (ICE)
Minimum number of ICE activities to complete 4 compulsory, 2 optional (out of 4)
Weighting towards the final module mark 10%
Summative Examination
Weighting 50%
Duration 3 hours
Total marks 120
Open/Closed book Limited open book
Resources required None
Learning Units covered All
Textbook instructions
1. Students are permitted to bring only ONE printed version of the textbooks
2. Only properly bound standard publishers’ editions are permissible. Photocopies, printed
copies of electronic versions, loose sections or isolated pages of texts are prohibited.
3. Students are permitted to highlight, underline, sideline and flag in the permitted texts.
Writing in the permitted texts is prohibited. Writing on flags is permitted for reference and
cross-referencing purposes only (name or number of the standard, statement or section).
4. Any contravention of these regulations will be dealt with as misconduct and shall be dealt
with in terms of the appropriate misconduct policy.
Examination
The examination will assess • Consult your examination brief for this module, which will
all learning units in this be made available prior to your examination. Make sure
module. that you practise answering the sample questions in the
brief so that you become familiar with the kinds of
The assessments will be questions likely to appear in the examination itself.
written with a combination • Ensure that you work through all the activities, exercises
of theory and application of and revision questions on Learn and in your textbook. You
theory to a given scenario. must have completed close readings of your prescribed
material to ensure that you have prepared adequately for
You will be given a number your examination for this module.
of scenarios and will need to • Pay close attention to the instruction words (like list, apply,
answer a selection of pure describe, analyse, etc.) and to the mark allocations of each
theory questions and be question to ensure that you provide the correct depth and
able to demonstrate your detail in your answers.
understanding of theory • Make sure that you are comfortable in responding to all the
through application of it to objectives for all learning units.
the given scenarios. • Brainstorm possible questions based on the learning
outcomes and objectives provided.
• To prepare effectively for auditing assessments, you need
to understand the theory that has been taught and be able
to apply it to different scenarios. The best way to master
this is to do as many questions as possible under exam
conditions. Once you have completed a question, you need
to mark the question and identify where you went wrong
and where you have gaps in your knowledge. Once these
gaps are identified, you need to revise that work and do
more questions on that section.
Module Pacer
Code Programme Contact Sessions Credits
AUDI7319 BAA2 96 30
Learning Unit 1 Planning an audit
Overview:
You are able to conduct preliminary engagement activities when deciding whether to accept
an engagement or not. The next step in the audit process is to plan the audit.
In this learning unit you will learn how to describe the different steps involved in planning an
audit, describe the audit risks at the overall financial statement and assertion level, describe
the aspects to be considered when developing the overall audit strategy and audit plan and
finally calculate materiality.
Therefore, at the end of this learning unit you will be competent in understanding and
answering any question relating to planning an audit of financial statements.
Please work through Themes 1, 2, 3 and 4 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of
your prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives
for this learning unit, please also ensure that you complete the following activities on Learn:
Activity Estimated
Time on Task
1.1.1 Basics on planning an audit of financial statements 90 minutes
1.2.1 Identifying and assessing risks of material misstatement 90 minutes
1.3.1 Audit Strategy and Audit Plan 90 minutes
1.4.1 Calculating materiality 90 minutes
Estimated total time for this learning unit’s activities 6 hours
The challenges you may experience in this learning unit are describing the risks at the assertion
level and describing the aspects that will affect the audit strategy and audit plan. It is always
important when studying auditing to breakdown every concept into its simplest form and
relate back to real life business scenarios.
Learning Unit 2 Our responsibility relating to fraud and internal control deficiencies
in an audit of financial statements
Overview:
What you have learnt so far in your auditing studies is that auditors give reasonable assurance
on the financial statements of their clients. You have also learnt that the responsibility to
prevent and detect fraud ultimately lies with those charged with governance at your clients.
However, this does not mean that the auditor has no responsibilities relating to fraud.
After this learning unit you will be able to identify the auditor and management’s responsibility
with respect to fraud and compliance with laws and regulations. You will also be able to
formulate audit procedures to obtain appropriate evidence in response to the assessed fraud
risk and when non-compliance is identified or suspected at your client. Finally, you will learn
how to identify the matters that need to be communicated to those charged with governance.
Please work through Themes 1, 2 and 3 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
The challenges you may experience in this learning unit are formulating audit procedures to
obtain appropriate evidence in response to the assessed fraud risk and when non-compliance
is identified or suspected at your client. You always need to remember that the point of these
procedures is to obtain evidence as to whether there is in fact fraud or non-compliance – put
your CSI hats on.
Overview:
If you consider what you have learnt about the audit process so far, you will see that you have
now mastered the pre-engagement activities and planning an audit. Therefore, in this learning
unit, the next step in the audit process is to obtain audit evidence, you will learn how auditors
obtain audit evidence through performing audit procedures, namely test of controls or
substantive procedures.
However, before you master the skills of obtaining audit evidence, you will learn how to
describe the objectives of auditors when obtaining audit evidence, discuss the considerations
when using the work of an expert, understand the importance of opening balances and
formulate audit procedures to test the opening balances and apply all the concepts of sampling
when obtaining audit evidence.
Please work through Themes 1-2 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
The challenges you may face in this learning unit would be describing the auditor’s
requirements when auditing opening balances. Ensure you understand the principle of the
topic and the different procedures that can be performed.
Overview:
As has been discussed in multiple learning units to date, auditors follow a risk-based audit
which means that auditors identify risks of material misstatement, they then assess them at
the overall and assertion level. These two steps are primarily during the planning phase of an
audit. The final step in a risk-based audit is to respond to the risks identified. An auditor
responds to the risks of material misstatement by obtaining sufficient and appropriate audit
evidence to determine if there are in fact material misstatements. Audit evidence is obtained
by performing audit procedures. Audit procedures can be split into three broad categories:
risk assessment procedures, test of controls or substantive procedures.
In learning unit 4 you will learn how to apply general and application controls in a
computerised environment. You will then move onto formulating test of controls in a manual
and automated environment for four of the business cycles covered in AUDI6211, namely;
revenue and receipts, acquisition and payments, inventory and production and finally the
payroll and personnel cycle.
Please work through Themes 1-2 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
The challenge you may face with this learning unit is formulating test of controls in an
automated environment. It is important that you always think about the control being in a real
life scenario and think logically how you would be able to test it.
Learning Unit 5 The Companies Act and The King Code on Corporate Governance
Overview:
In AUDI6211 you learnt about the Auditing Profession Act and the Code of Professional
Conduct. There are two more pieces of legislation that you need to know in order to run an
effective audit; The Companies Act and the King IV report on Governance.
In this learning unit you will learn how to apply the principles of the Companies Act and King
IV report on Governance to various scenarios.
Please work through Themes 1-2 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
Students generally struggle with identifying the ‘concerns’ relating to the Companies Act and
King IV report on Governance in a given scenario. The only way this can be resolved is by doing
as many practice questions as possible. Practice makes perfect!
Overview:
In AUDI7311 you learnt how to plan an audit of financial statements and you started learning
how to obtain audit evidence through test of controls. We will continue in AUDI7319 with
obtaining audit evidence through substantive procedures all the while remembering our
ultimate destiny, issuing an opinion on the fair presentation of the financial statements of our
clients.
In this learning unit you will gain an understanding of the principles of substantive procedures
and the difference between test of details and analytical procedures along with the purposes
of these tests. You will be able to apply your knowledge of the business cycles learnt in
AUDI6211 and AUDI7319 to formulating substantive audit procedures in a manual and
automated environment, to address the risks identified when planning an audit.
Please work through Themes 1 and 2 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please also ensure that you complete the following activities on Learn:
Activity Estimated
Time on Task
6.1.1 Introduction to substantive audit procedures 120 minutes
6.1.2 Analytical procedures 120 minutes
6.2.1 Auditing Inventory using CAATs 120 minutes
6.2.2 Substantive procedures for Accounts Receivable 120 minutes
6.2.3 Substantive procedures for Inventory 60 minutes
6.2.4 Substantive procedures for Payroll 90 minutes
Estimated total time for this learning unit’s activities 10.5 hours
The challenge you may experience in this learning unit is being able to put down on paper the
substantive procedure you believe should be executed to address the identified risks. The key
is to always plan your question properly before writing your answer as well as always referring
back to the assertions.
Overview:
This is the final stage in the audit process. Once the auditor has obtained sufficient and
appropriate audit evidence through performing test of controls and substantive procedures,
the auditor finally needs to evaluate all this evidence and conclude on the audit by issuing the
audit report.
In this learning unit you will learn how to apply the requirements of auditing related party
transactions, subsequent events and going concern to given scenarios in order to evaluate the
audit evidence obtained. You will also learn how to evaluate misstatements identified and
accumulated during the audit. Finally, you will learn how to formulate an audit report.
Please work through Themes 1 and 2 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
The challenges you may face in this learning unit would be formulating audit procedures for
the evaluation of related party transactions, subsequent events and the going concern
consideration. The key to success here is to refresh your knowledge on learning unit one and
the accounting standards on these sections.
Overview:
In the journey of learning how to conduct an audit of financial statements, we also need to
consider the fact that there may be others, outside the audit team, that could be involved in
the audit. It is important that you understand their purpose and the considerations needed to
be made before we use the work of someone outside of our audit team.
In this learning unit you will learn the procedures and requirements necessary to be executed
when auditing a group company, using internal auditors and using an auditor’s expert.
Please work through Themes 1, 2 and 3 on Learn, together with the relevant sections of your
prescribed source/s. To ensure that you are working towards mastering the objectives for this
learning unit, please complete the following activities on Learn:
The challenges you may experience in this learning unit are formulating the audit procedures
necessary to be conducted before contracting someone outside the audit team as well as
formulating the procedures to be conducted to evaluate their work once done. This challenge
can be overcome by using your ISA standards smartly and always following the same approach
when answering these questions.