Case Study

Module Name:

Student Number:

Word Count:

Submission Deadline:

1
Table of Contents
Introduction......................................................................................................................................3

Task 1...............................................................................................................................................4

Quality management approaches of Toyota................................................................................4

Comparison of the quality management approaches...................................................................6

Task 2...............................................................................................................................................7

a) Different approaches to measuring project success.................................................................7

b) Effective project management principles with examples............................................................9

Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................10

References......................................................................................................................................11

2
Introduction
Toyota, an automobile-producing company, is successful worldwide because of its quality and
innovations. Toyota has been a market leader for many years due to the company's long and
storied heritage. The Toyota Production System (TPS) and the company's commitment to
constant development are prime examples of the company's dedication to maximizing its
potential (Liker, 2021). Through its dedication to quality assurance, employee autonomy, and
client fulfilment, Toyota has gained the loyalty of tens of millions of car buyers across the world.
In this report, Toyota’s quality management will be discussed and there will also be a
comparison of quality management between Toyota and another automobile-producing company
Volkswagen. Besides, this report will also give a simple concept of project success and a
project’s principles that lead to effective project management.

3
Task 1
Quality management approaches of Toyota
The term "quality management" means a methodical approach and a collection of actions that are
carried out to make sure a company's goods, services, and procedures satisfy or go above and
beyond the requirements of its customers (Stravinskiene and Serafinas, 2020). Over the course of
a product's or service's whole lifecycle, it includes a variety of tactics, processes, and techniques
meant to preserve and enhance the product's or service's quality. Toyota's dedication to quality
management has earned the company international recognition. Several strategies and methods
have been employed by the firm to embed quality within its core business. Toyota undertakes
some quality management approaches to describe quality issues, continuous innovation
processes and prevent unwanted defects (Liker, 2021). Here, are some quality management
approaches undertaken by Toyota:

1) Just-in-Time production (JIT): To reduce overhead and maximize efficiency, Toyota

operates under the JIT concept, which dictates that products are made on demand. In addition to
cutting down on errors, this method also makes it easier to adapt quickly to shifting customer
preferences (Vanichchinchai, 2022).

2) Kaizen: Kaizen is a Japanese term which means “Continuous Improvement”. Every member
of staff is encouraged to look for methods to enhance operations, output, and customer service.
The four steps of kaizen are problem analysis, idea generation, action and evaluation. Every
member of Toyota's staff is encouraged to offer suggestions for how the company might better
serve its customers through its Kaizen culture (Vanichchinchai, 2022). Toyota's commitment to
quality is reflected in the company's products and procedures, which are constantly improved
thanks to the input of employees at all stages.

3) Toyota Production System (TPS): TPS is a very effective quality management approach
taken by Toyota. TPS helps Toyota successfully to reduce waste, detect defects, improve
production efficiency, and increase the quality of the product. Through TPS Toyota is
continuously improving the efficiency of its employees and production.

4
4) Poka-yoke: Poka-yoke means “mistake proofing”. Through poka-yoke, Toyota reduces or
prevents mistakes in the manufacturing process. Poka-yoke refers to the practice of creating
systems where errors are eliminated or defects are minimized to an absolute minimum. Physical
tools, visible indicators, or even just tweaks to the procedure can all play a role in alerting
workers to problems and guiding them toward solutions. Poka-yoke is a preventative method of
quality management that enhances the consistency and durability of goods by spotting flaws
before they reach consumers (Wen et al.,2022).

5) Jidoka: It means “autonomation” It is another quality control approach used by Toyota. It's
based on the idea that if workers are given the right to halt the manufacturing line if an error is
discovered, then quality will be built throughout the process from the beginning (Amasaka,
2002). As a result of using jidoka, quality is increased and client satisfaction is enhanced by
fewer faulty products making it throughout the manufacturing process.

6) Genchi Genbutsu: The meaning of Genchi Genbutsu is “go and see for yourself”. It
highlights the value of going out into the field or onto the factory floor to see things for oneself
(Wen et al.,2022). Employees are encouraged to take an active role in observing and interacting
with processes, goods, and customers to spot potential problems and make educated decisions
based on hard evidence.

These are the same approaches Toyota uses in its business which increase the quality of the
production and the process. These approaches help Toyota to improve the overall performance of
the production process and the employees. As a result, Toyota achieves customer satisfaction.

5
Comparison of the quality management approaches
To compare the quality management approaches of Toyota, another automobile manufacturing
company Volkswagen are chosen. Both of the companies are worldwide famous for their quality
products. Both companies develop their unique quality management approaches. The comparison
will show which organization is more effective in maintaining quality management.

The Toyota Production System (TPS) is an example of the company's approach that prioritizes
minimizing waste while also encouraging constant innovation and giving workers a voice in the
workplace (Soviar et al.,2018). Toyota uses Jidoka and Poka-yoke to embed quality into every
step of the manufacturing process. The organization promotes a Kaizen culture in which all
employees are expected to participate in and support continuous quality improvement. Toyota
places a premium on ensuring its customers are happy, and as a result, its automobiles are
consistently reliable and long-lasting.

On the other hand, some o of the approaches undertaken by Volkswagen are quality assurance
systems, supplier quality management, lean manufacturing, customer feedback and quality
metrics etc The production procedures are closely monitored and controlled by the organization
to guarantee uniformity and dependability. Volkswagen places a premium on customer opinion
and uses several indicators to track and improve product quality (Jung and Sharon, 2019).
Volkswagen is committed to providing its customers with high-quality automobiles by strictly
following all applicable quality standards and government requirements.

While their approaches to quality management are distinct, both Toyota and Volkswagen have
found success with their strategies. The Toyota Production System (TPS) is largely responsible
for the company's excellent reputation in the auto industry, whereas Volkswagen's emphasis on
quality assurance systems and supplier management contributes to the company's ability to
consistently produce high-quality products throughout its supply chain.

6
In the case of effectiveness, Toyota is more effective in maintaining quality management.
Because Toyota is more committed to its quality management and successfully achieved more
customer satisfaction (Soviar et al.,2018).. Besides, the company is continuously improving its
activities in all sectors.

Task 2
a) Different approaches to measuring project success
Measuring project success is essential in project management because it provides insight into the
results and effects of initiatives. Projects vary greatly, and so do the criteria by which they can be
judged successful. Some of the approaches to measure project success are given below:

1) Quality and performance metrics

The focus of this approach is on evaluating project success about established norms. Product
quality, customer satisfaction, effectiveness, and productivity are all indicators by which a
business's success can be measured (Irfan et al.,2023). Project success can be measured in a
variety of ways, including through the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) and metrics
focused on things like process enhancement, defects, feedback from consumers, or operations
effectiveness.

2) Return on Investment

The Return on Investment method is used to calculate the worth or benefits of the business.
Examining the return on investment (ROI) of a project entails weighing the project's net savings
or benefits against the initial cost (Kristiansen and Ritala, 2018). Financial indicators like NPV,
ROI, and payback period are used to evaluate results. This strategy should be used for projects
that have monetary goals as their top priority or have significant effects on the economy.

7
3) Long-term sustainability

This method is more holistic because it considers the project's effects and viability across time.
The success of a project can be gauged by how well it achieves its stated goals and how
significantly it improves the world around it or the organization as a whole (Gunduz and Yahya,
2018). Indicators like social and environmental sustainability as well as economic viability can
be utilized to measure the success of a project in this setting.

4) Stakeholders’ satisfaction

The success of a project is measured by how happy its clients, consumers, team members, and
everyone else who has an interest in its outcome can be. To determine whether or not a project
was successful, analysts analyze how satisfied various parties were with its quality,
effectiveness, and ability to meet their needs (Kristiansen and Ritala, 2018).. It is possible to
assess stakeholder happiness through the use of surveys, individual interviews, and group
discussions.

5) Objectives achievement

This strategy places primary emphasis on determining the degree to which objectives were
successfully attained and deliverables associated with the project have been finished. It entails
determining whether or not the project has achieved the goals that were set out in the beginning.
The execution of work promptly, compliance with the allotted budget and the accomplishment of
predetermined performance standards are some of the tangible results that are used to evaluate
success (Jung and Sharon, 2019).

To accurately measure the performance of a project, one needs a thorough and clearly defined
collection of metrics that are in line with both the project goals and the organizational goals. The
continual observation, collection of feedback, and review that takes place throughout every phase
of a project all contribute to a more precise evaluation of its level of success. Organizations can
boost their project management practices, increase their likelihood of making well-informed
decisions, and continually raise the quality of their project results when they utilize proper
measurement methodologies.

8
b) Effective project management principles with examples
Several principles increase the effectiveness of a project. Here, are some effective project
management principles and the way they contribute to effective project management:

1) Clear goals and objectives: The effectiveness of a project mostly depends on clear goals and
objectives that the project is going to achieve. The main concept of this principle is that project
teams and the stakeholders have a clear understanding of what they are going to do and what the
project is going to achieve (Liu et al.,2020). For example, construction projects where time,
budgets and other activities are clear to the parties related.

2) Planning: Planning is the most important principle of a project. Proper planning should be
made to allocate resources without any mistakes, minimize risks, allocate tasks, set a time frame
and prepare a budget (Bianch et al 2021). For example: constructing a building needs detailed
planning of tasks, resources, time etc.

3) Resource allocation: Allocation of resources in proper time helps a project to be finished in

the timeframe. Resource allocation may include man, machine, and material. This principle
ensures a project is finished effectively and within the time. For example, in a construction
project, the allocation of workers, machines, bricks, cement, rods etc. properly increases the
chances of the work being finished properly.

4) Risk management: To practice effective risk management, one must first recognize the
existence of potential dangers, then evaluate the consequences of those dangers, and finally
devise ways to reduce or eliminate such dangers. Project managers can limit the possibility of
adverse impacts on the successful completion of their projects by taking preventative measures
to control project risks (Bianch et al 2021).. For example: in a construction project potential risks
may include safety-related risks. Implementing proper planning can reduce the risk.

5) Engaging and communication: Maintaining open lines of communication and involving

stakeholders early and often is essential. Maintaining open lines of communication is essential
for effectively managing expectations, resolving problems, and addressing issues. For example,
in a construction project, workers send messages to the contractor to send materials.

9
The principles effectively contribute to different elements of project success in the following
way:

1)Goal achievement: Successful projects can be judged by how well they meet their stated goals
and objectives. When a project is well-managed, all of its intended outcomes are realized.

2) Stakeholders’ satisfaction: Stakeholder satisfaction is crucial to the overall success of a

project, thus it's important to keep everyone involved informed and involved throughout the
process ( Lalmi et al 2021).

3) Budget adherence: Successful projects often have tight budgets that are maintained by
careful allocation of resources, control of potential pitfalls, and close oversight.

4) Timely delivery: Successful projects typically have timely deliveries thanks to careful
planning, allocation of resources, and monitoring.

5) Adaptability and resilience: Continuous monitoring, risk management, and adaptability help
projects successfully handle unanticipated problems and changes, all of which contribute to the
success of the project (Wen et al.,2022).

Conclusion
Businesses can’t succeed, grow, and satisfy their customers without a solid quality management
system in place. Organizations might boost customer happiness and loyalty by improving their
processes, goods, and services with the help of well-established quality management systems and
methodologies (Liu et al.,2020). Successful quality management is based on several guiding
concepts, including employee participation, customer focus, continuous improvement, and data-
driven decision-making.

10
References
Liker, J.K., 2021. Toyota Way: 14 management principles from the world's greatest manufacturer.
McGraw-Hill Education.

Stravinskiene, I. and Serafinas, D., 2020. The link between business process management and quality
management. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 13(10), p.225.

Vanichchinchai, A., 2022. The relationships between soft and hard factors of the Toyota way: a socio-
technical perspective. Operations Management Research, pp.1-12.

Wen, D., Sun, X. and Yan, D., 2022. The quality movement: where are we going? Past, present and
future. Total Quality Management & Business Excellence, 33(1-2), pp.92-112.

Amasaka, K., 2002. “New JIT”: A new management technology principle at Toyota. International Journal
of Production Economics, 80(2), pp.135-144.

Soviar, J., Holubčík, M., Vodák, J., Rechtorík, M. and Pollák, F., 2019. The Presentation of Automotive
Brands in the On-Line Environment—The Perspective of KIA, Peugeot, Toyota and VW in the Slovak
Republic. Sustainability, 11(7), p.2132.

Jung, J.C. and Sharon, E., 2019. The Volkswagen emissions scandal and its aftermath. Global business
and organizational excellence, 38(4), pp.6-15.

Irfan, M., Khalid, R.A., Kaka Khel, S.S.U.H., Maqsoom, A. and Sherani, I.K., 2023. Impact of work–life
balance with the role of organizational support and job burnout on project performance. Engineering,
Construction and Architectural Management, 30(1), pp.154-171.

Kristiansen, J.N. and Ritala, P., 2018. Measuring radical innovation project success: typical metrics don’t
work. Journal of Business Strategy, 39(4), pp.34-41.

Gunduz, M. and Yahya, A.M.A., 2018. Analysis of project success factors in construction
industry. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 24(1), pp.67-80.

Liu, B., Xue, B., Meng, J., Chen, X. and Sun, T., 2020. How project management practices lead to
infrastructure sustainable success: an empirical study based on goal-setting theory. Engineering,
Construction and Architectural Management, 27(10), pp.2797-2833.

Bianchi, M.J., Conforto, E.C., Rebentisch, E., Amaral, D.C., Rezende, S.O. and de Pádua, R., 2021.
Recommendation of project management practices: A contribution to hybrid models. IEEE transactions on
engineering management, 69(6), pp.3558-3571.

11
12
Lalmi, A., Fernandes, G. and Souad, S.B., 2021. A conceptual hybrid project management model for
construction projects. Procedia Computer Science, 181, pp.921-930.

13