You are on page 1of 10

The nutrition transition in South Korea1–3

Soowon Kim, Soojae Moon, and Barry M Popkin

ABSTRACT transition in South Korea, a country that modernized earlier than


Background: An accelerating shift from infectious to noncom- did most Asian countries while keeping its unique features.
municable diseases and concurrent shifts in diet, activity, and Although other authors have discussed aspects of the South
body composition are universal trends but are especially appar- Korean transition (2–6), this article broadly reviews the transition
ent in middle- and lower-income countries. A unique nutrition to provide a thorough understanding of the transition and insights
transition has occurred in South Korea, a country that modern- into directions other countries might follow to retain more of the
ized earlier than most Asian countries did. healthful elements of their traditional diets.
Objective: The purpose of this analysis was to describe the Unlike the gradual transition that occurred in the United States
South Korean nutrition transition, focusing on specific features and most European countries, the nutrition transition in many
that other countries might follow to retain the healthful elements lower-income countries has been rapid. Information from Asian
of their traditional diets. countries such as Japan, China, and Thailand and from South
Design: We used secondary data on economics, dietary intake, Africa and the Caribbean shows an accelerated change in the
anthropometry, and causes of death, including a series of com- structure of diet after these countries attained dietary sufficiency
parable nationally representative dietary surveys (the National at the national level (1, 2, 7). In Asia, the effect of economic fac-
Nutrition Survey). tors on the nutrition transition has been particularly apparent (1, 8).
Results: The structure of South Korea’s economy, along with the Japan experienced a rapid shift in its dietary structure during its
country’s dietary and disease patterns, began an accelerated shift accelerated economic growth from 1950 to 1970 (2). China is
in the 1970s. Major dietary changes included a large increase in experiencing an even more rapid shift in diet, especially among
the consumption of animal food products and a fall in total cereal its urban residents (9, 10). Concurrent with these transitions, obe-
intake. Uniquely, the amount and rate of increase in fat intake sity is increasing in most Asian nations (11).
have remained low in South Korea. South Korea also has a rela- South Korea experienced earlier economic change than did
tively low prevalence of obesity compared with other Asian most Asian countries. Its economy grew at an impressive rate
countries with similar or much lower incomes. during the past 3 decades, after its recovery from the Korean War
Conclusions: The nutrition transition in South Korea is unique. (1950–1953). Concurrent changes in lifestyle included the rapid
National efforts to retain elements of the traditional diet are introduction of elements of what may be termed a Western
thought to have shaped this transition in South Korea in the lifestyle. Fast-food restaurants were introduced and became pop-
midst of rapid economic growth and the introduction of Western ular, especially with the younger generation. At the same time,
culture. Am J Clin Nutr 2000;71:44–53. however, movements arose to keep elements of traditional
dietary patterns and staples. This combination of events, which
KEY WORDS Nutrition transition, South Korea, economic resulted in the unique shape of the nutrition transition in South
growth, diet, National Nutrition Survey, anthropometry, causes Korea, may provide important insights for many other countries.
of death, fat intake, obesity
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
INTRODUCTION We analyzed secondary economic, dietary intake, anthropomet-
The epidemiologic transition, particularly the rapid shift in ric, and cause-of-death data from published reports and articles.
morbidity and mortality patterns toward much higher rates of
noncommunicable diseases, is dominating the health profile of an
1
increasingly large number of persons in middle- and lower- From the Department of Nutrition, University of North Carolina at
income countries. Concurrent shifts in diet, activity, and body Chapel Hill, and the Department of Food and Nutrition, Yonsei University,
Seoul, South Korea.
composition also appear to be accelerating in many regions of the 2
Supported in part by a grant from the US National Institutes of Health
world (1). The concept of nutrition transition, a sequence of char-
(R01-HD30880).
acteristic dietary and nutritional patterns resulting from large shifts 3
Address reprint requests to BM Popkin, Carolina Population Center, Uni-
in overall dietary structure, related to changing economic, social, versity of North Carolina, University Square, CB 8120, 123 West Franklin
demographic, and health factors (2) summarizes the universal Street, Chapel Hill, NC 27516-3997. E-mail: popkin@unc.edu.
trends. The purpose of this analysis was to provide an under- Received February 26, 1999.
standing of the multidimensional phenomenon of the nutrition Accepted for publication June 29, 1999.

44 Am J Clin Nutr 2000;71:44–53. Printed in USA. © 2000 American Society for Clinical Nutrition
SOUTH KOREAN NUTRITION TRANSITION 45

Economic data has aged, which means we underemphasized trends related


Data on work force structure were obtained from South to decreased intake and overemphasized trends related to
Korea’s National Statistical Office (12). For economic trends, increased intake.
we used national income data from the official estimates of Other published papers describing nationally representative
gross national product (GNP) per capita (Atlas method) from nutritional intake in earlier periods were also included in a table
1962 to 1996 as established by the World Bank (13). GNP per and a figure examining dietary trends (17–21). To compare fat
capita was expressed in 1996 US dollars adjusted for inflation intake in South Korea with that in other Asian countries, we
on the basis of consumer price indexes (14) to allow for an eas- included comparable survey data on national household food
ier comparison across the years. Urbanization data also came consumption from China (22) and Japan (23, 24).
from the World Bank (13). Anthropometric data
Several studies in which adults’ mean height and weight were
Dietary data reported were available for analysis (25). We focused on the shift
A series of comparable nationally representative dietary sur- toward greater obesity and reported the distribution of body mass
veys was used to provide a more coherent picture of the nutrition index (BMI; in kg/m2) from the National Nutrition Survey
transition in South Korea than we can find for most countries. Report. However, information on the distribution of BMI was not
Most of the dietary intake data were obtained from the most included in the National Nutrition Survey Report until 1990.
recent published report of the National Nutrition Survey (15), Data that incorporated international standards for measuring
which has been conducted annually by the South Korean Ministry obesity were available only for 1995, when we had BMI distri-
of Health and Welfare since 1969 (16). All the surveys were con- bution data for adults aged ≥ 20 y. Therefore, we chose to pres-
ducted nationwide and included only independent persons who ent only 1995 BMI data from South Korean adults and included
were not institutionalized. Surveys were carried out during a 1-mo comparable obesity data from other Asian countries to compare
period between August and November each year. Since 1975, the prevalences of obesity. We followed the World Health Organ-
sample households representative of the nation were selected by ization cutoffs to delineate obesity [BMI of 25.0–29.99 for over-
using a multistage stratified sampling, a multistage cluster sam- weight (preobesity) and ≥ 30.0 for obesity] (26). In lieu of pub-
pling, or a sampling method with probability proportional to size, lished BMI data for children, we crudely approximated the mean
depending on the year. The number of households surveyed BMI for 8- and 17-y-olds by using average weight and height
ranged from 543 to 2000 before 1988. The sample size was kept data (27).
at 2000 households nationwide after that time. For dietary intake
data, a trained interviewer weighed everything the surveyed Cause-of-death data
household members ate at home for 2 consecutive days. Nutrient We present cause-of-death trends as percentages of total
values were calculated by using a food-composition table from deaths for 4 disease categories in which the death rates changed
the Rural Development Administration and the Rural Nutrition noticeably in South Korea during the past several decades (28,
Institute (15, 16). 29). Diseases were classified according to the Korean Standard
The National Nutrition Survey has limitations (16), as does Classification of Causes of Death (30), which was based on the
any nutritional survey. It is almost impossible to measure usual World Health Organization’s International Statistical Classifica-
diet by a weighed method in a free-living population. Even tion of Diseases, Injuries and Causes of Death (ICD). The 4 cat-
though weighing eliminates the main problems inherent in egories chosen to illustrate major shifts in disease patterns from
dietary assessment methods, such as inaccuracy of recall and infectious to chronic diseases were 1) infectious and parasitic
under- or overreporting, weighing is invasive enough to alter diseases (including tuberculosis), 2) diseases of the respiratory
people’s usual intake. Also, estimation methods are inaccurate. system (eg, pneumonia and bronchitis), 3) malignant neoplasms
Skipped meals or meals taken away from home were not (eg, cancers of the stomach, liver, bronchus, and lung), and 4)
included in the measure of total household consumption. diseases of the circulatory system (eg, rheumatic heart disease,
Because men are the major group who eat out in South Korea, hypertensive disease, ischemic heart disease, cerebrovascular
whereas children, the elderly, and women not working tend to disease, and diseases of the pulmonary circulation).
eat at home, per capita intakes do not reflect household mem-
bers’ intakes equally. Also, because all household members in
urban areas tend to have breakfast (the lightest meal of the day) RESULTS
at home, assignment of the same weight to each meal probably
caused underestimation of the intakes. Flaws in the food-com- South Korean economy
position table, including incomplete listings of newly intro- We found that remarkable changes occurred in the South
duced processed foods and specific varieties and outdated nutri- Korean economy and the structure of the work force over the
ent-analysis methods, were also weaknesses. In addition, even past 35 y. GNP per capita increased dramatically from the early
with the best household-weighed-food data, some foods are not 1960s to the mid-1990s (Figure 1), with the rate of increase
measured, especially alcohol and herbal foods that are often accelerating in the late 1980s. The GNP increased more than
used for health-related purposes. These omissions may result in 17 times between 1962 and 1996. Such rapid economic growth
underestimates of dietary intake. increased national food availability and enhanced the purchasing
The most recent report of the National Nutrition Survey (15), power of the people, which accelerated the nutrition transition.
which summarized survey data from 1969 to 1995, reported With this rapid shift in income, associated changes in the
dietary intake data per capita only. This limitation prevented population and occupation distributions occurred. South Korea
us from adjusting for the fact that South Korea’s population was only 27.7% urban in 1960; by 1996 this percentage was
46 KIM ET AL

FIGURE 1. Trends in gross national product (GNP) and the distribution of occupations, South Korea, 1962–1996 (12, 13).

82.3%. A shift from energy-intensive occupations in the rural percentage of plant-food intake decreased consistently, from
primary-product sectors of agriculture, forestry, and fisheries to 97% in 1969 to 79% in 1995. In contrast, the percentage of ani-
occupations in services and manufacturing came with the mal food intake increased 7 times during that period.
growth in South Korea’s GNP (Figure 1). The current occupa- This shift can be clearly seen by examining the intake trends
tional structure of South Korea is similar to that of most West- for each food group. Consumption of cereals and grain products,
ern countries. As we noted elsewhere, this transition is linked to the major contributors to food intake of South Koreans, decreased
a major reduction in energy expenditure at work (1, 11). significantly. In 1969, per capita intake of cereals accounted for
53% of total grams of food intake. In contrast, cereals accounted
Diet for only 28% of total intake in 1995. However, rice consumption
The dietary transition in South Korea was accelerated by the did not change much throughout the survey period. Legume
importation of wheat from the United States to make up for food intake increased until the mid-1980s but decreased thereafter. The
shortages that emerged after 1969 (3). Many processed foods intake of potatoes and other starchy tubers decreased. Vegetable
made from wheat flour, such as breads and noodles (including intake fluctuated over the whole period, but overall consumption
ramen noodles), entered the food supply. The government changed little. An important shift occurred toward the consump-
encouraged the consumption of these foods and other grains. tion of more processed vegetables than fresh ones. This trend
Exposure to the new foods altered people’s preferences. The resulted from the shifts that occurred both in lifestyles and in the
government also helped to promote farming in the 1960s. In the agribusiness sector. Increased residence in urban areas and a
early 1970s, a new, improved variety of rice was successfully rapid increase in the number of apartments reduced home gar-
developed to increase rice production. In 1979, fast-food restau- dening remarkably. The increased percentage of women in the
rants first appeared (31). In the 1980s, new technologies were labor force (17.8% in 1961, 31.9% in 1980, and 40.6% in 1997)
introduced widely from advanced countries and there was a (32) reduced the time available to women to prepare food. Fruit
noticeable expansion in the food-processing industry. More intake increased gradually until the late 1980s but more rapidly
recently, the removal of trade restrictions related to the Uruguay after 1990. Seaweed consumption increased gradually.
Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (1994) Intake of all animal food products increased significantly
was important in opening up restrictions on the importation of over the past 35 y. Meat and poultry consumption increased
meat. This series of changes in the food supply, brought about by 10-fold between 1969 and 1995. The rate of increase was high-
industrial development and policy changes, is thought to be a est starting in the early 1980s. Consumption of milk and dairy
direct cause of the shift in food intake in South Korea. The fol- products increased even more rapidly: 4.3-fold during the 5-y
lowing 2 sections of this article describe trends in dietary intake period between 1980 and 1985. This increase was attributed to
in terms of food groups and nutrients. an increase in the importation of milk cows and the growth of
the animal-feed industry. Consumption of fish and shellfish,
Food groups particularly processed items, also increased rapidly during this
The total amount of food intake per capita per day, calculated period. However, the rates of increase for fish and shellfish
from household food intake, fluctuated around 1000 g between were lower than those for meat, poultry, and milk. In 1995,
1969 and 1995 (Table 1). The fluctuation seems random, even intake of fish, meat, and milk products was balanced, each
though the trend since the late 1980s was a gradual increase in accounting for approximately one third of animal food products
total food intake. A shift did occur in the sources of food; food consumed. Although the rate of increase in fish and shellfish
intake from animal sources increased. This shift became espe- consumption was not as high as that of meat, poultry, or milk
cially apparent after the 1970s. In terms of grams of food, the consumption, fish and shellfish were still the most significant
SOUTH KOREAN NUTRITION TRANSITION 47

TABLE 1
Changes in intake by food groups1
1969 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995
Plant foods (g · capita21 · d21)
Cereals and grain products 558.8 516.8 473.8 495.3 383.7 344.0 308.9
Legumes and their products 24.9 53.1 31.1 46.9 74.2 58.1 34.7
Potatoes and starches 75.6 49.8 54.6 35.8 39.8 43.1 21.2
Vegetables
Fresh 190.6 143.9 164.0 165.8 147.9 142.0 —2
Processed 80.4 151.1 81.7 135.3 125.0 139.0 —2
Fresh and processed 271.0 295.0 245.7 301.1 272.9 281.0 286.2
Fruit 48.1 18.9 22.4 41.3 64.1 68.8 146.0
Seaweeds 0.8 2.4 1.9 1.5 3.2 6.0 6.6
Seasonings, beverages 41.0 16.9 17.7 36.6 21.7 34.7 47.6
Vegetable oils and fats 3.5 —3 3.1 4.4 6.9 5.6 7.5
Others —3 0 0.1 0 0 9.4 11.9
Total 1023.7 952.9 850.4 962.9 866.6 850.7 870.6
Animal foods (g · capita21 · d21)
Meat, poultry, and their products 6.6 19.8 14.3 13.6 38.9 47.3 67.0
Eggs 4.2 8.8 5.1 8.3 20.6 19.5 21.8
Fish and shellfish
Fresh 12.1 32.0 38.8 57.3 52.5 51.9 —2
Processed 6.1 12.5 9.0 8.4 28.1 26.7 —2
Fresh and processed 18.2 44.5 47.8 65.7 80.6 78.6 75.1
Milk and dairy products 2.4 4.9 4.7 9.9 42.8 52.2 65.6
Animal oils and fats 0.3 —3 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.4 0.1
Others 0.3 4.2 0 0 0 0 —3
Total 32.0 82.2 72.0 97.6 183.0 198.0 229.6
Total (g · capita21 · d21) 1055.7 1035.1 922.4 1060.5 1049.6 1048.7 1100.2
Percentage of animal food (%) 3.0 7.9 7.8 9.2 17.4 18.9 20.9
1
From reference 15.
2
Data no longer provided.
3
Data not available.

source of animal food products for South Koreans. Egg intake portion of energy derived from each nutrient shows the shift in
increased until 1985 but stayed almost steady after that. During nutrient intake (Figure 3). Carbohydrate intake decreased grad-
the transition, mass production of animal feed led to an expan- ually after 1940 from 81% of total energy intake to 64% in 1995.
sion of the poultry industry and a subsequent reduction in egg Total protein intake was relatively constant throughout the
prices. Lower egg prices enhanced the role of eggs as a source period (Table 2). The source of the intake, however, changed
of higher-quality protein in the 1980s. Consumption of added significantly. In the past, Koreans obtained protein mainly from
fats and oils doubled between 1969 and 1995. As with the rest rice, with frequent consumption of soy products enhancing the
of Asia, this increase was predominantly from vegetable oil overall quality of the protein source. Now, animal sources con-
consumption, but the increase was very small relative to that of tribute substantially to protein intakes. Less than 10% of protein
other Asian countries (8). intake per capita per day came from animal sources in 1948. In
Intake trends for major food groups between 1969 and 1995 1995, almost 50% came from animal sources. These increases
are shown in Figure 2. The figure illustrates the dramatic fall in parallel the substantial increases in meat, poultry, fish, and dairy-
total cereal intake with the significant rise in total animal food food consumption during this period as described in the previous
product intake. The transition coincided with the rapid increase section. Protein-derived energy increased slightly until 1989 and
in GNP in the early 1980s (see Figure 1). has remained relatively constant since then.
Fat-derived energy intake increased gradually throughout the
Nutrients whole period, from 6.2% to 18.8%. However, this was still lower
Nutrient-intake data can be used to capture the South Korean than the fat-derived energy intake of many other Asian countries
nutrition transition. Total energy intake decreased gradually after and even lower than that of most of the Western countries (8).
1940, when nutrient data were first available from a published Trends in total dietary fat intake in China, Japan, and South
journal article (17) (Table 2). Total energy intake was as high as Korea from comparable national household-food-consumption
10.2 MJ (2446 kcal) per capita per day in 1940, fluctuated surveys are shown in Figure 4. Fat intake in South Korea is even
between 8 and 9 MJ until the beginning of the 1980s, fell below lower than that in China, which had a GNP < 1/14th of South
8 MJ in the mid-1980s, and continued to decrease thereafter, as Korea’s in 1996 (13). China obtained > 20% of energy from fat
was expected with the rapid industrialization and mechanization starting in the 1990s. In 1995, South Korea still consumed < 20%
that was occurring in the country. of energy from fat.
In terms of individual nutrients, carbohydrates showed the The change in the ratio of energy from carbohydrate to pro-
same pattern as did total energy intake. The change in the pro- tein to fat gives a broad picture of the transition. The ratio was
48 KIM ET AL

FIGURE 2. Trends in daily intake per capita by food group in South Korea (15). Values are presented as a 3-y moving average between 1969 and 1995.

81:13:6 in 1940, indicating that energy intake was mainly from available, it was impossible to describe trends in the distribution
carbohydrate and that fat did not contribute much. After 55 y, of overweight. Instead, comparable adult overweight and obesity
the ratio shifted to 64:16:19, closer to what nutritionists would data for China, Japan, and other Southeast Asian countries are
term an ideal ratio (33). Carbohydrate still contributed a great shown in Figure 5. The data were from the most recent large sur-
proportion of energy but to a much lesser extent. In 1992, the veys that were representative of a region or country. The preva-
proportion of energy from fat began to exceed that from protein, lence of overweight in South Korea was lower than that in many
but the difference was very small (3% in 1995). As will be dis- other Asian countries relative to South Korea’s level of income
cussed, the proportion of energy consumed from fat in South and development. The prevalence of obesity was much lower for
Korea was much lower than that in Asian countries with similar South Koreans than for all other groups except Chinese females.
or lower income levels. The prevalences in South Korea were even lower than earlier
prevalences in countries in which the national income remains
Anthropometric data lower than that of South Korea. Obesity rates are increasing
As one might expect, mean weight and height trends among rapidly in these countries and more recent data would show even
South Korean adults showed an improvement between 1913 and higher prevalences than those presented here. For example, a
1994 (25). Although there is some value in examining changes in recent report on Thailand showed that the prevalence of over-
mean weight and height, the distribution of these changes and the weight and obesity (combined) in adults was 26.1% in 1995 (36),
increases in obesity and reductions in chronic energy deficiency significantly higher than the prevalence in 1991.
are more important. The prevalence of adult obesity in South What appears to be a relatively recent increase in overweight
Korea was very low in 1995 (0.8% for men and 2.2% for women) in South Korean adults was echoed by higher BMIs in younger
(Figure 5). The prevalence of overweight in 1995 was close to children (Figure 6). Again, it is important to note that BMI data
20% for both men and women. Because earlier data were not for children were calculated by using average weight divided by

TABLE 2
Changes in macronutrient and energy intakes1
1940 1948 1950 1960 1969 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995
Carbohydrate (g) 494 484.4 486 482 422.5 434 398.5 396.1 341.5 316 295
Fat (g) 16.8 18.2 15.5 17.1 16.9 17.2 19 21.8 29.5 28.9 38.5
Protein (g) 79.7 83.6 83 73.9 65.6 64.6 63.6 67.2 74.5 78.9 73.3
Percentage of intake —2 8.9 —2 —2 10.4 14.7 20.6 28.7 41.7 39.8 47.3
from animal foods (%)
Energy
(MJ) 10.2 10.2 10.1 9.9 8.8 9.0 8.3 8.6 8.1 7.8 7.7
(kcal) 2446 2438 2416 2378 2105 2150 1992 2052 1936 1868 1839
1
From references 15, 18, and 21.
2
Data not available.
SOUTH KOREAN NUTRITION TRANSITION 49

FIGURE 3. Trends in total energy intake and sources of energy in South Korea (15). Values are presented as a 3-y moving average between 1969
and 1995. 1 kcal = 4.184 kJ.

average height squared, not the mean of the BMIs. Although a causes of death. Data from 1938 to 1942 indicate that food inse-
slight increase occurred in 17-y-olds between 1956 and 1993, the curity and malnutrition were major concerns (Figure 7). Infec-
greater increase in the 1990s for younger children portends tious and parasitic diseases predominated. It was only in the early
future increases in all age groups. Ideally, we would look at how 1970s that this pattern reversed and cancer and cardiovascular-
the proportion of overweight children has increased; however, related deaths became predominant. Since 1970, except in the
such data were unavailable for a systematic comparison. case of signs, symptoms, and uncertain conditions, diseases of the
circulatory system have been the leading causes of death. Death
Causes of death from these diseases began to accelerate especially rapidly around
The nutritional focus of South Korea shifted from dietary 1965. In the late 1970s, cancer became another significant cause
deficit and food insecurity to overconsumption; therefore, one of death. Since then, cancer deaths have been accelerating even
would expect to see concurrent and possibly related shifts in the faster. The disease classification system presented here does not

FIGURE 4. Trends in percentage of energy from fat (per capita per day) in China (22), Japan (23, 24), and South Korea (15, 17, 20).
50 KIM ET AL

FIGURE 5. Obesity patterns in adults in Asian countries as measured by BMI (in kg/m2): South Korea (14), China (11, 34), Japan (35), Thailand
(36), others (11).

distinguish individual diseases. For example, diseases of the cir- Demographic changes cannot be overlooked. The dramati-
culatory system included rheumatic heart disease, hypertensive cally increasing life span (from 22.6 and 24.4 y in 1910 to
disease, ischemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, and 69.5 and 77.4 y in 1995 for males and females, respectively) (37)
other diseases of the pulmonary system. When the diseases were and the subsequent increase in the relative size of the elderly
classified individually, malignancy became the leading cause of population may have made the increasing trend in chronic dis-
death in 1993, surpassing cerebrovascular disease for the first eases apparent. The elderly population (aged ≥ 65 y) rose from
time (3). 3.3% in 1960 to 5.8% in 1996 (13).

FIGURE 6. BMI trends among 8- and 17-y-olds, South Korea, 1956–1993 (27). BMI figures were derived from mean heights and weights.
SOUTH KOREAN NUTRITION TRANSITION 51

FIGURE 7. Trends in causes of death in South Korea, 1938–1993 (28, 29).

DISCUSSION drate intake of South Koreans. Typically, increases in the GNP


South Korea is far along in its nutrition transition. Related to are associated with rapid declines in the proportion of energy
remarkable economic and sociodemographic changes, large shifts from carbohydrates (8). South Korea is an exception, possibly
in the overall structure of diet and disease patterns became appar- because rice has been, and still is, the primary element of the
Korean diet (40). The fact that the traditional Korean greeting
ent in the 1970s. The change has been reflected in increased body
“Have you eaten rice yet?” is roughly equivalent to the English
size, especially among younger children, and in dramatic shifts in “How are you?” (6) shows the deep psychologic connection to
causes of death from communicable to chronic diseases. rice. The predominance of rice as a staple food may have helped
The most noticeable feature of the South Korean nutrition keep fat intake relatively low.
transition is that the dietary shift was not linked with an The lack of effect of increases in GNP on fat intake in South
increase of fat intake commensurate with the country’s Korea is explained partly by the style of cooking. With tradi-
increase in income. The relation between GNP per capita and tional Korean cooking, small amounts of sesame-seed oil are
dietary fat intake was studied in 88 countries (8) and recently added to vegetables after they have been boiled or steamed,
updated to include 121 countries (38). On the basis of these unlike with Chinese cooking, in which foods are frequently stir-
studies, we expected that in 1996 the percentage of energy fried. Stir-frying has a high potential to add oil when oil is read-
from fat in South Korea would be 35.5%; the actual percent- ily available. Interestingly, however, other Asian countries that
age of energy from fat was 18.8%, 16.7 percentage points less do not rely on stir-frying have also rapidly increased their fat
than the expected level. When we calculated what the GNP intake (10). South Korea is different.
should be on the basis of the fat intake in 1996, we got $311; A more plausible explanation is that movements to retain the tra-
actual GNP was $10,610. If we focused on South Korea’s ditional diet have been strong in South Korea. These movements
food-disappearance data, on which this relation was based for include mass media campaigns, such as television programs that
both studies, we would have found that the predicted fat intake promote local foods by emphasizing their higher quality and the
as a percentge of energy was 13.5 percentage points more in need to support local farmers (eg, Korean Broadcasting System
1996 than the actual food balance data (22%) (39). Consider- First station’s daily program Six O’clock My Village introduces
ing the current concerns about the worldwide increase in fat famous products of South Korean villages and promotes consump-
intake (8) and diet-related diseases, the low fat intake in South tion of traditional dishes). South Korea also promoted the concept
Korea is noteworthy. South Korea’s low fat intake may be part of “Sin-To-Bul-Yi” (translated directly as “A body and a land are
of the reason for the lower prevalence of obesity in South not 2 different things,” meaning that a person should eat foods pro-
Korea than in many other Asian countries (8, 11). The follow- duced in the land in which he or she was born and is living).
ing discussion focuses on unique aspects of the nutrition tran- Part of this effort is reflected in a unique training program
sition in South Korea that are related to its unexpectedly low offered by South Korea’s Rural Development Administration.
fat intake and obesity level. Beginning in the 1980s, the Home Management Division of the
Rural Living Science Institute trained thousands of extension
Why is fat intake so low in South Korea? workers to provide monthly training sessions on cooking meth-
There are several possible explanations for the low fat intake ods of traditional Korean foods such as rice, kimchi (pickled and
in South Korea. One may relate to the relatively high carbohy- fermented Chinese cabbage), and fermented soybean foods.
52 KIM ET AL

These sessions are open to the public in most districts of the We thank Kyungmi Ahn, Youn-Wook Lee, and Keum Bong Han of South
country and the program appears to reach a large audience (41). Korea for their help in gathering information and Kumju Chung and Young-
Studies confirm South Korea’s adherence to traditional suk Hwangbo of the Rural Living Science Institute for sharing some of the
programs offered by the institute.
dietary patterns. A small study revealed that most adults—even
young adults—consume a traditional breakfast (42), which typi-
cally comprises steamed rice, soup, kimchi, cooked or uncooked REFERENCES
vegetables, and roasted or broiled meat or fish. In addition, there 1. Popkin BM. The nutrition transition and its health implications in
is stong support for the development of Korean-style fast foods, lower-income countries. Public Health Nutr 1998;1:5–21.
ie, traditional foods modified to be faster and more convenient to 2. Popkin BM. Nutritional patterns and transitions. Popul Dev Rev
1993;19:138–57.
serve (43). The dietary shifts in South Korea, such as increased
3. Moon SJ. (Nutrition problems of Koreans.) Korean J Nutr 1996;
animal food intake, are not necessarily westernization (6). For 29:371–80 (in Korean).
example, Koreans especially like traditionally prepared meat 4. Tchai BS, Ju JS. The trend of the nutritional status of the Korean,
dishes. Traditional foods continue to represent a major compo- 1969–1984. World Rev Nutr Diet 1987;51:45–73.
nent of today’s Korean diet. 5. Kim SH, Yoon KA, Kim WK, Park OJ. Urban nutritional problems
The household data contained potential measurement errors of Korea. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1992;23(suppl):
that might have led to underestimates of fat intake. The survey 69–76.
excluded the increasing number of meals eaten away from 6. Kim SH, Oh SY. Cultural and nutritional aspects of traditional
home, which potentially contain more meats and edible oils. Korean diet. World Rev Nutr Diet 1996;79:109–32.
7. Monteiro CA, Mondini L, de Souza ALM, Popkin BM. The nutri-
The higher fat intake from these meals may have been ignored.
tion transition in Brazil. Eur J Clin Nutr 1995;49:105–13.
The difference between the survey data and the food balance 8. Drewnowski A, Popkin BM. The nutrition transition: new trends in
sheet may be related to the secular trend toward consumption the global diet. Nutr Rev 1997;55:31–43.
away from home. Nevertheless, the food- balance data for South 9. Popkin BM, Keyou G, Zhai F, Guo X, Ma Ha, Zohoori N. The nutri-
Korea also showed much lower fat consumption than expected. tion transition in China: a cross-sectional analysis. Eur J Clin Nutr
Failure to adjust for changes in the age composition of the pop- 1993;47:333–46.
ulation may have affected estimates of dietary intake, but it is 10. Popkin BM. The nutrition transition in low-income countries: an
unlikely that this would have affected the estimate of the pro- emerging crisis. Nutr Rev 1994;52:285–98.
11. Popkin BM, Doak CM. The obesity epidemic is a worldwide phe-
portion of energy from fat.
nomenon. Nutr Rev 1998;56:106–14.
The unusually low fat intake in South Korea might change. 12. South Korean National Statistical Office, Economic Planning
The Uruguay Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Board. (Korean statistical yearbook.) Seoul, South Korea: National
Trade may produce further changes as South Korea is forced to Statistical Office, 1962, 1967, 1972, 1977, 1982, 1987, 1990, and
allow increased international trade in food. It is impossible to 1993 (in Korean).
predict the long-term effects of this agreement at this time. 13. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development. World
development indicators 1998. WIN*STARS (Socioeconomic Time
Obesity prevalence is lower Series Access and Retrieval System) version 4.01. Washington, DC:
World Bank, 1998 (CD-ROM).
Given South Korea’s level of economic development, the rate
14. Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Department of Labor. BLS most
of obesity is lower than we might expect compared with other requested series. Version current December 1998. World Wide Web:
Asian countries (Figure 5) and especially compared with most http://stats.bls.gov/blshome/datahome/top20.html (accessed 1 Octo-
Western countries (11). More thorough analysis of other deter- ber 1999).
minants of obesity, smoking and physical activity in particular, is 15. South Korean Ministry of Health and Welfare. (1995 national nutri-
needed to better understand obesity trends. tion survey report.) Seoul, South Korea: Ministry of Health and
Studies indicated that child obesity in South Korea was a Welfare, 1997 (in Korean).
concern (44–46). A report on the prevalence of child obesity 16. Moon HK. (The method of the Korean National Nutrition Survey.)
Korean J Nutr 1994;27:509–24 (in Korean).
from 1979 to 1996 in Seoul showed that the increase in the
17. Chai RS. (A nutritional survey in 1948.) Rep Natl Chem Lab
prevalence of obesity [≥ 95th percentile of the first National
1948;1:65 (in Korean).
Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (47)] was even 18. Ju JS. (Nutritional situation in Korea.) Korean J Nutr 1968;1:37–42
greater than that of overweight (90–95th percentile) (48). Our (in Korean).
results were consistent with the report, showing a rapid 19. Haw K, Yu JY, Lee KY, Sung NE. [A report of a nutrition survey
increase in mean BMI, especially among younger children. (1969).] Korean J Nutr 1970;3:2–43 (in Korean).
This increase may predict increases in body fatness in all age 20. Moon SJ. (An ecological analysis of dietary patterns and health sta-
groups in the near future. tus of Korean men in the later part of 19th century.) Korean J Nutr
1989;22:194–208 (in Korean).
Conclusion 21. Tchai BS. (The trends and prospects of Korean dietary intakes.)
Korean J Nutr 1990;23:187–96 (in Korean).
Identifying the characteristics that are related to maintaining 22. Chen C. Progress in overcoming hunger in China: 1989–1994. In:
South Korea’s relatively low fat intake would help us better Messer E, Uvin P, eds. The hunger report 1995. Amsterdam: Gordon
understand how to promote a healthier diet. Further research on and Breach Publishers, 1996:105–19.
the efforts of the South Korean people and government to retain 23. Yoshiike N, Matsumura Y, Iwaya M, Sugiyama M, Yamaguchi M.
features of the traditional diet should also analyze the healthful- National nutrition survey in Japan. J Epidemiol 1996;6:S189–200.
24. Japanese Health and Welfare Statistics Association. Health and wel-
ness of this diet. Additional research is needed to explore the full
fare statistics in Japan. Tokyo: Health and Welfare Statistics Associ-
set of determinants of this dietary pattern and the subsequent ation, 1997.
health consequences, not only for obesity but for a range of diet- 25. The Korean Nutrition Society. Recommended dietary allowances for
related noncommunicable diseases. Koreans. 6th ed. Seoul, South Korea: Korean Nutrition Society, 1995.
SOUTH KOREAN NUTRITION TRANSITION 53

26. International Obesity Task Force. Obesity: preventing and managing 37. Lee KY, ed. (The evaluation of the Korean diet: focusing on the 20th
the global epidemic. Report of World Health Organization consulta- century.) Seoul, South Korea: Shin-Kwang Publishing Co, 1998 (in
tion on obesity. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1998. Korean).
27. South Korean Department of Education. (Yearbook of education.) 38. Guo X, Mroz TA, Popkin BM, Zhai F. Structural changes in the
Seoul, South Korea: Department of Education, 1955–1993. impact of income on food consumption in China, 1989–93. Econ
28. Kong SK, Lim JK, Kim MK. (Report of the history of causes of Dev Cult Change (in press).
death in Korea.) Seoul, South Korea: Institute of Population and 39. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. FAO-
Public Health Studies of Korea, 1983 (in Korean). STAT statistical database 1997. Food balance sheet reports. Rome:
29. South Korean National Statistical Office, Economic Planning Food and Agriculture Oranization, 1998 (CD-ROM).
Board. (Annual report on cause of death statistics.) Seoul, South 40. Moon SJ. Rice in the Korean diet: a value system. DACO Industrial
Korea: National Statistical Office, 1994 (in Korean). Research Institute symposium on manufacturing techniques of tra-
30. South Korean National Statistical Office. The Korean standard classi- ditional food utilizing rice. Seoul, South Korea: DACO Industrial
fication of diseases and causes of death. Version current January 1999. Research Institute, 1993.
World Wide Web: http://www.nso.go.kr/diss-krlist.htm (accessed 12 41. South Korean Rural Living Science Institute, Rural Development
October 1999). Administration. (1999 education training plan.) Suwon, South
31. Mo SM. (The effects of the development of the food industry on Korea: Rural Living Science Institute, 1999 (in Korean).
dietary patterns and nutrition of Koreans.) Korean J Nutr 1986; 42. Chang NS. (Changes in dietary habits of adults with middle and
19:120–8 (in Korean). upper income levels in Seoul.) Korean J Nutr 1996;29:547–58 (in
32. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. FAO- Korean).
STAT statistical database 1997. Population annual time series. 43. Sim KH, Kim SA. (Utilization state of fast foods among Korean
Rome: FAO, 1998 (CD-ROM). youth in big cities.) Korean J Nutr 1993;26:804–11 (in Korean).
33. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Food- 44. Ahn HS, Lee IH. (The relationships between obesity index and
based dietary guidelines. Version current January 1999. World Wide major risk factors in patients with cardiovascular disease.) Korean J
Web: http://www.fao.org/es/esn/fbdg (accessed 1 October 1999). Nutr 1993;26:1071–84 (in Korean).
34. World Health Organization. Report of a WHO consultation on obe- 45. Ahn HS, Park JK, Lee DH, Paik IK, Lee JH, Lee YJ. (Clinical and
sity. Obesity: preventing and managing the global epidemic. nutritional examination in obese children and adolescents.) Korean
Geneva: World Health Organization, 1997. J Nutr 1994;27:79–89 (in Korean).
35. Japanese Ministry of Health and Welfare. Kokumin Eiyo No Gen- 46. Lee HK. (Nutritional problems of Koreans: pattern of disease inci-
jyou. (The present situation of national nutrition—results of the dence and nutrition in Korea.) Korean J Nutr 1996;29:381–3 (in
National Nutrition Survey in 1995.) Tokyo: Daiichi-shuppan Pub- Korean).
lishing Co, 1997 (in Japanese). 47. National Center for Health Statistics. Plan and operation of the
36. Supornsilaphachai C. Behavior and socio-cultural aspects of pre- National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, United States,
venting obesity and its associated problems in Thailand. Proceed- 1971–73. Vital Health Stat 1 1973;10.
ings of the WHO consultation on behavioral and socio-cultural 48. Kang YJ, Hong CH, Hong YJ. (The prevalence of childhood and
aspects of preventing obesity and associated problems. Tokyo: adolescent obesity over the past 18 years in the Seoul area.) Korean
World Health Organization, 1998. J Nutr 1997;30:832–9.

You might also like