Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Background: The surge in number of people needing palliative care services along with the deficit
in nursing knowledge in in this field are challenges to be addressed in order to ensure higher quality
end of life life care. Aim: The aim of this cross-sectional, exploratory pilot study was to assess
nurses’ knowledge in palliative care using the palliative care knowledge test (PCKT). Method:
Descriptive analysis and correlations were carried out. Findings: Nurses showed insufficient
knowledge in palliative care; 52% had a poor level (≤18 points) and 48% a fair level (19–28) of
knowledge. No participants scored more than 73% in the total PCKT score. Nurses scored poorest
in the management of dyspnoea and psychiatric problems. Conclusion: This pilot study
demonstrated that promoting continuous education in palliative care is needed to provide quality
care to terminally ill patients.
Key words: l knowledge l palliative care knowledge test l Lebanon l nurse l palliative care
T
he quality of care provided for patients managing symptoms, educating the patient and
struggling with serious health-related family members, and organising the patient’s
problems can strongly affect the quality environment to minimise loss of control, is critical
of life (QoL) of both patients and their loved ones to the delivery of high-quality palliative care
Sarah El Khatib
(Huijer et al, 2009a; World Health Organization, (Menekli et al, 2021).
Assistant Professor, 2018; Radbruch et al, 2020). According to However, multiple factors such as knowledge,
Faculty of Public Health,
Lebanese University,
the World Health Organization, palliative attitude, beliefs and experiences affect nurses’
Lebanon; Center for care (PC) is defined as an interdisciplinary effectiveness in providing palliative care services
Epidemiology and
Research in Population
caregiving approach aimed at optimising the (Doumit, 2021). It was reported that many nurses
Health (CERPOP), QoL of patients facing life-threatening illness often do not feel well-prepared, or have a lack of
Université de Toulouse,
Inserm, Université Paul
and their families, by alleviating physical, knowledge in caring for terminally ill patients;
Sabatier, France spiritual and psychosocial distress (World Health thus, needing further education in palliative care
Ansar Khoder Organization, 2018). It can be implemented (Vu et al, 2019).
Registered Nurse, Faculty at any time and at any stage of illness, whether Even though palliative care services in Lebanon
of Public Health, Lebanese
University; Al Youssef terminal or not, contrary to hospice care, which is have made some important strides in the last
Hospital Center, Lebanon a comfort care without curative intent offered to decade, significant challenges and barriers to
Dalal Moghrabi dying patients (Currow et al, 2020). Worldwide, it healthcare systems remain:
Registered Nurse, Faculty
of Public Health, Lebanese is estimated that 40 million people need palliative ● The rapidly ageing population
University; Al Youssef care each year, yet only 14% receive the services ● The high burden of non-communicable
Hospital Center, Lebanon
they need (World Health Organization, 2018). diseases (NCDs)
Mohamad Rabah Nurses play a key role in providing palliative ● Lack of knowledge and skills in palliative care
Registered Nurse, Faculty
of Public Health, Lebanese care for patients who need it (Rosa et al, 2022). among healthcare providers (Abu Sharour et al,
University; Nini Hospital, The nurse is the most valuable palliative care 2021; Doumit, 2021).
Lebanon
team member as they have the greatest contact
Samaa Al Tabbah
Clinical Pharmacist, with the patient (Schroeder and Lorenz, 2018; Aim
Faculty of Health Getie et al, 2021). This prolonged contact The aim of this pilot study was to assess the
© 2022 MA Healthcare Ltd
Sciences, American
University of Beirut; gives the nurse a unique opportunity to know level of palliative care knowledge among nurses
School of Pharmacy, the patient and properly address their wishes working at two different hospitals in North
Lebanese American
University, Lebanon and needs (Achora and Labrague, 2019). Lebanon using the PCKT score, as well as to
Correspondence to:
In addition, a nurse’s expertise in providing study the factors affecting nurses’ palliative
samaa.tab@hotmail.com physical and emotional care to the patient, care knowledge.
also calculated. In addition, factors that may Current function Registered nurse 41 85.4
affect nurses’ knowledge such as age, gender,
Head nurse 7 14.6
educational level, years of experience, current
Attended previous palliative care Yes 14 29.2
position, previous training in palliative care
educational session No 34 70.8
were measured.
International Journal of Palliative Nursing October 2022 Vol 28, No 10 475
0
This can be attributed to the existing culture
ca hy
in
ric
st ro
n
oe
tio
Pa
of sop
te st
re
al
iat
ica
in Ga
in
ch
ilo
ys
un
y
D
Ph
Ps
*p>0.05 non-significant
patient’. Only 63% of the responding nurses had
Table 2. Prevalence of correct answers for different questions of Palliative Care Knowledge Test
(PCKT) scores
Dimension Question Correct Correct
answer response
true/false n (%)
(T/F)
Philosophy of 1. Palliative care should only be provided for patients who have no curative treatments available F 28 (58.3)
care 2. Palliative care should not be provided along with anti-cancer treatments F 31 (64.6)
3. What is important to quality of life varies from individual to individual T 44 (91.7)
4. Patients who receive palliative care must accept death F 18 (37.5)
Total 121 (63)
Pain 5. When a cancer patient has pain, opioids should be introduced first F 14 (29.2)
6. One of the goals of pain management is to get a good night’s sleep T 37 (77.1)
7. When opioids are taken on a regular basis, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs should not be used F 28 (58.3)
8. Regular use of pain relievers is effective in the management of cancer pain T 39 (81.3)
9. Antidepressants and anticonvulsants sometimes help relieve cancer pain T 28 (58.3)
10. Although severe pain occurs when opioids are used regularly, the next dose should not be given early F 25 (52.1)
11. Long-term use of opioids can often induce addiction F 8 (16.7)
12. The use of laxatives is effective in preventing opioid-induced constipation T 41 (85.4)
13. Increasing the dosage of opiates should be limited as respiratory depression can occur as a side-effect F 17 (35.4)
14. The use of opiates does not influence the patient's survival time T 5 (10.4)
Total 242 (50.4)
Dyspnea 15. Morphine should be used to relieve dyspnea in cancer patients T 23 (47.9)
16. When opioids are taken on a regular basis, respiratory depression will be common F 15 (31.3)
17. Oxygen saturation levels are correlated with dyspnoea F 12 (25)
18. Assessment of dyspnea should be based on the subjective perception of patients T 26 (54.2)
19. Anticholinergic drugs or scopolamine hydrobromide are effective for alleviating bronchial secretions T 18 (37.5)
of dying patients
20. The only effective way to reduce bronchial secretions in patients at the end of life is manual aspiration F 15 (31.3)
Total 109 (37.8)
Psychiatric 21. During the last days of life, drowsiness associated with electrolyte imbalance should decrease discomfort T 18 (37.5)
problems 22. Benzodiazepines should be effective for controlling delirium T 29 (60.4)
23. Some dying patients will require continuous sedation to alleviate suffering T 38 (79.2)
24. Morphine is often a cause of delirium in terminally ill cancer patients F 15 (31.3)
25. Delirium occurs frequently in patients who are prone to mental weakness (anxiety, anxiety) F 16 (33.3)
Total 116 (48.3)
Gastrointestinal 26. A gastric tube should be inserted to decrease symptoms caused by obstruction of the digestive tract F 8 (16.7)
problems 27. At terminal stages of cancer, higher calorie intake is needed compared to early stages F 21 (43.8)
28. A decrease in oral fluid intake associated with cancer can only be treated with an infusion F 24 (50)
29. Even though oral fluid intake is not possible due to obstruction of the digestive tract, parenteral T 40 (83.3)
high-calorie nutrition often improves quality of life if the patient's general condition is good
30. There is no route except central venous for patients unable to maintain a peripheral intravenous route F 18 (37.5)
31. When patients receive an infusion of 1000ml or more per day, pleural effusion and ascites tend to increase T 22 (45.8)
32. Steroids should improve appetite among patients with advanced cancer T 30 (62.5)
33. When patients with ileus use metoclopramide, stomach pain and vomiting may worsen T 38 (79.2)
34. Intravenous infusion will not be effective for alleviating dry mouth in dying patients T 29 (60.4)
Total 230 (53.2)
Communication 35. Communication skills and techniques can be learned T 42 (87.5)
© 2022 MA Healthcare Ltd
36. The information required by patients and families as well as the degree to which they take part in T 40 (83.3)
decisions may change depending on the course of the disease and the duration of the disease
37. Uncertain information should not be given to patients or families because it could cause additional anxiety F 21 (43.8)
Total 103 (71.5)
International Journal of Palliative Nursing October 2022 Vol 28, No 10 477
Table 3. Factors affecting the total Palliative Care Knowledge Test knowledge score
Characteristic Variable n Total score Effect size Statistical
mean (Cohen’s d=) evaluation
(+/-SD)
Age (years) <25 9 20.22 (2.38) 0.041 ANOVA: F=0.681;
25–30 21 18.52 (3.65) p*=0.568
4 19 19.29 (4.27)
>4 2 19.5 (0.7)
Years of experience <10 33 18.96 (3.19) 0.07 Anova F=0.246;
10–20 14 19.76 (4.24) P*=0.783
>20 3 19 (3)
Current function Registered nurse 42 19 (3.13) 0.07 T=0.791; P*=0.593
Head nurse 8 20.14 (5.11)
Attended previous Yes 15 18.07 (3.38) 0.048 T=-1.458;
palliative care No 35 19.65 (3.41) P*=0.152
educational session
*P>0.05 non-significant
correct answers regarding the philosophy of care Nurses’ knowledge in the communication
compared with 91% in Iori and Morin’s (2015) dimension was the highest (71.5%); this result
article; this may be due to the late integration of is not consistent with the study conducted by
palliative care in the health system in Lebanon Huijer et al (2009b). This result is promising,
compared with Switzerland. since good communication allows nurses to
In the gastrointestinal dimension, only connect with their patients and understand
16.7% correctly answered the question their priorities and wishes, which results in
regarding whether or not a gastric tube should better patient outcomes (Huijer et al, 2009b).
be inserted to reduce the symptoms caused Regarding the factors affecting nurses’
by an obstruction of the digestive tract, in palliative care knowledge, none of the studied
contrast to 53% in the Swiss study (Iori and factors seemed to significantly affect the
Morin, 2015). This may be due to the fact that nurses’ level of knowledge. The authors did
nursing courses often instruct the use of gastric not find any statistically significant differences
© 2022 MA Healthcare Ltd
tubes as a viable solution in case of obstruction in palliative care knowledge between the
(Roveron et al, 2018), contrary to its use in two sexes examined in the study, nurses who
the management of palliative care, where the had or had not worked in palliative care
main purpose is to maintain patient comfort previously, or nurses who had a different
(Mobily and Patel, 2015). level of experience or level of education. These
www.ijpn.com
© 2022 MA Healthcare Ltd
International Journal of Palliative Nursing October 2022 Vol 28, No 10 481