Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T
Innov Clin Neurosci. 2020;17(1–3):22–26
D E PA R T M E N T E D I TO R The intersection of sexual assault and with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) that
psychotherapy is complicated. It was not might have resulted from sexual assault.4,5
Julie P. Gentile, MD, is a professor with and chair until relatively recently that the treatment Gabbard previously described the distinctive
of the Department of Psychiatry at Wright State
of survivors of sexual assault came to be features of psychodynamic psychotherapy
University in Dayton, Ohio.
under the purview of psychotherapeutic (Table 1).6
treatment.1 In their 1974 American Journal When treating a patient who has been
E D I TO R ’ S N OT E of Psychiatry article, Burgess and Holmstrom sexually abused or assaulted, these distinctive
reported that there was little information features of psychodynamic psychotherapy
The patient cases presented in Psychotherapy on the physical and psychological effects of remain the focus of the treatment. “Follow the
Rounds are composite cases written to illustrate rape or how to manage the treatment of a red thread” is a phrasing used to encourage the
certain diagnostic characteristics and to instruct
survivor of sexual assault in the psychiatric therapist to focus on the feelings and emotions
on treatment techniques. The composite
literature.1 In the past, rape survivors were occurring in the therapy session rather than
cases are not real patients in treatment.
Any resemblance to a real patient is purely
thought to need only counseling—that is, be pulled into discussing superficial issues.
coincidental.
direct, problem-focused treatment—rather In order to do this, the therapist must create
than broader, more in-depth treatment a safe space for talking with the patient by
such as psychotherapy and, if the survivor being empathic and nonjudgmental, attending
A B S T R AC T did undergo psychotherapy, the major focus to the patient’s physical comfort, and
was on preexisting psychopathology.2 The demonstrating understanding.7 Without these
Sexual assault and abuse can result in severe
United States Centers for Disease Control elements, a patient might feel retraumatized
physical and emotional trauma to the victim.
Deploying targeted psychotherapeutic
and Prevention (CDC) estimates that sexual and unsafe.
treatment that is individualized for the violence affects one in three women and one Composite case vignette 1. Ms. A is a
survivor is important to achieving optimal in four men over the course of their lifetimes.3 28-year-old woman who has survived multiple
patient outcomes. There are several valid The treatment of survivors of sexual assault instances of sexual abuse and sexual assault
and evidence-based treatments available gains benefits from several general and from men of authority in her life. She initiated
for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and specialized types of psychotherapy including therapy with the goal of improving her
interpersonal difficulties that can result from psychodynamic psychotherapy, trauma- comfort in and ability to maintain an intimate
sexual abuse and assault. In this article, the focused cognitive–behavioral therapy (TF- relationship.
authors discuss psychodynamic psychotherapy, CBT), and eye movement desensitization and Dr. B—Last week, we talked about your
trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy reprocessing therapy (EMDR). In this article, date that you had planned for this past
(TF-CBT), and eye movement desensitization and we review these psychotherapeutic treatment weekend. How did it go?
reprocessing therapy (EMDR) for the treatment methods in regard to managing this patient Ms. A—It went well! He was handsome and
of patients following sexual assault and abuse. population and provide additional treatment charming. We went to the boardwalk, played
The authors also provide practice points on suggestions to assist therapists in achieving games, and he put his arm around me and
common issues in the management of the optimal outcomes among survivors of sexual kissed me.
treatment of sexual assault survivors, including assault and abuse. Dr. B.—How did that feel?
transference, countertransference, and avoiding Ms. A.—It felt good, I wanted him to…
retraumatization. Composite case vignettes are
PSYCHODYNAMIC PSYCHOTHERAPY Also, we had sex.
used to illustrate treatment techniques.
Psychodynamic psychotherapy has been Dr. B.—Oh, okay. How do you feel about
KEYWORDS: Sexual abuse, sexual trauma,
shown to be effective in treating patients that?
transference, countertransference, trauma
FUNDING: No funding was provided.
DISCLOSURES: The authors have no conflicts of interest relevant to the content of this article.
CORRESPONDENC: Julie P. Gentile, MD; Email: julie.gentile@wright.edu
Ms. B.—Ugh, fine. I guess I’ve felt better survivors of sexual abuse and assault are edu/coe/tfcbt/workbook/Trauma%20
since I started coming here, but I feel worse, awareness of common pitfalls, managing Narrative/Trauma%20Narrative%20
too. It is so hard to drag myself in here every transference and countertransference, and Goals%20and%20Process.pdf. Accessed:
week to go over this. I feel like I’m falling avoiding retraumatization. January 19, 2020.
apart. 11. Shapiro F, Snyker E, Maxfield L. EMDR:
Dr. A.—Are you, though? Falling apart? REFERENCES eye movement desensitization and
Ms. B.—I guess not. I feel pretty strong 1. Burgess AW, Holmstrom LL. Rape reprocessing. In: Kaslow FW, Patterson
today. trauma syndrome. Am J Psychiatry. T (eds). Comprehensive Handbook of
This vignette demonstrates how intense 1974;131(9):981–986. Psychotherapy, Cognitive-Behavioral
emotions can emerge in session, but, here, 2. Rose DS. “Worse than death”: Approaches. West Sussex, UK: John Wiley &
Dr. A. creates an environment where Ms. B. psychodynamics of rape victims and the Sons. 2004; 248–254.
can talk about her rage and disappointment. need for psychotherapy. Am J Psychiatry. 12. Shapiro R, Brown LS. Eye movement
Because Dr. A. is not actually overwhelmed 1986;143(7):817–824. desensitization and reprocessing therapy
or hurt by listening to Ms. B., Ms. B. begins 3. Smith SG, Zhang X, Basile KC, et al. The and related treatments for trauma: an
the process of examining her feelings and national intimate partner and sexual innovative, integrative trauma treatment.
reactions. This allows a more nuanced violence survey: 2018 data brief—updated Practice Innovations. 2019;4(3):139.
introspection that can bring solace and release. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/ 13. Davidson PR, Parker KC. Eye movement
understanding. If Ms. B. had become too upset violenceprevention/pdf/2015data-brief508. desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR):
or became inappropriate, Dr. A. could have pdf. Accessed February 6, 2020. a meta-analysis. J Consult Clin Psychol.
redirected her with a statement like, “I can’t 4. Levi O, Bar‐Haim Y, Kreiss Y, Fruchter 2001;69(2):305–316.
hear what you’re saying when you’re yelling E. Cognitive–behavioural therapy and 14. Cusack K, Jonas DE, Forneris CA, et al.
at me” or “time out; I think it’s getting too hot. psychodynamic psychotherapy in the Psychological treatments for adults with
Let’s do our five senses mindfulness grounding treatment of combat‐related post‐ posttraumatic stress disorder: a systematic
exercise, and then we can come back to that.” traumatic stress disorder: s comparative review and meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev.
Further reading. Every patient deserves effectiveness study. Clin Psychol Psychother. 2016;43:128–141.
individualized care that is compassionate and 2016;23(4):298–307. 15. Women’s Health: Treating Survivors of
helpful. There are some specific resources for 5. Paintain E, Cassidy S. First‐line therapy for Sexual Assault. (August 2019). Women’s
sexual assault survivors. The Sexual Trauma post‐traumatic stress disorder: a systematic Health. DOI 10.2310/7800.13087. Decker
Workbook for Teen Girls is a guide for recovery review of cognitive behavioural therapy Psychiatry.
from sexual assault and abuse.17 Additionally, and psychodynamic approaches. Couns 16. Hockett JM, Saucier DA, Badke C. Rape
Opening the Door focuses on therapy for Psychother Res. 2018;18(3):237–250. myths, rape scripts, and common rape
male survivors of sexual abuse.18 Finally, the 6. Gabbard GO. Long-term Psychodynamic experiences of college women: Differences
Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network is Psychotherapy: A Basic Text. Washington DC: in perceptions of women who have
an American nonprofit anti–sexual assault American Psychiatric Publishing; 2017: 3–4. been raped. Violence Against Women.
organization and has many local and national 7. Cohen JA, Mannarino AP, Perel JM, Staron 2016;22(3):307–323.
resources that survivors and family can V. A pilot randomized controlled trial 17. Lohmann RC, Raja S. The Sexual Trauma
reference.19 of combined trauma-focused CBT and Workbook for Teen Girls: A Guide to Recovery
sertraline for childhood PTSD symptoms. from Sexual Assault and Abuse. Oakland, CA:
CONCLUSION J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. Instant Help; 2016.
The CDC estimates that sexual violence 2007;46(7):811–819. 18. Crowder A. Opening the Door: A Treatment
affects one in three women and one in 8. Cabaniss DL. Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: Model for Therapy with Male Survivors of
four men over the course of their lifetimes. A Clinical Manual. West Sussex, UK: John Sexual Abuse. Oxfordshire, UK: Routledge;
Survivors of sexual assault can benefit from Wiley & Sons; 2016. 2014: 1–226.
several types of psychotherapy including 9. Cohen JA, Deblinger E, Mannarino AP. 19. Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network.
psychodynamic psychotherapy, TF-CBT, and Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral Materials. Available at: https://www.rainn.
EMDR. Processing abuse and trauma is a therapy for children and families. org/materials. Accessed January 30, 2020.
helpful and necessary step to recovery and is Psychother Res. 2018;28(1):47–57. ICNS
the main focus in these treatment modalities. 10. Vanderbilt University. Trauma narrative.
General considerations for working with Available at: https://www.mc.vanderbilt.