Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s10661-009-1107-2
Received: 30 March 2009 / Accepted: 27 July 2009 / Published online: 8 August 2009
© Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
Abstract The study aimed to determine the ha- 18 to 58 years. PChE levels were estimated by
zardous health effects of pesticides exposure in Ellmann’s method. Plasma pesticides residue ana-
the factory workers by measuring plasma cho- lysis was performed by using reverse phase C-18
linesterase (PChE), pesticides residues, and renal on high-performance liquid chromatograph and
and hepatic biochemical markers. In addition, GC with NPD detector. Plasma alanine amino-
we also assessed the knowledge, attitudes, and transferase (ALT), aspartate aminotransferase
safety practices adopted by the industrial wor- (AST), creatinine, urea, and gamma glutamyl-
kers. The study was conducted in three differ- transferase (GGT) were measured on Selectra E
ent sizes of factories located in Lahore (large), auto analyzer. Plasma and C-reactive protein was
Multan (medium), and Karachi (small) in analyzed by Immulite 1000. The results revealed
Pakistan. Total 238 adult males consisting of 184 a significant decrease in plasma post exposure
pesticide industrial workers (exposed group) PChE levels (<30%) as compared to baseline in
from large-sized (67), medium-sized (61), small- the workers of small (29%) and medium (8%)
sized (56) industrial formulation factories, and industrial units ( p < 0.001). Plasma cypermethrin,
54 controls (unexposed) were included in the endosulfan, imidacloprid, thiodicarb, carbofuran,
study. All the participants were male of aged and methamidophos levels were found to be
higher than allowable daily intake. Serum AST,
ALT, creatinine GGT, malondialdehyde, total
antioxidant, and CRP were significantly raised
among the workers of small and medium pesticide
formulation factories as compared to large in-
dustrial unit and controls ( p < 0.001). The study
D. A. Khan · W. Mahjabeen · T. A. Naqvi demonstrated that unsafe practices among small-
Department of Chemical Pathology, and medium-sized pesticides industrial workers
Army Medical College,
National University of Sciences and Technology,
cause significant increase in pesticide exposure,
Rawalpindi, Pakistan oxidative stress, and derangement of hepatic and
renal function.
I. Hashmi (B)
School of Civil and Environmental Engineering,
National University of Sciences and Technology,
Keywords Pesticides toxicity · Residues ·
Rawalpindi, Pakistan Health effects · Industrial workers ·
e-mail: hashmi71@gmail.com Acetyl cholinesterase · Biochemical markers
232 Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240
the atmospheric pressure. Finally, the column was cal pesticides standards purchased from Riedal-de
dried under vacuum on SPE station for 30 s and Haen AG Seelze (Germany). Pesticide residues
rinsed with 2 ml, n-hexane and eluted with 3 ml in the samples were identified on the basis of
n-hexane, dichloromethane (1:1). The solvent was retention times and quantified on the basis of
evaporated, and sample was resolved using 25 μl peak area by using external standard method. The
toluene. retention time for methamidophos, chlorphyrifos,
Cleanup was made by USEPA Method 3620B and carbofuran were 8.2, 17.3, and 8 min. The
(US-EPA 1996). Florisil was activated at 130◦ C recoveries of the insecticides were found to be in
overnight and cooled in a dessicator before use. the range from 81% to 94%.
Column was packed with 1 g of Florisil. Extract
was transferred to the column and eluted with
hexane and diethyl ether. Eluent was collected
Statistical analysis
and evaporated to dryness. Final sample were
prepared in 2 ml of acetonitrile.
The data were entered into SPSS version-15
(SPSS Inc, Chicago) for statistical analysis. Me-
Instrumental analysis of samples
dian, percentile, and interquartile range (IQR)
of all biochemical markers were calculated. Post-
The instruments used in this study was high-
exposure PChE in the pesticides packing workers
performance liquid chromatograph (HPLC;
as compared to baseline levels by Wilcoxon rank
Shimadzu, Japan) consisting of binary LC pump
sum test. Biochemical, oxidative, and inflamma-
and UV/VIS detector. The residues of methomyl,
tory markers in the workers of three pesticides
thiodicarb, imidacloprid, cypermethrin, and endo-
packing industries were analyzed by Kruskal–
sulfan were determined by using reverse phase
Wallis test. Mann–Whitney U test was applied
C-18 column (VA-ODS 150 × 4.6 Shimadzu,
for pairwise group comparisons. Association of
Japan) at wavelength of 254 nm with flow rate of
reduction cholinesterase (%) with change in bio-
1 ml/min on HPLC. Analysis was performed using
chemical markers in pesticide industrial workers
60% acetonitrile, 20% methanol, and 20% water
was established by Spearman’s coefficient correla-
as mobile phase. All the chemicals used during
tions. P value of <0.05 was considered significant.
analysis were HPLC grade (Merck, Germany).
Calibration of the instrument was done before
the sample analysis by using analytical pesticide
standards purchased from Riedal-de Haen AG Results and discussion
Seelze, (Germany). Every possible care was taken
to observe good laboratory practices to avoid Total 184 pesticides factory workers participated
contamination and keep the precision with in 5%. from the three pesticides formulation industrial
Analysis of methamidophos, chlorpyrifos, and units. All the workers were males with age ranging
carbofuran were done by using Elite-5 column from 18 to 58 years. The duration of pesticide ex-
(HP-5ms, 30 m × 0.32 mm × 0.25 μm) and posure among the workers ranged between 1 and
NPD detector on GC Model Clarus-500 (Perkin 19 years. The pesticides workers of small-sized
Elmer, USA). The injector and detector temper- industry experienced more symptoms of central
atures were 225◦ C and 300◦ C, respectively. Ini- nervous (Fig. 1), gastrointestinal, and respiratory
tially, the oven was ramped to 100◦ C at a rate systems than the other two factories. Headache
of 20◦ C/min; Ramp 2:5◦ C/min to 150◦ C (5 min) followed by dizziness, vomiting, and shortness of
Ramp 3:10◦ C/min to 200◦ C. Helium gas with a breath and skin rash were quite high among these
flow rate of 50 ml/min was used as a carrier. Three workers. Few workers complained of fatigue and
microliters of the samples was injected through tiredness.
10 μl. Hamilton syringe by the solvent flush injec- Pesticide exposure is a global public health is-
tion technique. Calibration of the instrument was sue. Pesticide industrial workers are constantly ex-
done before the sample analysis by using analyti- posed to a variety of toxic chemicals (Javed et al.
Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240 235
Cholinesterase activity
Fig. 2 Comparison of
PChE levels in the
industrial workers as
compared to control
236 Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240
(2004), both directly and indirectly exposed work- Oxidative stress markers
ers presented significant decreased levels of PChE
at the time of maximum exposure to pesticides. The pesticide-exposed industrial workers had in-
creased oxidative stress indicated by significantly
raised plasma total antioxidant, gamma glutamyl-
Biochemical markers transferase (GGT), MDA, and CRP levels in
small-sized industrial workers as compared to
The industrial workers of small- and medium- other two industries (Table 2). Plasma CRP levels
sized industries had significant hepatic injury were also increased due to nonspecific inflamma-
when compared to the large-sized industry and tory changes in the exposed workers.
control. The enzyme activity of ALT and aspar- Our study had revealed significant association
tate aminotransferase (AST) were significantly between reduction PChE (%) with change in bio-
raised ( p < 0.001) among the pesticide-exposed chemical markers of oxidative stress and inflam-
industrial workers as compared to less-exposed mation in pesticides small-sized industrial factory
workers of large-sized industry Table 1. Other workers. The workers also had negative correla-
markers such as plasma bilirubin, albumin, to- tion between cholinesterase and MDA (r = 0.54;
tal proteins, urea, and creatinine were not sig- p < 0.01), GGT (r = 0.21; p < 0.05), and CRP
nificantly changed among pesticides formulation (r = 0.55; p < 0.01). The post-exposure reduc-
workers. Our studies also revealed inverse cor- tion PChE (%) with total antioxidant status (r =
relation between the PChE with AST (r = 0.42; −0.34; p < 0.01) is exhibited in Fig. 5.
p < 0.01) and ALT (r = 0.50; p < 0.01) in the The workers knowledge regarding the health
pesticide-exposed workers. hazards of pesticide and safety were assessed on
Table 2 Comparison of oxidative stress and inflammatory biochemical markers among pesticide exposed workers of three
different industrial units (n = 184)
Parameters Small industry Medium industry Large industry
(n = 56) (n = 61) (n = 67)
Median (IQR) Median (IQR) Median (IQR)
Total antioxidants (mmol/L) 1.53 (1.37–1.66)* 1.56 (1.40–1.66)* 1.65 (1.47–1.70)
Gamma glutmyl transferase (U/L) 26 (22–30)** 21 (19–26) 20 (19–22)
Malonylialdehyde (μmol/L) 2.44 (1.72–4.00)** 1.62 (1.51–2.46) 1.85 (1.55–2.41)
C-reactive protein (mg/L) 1.55 (0.90–2.65)** 0.80 (0.30–1.40) 0.90 (0.30–1.50)
* p =< 0.05, ** p =< 0.01
238 Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240
Fig. 5 Correlation of
PChE with total
antioxidant level in the
industrial workers
the pretested questionnaire by the health team. they practice the standards of occupational health
Among 184 workers, 62% were not literate and a and safety.
few (10%) had completed their high-school level The study demonstrates that casual attitude
education. Only the workers (95%) of large-sized and unsafety practices among small industrial
industry had formal training in safe pesticide han- workers causes significant decrease in PChE levels
dling and packing. About 90% of the workers and increased multiple pesticide residues. Pro-
had knowledge of the detrimental health effects longed exposure of pesticides causes derangement
of pesticide but were not well aware of the safety of hepatic renal function. This is accompanied by
precautions regarding pesticide handling. How- increased concentration of oxidative stress and in-
ever, many workers reported (85%) to wash hands flammatory markers. On the basis of information
and bodies after work. gathered, best management practices at work-
The participants had casual attitude in handling place were recommended to industrial units for
of pesticide and personal protection. We observed the safety of their workers. Baseline data regard-
that 90% workers of small-sized industry did ing health risks caused by the unsafe handling and
not use any personal protective equipment dur- packing of pesticides thereby help government
ing pesticide handling while 35% medium-sized and policy makers in reviewing pesticide-related
industrial workers used gloves and ace masks. health and environmental policies.
Large-sized industry workers (95%) used proper
protective head cover, gloves, and masks during
work. Large-sized industry possessed a compe- Conclusions
tent, knowledgeable, and experienced staff and
was meeting the standard of occupational health In conclusion, unsafe practices among industrial
and safety measures. They were fully equipped workers cause significant decrease in PChE lev-
to meet any emergency situation and workers’ els, increased oxidative stress, and derangement
pesticides exposure was regularly monitored by of hepatic function in workers. Furthermore, the
measuring PChE levels. The workers of large in- workers of small and medium factories had little
dustry were knowledgeable and experienced, and knowledge about the safety practices and use of
Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240 239
basic protective equipment. Concerted efforts are International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental
required to create awareness, change in attitude, Health, 210(2), 121–132.
Doumas, B. T., Watson, W. A., & Bigg, H. G. (1997).
and safety practices among the industrial workers
Albumin standards and the measurement of Plasma
for prevention of hazardous health effects. albumin with bromocresol green. Clin PChEm Acta,
31, 87–96.
Acknowledgements This study was a part of the Project Economic Survey of Pakistan (2008–9). Finance Division,
No. 20-770/R&D/2007/446 entitled, “The Effects of Envi- Government of Pakistan, Islamabad. http://finance.
ronmental Pesticides Residues on the Health of workers in gov.pk/survey/survey_2008–09/02-Agriculture.
Pesticide Manufacturing Industries of Pakistan” supported El-Demerdash, F. M., Yousef, M. I., & Elagamy, E. I.
by Higher Education Commission (HEC) Pakistan. We (2001). Influence of paraquat, glyphosate, and cad-
acknowledge the participation of pesticides formulation mium on the activity of some serum enzymes and
industrial units from Karachi, Multan, and Lahore for protein electrophoretic behavior (in vitro). Journal of
extending their cooperation in all aspects of the study and Environmental Science and Health B, 36(1), 29–42.
continuous support. Ellmann, G. L., Courney, K. D., Andres, V., &
Featherstone, R. M. (1961). A new and rapid colori-
metric determination of acetylcholinesterase activity.
Biochemical Pharmacology, 7, 75–88.
Gavino, V. C., Miller, J. S., Ikharebha, S. O., Milo, G. E.
References & Cornwall, D. G. (1981). Effects of polyunsaturated
fattyacids and antioxidants on lipid peroxidation in
Australian Government, Department of Health Sciences tissue cultures. Journal of Lipid Research, 22, 763–769.
and Ageing, Office of Chemical Safety (2008). Accept- Goel, A., Chanuhan, D. P., & Dhawan, D. K. (2000). Pro-
able daily intakes for agricultural and veterinary chem- tective effects of zinc in chlorpyrifos induced hepatoxi-
icals. Woden: Office of Chemical Safety, Australian city; a biochemical and trace element study. Biological
Government. http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/ Trace Element Research, 74, 171–183.
publishing.nsf/Content/ocs-adi-list.htm. Hernández, A., Gómez, M. A., Pena, G., Gil, F., Rodrigo,
Azmi, M. A., Naqvi, S. N., Azmi, M. A., & Aslam, L., Villanueva, E., et al. (2004). Effect of long-term
M. (2006). Effect of pesticide residues on health exposure to pesticides on plasma esterases from plastic
and different enzyme levels in the blood of farm greenhouse workers. Journal of Toxicology and Envi-
workers from Gadap (rural area) Karachi-Pakistan. ronmental Health A, 67(14), 1095–1108.
Chemosphere, 64(10), 1739–1744. Javed, A. B., Khan, Q. M., Haq, M. A., Khalid, A. M. &
Bergmeyer, H. U., Hereder, M., & Rej, R. (1998). Ap- Nasim, A. (2006). Cytogenetic analysis of Pakistani
proved recommendation 1985 on IFCC method for the individual’s occupationally exposed to pesticides in
measurement of catalytic concentration of enzymes a pesticide production industry. Mutagenesis, 21(2),
part 2. IFCC method for aspartate aminotransferase. 143–148.
Journal of Clinical Chemistry and Clinical Biochem- Kingsley, G. R. (1942). The direct Biuret method for the
istry, 24, 49. determination of serum proteinsas applied to photo-
Cabello, G., Valenzuela, M., Vilaxa, A., Durán, V., electric and visual colorimetry. Journal of Laboratory
Rudolph, I., Hrepic, N., et al. (2001). A rat mam- and Clinical Medicine, 27, 840–845.
mary tumor model induced by the organophosphorus Merhi, M., Raynal, H., Cahuzac, E., Vinson, F., Cravedi, J.
pesticides parathion and malathion, possibly through P., & Gamet-Payrastre, L. (2007). Occupational expo-
acetylcholinesterase inhibition. Environmental Health sure to pesticides and risk of hematopoietic cancers:
Perspectives, 109(5), 471–479. Meta-analysis of case-control studies. Cancer Causes
Catharina, W., Matthew, K., Anders, A., Rob, M., Control, 18(10), 1209–1226.
Jai-Dong, M., Linda, R., et al. (2002). Long-term Miller, N. J., Rice-Evans, C., Davies, M. J., Copinathan,
neurobehavioral effects of mild poisonings with V., & Milner, A. (1993). A novel method for measure-
organophosphate and n-methyl carbamate pesticides ment antioxidant capacity and its application to mon-
among banana workers. International Journal of itoring the antioxidant status in prematureneonates.
Occupational and Environmental Health, 8(1), 27–34. Clinical Science, 84, 407–412.
Coronado, G. D., Thompson, B., Strong, L., Griffith, W. Misra, U. K., Nag, D., Dhushan, V., & Ray, P. K. (1985).
C., & Islas, I. (2004). Agricultural task and exposure Clinical and biochemical changes in chronically ex-
to organophosphate pesticides among farm workers. posed organophosphate workers. Toxicology Letters,
Environmental Health Prospective, 112(2), 142–147. 244, 187–193.
Daniel, V., Huber, W., & Baver, K. (2002). Association of Murphy, H. H., Haon, N. P., Matteson, P. & Morales, A. L.
dichlorodiphenyl trichloroethne (DDT) 4.4. and DDE C. (2002). Farmers self surveillance of pesticide poi-
4.4 blood levels with plasma IL.4 Arch. Environmental soning: A twelve month pilot in Northern Vietnam.
Health, 57(6), 541–547. International Journal of Occupational and Environ-
Dasgupta, S., Meisner, C., Wheeler, D., Xuyen, K., & Thi, mental Health, 8(3), 201–221.
L. N. (2007). Pesticide poisoning of farm workers – Ohayo-Mitoko, G. J. A., Kromhout, H., Simwa, J. M.,
implications of blood test results from Vietnam. Boleij, J. S. M., & Heederik, D. (2000). Self reported
240 Environ Monit Assess (2010) 168:231–240
symptoms and inhibition of acetylcholinesterase activ- fects of pesticides. Systematic review and implications
ity among Kenyan agricultural workers. Occupational for family doctors. Canadian Family Physician, 53,
and Environmental Medicine, 57, 195–200. 1712–1720.
Peres, F., Moreire, C. J., Rodrigues, M. K., & Claudio, L. Schumann, G., Bonora, R., Ceriotti, F., Clerc-Renaud, P.,
(2006). Risk perception and communication regarding Ferard, G., Ferrero, C. A., et al. (2002). IFCC primary
pesticide use in rural work: A case study in Rio de reference procedures for the measurement of catalytic
Janeiro State, Brazil. International Journal of Occupa- activity concentrations of enzymes at 37◦ C. Reference
tional and Environmental Health, 12(4), 400–407. procedure for the measurement of catalytic concen-
Perry, B. W., Doumas, B. T., & Bayse, D. D. (1983). tration of gamma glutamyltransferase. Chemistry and
A candidate reference method for determination of Laboratory Medicine, 0, 734–738.
bilirubin in plasma: Test for transferability. Clinical Spencer, K. (1986). Analytical reviews in clinical biochem-
Chemistry, 29, 297–301. istry: The estimation of creatinine. Annals of Clinical
Ranjbar, A., Pasalar, P., & Abdollahi, M. (2002). Induc- Biochemistry, 23, 1–25.
tion of oxidative stress and acetylchol inesterase inhi- Tariq, M. I., Afzal, S., Hussain, I., & Sultana, N. (2007).
bition in organophosphorous pesticide manufacturing Pesticides exposure in Pakistan: A review. Environ-
workers. Human & Experimental Toxicology, 21(4), ment International, 33, 1107–1122.
179–182. US-EPA (1996). Method 3620B: Florisil cleanup.
Sampson, E. J., & Baird, M. A. (1979). Chemical inhibi- Washington, D.C.: U.S. Environmental Protection
tion used in a Kinetic Urease/ glutamate dehhydroge- Agency.
nase method for urea in serum. Clinical Chemistry, 25, Wesseling, C., McConnell, R., Partanen, T., & Hogstedt, C.
1721–1729. (1997). Agricultural pesticide use in developing coun-
Sanborn, M., Kerr, K. J., Sanin, L. H., Cole, D. C., Bassil, tries: Health effects and research needs. International
K. L., & Vakil, C. (2007). Non-cancer health ef- Journal of Health Services, 27(2), 273–308.