You are on page 1of 11

.03"- ²5*$" %&0/50-0(*"%01"3"%090"01"3"%*(.


.03"- &5)*$4"/%%&0/50-0(:'30.1"3"%09501"3"%*(.
.03"- ²5*$" %&0/50-0(¶"%&-"1"3"%0+""-1"3"%*(."

.JDIFM.BòFTPMJ

3FTVNP&TUFBSUJHP OVNFTUJMPFOTBÓTUJDP QSPDVSBFTDMBSFDFSPTJHOJöDBEPEFUSÐTUFSNPT


SFDPSSFOUFT OB MJUFSBUVSB BDBEÐNJDB NPSBM  ÏUJDB F EFPOUPMPHJB5SBUBTF BOUFT EF VNB
BUVBMJ[BÎÍPEPRVFEFVNBIJTUPSJDJ[BÎÍP QSPDVSBOEPTJUVÈMPTOPUFNQPQSFTFOUF FTTF
NFTNPUFNQPRVF QBSBNVJUPT TFDBSBDUFSJ[BQPSWBMPSFTBMUFSOBUJWPTBPTEPQBTTBEPF
RVF QPSJTTP SFDFCFBEFOPNJOBÎÍPEFQØTNPEFSOP*TUPÏ VNUFNQPDVKBTFOTJCJMJEBEF
ÏBEPUSJCBMJTNP EPIFEPOJTNPFEBTDPNVOIÜFTFNPDJPOBJT"3B[ÍP B7FSEBEFFP
1SPHSFTTP PUSJQÏDPODFJUVBMEFVNNBUFSJBMJTNPEJBMÏUJDPNBSYJTUB DFEFFTQBÎPQBSBB
USBOTöHVSBÎÍPEBQPMÓUJDBPV DPOGPSNF/JFU[TDIF ËiUSBOTWBMPSBÎÍPEFUPEPTPTWBMPSFTw
1BMBWSBTDIBWF1ØTNPEFSOJEBEFUSJCBMJTNPJNBHJOÈSJP/JFU[TDIFÏUJDB

"CTUSBDU5IJTQBQFS JOBOFTTBZJTUJDTUZMF TFFLTUPDMBSJGZUIFNFBOJOHPGUISFFSFDVSSJOH


UFSNTJOUIFBDBEFNJDMJUFSBUVSFNPSBM FUIJDTBOEEFPOUPMPHZ*UJTSBUIFSVQEBUJOHUIBO
IJTUPSJDJ[JOH USZJOHUPQMBDFUIFNBUUIFQSFTFOUUJNF UIJTTBNFUJNFUIBU GPSNBOZ JT
DIBSBDUFSJ[FECZBMUFSOBUJWFWBMVFTJODPNQBSJTPOUPUIFQBTUBOEUIBU UIFSFGPSF SFDFJWFTB
QPTUNPEFSO EFTJHOBUJPO 5IF UJNF JO XIJDI TFOTJUJWJUZ JT USJCBMJTN  IFEPOJTN BOE
FNPUJPOBMDPNNVOJPOT3FBTPO 5SVUIBOE1SPHSFTT UIFDPODFQUVBMUSJQPEPGB.BSYJTU
EJBMFDUJDBMNBUFSJBMJTN HJWFTSPPNUPUIFUSBOTöHVSBUJPOPGQPMJUJDTPS BT/JFU[TDIFTBZT 
UIFSFWBMVBUJPOPGBMMWBMVFT
,FZXPSET1PTUNPEFSOJUZUSJCBMJTNJNBHJOBZ/JFU[TDIFFUIJDT

&YJTUF VNB SFMBÎÍP FOUSF B BSUF EF DPNQSFFOEFS F B EF UPSOBS


DPNQSFFOTÓWFJTBTDPJTBTEBWJEB&TUBTDPJTBTTÍPPRVFFMBTTÍP4FSJBNVJUB
JOHFOVJEBEFOPTTBBDSFEJUBSNPTRVFTPNPTOØTRVFBTDSJBNPT*OHFOVJEBEF
PV QSFUFOTÍP  EFQFOEFOEP EP DBTP %F RVBMRVFS GPSNB  Ï JTTP RVF FTUÈ OB
PSJHFN EFTTB DPOGVTÍP DPOGVTÍP EF QBMBWSBT  DPOGVTÍP EF TFOUJNFOUPT 
DPOGVTÍP QSØQSJB EB NFOUBMJEBEF EF VNB ÏQPDB $FSUBNFOUF  OÍP TF QPEF
KBNBJTEFJYBSEFSFQFUJSRVFPFTUBSKVOUPÏUSJCVUÈSJPEPNPEPDPNRVFOPT
FYQSFTTBNPT%BÓBOFDFTTJEBEFEFPQFSBDJPOBMJ[BSFTUFUSBCBMIPDPOTUBOUFEF
QBESFRVFDPOTJTUFFNEFTPCTUSVJSPQFOTBNFOUPEPTOPTTPTDPOGPSNJTNPT
IBCJUVBJTFPVUSBTQBMBWSBTEPHNÈUJDBT BöNEFSFTHBUBSNPTPTFOUJEPPSJHJOBM
EBTFYQSFTTÜFTGVOEBEPSBT
/FDFTTÈSJP NBTRVFOÍPÏGÈDJM UBNBOIBBRVBOUJEBEFEFNPSBMJTUBTOB
WJUSJOF$POWÏN OBWFSEBEF TBCFSTFMJCFSUBSEBPQJOJÍPEPNJOBOUF PRVF 
BOUJHBNFOUF  TF DIBNBWBiEPYBw  B öN EF QFOTBSNPT  EB GPSNB NBJT KVTUB
QPTTÓWFM BRVJMPRVFÏ$BUÍP P7FMIP TFNQSFEFTUBDBWBFNTFVTEJTDVSTPTB

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

GBNPTBFYQSFTTÍP%FMFOEB$BSUIBHPFTU4JHOJöDBWBVNBJNQFSJPTBFYJHÐODJB
QFMB TPCSFWJWÐODJB EF 3PNB 5BMWF[ TFKB FTTB FYJHÐODJB RVF EFWBNPT
JEFOUJöDBS NPTUSBS B JOJRVJEBEF EP EJTDVSTP NPSBMJTUB TF RVJTFSNPT
DPNQSFFOEFS  DPN QSFDJTÍP F MVDJEF[  P FTUBSKVOUP DPOUFNQPSÉOFP
1SJODJQBMNFOUF  QPSRVF FTTB CBCÏMJB NPSBMJTUB TF FODPOUSB FN UPEPT PT
EJTDVSTPT QPMÓUJDPT  PT BSUJHPT KPSOBMÓTUJDPT F PT MJWSPT VOJWFSTJUÈSJPT
JNQSFHOBEPTEFCPOTTFOUJNFOUPT
5PEPTPCOVCJMBEPTQPSVNBMØHJDBEPEFWFSTFS PRVFOÍPÏBNFMIPS
NBOFJSB EF BQSFDJBS P RVF Ï 1BSB SFUPNBS VNB JNBHFN EF /JFU[TDIF  FTUB
TFDSFÎÍPEFNPSBMJOBUSBEV[ TJNQMFTNFOUF BEFGBTBHFNEBTFMJUFTTPDJBJTFN
GBDFEBWJEB0VBJOEBPGBUPEFRVFFTTBNPSBMJOB FNOPNFEFVNQSJODÓQJPEF
SFBMJEBEF QPMÓUJDB  FDPOÙNJDB  TPDJBM  TFKB VNB BCTUSBÎÍP EF VN SFBM NBJT
DPNQMFYPFSJDP3FBMOPRVBMBTQBJYÜFT BTFNPÎÜFTDPNVOTUÐNVNQBQFM
JOFHÈWFM3FBMPVMÞEJDP PGFTUJWPFPPOÓSJDPOÍPQPEFNNBJTTFSBDBOUPOBEPT
BUSÈT EP iNVSP EB WJEB QSJWBEBw ² FTTB EFGBTBHFN RVF OPT QFSNJUF
DPNQSFFOEFSFTUBTVSQSFFOEFOUFJOWFSTÍPEFWBMPSFTOBRVBMPDPHJUPFSHPTVN
DBSUFTJBOPUPSOBTFVNPEJ FSHPTVN iFVPEFJP QPSUBOUPFVTPVw3BJWBRVF
USBEV[OBTIJTUØSJBTIVNBOBTRVFVNBiDJSDVMBÎÍPEBTFMJUFTwFTUÈFNDVSTP
/BWFSEBEF RVBOEPBTPDJFEBEFPöDJPTBOÍPÏNBJTSFQSFTFOUBEBQFMB
TPDJFEBEFPöDJBM FTUBNFTNBUFOEFBFYQSFTTBSTFVNBVIVNPS-PHP QBSB
BRVFMFT RVF BRVÏN PV BMÏN EF VNB QPTUVSB DBUBTUSPöTUB EFTFKBN FTUBS
BUFOUPTBPWJUBMJTNPEPTIVNPSFTBUVBJT DPOWÏNQFSDFCFSBTVBGPSNBJOUFSJPS
"QFTBSEPBTQFDUPFSSÈUJDPEPGFOÙNFOP IÈVNQSJODÓQJPRVFBTTFHVSBVNB
DPFSÐODJBQSPGVOEBFPCTUJOBEB1SJODÓQJPSFHVMBOEPBBÎÍPFEFMJNJUBOEPP
JNBHJOÈSJP RVF DBSBDUFSJ[B P FTUBSKVOUP ² P RVF 4BOUP 5PNÈT EF "RVJOP

EFOPNJOPVj)BCJUVTx 5SBUBTFEFVNQSJODÓQJPSFHVMBEPSOPRVBMPDMÏSJHPEP
2VBSUJFS-BUJO DPNPIÈCJUP /53FGFSFTF BRVJ ËWFTUJNFOUB JOEV[JBTFVT
IÈCJUPTEFWJEB BPQBTTPRVFPKVSJTUBEB$JEBEF UFOEPPVUSPIÈCJUP QPEJB
BQSFTFOUBS PVUSBT NBOFJSBT EF TFS ² QBSB QFSDFCFS VN UBM IBCJUVT RVF FV
EFTJHOFJiBT USJCPT QØTNPEFSOBTwF RVF Ï QSFDJTP  UBNCÏN  GB[FS EJTUJOÎÜFT
FOUSFUFSNPTRVFTFDPOGVOEFNGSFRVFOUFNFOUFNPSBM ÏUJDBFEFPOUPMPHJB
0IVNBOP KVTUBNFOUF ÏSFQMFUPEFIÞNVT0RVFOPTFODPSBKBBUFSB
IVNJMEBEFEFBDFJUBSPDMBSPPCTDVSPEFUPEBFYJTUÐODJB&TUFÏ FYBUBNFOUF P
GVOEBNFOUPEBRVJMPRVFGPJ EFBOUJHBNFNØSJB PDBSÈUFSFTTFODJBMUBOUPEP
QFOTBNFOUPFSVEJUPRVBOUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPDPNVNPEJTDFSOJNFOUP&N
TVBFUJNPMPHJBMBUJOB EJTDSFUJP*TTPRVFSEJ[FSPTFOUJEPEBNFEJEBRVFQSFGFSF
VNBKVTUJÎBDPODSFUBËKVTUJÎBBCTUSBUB%JTDSJÎÍPRVFSFGVUBPTGBOBUJTNPTF
PVUSBTJOUPMFSÉODJBTOBPSJHFNEBTEJWFSTBTJORVJTJÎÜFTFUSJCVOBJTQPQVMBSFT
DPOIFDJEPT EF UPEPT PT UPUBMJUBSJTNPT /FTTF DBTP  P TFOUJEP EFTTF
EJTDFSOJNFOUPÏFYBUBNFOUFPGVOEBNFOUPEFTUBWJSUVEFRVF.BDIJBWFMGBMBF
RVF MPOHFEFTFSPCTPMFUB HBSBOUF JTUPTJN BEVSBCJMJEBEFEFMPOHBEVSBÎÍP
RVFÏPQSJODÓQJPCÈTJDPEFRVBMRVFSTPDJFEBEFPFTUBSKVOUP
0TKVMHBNFOUPTBQSJPSÓTUJDPTTÍPDBVTBFFGFJUPEPTNJNFUJTNPTTPDJBJT 
EFTUB QVMTÍP BOJNBM RVF TFSWF EF GVOEBNFOUP ËRVJMP RVF (BCSJFM 5BSEF

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

EFOPNJOBWB  KVTUBNFOUF  BTiMFJT EB JNJUBÎÍPw 0 JOTUJOUP HSFHÈSJP  DPNP TF


TBCF ÏPNPUPSDPOTUBOUFEFOPTTBFTQÏDJFBOJNBM%FTEF(JEF TBCFTFCFN
RVF OÍP TF GB[ CPB MJUFSBUVSB DPN CPOT TFOUJNFOUPT $PSSFN P SJTDP EF TFS
UPUBMNFOUFJOFöDB[FTQBSBEBSFNDPOUBEFTUBSFUØSJDBTPDJBMRVFDPOTUJUVJP
DPUJEJBOP%FGBUP ÏQSFDJTPBDFJUBSDPNMVDJEF[FIVNJMEBEFRVFPJNQFSBUJWP
EPDPOIFDJNFOUPOÍPTFFODPOUSBFNVNNVOEPWFSEBEFJSPQBSBBMÏNEFTUF
NVOEP BRVJ  VNB DPOTPMBÎÍP OVNB WJEB QBSB BMÏN EFTUB  OVN IJQPUÏUJDP
EFWFSTFS &N TVNB  JTTP TJHOJöDB OÍP QSPDVSBS NBJT B WFSEBEF EBT DPJTBT B
QBSUJSEFVNBBUJUVEFTBMJFOUF BRVFMBTBÓEBEBiMFJEP1BJw BNBSDBEP0DJEFOUF
KVEBJDPDSJTUÍP FTJNFNTFDPOUFOUBSDPNVNBWFSEBEFFOJHNÈUJDB TBÓEBEF
VNEFTWFMBNFOUPEBRVJMPRVFÏ EFTWBMBNFOUPTFNQSFJOBDBCBEP
&JTPRVFÏDPOHSVFOUFDPNBIPSJ[POUBMJEBEFEBiMFJEPTJSNÍPTwDVKPT
EJWFSTPT NFJPT EF DPNVOJDBÎÍP JOUFSBUJWPT  QSJODJQBMNFOUF B JOUFSOFU  TÍP
WFUPSFT QSJWJMFHJBEPT ² FTTB FTQÏDJF EF QPTUVSB JOUFMFDUVBM RVF BDFOUVB P
RVFTUJPOBNFOUP TPCSF B QSPCMFNÈUJDB DPNP VN DPOKVOUP EF QSPCMFNBT B
NBJT EP RVF BT TPMVÎÜFT QSPOUBT  QSØQSJBT EBT DFSUF[BT EPHNÈUJDBT  ² FTUB
BUJUVEF  FN DPOTPOÉODJB DPN B JORVJFUVEF FYJTUFODJBM  RVF QFSNJUF RVF TF
TJOUBCBUFSPJNQVMTPEBWJEBFEFSFDPOIFDFSBTMJOIBTEFGPSÎBEBTPDJBMJEBEF
DPOUFNQPSÉOFB OB RVBM P iQPMJUFÓTNP EPT WBMPSFTw  P QPMJDVMUVSBMJTNP  BT
JEFOUJöDBÎÜFT NÞMUJQMBT QBSFDFN QSFEPNJOBS ² FTUB USBOTGPSNBÎÍP EP
JOEJWÓEVPFNQFTTPBQMVSBM FTUBGSBHNFOUBÎÍPEBTJOTUJUVJÎÜFTIPNPHÐOFBT
FNUSJCPTIFUFSPHÐOFBT EFVNB3FQÞCMJDBVOBFJOEJWJTÓWFMFNVNNPTBJDP 
NBJTPVNFOPTDPFSFOUF EFDPNVOJEBEFT RVFEFWFOPTJODJUBSBQFSDPSSFSVN
DBNJOIPFQFOTBNFOUPBVEBDJPTP
"RVFMFRVFQFSNJUBDPNQSFFOEFS PRVFÏBDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBFTTFODJBMEB
QØTNPEFSOJEBEF EFRVFGPSNBPTQBSBEPYPTTFUPSOBNQBSBEJHNBT"ÏUJDB
RVFÏ GSFRVFOUFNFOUF DPOGVOEJEBDPNNPSBM Ï FUJNPMPHJDBNFOUF USJCVUÈSJB
EFVNiTJUFw MVHBS EFUFSNJOBEP&MBÏMJHBEBBVNMVHBSFËDPNVOJEBEFOB
RVBM WJWF &TUF iUFSSJUØSJPw QPEF TFS SFBM PV TJNCØMJDP WJSUVBM  0T iTJUFTw
DPNVOJUÈSJPTOB*OUFSOFUPUFTUFNVOIBN"ÏUJDBÏQBSUJDVMBS&MBQPEFTFS EF
WF[FNRVBOEP JNPSBMOPRVFUFNEFDJNFOUPDPNVNHSVQPEBEPFMBQPEF
JOGSJOHJS BT MFJT FTUBCFMFDJEBT &N PQPTJÎÍP B VNB NPSBM VOB  BT ÏUJDBT TÍP 
FTUSVUVSBMNFOUF QMVSBJT PRVFWBJDPMPDBSMIFVNQSPCMFNBEFBEFRVBÎÍP²P
GBUPEFBIBSNPOJBOÍPTFSNBJTBQSJPSJ NBTBQPTUFSJPSJ4FöDBSNPTDPNTVB
FUJNPMPHJB BEFPOUPMPHJBÏBFYQSFTTÍPFYBUBEPEFTMJ[BNFOUPEPDPOUSBUP
SBDJPOBMFQFOTBEPOPMPOHPUFSNP FNEJSFÎÍPBPQBDUP
&YJTUFBMHPEFTFMWBHFN EFQSJNJUJWPOPiTJUVBDJPOJTNPwEFPOUPMØHJDP
&TUBNPTMPOHFEBIBCJUVBMTJHOJöDBÎÍPSFNFUFOEPËTSFHSBTFEFWFSFTEFVNB
QSPöTTÍP"EFPOUPMPHJBDPOTJTUFFNBHJS TFNDPOTJEFSBÎÍPEPCFNFEPNBM 
DPNPVNiEFWFGB[ÐMPw EPKFJUPRVFDPOWÏNGB[ÐMPFNGVOÎÍPEBTJUVBÎÍP
QSFTFOUF²RVBOEPFYJTUFDPOGVTÍPEFQBMBWSBTRVFBTDPJTBTFPTTFOUJNFOUPT
UFOEFN JHVBMNFOUF BTFPCTDVSFDFS%BÓBOFDFTTJEBEFEFTBJSEBiBSNBEJMIB
TFNÉOUJDBwVUJMJ[BOEPVNBQBMBWSBQPSPVUSB1BSBEJ[ÐMPEFVNNPEPNBJT
GBNJMJBS ÏQSFDJTPQBSBSEFiKPHBSBSFJBOPTOPTTPTPMIPTw2VBOEPVNBQBMBWSB

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

OÍPFTUÈNBJTFNEJBDPNPWJWJEP FMBTFUPSOBEPHNÈUJDB DPNPBGBNPTB


DPOWFSTB öBEB EBT CVSPDSBDJBT FTUBMJOJTUBT  F QFSEF TVB QFSUJOÐODJB DPN P
TFOUJEP DJFOUÓöDP %F SFQFOUF  UPSOBTF JOBEFRVBEB & RVBOEP VNB QBMBWSB
FTUÈTBUVSBEB BDPJTBRVFFMBEFTJHOBUBNCÏNQFSEFDPOTJTUÐODJBFOÍPUFN
NBJTGPSÎBEFBUSBÎÍP
%BÓBOFDFTTJEBEF QBSBBMÏNEPTTFSNÜFTFODBOUBUØSJPT EFBKVTUBSBT
QBMBWSBT ËT DPJTBT UBJT DPNP TÍP 4BCFTF  EF MPOHB EBUB  RVFiP QÈTTBSP EF
.JOFSWBTØWPBEVSBOUFBOPJUFw%FGBUP ÏGSFRVFOUFOÍPTFWFSPRVF IÈNVJUP
UFNQP  KÈ DIFHPV ² TPCSF FTTF GPTTP RVF SFQPVTB P EFTBQBSFDJNFOUP EB
iDPNQFUÐODJBOBSSBUJWBwRVFÏBFTQFDJöDJEBEFEBTFMJUFTNPEFSOBTEBTRVBJT

TFEJWFSUFNBTEJTDVTTÜFTOP$BGÏEP$PNÏSDJPFPTEJWFSTPTi(VJHOPMTw EB
NÓEJB /B WFSEBEF  Ï RVBOEP BT QBMBWSBT OÍP TÍP NBJT QFSUJOFOUFT RVF Ï
JNQPTTÓWFMBQSFFOEFSBGPSÎBJOUFSJPSRVFBOJNBDFSUBDVMUVSBF QPJT BTGPSNBT
FYUFSJPSFTOBTRVBJTFTUBTFNBOJGFTUB%POEFBTVQFSöDJBMJEBEFEBNBJPSJBEBT
BOÈMJTFTKPSOBMÓTUJDBT QPMÓUJDBT VOJWFSTJUÈSJBTDPOUFNQPSÉOFBT5SBUBTFEFVN
QSPWJODJBMJTNPEFFTQÓSJUP JODBQB[EFWFSRVFPBOÙNJDPEFIPKFÏPDBOÙOJDP
EFBNBOIÍ
/BWFSEBEF OØTFTUBNPTEFJYBOEPVNBÏQPDBOBRVBMPIPNFNTF
DPOTJEFSBWBiNFTUSFFTFOIPSUBOUPEFTJRVBOUPEPVOJWFSTPw²QPDBOBRVBMTF
BDSFEJUBWBRVFTFGB[JBIJTUØSJB0VOJWFSTBMJTNP BNPSBMFPDPOUSBUPTPDJBMTÍP
BT QBMBWSBTDIBWF EF UBM TFOTJCJMJEBEF .BT FJT RVF  TVCSFQUJDJBNFOUF BT
WFSEBEFJSBT SFWPMVÎÜFT  DPNP TF TBCF  iBWBOÎBN B QBTTP EF QPNCBw  FTTF
PUJNJTNPTFTBUVSBFUFOEFBEFJYBSMVHBSËFNFSHÐODJBEFVNEFTUJOPBPRVBM
DPOWÏNTFBKVTUBS²EJTTPRVFTFUSBUBBÏUJDBTFBDPNPEBSFNVNiTJUFw TF
BDPNPEBSOFTUFMVHBS%BÓBFNFSHÐODJBEPTQBDUPTRVFUSBEV[FNPBTQFDUP
FNPDJPOBMEPMBÎPDÓWJDP1BDUPTFNPDJPOBJTEPTRVBJTBGPSNBQBSPYÓTUJDBÏP
iTJUVBDJPOJTNPEFPOUPMØHJDPw BRVFMFEBPQPSUVOJEBEF OPRVBMBJOUFOTJEBEF
EPNPNFOUPDPNQBSUJMIBEPDPNPTPVUSPTFBEVSBÎÍPEPJOTUBOUFTVCTUJUVFN
PQSPKFUPNPSBM MPOHFFQFSNBOFOUF FDPOÙNJDP QPMÓUJDP TJNCØMJDP QSØQSJP
EBNPEFSOJEBEF
²QSFDJTPJOTJTUJSOJTTP"NPSBMSFQPVTBTPCSFVNBMØHJDBEFQSPKFÎÍP
&MBÏ BMÏNEJTTP EFFTTÐODJBSFMJHJPTB SFMJHJÜFTTFNÓUJDBT SFNFUFOEPQBSB
VNBWJEBOPBMÏNEFTUBWJEBBRVJ BDJNBEFMB"NPSBMHPWFSOBEFVNNPEP
OPSNBUJWP F KVEJDBUJWP B USBOTJÎÍP FN EJSFÎÍP Ë WFSEBEFJSB WJEB  B EF VN
QBSBÓTPDFMFTUF KVEBJDPDSJTUÍP PVUFSSFTUSF BTVUPQJBTTPDJBMJTUBT &MBJOTUBMBB
JOKVOÎÍP EPiEFWFS TFSw F FTUJNVMB B DPOTDJÐODJB JOEJWJEVBM F TVB FYQSFTTÍP
öMPTØöDBPSBDJPOBMJTNP4VBFTTÐODJBÏ RVFSTBJCBNPTPVOÍP BFTDBUPMPHJB
"ÏUJDB QPSPVUSPMBEP TFBHBSSBTJNQMFTNFOUFBPiQPEFSTFSw GVOEBEPTPCSFB
FYQFSJÐODJBEBDPNVOJEBEF²DBVTBFFGFJUPEFVNBöMPTPöBEBFYJTUÐODJB 
BQPJBOEPTF OB FNQJSJB F OP DPODSFUP 2VBOUP BP iTJUVBDJPOJTNP
EFPOUPMØHJDPw  P BKVTUBNFOUP FN SFMBÎÍP BPT PVUSPT F BP NVOEP Ï 
FTTFODJBMNFOUF JOUSPKFUJWP
"MFJNPSBM BEFVNJOEJWÓEVPBVUÙOPNP DBQB[EFFMBCPSBSTVBQSØQSJB
MFJ BVUPOPNPT QFÎBFTTFODJBMEPDPOUSBUVBMJTNP ÏDFOUSÓGVHB"ÏUJDBEFTJPV

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

EFPOUPMPHJB BPDPOUSÈSJP ÏDFOUSÓQFUB%FVNNPEPIFUFSÙOPNP ÏP0VUSP


RVFMIFEJUBBMFJ00VUSPEBUSJCP P0VUSPEBOBUVSF[B P0VUSPEBEFJEBEFÏ
FTUF0VUSPRVFPGB[TFSPRVFÏ&MFBCTPSWFPNVOEPFP0VUSPEPHSVQP0V P
RVFEÈOBNFTNB FMF MJUFSBMNFOUF ÏBCTPSWJEPQFMPNVOEPFQFMPHSVQP%P
QBHBOJTNPEBEFFQFDPMPHZBPGBUPEFiTFQFSEFSwOPTBKVOUBNFOUPTGFTUJWPT Ï
VNBNFTNBMØHJDBRVFFTUÈFNDVSTPBRVFMBEBGVTÍP RVFSEJ[FSDPOGVTÍP
/ÍPTFSWFQBSBOBEBFTUJHNBUJ[ÈMBÏNFMIPSQFOTÈMB OFNRVFTFKB DPNPFN
DBTPTTJNJMBSFT QBSBFWJUBSPQJPS5BMWF[TFKBBTTJNRVFVNTPOIPDPMFUJWPTF
UPSOFQFTBEFMP&VKÈJOEJRVFJ FWBMFBQFOBTFEFTQSFHBSEPTQFOTBNFOUPT
DPNVOTTFRVJTFSNPTFOUFOEFSPRVF%VSLIFJNDIBNPVEFiDBSÈUFSFTTFODJBMw
EFVNBÏQPDB EFVNBTJUVBÎÍPPVTJNQMFTNFOUFVNBJEFPMPHJBTPDJBM
0 RVF Ï FTTFiDBSÈUFSw TFOÍP B NBSDB FTQFDÓöDB  BMHP DPNP B EJHJUBM
QSØQSJBBFTTFJOEJWÓEVPPVBVNBEFUFSNJOBEBDVMUVSB /ÍPDVTUBOBEBJSËSBJ[
EBT DPJTBT )È NPNFOUPT FN RVF FTTB SBEJDBMJEBEF QFSNJUF RVF
QFSNBOFÎBNPTBDPSEBEPT FNVNUFNQPEFBOFTUFTJBHFOFSBMJ[BEB²VNB
HBSBOUJBEFMVDJEF[RVBOEPUFOEFBQSFWBMFDFSPiQPMJUJDBNFOUFDPSSFUPw RVFKÈ
EÈTJOBJTEFEFTHBTUF&NQSJNFJSPMVHBS DPNPVNQSJODÓQJPGVOEBNFOUBM B
JOWFOÎÍP EP JOEJWÓEVP &V EJHPiJOWFOÎÍPw OP TFOUJEP EF VNB DPNVOJEBEF
PSJHJOÈSJBFNBUSJDJBMRVFUSPVYFËMV[ JOWFOJSF VNBFOUJEBEFTFQBSBEB VN
NVOEPiJOEJWJTÓWFMw  UPSOBOEPTF VNB TVCTUÉODJB BVUPTVTUFOUBEB &TUF Ï P
QSJODJQJVNJOEJWJEVBUJPOJTRVFBOPUØSJBJODVMUVSBDPOUJOVBBOFHMJHFODJBS PV
NFTNP OFHBS  NBT RVF DPOUJOVB B TFS P GVOEBNFOUP JSSFGVUÈWFM EB DVMUVSB
PDJEFOUBMPVNPEFSOB RVFÏBNFTNBDPJTB.BTWBNPT BJOEB NBJTGVOEP
5BMJOEJWJEVBMJTNP PRVFQPEFTFSRVBMJöDBEPEFFQJTUFNPMØHJDP QPEF
NVJUPCFNTFSDPOTJEFSBEPDPNPVNNPOPUFÓTNPEFUSBEJÎÍPTFNJUB1BSB
FTUFÞMUJNP BUSBWÏTEFWÈSJBTSFWFMBÎÜFTPVBMJBOÎBT GPSNBMJ[BEBTQPSBMHVOT
QSPGFUBT  EF BDPSEP DPN BT MFJT CÈTJDBT B SFTQFJUBS  B TBMWBÎÍP JOEJWJEVBM Ï
QPTTÓWFM ² FTUB B FYDFÎÍP EF RVF GBMFJ &TUBT SFMJHJÜFT SFQPVTBN TPCSF VNB
DPODFQÎÍP EJUB TPUFSJPMØHJDB DSFOÎB OP BMÏN  PSJHFN EF OVNFSPTPT NJUPT 
GBOUBTNBTFPVUSPTEFWBOFJPT DBEBVNEFMFTUFOEPEJSFJUPBVNBFUFSOJEBEF
EF CFBUJEVEF RVF OBEB P QFDBEP  B EJTGVOÎÍP  B JNQFSGFJÎÍP FUD  QPEFSÈ
FOUSBWBS "T WJBT QBSB BDFTTBS VN UBM QBSBÓTP TÍP  DFSUBNFOUF  WBSJÈWFJT "T
RVFSFMBTUFPMØHJDBTFBTOVNFSPTBTHVFSSBTSFMJHJPTBTFTUÍPBÓQBSBDPNQSPWBS
.BTPEFOPNJOBEPSDPNVNÏCFNPSFTQFJUPEFVNBMFJEBRVBMPJOEJWÓEVPÏ
DPOUÈWFMFRVFMIFBTTFHVSBSÈ EFVNNPEPJOFMVUÈWFM BTBMWBÎÍPFUFSOB
.BT QBSBJTTP ÏQSFDJTPRVFFMFUFOIBDPOTDJÐODJBEPTTFVTEFWFSFT²
QSFDJTP TPCSFUVEP RVFQBSBBMÏNEPTJOTUJOUPTFEBTQVMTÜFTBOJNBJT FTUF
JOEJWÓEVP QSJWJMFHJF P RVF P EJGFSFODJF  KVTUBNFOUF  EBT PVUSBT DSJBUVSBT B
DPOTDJÐODJB FN TVBT NÞMUJQMBT NPEBMJEBEFT DPHOJUJWBT /B WFSEBEF  Ï VNB
FTQFDJöDJEBEFEPNPOPUFÓTNPRVFJODJEFTPCSFBSB[ÍP&TUFQSPCMFNBUFN 
BRVJ  TVB MFHJUJNJEBEF %F GBUP  VNB EBT SBÓ[FT EPiEFWFS TFSw NPSBM Ï FTUB
QSPHSFTTJWBSBDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPEPTBHSBEP4BOUP"HPTUJOIP PRVFQPEFTFSEJUP
TFN HSBOEF BOBDSPOJTNP  Ï P GVOEBEPS EB NPEFSOJEBEF  EP NPOPUFÓTNP
CBTFBEPOBSB[ÍPi"SB[ÍPIVNBOBDPOEV[ËVOJEBEFw EJTTFFMF%FTTFNPEP P

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

BTQFDUPGBTDJOBOUFFQFSUVSCBEPSEPTBHSBEPÏDBOBMJ[BEP FYQVSHBEPEFTVBT
TPCSBT JEØMBUSBT UBNCÏN 0T HSBOEFT TJTUFNBT UFPMØHJDPT EP TÏDVMP 9***
QFSTFHVFNFTTBEPNFTUJDBÎÍPMFOUBRVFB3FGPSNB1SPUFTUBOUFJSÈDPOEV[JS
" BOÈMJTF EF .BY 8FCFS TPCSF B iSBDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP HFOFSBMJ[BEB EB
FYJTUÐODJBw  GVOEBNFOUP EP DÏMFCSF iEFTFODBOUBNFOUP EP NVOEPw
&OU[BVCFSVOHEFS8FMU ÏVNNPNFOUPJNQPSUBOUFEBFWPMVÎÍPEBJEFPMPHJB
NPEFSOBRVF EBUFPEJDFJBEBTiMV[FTSBEJDBJTwËi%FVTBEB3B[ÍPw WBJDIFHBSBP
SBDJPOBMJTNPTFN%FVT UFSNJOBOEPQPSTFJNQPSBPMPOHPEP9*9TÏDVMP"RVJ
QPEFNPT WFS RVF BMHVOT DIBNBSBN Bi.BSDIB 3FBM EP 1SPHSFTTPw  RVF  EF
%FTDBSUFT B %VSLIFJN  BTTFHVSPV P GVOEBNFOUP EB FEVDBÎÍP NPSBM EPT
JOEJWÓEVPT DVKP ÞMUJNP SFDVSTP Ï FTUJNVMBS  GPSUBMFDFS F BQFSGFJÎPBS PiMJWSF
BSCÓUSJPw6NMJWSFBSCÓUSJPRVFEFTUJMB BPMPOHPEPTTÏDVMPT VNGPSUFEFTFKPEF
QFSGFJÎÍP*TTPQPEFTFSBBTDFTFEPTBUMFUBTEBGÏPVBBCOFHBÎÍPEPiWBMPSEP
USBCBMIPw  QSPQPTUP QPS .BSY  F RVF PT IFSØJT EP SFBMJTNP TPWJÏUJDP
TJNCPMJ[BWBNNVJUPCFN&NUPEPTPTDBTPT PiUSBCBMIPTPCSFTJwPVPUSBCBMIP
TPCSFPNVOEPEFWFBKVEBSBTVQFSBSBBMJFOBÎÍPEFVNNVOEPDPSSPNQJEP
0NPSBMJTNPTFNJUBUFNVNBFTTÐODJBBQPDBMÓQUJDB&MFQPTUVMBVNB
SVQUVSB GVOEBNFOUBM FOUSF VN QSFTFOUF JNQFSGFJUP  BCKFUP F VN GVUVSP
SBEJPTP2VFSTFFYBDFSCFFNTVBTGPSNBTQBSPYÓTUJDBT DPNPPTGBOBUJTNPT
SFMJHJPTPTPVPTFWFOUPTSBDJTUBT PVTFEJMVBOBJEFPMPHJBDPOUFNQPSÉOFBEP
iQPMJUJDBNFOUF DPSSFUPw  B NPSBM OBTDF F TF DPOGPSUB FN VNB BNCJÐODJB
NJMFOBSJTUB.JMFOBSJTNPEJGVTP VUPQJTUBPVDBUBTUSPöTUB DPNVNBDPOTUBOUF
G B T D J O B Î Í P  Q F M B  E F T P S E F N  Ë  R V B M  D P O T D J F O U F  S F W P M V Î Í P  P V
JODPOTDJFOUFNFOUF SFMJHJÍP  BTQJSBTF  KÈ RVF Ï BTTJN RVF TF BMDBOÎBSÈ B
iQBSVTJBwPVBTPDJFEBEFQFSGFJUBQSPNFUJEBQFMBTUFPSJBTEFFNBODJQBÎÍPRVF
øPSFTDFSBNOPTÏDVMP9*9FEBTRVBJTTFQPEFOPUBSPDBSÈUFSSFMJHJPTP5BMWF[
TFKBJTTPRVFEÐFTUFBSNBMIVNPSBEPBPTDBWBMFJSPTEFiUSJTUFöHVSBwRVFTÍP
NPSBMJTUBTEFUPEPTPTUJQPT
1SPUBHPOJTUBT EF VNBiVUPQJB EP EFTBTUSFw RVF FTUÍP UFOUBOEP  TFN
TVDFTTP  FTDPOEFS BTQFDUPT GVUVSPT  NBT P DVKP QSJODJQBM NPUJWP Ï B
DPOEFOBÎÍPEPiNVOEPEFNJTÏSJBw PFTUJHNBEBTJNQMFTGFMJDJEBEFUBMWF[EP
TFS TJNQMFTNFOUF&VRVFSPEJ[FSDPNJTTPRVF QBSBVTBSVNUFNBSFDPSSFOUF
OBPCSBEPQTJDØMPHPEBTQSPGVOEF[BTRVFÏ+VOH FOBEPBOUSPQØMPHP(JMCFSU
%VSBOE  B USBEJÎÍP PDJEFOUBM Ï  FTUSVUVSBMNFOUF iFTRVJ[PGSÐOJDBw &MB DPSUB 
EJTTFDB EJTUJOHVF"TTJNDPNP%FVT JOUFNQPSFJMMP TFQBSPVBMV[EBTUSFWBT 
TFQBSPV DPNQMFUBNFOUF P DFSUP EP FSSBEP %JDPUPNJ[BÎÍP EP NVOEP
OBUVSF[BDVMUVSB DPSQPNFOUF NBUFSJBMJTNPFTQJSJUVBMJTNP F PVUSPT DPSUFT
UÍPBCTUSBUPTRVBOUPSBEJDBJT&TUBBUJUVEFiBOBMÓUJDBwEFTQFSUPVDFSUBNFOUFP
EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP DJFOUÓöDP F UFDOPMØHJDP  NBT P iFGFJUP QFSWFSTPw MFWPV 
UBNCÏN ËiEFWBTUBÎÍPEPNVOEPw EFRVFOØTTBCFNPTBTDPOTFRVÐODJBT
0RVFÏDFSUPÏRVFÏFTTBFTRVJ[PGSFOJBRVFÏDBVTBFFGFJUPEBQSØQSJB
SFEFOÎÍP EP TVKFJUP QBSB VNB öMPTPöB EB IJTUØSJB öOBMJ[BEB )JTUØSJB EB
TBMWBÎÍP JOEJWJEVBM F IJTUØSJB EB TBMWBÎÍP EB IVNBOJEBEF  QPOUVBOEP
BQPDBMJQTFTSFMJHJPTPTFPVQPMÓUJDPT RVFTÍPPGVOEBNFOUPJSSFGVUÈWFMEFUBM

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

USBEJÎÍPDVKPUSPQJTNPQSJNÈSJPTFDSJTUBMJ[BOBMØHJDBEPEFWFSTFS&YJTUFVNB
EJGFSFOÎB FTTFODJBM FOUSF i"T DPOöTTÜFTw  EF 4BOUP "HPTUJOIP  i0 DPOUSBUP
TPDJBMw EF+FBO+BDRVFT3PVTTFBVFPi.BOJGFTUPDPNVOJTUBw EF,BSM.BSY /ÍP 
SFBMNFOUF1PSRVFBPMBEPEFNVJUBTPVUSBTPCSBTEFDPOTUSVÎÍP BOUFTEPT
NVJUPT MJWSPT EFiEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP QFTTPBMw DVKP FTUJMP /PWB &SB UPSOPVTF
FTQFDJBMJTUB FMFTFOGBUJ[BNBOFDFTTJEBEFEBFNBODJQBÎÍPWJTËWJTVNiEBEPw
OBUVSBMEFQFOEFOEPEPRVFQPEFSJBTFS PRVFHPTUBSÓBNPTEFTBCFS
&TUBNPT CFN OP DFOUSP EFTUB OFDFTTJEBEF QBSBOPJDB EF NVEBS P
NVOEP *OKVOÎÍP QSØQSJB BP BUJWJTNP QSPNFUFJDP RVF TFS WJV EF
EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPDJFOUÓöDPUFØSJDPFUSJVOGPHMPCBMEFUÏDOJDB FTQFDJöDJEBEF
EP NPSBMJTNP BOHMPTBYÍP %FTEF B 3FGPSNB 1SPUFTUBOUF  FTUF ÞMUJNP  OB
WFSEBEF  BTTVNJV OP DFUJDJTNP .FEJUFSSÉOFP  QBSB P RVBM B NJTUVSB FOUSF B
SBDJPOBMJEBEF DMBSB F P QBHBOJTNP  MFWPV B FOUSFHBSTF BP NPNFOUP  B
DPOTJEFSBSOBUVSBMPOBUVSBM BBDFJUBSPJOFWJUÈWFM0RVF/JFU[TDIFDSJTUBMJ[PV
FN TFV iBNPS GBUJw .BT DPNP UPEBT BT DPJTBT IVNBOBT  B GPSÎB JOUFSOB
DPORVJTUBEPSB EFTUF QSPNFUFÓTNP UPSOPVTF QSPHSFTTJWBNFOUF SFUØSJDB EF
CPOT TFOUJNFOUPT  TFSNÜFT YBSPQPTPT  BEFRVBEB QBSB UPEPT PT MJWSPT EF
FEJöDBÎÍP NPSBM  FTDSJUPT QPS BRVFMFT RVF .BY 8FCFS DIBNPV  VN UBOUP
JSPOJDBNFOUF i,BUIFEFSQSPQIFUFOw
%BÓPBTQFDUPOPSNBUJWP KVEJDBUJWPRVFTFNQSFQSFWBMFDFOBQPTUVSB
NPSBM"DSÓUJDB FNTFVBTQFDUPUSJWJBMPVJOUFMFDUVBMNFOUFTPöTUJDBEP FTUÈ
DPOTUBOUFNFOUF FN BUJWJEBEF " DSÓUJDB RVF  OÍP FTRVFÎBNPT  FSB
PSJHJOBMNFOUF P JOTUSVNFOUP BUSBWÏT EP RVBM P KVJ[ QFTBWB BT WÈSJBT QBSUFT
FOWPMWJEBT F  BTTJN  BWBMJBWB PT TFVT WBMPSFT FTQFDÓöDPT " CBMBOÎB EP
NBHJTUSBEPBJOEBBUVBFNNVJUBTDBCFÎBT²UÍPWFSEBEFRVFNVJUBTWF[FTÏB
QSJPSJ DPNCBTFFNSFQSFTFOUBÎÜFTCBTUBOUFBCTUSBUBT JEFPMPHJBTFUÏSFBTPV
VUPQJBTHFOFSPTBT NBTOÍPNFOPTEFTFODBSOBEBT RVFTFDPNFUFNBTQJPSFT
QSÈUJDBTJORVJTJUPSJBJT FRVF DPNPTFTBCF TÍPQSPNVMHBEBTQBSBPiCFOFGÓDJPw
EFRVFNBTTPGSF.BT DPNPQBSBBTWÈSJBTJORVJTJÎÜFTFUSJCVOBJTQPQVMBSFT ÏB
BOTJFEBEF EJGVTB RVF FTUÈ OB PSJHFN OB QPTUVSB KVEJDBUJWB0V P NFEP FN
SFMBÎÍPBVNBWJEBRVF NVJUBTWF[FT TFBQSFTFOUBEFGPSNBFGFSWFTDFOUF
"P MPOHP EB IJTUØSJB  CFOGFJUPSFT EP iQPMJUJDBNFOUF DPSSFUPw
NBTDBSBSBNTPCVNNPSBMJTNPWFSEBEFJSPVNSFBMØEJPEBFYJTUÐODJB.FOUFT
BöBEBT DPNP 4DIFMFS PV /JFU[TDIF FOGBUJ[BSBN P DBSÈUFS NPSBM EFTTF
SFTTFOUJNFOUPBNBSHP/BWFSEBEF USBUBTFEFöHVSBTQBSPYÓTUJDBT NBTDVKB
DBSJDBUVSB Ï TFNQSF JOTUSVUJWB &N TVNB  B NPSBMJEBEF Ï VNB FTQÏDJF EF
SFQSPWBÎÍP DPOTUBOUF EP RVF Ï BQSFTFOUBEP DPN CBTF OP RVF OØT
SFQSFTFOUBNPT/ÍPÏJTTPRVFTFQPEFEFöOJS DPOGPSNF(PFUIF BRVFMFRVF 
DPOTUBOUFNFOUF FTUÈFNEFTBDPSEPDPNPNVOEPFNRVFFMFTFFODPOUSB
i%FS (FJTU EFS JNNFS WFSOFJOUw 0 FTQÓSJUP RVF TFNQSF EJ[ RVF OÍP
%FTBQSPWBÎÍPEFPSJHFNKVEBJDPDSJTUÍ SFGFSJOEPTFBPQSB[FSFNVNNVOEP
NFMIPS VNiNVOEPQBSBUSÈTwEFDPOUPSOPTJOEFöOJEPT NBTEPTRVBJTBGBMUB
EFEFöOJÎÍPNFTNBDSJBBOFDFTTJEBEFEFBMFJ BMDBOÎBOEPPBCVTPEFMFJTRVF
DPOIFDFNPT OBWJEBFDPOÙNJDB TPDJBM QPMÓUJDB QBHPVPQSFÎP

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

.BTDPOWÏN JHVBMNFOUF SFDPOIFDFSRVFTFBDBSJDBUVSBÏJOTUSVUJWB 


FMB TVCMJOIB  OP TFV FYDFTTP  TVB GSBHJMJEBEF %F GBUP  BT OVNFSPTBT
QSPDMBNBÎÜFTNPSBJTTÍP BDJNBEFUVEP FODBOUBÎÜFTPVGØSNVMBTNÈHJDBT
QSPOVODJBEBT  MJUVSHJDBNFOUF  B öN EF PCUFS FGFJUPT TPCSFOBUVSBJT 0
NPSBMJTNP BNCJFOUF TVCMJOIB  BP DPOUSÈSJP  RVF FTUBNPT BTTJTUJOEP È
TBUVSBÎÍPEBMØHJDBEPiEFWFSTFSwRVFNBSDPVBNPEFSOJEBEF/ÍPTFQPEF
BENJUJS RVF QBSB BMÏN EP MJOFBSJTNP IJTUØSJDP P UPSOBSTF IVNBOP TFKB
USJCVUÈSJPEFVNDJDMPQFSNBOFOUF PRVF"OBYJNBOESPDIBNBWBHFOFTJTLBJ
QIUIPSB HÐOFTFFEFDMÓOJP &NTVNB RVFEFQPJTEPDJDMPEPVOJWFSTBMJTNP
NPSBM  BEWÏN P EP QBSUJDVMBSJTNP ÏUJDP  )JQØUFTF RVF P SFUPSOP EPT
GFOÙNFOPT ÏUJDPT  EBT FYBDFSCBÎÜFT USJCBJT  EBT NÞMUJQMBT SFJWJOEJDBÎÜFT
MPDBMJTUBT DPJTBTEBTRVBJTBBUVBMJEBEFOÍPÏBWBSB QBSFDFDPSSPCPSBS
$POUSBPNJMFOBSJTNPNPSBMJTUB TPCSFPRVBMFVJOEJRVFJRVFPBTQFDUP
FODBOUBUØSJP NBSDBWB TFV öN  DPOWÏN FTUBSNPT BUFOUPT B VNB BNCJÐODJB
EJGVTBRVFFOGBUJ[BPEFTBQFHP1BSBEPYPTFBGBTUBSEPEJTUBOUFQBSBTFBOFYBS
B VN MVHBS DPNQBSUJMIBEP DPN PVUSPT "KVTUBSTF P NFMIPS QPTTÓWFM OFTUF
NVOEP .JTUÏSJP EB QSPYFNJB 0 MVHBS GB[ P FMP  FJT P RVF QPEF SFTVNJS B
QFSUJOÐODJBEPBTQFDUPQSPTQFDUJWPEBÏUJDB&YJTUFVNBöHVSBNJTUFSJPTBEB
RVBMGBMB4ÍP1BVMPOB‹FQÓTUPMBBPT5FTTBMÙOJDPTRVFÏBEF,BUFDIPO BRVFMF
RVFJNQFEFBWJOEBEPBOUJDSJTUPFRVFQFSNJUFDPNRVFTFFWJUFPBQPDBMJQTF
&JTPRVFÏQBSBEPYBMOBWJTÍPFTDBUPMØHJDB FTQFDÓöDBEBUSBEJÎÍPDSJTUÍ0RVF
OÍP DFTTB EF DPMPDBS QSPCMFNBT BPT EJWFSTPT DPNFOUBSJTUBT EBT FQÓTUPMBT
QBVMJOBT
0 KVSJTUB $BSM 4DINJUU GB[ EFTTB öHVSB VN VTP KVEJDJPTP OB TVB MVUB
DPOUSBBMØHJDBEPiEFWFSTFSw%FNJOIBQBSUF FVQFOTPRVFTFQPEFJOUFSQSFUBS
BöHVSBEF,BUFDIPODPNPBNFUÈGPSBEPiTJNwËWJEB$POUSÈSJPBPiOÍPwEB
DSÓUJDB  QSØQSJB EB NPSBM  P BQFHP BP QSB[FS EF TFS TF BQSFTFOUB DPNP VNB
JSSFGSFÈWFMBöSNBÎÍPEBWJEBDPNPFMBÏUBMDPNBQSFTFOUBFOÍPDPNPFMBTF
SFQSFTFOUB"ÏUJDB UBOUPOBTVBFTTÐODJBRVBOUPOPRVFFMBÏWJWJEB OPEJBB
EJB ÏBFYQSFTTÍPEFVNQVSPJNBOFOUJTNPPV QBSBEJ[FSEFPVUSBGPSNB EF
VNIFEPOJTNPEJGVTP"USBWÏTEBÏUJDB DPNFÎBVNNPNFOUPDSVDJBM VNHJSP
TPCSFTJNFTNPBPMPOHPEPUFNQP0ÓOEJDFEFVNDJDMPRVFFTUÈUFSNJOBOEPF
P JOÓDJP EF PVUSP FN HFTUBÎÍP 3FMBUBTF RVF )FHFM EJBOUF EBT NPOUBOIBT
TVÓÎBTOÍPBENJUJBEJ[FSi²BTTJNw
#BOBMJEBEF PV BNBSHB TBCFEPSJB Ï UVEP RVF QSFDJTBNPT UFS QBSB
BTTVNJSNPTBDPSBHFNJOUFMFDUVBMEFOPNFBSBTDPJTBTDPNPFMBTTÍP"ÏUJDB 
QPJT  SFøFUF B FYQFSJÐODJB DPODSFUB DVN DSFTDFSF  P RVF DSFTDF DPN /FTUF
TFOUJEP BÏUJDBFYQSJNFBFTTÐODJBEPWJWFSKVOUPQPQVMBS²PRVF)ÚMEFSMJO
DIBNBWBBFTTFODJBMJOUJNJEBEFi*OOJHLFJUw5BOUPTVBSFBMJEBEFJOUFSJPSRVBOUP

PRVFBTTFHVSBBWJEBDPNVOJUÈSJBDPNPTPVUSPT 0RVFBÏUJDBEFTDPCSFÏRVF
BP MBEP EPiDPOTUSVÓEPw FYJTUF PiEBEPw /P GVOEBNFOUP EP QPEFS SBDJPOBM 
FYJTUFBQPUÐODJBFNPDJPOBM1PSNBJTQBSBEPYBMRVFQPTTBQBSFDFS PSFUPSOP
EB ÏUJDB Ï  TF FTUBNPT EF BDPSEP DPN B QBMBWSB OP TFV TFOUJEP QMFOP  VNB
WFSEBEFJSBJOPWBÎÍP PVTFKB RVFJOWFOUPVBWJEB USB[FOEPËMV[ JOWFOJSF P

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

RVFFTUÈFOSBJ[BEPOBNFNØSJBBOUJHBJTUPOPTTVHFSFQFOTBSPBUVBMBQBSUJS
EPTVCTUBODJBM
&ORVBOUP B NPSBM Ï VNB DPSSJEB GSFOÏUJDB QBSB B WJEB BQØT B NPSUF
UFSSFTUSFPVDFMFTUJBM BEB$JEBEFEF%FVTPVBTPDJFEBEFQFSGFJUB BÏUJDBÏ
VN MFOUP SFUPSOP Ë PSJHFN  BPiBSDBJDPw  DBSBDUFSJ[BOEP P RVF Ï P QSJNFJSP 
GVOEBNFOUBM"CBTFPSJHJOBMEPFTUBSKVOUP²UJDBRVFFYQSFTTBBFYQFSJÐODJB
QSJNPSEJBMEPiEBEPNVOEBOPw'BWPSFDFBJOUVJÎÍP&MBDPNQMFNFOUBBSB[ÍP
QFMP TFOTÓWFM 0V NFMIPS  TFOTJCJMJ[B B SB[ÍP 5VEP JTTP QPEF BKVEBS B
DPNQSFFOEFS P NFEP EB JOUFMMJHFOUTJB EJBOUF EBiöMPTPöB EF WJEBw  RVF  EF
/JFU[TDIF B #FSHTPO  EFTUBDPV B FNQBUJB  B JOUVJÎÍP  B QSFWBMÐODJB EBT
FNPÎÜFT F EBT QBJYÜFT DPNVOT  DPOTJEFSBEBT VMUSBQBTTBEBT  NBT RVF
BQBSFDFN OBT NÞMUJQMBT NBOJGFTUBÎÜFT EF VN FNPDJPOBM DBEB WF[ NBJT
QSFTFOUF"ÏUJDBDPNQSFFOEJEBBTTJNFTUÈMPOHFEFVNBNPSBMUSBOTDFOEFOUF 
SFQPVTBOEPOVNWBMPSÞOJDP PNPOPUFÓTNP
.BTPDPOUSÈSJP CBTFBEBOPQSFTFOUF FMBÏBPNFTNPUFNQPJNBOFOUF
FQPMJUFÓTUB²DPNJTTPRVFTFQPEFGBMBSEFVNJNPSBMJTNPÏUJDPPCTFSWÈWFMOBT
JOÞNFSBTQSÈUJDBTKVWFOJTF HFOFSJDBNFOUF OPRVFTFQPEF NFUBöTJDBNFOUF 
DIBNBSEFiUSJCPTQØTNPEFSOBTw0RVFQSFWBMFDFOFMBTÏPGBUPEFTFWJWFS
KVOUP VNB FYQFSJÐODJB DPMFUJWB  EF WJCSBS FN HSVQP ² P RVF PT TPDJØMPHPT
DIBNBN EF FNQBUJB PV TJOUPOJB 4ÍP FTUBT FYQSFTTÜFT RVF USBEV[FN  QBSB
BMÏNEPGFDIBNFOUPOBDPOTDJÐODJBJOEJWJEVBM BQVMTÍPBOJNBMEFWJWFS EF
QBSUJDJQBS NBHJDBNFOUF  NJTUJDBNFOUF P RVF %VSLIFJN EFOPNJOBWB
iFGFSWFTDÐODJBTDPNVOJUÈSJBTw1PEFTF OFTTFTFOUJEP GBMBSEFVNBiÏUJDBEB
FTUÏUJDBw  EF VN MBÎP  EF VN DJNFOUP B QBSUJS EBT FNPÎÜFT PV EBT QBJYÜFT
DPNQBSUJMIBEBT ² UÍP WFSEBEF RVF iFNQBUJBw PV iIBSNPOJBw QPEFN TFS
FODPOUSBEBTFNVNBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFEFFWFOUPTGFTUJWPT FNPDBTJÜFTMÞEJDBTF
PVUSBT GBOUBTJBT DPMFUJWBT TPCSF BT RVBJT BT OPUÓDJBT GPSOFDFN FYFNQMPT FN
BCVOEÉODJB
²UJDB F FTUÏUJDB "MHVOT FTQÓSJUPT NBMIVNPSBEPT OÍP EFJYBN EF
WJUVQFSBSDPOUSBPTVSHJNFOUPEFVNiIPNPGFTUJWVTw&FTRVFDFOEPTFRVFUBM
DPOKVOÎÍP FTUBWB OB PSJHFN EBT HSBOEFT DVMUVSBT  DPNP OP 2VBUUSPDFOUP
JUBMJBOP F OB 'SBOÎB SFOBTDFOUJTUB /PUFNPT RVF TF P IPNP TBQJFOT GPJ P
GVOEBNFOUP EP QSPHSFTTJTNP PDJEFOUBM  P IPNP MVEFOT FOGBUJ[B VNB
DPODFQÎÍPNBJTDPNQMFYBEBIVNBOJEBEF BEBQSPHSFTTJWJEBEF RVFJNQMJDBB
DPOUSJCVJÎÍPEPQBTTBEPFEBUSBEJÎÍP&NSFTVNP BTGPSNBTBSDBJDBT PVTFKB 
PSJHJOBJT EF UPEP WJWFSKVOUP ² EFTTB GPSNB RVF QPEFNPT FOUFOEFS FTUF
JOFHÈWFM IFEPOJTNP QPQVMBS  GBMBOEP OB NFMIPS EBT IJQØUFTFT EF VN CPN
TFOTPÏUJDPUBMWF[BWJEBOÍPWBMFOBEB NBTOBEBWBMFBWJEB0RVFUSBEV[ BP
NFTNPUFNQP PGBUPEFRVFPQPWPÏBSUJTUB DSJBEPSEFTVBWJEB
"3FQÞCMJDBOÍPÏVNBFJOEJWJTÓWFM SFQPVTBOEPDPNCBTFFNVNÞOJDP
WBMPS FN GPSNB EF VN FTQÓSJUP EF TFSJFEBEF "iSFTQVCMJDBw Ï  JTUP TJN  VN
NPTBJDP NVMUJGBDFUBEP  OP RVBM WÈSJPT WBMPSFT  JODMVJOEP P QSB[FS EF TFS 
QPEFN PDVQBS VN MVHBS FTQFDJBM "TTJN  FN DPOUSBTUF BP VUJMJUBSJTNP RVF
QSFWBMFDFV EVSBOUF UPEB B NPEFSOJEBEF  F DVKB FYQSFTTÍP NPSBM GPJ

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

DPNQMFUBEB BiDPJTBQÞCMJDBwFODPOUSB BUSBWÏTEBÏUJDB BJNQPSUÉODJBEPJOÞUJM


P QSFÎP EBT DPJTBT TFN QSFÎP " JNQPSUÉODJB EP GSÓWPMP  EP TVQÏSøVP  EB
OFDFTTJEBEFEPMVYP FYQSFTTBOEPQBSBBBSJTUPDSBDJBQPQVMBSPEFTFKPEPOÍP
GVODJPOBM"ÏUJDB OPRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPBPTFVJNPSBMJTNP ÏBFYQSFTTÍPEFVNB
TPDJFEBEF BCFSUB  QPMJDVMUVSBM  SFMBUJWJTUB 4PDJFEBEF OB RVBM P DIPRVF EPT
WBMPSFT Ï HBSBOUJB EF VNB IBSNPOJB DPOøJUVBM *TTP RVFS EJ[FS OÍP VNB
IBSNPOJB B QSJPSJ  QVSBNFOUF JOUFMFDUVBM F VN QPVDP BCTUSBUB  BRVFMB EP
DPOUSBUPTPDJBM FTJNVNBIBSNPOJBBQPTUFSJPSJ BRVFMBDPODSFUBFRVFJOUFHSB
BJOUFJSF[BEBTFTQFDJöDJEBEFTIVNBOBT IBSNPOJBTBÓEBEPQBDUPFNPDJPOBM
&TUBGVOÎÍPEFiSFMJHBÎÍPwEBÏUJDB RVFÏVNFOSBJ[BNFOUPEJOÉNJDP 
QPEFBKVEBSBDPNQSFFOEFSRVF QBSBBMÏNEPTQPEFSFTFGÐNFSPT TFKBNFMFT
FDPOÙNJDPT QPMÓUJDPT TPDJBJTPVTJNCØMJDPT FYJTUFVNBQPUÐODJBEFCBTFRVF
QFSEVSBOPUFNQP"QPUÐODJBÏUJDBTBCFEJTTP BUSBWÏTEFVNiDPOIFDJNFOUP
JODPSQPSBEPw RVFPQPEFSNPSBMÏUFNQPSÈSJPFUJMMVEUSBOTJUJTUPUBNCÏN
QBTTBSȲOFTUFTFOUJEPRVFBUFPMPHJBDBUØMJDBTFNQSFFOGBUJ[PVRVFBJHSFKB
IJFSÈSRVJDBJOTUJUVDJPOBM WJTÓWFM UJOIBMFHJUJNJEBEF FNSFGFSÐODJBBPiDPSQP
NÓTUJDPwFTQFDÓöDPEBDPNVOJEBEFEBHSBÎB$PNVOJEBEFJNBUFSJBM NBTOÍP
NFOPT SFBM F GPSNBOEP FN TFV TFOUJEP FTDVMUVSBM  B BMNB  JTUP Ï  P OÞDMFP
DFOUSBMEBBSRVJUFUÙOJDBFDMFTJBM%BNFTNBGPSNBPJEFBMJTNPBMFNÍP FNTFV
NPNFOUP FGFSWFTDFOUF  WFSÈ PT KPWFOT )FHFM  4DIFMMJOH F )ÚMEFSMJO PQPS Ë
JHSFKB WJTÓWFM B JHSFKB JOWJTÓWFM  FTUB ÞMUJNB GPSOFDFOEP B CBTF  JSSFGVUÈWFM 
EBRVFMB
&YJTUF BMHVNB DPJTB EF QBHÍ OB ÏUJDB QFMP GBUP EF JNQMJDBS VNB
FYQFSJÐODJBDPNVNOFTUFNVOEPBRVJ/PWBFFUFSOB TBCFEPSJB  BRVFMBEB
FDPTPöB RVFOPTFOTJOBBBQSFDJBSBQFSUJOÐODJBEPBTQFDUPQSPTQFDUJWP"JOEB
OP RVF EJ[ SFTQFJUP Ë ÏUJDB  FMB TF DPOUFOUB DPN B KVTUF[B " QBSUJS EF VN
FOSBJ[BNFOUP FN VN EFUFSNJOBEP MVHBS iTJUFw  SFBM F WJSUVBM P CBJSSP PV
*OUFSOFU  FMB TF VTB QBSB GBWPSFDFS P iQPEFS TFSw &MB Ï QBSUJDVMBS  MPDBM F
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF PCTFSWÈWFM OB NVMUJQMJDJEBEF EF BKVOUBNFOUPT QØT
NPEFSOPT NVTJDBJT  SFMJHJPTPT  FTQPSUJWPT  OPT RVBJT P MÞEJDP F P GFTUJWP
PDVQBNVNMVHBSEFEFTUBRVF"ÏUJDBÏDBVTBFFGFJUPEBTWJCSBÎÜFTDPNVOT 
EBTQBJYÜFTFFNPÎÜFTDPMFUJWBT5PEBTFTUBTDPJTBTSFNFUFNBPRVFTFQPEF
EFOPNJOBSVNBiÏUJDBEBFTUÏUJDBw2VBOUPËTEFPOUPMPHJBT FMBTTFEFCSVÎBN
TPCSF B JNQPSUÉODJB EBT TJUVBÎÜFT WJWJEBT OP DPUJEJBOP 5PEBT FTUBT DPJTBT
BOØEJOBT GBNJMJBSFT TJUVBÎÜFTQSØQSJBTEBWJEBDPUJEJBOBRVFPTFTQÓSJUPTTÏSJPT
SFMFHBNËSVCSJDBEPOÍPFTTFODJBM

/PUBT

4PDJØMPHPFQSPGFTTPSEB4PSCPOOFFNFNCSPEP*OTUJUVUP6OJWFSTJUÈSJPEB'SBOÎB&NBJM
NJDIFM!NBòFTPMJPSH

&TUFUFYUPEF.JDIFM.BòFTPMJGPJFMBCPSBEPQBSBVNTFNJOÈSJPOB4PSCPOOF FN F
RVFFMF HFOUJMNFOUF DFEFVEVSBOUFNFVQØTEPVUPSBEPOPHSVQPEFQFTRVJTBTEJSJHJEP
QPS FMF  P $&"2 $FOUSF E}&UVEF TVS M}"DUVFM FU MF 2VPUJEJFO  FN 1BSJT $BCF PVUSB
PCTFSWBÎÍPBWFSTÍPBRVJUSBEV[JEBOÍPÏJOUFHSBM NBTTFQSPDVSPVNBOUFSVNBDPFSÐODJB

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO


.PSBM ÏUJDB EFPOUPMPHJB%PQBSBEPYPBPQBSBEJHNB

FTUJMÓTUJDBFGPSNBMOBUSBOTJÎÍPFOUSFVNQBSÈHSBGPFPVUSP TFRVÐODJBFTTBRVF BMHVNBT


WF[FT  OÍP SFTQFJUB B GPSNB PSJHJOBM EP UFYUP 5SBEVÎÍP &EVBSEP 1PSUBOPWB #BSSPT
1/1%$"1&411(FN$JÐODJBT4PDJBJT6OJTJOPT "VUPSEFi.BòFTPMJFOUSFBDJÐODJBBMFHSF
FPEFNBTJBEPIVNBOP"QSPYJNBÎÜFTEFVNBTPDJPMPHJBBOBSRVJTUBw  5SBEVUPSEF
i4PDJPMPHJBEPJNBHJOÈSJPw -&(304 1FUBM1PSUPBMFHSFTVMJOB  

5PNÈTEF"RVJOP 4VNNB5IFPMPHJDB *F** RVFTUÍP BSUB

3FGFSFTFBVNQFSTPOBHFNEFGBOUPDIFNVJUPQPQVMBSOB'SBOÎB

$G.BSUJO)FJEFHHFS "QQSPDIFEF)ÚMEFSMJO (BMMJNBSE  Q

3FDFCJEPFNTFUFNCSPEF
"QSPWBEPFNEF[FNCSPEF

3FWJTUB/61&. $BNQP.PVSÍP W O KBOKVO



You might also like