Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Museum Definition and Its Cretique
Museum Definition and Its Cretique
1. There should be collections of objects and the center of a museum is these collections of
tangible objects.
2. They (the tangible objects) should be exhibited on a permanent basis.
3. They (museums) should be accessible to the general public.
4. The objects collected in the museum shall have a value of cultural, artistic, archeological,
or of some kind.
In the later times developments a museum definition includes: -
1. The institutions that are considered as a museum shall be a non-profit making institute.
2. They should be purpose or mission driven, and need only to serve their mission/ goal.
In Malaro’s museum definition we find one unique characteristic, and that is the “utilization
of a professional stuff” in the museum is mandatory.
To Margaret Birtley the fore mentioned definitions in general and that of the ICOM’s
definition in particular have its own limitations. Her words are worth quoting.
The ICOM museum definition has several limitations. The term ‘non-profit
making’ requires the specialized understanding of the meaning of ‘profit’. The
phrase ‘in the service of society and of its development’ carries ambiguities, and
implies that museums are retroactive rather than pro-active.
The focus on ‘study, education, and enjoyment’ suggests that museums that are the
custodians of distressing materials (such as prison or holocaust museums) must
nevertheless create an enjoyable experience for their visitors.
Elaborating her argument Margaret continues,
The ICOM definition of a museum is rather dreary. If, as a museum practitioner,
you are asked to define museum for the benefit of a local politician, or for a
simple friend, you know precisely how fast the eyes of your audience glaze over as
you labor through the first half of the ICOM definition. ‘A non-profit making,
permanent institution, in the service of society and of its development, and open to
the public’ could be a hospital, a patents office or a police station … the ICOM
definition was actually a hindrance to our advocacy of museums to politicians,
sponsors and community partners.
[Margaret: 2005:5]
Margaret’s apprehension on the ICOM’s museum definition is worth sharing. Indeed, the ICOM
museum definition seemed to be written in the days before the Internet had given us the
possibility of virtual museums and before the importance of the intangible heritage had been
recognized.
Thus, in the ICOM definition phrases like ‘ a permanent institution’, ‘ in a permanent basis’, and
‘ the tangible objects of the people’ would construct problems, and do not reflect on the non-
western experience of culture and museum.