Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What Critics Say
What Critics Say
He wrote many
novels and short stories and his works are held in very high regard in the literature world.
However, some of his books have brought forth much controversy. While some authors view him
as the foundation for modern American literature, one of his books, The Adventures of
Huckleberry Finn, is one of the most banned books from schools. Many of Mark Twain’s
characters, settings, and plots are unlike any other. Critics have many different opinions about the
writing of Twain, but it’s clear that Twain has incredible stories that leave much to be analyzed
and discovered.
The structure of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is a topic that is often under analysis by
critics. Many people say that this novel is either a sequence of Tom Sawyer making mistakes and
later maturing, or there isn’t much structure. Hamlin Hill puts it this way, “These then are the
two poles: that Tom Sawyer has a narrative plan and exhibits what was for Twain a high degree
of literary craftsmanship; or that it is a ragbag of memories, thrown together at random with little
or no thought to order or structure” (Hill 379). This is an important thing to try and determine
because it gives us deeper insight into Twain’s mind as a writer. Indubitably, structure is one of
the most important aspects of a story, so no matter what “pole” Twain’s writing falls to, it still
creates an excellent setup for an even more excellent novel. Hill goes on to say, “The author’s
own statements suggested that he wrote those memories of his childhood which came to mind,
waited until he remembered some more, and then added them to his manuscript” (Hill 384). To
summarize, Hill is claiming that Twain didn’t have so much a structure as he had a hodgepodge
of memories thrown together to emphasize nostalgia and childhood. Nonetheless, Twain’s novel
accomplishes his exact goal — to make adult readers feel like children again, through his unique
structure.
While the structure of a story is important to the novel, many people would argue that
characters are even more important. Mark Twain does an excellent job with character
development and character building in his novels. In The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, Twain
shows us just how well he can portray a child through his character of Tom Sawyer. Forrest
Robinson shows us just how much thought went into creating this character, “Full self-awareness
on this score would be fatal to his gamesmanship, for it would be accompanied by the onset of
guilt, and the erosion of confidence and manipulative élan” (Robinson 24). In a sense, Tom
Sawyer has to be portrayed as an arrogant person so that he could believably pull off the stunts
that Twain needed him to do. It’s clear that Twain’s characters weren’t just created randomly on a
whim, but they were thoughtfully crafted and every part of them is for the bigger picture of the
novel. It’s because of this, people are so inclined to read Twain’s books and easily fall in love
with the characters, “…Tom will continue to occupy center stage before an audience of
breathlessly attentive and willingly “sold” admirers” (Robinson 24). Robinson makes it clear that
Twain created the character Tom Sawyer in the way he did, so readers could feel a deeper
connection with him. This, ultimately leading to Twain’s novels making a large impact on the
reader’s lives.
race and social inequality. Daniel Traber claims, “One of the most frequently examined, indeed
celebrated, themes in Huckleberry Finn studies has been Mark Twain’s advocacy of a
achieved by living outside the social institutions of “sivilization”” (Traber 24). Huck Finn goes
against the social norms during that time period by freeing a slave named Jim. This was very
controversial at the time and some would argue that through this, Mark Twain was trying to
make a point. Traber goes on to say, “Through Huck-the-narrator, Twain reminds readers that
social control is always present but never total” (Traber 42). Traber is suggesting that Twain
wanted to show the public that no matter what people did there would always be some form of
social control in society. This is clearly shown in Huckleberry Finn, because although Huck is
able to help his friend Jim, it doesn’t come without consequences. Twain uses the character of
One thing that’s excellent about many of Mark Twain’s writings is his inclusion of
morals. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is no exception to this, and many people would
argue that this novel includes many valuable life lessons. When discussing this idea, Gilbert
Rubenstein claims that one of the lessons Mark Twain is trying to teach us is the idea that,
“Human beings are superior to one another only in the goodness of their hearts and in their love
for people” (Rubenstein 76). The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn includes a large theme of
friendship in the face of adversity and choosing love over hate. This was a message a lot of
people needed to hear during the time this book was written, and Mark Twain used his novel to
do this. Rubenstein continues this idea when he claims, “But meanwhile it can surely be said that
the moral structure of the book alone teaches timeless lessons to all humanity” (Rubenstein).
Twain’s novels are much more than an entertaining book, they also teach valuable life lessons to
It is clear that Mark Twain pays great attention to detail in what he writes. His books
include excellent characterization, morals and life lessons, and intentional structure. Ultimately
it’s because of all these things that Mark Twain is known as one of the best American authors
ever by some people. Mark Twain makes it easy for people to read his writings over and over