Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(a) Scalability (including proportionality to the standard’s relative impact on different stakeholders).
(b) Relevance (through recognizing and responding to emerging issues, changes in business or public practice environments,
developments in accounting practices, or changes in technology).
(c) Comprehensiveness (through limiting the extent to which there are exceptions to the principles set out).
(d) Clarity and conciseness (to enhance understandability and minimize the likelihood of differing interpretations).
(e) Implementability and ability of being consistently applied and globally operable.
(g) Coherence (with the overall body of ISAs, for example, by building appropriately on the relevant requirements of foundational standards
(e.g., ISA 315 (Revised 2019) 2 and ISA 330). 3
1
Qualitative characteristics from those outlined in paragraph 26 of the project proposal and those that arose as the development work progressed. Also see the Public Interest
Framework (Section “What qualitative characteristics should the standards exhibit?”) published by the Monitoring Group in July 2020 (as part of their report “Strengthening the
International Audit and Ethics Standard-Setting System”).
2
ISA 315 (Revised 2019), Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement
3
ISA 330, The Auditor’s Responses to Assessed Risks
Page 1 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
A. Project Objective: Clarify the role and responsibilities of the auditor for fraud in an audit of financial statements.
A.1: Introductory Paragraphs in ISA 240 6 Paras. 1– • Reordered the introductory paragraphs (including • Clarity and
– Emphasis on the Auditor’s 11, A1–A12 related application material) to refer to the conciseness
Responsibilities responsibilities of the auditor before the
• Comprehensiveness
responsibilities of management and TCWG to
Enhance and clarify the introductory
describe first the role of the auditor related to fraud in • Enforceability
paragraphs in ISA 240 to emphasize the
an audit of financial statements, recognizing that this
auditor’s responsibilities regarding fraud,
is an auditing standard.
including:
• Moved the inherent limitations (including related
• Considering changes and
application material) of an audit out of the
enhancements made by others in
“Responsibilities of the Auditor” into the new “Key
different jurisdictions in their equivalent
Concepts of this ISA” section in ED-240. The intent
of ISA 240 to reduce the ambiguity
was to decouple descriptions about inherent
between the inherent limitations of an
limitations of the audit and the auditor’s
audit and the auditor’s responsibilities
responsibilities because the inherent limitations do
for fraud in an audit of financial
not diminish the auditor’s responsibility to plan and
statements.
perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance
• Considering whether to provide about whether the financial statements as a whole
context for the auditor’s responsibilities are free from material misstatement due to fraud.
by explaining the responsibilities of
others in the financial reporting
ecosystem (relevant to the financial
statement audit) within the introductory
4
Proposed actions in the Project Proposal related to the development of non-authoritative guidance have been greyed out as these have not been addressed in ED-240.
5
The qualitative standard-setting characteristics listed are those that were at the forefront, or of most relevance, when determining how to address each proposed action.
6
ISA 240, The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements
Page 2 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
paragraphs.
A.2: Application Material – Definition of Paras. • Added application material that: • Clarity and
Fraud A18–A20 conciseness
o Clarifies the relationship of fraud with
Enhance application material to clarify how corruption, bribery and money laundering. • Coherence
concepts such as bribery and corruption, and
o Indicates that certain laws, regulations or
money laundering, relate to the definition of
aspects of relevant ethical requirements
fraud for purposes of an audit of financial
dealing with corruption, bribery or money
statements, including consideration of the
laundering may be relevant to the auditor’s
most appropriate standard for this application
responsibilities to consider laws and
material (i.e., ISA 240 or ISA 250
regulations in an audit of financial statements
(Revised)). 7
in accordance with ISA 250 (Revised).
A.3: Requirements and Application Paras. 22– • Added requirements that expand on relevant • Scalability
Material – Specialized Skills 24, A33– requirements in ISA 220 (Revised), for the
• Relevance
A38 engagement partner to:
Consider enhancing requirements and
• Clarity and
application material in ISA 240 on the need o Determine that members of engagement team
conciseness
for specialized skills (including forensic collectively have the appropriate competence
skills): and capabilities, including appropriate
specialized skills or knowledge to perform risk
• Consider a new requirement and
assessment procedures, identify and assess
enhanced application material for
7
ISA 250 (Revised), Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements
Page 3 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
8
ISA 220 (Revised), Quality Management for An Audit of Financial Statements
Page 4 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B. Project Objective: Promote consistent behavior and facilitate effective responses to identified risks of material misstatement due to
fraud through strengthening ISA 240 to establish more robust requirements and enhance and clarify application material where necessary.
B.4: Requirements and Application Paras. 26– • Enhanced or added requirements and application • Scalability
Material – Identifying and Assessing 42, A44– material to incorporate recent changes in ISA 315
• Relevance
Risks of Material Misstatement A113 (Revised 2019) to make fraud risk identification and
assessment more robust, including requirements • Comprehensiveness
Enhance and clarify requirements and
describing the auditor’s explicit or specific fraud • Implementability
application material in ISA 240 to incorporate
considerations when obtaining an understanding of
recent changes in ISA 315 (Revised 2019) to • Coherence
the:
make fraud risk identification and
assessment more robust, including: o Entity and its environment, and the applicable
financial reporting framework; and
• Developing explicit fraud
considerations in risk assessment o The components of the entity’s system of
procedures. internal control, including the control
environment, the entity’s risk assessment
• Clarifying that risk assessment
process, the entity’s process to monitor the
procedures in ISA 240 are not
system of internal control, the information
separate from those in ISA 315
system and communication, and control
(Revised 2019).
activities.
• Enhancing the requirements to
• Restructured ED-240 to follow a similar structure as
consider information obtained from
ISA 315 (Revised 2019), which helps demonstrate
acceptance and continuance when
the integrated relationship between the two
obtaining an understanding of the
Page 5 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
10
ISA 540 (Revised), Auditing Accounting Estimates and Related Disclosures
Page 6 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.5: Requirements and Application Paras. 29, • Enhanced requirements by clarifying that the • Scalability
Material – Engagement Team Discussion A38, A48– discussion is between the engagement partner and
• Relevance
A53 other key engagement team members, and
Enhance requirements and application
specifying what topics are required to be discussed, • Comprehensiveness
material in ISA 240 to make the engagement
including: • Implementability
team discussion on fraud considerations
9
ISA 720 (Revised), The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Other Information
Page 7 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.7: Requirements and Application Paras. 43– • Added a requirement for the auditor to design and • Relevance
Material – Responses to the Assessed 53, A114– perform audit procedures in response to the
• Comprehensiveness
assessed risks of material misstatement due to fraud
Page 8 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Risks of Material Misstatement A141 in a manner that is not biased towards obtaining audit • Implementability
evidence that may corroborate management’s
Enhance the requirements and application • Enforceability
assertions or towards excluding audit evidence that
material in ISA 240 to strengthen the
may be contradict such assertions. The requirement • Coherence
auditor’s responses to assessed risks of
is consistent with similar requirements in ISA 315
material misstatement due to fraud, as
(Revised 2019) and ISA 540 (Revised).
necessary in light of the proposed actions
addressing fraud risk identification and • Clarified that irrespective of the auditor’s assessment
assessment and other fraud-related of the risks of management override of controls, the
procedures, including: auditor is required to design and perform audit
procedures addressing journal entries, accounting
• Considering a stand-back requirement
estimates and significant transactions outside the
in ISA 240 to evaluate all relevant
normal course of business, and determine whether
audit evidence obtained, whether
other audit procedures are needed in addition to
corroborative or contradictory, and
those required, in order to respond to the identified
whether sufficient appropriate audit
risks of management override of controls.
evidence has been obtained in
responding to the assessed risks of • Enhanced the requirement for the auditor to review
material misstatement due to fraud. accounting estimates for “indicators of possible
management bias,” by adding a requirement for the
• Enhancing application material in ISA
auditor to consider the audit evidence obtained from
240 to encourage emphasis on
the retrospective review performed. Added
management bias when considering
application material addressing indicators of possible
the appropriateness of accounting
management bias, including relevant linkages to ISA
estimates from a fraud perspective as
540 (Revised) and examples of indicators of possible
well as improving the link to the
management bias in how management makes the
procedures required in ISA 540
accounting estimates that may represent a risk of
(Revised).
material misstatement due to fraud.
B.8: Requirements and Application Paras. 65, • Enhanced the requirement by adding that the auditor • Clarity and
Page 9 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Material – Written Representations from A180–A181 shall obtain written representations from conciseness
Management management and, where appropriate, TCWG, about
whether they have appropriately fulfilled their
Consider enhancing and clarifying the
responsibilities for the design, implementation and
requirements and application material for
maintenance of internal control to prevent or detect
written representations from management.
fraud.
B.9: Application Material – Technology Paras. A5, Added application material to reflect and describe the use of • Scalability
Considerations A9, A28, technology, including:
• Relevance
A35, A51,
Enhance application material in ISA 240 to • Examples of how fraud can be committed by
A60, A64, • Clarity and
reflect and describe the use of technology to: management overriding controls using automated
A85, A97, conciseness
tools and techniques.
• Enable fraudulent activity (including A116, • Implementability
cybercrime). A117, • Guidance on how the auditor may use automated
A135, tools and techniques to perform audit procedures
• Perform fraud-related procedures by
A139, related to identifying and assessing the risks of
auditors.
A143, material misstatement due to fraud.
In doing so, remaining mindful of maintaining Appendix 2 • Guidance highlighting that expertise in Information
a balance of not ‘dating’ the standard by and Technology systems may be considered when
referring to technologies that may change Appendix 4 determining whether the engagement team has the
and evolve, and consulting with a technology
appropriate competence and capabilities.
expert(s) as needed.
• Guidance on the use of automated tools and
techniques by the engagement team to support their
discussions about susceptibility of the entity’s
financial statements to material misstatement due to
fraud.
• Guidance and examples of automated controls that
Page 10 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.11: Introductory Paragraphs and Paras. 14, • Added an introductory paragraph explaining the • Clarity and
Application Material in ISA 240 – A15–A17 relationship of ED-240 with the other ISAs, including conciseness
Relationship Between ISA 240 and ISA ISA 250 (Revised).
• Coherence
250 (Revised), and Other ISAs
• Clarified that fraud constitutes an instance of non-
Enhance the introductory paragraphs and compliance with laws and regulations, and as such,
consider application material in ISA 240 to the identification of fraud or suspected fraud could
clarify the relationship between ISA 240 and give rise to additional responsibilities under law,
Page 11 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.14: Requirements and Application Paras. 37– • Added requirements and related application material, • Relevance
Material – Journal Entries 38, 49–50, for the auditor to obtain an understanding of:
• Comprehensiveness
A95–A101,
Clarify the requirements and application o How journal entries are initiated, processed,
A124– • Implementability
material in ISA 240 on the approach to recorded, and corrected, as necessary.
A135, • Enforceability
testing journal entries, including:
Appendix 4 o Controls over journal entries, designed to
• Considering enhancing requirements prevent or detect fraud. • Coherence
in ISA 240 to:
These requirements build on the relevant
o Clarify that the auditor’s risk requirements in ISA 315 (Revised 2019).
assessment procedures
• Added a requirement and related application
Page 12 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
performed as part of ISA 315 material, for the auditor to obtain audit evidence
(Revised 2019) for controls over about the completeness of the population of all
journal entries are also relevant journal entries and other adjustments made in the
to the auditor’s decisions on preparation of the financial statements throughout the
journal entry testing in ISA 240. period.
o Take account of the impact of • Strengthened the work effort related to the
technology when testing journal requirement to test journal entries and other
entries. adjustments throughout the period by changing the
work effort verb from “consider” to “determine.”
o Address the extent of testing of
journal entries to respond to • Added application material that:
identified risks.
o Clarifies why the testing of journal entries and
• Enhancing application material to: other adjustments is performed.
o Clarify what the auditor’s o Explains that the auditor’s design and
objectives are when testing performance of audit procedure procedures
journal entries, and explain how over journal entries and other adjustments may
auditors may determine the be informed by:
nature, timing and extent of the
Leveraging insights based on the
auditor’s procedures for journal
auditor’s understanding of the entity and
entry testing.
its environment, the applicable financial
o Consider the impact of any reporting framework and the entity’s
proposed changes being made system of internal control.
to ISA 500 11 (e.g., obtaining
Drawing on the experience and insight
audit evidence about the
of the engagement partner or other key
completeness of the information
members of the engagement team.
11
ISA 500, Audit Evidence
Page 13 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
used to test journal entries). o Explains how the use of automated tools and
techniques may be used by the auditor to test
journal entries.
• Added an appendix with additional considerations
that may inform the auditor when selecting journal
entries and other adjustments for testing.
B.15: Requirements and Application Paras. 41, • Enhanced the requirement by changing the work • Scalability
Material – Presumption of Fraud Risk in A104, effort verb from “evaluate” to “determine” which types
• Relevance
Revenue Recognition A106, of revenue, revenue transactions or relevant
A107–A112 assertions give rise to risks of material misstatement • Clarity and
Revise requirements and enhance
due to fraud, taking into account related fraud risk conciseness
application material in ISA 240 to clarify how
factors. Also, the reference to the documentation
performing a robust risk assessment is
requirement, where the auditor concludes that the
critical in determining whether or not the
presumption is not applicable in the circumstances of
presumption of fraud risk in revenue
the engagement, was removed to shift the focus from
recognition is applicable, including:
the auditor developing a rebuttal to emphasizing the
• Revising the requirement in ISA 240 to importance of performing robust risk identification and
shift the focus from the auditor assessment.
developing a rebuttal to emphasizing
Enhanced or added application material that:
the importance of performing robust
risk identification and assessment. • Highlights relevant assertions and the related classes
of transactions, other account balances, or
• Enhancing the application material in
disclosures that may be particularly susceptible to
ISA 240 to:
risks of material misstatement due to fraud.
o Highlight other account
• Illustrates additional examples of circumstances
balances that may be
where there may be greater risks of material
particularly susceptible to
misstatement due to fraud in revenue recognition.
material misstatement due to
Page 14 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
fraud (such as goodwill). • Clarifies that the significance of fraud risk factors
related to revenue recognition, individually or in
o Clarify when it is inappropriate
combination, ordinarily makes it inappropriate for the
to rebut the presumption of risks
auditor to rebut the presumption that there are risks
of fraud in revenue recognition
of material misstatement due to fraud in revenue
(shifting away from clarifying
recognition. Further clarifies when it may be
when it may be appropriate to
appropriate to rebut the presumption that there are
rebut the presumption of risk of
risks of material misstatement due to fraud in revenue
fraud in revenue recognition).
recognition, in the case where fraud risk factors are
o Describe public sector not significant.
considerations.
• Describes considerations specific to public sector
entities relating to misappropriation of assets (e.g.,
misappropriation of funds) as a common type of
fraud.
B.16: Application Material – Analytical Paras. 31, • Enhanced requirements relating to analytical • Clarity and
Procedures 54, A54, procedures at the planning and completion stages of conciseness
A142–A143 the audit by changing the work effort verb from
Consider enhancing and clarifying the
“evaluate” to “determine.”
application material in ISA 240 to emphasize
the link to ISA 315 (Revised 2019) and ISA • Enhanced or added application material that:
520 12 with respect to analytical procedures at
o Explains that, at the planning stage, the
the planning and completion stages of the
auditor may identify fluctuations or
audit and how such procedures can be
relationships when performing analytical
effectively used to consider the possibility of
procedures in accordance with ISA 315
fraud.
(Revised 2019) that are inconsistent with
other relevant information or that differ from
12
ISA 520, Analytical Procedures
Page 15 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.17: Requirements and Application Paras. 55– • Added a separate section in ED-240 for audit • Scalability
Material – Fraud Is Identified or 59, A7– procedures when fraud is identified or suspected.
• Relevance
Suspected A10, A29,
• Added requirements, and related application material,
A144–A157 • Comprehensiveness
Designate a separate section in ISA 240 for that:
required audit procedures when fraud is • Clarity and
o Clarifies the engagement partner’s
identified or suspected, including: conciseness
responsibilities when fraud or suspected fraud
• Developing new requirements, is identified, including that the engagement • Implementability
relocating existing requirements, or partner is required to: • Enforceability
elevating existing application material
Obtain an understanding of the fraud or
to requirements.
suspected fraud to determine the effect
• Enhancing application material as on the audit engagement;
needed.
Determine whether to perform additional
risk assessment procedures, design and
perform further audit procedures; and
Page 16 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
including:
B.18: Application Material – Paras. • Enhanced the application material by adding • Scalability
Unpredictability of Audit Procedures A114–A115 examples of unpredictable audit procedures,
• Relevance
including incorporating unpredictability through the
Enhance or clarify application material in ISA
use of automated tools and techniques, such as • Clarity and
240 on how to design unpredictable audit
anomaly detection or statistical methods, on an entire conciseness
procedures, including providing examples of
population to identify items for further investigation. • Implementability
the types of procedures that can be used by
the auditor, and how such procedures can
13
ISA 705 (Revised), Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor’s Report
Page 17 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
be scalable.
B.19: Introductory Paragraphs and Para. A11 • Enhanced the application material by clarifying that • Comprehensiveness
Application Material in ISA 240 – Non- identified misstatements due to fraud that are not
• Clarity and
Material Fraud quantitatively material may be qualitatively material
conciseness
depending on who perpetrated the fraud and why the
Enhance the introductory paragraphs and
fraud was perpetrated, for example, misstatements
consider application material in ISA 240 to
that are not material quantitatively but have been
describe the auditor’s responsibilities when
made intentionally by management to manage key
non-material fraud is identified or suspected
performance indicators.
(e.g., that more work is required to conclude
that it is a non-material fraud, taking into • Clarified that the “fraud or suspected fraud
account the quantitative and qualitative requirements” in paragraphs 55–59 apply to all
characteristics of a possible misstatement). instances of fraud or suspected fraud identified by the
auditor, irrespective of materiality, and that the auditor
is required to apply some or all of those requirements
before determining the implications of the fraud or
suspected fraud on the audit, including whether it is
inconsequential.
B.20: Application Material – Third Party Para. • Enhanced requirements and related application • Comprehensiveness
Fraud 29(a)(ii)(c), material addressing third-party fraud by requiring that
• Clarity and
A21, A52, the engagement team discussion shall include an
Enhance application material in ISA 240 to conciseness
A80 exchange of ideas about how assets of the entity
determine the auditor's actions when third
could be misappropriated by third parties.
party fraud is identified or suspected that
may give rise to risks of material • Added application material that:
misstatement due to fraud.
o Clarifies that fraud as defined in paragraph
18(a) of ED-240 can include an intentional act
by a third party and describes generally what
Page 18 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
B.21: Requirements and Application Para. 70, • Added a requirement for the auditor to document: • Scalability
Material – Audit Documentation A193
o Key elements of the auditor’s understanding in • Clarity and
Consider the need to enhance or expand the accordance with paragraphs 33–38 of ED-240. conciseness
specific documentation requirements in ISA
o Matters related to fraud or suspected fraud. • Implementability
240, and application material, as appropriate,
once the other changes within the standard • Added application material leveraging paragraphs 11 • Enforceability
have been developed (as such changes may and A15 of ISA 230 14 dealing with the documentation
necessitate new or revised specific of inconsistencies with the auditor’s final conclusion
documentation requirements and guidance). regarding a significant matter.
B.22: Application Material – External Paras. • Added application material that: • Scalability
Confirmations A118–A122
o Highlights the usefulness of external • Relevance
Consider enhancing application material in confirmations as an audit procedure and
• Clarity and
ISA 240 related to fraud considerations for highlights that the use of external confirmation
conciseness
external confirmation procedures (e.g., when procedures may be more effective or provide
considering third party fraud), including: more persuasive audit evidence over the terms
and conditions of a contractual agreement.
• Modernizing ISA 240 for current
practice and developments in
14
ISA 230, Audit Documentation
Page 19 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
technology, including technology used o Clarifies the relationship with ISA 505. 15 The
in practice for external confirmations. application material includes guidance and
examples that:
• Considering the impacts of revisions to
ISA 500 on ISA 240 with respect to Are modernized for current practice and
audit evidence obtained from the developments in technology; and
external confirmation process.
Addresses fraud considerations for
• Revising the existing guidance when external confirmation procedures.
there are non-responses.
C. Project Objective: Enhance ISA 240 to reinforce the importance, throughout the audit, of the appropriate exercise of professional
skepticism in fraud-related audit procedures.
C.25: Requirements and Application Paras. 12– • Added an introductory paragraph, which draws on • Scalability
15
ISA 505, External Confirmations
Page 20 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Material – Professional Skepticism 13, 19–21, the approach adopted in paragraph 7 of ISA 220 • Comprehensiveness
43, A13– (Revised), paragraph 3 of ISA 315 (Revised 2019),
Enhance requirements and application • Clarity and
A14, A26– and (Revised) and paragraph 9 of ISA 600
material in ISA 240 to reinforce more robust conciseness
A32 (Revised). 16 The paragraph clarifies that professional
exercise of professional skepticism when
skepticism supports the quality of judgments made by • Implementability
performing procedures related to fraud,
the engagement team when exercising their • Coherence
including:
professional judgment in making informed decisions
• Enhancing requirements and about the courses of action that are appropriate in the
application material in ISA 240 for the circumstances, including when the auditor identifies
auditor to design and perform fraud or suspected fraud.
procedures that is not biased towards
• Removed the reference to “notwithstanding the
obtaining audit evidence that may be
auditor’s past experience of the honesty and integrity
corroborative or towards excluding
of the entity’s management and those charged with
evidence that may be contradictory.
governance” to emphasize that the exercise of
• Explaining the ‘ramp up’ of procedures professional skepticism requires the auditor to,
when fraud is identified or suspected among other things, approach each audit with a
in the application material. “fresh pair of eyes.”
16
ISA 600 (Revised), Special Considerations—Audits of Group Financial Statements (Including the Work of Component Auditors)
17
ISA 200, Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing
Page 21 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Page 22 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
D. Project Objective: Enhance transparency on fraud-related procedures where appropriate, including strengthening communications
with Those Charged with Governance (TCWG) and the reporting requirements in ISA 240 and other relevant ISAs.
• Enhance requirements and application Paras. 25, • Added an overarching requirement to communicate • Scalability
material in ISA 240 to strengthen 30, 34(c) – with management and TCWG matters related to
• Relevance
required communications with TCWG, 34(d), fraud at appropriate times throughout the audit
including: 35(b), engagement. Related application material highlights • Implementability
36(b), that the appropriate timing of the communications • Coherence
o Enhancing the requirements in
50(a), 55, may vary depending on the significance and nature of
ISA 240 for specific discussions
60(c)(i), 66- the fraud-related matters and the expected action(s)
with TCWG about the entity’s
68, A39– to be taken by management or TCWG.
risks of material misstatement
A43, A75–
due to fraud and to encourage • Enhanced requirements and application material
A78, A89–
more appropriate two-way related to making inquiries of TCWG about certain
A91, A93–
communication. Enhancements fraud related matters, when obtaining an
A94,
could include, for example, understanding of the entity’s system of internal
A182–
explicit discussions about: control.
A187
Susceptibilities to • Enhanced the requirement addressing inconsistent
misstatement due to responses to inquiries of management or TCWG by
management bias, and expanding on the relevant requirement in ISA 500.
corroborating inquiries of
Page 23 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Page 24 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
• Explore 18 revisions to requirements Paras. 61– • Added a separate section in ED-240 (Implications for • Scalability
and enhancements to application 64, A162– the auditor’s report) to emphasize the importance of
• Relevance
material to determine the need for A179 transparency in the auditor’s report related to fraud.
more transparency in the auditor’s • Implementability
• Added requirements and application material that
report describing fraud-related • Enforceability
expand on ISA 701 19 and strengthen the
matters, and if needed, how this may
requirements for the auditor to report key audit • Coherence
be done, including:
matters related to fraud, including requirements for
o Exploring what changes may be the auditor to:
needed to better describe the
o Determine, from the matters related to fraud
auditor’s responsibilities and
communicated with TCWG, those matters that
procedures related to fraud in
required significant auditor attention in
an audit of financial statements,
performing the audit.
including:
o Determine, from the matters which required
Additional outreach with
significant auditor attention in performing the
investor groups as well
audit, were of most significance in the audit of
as other relevant
the financial statements of the current period
stakeholders about the
and therefore are key audit matters.
need for more
18
The term "explore" is used here because this is an area where significant mixed views were expressed by stakeholders and during Board deliberations on the need for enhanced
transparency in the auditor's report and will require further consideration by the Fraud TF and the Board before possible actions can be proposed.
19
ISA 701, Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independent Auditor’s Report
Page 25 of 28
PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES TABLE–MAPPING OF KEY CHANGES PROPOSED IN ED-240 TO THE ACTIONS AND OBJECTIVES IN THE PROJECT PROPOSAL THAT
SUPPORT THE PUBLIC INTEREST
Proposed Actions in the Project Proposal Key Changes Proposed in ED-240 Qualitative Standard-
Setting Characteristics
(Ref. Section VI, paragraph 25) 4 Paragraph Description Considered 5
Page 26 of 28
COPYRIGHT, TRADEMARK, AND PERMISSIONS INFORMATION
The International Foundation for Ethics and Audit™ (IFEA™), the International Auditing and Assurance
Board (IAASB®) and the International Federation of Accountants® (IFAC®) do not accept responsibility for
loss caused to any person who acts or refrains from acting in reliance on the material in this publication,
whether such loss is caused by negligence or otherwise.
International Standards on Auditing, International Standard on Auditing for Audits of Financial Statements
of Less Complex Entities, International Standards on Assurance Engagements, International Standards on
Review Engagements, International Standards on Related Services, International Standards on Quality
Management, International Auditing Practice Notes, Exposure Drafts, Consultation Papers, and other
IAASB publications are copyright of IFAC.
Copyright © February 2024 by the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC). All rights reserved.
Permission is granted to make copies of this work to achieve maximum exposure and feedback provided
that each copy bears the following credit line: “Copyright © February 2024 by the International Federation
of Accountants® or IFAC®. All rights reserved. Used with permission of IFAC. Permission is granted to
make copies of this work to achieve maximum exposure and feedback.”
The ‘International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board’, ‘International Standards on Auditing’,
‘International Standard on Auditing for Audits of Financial Statements of Less Complex Entities’
‘International Standards on Assurance Engagements’, ‘International Standards on Review Engagements’,
‘International Standards on Related Services’, ‘International Standards on Quality Management’,
‘International Auditing Practice Notes’, ‘IAASB’, ‘ISA’, ‘ISA for LCE’ ‘ISAE’, ‘ISRE’, ‘ISRS’, ‘ISQM’, ‘IAPN’,
and IAASB logo are trademarks of IFAC, or registered trademarks and service marks of IFAC in the US and
other countries. The ‘International Foundation for Ethics and Audit’ and ‘IFEA’ are trademarks of IFEA, or
registered trademarks and service marks of IFEA in the US and other countries.
The processes that support the operations of the IAASB are facilitated by IFAC.