Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FOREWORD 3
INTRODUCTORY REMARKS - SEC 5
INTRODUCTORY REMARKS - CMWG
CONTENT
7
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 8
INTRODUCTION 16
OVERVIEW OF GHANA’S CAPITAL MARKET 20
MACROECONOMIC AND POLICY ENVIRONMENT 21
MONEY MARKET AND GOVERNMENT DEBT 23
CAPITAL MARKET INSTRUMENTS – SUPPLY 24
CAPITAL MARKET INSTRUMENTS - DEMAND 31
CAPITAL MARKET INSTRUMENTS - INFRASTRUCTURE 36
REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS AND CHALLENGES 37
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK 62
GOVERNANCE OF THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN 62
CHAMPION 62
STEERING COMMITTEE 62
INDUSTRY REVIEW COMMITTEE 63
WORKING GROUPS 64
SECRETARIAT 64
SEQUENCING OF THE INITIATIVES 65
MONITORING THE DELIVERY OF THE PROJECT 68
COSTS OF IMPLEMENTATION 70
GLOSSARY OF TERMS 75
T
he Capital Market is an
01. Foreword
It is my hope that this Plan will achieve In this regard, this plan which is the first
its intended purpose of providing “a deep, dedicated strategy to develop the capital market
efficient, diversified and well-regulated capital is therefore critical to help Government position
market with a full range of products attractive the securities industry more firmly as a pillar for
to domestic and international investors”. economic growth and development towards
To position our achieving the
financial market on It is my hope that, this Plan will “Ghana Beyond
Aid” agenda.
a competitive edge, achieve its intended purpose
I urge all to support
the implementation
of providing “a deep, efficient, Our appreciation
of the policy diversified and well-regulated goes to the
UK’s Foreign,
recommendations capital market with a full range of Commonwealth
contained in the
Capital Market products attractive to domestic and and Development
Master Plan (CMMP) international investors. Office (FCDO)
to achieve the vision which financed
for the industry and the financial sector as a the development of the Plan, Ghana Securities
whole. I hope this strategy will fully integrate Industry Association (GSIA), Capital Market
our domestic market with the global financial Working Group established by the MoF and
system and leverage on the opportunities that the SEC, and the World Bank for their immense
the International Financial Services Centre contribution during the development of the
(IFSC) would represent. CMMP.
T
Remarks - SEC
he Capital Market Master
Plan forms part of Ghana’s
efforts at building a robust and
sustainable long-term financial market
to anchor the country’s accelerated
development goals of its real sector of
the economy. It is aimed at charting
the course and providing the blueprint
to guide the development and growth
trajectory of the capital market over a
ten-year uninterrupted period. The four
strategic pillars or goals underscoring
the plan are as follows:
The
I
t has been a privilege to lead the as central to mobilizing savings and enhancing
development of the first 10-year Capital investments to support economic development
Market Master Plan for the Securities and compliment other financial initiatives
and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the such as mortgage financing, developing a
general market. The plan is timely, following robust domestic rating agency and positioning
the recent financial sector clean-up with Ghana as an International Financial Services
Center in the region.
expected increase in
financial activity and a I want to extend my
rebound in the coming sincere gratitude to
years. the World Bank team,
Mr. Carlos Leonardo
The design process Vicente, Ms. Swee
set us on a course Ee Ang, Ms. Barbara
of comprehensively Wiafe, the Director,
analyzing and Financial Sector
reviewing existing Division, Ministry of
trends and projections Finance Mr. Sampson
in the domestic, Akligoh, Director-
regional and General of SEC, Rev
Daniel Ogbarmey
international capital market, an Tetteh, and Deputy
evidence-based and policy-driven Director- General,
approach to effective execution
of the plan. We are confident this will strengthen Finance, of SEC, Mr. Paul Ababio for their
our credibility in the global capital market space. guidance and support, our internal and external
stakeholders who have contributed immensely to
The plan is expected to position Ghana’s the development of this plan, the Financial Sector
domestic market as the preferred choice for Division team led by Ms. Marian Mensah and the
investors and issuers by improving diversity of outstanding team of consultants Mr. Ato Barnes,
investment products and liquidity, increasing Mr. Phillip Delali Zumanu and Matthew Sullivan
investor base, strengthening infrastructure, and for spearheading the development of the plan.
improving regulations, enforcement and market
confidence. It will leverage global practice and
align infrastructure to support market efficiency Richard A Obuobi
while concurrently facilitating the deployment of
Financial Technology by the industry. Chairman
Capital Market Development Working Group
The government has identified the capital market
T
his Capital Market Master Plan At the end of the plan period, it is anticipated that
sets out a proposed path for the the capital market in Ghana will be demonstrably
development of Ghana’s capital successful and well-functioning:
market over the next ten years (2020–
The market will be firmly established as
2029). This is not the first attempt at long-
an emerging market, with a commitment
1
term planning in this area. Indeed, this Plan joins of all participants to further improve
with and supports prior efforts, by both the private and promote the implementation of
sector and the government. It however represents international standards of regulation and
the first long-term plan dedicated to the capital of infrastructure;
market.
The Plan is built around a vision discussed and It will offer a wide range of investment
opportunities, including different sectors
2
agreed with key stakeholders in the market.
and different types of instruments;
key financial instruments will be
liquid; prices will be well-formed and
transparent;
3
opportunities, thereby creating jobs,
around a vision boosting economic growth, and
supporting the financial stability
discussed and of the country;
5
domestic investors to channel their
savings while attracting significant
inflows of regional and overseas
investment funds.
The development of the capital market will goals of Ghana’s development aspirations as
provide relatively cheaper finance and investment enshrined in the following documents:
to businesses in the real sector which will result 1. Medium-Term National Development Policy
in increase in production and services making Framework (2018 – 2021)
businesses more productive. This will have a ripple 2. Ghana Beyond Aid Strategy Document
effect on the creation of more jobs, higher standards 3. Ghana: Voluntary National Review on
of living, increase in savings and investments and the implementation of the 2030 Agenda for
poverty reduction. These effects reflect the main sustainable Development, June, 2019
The capital market in Ghana has made significant total market capitalisation to GDP took a nosedive
strides in its development over the past two from ~32% in 2015 to ~16% in 2019. However,
decades but it is still small relative to other domestic market capitalisation to GDP has seen a
emerging markets. It is dominated by government marginal increase over the last 5 years from 6.2%
domestic debt with total value outstanding at in 2015 to 6.5% in 20192. In terms of values, total
GH¢115 billion as at December 2019 representing market capitalisation remained relatively flat from
33% of GDP1 from just GH¢ 19.4 billion in 2015 (11% GH¢57.1 billion in 2015 to GH¢ 56.8 billion in 2019.
of GDP).
Domestic market capitalisation however witnessed
Market Capitalisation to GDP (GH¢ Billions) a significant increase from just GH¢ 11.2 billion in
Total market capitalisation has however remained 2015 to GH¢ 22.7 billion in 2019 representing a
relatively flat over the last 5 years. Unfortunately, healthy CAGR of 19.3%.
GH¢57.1 billion GH¢ 56.8 billion GH¢ 11.2 billion GH¢ 22.7 billion
1
GSE, SEC, MoF I 2 GSE, SEC, MoF
38
There were 38 equity listings on the Secondary trading activities on the
Ghana Stock Exchange with market debt market front have however
capitalisation of GH¢ 56.8 billion seen a tremendous uptick in both
(25% of GDP) as at 31 Dec 2019. number of volumes and values of
transactions. From just total trade
Additional listings have had a values of GH¢ 9.6 billion in 2015, the
limited impact on overall number of Number of equity values shot up to GH¢ 55.7 billion in
listed entities over the past 5 years listings on the Ghana 2019 representing a 55% CAGR over
as a result of delistings. There have Stock Exchange the period.
been 3 IPOs on the main market
since 2016 one of which was ADB, Asset Management Industry
with more than 95% of the shares The Asset Management industry in
currently held by the Central Bank. Ghana has experienced significant
The period however witnessed the GH¢ 2.8 billion growth especially over the past five
largest equity capital raised on the years. The funds under management
Ghana Stock Exchange with the excluding pension funds recorded a
listing of MTN Ghana, which raised slight dip from GH¢ 11.1 billion in
GH¢ 1.1 billion in 2018. Overall, December 2015 to GH¢ 10.4 billion
GH¢ 2.8 billion was raised through Total equity capital in December 2019 representing
6 IPOs (GH¢ 1.5 billion) and nine raised through IPOs a negative CAGR of 2.3%. The
rights issues (GH¢ 1.3 billion) within and Rights Issues reduction (negative growth) was
the last 5 years. due to the clean-up exercise which
led to revocation of the licenses of
The launch, in 2013, of the Ghana 53 Fund Managers some of whom
Alternative Stock market has seen had ceased operations and had
the listing of 5 equities as at the end GH¢ 9.6 billion significantly impaired portfolios.
of 2019.
Worthy of mention is the rapid
Level of liquidity growth of the collective investment
The level of liquidity on the equities Total trading activities schemes which increased from just
market compared with the total on the debt market in GH¢ 0.7 billion in 2015 to GH¢ 3.8
market capitalisation has been very 2015 billion in 2019 representing a CAGR
low over the years. The past two years of 51% over the 5-year period in
have however seen an improvement question.
in market turnover from under 1%
of market capitalisation per annum, Private pension funds under
to 1.1% in 2018 and 2019. This management, that is the Tier 2 and
therefore requires greater attention Tier 3, being managed by SEC-
and resources to drive liquidity to
GH¢ 55.7 billion licensed Fund Managers have
the range of 3 – 5% within the next increased significantly from GH¢
10 years. The total value traded on 2.6 billion in 2015 to GH¢17.4 billion.
the equities market however saw
healthy CAGR of 17.1% from GH¢ Total trading activities
151.3 million in 2010 to GH¢ 624.2 on the debt market in
2019
The growth of pension funds and life insurance with a crisis of confidence given the failures
industry are areas with the potential to expand of some licenced financial institutions due to
the investor base for the capital market. Both the toxic assets and misconduct;
pensions and life insurance industry are growing
at faster rates than the real sector of the economy. ii. The investor base is shallow and needs to
be deepened;
Several infrastructure developments have taken
place which have improved trade settlements, iii. Interest rates on borrowings remain
transparency and market participants’ access to elevated despite lower inflation, sustained
data. The Central Securities Depository maintains economic stability and growth, and greater
the central register of dematerialized securities political certainty;
and performs clearance and settlement for trades
conducted on the Ghana Stock Exchange, the iv. The government yield curve has improved
Ghana Fixed Income Market and the over-the- significantly with greater visibility on the
counter market. Trading in commodities has also issuance calendar and gradual formation of
received a boost with the establishment of the benchmarks. This needs to be sustained in
Ghana Commodity Exchange in 2018 trading order to have a reliable reference for medium
white and yellow maize, soya, sorghum, sesame to longer-term risk free rates;
and rice.
v. Financial literacy is generally low and the
However, despite these advances and all the capacity of intermediaries needs
potential benefits of future growth, the challenges improvement; and
faced by Ghana in the development of an effective
capital market remain significant. They include vi. The Securities and Exchange Commission
a wide range of issues that need a coordinated also faces significant obstacles in terms of
response to be resolved. Key among these are that: its human and financial resources and its
powers to act to prevent abuses.
i. The financial market as a whole is riddled
The vision for the plan: “A deep, efficient, (ii) Pillar 2: Increasing the investor base
diversified and well-regulated capital market with
a full range of products attractive to domestic and (iii) Pillar 3: Strengthening infrastructure
international investors” has been translated into a and improving market services
set of four focused strategic pillars:
(iv) Pillar 4: Improving regulation,
(i) Pillar 1: Improving diversity of investment enforcement and market confidence.
products and liquidity of securities market
Each of these pillars is further broken down into a series of specific initiatives as follows:
1
Pillar
: Improving the diversity of creation of digital platforms for both of which are currently limited;
investment products and retail investors leveraging on the implementing more detailed
liquidity of securities market digitization of the banking sector; conduct of business regulation;
includes revision of the a refreshing of the investment establishing an enhanced
market models used and the guidelines for funds emphasising resolution framework within
introduction of market makers the need to look for diversification, Act 929 that extends beyond
with securities lending and short and issuer roadshows in key broker-dealers; strengthening
selling to support them; promotion overseas investor cities. the asset management industry
of real estate investment trusts
after the full resolution of
3
(REITS), simplification of Pillar
collective investment schemes : Strengthening toxic assets of affected Fund
(CIS); strengthening the repo infrastructure and Managers; training of trustees
market with introduction of improving market and custodians of collective
international standard agreements services includes the investment schemes as well
and supporting frameworks, a demutualization of as banks who handle trust
comprehensive review of taxation the GSE group; a review of the accounts; an overhaul of the
issues and incentives in the processes at CSD for handling licensing regime particularly
capital market; opening up retail delayed trades so that pre- the licences that involve
access to both the corporate and validation can be lifted; and handling client assets and
government bond markets and putting in place continuous money; implementation of
equities, and improvements to the professional education program the newly launched AML-CFT
venture capital framework. This for intermediaries. Also, complete
Guidelines; implementing
pillar also includes the setting up phasing out of dividend warrants
of a special forum for interaction to ensure shareholders receive risk-based supervision so
between Fintech providers and the dividends directly into their bank as to enable the regulator to
players in the capital market. accounts. Getting all issuers better direct its resources;
to establish investor relations and the rolling out of a
2
Pillar department. regulatory sandbox to facilitate
: Increasing the investor innovation.
4
base includes the Pillar
promotion of the simplified : Improving regulation,
CIS to the retail investors; enforcement and market
establishing a vibrant confidence includes
shareholder association, investment improving SEC resources
clubs, the deepening of relationship and powers to take early
with pension fund trustees; the and decisive enforcement action,
Figure 1 below highlights the game-changing flagship initiatives to be implemented under the four pillars
of the Master Plan.
Training of Service
Securities Lending Providers especially Robust investor Improve information
and Borrowing custodians, trustees education flow to the capital
and other banks market by issuers
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK
A clear and effective framework of governance is The Steering Committee will be closely supported
critical to the successful implementation of the by a Secretariat led by a senior person with market
Master Plan. The proposed governance structure and project management experience, which will
includes a Champion, who will be the public leader organize the Working Group meetings, monitor
of the Master Plan, a Steering Committee to direct progress and costs, and report all issues that cannot
and oversee all aspects of the development and four easily be resolved to the Steering Committee.
Working Groups to oversee the implementation of
the initiatives. The four Groups envisaged under The Secretariat will be part of the Securities and
this Plan are as follows: Exchange Commission and resourced accordingly.
1. Markets and Products, The industry will be consulted regularly through an
2. Market Infrastructure, Industry Review Committee, which will comprise
3. Legal and Regulatory, and representatives of all significant sectors within the
4. Education and Research. market intermediaries and users.
A phased approach is envisaged for the implementation of the Capital Market Master Plan. The following
three phases have been identified:
1
PHASE not have significant dependencies on others and for which the market
will be ready relatively quickly. Several of the initiatives are currently
ongoing, and include essential actions to increase market confidence,
such as resolution of toxic assets of Fund Managers, enhancing conduct
regulations and licensing requirements, broad investor education
programs, the demutualization of the GSE, opening up retail access to
government bonds and the introduction of market makers.
2
PHASE will focus on deepening the quality and breadth of products, services
and facilities. It includes the development of a readiness program for
state owned enterprises; the delivery of taxation changes to promote
issuance and investment; the introduction of obligatory continous
professional development for securities intermediaries; and the
creation of an investor protection fund.
3
PHASE initiatives and the growth of more complex products and services,
that are to some extent dependent on the successful implementation
of earlier initiatives, and on the consolidation of matters such as
price formation, education and awareness and the understanding of
risks. These include margin trading, opening up short selling to all
participants.
BACKGROUND
1. Ghana’s Capital Market began to & II) were implemented in consultation with key
develop with the establishment of stakeholders to serve as government’s blueprint
the Ghana Stock Exchange in 1990 for transforming the financial sector especially the
with associated institutions such as capital market for the period 2003 – 2016.
broker-dealers, investment advisors
and Fund Managers. Over the past three decades, 2. Impact assessment of FINSSP I & II conducted
the market has gone through showed that about 80 percent
several extensive reforms of the recommendations
which have helped in the were implemented, thus,
rapid development of the yielding positive results.
market. These reforms served Initial interviews of market
as part of the key priority participants during the
goals of the Government scoping phase of the Capital
of Ghana enshrined in its Market Master Plan Project
developmental agenda to indicated that a lot more
diversify and modernize remained to be done to deepen
the economy to support and broaden the capital
economic growth, improve market. Trading volumes and
the living standards of its listings have not grown over
citizens and reduce poverty. the past 5 years even though
Government’s strategy to the economy has grown
achieve this agenda is to develop a strong financial significantly during this period. Even though total
system which includes a vibrant capital market market capitalisation has remained relatively
driven by market-based principles that effectively flat over the last 5 years from GH¢ 57.1 billion in
mobilizes and allocates resources needed to 2015 to GH¢ to GH¢ 56.8 billion in 2019, domestic
achieve sustainable development. To this end, capitalisation has more than doubled from GH¢
two Financial Sector Strategic Plans (FINSSP I 11.2 billion in 2015 to GH¢ 22.7 billion in 2019.
creation of an appropriate development plan 6. This Master Plan therefore, is a document that
for Ghana’s Capital Market. The Securities defines the strategy to accelerate the development
and Exchange Commission is aware that to be of Ghana’s Capital Market over the next ten years
successful, a development plan needs to harness (2020 – 2029) and builds on past and current efforts
the ideas, contributions and commitment of all by both the private sector and the government.
stakeholders. After the workshop, stakeholders’
concerns were collated and incorporated in 7. The need for a plan to develop the capital market
refining the blueprint and developing it into the in Ghana is rooted in three main public policy
Capital Market Master Plan. objectives:
a
a. Firstly, to fund Ghana’s development priorities, Government requires
efficient public borrowing through a deep capital market and robust growth in
the private sector. These factors also underpin economic growth. Numerous
studies conducted on developed markets shows that broader and deeper
capital markets will likely lead to better investment, more growth, increased
employment and higher standards of living. Capital markets are better
suited for funding long-term projects and raising equity capital for building
businesses and creating wealth. For a private sector-led economy, access to
capital is crucial for the growth of businesses, thus a robust capital market
that invests in debt and equity of issuers supports long-term economic
growth as jobs are created from these businesses.
b
b. Second, capital markets create economic opportunities for the ordinary
citizen that would be otherwise unavailable to him/her. Capital markets
provide the chance to participate in a wide range of investment opportunities
by sharing risk and the required minimum investment to access those
opportunities. For instance, mutual funds allow retail investors to gain
exposure to securities that have high minimum subscription levels and would
ordinarily be out of the reach of the average retail investor.
c
c. Third, capital markets serve to manage systemic risk. They are an antidote
to bank-centric structures where the majority of credit risk rests within the
banking system itself and exposes the government to high levels of fiscal risk
in the case of bank failures, as experienced in Ghana recently. The recently
established Financial Stability Council will play an integral role in addressing
systemic risk and with a membership incorporating all the financial sector
regulators, will recommend solutions that use the capital markets to address
regulatory issues, identification of risks, diversification, and preparedness for
crisis.
8. Capital markets play a vital role in channeling to businesses in the real sector thereby driving
investment into the economy to help drive growth, an increase in production and services, making
prosperity, creation of employment opportunities businesses more profitable. This will have a ripple
and ultimately improvement on people’s everyday effect on the creation of jobs, higher standard of
lives. The development of the capital market will living, increase in savings and investments and
help to lower the domestic cost of capital, resulting finally, poverty reduction (Figure 2 below).
in relatively cheaper finance and investment
1. Increased Employment
2. Higher Standards of Living
Capital 3. Poverty Reduction
4. Increase in Savings/Investments
Market 5. Increase in Entrepreneurs
FIGURE 2:
CAPITAL MARKET
IMPACT ON THE Real
REAL SECTOR AND Sector
LINKAGE BETWEEN GHANA’S DEVELOPMENT AGENDA AND THE CAPITAL MARKET MASTER PLAN
The implementation of the Capital Market Master Plan will result in growth of businesses and increased
production which will result in employment, high standard of living and eventually, poverty reduction.
The development of the Capital Market fully aligns therefore with Ghana’s development aspirations as
enshrined in the following documents:
1 2 3
Ghana Beyond Aid Strategy Medium-Term National Ghana: Voluntary National
Document3: Development Policy Review on the Implementation
This national transformation Framework (2018 – 2021)4: of the 2030 Agenda for
document emphasizes This policy intervention Sustainable Development,
increased manufacturing and is aimed at restoring the June 20195:
high value services that will economy, transforming The document is based
result in providing jobs and agriculture and industry, on priorities mirroring the
prosperity to all Ghanaians. strengthening social protection, four pillars of sustainable
The focus on private sector revamping economic and social development in the Ghanaian
as an engine of growth will infrastructure and reforming context – economic,
also enhance Government’s public services delivery. In social, environmental and
tax base, reducing the reliance the end, the intervention is institutional. It provides
on foreign aid for critical expected to create jobs and key actions needed in
government expenditures. increased productivity resulting implementing Sustainable
in poverty reduction. Development Goals (SDGs)
with emphasis on job creation
and growth of businesses.
3
https://thinknovate.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Ghana-Beyond-Aid-Charter-and-Strategy-Document.pdf I 5 https://www.mofep.gov.gh/sites/default/files/news/Ghanapercent27s-SDG-Budget-Baseline-Report-Aug-09-18.pdf
4
https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/new-ndpc-static1/CACHES/PUBLICATIONS/2018/08/23/Medium-term+Policy+Framework-Final+June+2018.pdf
PILLAR 4
9. The Capital Market in Ghana has seen significant at 25 percent of GDP as at 31 Dec 2019.
advances in its development over the past decade,
but is still relatively small compared to other 10. Institutional investors such as pension funds,
emerging markets. The market is dominated collective investment schemes and insurance
by government domestic debt with total value companies are growing but have few investment
outstanding at GH¢115 billion, representing about options in capital market products since current
33 percent of GDP as at the end of 2019. The tradable options are limited to government debt,
establishment of the Ghana Fixed Income Market a few corporate bonds and a few equity listings.
has helped to improve liquidity on the fixed income Assets under management at December 2019 was
market, though liquidity remains a challenge. GH¢26.2 billion, representing 6.8% of GDP. This
represents a significant growth from December
Corporate bonds, with total outstanding amount 2015 AUM of GH¢13.7 billion. The growth has been
as at the end of 2019 being GH¢ 7.97 billion, driven by the reforms in the pension sector, which
are growing in representation, but currently ceded a portion of pension assets to be managed
dominated by non-bank financial institutions and a by Fund Managers (Tier 2 and Tier 3 contributions)
government sponsored SPV, ESLA Plc. ESLA alone and administered by Pension Trustees. The Tier 2
has issued GH¢ 6 billion representing 75 percent and Tier 3 assets increased from GH¢ 2.6 billion
of the outstanding issuance as at Dec 2019. Equity in 2015 to GH¢ 17.4 billion at the end of Dec 2019.
market development has been painstakingly slow.
The market has attracted few equity listings and
many listed equities experience limited trading.
There were 38 equity listings on the Ghana Stock
Exchange’s main board with market capitalisation
50%
349.5
300.6 40%
256.7
33%
215.1 30%
180.4
27%
25%
20%
17% 114.8
30.0 15.0%
8.4%
20.0 10.0%
6.5%
6.3% 25.4
22.7
10.0 6.2% 5.1% 5.0%
16.2
11.2 10.9
- 0.0%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
39 41 40 39 38
4 4 4 5 5
70 1.2%
64.4 1.1%
61.2 62.9 1.1%
60 1.0%
57.3 57.1
0.9% 61.1 56.8
52.7
50
47.3 0.8% 0.8%
0.7%
40 0.8%
0.5% 0.6%
30 0.5%
0.4%
20.1 0.4%
20
0.2% 0.2%
10
0.15 0.45 0.10 0.46 0.35 0.25 0.24 0.52 0.66 0.62
- 0.0%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Value Traded (GHS Bn) Market Cap (MC) - GHS BN Value Traded to MC
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
420
323
331
313
253
1,000
246
201
207
218
-
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
25.0
17.9
20.0 14.6
14.5
14.2
15.0
10.4
11.7
10.0
6.5
7.2
4.4
3.8
2.6
2.5
2.2
5.0
1.1
0.7
-
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
140,000
30.7
120,000
36.0
100,000
15.6
80,000
9.6
60,000
40,000
20,000
-
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
55.7
60.0
50.0
36.0
40.0
30.7
30.0
15.6
20.0
9.6
10.0
11. The period 2012 to 2016 saw Ghana pass through Consolidated Bank Ghana Limited (CBG), as well
difficult macroeconomic challenges that resulted as the capitalisation of the Ghana Amalgamated
in stalled economic growth, with GDP growth Trust (GAT). Additionally, with the President’s
averaging 3.8% during the last three years of the directives to fully pay all depositors whose funds
period. That period was also characterized by large were locked up with the failed SDIs and MFIs,
budget deficits, pronounced inflation (18.7% in an amount of GH¢5 billion was allocated. This
2016), higher average lending rates (32.1% in 2016) brings the total expenditure on financial sector
and the steep depreciation of the local currency. interventions as of June 2020 to GH¢18.6 billion
Nevertheless, macroeconomic performance (4.8% of GDP).
improved significantly under the IMF Extended
Credit Facility (ECF) covering the period 2015 to 13. The Securities and Exchange Commission
April 2, 2019. Growth in both 2017 and 2018 was (SEC) also embarked on a series of reforms in 2018
robust, buoyed by increased oil production with and 2019 which culminated with the sanitization
Ghana being touted as one of the fastest growing of the asset management industry, which entailed
economies in Africa in 2018. Inflation has declined the revocation of the licenses of 50 Fund Managers
from 17.5% in 2016 to 9.4% in 2018 and reduced in November 2019. The assets under management
further to 7.9% in Dec 2019. of the revoked Fund Managers at the time of
revocation was GH¢ 8.1 billion. The liquidation of
12. The Bank of Ghana (BoG) resolved nine these firms and addressing investor compensation
insolvent banks over a period of 18 months, in was ongoing at the time of preparation of this
line with its commitment to clean up the banking document. Government has also committed an
sector. The Bank of Ghana also increased the amount of GH¢3.1 billion (0.78% of GDP) towards
capital requirements for banks from GH¢ 120 supporting investors in failed asset management
million to GH¢ 400 million in order to strengthen companies regulated by the SEC. This would
the sector. As at the end of first quarter 2020, a total bring the overall cumulative total Government
amount of GH¢13.6 billion (3.5% of GDP) had been expenditure for the failed financial institutions to
spent on the resolution of failed banks, Specialised GH¢21.62 billion.
Deposit-taking Institutions (SDIs), Micro Finance
Institutions (MFIs), the establishment of the Structural reforms to strengthen public financial
3.8%
Average GDP
growth from 2012 to
2016
1. The period 2012 to 2016 saw
Ghana pass through difficult
macroeconomic challenges
that resulted in stalled
18.7%
economic growth.
2. Macroeconomic
performance improved
Average inflation
from 2012 to 2016 significantly under the IMF
Extended Credit Facility (ECF)
covering the period 2015 to
April 2, 2019.
50
2019 which culminated with
the sanitization of the asset
management industry.
Number of
Fund Managers
whose licenses
were revoked in
November 2019
management and oversight of the state-owned of the economy and respect for the rule of law. This
enterprises continue to be implemented. Robust focus has helped the capital market in ensuring
growth is expected to be sustained in 2019 into continuity in its development. If a master plan
2020, propped up by sturdy private consumption for the development of capital markets is to be
and healthy investment activity growth. Strong successful, it will be important that the government
demand for Ghana’s key commodity exports and maintains the focus and discipline that has
increased productivity in the agricultural sector underpinned recent stability and will enable an
contributed to real GDP growth of 7.9% in 2019. The attractive economy and investment environment.
outlook for growth in 2020 has been clouded by the
impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the
focus on digitization of government operations, MONEY MARKET AND GOVERNMENT DEBT
improved use of technology by the private sector
and buffers established in the first quarter of 2020 16. The money market is the market in which
have reduced the net impact of the pandemic on short-term borrowing and lending is accessed. It
Ghana’s economic outlook. It is expected that includes lending between financial institutions,
the economy will grow at 0.9% in 2020 (revised particularly banks, and the issuance of short-
downward from pre- term commercial paper
pandemic outlook of 6.8 by large corporations.
percent), and 4.7% in 2021. Money market
instruments are therefore
14. However, there remain debt instruments and
significant challenges. include the interbank
These include a continued market borrowings,
dependence on primary Treasury bills, BoG bills,
commodity exports repurchase agreements
and a need for fiscal and commercial paper.
discipline in the context The money market
of elevated government is dominated by
financial needs. Foreign government securities
exchange reserves fell in and it plays a critical
2018 but climbed in 2019, role in the execution
underlining Ghana’s of BoG monetary
exposure to shifting policy through its open
investor sentiment and market operations. As
external shocks. The stock at the end of December
of Net International Reserves (NIR) increased 2019, the total outstanding listed money market
to US$5.19 billion at end-December 2019, from instruments (91-day – 182-day maturity) was
US$3.85 billion at end-December 2018, indicating GH¢27.5 billion compared with GH¢15.5 billion in
a build-up of US$1.34 billion. Gross International 2018 representing a 77% growth rate.
Reserves (GIR) also increased by US$1.39 billion
to US$8.42 billion at end December 2019, sufficient 17. One especially key component of the money
to cover 4.0 months of imports compared to 3.6 market is interbank secured lending using
months at end-December 2018. Gross international repurchase agreements (repo transactions). These
reserves are expected to cover 4 months of import repo transactions are discussed below in more
for 2020 and 2021, partly due to the successful and detail in the section on interbank transactions.
historic US$ 3 billion 3-tranche Eurobond issued in
February 2020 which was 5 times oversubscribed. The Interbank and Treasury bill markets are
active in Ghana. Money market interest rates
15. The government’s economic and political have moderated in the past 3 years, (2017 – 2019)
philosophy has in recent years converged on a reflecting diminishing inflation expectations and
common set of principles which include emphasis policy rate easing. This part of the money market
on the private sector as the main engine of growth dominates the financial markets in Ghana, owing to
the volatility of the macroeconomic policy rate has fallen steadily over
environment which makes short- the past three years. As at the end of
term financial instruments more 2017, the policy rate was at 20% but
attractive. it had fallen to 17% as at the end of
the year 2018 and further declined
19. The private sector money market to 16% by December 2019.
instruments is dominated by fixed
deposits and commercial paper which 21. The BoG also manages the
has increased in importance over the supply of money through the
past 5 years, with Fund Managers, Fund Managers issuance or retirement of BoG bills
mutual funds and pensions being in the interbank market.
the main demand participants. Fund had invested
Managers had invested GH¢ 7.1 GH¢ 7.1 billion
billion in money market instruments
as at December 2019. They are in money market INTERBANK MONEY MARKET
becoming increasingly important instruments as
players in the money markets. 22. Ghana has a vibrant interbank
at December market where banks lend funds to
2019. They each other. The total value of trades
increased from GH¢ 80.9 billion
are becoming in 2018 to GH¢ 119.5 billion at the
CENTRAL BANK OPERATIONS
WITH BANKS increasingly end of December 2019. Maturities
are short, usually overnight. The
important number of all repo transactions
20. Commercial banks borrow from players in the settled by CSD increased by 9.8%
the Bank of Ghana to meet liquidity from 5,427 in 2018 to 5,957 in 2019.
challenges when their cash on hand money markets. The settlement value of all the repo
is low before the close of the business transactions also increased by 25.8%
day. Borrowing from the Central Bank to GH¢ 201.6 billion in 2019 from
is convenient because it is always GH¢ 160.2 billion in 201820. The
available, and the lending process interbank rate has fallen from 23.9
includes no negotiation or extensive percent at the end of 2015 to 15.2%
documentation. The downside, in 2019 reflecting diminishing
however, is the interest rate or the inflation expectations and policy
Policy rate at which the Central rate easing.
Bank lends to banks, is higher than
borrowing from another bank. The
23. Banks deal directly with each other in the 25. The localization and adoption of the Global
interbank market and this has improved banks’ Master Repo Agreement (GMRA) by Bank
feel for the state of the market and led to closer of Ghana in 2019 should increase liquidity
relationships between market participants. and pricing transparency in money markets,
Transactions are done by a pledge to the lender thereby helping to properly price long term risk
with Central Securities Depository (CSD) blocking and support transmission of monetary policy
the securities pledged while the Ghana Interbank decisions. The GMRA also provides a structure for
Payment and Settlement System (GhIPSS) which securities lending between financial institutions
is Ghana’s Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) and professional investors. Securities lending is
system is used to make payment. This has worked essential to support short selling, which in turn
adequately to date but when there is a default, the is a key facilitator of many important features of
pledged securities cannot be transferred to the active capital markets, including market making,
lender immediately. The lender must ask the CSD hedging, creating exchange traded funds (ETFs),
to intervene and to transfer the securities to them, and derivatives.
for which the CSD requires letters of indemnity.
The limitations therefore of the interbank market
is the lack of documented right to the security held INTEREST RATE ENVIRONMENT
and there is no carve out from insolvency law for
26. The high level of interest rates in Ghana has
this approach. In addition, there is no integrated
continued to be a significant source of concern
legal documentation.
as it hinders the development of an effective and
24. A more usual active bond market.
structure for these While average
transactions, which lending rates have
addresses these and declined from 32.1%
other problems, is in December 2016 to
the repo transaction 23.6% in December
mentioned earlier. 2019, they remain
A repo transaction significantly higher
is effectively a than the Monetary
temporary transfer Policy Rate of 16.5%
of cash and in December 2019.
collateral between The prevailing level
the two institutions of rates do not reflect
under an agreement the macroeconomic
that is specially stability Ghana has
constructed so as to ensure that beneficial enjoyed in recent years, and the entrenchment
ownership of the collateral remains with the of fiscal discipline and political stability across
original holder and that the bankruptcy of either election cycles. The high interest rates pose a
party will not prevent the transaction from being challenge to the attractiveness of stocks given
closed down with no damage to the interests of relatively lower dividend yields and recent weak
the other party. These agreements also protect performance.
the original holder from accounting and taxation
problems that arise from collateral transfers. The 27. At the apex of the interest rate regime is the BoG
newly introduced master repo agreement seeks Policy Rate which serves as a key benchmark. It is
to address the shortfalls in the current framework. charged on (overnight) short-term credit extended
The Corporate Insolvency and Restructuring Act to banks to replenish their liquidity shortfalls. It
2020 (Act 1015) has also been prepared to enable therefore signals the cost of funds available to the
effective implementation of derivative transactions banks as a last resort and should be transmitted
in the event of default. The tax regime may need throughout the financial system. However, because
to be reviewed to ensure that it does not create the use of central bank funds is an exception, the
problems for repo transactions around interest cost of capital of banks is not impacted much by
payments or additional transaction costs. the policy rate. The banks’ lending rates have
Eurobond in 2019. All these securities are listed since GFIM was established, the value of secondary
on the GSE, with trades being executed either on trading in GoG bonds and corporate bonds has
the GSE platform, or Bloomberg’s e-bond trading risen from GH¢9.6 billion in 2015 to GH¢48 billion
platform and settled through the CSD. Currently, in 2019.
there are no benchmarks or on-the-run Treasury
issues for each maturity. 33. The BoG issues securities on behalf of the
government and has licensed financial institutions
31. In recent years, the government has shifted its called Primary Dealers (PDs) to participate in the
issuance strategy by focusing more on medium wholesale auctions of GoG securities. The roles of
and longer-dated instruments. Government’s high the PDs are to (i) take up, market and distribute the
borrowing requirements to finance its activities primary issuance of GoG Securities, (ii) actively
has increased owing primarily to lower-than- participate in the secondary market for GoG
expected revenues, limited fiscal space and interest Securities, thereby, facilitating price discovery, (iii)
cost burden. Government therefore resorted developing liquidity in the government securities
to borrowing from the domestic market, thus, market and (iv) to be an active and effective
increasing its debt stock significantly especially in participant in the BoG’s Open Market Operations
medium and long-term debt. The yield curve now (OMO). Unfortunately, the PD concept has not
stretches to 15 years but there are pricing issues resulted in effective distribution of government
with the longer-dated instruments which make securities, prompting the Ministry of Finance to
them less attractive. Although significant progress create a new form of intermediary called Joint
has been made in the development of both money Book Runners (JBR) who also have access to the
markets and longer dated government debt, primary market and take fees for distribution.
secondary trading remains an issue.
34. The framework for secondary trading of bonds
32. Following recommendations of the SEC’s needs to be enhanced and made more accessible to
medium-term strategic plan and the Fixed Income retail investors through digital channels. Extensive
Working Group, key stakeholders in the financial education is required to embed the concept of
market set up the Ghana Fixed Income Market long-term investing in the general public in order
(GFIM) in 2015. These stakeholders were led by to increase retail demand for government bonds as
the Bank of Ghana (BoG), Ghana Stock Exchange a viable investment avenue.
(GSE), Central Securities Depository (CSD),
Ghana Association of Bankers, the Ministry of 35. The shape of the yield curve is upward sloping
Finance (MoF), Financial Market Association but almost flat for medium to longer-dated bonds.
(ACI Ghana) and the Licensed Dealing Members This means that there is very little price differential
(LDMs) of the Ghana Stock Exchange. The among the two-to-fifteen-year bonds making
objectives for the GFIM included providing an investment in longer-dated bonds unattractive.
orderly and transparent and efficient market for all This may explain the lack of distribution of
fixed income and similar securities and bringing government securities by the primary dealers to
secondary trading activities in fixed income investors due to investors’ affinity towards short-
securities in Ghana to international best practice term securities.
standards. This move has significantly improved
secondary trading in GoG securities. For example,
FIGURE 12: DOMESTIC YIELD CURVE (AT CONSTANT MATURITY), 2018 & 2019
2018 2019
22.0
20.0
18.0
Interest Rates (%)
16.0
14.0
12.0
10.0
2022 EUROBOND 2023 EUROBOND 2026 EUROBOND 2027 EUROBOND 2029 EUROBOND
2030 EUROBOND 2032 EUROBOND 2049 EUROBOND 2051 EUROBOND
18
16
14
12
Yield (%)
10
0
Oct- 17
Feb- 18
Dec- 17
Aug-14
Oct.-14
Aug-16
Aug-19
Aug-18
Aug-15
Aug-17
Dec-14
Dec-16
Dec-19
Feb-16
Dec-18
Feb-19
Apr-16
Apr-19
Dec-15
Apr-18
Feb-15
Jun-16
Jun-19
Feb-17
Jun-18
Apr-15
Apr-17
Jun-15
Jun-17
Oct-16
Oct-19
Oct-18
Oct-15
Source: Bloomberg
interest in bonds are the following: 42. Secondary trading in corporate bonds is
negligible compared to the equity and government
a. Cumbersome issuance processes which debt markets, but this is not unusual in private
are the same as or very similar to those for sector corporate bonds. This is because of factors
equity. This makes bank loan processes inherent in the nature of these bonds:
much more attractive to a borrower.
a. They are generally relatively small in size,
i. Equity-focused processes usually particularly in smaller economies.
include lengthy approval processes
which create risks for both bond b. They are held by a small number of
issuers and bond-investors. For both investors, largely institutions that bought
issuers and investors, timing and with the intention of holding the bonds to
speed to market are key since there maturity. These investors are not likely to sell
are competing demands on liquidity
and management time. unless they are rebalancing their portfolios,
even if there are movements in prices.
ii. Equity-based approaches
also include high demands for c. The securities are held in large blocks
transparency of information that is which are best negotiated bilaterally rather
relevant to equity investors, such than through automated platforms, with
as the detail of governance and subsequent “post-trade” reporting to the
senior management remuneration. Exchange or settlement framework.
Many bond issuers regard these
disclosures as onerous and are
therefore reluctant to make them. 43. ESLA plc dominated both trading volumes and
values of the corporate bond market. The entity
b. Perceived high transaction costs, traded 2,731 volumes in 2018 compared with 1,989
in 2019 with values of GH¢ 4.7 billion and GH¢ 3.8
c. Historical macro-economic instability, billion respectively.
d. Lack of clear guidelines on corporate
bond issuance, EQUITIES
e. Limited investor base and
44. The GSE has 38 equity listings as at the end
f. Lack of independent credit ratings.
of December 2019. A total amount of GH¢2.8
billion has been raised since 2015 on the Exchange
through six IPOs and nine Rights Issues.
45. Market capitalisation has increased from years. So far, there are only 5 listings on GAX. The
GH¢20.1 billion in 2010 to GH¢ 56.8 billion in low levels of listings on the GAX is attributed partly
2019 due to gains in both prices and listings. This to lack of awareness of its existence by SMEs. The
represents a compounded annual growth rate of timing of the launching of the GAX also coincided
12.2%. Notable listings since 2010 include Tullow with challenging economic conditions during the
Oil, Access Bank and MTN, a telecommunication period 2014 to 2016. This did not favour equity
giant in Ghana. In relation to GDP, however, investments as potential investors had short-term
capitalisation fell from 31.7% of GDP in 2015 to investment horizons and thus, preferred to remain
16.3% in 2019, owing to faster growth of GDP invested in money market instruments.
compared to the market. The main sectors of the
economy represented at the exchange include 48. The Venture Capital Trust Fund (VCTF) was
the financial sector, manufacturing, mining, oil set up in 2004 through an Act of Parliament
and gas, and telecommunication, even though (VCTF Act 680) to provide long-term capital and
representation for the mining, oil and gas, and technical support to enable Small and Medium-
telecommunications is with single entities. scale Enterprises (SMEs) to grow. This support is
carried out through partner financial institutions
46. The GSE Composite Index (GSE-CI) is the (Venture Capital Financing Companies) who act
major stock market index which tracks the as Fund Managers. Currently VCTF channels
performance of all equities trading on the Ghana financial commitments to SMEs by providing
Stock Exchange. Over the past ten years, the GSE- credit and equity financing to funding vehicles.
CI has had its highs and lows - registering a return Although VCTF has leveraged its seed capital
of 79% in 2013 and –15.3% in 2016. The volatile of GH¢22.4 million by about three-fold, the
nature of the market coupled with lack of adequate huge SME demand makes its impact on SME
knowledge of the equity market has over the years development negligible. The Trust Fund does
driven many investors to largely focus on investing receive inflows from government, but the amount
permanently in fixed income, thus shrinking the is relatively small to make a dent in SME financing.
equity investor base. By its very nature, the venture capital and private
equity models are relatively long-term, robust
47. As part of a strategy to increase the number of and effective approach to easing access to long-
listings, the GSE launched the Ghana Alternative term capital and spurring business growth. It will
Exchange (GAX) in 2013 as a parallel market to require significant long-term commitment from
target Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) the government and the private sector to ensure
with potential for growth. This is in line with a consistent flow of investable funds to maintain
broader trend in Africa with Nigeria, Egypt and sustainability.
Morocco all establishing similar markets in recent
49. As at the end of 2017, there were eighty-six CAPITAL MARKET INSTRUMENTS - DEMAND
(86) entities in which government has equity
investments. State Owned Enterprises (SOEs)
50. Pension funds and the life insurance industry
constitute a significant portion of the public
are areas of potential demand and
finances and control more than
growth for the capital market. Both
50% of national assets, therefore
the pensions and life insurance
have important roles to play in
industry are growing at faster rates
the development of the market.
than the real sector of the economy.
Unfortunately, of the 38 listed
companies, only six are state- Total assets However, the flow of funds from
the pensions and life insurance
owned: GCB Bank, ADB Bank, under into the capital market leaves
State Insurance Company (SIC), management of much to be desired. The 2017-2019
Cocoa Processing Company
(CPC), Produce Buying Company
pension funds resolution of banks, savings and
stood at GH¢ loans and finance houses which
(PBC) and Ghana Oil Company
served as fixed-deposit issuers has
(GOIL). In several jurisdictions 26.3 billion in exacerbated flight to safety, with
where the capital market has
developed significantly, SOE
2019. Until the more Fund Managers allocating
implementation increasing proportions of their
listings have spearheaded the
portfolios to government securities.
development of the equity-market. of the Pensions
SOEs can often be brought to a Act (2008) in
capital market by government
as a stage of their corporate 2010, pensions
development, and as a contribution were managed PENSION FUNDS
towards the development of the solely by the
capital market. This is usually done
after significant work to clarify Social Security 51. Total assets under management
of pension funds stood at GH¢
their mandates and to embed and and National 26.3 billion in 2019. Until the
protect high standard practices of Insurance Trust implementation of the Pensions
accounting and governance. SOEs
that are attractive to investors
(SSNIT). Act (2008) in 2010, pensions were
managed solely by the Social
may then come to the corporate
Security and National Insurance
bond market, with or without a
Trust (SSNIT) which administered
guarantee from the state, or to the
a defined benefit scheme. As at
equities market (if the state is looking for partial or the end of 2019, it was managing GH¢8.9 billion
complete privatization). Because of their size and representing 33.8% of total pension assets. The
name-recognition, these SOEs can often become Trust is the largest single institutional investor on
important cornerstones of a market. the Ghana Stock Exchange (GSE) and the main
driver of the development of the Capital Market 54. In 2016, the National Pensions Regulatory
in Ghana. SSNIT currently holds a significant Authority (NPRA )revised its investment guidelines
number of shares listed on the GSE with twenty-two which increased the allocation to a number of the
(22) out of the thirty-seven (37) listed companies. capital market products. The revision introduced
SSNIT’s holdings on the Ghana Stock Exchange new asset classes and increased the investment
was GH¢2.7 billion as at June 2018. limits for asset classes aligned to the capital market.
The limits for equities increased from 10 percent
52. Following the pension reforms of 2010 based on to 20 percent, while alternative investments (real
Act 766, private pension schemes were created with estate investment trusts, private equity funds and
licensed trustees, pension Fund Managers, and international investment securities) were also
pension fund custodians all under the supervisory introduced.
oversight of the National Pensions Regulatory
Authority. These new players have responsibility 55. The asset allocation of SSNIT and the private
for the Tiers 2 and 3 of employee contributions. pensions as at December 2019, are shown in
Figures 13 and 14. The asset allocation of the
53. Pension funds are recognised internationally private pension schemes are concentrated in
as one of the main drivers of deep, vibrant, liquid government securities and fixed deposits (about
capital markets by creating demand for capital 86 percent) as the Trustees seek safer investments
markets products. due to the current financial upheaval.
LOANS 6.97
REIT 0
PERCENTAGE ALLOCATION
24% 23%
Property & Land Investments
GoG Securities
3% 3%
Investments in Associates
Investments in Associates
28%
Property & Land Investments
17%
GoG Securities
9% 44%
Fixed Deposits
Other Securities
4% 1%
Listed Equity Corporate Debt
1%
MutualFunds 1%
Mutual Funds
2%
Corporate Debt 5%
29%
Listed Equity
Fixed Deposits
6%
Other Securities
Schemes by the investing public and high interest competitive nature of the investment industry
rate regime. drove many Fund Managers to offer relatively
high guaranteed returns to investors in order to
62. Despite the growth experienced in the industry, increase their assets under management. The Fund
some key challenges have emerged including Managers invested in short-term fixed deposits
the growing levels of impaired assets due to the of Savings and Loans, Finance Houses and
collapse of several financial institutions, especially Microfinance institutions which offered very high
for funds being managed on a discretionary basis. interest rates. Unfortunately, the Fund Managers
This led to a clean up of the Asset Management could not redeem their investments as many of
industry, resulting in 50 Fund Management firms these institutions had liquidity issues resulting
having their operating licenses revoked. The in many Fund Managers carrying high levels of
cleanup exercise was in line with the Commission’s impaired assets. This has brought about loss of
mandate of protecting investors and the integrity confidence in the investment industry with some
of the industry. The rollout of a Government bailout retail investors now turning to safer government
on the back of the clean up is expected to prop the securities and others investing in physical assets
confidence of investors in the Asset Management such as land, buildings, etc.
Industry.
FOREIGN INVESTORS
INDIVIDUAL DOMESTIC INVESTORS 66. Foreign investors have played a significant
63. The participation level of Ghanaian individual role in the development of the capital market by
investors in the capital market is low. As at the end creating demand for longer-dated government
of 2019, there were 1,122,778 depository accounts, securities and equities. Available data from the
representing a CAGR of 11.5% from 2014 levels of Central Securities Depositary (CSD) shows that
647,212. This represents 3.7% of the population of the total value of foreign investor holdings in
Ghana. Individuals with investment management government securities in 2019 amounted to about
accounts were 503,177, representing 1.7% of the GH¢29.1 billion, representing 34% of government
population. There is therefore significant room for securities.
growth in promoting retail investment products.
67. In terms of trend, foreign investors’ holdings in
64. Key factors in the low level of participation government securities have been increasing over
include low income levels and limited exposure recent years, with the exception of the latter part
to financial education. As adoption of mobile of 2018 and early 2019. The 2019 divestment of
money exceeds the use of the banking sector due securities coincided with plans by the US Federal
to its inclusive nature, it is critical for the capital Reserve to raise its interest rates, which was
markets to leverage mobile technology to increase expected to hold back huge inflows to emerging
distribution and information dissemination. economies – foreign investors sold about 5 % of
their aggregate securities. The decline in foreign
65. There is a strong need
for broad investor education
to enhance appreciation of
investments in the general
populace. The level of
awareness is low given the
recent experience of investors
expecting fixed returns
from Fund Managers. Retail
investors have often typically
demanded guaranteed returns
which are about 5 to 10%
above yields on government
securities. The highly
69. The tax benefits for investors in Ghana are GFIM. GFIM uses the Bloomberg platform
therefore impressive, but they are due to expire for trades of its listed fixed income securities
in December 2021. The end of these concessions market for the global investment community.
could have a significant negative implication for
capital market development as it would mean • In addition to the operations of the markets,
that listed investments were treated equivalently the Exchange also provides services by
way of: Securities Courses, Professional
to non-listed investments. Lifting the concession
Development Seminars and the sale of
could also cause problems for repo transactions capital market data. The training function
based on corporate bonds, which could be an is expected to migrate to the Ghana
additional impediment to development of the Investments and Securities Institute (GISI)
bond market. in 2020.
70. It is important to note that there are no • The Ghana Stock Exchange (GSE) also
significant enduring tax benefits for issuers in has an ownership interest in the Central
Ghana. Tax reliefs and preferential policies can Securities Depository (CSD) and the Ghana
be particularly important if the country is to Investments and Securities Institute (GISI).
attract more issuers to the market. The decision
to list is made principally by an issuer’s board and GHANA COMMODITY EXCHANGE
financial team, for whom listing means extra costs
(in compliance, in governance, in publication, 72. Although the Ghana Commodities Exchange
as well as the efforts required to maintain high (GCX) was established as a private company
quality accounting records and transparency). Tax limited by shares and structured as a Public-Private
incentives can help to soften the impact of those Partnership, the government of Ghana currently is
extra costs. In an environment such as Ghana the sole shareholder.
where there are potential difficulties in finding The government however intends to reduce its
an acceptable price for corporate bonds, these holdings over time. GCX operates an electronic
incentives can also give issuers some additional platform for buyers and sellers of agricultural and
flexibility. other commodities to trade in an efficient and
orderly manner under the regulation of the SEC.
The aim of the Exchange is to establish linkages
CAPITAL MARKET INSTRUMENTS - between agricultural and commodity producers
INFRASTRUCTURE and buyers, to secure competitive prices for their
products, assuring the market quantity and quality
GHANA STOCK EXCHANGE AND THE as well as timely settlement of their trades. It has
GHANA FIXED INCOME MARKET the vision of transforming Ghana’s economy by
GCX
beans, sorghum, the expanded
sesame seeds and nature of Ghana’s
rice. A total of 51,296 securities market.
farmers have been The Act allows
trained directly the introduction
or indirectly and of some new
20 farmer-based Ghana Commodity Exchange products and
organizations have services into the
signed up with the securities market
GCX. and brings new
market operators
under the
regulation of the
Commission.
CENTRAL SECURITIES DEPOSITORY
74. The Central Securities Depository (CSD) serves 76. The SEC is responsible for the oversight of the
as the single depository for all securities including activities of all securities companies. Act 929 sets
public sector bonds and private sector bonds its responsibilities out as follows (summarized):
and shares. It provides safe, secure, dependable
• Maintain surveillance over activities
clearing, settlement and depository services to
Ghana’s securities market. It has upgraded its in securities to ensure orderly, fair and
equitable dealings
system with a highly advanced platform that
directly connects to GSE’s trading system and • Register, license, authorize or regulate
BoG’s real time gross settlement system for the establishment of securities exchanges,
straight-through processing of transactions. The commodities and futures exchanges,
system is also connected to brokers, custodians securities depositories, clearing and
and registrars and keeps all securities for an settlement institutions, credit rating
investor in a single account. In due course, these agencies, Fund Managers, investment
systems should facilitate the development of new advisers, unit trusts, mutual funds, private
services and products including derivatives and equity funds, venture capital funds,
securities borrowing and lending. nominees, underwriters, issuing houses,
registrars, custodians, trustees, primary
• Monitor the solvency of license holders and (v) Foreign Exchange Act 2006 (Act 723) –
take measures to protect the interest of the Act that removed restrictions on foreign
customers where the solvency of a license and non-resident investors, including the
holder is in doubt; and limits and requirement for prior approval of
purchases.
• Advise the Minister on matters relating to
the securities industry. 78. The SEC is subject to a number of significant
regulatory challenges
77. The key legislations that are relevant in the
regulation of the securities industry includes the (a) Since 2016, SEC has been financially self-
following: sufficient, relying only on industry fees, which
is listed as one of its funding sources by the
(i) Securities Industry Act, 2016 (Act 929) - Act 929. However, its financial resources are
the primary legislation for the regulation of limited, thus, hindering its ability to function
the securities market. effectively. If the Government seeks to have
a well-functioning capital market, it will
(ii) Securities and Exchange Commission need a SEC that has the human and financial
Regulations, 2003 (LI 1728) - the detailed resources to develop it and to oversee it. The
regulations for the market operators and Commission needs to be resourced to be able
for the disclosure of information by issuers to execute its functions properly.
of public offer securities. The Regulations
were amended with segments to be replaced Headcount is at present 62 persons, which is
by Licensing Guidelines and Conduct of low given the range and number of activities
Business Guidelines. and entities under its supervision. The Public
(iii) Unit Trusts and Mutual Funds Regulations Services Commission conducted a human
2001 (LI 1695) - the detailed regulations resource establishment audit of the SEC in
for the operation of collective investment 2018 and recommended a staffing level of
schemes (unit trusts and mutual funds) under 118 persons. However, the existing financial
the Securities Industry Act. constraints means that it will be a challenge to
recruit persons with expertise and knowledge demanding conduct and capital requirements
of the capital markets. in order to protect clients.
(b) The SEC has powers under Act 929 but (e) The regulatory framework is currently
these are highly limited. They are unable implemented manually, resulting in
to conduct certain enforcement actions significant time lags in enforcement
without going first through the courts. There actions and risk assessment of segments
is the need for a review to ensure that there of the industry. The compliance-based
are adequate powers to act promptly while framework is paper based and analysis of
limiting the damaging effects of unauthorized returns and queries is slow with potential for
or delinquent firms’ actions on investor inaccuracies. The Commission has developed
interests. Moreover, the fines for infringement an IT strategy that envisages a three-pronged
are fixed, regardless of the intention, the scale approach to digitization: (i) automation of
of the breach or the numbers and types of internal processes, (ii) digitizing interactions
clients that were impacted. Further, these with market operators, (iii) making data
fixed fines are extremely low and therefore do available to the public on a timely basis.
not serve as a sufficient deterrent. They are Implementation is expected to commence in
usually between 150 and 2020.
500 penalty units, with
the highest penalty being (f) Act 929 does not have
4,500 penalty units (a Since 2016, SEC has a resolution framework for
penalty unit is currently market operators following
GH¢12). been financially the revocation of licenses.
self-sufficient, relying This leaves a gap in the
(c) Collective Investment powers of the Commission
Schemes are the classic
only on industry in its mandate of protecting
tool for channeling the fees, which is listed investors. It is critical that the
savings of retail investors as one of its funding law be amended to enhance
to the capital markets, but the Commissions powers
the dual legal framework sources by the Act in this regard, along with
of mutual funds and 929. However, its intermediate steps to limit
unit trusts for CISs is damage to market confidence
creating governance financial resources when operators begin to fail.
loopholes and without are limited, thus,
uniform standards on hindering its ability
performance reporting.
With the current to function effectively.
regulations on Unit
trusts, the fiduciary
duties that trustees have
for their clients are not clearly set out.
establishing the requisite market infrastructure. represent a relatively safe haven for individual
However, there is still more room for improvement and corporate investors who only currently
and enhancement. have access to T-Bills. This will be dependent
on a range of matters including the creation
Strategic Pillar 4 of easy access to trading and custody of
government bonds by persons who are not
Improving regulation, enforcement and CSD participants, a decision by the issuer
market confidence deliberately to direct part of issuance of
Development of the capital market is benchmark bonds to retail investors as well
dependent on the level of confidence of as to make any necessary structural changes,
investors and other key actors in the market and on the promotion of these bonds to the
and on the credibility of the legal and retail sector.
regulatory framework that underpins this
confidence. This Pillar combines initiatives • Corporate Bonds - through the creation of
a wholesale bond market available only
to fortify the understanding of markets and
to qualified investors. The market would
products of the stakeholders, with initiatives incorporate a fast route to issuance and a
to build safety, soundness and stability limited content offering document. Even with
within the markets. The legal and regulatory Wholesale bonds in place, the corporate bond
framework for capital markets will be reviewed market is expected to remain a relatively quiet
and improved to give more powers to the SEC market until the issuance of medium-term
in the area of enforcement, to ease issuance of bonds by banks is facilitated and encouraged
securities, enhance time to market and to allow – something that has proven internationally
for innovation and product development. to be one of the main tools that banks
Enforcement of the AML/CFT guidelines have used for the management of maturity
that were issued in 2019 is also of critical mismatch risks in their balance sheets. It is
importance. common to find that in active bond markets,
banks are usually responsible for over half of
all issuance of bonds.
DELIVERING GROWTH • Collective Investment Schemes - these are
important vehicles for encouraging and
83. The specific initiatives within each of the pillars safeguarding retail investment, providing a
are described below and are aimed at constructing way for retail investors to enjoy economies of
markets across a wide range of areas. Subject to scale, diversification, expert intermediation
addressing several important precursors described and advice, and access to institutional
below, the initial areas of growth are expected to instruments; and important investors for
fall into the following four areas: issuers to consider. The proposed way
• Retail access to government bonds – this would forward is a restructuring of the Collective
MTN mobile money). Fintech mobile internet • Regulatory Sandbox – a regulatory framework
solutions in Ghana have contributed significantly to be created by SEC for piloting innovative
to digital banking, made remittances and transfers proposals and determining their impact and the
faster and safer, helped to bridge the gap between appropriate regulatory approach within a safe
banks and customers and revolutionised product space. This partnership will make it easy for the
development. regulator to deal adequately with associated risks
such as the use, analysis and sale of customer data
88. The Capital Market value chain offers many and increased systemic vulnerabilities.
opportunities for technological innovation with
the potential to revolutionise the market in a range • Create digital platforms for retail trading – a
of areas, including: core market infrastructure, post specific initiative to seek to incorporate within
trade operations, analytics and decision making, the capital markets the best practices and lessons
funding platforms and new products. To deliver the learned from the application of Fintech in other
needed solutions, the capital market must create sectors, particularly digital banking.
the room for mutually beneficial partnerships with
Fintech firms. A functional partnership will help • Capital Market Fintech Meeting – quarterly/semi-
Fintechs to create and scale the right innovations annual meetings coordinated by SEC attended
for the Ghanaian market, improving product by GSE, CSD, selected market participants and
offerings, increase efficiency and lowering costs Fintech companies in Ghana to discuss market
for market participants. needs and opportunities and regulatory obstacles
to technological development within the market.
89. To help promote these developments, this
Plan includes three initiatives specifically aimed
at helping create this partnership between the STRATEGIC INITIATIVES
market and the Fintech providers:
90. The strategic initiatives are the means through
which the vision will be translated into practice.
The following are the strategic initiatives for each
strategic pillar:
Pillar 1
1. IMPROVING DIVERSITY OF INVESTMENT PRODUCTS AND LIQUIDITY OF
SECURITIES MARKET
Investment products - Specific Strategic Initiatives
a) Comprehensive review of taxation issues applicable to the n) Establish credit rating agency
capital market 0) Promote the development of REITs
b) Revise market models and introduce market makers p) Amend regulation on Tier 2 capital
c) Make credit ratings mandatory q) Develop a framework to bring about transparent
d) Develop wholesale corporate bond framework environment for the issuance of infrastructure bonds
e) Strengthen the repo market r) Facilitate retail access to government bonds
f) Create a listing business development unit at the GSE s) Establish incubation program for SOEs and SMEs
g) Clarify the definition of free float t) Introduce additional commodities at GCX
h) Facilitate the creation of limited partnerships u) Promote Private equity and venture capital investing
i) Permit margin trading v) Establish securities lending and borrowing, and short
j) Promote asset-backed securities selling
k) Review of readiness for commodity futures w) Facilitate the issuance of municipal bonds
l) Develop a framework for the issuance of infrastructural bonds x). Risk Capital funds
m) Improve liquidity of the government bond market y) Facilitate the issuance of green bonds
COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF TAXATION policy and financial stability. There is the need to
ISSUES APPLICABLE TO THE CAPITAL revise government’s issuance practices including
MARKET the definition of benchmarks and the use of
There is the need to identify appropriate measures liquidity management operations (including buy-
to make issuance attractive to issuers and backs and switches). As matching supply and
investors including taxation of private equity and demand for a debt market instrument becomes
venture capital funds. This should be part of a more challenging, the role of the Primary Dealers
larger exercise including incentives for investors. (PDs) should be enforced to provide liquidity to
It could include consideration of matters such as the secondary market. This will involve buying or
reductions in corporate taxes for listed companies selling financial instruments without an immediate
that have carried out IPOs of more than 25% of their matching transaction and it requires the PDs to
share capital; super-deduction of listing costs in the bear risks relating to the movement in inventories.
annual declarations, Enhanced capital
and amnesties requirements for
for taxes arising banks, savings &
from corporate loans institutions,
restructurings ahead broker-dealers and
of a listing. It will be Fund Managers will
important that this require them to hold
exercise balance the increased levels of
cost of taxes foregone risk-free assets on
against the utility their balance sheets.
to the state of the This will help boost
activity promoted, domestic trading of
and also ensure that government bonds.
any incentive is
commensurate with REVISE MARKET
the benefit it brings MODELS AND
to the economy. I N T R O DU C E
MARKET MAKERS
This is not simply There is the need to
a matter of identifying new incentives, but also define and implement appropriate market models
of identifying and resolving potential obstacles for GSE markets, including introducing effective
that may be difficult to spot in the absence of a market makers, subject to the right set of obligations
capital market, but which become critical once the and benefits, and other appropriate measures that
market tries to develop. This would also include will promote liquidity and price discovery. This
identifying and fixing existing incentives that are may include introducing market makers within
unnecessary or are open to abuse. International the GFIM government bond market. In this
experience in this area has highlighted a wealth context, the SEC’s enhanced capital requirements
of lessons. Activities to be undertaken will include for broker-dealers and the concurrent migration
identifying the tax issues relating to the capital to enhanced liquidity requirements based on
market and forwarding proposals to Ministry of asset risk will drive a review of business models.
Finance for consideration. In the medium-term, a risk-based capital regime
for securities firms will be essential to firms who
IMPROVE LIQUIDITY OF THE GOVERNMENT want to be market makers. There is also the need to
BOND MARKET open up primary dealership space to grant access
Liquidity is important for effective government to Fund Managers in the purchase of government
bond market functioning. It facilitates the efficient primary issues. This will make it easier for Fund
allocation of economic resources through the Managers to invest more in Treasury bills and
efficient allocation of capital and risk, the effective bonds.
generation and dissemination of issuer-specific
information, and the effectiveness of monetary
FACILITATE THE ESTABLISHMENT OF CREDIT the process which is equivalent to the issuance
RATING AGENCIES of shares. The creation of a fast-track wholesale
This initiative marks the launch of a functioning corporate bond framework, including template
credit rating agency, able to provide investors information memorandum, definition of eligible
with important information regarding the investors and automated listing process will help
creditworthiness of an issue or issuer. These credit remove obstacles to make it easier for potential
rating agencies help measure the quantitative and issuers to come to the market. A wholesale bond
qualitative risks of an issue and allow investors is a debt security, which at the time of issue, could
to make informed decisions by benefiting from be sold to only institutional clients. An active
the skills of professional risk assessment. It wholesale bond market would also provide a
is recommended that the use of a local credit platform for the initial development of mortgage-
rating agency be made mandatory for all banks backed securities. It would also enable regulators
and insurance companies, and issuers of bonds prepare a path for the creation of green bonds and
and syndicated loans held by Fund Managers, social bonds, which will help to deliver some of
Collective Investment Schemes and Pension Funds. the Ghana’s sustainable development goals. SEC
Implementation of the will develop separate
recommendation will guidelines for the
be by the SEC and issuance of wholesale
BoG in consultation and retail bonds.
with the market and
in line with the other AMEND
initiatives. REGULATION ON
TIER 2 CAPITAL FOR
PROMOTE THE BANKS
DEVELOPMENT OF Under the current
REITS regulatory regime of
Considering the fact the Bank of Ghana,
that Ghana has close the use of debt
to 2 million deficit in issuance by the banks
residential housing, is treated harshly for
REITs will serve as consideration as part
a good vehicle to pool funds for the provision of Tier 2 capital, making it unattractive for the
of housing to reduce this deficit and diversify banks to issue debt instruments. They are usually
the pool of capital available for growing the real key issuers of medium-term bonds. The standards
estate sector. To a Ghanaian investor, REITs will set out in Basel II would help to facilitate bank
serve both as a diversifier of a portfolio and access issuance and therefore create more products in the
to investments in residential and commercial market. This issue needs to be resolved through
properties. SEC has developed the guidelines for engagements with Bank of Ghana, the Ghana
the setting up of REITs but there is the need for Association of Bankers and the Securities and
active support for its issuance and specific training Exchange Commission in order to enable banks
programs for intermediaries and investors to use domestic funding to raise long-term capital for
promote its development and usage. productive projects.
1. State-Owned Enterprises
(SOEs): These firms are
often brought to a capital
market by a government as
a stage of their corporate
development, and as a
contribution towards the
investment worldwide each year. But only 10% of Exchange is working on rules to allow margin
it reaches emerging markets and an insignificant trading. It is therefore necessary to create a
portion coming to Ghana. Promoting private holistic regulatory framework for margin trading
equity in Ghana will entail improving the legal including appropriate protections for the firm and
framework of venture capital and private equity for the clients. Training for the SEC and broker-
operations in Ghana and finding solutions to dealers should also precede and accompany the
the bottlenecks plaguing the sector. Some of the deployment of this initiative.
challenges include the corporate form of private
equity funds. Currently, Ghana does not have a FACILITATE THE ISSUANCE OF MUNICIPAL
limited-liability partnership structure. Thus private BONDS
equity funds have to be structured as companies The passage into law of the draft Local
limited by shares. This creates the following issues: Government Finance Bill, otherwise known as
(a) Taxation of management fees at the fund level the Municipal Finance Bill, to help cash-strapped
instead of at the general partner level, (b) Taxation districts and municipalities float municipal bonds
of the vehicle as a company instead of pass-through to raise private capital to finance infrastructural
tax treatment, and (c) Limited ability for payouts developments has stalled for several years. The
since standard companies cannot distribute in a aim of this initiative therefore is to address all the
way that impairs capital, which is not relevant in issues delaying the passage of the bill into law,
the case of a private equity fund. This will require address all legal impediments to the issuance of
working with the Attorney General, the Registrar- municipal bonds and offer assistance to capable
General, the Ghana Revenue Authority, and the municipalities to issue municipal bonds.
SEC to fashion a framework that enables private
equity and venture capital to thrive if Ghana is to PROMOTE ASSET-BACKED SECURITIES
become a financial hub for the sub region. The Ghana Stock Exchange is in the process of
developing new products such as asset-backed
ESTABLISH SECURITIES LENDING AND securities. Before these new products can come
BORROWING, AND SHORT SELLING to the market, a legal framework for asset-backed
The Ghana Stock Exchange is developing and mortgage-backed securities is necessary.
rules to allow securities lending and borrowing In addition, the creation and marketing of these
which will go a long way to improve liquidity products will also form part of the actions to be
and increase trading volumes. This calls for the undertaken under this initiative. There is currently
gradual introduction of facility for securities loans, one asset-backed security listed on the GSE.
supported by an appropriate legal framework.
The opening up of the ability to borrow securities RISK CAPITAL FUNDS
and to sell them short should proceed gradually, In due course, once the Fund Manager license
starting initially with (i) market makers only at regime is streamlined and the impaired assets
first and (ii) only the most liquid securities where within the fund management industry are resolved,
short positions can be closed relatively easily. the SEC will consider the creation of risk capital
funds to specialize in different areas, such as
PERMIT MARGIN TRADING infrastructure and unlisted equity, and dedicate part
Many markets have frameworks and guidelines of their portfolio to emerging, growth companies.
for margin trading which have benefits for These funds would need to be accompanied by a
market liquidity. Currently, the Ghana Stock carefully-constructed governance framework.
Pillar 2
2. INCREASING THE INVESTOR BASE
Investor Base - Specific Strategic Initiatives
• Promote collective investment schemes • Develop NPRA guidelines on pre-approved overseas investments
• Conduct training for pension fund trustees • Undertake insurance awareness program for the public
• Develop relationship with institutional investors overseas • Long-term incentivized savings schemes
• Undertake roadshows in key overseas investor cities • Create digital platforms for retail trading
Pillar 3
3. STRENGTHENING INFRASTRUCTURE AND IMPROVING MARKET SERVICES
Infrastructure and Services - Specific Strategic Initiatives
• Speed up the process of GSE demutualization • Review processes at CSD
• Undertake a focused training program for professional • Fund the settlement guarantee fund
intermediaries
• Establish continuous professional education for intermediaries • Develop modern warehousing facilities
• Capital Market Fintech Meetings • Improve the distribution of market data and information
• Facilitate the establishment of currency trading platform • Facilitate the integration of West African Capital Market
• Utilize blockchain applications in financial service
FUND THE SETTLEMENT GUARANTEE FUND their investment decisions, or at least as much as
Although the settlement guarantee fund has been their counterparts in the market. The GSE must
created at the CSD, it is not adequately funded. The review the way that data and announcements are
objective of this initiative is to fund the settlement distributed so as to ensure that the wide investor
guarantee fund in order to perform the following base that they wish to attract has proper access to
functions: this information. Key elements of this framework
• To meet default obligations, shortfalls, are:
deficiencies and or any other defaults during 1. Improve quality and flexibility of
clearing and settlement. information provided by SEC
• To enhance investors’ confidence in the 2. Establish a Financial Data Hub as part of
securities market of Ghana. this initiative to host financials of all public
• To guarantee that settlements for
companies,
Depository Participants are executed as
3. Complete digitization of SEC’s operations
scheduled.
CAPITAL MARKET FINTECH MEETING
ESTABLISH CONTINUOUS PROFESSIONAL
Ongoing communication between the capital
DEVELOPMENT (CPD) FOR INTERMEDIARIES
market sector and the Fintech companies will be
A well-crafted and delivered continuous
important if the introduction of innovation is to be
professional development scheme is important
promoted. This innovation will see the initiation
because it delivers benefits to the individual,
of regular meetings (quarterly or semi-annual, to
their profession and the public. CPD ensures that
be defined by members of the group), coordinated
capabilities keep pace with the current standards
by SEC, and attended by GSE, CSD, selected
of others in the same field. It helps maintain and
market participants and Fintech companies in
enhance the knowledge and skills needed to deliver
Ghana. The meetings will discuss market needs
a professional service to customers and clients.
and opportunities, as well as regulatory obstacles
The Ghana Investment and Securities Institute
to technological development within the market.
will lead in the development of a comprehensive
CPD framework that will be reviewed by the SEC
FACILITATE THE DEVELOPMENT OF MODERN
as requirements for senior management of market
WAREHOUSING FACILITIES FOR GCX
operators. This will ensure that professionals in
A well-developed commodities market in Ghana
the industry remain current with the regulatory
has the potential to revolutionize the agricultural
and operational landscape and also invest
sector which is the mainstay of the economy. As
adequately in human capital to drive innovation
part of its plans to deepen its warehouse receipt
and industry growth.
system to cover the whole span of commodities
available in Ghana and other nearby West Africa
IMPROVE DISTRIBUTION OF MARKET DATA
countries, there is the need for GCX to build
AND INFORMATION TO INVESTORS
modern warehouses across the country.
Without adequate data distribution of market
data and information (such as company
announcements), investors cannot be sure that
they have all the information that they need for
Pillar 4
4. IMPROVING REGULATION, ENFORCEMENT AND MARKET CONFIDENCE
Regulation and Confidence - Specific Strategic Initiatives
• Improve SEC financial and human capacity • Implement Conduct of Business Guidelines
• Resolve the impairment of portfolio account assets • Implement a coordinated investor education program
• Create investor protection fund • Simplify structure of CIS
• Outsource insurance portfolio fund management • Require a standardized investment performance reporting
• Strengthen and enforce corporate governance standards • Improve SEC powers to enforce laws and regulation,
including resolution powers
• Improve licensing regime • Acquire surveillance system
• Implement risk-based supervision • Attain IOSCO Signatory A status
• Passing of the insurance bill • Develop regulation for crowdfunding
• Establish a regulatory sandbox • Implement the role and regulation of SROs
• Implement AML/CFT Guidelines and monitoring capacity
IMPROVE SEC FINANCIAL AND HUMAN complex instruments may be challenging for
CAPACITY even well-informed customers (or the brokers
It is critical to ensure that the capital market themselves) to properly appreciate,
regulator can protect vulnerable investors
before opening up significant new investment • Customers are often uninformed about even
opportunities for them. This means SEC must the simplest instruments and often reluctant
to become more engaged, preferring to rely
be resourced to play its vital role. This will mean
on a trusted broker,
increasing financial and human resources for
SEC, hiring experienced professional staff and • Brokers are highly dependent on client
delivering internal capacity building training commissions for their own remuneration.
programs consistently. Financial resourcing This creates pressure to generate trading
options to be considered could include an annual activity and therefore a potentially significant
budgetary amount, determined through a pre- conflict between the interests of the broker
agreed formula for a specific period (e.g. the next and those of their client,
five years, so as to avoid the need for renegotiation
every year), a perpetual fund to be invested by • There usually is a wide range of instruments
SEC in GoG bonds, and additional fees collected available for a firm to offer a customer at any
from other parts of the financial sector benefiting one time, with new products appearing
regularly, and
from SEC but not currently contributing, such as
Pension Funds. • Firms often have direct conflicts of interest
that are difficult for even a well-informed
IMPLEMENT THE ROLE AND REGULATION OF customer to spot, understand, avoid or
SELF-REGULATORY ORGANIZATIONS manage: a firm may have been involved in the
The current legal framework incorporates the structuring of the instrument it is selling; a
recognition of Self-Regulatory Organizations firm may be selling off a proprietary position;
(SROs) which are empowered to create and enforce a broker may be selling securities from the
rules relevant to their field of activity. The SEC account of another customer with whom they
will monitor their rules to ensure appropriateness have a closer relationship.
and that they are being adequately monitored and
enforced by the SRO, but otherwise they represent RESOLVE THE IMPAIRMENT OF PORTFOLIO
a delegation of some of the responsibilities ACCOUNT ASSETS
of the SEC. Usual candidates for SROs are Following the SEC’s sanitisation efforts in 2019
stock exchanges, clearing houses and industry and the BoG’s cleanup in 2018-2019, there is the
associations such as the Ghana Securities Industry need to enhance liquidity for the remaining Fund
Association (GSIA). Managers and enhance investor confidence. This is
important for investors who are finding it difficult
IMPLEMENT CONDUCT OF BUSINESS to redeem their investments. This situation poses
GUIDELINES a greater hindrance to capital formation and
This will include proper transition arrangements economic growth especially in an underdeveloped
that recognize an immediate application of all country where capital is scarce. There is the need
matters relating to fair treatment of clients and to establish an investor protection fund to mitigate
prioritization of their interests. Proper conduct is the fiscal impact of such future occurrences and in
at the heart of securities regulation. While the risk market dislocation events. One of the key actions
of misconduct is real in all of the financial sector, to be taken to win back confidence is facilitating
it is particularly relevant to securities market for the redemption of impaired portfolios. This means
many reasons including the following: that the impaired portfolio account assets must be
ring-fenced, quantified and resolved.
• The asymmetry of information between
firms and their customers is extreme.
This could include clearer distinctions between FACILITATE THE PASSING OF THE
firms able to give investment advice only, those INSURANCE BILL
able to manage client accounts and those allowed Many of the elements of the bill are already being
to manage public-offer CISs. applied in the market place. The bill deals with
governance of the insurers where insurers will be
ACQUIRE SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM required to establish risk management policies,
To be effective capital markets operator separate risk oversight from management and
and regulator, the GSE and SEC must have publish a code of corporate governance. Another
comprehensive, real-time data about the capital area of the bill deals with a more sophisticated
market and the ability to analyze market behavior solvency requirement. Unfortunately, the passage
through the acquisition of a market surveillance into law of the bill has delayed making NIC lack
system. The GSE and SEC must have this the necessary legal backing to implement stricter
surveillance system and the tools to analyse data measures for the safety and soundness of the
from it so as to spot egregious conduct, identify insurance industry.
trends in the market, and re-construct market
movements accurately. DEVELOP REGULATION FOR
CROWDFUNDING
IMPROVE SEC POWERS TO ENFORCE LAWS Crowdfunding has been trending over the past
AND REGULATIONS few years. It serves as an alternative form of fund
SEC’s power to enforce laws and regulation is raising from the public. It is important therefore
limited due to the nature of the legal framework for SEC to develop clear regulations, aimed at
that governs its operations. There is the need protecting public and informing decisions, without
to improve the legal powers of SEC so that it opening up riskier issuance risks.
can enforce laws and regulations and impose
meaningful proportionate fines. IMPLEMENT THE REGULATORY SANDBOX
As the market develops and technology
IMPLEMENT RISK-BASED SUPERVISION application in the capital market increases,
Risk-Based Supervision (RBS) is gradually it becomes necessary therefore to launch a
becoming the dominant approach to regulatory framework for the testing of innovative, Fintech
supervision of financial institutions around the solutions and the identification of appropriate
world. It is a comprehensive, formally structured regulatory frameworks for them. The essence of
system that assesses risks within the financial this initiative is to promote product development
system, giving priority to the resolution of those and innovation. The Commission has developed
risks. In line with current market trends and the guidelines that need to be implemented in this
current financial crisis due to the failure of many regard.
financial institutions in Ghana, it is imperative
for the regulators to double their effort towards
implementing risk-based supervision.
91. The governance structure is designed at four levels consisting of a Champion, a Steering
Committee, an Industry Review Committee and a Secretariat.
92. A champion is a person who provides strong 94. As indicated, a Steering Committee will
leadership for, and rigorously defends a cause. be formed to oversee the implementation of
the Capital Market Master Plan. This Steering
93. This project has a very large number of Committee will be the ultimate authority in matters
stakeholders each of whom has a different set of relating to initiatives, priorities and timings.
interests and agendas. It needs a publicly known
and easily identified champion behind whom these 95. The Steering Committee will monitor and
stakeholders can rally. It needs to be somebody direct the progress of the plan, with reports coming
with credibility in the financial sector, who can from the working group via the secretariat. The
represent the vision convincingly and who will be Steering Committee will resolve issues arising at
able to negotiate lasting agreements between the the working group level, whether these be matters
participants. The Minister for Finance will serve of design, of new obstacles emerging, of conflicts
as the Champion of the Capital Market Master in the priorities of different working groups or of
Plan, and will mobilize support from a whole of changes required to plans. It is proposed that the
government perspective given the far-reaching Steering Committee include senior representatives
implications of effective execution of this plan. from the MoF, BoG, SEC, GSE, GCX, NPRA,
NIC, CSD and GSIA, and that they meet at least • Identify, recommend and approve funding
every four months. It is further proposed that the options
Director-General (DG) of SEC be the chair for this
• Review, confirm and take responsibility for
committee. The Steering Committee will have at
key objectives, performance indicators and
least the following three key objectives: development targets
a) Direction – drive and direct progress • Monitoring risks and ensure that an
on implementation and ensure it remains appropriate risk management approach is
focused on the sustainable economic applied
development of Ghana
• Ensuring the quality of project and
b) Oversight – monitor progress and results controlling changes to the plan as it
and resolve obstacles and risks as they arise develops
c) Stakeholders – retain the buy-in and • Oversee the work of the secretariat and
commitment of all stakeholders. working groups
For these reasons, it is vital that the Steering • Review and approve implementation plans
Committee be comprised of persons empowered of the working groups
to take decisions and make commitments on
• Review and approve regular progress
behalf of the entities that they represent.
reports
96. The Steering Committee’s overarching role • Liaise as necessary with Financial Stability
to ensure delivery of market development may Council and other authorities.
encompass a wide range of tasks. These are the
tasks usually associated with a project board, and 97. Table 2 below shows the proposed composition
potentially include the following: of the Steering Committee.
• Take key decisions on implementation
priorities, timings and strategy
– Give feedback on the effectiveness of initiatives 101. Each group will comprise representatives of
delivered the entities that are responsible for the delivery
– As necessary, develop relevant proposals for of the initiatives assigned to that group. Those
consideration by the Steering Committee. representatives must be able to ensure that
the entity they represent will follow through
on commitments made at the working group
WORKING GROUPS level. It may be necessary to have more than one
representative from an entity.
99. There will be four working groups, as follows:
• Markets and Products 102. Each working group will also nominate a
• Legal and Regulation member who has good technical knowledge of the
• Market Infrastructure work of the group, as group coordinator to support
• Education and Research the Secretariat as necessary.
100. The strategic initiatives will each be assigned 103. It is proposed that the working groups
to one of the four working groups. An outline of the include representatives of at least the following
proposed assignation is shown in Table 3 below. stakeholders:
104. Among the functions of the working groups – Help brainstorm solutions to issues arising
are as follows: on their initiatives
– Meet as often as necessary (at least
quarterly) to plan and control the initiatives – Make recommendations to the Steering
that they have been assigned Committee on implementation issues and
update of the status of implementation.
– Develop their own work plan for the delivery
of the initiatives assigned to the group by the
Steering Committee SECRETARIAT
– Develop a detailed implementation plan 105. The Secretariat will be the coordinating center
for initiatives that are to be delivered in the for the Capital Market Master Plan. This office will
near term, based so far as possible on using
be managed by a Senior Project Manager who
resources available to the entities represented
on the group has many years of industry experience and has
built key relationships within the market. This
– Develop an estimated costing for the individual must also understand the vision, the
implementation of each initiative. Where framework and the deliverables of the plan. There
external financing is required, they should will be four working groups with responsibility for
approach the Steering Committee for these the implementation of the plan. The secretariat
funds will work closely with the four working groups.
– In so far as it becomes relevant, propose 106. The Secretariat will have the Project Manager
other initiatives critical to the development of and support staff, and will perform project office
capital markets to the Steering Committee functions including the following:
– Report to the Steering Committee and carry delivery of the initiatives on time or on budget
out any instructions given. and ensure that they are either resolved at the
level of working groups or escalated to the
– Coordinate the activities of the working Steering Committee.
groups.
– Develop a budget for implementation of
– Administer the logistics for Steering the initiatives within their various phases,
Committee and Industry Review Committee working from inputs from the working groups.
meetings.
– Monitor, evaluate and report progress to
– Provide secretarial assistance to Steering Steering Committee, possibly quarterly.
Committee and the working groups.
– Create a data bank of relevant capital
– Ensure that the working groups have the market information for use by the Steering
right membership given their responsibilities Committee and working groups.
and that they are progressing.
– Prepare semi-annual and annual progress
– Identify any problems that may impact the reports.
107. The development of a capital market is a instruments if the current market products are
step-by-step process where pragmatic sequencing yet to be assimilated. Bearing this in mind, the
is of vital importance. The market cannot development framework for the capital market has
suddenly mature by introducing sophisticated been structured in phases as follows:
This will be the preparatory work where the goal is to restore market
confidence, enlighten the understanding of key market participants
and resolve fundamental issues plaguing the market especially in
the area of regulation. Key strategic initiatives to be undertaken
include:
a. Addressing the weaknesses of government bond market
b. Enhance conduct regulation
c. Resourcing Securities & Exchange Commission
d. Implement enhanced licensing regime
e. Sanitizing portfolio accounts
f. Establishing of an investor protection fund
g. Develop additional long-term incentivized savings schemes
h. Introducing market makers
i. Establishing securities lending and short selling for market
makers
j. Demutualized status of Ghana Stock Exchange
108. The Table below shows all the strategic initiatives, indicating the phases of the plan and the Working
Group responsible for the initiatives.
109. The Steering Committee will need to ensure that monitoring is in place at several different levels,
including the following:
The Steering Committee will At the level of the Working The Steering Committee,
need to choose metrics that Groups, there will need to through the Secretariat,
will best serve to demonstrate be careful monitoring of the will also be responsible
the advances made towards progress of the groups in the for monitoring the cost
the vision. This is discussed delivery of their initiatives. of the project, particular,
further below. This is likely to be best the external costs. For this
done through the creation monitoring to be effective,
of project plans for the when the Working Groups
various initiatives anchored are building their detailed
around the delivery of clear implementation plans for the
and identifiable milestones various initiatives, they will
at regular intervals. The need to estimate the external
completion of tasks and the costs of each initiative. There
delivery of those milestones is a cost estimate provided in
will comprise the heart of a later section, but this is only
the monitoring. for initial guidance of the
Steering Committee and has
been calculated on a broad
basis, without reference to
detailed plans by experts in
the field. Cost estimates by
the Working Group will be
informed by the actual plan
for implementation and by
knowledge of costs in situ.
110. The Steering Committee will be the ultimate 111. As a starting point in that process, the
authority responsible for the delivery of the vision: following are offered up as a first draft of potential
“a deep, efficient and well-diversified capital indicators and targets for the Steering Committee
market with a full range of products attractive to consider. Reaching targets is of course subject
to domestic and international investors”. As a to being able to count on critical success factors,
part of meeting this responsibility, it will need which are also discussed below:
to identify key development indicators that it
will use to monitor progress in the creation of a
deep, efficient and attractive market. This includes
setting challenging but plausible targets for those
indicators.
Ghana Capital Market Master Plan
Critical Success Factors intentions of each firm. They will be estimated and
met by participants as the program develops.
112. For the Steering Committee to set any targets
for these key development indicators it should be b) Large-scale cross-entity initiatives, such as the
clear about the assumptions and success factors demutualization of the GSE, the acquisition and
that will need to be in place for the targets to be deployment of appropriate surveillance systems,
met. In addition to the preconditions mentioned the design and introduction of new markets, the
earlier, these include the following: resolution of the portfolio accounts issues, and
training programs to bring participants and
authorities up to capacity and to keep them there.
• Maintenance of political, social and The costs of these initiatives will depend on the
economic stability detail and scope of the Working Group plans and
will be estimated at that stage. They may, of course,
• Macroeconomic management
continues to be strengthened vary enormously depending on the underlying
assumptions.
• No severe external economic shocks
c) Incremental external costs directly related
• The Steering Committee is able to to the program – these include the costs of the
source adequate financing for the
project and to maintain control and Secretariat, the logistics of running new bodies
direction of the project such as the Steering Committee and the Working
Groups and the costs of creating new regulations
• An effective Secretariat can be appropriate for the market and acceptable to all
created participants. These will also depend on exact
details but as a guide to these, assuming a three-
• All key participants can meet the
commitments they make in the person secretariat with qualified and credible
working groups professionals, it is estimated that the team will cost
no less than USD 200,000 per year. The logistics
• Adequate financial and human around the meetings of the main bodies (Steering
resources can be found to boost the Committee, Industry Review Committee and
capacity of the SEC.
Working Groups are estimated to cost up to USD
50,000 per year assuming that all persons attend
as representatives of interested stakeholders
and not on the basis of any fees paid). If external
consultants are brought in to draft the regulations
COSTS OF DEVELOPMENT required to support all the proposals set out above,
this could be costly. It is emphasized, however,
that external experts can only bring so much to
113. The costs of the implementation will include
these regulatory frameworks. They can only work
many different classes of costs, which for simplicity
off international examples and lessons learned; it
are categorized into the following groups:
will therefore be essential for them to be closely
accompanied by the market authorities and actors
a) Internal costs of market actors – which
so as to ensure that the frameworks are appropriate
participants meet as part of their own development.
for Ghana and actually workable in the context in
These include costs of systems updates and
which they will be implemented.
additional resources required (human and
financial) for new services offered or new functions
undertaken, changes to risk management
and compliance processes, and technical and
legal assistance to support the creation of new
regulatory frameworks and the evolution of the
firms. These costs will depend on the exact plans
of the Working Groups for the implementation of
the initiatives and the circumstances and strategic
APPENDIX
For Emerging markets, the new minimum investable market cap and securities count requirements are
as follows:
1. For Entry - the combined investable market cap of the eligible securities is greater than 10 basis points
of the FTSE Emerging All Cap Index, and a minimum of 5 securities meet the FTSE Global All Cap Index
eligibility screens.
2. For Exit (i.e. to be placed on the Watch List) - the combined investable market cap of the eligible
securities falls below 5 basis points of the FTSE Emerging All Cap Index, or the number of eligible stocks
decreases to 2 or fewer.
Asset
09. Glossary of
C
company, regarded as having value and Capital Market
available to meet debts, commitments, or
legacies. Capital markets are venues where savings
and investments are channelled between
Asset Class the suppliers who have capital and those
who are in need of capital.
Terms
A
appreciation of a client’s assets over time
while mitigating risk. acquisition, holding, management or
disposal of the property or sums paid out
Asset-Backed Securities of such profits or income.
A type of financial investment that is
Commodity
collateralized by an underlying pool of
assets—usually ones that generate a cash A commodity is a basic good used in
flow from debt, such as loans, leases, commerce that is interchangeable with
credit card balances, or receivables. other goods of the same type.
B
Corporate Bond
Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy is a legal proceeding involving A corporate bond is a type of debt
a person or business that is unable to security that is issued by a firm and sold
repay their outstanding debts. to investors.
Broker-Dealer
A Broker-Dealer (B-D) is a person or firm
in the business of buying and selling
securities for its own account or on behalf
of its customers.
D
Data Bank Equity
A large collection of information that can A bond is a fixed income instrument
be searched through quickly, especially by that Equity, typically referred to as
a computer. shareholders’ equity (or owners’ equity
for privately held companies), represents
Debt Market the amount of money that would be
The bond market—often called the debt returned to a company’s shareholders if
market, fixed-income market, or credit all of the assets were liquidated and all
market—is the collective name given to all of the company’s debt was paid off in the
trades and issues of debt securities. case of liquidation.
Demutualization Eurobond
Demutualization is a process by which a A Eurobond is a debt instrument that’s
private, member-owned company, such denominated in a currency other than
as a co-op, or a mutual life insurance the home currency of the country or
company, legally changes its structure, in market in which it is issued.
order to become a public-traded company
F
owned by shareholders. Fixed Income
Fixed income broadly refers to those
Depository Account
types of investment security that pay
Depository Account means any account of investors fixed interest or dividend
the Client or for the Client with an entity payments until its maturity date.
registered as a depository participant as
per the relevant regulations in which the
G
securities comprising part of the portfolio
of the client are kept by the portfolio GDP
manager. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the
total monetary or market value of all the
Digital Platform finished goods and services produced
A digital platform can be thought of as within a country’s borders in a specific
the sum total of a place for exchanges of time period.
information, goods, or services to occur
between producers and consumers as well Green Bond
as the community that interacts with said A green bond is a type of fixed-
platform. income instrument that is specifically
earmarked to raise money for climate and
Diversification environmental projects.
Diversification is a risk management
I
strategy that mixes a wide variety of
investments within a portfolio. Inflation
Inflation is the decline of purchasing
power of a given currency over time. A
E
E-Bond quantitative estimate of the rate at which
E-bonds refer to a joint European sovereign the decline in purchasing power occurs
bond (Eurozone common bond) issued by can be reflected in the increase of an
European Debt Agency. average price level of a basket of selected
goods and services in an economy over
Equity Market some period of time.
An equity market is a market in which
shares of companies are issued and
traded, either through exchanges or over-
the-counter markets.
K
unemployed or low-income individuals
Key Stakeholders or groups who otherwise would have no
The primary stakeholders in a typical other access to financial services.
corporation are its investors, employees,
customers, and suppliers. Mortgage-Backed Securities
L
A Mortgage-Backed Security (MBS) is an
Liquidity investment similar to a bond that is made
Liquidity refers to the efficiency or ease up of a bundle of home loans bought from
with which an asset or security can the banks that issued them.
be converted into ready cash without
affecting its market price. Mutual Fund
A mutual fund is a type of financial vehicle
M
Macroeconomics made up of a pool of money collected from
Macroeconomics is a branch of economics many investors to invest in securities
that studies how an overall economy—the like stocks, bonds, money market
market or other systems that operate on a instruments, and other assets. Mutual
large scale—behaves. funds are operated by professional money
managers, who allocate the fund’s assets
and attempt to produce capital gains or
income for the fund’s investors.
P
Pension Fund Risk Management
A pension fund, also known as a Risk management is the process of
superannuation fund in some countries, is identification, analysis, and acceptance or
any plan, fund, or scheme which provides mitigation of uncertainty in investment
retirement income. decisions.
R
Regulator system that assesses risks within the
financial system, giving priority to the
A person or body that supervises a resolution of those risks. RBS is often
particular industry or business activity. contrasted with rules-based regulation.
Regulatory Framework
S
Savings Scheme
A Regulatory framework is legal
mechanism that exists on national and A scheme designed to encourage savings
international levels. It can be mandatory by making small deposits automatically
and coercive (national laws and regulations, into a special savings account.
contractual obligations) or voluntary
(integrity pacts, codes of conduct, arms Securities
control agreements). Securities are fungible and tradable
financial instruments used to raise capital
Repo Transactions in public and private markets.
A repurchase agreement (repo) is a form
of short-term borrowing for dealers in Solvency
government securities. Solvency is the ability of a company to
meet its long-term debts and financial
Risk Assessment obligations.
Risk assessment is a general term used
across many industries to determine the Steering Committee
likelihood of loss on an asset, loan, or Steering committees are advisory bodies
investment. Assessing risk is essential for that are made up of senior stakeholders or
determining how worthwhile a specific experts that provide guidance on a lot of
investment is and the best process(es) to different issues that could face companies
mitigate risk. such as budgets, new endeavours,
company policy, marketing strategies, and
Risk Capital project management concerns.
Risk capital refers to funds allocated to
speculative activity and used for high-risk, Stock Market
high-reward investments. The stock market refers to the collection
of markets and exchanges where regular
activities of buying, selling, and issuance
of shares of publicly held companies take
place.
U
Systemic risk is the possibility that an Underwriters
event at the company level could trigger
severe instability or collapse an entire An underwriter is any party that evaluates
industry or economy. and assumes another party’s risk for a fee.
V
Venture Capital Funds
T
Taxation
Venture capital funds are pooled
Taxation is a term for when a taxing
investment funds that manage the money
authority, usually a government, levies
of investors who seek private equity stakes
or imposes a financial obligation on its
in startups and small to medium-sized
citizens or residents.
enterprises with strong growth potential.
Treasury bills
A Treasury Bill (T-Bill) is a short-term
investment product (from 91 days to 365).
Acronyms
B BoG Bank of Ghana
C
CAGR Compounded Annual
Growth Rate
CAR Capital Adequacy Ratio
CI Composite Index
CSD Central Securities Depository
N
NBFI
NIC
Non-Bank Financial
Institutions
National Insurance
F
Commission
FINSSP Financial Sector
Financial Sector Strategic
Strategic
NPL Non-Performing Loans
Plan
NPRA National Pensions
FSD Financial Sector Division
Regulatory Authority
FSC Financial Stability Council
G P
GAB Ghana Association of Bankers PNDC Provisional National
GAX Ghana Alternative Market Defence Council
GBA Ghana Bar Association
GCX Ghana Commodities
Exchange
GDP
GFIM
GhIPSS
Gross Domestic Product
Ghana Fixed Income Market
Ghana Interbank Payment
and Settlement System
R RAFIP
RCB
Rural and Agricultural
Finance Programme
Rural and Community
Banks
GIS Ghana Interbank Settlement ROA Return on Assets
GISI Ghana Investments and ROE Return on Equity
Securities Institute
S
GSE Ghana Stock Exchange
GSIA Ghana Securities Industry SDC Securities Depository
Association Company
SEC Securities and Exchange
Commission
I
IFC International Finance
SMEs Small and Medium Scale
Corporation
Enterprises
IFSC International Financial
SSNIT Social Security and
Services Center
National Insurance Trust
IOSCO International Organization
of Securities Commissions
T
IPO Initial Public Offering
TPFA Temporary Pension Fund
Account
M
MFI Microfinance Institutions
MMDA Metropolitan, Municipal and
MoF
MSMEs
District Assembly
Ministry of Finance
Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises
V VCTF Venture Capital Trust Fund